Call Girls Service Chennai Jiya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Chennai
A New Era in Psychiatry: Paradigms & Protocols for Difficult to Treat Mental Health Conditions Using Psychedelics
1. A New Era in Psychiatry:
Paradigms & Protocols for Difficult to
Treat Mental Health Conditions Using
Psychedelics
For UNM Psychedelic Interest Group
Reid Robison, MD MBA
Chief Medical Officer, Novamind
Feb 7th, 2022
2. How I came to study psychedelics…
● Ketamine clinical work & research since 2011
○ Facilitated thousands of sessions since then, including >5000 Spravato doses since its approval
in 2019, >5000 ketamine sessions
○ First research study in 2011 (Intermountain Foundation grant)
○ Led Janssen’s IV ketamine study for treatment-resistant depression in SLC from 2011 - 2012
○ Group-based Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy pilot in 2018-2019 at Center for Change
○ Co-developed Emotion-focused Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy (EF-KAP) with Dr. Adele Lafrance
■ Completed Anorexia study in 2020, depression case series, & family-based retreat work
● Ayahuasca retreat work since 2019
○ Found it while exploring new potential ED treatments -- got more than I bargained for
● MDMA research since 2018
○ Coordinating investigator for MAPS MED1 study of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for eating
disorders
○ Collaborating with MAPS on MDMA IIT for gender minority trauma (Utah & Portland sites)
● Psilocybin research now active in Utah
○ MDD study now recruiting
○ Psilocybin + IFS for eating disorders study plans
○ Psilocybin or cancer-related depression study plans (ongoing in collaboration with Univ of Utah)
4. Mainstream treatments fall short for too many people.
Say you’re in a room with 400 adults, chances are nearly 100 of them are going to
develop a diagnosable mental health condition (and only 50 of them will receive
adequate treatment)
The rate of antidepressant use in the US increased by 400% between 1980 to
2000 -- and these things don’t even work that well (i.e. 20-30% attain remission)
Psychedelic medicines, when properly used, and coupled with psychotherapy, are
showing unprecedented promise for those who are suffering.
6. Timeline of Psychedelic “Discoveries”
DMT
Synthesized in 1931
MDMA
Synthesized in 1912
LSD
Synthesized in 1938
Psilocybin
Synthesized in 1955
Mescaline
Discovered in 1897
Synthesized in 1918
7. Favorable Safety Profiles
Cases of mental health complications following a
psychedelic are rare (<0.1%), even in vulnerable populations
(<0.2%), and rarer still with proper screening.
No evidence of increased rates of mental health problems,
and psychedelic use has been associated with reduced
psychological distress and suicidality.
Studies examining use patterns in humans & self-administration
in animals suggest that classic psychedelics possess little or no
abuse liability, and may even be anti-addictive.
(Studerus et al., 2011)
(Krebs et al., 2013; Hendricks et al., 2015; Sexton et al., 2019)
(Heal et al., 2018; Winkelman 2014)
8. Tryptamines:
(chemically similar to l-tryptophan, an essential amino acid and serotonin precursor)
● Psilocybin
● DMT
● Ibogaine
Phenethylamines:
● Mescaline
● MDMA
● The 2-C’s
Ergolines:
● LSD
Three Main Classes of Psychedelics
9. 3 Brain Pathways to Induce Hallucinations
1) Activation of dopamine D2 receptors (D2Rs) with psychostimulants
2) Activation of serotonin 5HT2A receptors (HT2ARs) with psychedelics
3) Blockage of glutamate NMDA receptors (NMDARs) with dissociative anesthetics
Psychostimulants
(cocaine, amphetamine)
Dissociative anesthetics
(PCP, ketamine)
Psychedelics
(LSD, psilocybin)
Schizophrenia
(paranoid)
Mechanism D2R activation NMDAR blockage 5HT2AR activation D2R activation &
NMDAR blockage
Main type of hallucination Auditory Visual Visual Auditory
Main type of delusion Paranoid Mixed Mystical Paranoid
Behavior Agitation Social withdrawal Mystical feelings Variable
Insight No Some Yes No
(Pang 2016)
10. SSRIs
5-HT1A receptor signaling -->
reduced limbic responsiveness, aka
emotional blunting.
Psychedelics
5HT2AR signaling → enhanced
sensitivity + emotional release,
combined with psychological
support = therapeutically potent
The serotonin 5-HT2AR receptor is expressed all over the brain, particularly in regions associated with cognitive functions and
social interactions. Stimulation of this receptor has been directly linked to cognitive flexibility, enhanced imagination, and
creative thinking.
Psychedelics vs. SSRIs
The therapeutic potential of psychedelic drugs
RL Carhart-Harris and GM Goodwin
11. Initial blast of serotonin yields
the short term “psychotomimetic”
effects (i.e. trippin’)
The longer-term effects produce a
“loosening” of the mind, and a
general increase in optimism and
well-being.
12. The Paradoxical Properties of Psychedelics
● When Albert Hoffman ingested 250 µg of LSD in 1943:
○ Initially unpleasant experience: altered perception, fear, paranoia
■ Next-door neighbor turned into a ‘malevolent, insidious witch with a coloured mask’
■ He sensed a ‘disintegration of the outer world’, a ‘dissolution of his ego’ and was
‘seized by a dreadful fear of going insane’ (Hofmann 1980)
○ “I then slept, to awake the next morning with a clear head… A sensation of wellbeing and
renewed life flowed through me. Breakfast tasted delicious and gave me extraordinary
pleasure. When I later walked out into the garden, in which the sun shone now after a
spring rain, everything glistened and sparkled in a fresh light. The world was as if newly
created.’
● When LSD was first distributed by Sandoz in 1948, the guidelines stipulated two main
applications:
1) Analytical psychotherapy (LSD could elicit the release of repressed material and
provide mental relaxation for anxiety & obsessional neuroses)
2) Experimental studies on psychosis
13. REBUS: RElaxed Beliefs Under pSychedelics
● How the brain works (aka the hierarchical predictive coding model of cognition).
○ The brain generates mental models that predict upcoming sensory input (“priors”
or “prior beliefs”)
○ These predictive models are layered on top of eachother in a hierarchy
■ The higher levels send predictions down the hierarchy
■ The lower levels report sensory input data up the hierarchy
○ When the top down predictions don’t match the bottom-up sensory input, the
model either:
■ Updates its “priors” based on the new sensory information, or
■ Ignores the sensory inputs and maintains its “prior beliefs”
● Initial ‘blast’ of 5-HT2AR stimulation has a residual influence on brain network dynamics
and associated cognition.
○ This is thought to have a ‘loosening’ or ‘lubricating’ influence on rigid thinking and
this is hypothesized to be conducive to improved psychological wellbeing (Carhart-
Harris 2016)
14. REBUS & How Psychedelics “Relax” Tightly-held Prior Beliefs
● Psychedelics relax the weight of held beliefs/rules/restrictions, allowing them to be more readily
changed
○ Psychedelics “heat up” the brain, increasing plasticity and weakening the influence of prior
beliefs
○ As the brain “cools”, the hierarchy re-forms, though perhaps in a new configuration than
before
■ Explains how lasting changes may persist after the substance is gone
● Psychedelics show particular promise for conditions associated with too-rigid thought patterns
○ i.e. "disorders that may rest on particularly rigid high-level priors that dominate cognition."
○ In these conditions, new information can't revise the existing story of how things are,
because strong priors suppress the new info before it can update anything.
● Psychedelics relax the strong top-down “prior beliefs” (i.e. ‘I can’t eat that because it will make
me fat’) and boost the bottom-up sensory inputs (i.e. intuitive, mindful eating)
15. 15
Psychedelics are like fresh coat of powder. They
provide a break from the everyday patterns, and
let the brain reset the ruts, so we get to choose the
next set of tracks, and end up consciously
arriving at new destinations.
17. First – What is ketamine?
1962 Developed by Calvin Stevens at Parke Davis Labs
1965 Professor Edward Domino conducts 1st human studies
Calls ketamine a potent psychedelic; coins the term “dissociative anesthetic”
1970 Approved for human use by the US FDA in 1970 for anesthesia
Widely used in Vietnam war as a battlefield anesthetic
2000 First controlled study of ketamine for major depressive disorder (MDD)
2019 Spravato (esketamine) nasal spray FDA approved for treatment-resistant depression
(TRD)
18. NMDA Receptor Blockade
Mechanism
Blocks NMDA
receptors, leading
to GABAergic
inhibition and a
surge of glutamate
release.
Effect
Rapid
improvements in
mood by restoring
glutamatergic
signaling
Analogy
Wakes up dormant
neurons like jump starting
a car battery; lets them
communicate freely
19. Brain Activity is Reduced
During Depression
Depressed Non- Depressed
20. Lateral Habenular Burst Mode
Mechanism
Turns off “burst
mode” in the lateral
habenula (the “anti-
reward” center)
Effect
A break from
stress mode:
facilitates emotion
processing, reduces
avoidance of negative
affective states
Analogy
Giving a dose of ketamine
is like extinguishing the
“fire” of stress in the brain
21. BDNF & Neuroplasticity
Mechanism
Stimulates BDNF,
leading to
neurogenesis & new
connections
Effect
Neuron growth & a
window of opportunity for
deep therapeutic work*
(neuroplasticity),
including: making new
connections and
strengthening
connections.
Analogy
Ketamine is like fertilizer
for neurons
*Ideally done during the 24-48 hour window of optimal
neuroplasticity after ketamine dosing
23. Three main ways we work with ketamine at Novamind
Psychedelic
Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy
(KAP)
IM (or IV) journeys in the ketamine
room, with brief therapy before and
after, and psychotherapeutic
integration sessions in between
Psycholytic
Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy
(KAP)
Lozenges or nasal spray taken
before the session to facilitate
openness & deeper work, with the
therapist present the whole time.
Psychiatric
Ketamine or Spravato as a
medical intervention.
In office, usually starting at twice a
week then decreasing frequency as
tolerated. Optional home dosing for
maintenance (lozenge or nasal spray).
24. Components of Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy
● Preparatory Session
○ Medical/Psychiatry screening (if not done previously)
○ Establish rapport, consent & psycheducation
○ Treatment goals
● Dosing session (4-6 sessions)
○ Intention setting prior to dosing
○ Brief/limited processing afterwards
● Integration sessions
○ Ideally within 1-2 days of dosing session
○ Explore material that emerged / draw connections, insights, meaning related to
intentions and day-to-day life
27. Optimizing Mindset for Psychedelic Experiences
● Psychedelic medicines are non-specific amplifiers of what’s in our subconscious
○ If you go in anxious, there’s a risk of this getting ‘amplified’
● Important to note that we are not trying to completely control or direct the experience when we
try to optimize mindset. We want to get out of the way of the medicine and the inner healing
intelligence.
○ Educate about what to expect
○ Make sure they understand the logistics
○ Give them a sense for what it will feel like
■ This will help reduce distracting thoughts, fear, and uncertainty.
● Prime the mind with meditative practices / inner work
● When in doubt, curiosity/surrender/let go. “If there’s a door, open it… etc.”
28. The WHY of Intention Setting
➔ A way to empower you and your experience; individualize the treatment
➔ Important that you really connect with the intention; own it; write it down
➔ An anchor for you in the moment and as you reflect after
➔ The intention often crosses over to an intention in life
➔ An anchor for the meaning making process, especially with the stance that the ketamine
unlocks the inner healer
29. Formula for Intention Setting
First choose one of the following verbs:
➔ Help me with
➔ Teach me about
➔ Show me
Combine it with:
➔ A difficult emotion (fear, anger, guilt, sadness, shame, joy) or
➔ An essential quality (peace, love, compassion, connection – essential human qualities the we might
have become disconnected from, through challenging life experiences)
Examples:
➔ Show me – my fear
➔ Teach me – about love
➔ Help me – experience joy
31. How to Optimize the SETTING for Psychedelic Experiences
● Setting can shape the experience vs. but we also want it to get out of the way of the medicine
○ Physical comfort:
○ Comfortable clothing, layers and a blanket for temp control
○ Access to bathroom, food, water.
○ chair / couch they are on
○ Eyeshades promote journey inward, but not required.
● Social presence. Private room is great, but not necessary. Everybody in there needs to be
mindful of the energy/noise/attitude they bring into the room.
● Feng Shui: lighting, decor, furniture
● Music.
○ Recommend non-lyrical. Instrumental, chanting, ceremonial drums, ambient nature sounds. A song
change can alter the experience for good or for ill. If they use their own phone they need to turn off
notifications. If they use a music service that inserts ads, they may want to find another way (like use
ours). Playlists on Spotify.
● Clinical presence. You as the facilitator are part of the setting.
○ If their mindset seems to take a turn for the worse, support with safe touch, reminders that they are safe,
coach through relaxation breathing.
33. Ceremony & Ritual
● The uncertainty of life can be quite uncomfortable at times
● You can “punctuate” the chaos of life with ceremony / ritual
○ Essentially, you are “sacramentalizing” the mystery of life
○ Collapses chaos into something more predictable / comforting
■ A place of more order, a place of worrying about less, a place for thinking less and feeling
more
● Rituals themselves can be “difficult” at times (like a sweat lodge or vision quest)
○ However, when done with intention / purpose / meaning, we get out of our heads and into our
experience
○ We start to be more accepting of the uncertainty
34. “In the sunlight of awareness,
everything becomes sacred.”
Thich Nhat Hanh
35. Emotion-Focused Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy
(EF-KAP, Lafrance & Robison, 2020, efkap.org)
Emotion-Focused Ketamine-Assisted Psychotherapy is an extension of KAP / a treatment
model informed by emotion-focused theory and techniques to facilitate healing and growth
Every aspect of the treatment is guided by two principles:
1. Supporting the emotional health of the patient (inspired by elements of Emotion-Focused Therapy)
a. By focusing on the development of skill and confidence with emotion processing
b. By focusing on transforming emotion with emotion
2. Leveraging the healing power of family (inspired by elements of Emotion-Focused Family Therapy)
a. By providing education and skills to a support person thereby:
b. Strengthening meaningful relationships
c. Creating a recovery-friendly environment outside of the therapy office
d. Extending healing beyond the individual
36. Sample Outline of
Family-Based
Ketamine-Assisted
Psychotherapy
“Intensive Retreat”
Day 1 AM Orientation, goals & intention setting
PM Family & individual psychotherapy
Day 2 AM Intention setting
Ketamine #1
Post-ketamine processing
PM Recovery
Personal integration practices
Day 3 AM Family & individual psychotherapy
PM Family activity
Personal integration practices
Day 4 AM Intention setting
Ketamine #2
Post-ketamine processing
PM Recovery
Personal integration practices
Day 5 AM Family & individual psychotherapy
PM Closing session
Recommendations /Treatment Planning
37. A real-world retrospective study evaluating safety,
efficacy and cost of Spravato
Clinical outcomes of Spravato for treatment resistant depression across multiple clinics.
38. Growing the evidence base for ketamine
A retrospective look at our IM ketamine data
39. Group-based ketamine-assisted psychotherapy pilot
program for COVID-19 frontline workers
● A novel psychedelic therapy protocol offering
critical mental health care for a timely need
● Depression & anxiety scores were measured
weekly
● Mystical experience & emotional
breakthrough scores were measured after
each dosing session
● From the psychedelic literature, and our real-
world data, we know that the mystical
experience can be a predictor of positive
changes
41. How does MDMA work?
● MDMA, while not a “classic psychedelic”, is unique among consciousness-altering
substances in its ability to promote acceptance of and empathy for self and others.
○ In addition to elevating oxytocin levels, MDMA stimulates the release
of the monoamines serotonin, norepinephrine and dopamine,
resulting in an improved mood and increased sociability.
○ Brain imaging after administering MDMA shows
decreased amygdala activation, and the reduced fear
response that follows allows the client to emotionally
engage in therapy without becoming overwhelmed by
anxiety or negative affective states.
42. Post 3rd
Experimental Session
Post 2nd
Experimental Session
Up to 12 months after treatment,
67% of individuals treated with MDMA-assisted psychotherapy
no longer met criteria for PTSD.
Mithoefer et al., 2019
High
Medium
Low
Baseline
Active (75-125 mg)
Control (0-40 mg)
PTSD Level
43.
44. More on MDMA Expanded Access (aka Compassionate Use)
After obtaining FDA approval, the protocol will be
submitted for DEA and IRB approvals.
The basic requirements of a qualified site include:
1. Treatment Facility conducive to MDMA-
assisted psychotherapy,
2. Therapy Team qualified and able to complete
required training, made up of at least two
therapy providers, and
3. Prescribing Physician who can obtain a DEA
Schedule 1 license for MDMA.
45. If clinical trials are not an option, drug manufacturers may
consider providing access to unapproved investigational
medicines under very specific circumstances.
Most common way for people to
access medicines before they are
approved by the FDA
46. MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for Anorexia Nervosa &
Binge Eating Disorder
● MED1: An Open-Label, Multi-Site Phase 2 Study of the Safety and Feasibility of MDMA-
Assisted Psychotherapy for Eating Disorders
● 12 participants with Anorexia Nervosa
● 6 participants with Binge Eating Disorder
● Protocol:
● Weeks 1-3: three participant preparatory sessions (individual and with caregiver)
● Weeks 4-12:
● Three 8-hour experimental sessions
● Six individual integration sessions
● Three individual + caregiver integration sessions
47. Why MDMA for eating disorders?
TRUST: MDMA increases oxytocin levels, which may
strengthen the therapeutic alliance
FEAR REDUCTION: MDMA increases ventromedial prefrontal
activity and decreases amygdala activity, which may improve
emotional regulation and decrease avoidance
EMOTIONAL ENGAGEMENT: MDMA increases norepinephrine
release and circulating cortisol levels, which may facilitate
emotional engagement and enhance extinction of learned
fear association
1
2
3
48. 48
"I’m tempted to say MDMA gave me ‘hope,’ but that word
isn’t right: the insight was more substantive than hope.
I’d held the sensation in my body; I understood, at a
visceral level, what might someday be mine: the sense
of peace and joy within my body. For me, the therapeutic
process could unfurl from there.”
MDMA Study Participant
49. Group MDMA for Gender Minority Trauma (a multi-site
IIT)
Rationale:
1) Gender diverse people (e.g., anyone not identifying as either cisgender male or cisgender
female) experience trauma & PTSD at higher rates than the general population, yet they have
not been adequately represented in clinical research aimed at investigating new PTSD
treatments. Research shows that gender diverse people experience high levels of stigma &
discrimination, including from healthcare providers, and also experience high rates of
depression & suicidality.
2) Group therapy offers unique healing opportunities and has the capacity to uncover the
resilience of community. Individuals with shared trauma experiences from systemic
oppression may especially benefit from group therapy. In addition, group therapy may act to
reduce cost and increase access to MDMA-assisted psychotherapy, although more research is
needed.
50. Group MDMA for Gender Minority Trauma: Protocol
Protocol synopsis:
● A total of 24 gender diverse individuals (4 cohorts of 6) will be enrolled in the study across two
sites: Portland and Salt Lake City.
● Our group therapy model involves 4 therapists (2 primary and 2 adjunct) for each cohort and
greatly reduces the number of therapist hours compared to standard individual treatment.
● Our team consists of equal numbers of gender diverse therapists and
cisgender therapists trained to conduct MDMA-assisted psychotherapy.
Clinical outcomes to measure:
● PTSD symptoms
● Markers of minority stress
● Symptoms of depression
● Suicidality
52. Maria Sabina, Mazatec Curandera (healer)
● In 1955, R. Gordon Wasson, amateur mycologist (and VP at JP
morgan) and his wife (Valentina Wasson, a pediatrician) to see a
woman named Maria sabina, who was healing the community with
powerful mushroom rituals
● She welcomed Wasson in to one of the rituals, in good faith, allowing
him to take pictures but taking his word that he wouldn't publish
them.
○ She called in the mushroom spirits for healing, and Wasson’s
life was transformed
● In 1957, Wasson published an article in Life Magazine about magic
mushrooms, altered states, and this shamanic lineage
● Americans flocked to Mexico in search of healing and spirituality
● Then the university studies began
53. Psilocybin Research is Back
● Year 2000, psilocybin research began again, after a multi-decade hiatus
● Psilocybin is sometimes called ‘Orally active DMT’
○ Similar chemical structure
● Serotonin mimicking is the hallmark of psychedelic neuroscience .
○ Serotonin allows human consciousness to assemble consensus reality that we inhabit,
and
○ Break down the walls around normal waking consciousness.
● Turns down the default mode network (DMN) -- the neurobiological seat of the ego
○ Which is very active during conditions of vigilance, and depression
○ The DMN is down-regulated in long term meditators.
○ The DMN is very rapidly down-regulated on psilocybin.
■ This may account for some of the antidepressant effects (“a wandering mind is an
unhappy mind”)
54. Psilocybin Dose Finding Study (Griffiths 2016 @ Hopkins)
● 18 healthy volunteers were given four tiers of psilocybin doses and encouraged to lie down in a comfortable
environment with headphones.
○ The study’s aim was to evaluate volunteers’ subjective experiences—positive and negative—at different
doses.
● The highest dose tested was 30 mg of psilocybin per 70 kg participant weight
○ This is roughly equivalent to a 155 lb individual taking ~5 g of dried psilocybe cubensis
● Four out of five volunteers receiving this dose reported the experience was one of the top five most spiritually
significant events of their lives
○ A third of participants also reported a significant psychological struggle.
○ At this higher dose, experiencing fear, anxiety, and stress was more likely.
● At a dose of 20 mg per 70 kg (equivalent to ~3 g of dried psilocybe cubensis), all volunteers reported positive
experiences, and only one experienced any negativity.
● This trend continued for lower doses, with slightly less profundity of experience but still significant, long-lasting
effects.
○ Even the lowest dose of 5mg/70kg found long-lasting positive effects on behavior/attitude/outlook
● Over a year later, the researchers followed up with volunteers and found that 94% still thought that their
experiences were in the top five most spiritually significant of their lives.
55. More on Psilocybin Dosing
● Terence McKenna called a heroic dose 5g (5DGISD= 5 dried grams in silent darkness)
○ Enough to elicit a profound spiritual experience in most
● The doses in Rick Strassman’s studies were almost 8g
○ The doses that we now consider high were just barely threshold in earlier psychedelic studies
● The probability of salient experiences increases with dose, but so does the probability of difficult
experiences.
○ But very often, it’s those deeply uncomfortable experiences that provide a window of opportunity,
through which, if people can investigate and go through, open up into larger experiences.
● The experiences that people describe as difficult, are among the most meaningful and beneficial.
Low dose: Problem solving
Medium dose: Therapy
High dose: Spirituality
56. In a treatment-resistant depression study,
2 doses of psilocybin plus psychological support lead to
improvements in mood within 1 week, with lasting benefits still
seen at 3 and 6 months.
Carhart-Harris et al., 2016
0
Baseline 1 Week
QIDS Score
5
10
15
20
25
2 Weeks 3 Weeks 5 Weeks 3 Months
Hedges’ g
3.1
p=0.002
Hedges’ g
3.2
p=0.002
Hedges’ g
3.2
p=0.002
Hedges’ g
2.7
p=0.003
Hedges’ g
2.0
p=0.003
57. IFS + Psilocybin
● It’s not about the food
● Disordered eating thoughts & behaviors are often ways to deal with the experiences in our life
that overwhelm us with fear, grief, shame and other emotional pain.
● IFS is a form of psychotherapy developed by Richard Schwartz in his therapy sessions with
individuals with eating disorders.
● It acknowledges the innate multiplicity of the mind and starts from the premise that the mind
is composed of relatively distinct subpersonalities or "parts“, i.e. self critical voices, pessimism…
● There are 3 categories of parts
● Exiles: Hold onto the burdens of trauma
● Managers: Take proactive measures to prevent activation of exiles and encounters with similar
painful situations. ex parts that "manage" food intake, sleep, public perceptions, self critical
voices, pessimism etc.
● Firefighters: Soothe exiles when they are activated. They use tools like food, drugs, meditation,
exercise, sex etc. to sooth activated or disrupted systems.
58. Planned feasibility study:
IFS + psilocybin for eating disorders
● Study Design:
● Group therapy preparation, dosing, integration, and follow-up
● Outcome measures:
● Safety and tolerability (vitals, ECG, adverse events)
● Exploring preliminary eating disorders outcomes & changes in functioning
59.
60. ● 10 healthy psychedelic-naive volunteers were given a single oral dose of 0.2-0.3mg/kg psilocybin
○ Anyone with any history of DSM diagnosis was excluded, as was anyone with a first degree
relative with a DSM diagnosis
○ Psychedelic-naive volunteers were chosen because of the potentially long-lasting effects
on 5-HT2AR that one or more past psilocybin doses might have
○ No placebo group
● Neuroimaging:
○ PET neuroimaging of 5-HT2AR (with the area of interest being the neocortex) at baseline
and 1 week later (using radioligand [11C]Cimbi-36, which has great test-retest reliability)
○ This was based on their assumption from past literature that 5-HT2AR levels would have
stabilized 1 week post-dose, and plasma psilocin levels would be zero
○ MRI done at BL and 1 week post-dose as well
Psilocybin Neuroscience (from the Madsen 2019 study)
61. ● Results
○ 8/10 had a “complete mystical experience” (MEQ>60% of max on all 4 sub scales)EDI mean score of 58.2
(range 36.7-79.7)
● Imaging:
○ They did NOT observe a direction-specific change in [11C]Cimbi-36 across individuals
○ They did, however, observe a negative correlation between change in [11C]Cimbi-36 at one-week and change
in mindfulness at three-months.
○ This suggests that psilocybin may indeed affect [11C]Cimbi- 36 levels, but that this effect varies between
individuals and possibly shapes the long-term outcome on mindfulness
● Assessments:
○ NEO-PI-R showed increased openness at 3 mo follow-up (127.0 at BL, 131.2 at 3mo, p=0.04)
○ MAAS scores, which are generally quite stable over time, increased at 3 mo follow-up from 4.2 to 4.6
(p=0.004)
○ The effect size of this is comparable to MBSR mindfulness training
○ Consistent with the findings of the Smigielski et al 2019 paper showing increased mindfulness on
psilocybin as compared to placebo in retreat participants, 1 day post retreat
○ Of note, this study did not include any mindfulness training
● PEQ scores indicated that the psilocybin session enhanced mood, spirituality and outlook on life and self
(consistent with previous studies, i.e. Griffiths 2011)
Psilocybin Study Results
62. ● They replicated the previous finding of long lasting increases in trait Openness after
psilocybin administration
● They showed an increase in mindfulness at 3 mo follow-up, which they point out may
constitute an important part of psilocybin therapy
● On a group level in this study, no differences were found on PET imaging (neocortical 5-
HT2AR binding), however, their finding of a negative correlation between individual change
in 5-HT2AR and mindfulness suggests a possible mechanism for psilocybin’s long term
effects on mindfulness
Psilocybin Study: Take Home Messages
Editor's Notes
My name is Reid Robison, I’m a psychiatrist and chief medical officer at Novamind, and i’ve been the medical director at center for change since 2017
My background is in clinical trials, and psychedelic medicine, started in academics - still adjunct faculty-- but 200 clinical trials later i was mostly underwhelmed. Except one stood out to me. Back in 2011 -- approached by janssen and j&j to do a ketamine study for them
I’ve been working with ketamine for over 10 years, in research and clinical settings. I got my first grant to study it in 2011, and worked with J&J on their ketamine studies along the way to Spravato approval
Developed a couple specific KAP protocols , including one with Dr. Adele lafrance , who was keynote speaker at our CFC conference for professionals a couple years ago, and developer of EFFT, a powerful therapy modality being used by a number of ED clinicians and centers, including here
And am working with other psychedelic medicines as well, and am the coordinating investigator for MAPS and their MDMA study for eating disorders
I co-founded cedar psychiatry and cedar clinical research , building clinics and research sites to bring psychedelic medicine into everyday healthcare
A lot of research has been conducted, and data continues to come out demonstrating that on the whole, these medicines are not only safe, but well tolerated by the majority of participants
Tryptamines
Psychedelics of this class are all derived from tryptamine (Figure 2), a ubiquitous endogenous ligand and agonist of the human trace amine-associated receptor 1 (TAAR1). The name tryptamine is derived from its structural similarity to l-tryptophan (Figure 3), an essential amino acid and the precursor to both serotonin and melatonin.
Recent research (Carhart-Harris & Friston, 2019) had brought together most of what we now know about your brain on psychedelics. In it they integrate the free-energy principle and entropic brain hypothesis. The resulting framework is called the relaxed beliefs under psychedelics (REBUS).
The main take-away is that psychedelics work to relax the precision of prior beliefs (priors, top-down). This relaxation allows bottom-up information to gain more prominence. This then allows a potential revision and deweighting of overweighted priors.
Or in other words, you cling less to old beliefs and patterns and you're more open to new ideas and experiences. If you've always hated going to the gym because of a bad experience, you might be more open to trying it out now.
This framework has many more applications outside of self-development. Many problems of mental-health are related to having rigid patterns (OCD, depression, trauma) that need to be broken. Currently much research is being done and we're optimistic that the use of psilocybin in clinical/therapheutic settings is only a few years away.
The key, then, to self-actualization is to consciously create for yourself healthy & positive habits that will, with enough repeated effort, become the new automatic/default behavior.
Personal anecdotes from ayahuasca retreat -- reboot , blank slate, fresh start towards
It was really quite striking to me
The lateral habenula connects the limbic system (which processed emotions) and inhibits positive emotions (i.e. blocks pleasurable chemical messengers such as serotonin and dopamine).
Depression is like a kink in a hose, where the flow of pleasure and joy is blocked, but ketamine rapidly unkinks the hose, to let these chemical messengers flow
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fncel.2020.00082/full
BDNF promotes neuron growth (neurogenesis; long term potentiation)
Neurotrophic hypothesis of depression:
Repeated stress prunes neuron
Ketamine can improve the abnormal plasticity of glutamate synapses
“When this promoted state of plasticity is combined with rehabilitation, plastic networks can reorganize so that impaired vision of one eye, due to developmental visual deprivation, can be fully restored (Castrén and Kojima, 2017).”
KAP is like doing this medication + rehabilitation, but for mental health.
Gene-environment interactions
Patients with the short (S) variant tri-allelic polymorphisms of the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR) promoter region were more likely than those with only one risk factor (genetic or environmental) to have smaller hippocampal volumes when experience childhood stress (Frodl et al., 2010).
The lateral habenula connects the limbic system (which processed emotions) and inhibits positive emotions (i.e. blocks pleasurable chemical messengers such as serotonin and dopamine).
Depression is like a kink in a hose, where the flow of pleasure and joy is blocked, but ketamine rapidly unkinks the hose, to let these chemical messengers flow
The lateral habenula connects the limbic system (which processed emotions) and inhibits positive emotions (i.e. blocks pleasurable chemical messengers such as serotonin and dopamine).
Depression is like a kink in a hose, where the flow of pleasure and joy is blocked, but ketamine rapidly unkinks the hose, to let these chemical messengers flow
The lateral habenula connects the limbic system (which processed emotions) and inhibits positive emotions (i.e. blocks pleasurable chemical messengers such as serotonin and dopamine).
which is reflected in the ways that you’re thinking about your experience, the actual contents of your thoughts during the experience, your attitude towards the experience, your mood going into/during/coming out of the experience.
How do we optimize mindset?
Important to note that we are not trying to completely control or direct the experience when we try to optimize mindset. We want to get out of the way of the medicine and the inner healing intelligence.
Educate about what to expect
Make sure they understand the logistics
Give them a sense for what it will feel like
This will help reduce distracting thoughts, fear, and uncertainty.
Intention setting
Help the client clarify their purpose for doing this/what they want to get out of this.
Arguably the most important thing you can do to affect mindset.
A way to empower the client; individualize the treatment
Important that the client really connects with the intention; owns it; records it
An anchor for the client / for you in the moment and in reflection in the future
Help them start with the following questions:
What did I come here for?
What am I trying to learn?
What am I hoping to heal?
What am I seeking to transform?
What am I trying to cultivate?
What is the most loving thing I could do for myself?
Next, select a verb
Help me with / Teach me about / Show me
Combine verb with answers to initial questions
Help me heal from my trauma
Teach me about my anger
Show me how to be less critical of myself
Have them write it down
Prime the mind with presence process or brief emotional inner work (e.g., process of emotional self-exploration)
When in doubt, curiosity/surrender/let go. “If there’s a door, open it… etc.”
While the physical space that someone occupies is the most obvious component of their setting, all five of the senses should be considered. Music, noise, lighting, social company, clothing, temperature, furniture and the ability to successfully meet basic needs are all essential too!
How do we optimize setting?
Setting can shape the experience vs. but we also want it to get out of the way of the medicine
Physical comfort:
Comfortable clothing, layers and a blanket for temp control
Access to bathroom, food, water.
chair / couch they are on
Eyeshades promote journey inward, but not required.
Social presence. Private room is great, but not necessary. Everybody in there needs to be mindful of the energy/noise/attitude they bring into the room.
Feng Shui: lighting, decor, furniture
Music. Recommend non-lyrical. Instrumental, chanting, ceremonial drums, ambient nature sounds. A song change can alter the experience for good or for ill. If they use their own phone they need to turn off notifications. If they use a music service that inserts ads, they may want to find another way (like use ours). Playlists on Spotify.
Clinical presence. You as the facilitator are part of the setting.
If their mindset seems to take a turn for the worse, support with safe touch, reminders that they are safe, coach through relaxation breathing.
life is full of mystery (especially the last year or two).. or some might call it uncertainty. and that can be quite uncomfortable at times.
you can punctuate the cycle of your life with ceremonies, and you can sacramentalize the mystery. it’s a collapsing of the chaos into something more predictable and comforting, — a place of more order, a place of worrying about less — thinking less and feeling more.
[and rituals themselves can be uncomfortable sometimes. — like a sweat lodge, a sun dance or vision question or even a yoga practice or some time spent sitting in meditation… but its’ done with intention, purpsose, meaning. and we start to get out of our heads and into our experience, relaxing a little more along the way, being more accepting of the uncertain stuff, the discomfort. making more of life ‘sacramentalize’.. ceremonialized]
Here's an example of how we're using clinical data to fill the medical device knowledge gap – a look at our spravato (esketamine) data
Current treatment strategies for treatment resistant depression include switching antidepressants, combining antidepressants, adding other meds.
Not only do these switching and augmenting strategies leave a high % of people still suffering with serious depressive sx, many of them also come with a number of unwanted side effects.
Add to that the fact that most antidepressants take several weeks or more to kick in, and the risk of suicidality with severe depression, and we literally have a crisis situation in our mental health system.
When spravato was approved in 2019, we made the decision to offer it as a treatment option for TRD at all our clinics. The approval was exciting for a number of reasons. This was the first rapid antidepressant approved by the FDA, and the first psychedelic type medicine approved for a psychiatric condition. The cost was high, but FDA approval meant that we could leverage clients insurance , something they'd been asking for years, but could rarely do with regular ketamine, as it's given 'off-label' since it was FDA approved for use in anesthesia, but later studied for depression when it was already a generic medicine.
However, there is really NO real-world and long-term data for patients with TRD receiving esketamine. And like I pointed out on the last slide, it's what happens in the real world that really matters
For this retrospective study of our data, we obtained IRB approval from the university of Utah ethics board. Then we extracted a deidentified cohort of patients with TRD (and often other conditions) receiving esketamine therapy July 2019—June 2020, as an initial first pass.
We explored some of the baseline characteristics of these clients -- This population with TRD had several other physical and mental health comorbidities and often multiple psychiatric medications. We observed clinically meaningful improvements in depressive symptoms as measured by the PHQ-9 survey instrument. I was also really encouraged to see that they did not experience significant tolerability issues, and the cost burden on the patients themselves for esketamine treatment was minimal..
○Look at the lives saved, and reductions in the burden that comes along with severe, treatment resistant depression
To both leverage our growing repository of real-world psychedelic medicine data, and our research infrastructure, we created a multi-clinic prospective registry of ketamine data.
Clinical registries, including patient, product and claims registries, not only provide a rich source of RWD. They are also critical tools for generating RWE itself and using RWE to support post-market surveillance and research.
This ketamine registry allows us to
•Establish clinical best practice guidelines
•Demonstrate the safety and effectiveness of ketamine
•Start to publish ketamine safety & efficacy data to make meaningful contributions to the evidence base.. And improve how psychedelic medicine is delivered
• … Sharing insights from these clinically-rich data assets is one of the key ways to advance care and improve health outcomes for all.
The Role of Registries in Generating Real-World Evidence
- Pharma companies use them for ‘phase IV’ post-marketing surveillance studies, also called pharmacovigilance
- collecting data in a structured way, so it can be not only analyzed but done so across our locations and across collaborators in this effort
- stay tuned for a broader initiative. We're going to announce collaborator
Here's an example of how we're using clinical data to fill the medical device knowledge gap – a look at our spravato (esketamine) data
Current treatment strategies for treatment resistant depression include switching antidepressants, combining antidepressants, adding other meds.
Not only do these switching and augmenting strategies leave a high % of people still suffering with serious depressive sx, many of them also come with a number of unwanted side effects.
Add to that the fact that most antidepressants take several weeks or more to kick in, and the risk of suicidality with severe depression, and we literally have a crisis situation in our mental health system.
When spravato was approved in 2019, we made the decision to offer it as a treatment option for TRD at all our clinics. The approval was exciting for a number of reasons. This was the first rapid antidepressant approved by the FDA, and the first psychedelic type medicine approved for a psychiatric condition. The cost was high, but FDA approval meant that we could leverage clients insurance , something they'd been asking for years, but could rarely do with regular ketamine, as it's given 'off-label' since it was FDA approved for use in anesthesia, but later studied for depression when it was already a generic medicine.
However, there is really NO real-world and long-term data for patients with TRD receiving esketamine. And like I pointed out on the last slide, it's what happens in the real world that really matters
For this retrospective study of our data, we obtained IRB approval from the university of Utah ethics board. Then we extracted a deidentified cohort of patients with TRD (and often other conditions) receiving esketamine therapy July 2019—June 2020, as an initial first pass.
We explored some of the baseline characteristics of these clients -- This population with TRD had several other physical and mental health comorbidities and often multiple psychiatric medications. We observed clinically meaningful improvements in depressive symptoms as measured by the PHQ-9 survey instrument. I was also really encouraged to see that they did not experience significant tolerability issues, and the cost burden on the patients themselves for esketamine treatment was minimal..
○Look at the lives saved, and reductions in the burden that comes along with severe, treatment resistant depression
Not only are these studies showing effectiveness, but also sustained effectiveness.
MAPS is conducting phase 3 trials of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for treatment-resistant PTSD, under the FDA’s breakthrough therapy designation, and the results are quite striking.
An analysis of phase 2 data showed that at 12-month follow-up 67% of participants no longer met criteria for PTSD.
http://www.imaginaria.org/wasson/life.htm
A WANDERING MIND
If you’re like most other people, your mind spends the majority of its time wandering from one place to another, without any real anchor. A study done by Harvard Psychologist and happiness guru Dan Gilbert showed just one of the many problems with that – distraction leads to unhappiness.
The study concluded, “a wandering mind is an unhappy mind.”
This is true, he showed, even when thinking about something pleasant. Remnants of day-to-day experiences get stuck in our minds, and we ruminate.
DEFAULT MODE NETWORK
Theres this bundle of neurons coursing through the brain called the default mode network. It’s more active when we’re not fully present, when we’re thinking about tomorrow or yesterday, or worrying. And people are much less happen when this DMN is active.
On the flip side, the DMN is less active when lost in our work, thinking about others, in that flow state where we’re lost in our work or activity.
(mg per kg is a typical clinical measure of dose for drugs of all kinds).
https://www.minds.com/blog/view/552472993125638144
"We seem to have found levels of the substance and particular conditions for its use that give a high probability of a profound and beneficial experience, a low enough probability of psychological struggle, and very little risk of any actual harm," says lead author Roland Griffiths, PhD.
A followup 14 months after the study showed that 94 percent of the subjects felt the experience was definitely within their top 5 most significant spiritual experiences.
Not only healing, but a sense that there is something more.
When administered to people carefully, in a safe space and the presence of trusting/safe people -- the great majority have remarkable experiences , that map on to naturally occuring mystical experiences.
That we are more than we could ever conceive of
And that we are all different expressions of the same underlying underlying fabric (ocean?)
BTW- you don’t need psychedelics to have one of these experiences, but with the rtight dose of psilocybin, set and setting, we can occasion these experiences with high probability.. And can therefore seek to understand this whole process a little more. (TELESCOPE quote)
Just to give one more example, this study by Robin and colleagues at imperial, published in The Lancet Psychiatry, they found that depressive symptoms were reduced rapidly and sustained over time
in patients with treatment-resistant depression who received just 2 doses of psilocybin in a therapeutic setting
As a psychiatrist, 2 doses of a medicine, plus psychotherapy , results in this type of change is incredibly exciting.