Most UX designers live in the world of the user, designing products, features, games, etc. But in Marketing, the buyer is #1. In this talk, we explore the difference in buyer vs. user personas and unpack the "Great Persona Controversy".
Architecture case study India Habitat Centre, Delhi.pdf
Buyer vs User Personas
1. @2023 GoDaddy Inc.
1
March 8, 2023
Tony Quiroz, Director, Strategy
Global Research & Insights Team @GoDaddy
Buyer vs. User
Personas
Mats Christéen
Foundry Wood
FOUNDRYWOOD.COM
UX in AZ Meet Up, Tempe, AZ
2. Hi, I’m Tony
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
2
• 6-Years at GoDaddy
• Global Research and Insights Team (GRIT)
• UX & Marketing background
• “The Journey Guy”
• tonyquiroz.com
3. Sketching
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
3
• Draw a picture of a college student
• Include 3-4 attributes/personality traits
• First thing that comes to mind
• 5 minutes
• Asdafds
• Asdasdf
• Asdfasdf
• asdfasdf
College Student: Traits:
• Questions?
• Let’s go!
4. So different…
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
4
Incoming Freshman Graduating Senior
Also: Part-Time Students, Remote Learners, Parent-Students, Grad Students, and on and on.
5. Can’t just
assume we all
know the
audience.
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
5
https://www.portent.com/blog/marketing-strategy/3-common-leadership-pitfalls-to-avoid-at-all-costs.htm
6. Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
6
7. Buyer vs. User Personas
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
7
https://medium.com/swlh/buyers-are-not-users-39cff82631cc
Buyers: Users:
• User journey
• May use pre-purchase (trials, etc.)
• Different types (Newbie, Pro, etc.)
• Success = Satisfaction over
time (JTBDs, 3E’s)
• Shopping journey
• Different types (B2C vs. B2B, etc.)
• Not always the user
• Success = Makes a purchase
decision they’re happy with
8. Different Personas / Teams
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
8
https://emeritus.org/in/learn/essential-tips-for-strategizing-the-marketing-plan/
https://leapscholar.com/blog/product-design-courses-in-canada-eligibility-admission/
Buyer vs. User
9. Research -
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
9
https://www.nngroup.com/articles/persona-types/
Proto-Personas
• Quickly align based on the
team’s existing assumptions.
• Internal SMEs.
• Not based on research.
Qualitative Personas
• Based on small-sample
qualitative research.
• Interviews (6-8 per).
• User tests.
• Field studies.
Statistical Personas
• Personas emerge from
statistical analysis.
• Early qual used to inform large-
scale survey.
• Survey data provides quant for
stat analysis.
Lightweight Qualitative Statistical
10. The Great
Persona
Controversy,
Part 1
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
10
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/please-remove-demographics-from-your-persona-below-indi-young/
Conditionally
Mary
29 years old
Female
Married, 3 kids
Queens, NY
11. Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
11
https://www.bostondigital.com/insights/audience-segmentation-why-demographics-are-no-longer-enough
“The major distinction
between the two is that
demographics can help you
infer what people choose,
whereas psychographics are
used to predict not just what
people choose, but
also how and why they
choose.”
– Samantha Davidson, Boston Digital
“Procrastinator Paul”
“Betty Browser”
“Antsy Angela, 12YO, 6th
Grade Class Trip Taker at
Desert Shadows Elementary”
12. The Great
Persona
Controversy,
Part 2
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
12
https://productcoalition.com/product-user-personas-a-waste-of-money-and-time-863735549f7e
Say what?
13. Personas: A Waste of $$$ and
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
13
“Personas are outdated
snapshots before they’re
even created … The
market is not standing still.
It’s a living breathing
organism of interactions
that’s continuously
evolving.”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._Stanley_Hall
Harvard PHD, Founder of the American Journal of Psychology, First President of the
American Psychology Association.
https://productcoalition.com/product-
user-personas-a-waste-of-money-and-
time-863735549f7e
14. Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
14
“They’re a gross over-
simplification and
absolutely worthless at
scale … Even the best
crafted personas only
begin to scratch the
surface … they do not
really get to the root
cause of why people made
those decisions within
their environment at that
specific moment in time.”
Remember this?
https://productcoalition.com/product-
user-personas-a-waste-of-money-and-
time-863735549f7e
Personas: A Waste of $$$ and
15. Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
15
“They’re often bound
together with another
time-wasting exercise in
a digital globalized
world — user interviews
… The problem with this
approach is that it’s built
on the premise that users
are going to tell you the
truth … We must learn
what customers really
want, not what they say
they want …”
https://productcoalition.com/product-user-personas-a-waste-of-money-and-time-863735549f7e
Personas: A Waste of $$$ and
16. Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
16
“What should we do
instead? ... the approach
that has worked for myself
is to define our target
audiences, and then seek
to understand the jobs to
be done by each of those
audiences … The focus
should be on continuous
improvement via a build,
measure, learn feedback
loop.”
https://productcoalition.com/product-
user-personas-a-waste-of-money-and-
time-863735549f7e
Personas: A Waste of $$$ and
17. • Identify top-level audiences and key sub-groups
• Alignment (teams, orgs, clients)
• Deeper understanding (surveys, journeys, JTBDs)
• Prioritization
• Better outcomes
Why Personas?
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
17
https://www.sketchappsources.com/free-source/3795-user-personas-template-sketch-freebie-resource.html
• Good for training and onboarding, too.
18. Examples
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
18
• Technical Buyer
• Economic Buyer
• Power User Pete
• “The Specialist” Buyer
• Fit-to-Project Buyer
• Dev-Minded Side Hustler
• On-the-Go Business Buyer
• Extra Device Buyers
• Remote Radha
19. Activity
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
19
https://svclookingglass.com/3557/entertainment/lifestyle/interested-in-buying-a-car/
• Break into groups
• Draw from the hat:
1. Vehicle
2. Buyer
3. User
• Build lightweight personas
using templates provided
• Share when done
Car Buyer / Driver
20. Buyer Persona
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
20 Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
Description:
Cares About:
Buyer Type:
Shopping Needs:
Budget:
Buyer Photo
Who is your buyer?
• Name
• Vehicle Type (P1)
• Demographics
• Psychographics (P2)
What’s important to
them about the vehicle
their shopping for?
• Must haves
• Nice to haves
• Deal breakers
(P3)
What can help them in
their shopping journey?
• From the automaker
• From 3rd parties
• Online
• Offline (friends, etc.)
Price range: $X - $X
21. User Persona
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
21 Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
Description:
Goals:
Driver Type:
Driving Behaviors:
Key Pain Point:
User Photo
Who is your user?
• Name (same as buyer
or different?)
• Vehicle Type (P1)
• Demographics
• Psychographics (P2)
What’s the vehicle used
for? What do they value
as a driver?
• Jobs the vehicle will
fulfill for the driver
(commuting to work,
etc.)
• How (safely, quickly)
How does this driver type
act behind the wheel?
• Approach
• Use of vehicle features
• Use of other items
• Passenger interactions
(P3)
#1 issue with regards to
operating the vehicle.
22. @2023 GoDaddy Inc.
22 https://www.zendrive.com/data-studies/driver-personas-new-behavioral-clusters-and-their-risk-implications
23. Wrap up
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
23
• Buyers vs. User personas = Different phases of the journey: Shopping vs. use
• They’re not always the same person
• Start with top-level audiences to align and prioritize
• Then do more research (Journeys, JTBDs)
• Consider demographics and psychographics
• Get better outcomes
24. Thanks, G’night!
Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
24
https://medium.com/swlh/buyers-are-not-users-39cff82631cc
Buyers:
Users:
26. @2023 GoDaddy Inc.
26
Family Vehicle
Sports Car
Work Truck
Off-Road 4x4
Commuter Car
Impulse
Researcher
Brand Loyalist
Price Sensitive
Luxury
Nervous Nellie
Tech Lover
Speed Demon
Safety First
Road-Rager
Vehicle Type Buyer Type User Type
27. Buyer Persona
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
27 Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
Description:
Cares About:
Buyer Type:
Shopping Needs:
Budget:
Photo + Name
28. User Persona
@2023 GoDaddy Inc.
28 Buyer vs. User Personas, UX in AZ Meet Up, Q1 2023 – Tony Quiroz, GoDaddy
Description:
Goals:
Driver Type:
Driving Behaviors:
Key Pain Point:
Photo + Name
Editor's Notes
After sketching: Walk around the room and find people who had the same kind of image as you. Stand together in groups. (HUMAN AFFINITY MAPPING!)
AND YET… so many times, projects kick off without a clear view of customer.
Freshman: First time living away from home, doesn’t know her way around campus yet, not sure about her major/minor, not thinking about what companies she’ll apply to work at.
Senior: Moving to another city, maybe back home? Have to learn a new place again. Not as concerned about that as he is about getting a job. Renting an apartment if he can afford it.
Freshman: First time living away from home, doesn’t know her way around campus yet, not sure about her major/minor, not thinking about what companies she’ll apply to work at.
Senior: Moving to another city, maybe back home? Have to learn a new place again. Not as concerned about that as he is about getting a job. Renting an apartment if he can afford it.
Survey data is mostly demographics. Hard to get at psychographics in a survey.
“Procrastinator Paul” – ”Betty Browser” – “Angela, 12, 6th Grade Class Trip Taker at Desert Shadows Elementary”
Freshman: First time living away from home, doesn’t know her way around campus yet, not sure about her major/minor, not thinking about what companies she’ll apply to work at.
Senior: Moving to another city, maybe back home? Have to learn a new place again. Not as concerned about that as he is about getting a job. Renting an apartment if he can afford it.
Harvard PHD, Founder of the American Journey of Psychology, First President of the American Psychology Association
Harvard PHD, Founder of the American Journey of Psychology, First President of the American Psychology Association
Harvard PHD, Founder of the American Journey of Psychology, First President of the American Psychology Association
Harvard PHD, Founder of the American Journey of Psychology, First President of the American Psychology Association
Ask them to share what Vehicle, Buyer, User they chose out or the hat, then talk about their persona.
Ask them to share what Vehicle, Buyer, User they chose out or the hat, then talk about their persona.
Ask them to share what Vehicle, Buyer, User they chose out or the hat, then talk about their persona.
Ask them to share what Vehicle, Buyer, User they chose out or the hat, then talk about their persona.