Prof. Molly Scott Cato: Economics for Justice and Sustainability. A presentation at the TheIU.org 2013 Conference 'Economics for Conscious Evolution', London, UK, July 2013.
8. Supporting Collective Ownership of
Windpower in Denmark
High and consistent
feed-in-tariff
Distance regulation +
consumption laws
Growth of coops =
84% of turbine
ownership, 12% of
population
10. The Bioregional Economy: A Globally
Local Proposal
• ‘Borrowing your
resources from the local
natural environment’
• Having a stake in your
local place
• Ownership and
accountability are
related
11. Objective for the Proposal
• To achieve the best possible
level of well-being for the
least possible use of
materials and energy
• To take steps through
participation and
engagement before the crisis
provokes more authoritarian
responses
• To focus the economy on
quality rather than quantity
12. What is a bioregion?
• ‘a unique region definable by natural (rather than
political) boundaries’
• A bioregion is literally and etymologically a ‘life-
place’—with a geographic, climatic, hydrological and
ecological character capable of supporting unique
human and non-human living communities. Bioregions
can be variously defined by the geography of
watersheds, similar plant and animal ecosystems, and
related identifiable landforms and by the unique
human cultures that grow from natural limits and
potentials of the region
13. An economic bioregion
• A bioregional economy would be embedded
within its bioregion and would acknowledge
ecological limits.
• Bioregions as natural social units determined
by ecology rather than economics
• Can be largely self-sufficient in terms of basic
resources such as water, food, products and
services.
• Enshrine the principle of trade subsidiarity
14. Context is Everything
• Western
economies are
bloated
• Message is
different in
economies with
absolute poverty
15. The Indigenous Perspective
• The land does
not belong to us
but we belong to
the land
• Sense of
reciprocity and
mutuality
16. In societies whose very existence depended
upon knowing the earth and how to hunt its
animals and forage for its foods—the way of
life for 99 percent of human history—respect
for the natural world and an appreciation of
the land itself as sacred and inviolable was
surely inevitable. That sensibility was literally
so vital that it was embedded in some central
place in each culture’s myths and traditions
and was embodied in each culture’s supreme
spirits and deities.
Kirkpatrick Sale
17. Life is relational not rational
• ‘Our ideas about our place in the world
pervade all our thought, along with the
imagery that expresses them, constantly
determining what questions we ask and what
answers can seem possible.’ Mary Midgley
• Rationalist, capitalist models of economic life
have lead to the ‘disenchantment of the
world’
Twoimages of thesustainabilityeconomy: istheexistingbusinessmodeltherightframework?
The publication in 2012 of the Resource Revolution McKinsey report world was a sign that the legal battle for the ownership of land worldwide is underway. The report considers that ongoing change in global land ownership patterns and land use is "the next revolution agro-industrial '. The West is concerned about preserving their lifestyle high energy and go to land as a sink for emissions. the first phase of this was the Clean Development Mechanism agreed in Kyoto, but the land has also been seized to produce biofuels. Grano campaign group have represented 17 million hectares of land that has been captured by global agribusiness producing fuel crops between 2002 and 2012. Much of this land is in some of the world's poorest countries, has been diverted to the production of subsistence of the local population in crops to produce energy for the west fuel starvation.
'Mean average CO2 emissions are strongly correlated with income: households within the highest equivalised income decile have mean total CO2 emissions more than twice that of households within the lowest equivalised income decile. Emissions from private road travel and aviation account for a high proportion of this differential: aviation emissions of the highest income decile are more than six times that of the lowest income decile.'
This slide shows what remains of local sourcing in my own local economy, or rather how local sourcing has been revived by the citizens with a pro-environmental attitude. Here we Cottage day, a local orchard that produces juices and cider, trying to divert consumption of orange juice imported. The focus of the bioregional economy is consumption reconnect back to the local soil. In my book I argue that this supports the possibility of accountability in a way that is impossible when we import vegetables or fruits from around the world, because we simply can not understand their impact along the length of the supply chain.
Siento la necesidad de señalar cómo culturalmente relativos esta obra. En Occidente hemos sido alentados a consumir en exceso y el regreso a los campos es un nostálgico, romántico y utópico esfuerzo de aquellos que siempre han vivido en el lujo. Soy consciente de que esto no es apropiado en las sociedades donde muchos todavía viven en la pobreza absoluta o, como en la imagen, donde la gente ha visto obligado a regresar a la tierra como en la Revolución Cultural China.
¿Qué podemos aprender acerca de una relación más estrecha con la tierra de otras sociedades que son más sostenibles que la nuestra? He tratado de imaginar cómo el mundo podría gustar a través de los trazos de la canción de los aborígenes de Australia. La interpretación inicial de estas songlines o pistas seguidas por los antepasados totémicos mientras seguían su viaje creativo a través de la tierra, es como una forma de dar sentido geográfico del lugar. Permiten a los pueblos originarios a encontrar su camino y encontrar fuentes de alimento y agua. Pero también son sistemas de significados, de los mitos que permiten a las identidades individuales, que construyen comunidades, y que facilitan las relaciones entre las comunidades humanas, las comunidades animales, y los recursos que comparten. El tacón antropólogo australiano identifica en el songlines un proceso de utilización de paisaje para facilitar la conexión y relación, para concluir que "la historia y la arqueología han demostrado repetidamente que las culturas que no mantienen conexiones sostenibles a grandes extensiones de tierra lo hacen por su necedad. Tal vez si nos enfocamos menos en autopistas informáticas y prestó más atención al cuidado de la diversidad que se encuentra a lo largo de las canciones Dreaming, cursos de agua y vías de recursos, nuestra propia supervivencia estaría menos amenazada.
Hay que despojarse de las ataduras de este sofocante del siglo 19 mentalidad.