SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
PROGRAM BRIEF
Towards Community Resilience:
An Integrated Multi-Sectoral Program Approach to Cyclic
Drought-Induced Household Food Insecurity Targeting Productive
Safety Net Program (PSNP) Beneficiaries in Wolayta, Ethiopia
FINDINGS
FINDINGS & LESSONS LEARNED
1
>> Beneficiary households receiving multi-year, multi-sector support improved more in select key
welfare indicators than those receiving intermittent, single-sector support, in subsequent years of
endured food insecurity shocks.
>> It takes time (multiple years of monitoring the same target households) to be able to demonstrate
resilience and often humanitarian donor funding cycles do not easily facilitate this as they tend to
support short duration projects.
>> Developing appropriate, e.g. social determinant indicators for monitoring and methodologies
for measurement to demonstrate resilience, is critical vis-à-vis traditional/classical humanitarian
emergency project indicator selection.
>> There is need for cost-effective, efficient, and simplified measures for gauging the shock, well-
being, and absorptive/adaptive/transformative capacities of intervention target groups.
>> There is a need for intra-consortium rationalization of monitoring and evaluation (M&E) efforts
where project implementation is undertaken by multiple implementing partner organizations.
>> There is a need to rationalize M&E efforts, where donor funding lines often have non-resilience
friendly, pre-scripted indicators, which can also be different from the Government of Ethiopia (GoE)
indicator and productive safety net program (PSNP) indicators, the latter of which is serving as the
basis for beneficiary client targeting.
>> There is considerable value add in a consortium approach in the context of joint advocacy, reach/
coverage, and intra-consortium skills-building and capacity transfer.
>> Sector integration contributes significantly to building resilience and addressing complex/multi-
faceted problems.
>> Good communication, collaboration, and joint planning with different governmental sector
agencies is critical.
>> Capacity strengthening of the government and community institutions is essential to successful
program accomplishment.
>> Behavior change models should be adapted to pre-existing community systems.
>> Existence of community-based structures (Health Emergency Workers (HEW)) and Health
Development Armies (HDAs)) at the grassroots level is vital for accessing the community at the
household (HH) level for the transfer of capacity building in life-saving skills.
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
3
Despite significant economic gains over the
last decade evidenced by GDP growth, poverty
reduction gains, and increased access to basic
health, sanitation, and education services, a
considerable segment of the rural population of
Ethiopia remains highly vulnerable to drought-
induced transitory and chronic food insecurity1.
About 10% of country’s population is chronically
food insecure with this figure rising to more than
15% during drought years2.
Reducing this vulnerability, stabilizing the net
volatility in the number of households exposed to
periodic drought induced shocks, and ultimately
building their resilience is a significant, complex
and perennial task requiring coordinated,
integrated, effective, and innovative interventions.
Over time, and in response, the Government of
Ethiopia (GoE) has evolved and is continuing to
develop, refine, and strengthen its strategies
and operational frameworks for resilience
actions. The Disaster Risk Management Strategic
Program and Investment Framework (DRM-SPIF)
and the Ethiopia Country Programming Paper to
End Drought Emergencies in the Horn of Africa
are two recent (2012) seminal guiding strategies
developed to advance the operationalization of
resilience.
The Ethiopian disaster response system is
complex, with support meant to cascade from
federal to regional and sub-regional (woreda and
kebele) levels based on scales, magnitude, and
duration of impact. Currently, the system has
largely evolved for supporting drought-related
hazard events. Proportionately and historically,
droughts have been the highest impact hazard
observed and consequently these events have
been accorded an elevated priority of focus
as a result of the significant food insecurity
(disaster risk) they generate. In the past, this risk
resulted in substantial mortality and morbidity as
evidenced in the ’73 and ‘83-85 famines. Climate
change and increasing climate variability as can
be manifested by protracted El Niño conditions,
substantially exacerbates this risk, rendering a
greater percentage of population vulnerable.
At the ground-level, the frontline national disaster
response key functions are discharged in part
or whole by food security task force disaster
prevention and preparedness committee
representatives at both the woreda and kebele
levels; development agents; health emergency
workers; and agriculture sector focal points.
Principally, the national system comprises (a)
food security reserve; (b) early warning & early
response committee; (c) incident command
system; (d) hotspot classification and analysis
facility; and (e) links to the productive safety net
program (PSNP).
This is informed by early warning forecast
information provided by systems such as Family
Early Warning Systems Network (FEWSNET),
seasonal emergency needs assessments, and
routine damage and loss/needs assessment-
reporting (kebeles to woreda and regional bureau
levels). The national disaster management system
classifies hotspot zones, estimates agriculture
production/yields, and identifies distressed
households. Ultimately, scale-specific and
resource-appropriate contingency responses are
triggered. Initial front-line responses fall under
the domain of woredas. When surpassed by scale
of need/demand, regional bureaus then provide
support, and for higher threshold responses, the
federal level engages. Based on hotspot zone
FIGURE 1:
Frequency of Drought Hazard in Ethiopia 1974-2007
Source: Olthof, W.; Svedin, S. (2014): Resilience in Practice.
Ethiopia Case Study. A presentation made by ECHO &
DEVCO officers to the European Commission.
BACKGROUND
4
trends and reported distress levels, households
identified as eligible to be permanent or transitory
“safety net” beneficiaries are identified. The
current common/universal “disaster response”
system trigger at household level for receiving
productive safety net assistance (PSNP) in the form
of food or cash transfer assistance is “nutrition
status.”
While the national disaster risk management
(DRM) system (Figure 2) and its interface with the
PSNP is well articulated, challenges remain in
optimizing its functionality, efficacy, and efficiency
at woreda, kebele
and lower levels.
International Medical
Corps discussions
(2015) with the Food
Security Coordination
Directorate of the Disaster Risk Management
Food Security Sector (DRMFSS) confirm that
interventions to build capacities at the woreda
and kebele levels, as well as strengthening the
systems and interface between regional bureaus
and woreda levels remain necessary and highly
desirable. As a strategic imperative, International
Medical Corps programming in country seeks
to support this decentralized capacity building,
wherever possible.
FIGURE 2:
Summary of Ethiopia’s National
Disaster Risk Management System
FIGURE 3:
Administrative Map
of Wolayta Zone
PSNP DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT
Early Warning & Response Directorate
• DRMEWR Case Team
• Emergency Logistics Management Case Team
• Emergency Finance & Procurment Case Team
• Early Warning Response Info Management
Case Workers
• Aid Agency Coordination Case Workers
Food Security Coordination Directorate
• Resettlement Coordination Case Team
• Safety Net & Household Asset Case Team
Natural Resource Management Directorate
• Public Works Coordination
EARLY WARNING
INFORMATION
SYSTEMS
• Reporting
• Risk Models
• Assessment
• Verification
MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE
DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT FOOD
SECURITY SECTOR
MINISTRY OF FINANCE &
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
NATIONAL DISASTER PREVENTION &
PREPAREDNESS
PREVENTION,
PREPAREDNESS,
RESPONSE,
MITIGATION/RISK
REDUCTION, RECOVERY,
REHABILITATION:
• Finance & resource
transfer requests
• Safety net beneficiary
identification
• Food / cash distribution
• Food reserves
• HH Asset Transfer
REACTIVE & PROACTIVE
RESPONSE:
• Emergency response
to all Clients
• Risk Financing
• Core / transitory
beneficiary screening
• Accountability &
Grievance
• Mulit-agency comms &
coordination
• Monitoring & feedback
• Food, nutrition,
livelihood, NRM
INPUTS
• Livelihood
Baselines
• Seasonal
Assessments
• Fast onset loss &
needs assessments
• Agro-metdata
• Agro-production
estimates
PROJECTCONTEXT
WOLAYTA
PROJECT CONTEXT
5
Wolayta zone (Figure 3) is situated approximately 300 kilometres
south of Addis Ababa and is one of 13 zones in the Southern Nations
and Nationalities Peoples Region (SNNPR). It encompasses an area
of 4471.3 km2 and is home to a population of 1,750,569 persons of
whom approximately 16% are children under five.
Wolayta experiences a mixture of low, mid, and highland climatic
conditions and is known to be part of the “green hunger zone”
of Ethiopia. Similar to other areas of rural Ethiopia, the zone is
characterized by recurrent droughts, high population density (386
p/km2), acute land shortages, land degradation, decreasing soil
fertility, and inadequate resource management. Forty percent of
the population lives below the poverty line and 45% suffer from
food shortage4.
The high population density results in very small landholdings (0.2-
0.5 hectares), which do not permit families to sustainably live off
the land. It is calculated that at a minimum 1.5 hectares are needed
per household. Typically, Wolayta has two harvest seasons: the
Belg, which occurs between mid-March to mid-May, and the Meher,
which occurs between July to September. Poverty and malnutrition
are high with child malnutrition appearing to be as much related
to issues of health (malaria) and hygiene (water) as with feeding
practices and food availability5. The zone is further at-risk due to
low institutional capacities for disaster risk management at woreda
and kebele levels. Generally, levels of preparedness across the
zone are insufficient to cope with repeated shocks.
For decades, the zone has been targeted with emergency
interventions in response to food insecurity and malnutrition.
From 2011, two consecutive years of harvest failure and persistent
drought have diminished food reserves and have led to a need for
concerted nutrition programming to address chronic malnutrition.
Delayed Belg rains, crop pests, livestock diseases, and malaria and
meningitis outbreaks all struck the zone in 2012. These conditions
resulted in significant increases in the number of people requiring
relief assistance.
PROJECTCONTEXT
6
In response, the GOE put in place a drought Early Warning System (EWS) and targeted
more than 200,000 persons under a large-scale PSNP7.
SNAPSHOT OF THE 2012 PROBLEMS
OBSERVED IN WOLAYTA
Key Sector
Indicators Trends
Nutrition April:
Therapeutic feed program (TFP) admission
increased by 200%
For children between 6 to 59 months, moderate
acute malnutrition (MAM) and severe acute
malnutrition (SAM) based on middle upper arm
circumference measurements (MUAC) and oedema
was:
18.2 and 5.1% in Boloso Sore woreda
8.6 and 4.2% in Damot Pullasa woreda
Health & WASH January- May
80,000 malaria cases detected in Boloso Sore and
Damot Pullasa woredas
Meningitis outbreaks
Livelihoods 2,117 livestock affected by disease in Damot Pullasa
275 hectares of crop damage from hailstones in
Boloso Sore woreda
255 hectares of crop damage from hailstones in
Damot Pullasa woreda
Yellow rust and sweet potato butterfly infestations
destroying 112 hectares of crops in Boloso Sore and
Damot Pullasa woredas
PROGRAMMING
With financial support (Euro 4.5M) from ECHO, between 2012 to 2014, a consortium of Concern Worldwide,
International Medical Corps, and People in Need (PIN) implemented a 36-month integrated, multi-sectoral
household resilience building program strategy targeting four emergency-prone woredas (districts) and
an estimated 385,000 persons combined in two respective phases (130,000 in phase 1/255, 000 in
phase 2).
Under the program strategy interventions that sought to move target households from emergency relief
through to longer term developmental assistance (LRRD – linking relief, rehabilitation, and development)
were implemented. Identified target beneficiary households receive multi-year nutrition support;
livelihood assistance (household asset transfer); primary health; water, sanitation, and hygiene (sanitation
marketing); community preparedness; and disaster risk reduction (DRR) services and other capacity
building interventions.
International Medical Corps implemented its project interventions in Damot Pullasa and Boloso Sore,
while Concern Worldwide and People in Need (PIN) implement in Dugna Fango and Kindo Koysha.
PROGRAMMING
7
The conceptual evolution and pursuit of this integrated multi-level, multi-partner, multi-sector resilience-
building program approach that focused on households and communities in emergency-prone woredas
has been driven by a convergence of factors, including but not restricted to:
>> GoE’s productive social safety net program (PSNP) specific remit to target vulnerable households
>> Donor (ECHO) policy promoting an integrated, resilience-building, cluster-approaches
>> Tripartite consensus between government, donors, and implementing partners regarding the
demand for a step-wise need to address immediate, intermediate, and root causes of malnutrition
>> International NGO consortium (Concern Worldwide, International Medical Corps, and PIN) preferred
implementation modalities
>> Past evaluation critiques which imply that previous emergency program responses have been less
well coordinated, spatially dispersed, and sector-concentrated and failed to impart/achieve any
significant residual capabilities for community resilience over the long-term to recurrent crises
PROGRAM EVOLUTION & DESIGN
8
PROGRAMMING
OPERATIONALAPPROACH
9
OPERATIONAL APPROACH
>> Providing multi-year support to PSNP targeted (“safety-net”) vulnerable
households
>> Executing multi-sector: primary health, nutrition, livelihood (household
asset transfer), water, sanitation, and hygiene (sanitation marketing), and
disaster risk reduction (DRR) interventions
>> Facilitating continuous and routine intra-consortium coordination
>> Promoting reflection, lessons learned reviews, and experience sharing
among and between consortium institutional partners
>> Consortium coordination with GoE
>> Considering and including social behavioral change in intervention design
and roll-out (Positive Deviance Hearth & Care groups)
>> Encouraging and incentivizing community mobilization/engagement/
participation and neutralization of dependency
Specifically,theprogrammingfocusedontheobjectiveofimprovingthenutritional
status of vulnerable households in Wolayta zone and building resilience of the
community to future shocks. This was implemented by:
10
International Medical Corps remains committed to the advancement, implementation, evaluation
of integrated, multi-sector programming, including contextually relevant and appropriately adapted
combinations of health; nutrition; mental health & psychosocial support (MPHSS); sexual reproductive
health (SRH); gender based violence (GBV); water, sanitation & hygiene (WASH); disaster risk reduction;
emergency response; and livelihood interventions, specifically targeted at building resilience of
communities.
RESULTS
>> Community ownership created
>> Transfer of assets achieved through cooperatives
>> Improved saving and credit cultures
>> Some beneficiaries started ensuring their HH food security
>> Good relationships developed with local authorities
>> Local institutional capacities have been enhanced through trainings and other support
>> Potable water and sanitation coverage increased
>> Vegetable gardening and food diversification practices increased
>> Improvement in beneficiary, infant and young child feeding (IYCF) practices
>> Severe acute malnutrition (SAM) and global acute malnutrition (GAM) rates significantly reduced
>> Increased use of long acting and permanent methods (LAPM) of family planning (FP) and antenatal
care (ANC) services
>> Malaria and diarrheal disease burden reduced
>> Immunization cold chain systems improved
>> Early detection and control of epidemics enhanced
In summary the main program results achieved were:
OPERATIONALAPPROACH
1.	 Sewnet, Y. (2015) Causes and coping mechanisms of food insecurity in rural Ethiopia.
Agric. Biol. J. N. Am., 2015, 6 (5): 123-133
2.	 Endalew, B.; Muche, M.; Tadesse, S. (2015) Assessment of food security situation in
Ethiopia: a review. Asian J. Agric. Res.; 9(2): 55-68, 2015
3.	 European Union (2014) Terms of reference for situation analysis of the eight
geographical clusters and development of strategy document under the EU resilience
building program in Ethiopia (RESET)
4.	 Frankenberger, T. et. al. (2015) Ethiopia Pastoralist Areas and Resilience
Improvement and Market Expansion. Project Impact Evaluation. Baseline Survey
Report. Vol. I.
5.	 Olthof, W.; Svedin, S. (2014) Resilience in Practice. Ethiopia Case Study. A
presentation made by ECHO & DEVCO officers to the European Commission.
6.	 Demisse, A.; Bawoke, T; Emebet, D. (2014) Case study on resilience building project.
A presentation made to the Strategic Integration Meeting of International Medical
Corps in Nairobi, Kenya.
7.	 Wolayta Zonal Agricultural Office (2013)
www.InternationalMedicalCorps.org
HEADQUARTERS
INTERNATIONAL MEDICAL CORPS
12400 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 1500
Los Angeles, CA 90025
PHONE: 310-826-7800
FAX: 310-442-6622
CONTACT DETAILS:
Dr. Tenaw Bawoke
Program Coordinator
TBawoke@InternationalMedicalCorps.org
Yuri Chakalall
Disaster Risk Reduction and Resilience Advisor
YChakalall@InternationalMedicalCorps.org

More Related Content

What's hot

Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...
Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...
Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...HFG Project
 
Joern escalate2
Joern escalate2Joern escalate2
Joern escalate2JSchultner
 
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...HFG Project
 
Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...
Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...
Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...Agriculture Journal IJOEAR
 
7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE
7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE
7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCENAP Events
 
Panel29b manlosa final
Panel29b manlosa finalPanel29b manlosa final
Panel29b manlosa finalJSchultner
 
USDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to action
USDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to actionUSDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to action
USDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to actionHarm Kiezebrink
 
Foodsecurityanalysis
FoodsecurityanalysisFoodsecurityanalysis
FoodsecurityanalysisBk Pradeep
 
Emergency Public Health & Disaster Medicine
Emergency Public Health & Disaster MedicineEmergency Public Health & Disaster Medicine
Emergency Public Health & Disaster Medicinebobbykapur
 
Role of non government organizations in disaster management
Role of non government organizations in disaster managementRole of non government organizations in disaster management
Role of non government organizations in disaster managementPramoda Raj
 
Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...
Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...
Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...inventionjournals
 
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...HFG Project
 
Never again-resilient-health-systems-ebola
Never again-resilient-health-systems-ebolaNever again-resilient-health-systems-ebola
Never again-resilient-health-systems-ebolaDr. Chris Stout
 
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...HFG Project
 
Land sparing versus land sharing: moving forward
Land sparing versus land sharing: moving forwardLand sparing versus land sharing: moving forward
Land sparing versus land sharing: moving forwardjoernfischer
 
Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2
Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2
Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2Yohannes Mengesha, PhD Fellow
 
Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food security
Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food securityCapital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food security
Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food securityjoernfischer
 
Needs for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in Nigeria
Needs for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in NigeriaNeeds for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in Nigeria
Needs for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in Nigeriaiosrjce
 

What's hot (20)

Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...
Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...
Tool to Assess Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector...
 
Global Health 2035 - The Lancet Commissions
Global Health 2035 - The Lancet CommissionsGlobal Health 2035 - The Lancet Commissions
Global Health 2035 - The Lancet Commissions
 
Joern escalate2
Joern escalate2Joern escalate2
Joern escalate2
 
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
 
Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...
Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...
Social Protection and Climate Resilience: A Review Of Sub-Saharan African Cas...
 
7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE
7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE
7.2.1 Assessing progress in VGCE
 
Panel29b manlosa final
Panel29b manlosa finalPanel29b manlosa final
Panel29b manlosa final
 
USDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to action
USDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to actionUSDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to action
USDA APHIS Veterinary Vervice: One Health call to action
 
Foodsecurityanalysis
FoodsecurityanalysisFoodsecurityanalysis
Foodsecurityanalysis
 
Emergency Public Health & Disaster Medicine
Emergency Public Health & Disaster MedicineEmergency Public Health & Disaster Medicine
Emergency Public Health & Disaster Medicine
 
Role of non government organizations in disaster management
Role of non government organizations in disaster managementRole of non government organizations in disaster management
Role of non government organizations in disaster management
 
Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...
Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...
Vulnerabilityin the Face of Climate Change and Variability: Perceptions and O...
 
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
 
Never again-resilient-health-systems-ebola
Never again-resilient-health-systems-ebolaNever again-resilient-health-systems-ebola
Never again-resilient-health-systems-ebola
 
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
Entomological Monitoring, Environmental Compliance, and Vector Control Capaci...
 
Land sparing versus land sharing: moving forward
Land sparing versus land sharing: moving forwardLand sparing versus land sharing: moving forward
Land sparing versus land sharing: moving forward
 
Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2
Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2
Measuring small farmers’ vulnerability to climate change2
 
Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food security
Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food securityCapital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food security
Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy for food security
 
Needs for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in Nigeria
Needs for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in NigeriaNeeds for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in Nigeria
Needs for Disaster Risks Reduction Education in Nigeria
 
The Roll Back Malaria Program
The Roll Back Malaria ProgramThe Roll Back Malaria Program
The Roll Back Malaria Program
 

Viewers also liked

Maqueta despacho de arquitectos
Maqueta despacho de arquitectosMaqueta despacho de arquitectos
Maqueta despacho de arquitectosesmeraldazazueta
 
Lofts planos
Lofts planosLofts planos
Lofts planossel hdz
 
Estilo minimalista
Estilo minimalistaEstilo minimalista
Estilo minimalistanandofernn
 
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA cARLA PALAFIX
 
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTAARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTApodakiii
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Maqueta despacho de arquitectos
Maqueta despacho de arquitectosMaqueta despacho de arquitectos
Maqueta despacho de arquitectos
 
Lofts planos
Lofts planosLofts planos
Lofts planos
 
Lofts
LoftsLofts
Lofts
 
Estilo minimalista
Estilo minimalistaEstilo minimalista
Estilo minimalista
 
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
 
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTAARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
ARQUITECTURA MINIMALISTA
 

Similar to Multi-Sector Program Builds Community Resilience

Why to consider disaster risk management in health sector, Myanmar
Why to consider disaster risk management in health sector, MyanmarWhy to consider disaster risk management in health sector, Myanmar
Why to consider disaster risk management in health sector, MyanmarKumar Sudhir
 
Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development Some Co...
Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development   Some Co...Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development   Some Co...
Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development Some Co...Ln Perch
 
DRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPAC
DRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPACDRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPAC
DRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPACAlmaz Demessie
 
drm governance ethiopia.ppt
drm governance ethiopia.pptdrm governance ethiopia.ppt
drm governance ethiopia.pptDaniWondimeDers
 
Kenya resilience programming (2)
Kenya resilience programming (2)Kenya resilience programming (2)
Kenya resilience programming (2)NE Kim
 
Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...
Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...
Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...Global Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Rural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and Resilience
Rural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and ResilienceRural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and Resilience
Rural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and ResilienceThe Transfer Project
 
2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters
2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters
2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters2020resilience
 
Foodsecurityanalysis
FoodsecurityanalysisFoodsecurityanalysis
FoodsecurityanalysisBk Pradeep
 
2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...
2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...
2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...AKADEMIYA2063
 
Ayalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual Conference
Ayalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual ConferenceAyalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual Conference
Ayalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual ConferenceAKADEMIYA2063
 
Rao 6d monitoring global food security
Rao 6d   monitoring global food securityRao 6d   monitoring global food security
Rao 6d monitoring global food securitySizwan Ahammed
 

Similar to Multi-Sector Program Builds Community Resilience (20)

2013 Global Hunger Index Launch Event Concern Worldwide Presentation
2013 Global Hunger Index Launch Event Concern Worldwide Presentation2013 Global Hunger Index Launch Event Concern Worldwide Presentation
2013 Global Hunger Index Launch Event Concern Worldwide Presentation
 
Why to consider disaster risk management in health sector, Myanmar
Why to consider disaster risk management in health sector, MyanmarWhy to consider disaster risk management in health sector, Myanmar
Why to consider disaster risk management in health sector, Myanmar
 
Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development Some Co...
Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development   Some Co...Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development   Some Co...
Linking Adaptation And Mitigation In Climate Change And Development Some Co...
 
Lecture 3 food insecurity
Lecture 3 food insecurity Lecture 3 food insecurity
Lecture 3 food insecurity
 
DRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPAC
DRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPACDRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPAC
DRM practice in Ethiopia and its Challenge ICPAC
 
Health and Disaster Risk
Health and Disaster RiskHealth and Disaster Risk
Health and Disaster Risk
 
SET4food abstract
SET4food abstractSET4food abstract
SET4food abstract
 
drm governance ethiopia.ppt
drm governance ethiopia.pptdrm governance ethiopia.ppt
drm governance ethiopia.ppt
 
Kenya resilience programming (2)
Kenya resilience programming (2)Kenya resilience programming (2)
Kenya resilience programming (2)
 
Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...
Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...
Climate Change, Disaster Risk and Hunger: Linking Availability, Access and Pr...
 
Rural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and Resilience
Rural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and ResilienceRural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and Resilience
Rural Social Protection: Economic Inclusion and Resilience
 
2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters
2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters
2020 Resilience Knowledge Fair E-Posters
 
Foodsecurityanalysis
FoodsecurityanalysisFoodsecurityanalysis
Foodsecurityanalysis
 
Building Resilience: Reflections from PSNP and the Role of Donors
Building Resilience: Reflections from PSNP and the Role of DonorsBuilding Resilience: Reflections from PSNP and the Role of Donors
Building Resilience: Reflections from PSNP and the Role of Donors
 
2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...
2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...
2020 ReSAKSS Annual Conference - Plenary Session IV–Policies for Inclusive De...
 
El Niño and Food Security
El Niño and Food SecurityEl Niño and Food Security
El Niño and Food Security
 
Ayalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual Conference
Ayalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual ConferenceAyalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual Conference
Ayalneh Bogale_2023 AGRODEP Annual Conference
 
2015 WWW report-Chapter 12
2015 WWW report-Chapter 122015 WWW report-Chapter 12
2015 WWW report-Chapter 12
 
Seminar major copy
Seminar major   copySeminar major   copy
Seminar major copy
 
Rao 6d monitoring global food security
Rao 6d   monitoring global food securityRao 6d   monitoring global food security
Rao 6d monitoring global food security
 

Multi-Sector Program Builds Community Resilience

  • 1. PROGRAM BRIEF Towards Community Resilience: An Integrated Multi-Sectoral Program Approach to Cyclic Drought-Induced Household Food Insecurity Targeting Productive Safety Net Program (PSNP) Beneficiaries in Wolayta, Ethiopia
  • 2. FINDINGS FINDINGS & LESSONS LEARNED 1 >> Beneficiary households receiving multi-year, multi-sector support improved more in select key welfare indicators than those receiving intermittent, single-sector support, in subsequent years of endured food insecurity shocks. >> It takes time (multiple years of monitoring the same target households) to be able to demonstrate resilience and often humanitarian donor funding cycles do not easily facilitate this as they tend to support short duration projects. >> Developing appropriate, e.g. social determinant indicators for monitoring and methodologies for measurement to demonstrate resilience, is critical vis-à-vis traditional/classical humanitarian emergency project indicator selection. >> There is need for cost-effective, efficient, and simplified measures for gauging the shock, well- being, and absorptive/adaptive/transformative capacities of intervention target groups. >> There is a need for intra-consortium rationalization of monitoring and evaluation (M&E) efforts where project implementation is undertaken by multiple implementing partner organizations. >> There is a need to rationalize M&E efforts, where donor funding lines often have non-resilience friendly, pre-scripted indicators, which can also be different from the Government of Ethiopia (GoE) indicator and productive safety net program (PSNP) indicators, the latter of which is serving as the basis for beneficiary client targeting. >> There is considerable value add in a consortium approach in the context of joint advocacy, reach/ coverage, and intra-consortium skills-building and capacity transfer. >> Sector integration contributes significantly to building resilience and addressing complex/multi- faceted problems. >> Good communication, collaboration, and joint planning with different governmental sector agencies is critical. >> Capacity strengthening of the government and community institutions is essential to successful program accomplishment. >> Behavior change models should be adapted to pre-existing community systems. >> Existence of community-based structures (Health Emergency Workers (HEW)) and Health Development Armies (HDAs)) at the grassroots level is vital for accessing the community at the household (HH) level for the transfer of capacity building in life-saving skills.
  • 3.
  • 4. BACKGROUND BACKGROUND 3 Despite significant economic gains over the last decade evidenced by GDP growth, poverty reduction gains, and increased access to basic health, sanitation, and education services, a considerable segment of the rural population of Ethiopia remains highly vulnerable to drought- induced transitory and chronic food insecurity1. About 10% of country’s population is chronically food insecure with this figure rising to more than 15% during drought years2. Reducing this vulnerability, stabilizing the net volatility in the number of households exposed to periodic drought induced shocks, and ultimately building their resilience is a significant, complex and perennial task requiring coordinated, integrated, effective, and innovative interventions. Over time, and in response, the Government of Ethiopia (GoE) has evolved and is continuing to develop, refine, and strengthen its strategies and operational frameworks for resilience actions. The Disaster Risk Management Strategic Program and Investment Framework (DRM-SPIF) and the Ethiopia Country Programming Paper to End Drought Emergencies in the Horn of Africa are two recent (2012) seminal guiding strategies developed to advance the operationalization of resilience. The Ethiopian disaster response system is complex, with support meant to cascade from federal to regional and sub-regional (woreda and kebele) levels based on scales, magnitude, and duration of impact. Currently, the system has largely evolved for supporting drought-related hazard events. Proportionately and historically, droughts have been the highest impact hazard observed and consequently these events have been accorded an elevated priority of focus as a result of the significant food insecurity (disaster risk) they generate. In the past, this risk resulted in substantial mortality and morbidity as evidenced in the ’73 and ‘83-85 famines. Climate change and increasing climate variability as can be manifested by protracted El Niño conditions, substantially exacerbates this risk, rendering a greater percentage of population vulnerable. At the ground-level, the frontline national disaster response key functions are discharged in part or whole by food security task force disaster prevention and preparedness committee representatives at both the woreda and kebele levels; development agents; health emergency workers; and agriculture sector focal points. Principally, the national system comprises (a) food security reserve; (b) early warning & early response committee; (c) incident command system; (d) hotspot classification and analysis facility; and (e) links to the productive safety net program (PSNP). This is informed by early warning forecast information provided by systems such as Family Early Warning Systems Network (FEWSNET), seasonal emergency needs assessments, and routine damage and loss/needs assessment- reporting (kebeles to woreda and regional bureau levels). The national disaster management system classifies hotspot zones, estimates agriculture production/yields, and identifies distressed households. Ultimately, scale-specific and resource-appropriate contingency responses are triggered. Initial front-line responses fall under the domain of woredas. When surpassed by scale of need/demand, regional bureaus then provide support, and for higher threshold responses, the federal level engages. Based on hotspot zone FIGURE 1: Frequency of Drought Hazard in Ethiopia 1974-2007 Source: Olthof, W.; Svedin, S. (2014): Resilience in Practice. Ethiopia Case Study. A presentation made by ECHO & DEVCO officers to the European Commission.
  • 5. BACKGROUND 4 trends and reported distress levels, households identified as eligible to be permanent or transitory “safety net” beneficiaries are identified. The current common/universal “disaster response” system trigger at household level for receiving productive safety net assistance (PSNP) in the form of food or cash transfer assistance is “nutrition status.” While the national disaster risk management (DRM) system (Figure 2) and its interface with the PSNP is well articulated, challenges remain in optimizing its functionality, efficacy, and efficiency at woreda, kebele and lower levels. International Medical Corps discussions (2015) with the Food Security Coordination Directorate of the Disaster Risk Management Food Security Sector (DRMFSS) confirm that interventions to build capacities at the woreda and kebele levels, as well as strengthening the systems and interface between regional bureaus and woreda levels remain necessary and highly desirable. As a strategic imperative, International Medical Corps programming in country seeks to support this decentralized capacity building, wherever possible. FIGURE 2: Summary of Ethiopia’s National Disaster Risk Management System FIGURE 3: Administrative Map of Wolayta Zone PSNP DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT Early Warning & Response Directorate • DRMEWR Case Team • Emergency Logistics Management Case Team • Emergency Finance & Procurment Case Team • Early Warning Response Info Management Case Workers • Aid Agency Coordination Case Workers Food Security Coordination Directorate • Resettlement Coordination Case Team • Safety Net & Household Asset Case Team Natural Resource Management Directorate • Public Works Coordination EARLY WARNING INFORMATION SYSTEMS • Reporting • Risk Models • Assessment • Verification MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT FOOD SECURITY SECTOR MINISTRY OF FINANCE & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT NATIONAL DISASTER PREVENTION & PREPAREDNESS PREVENTION, PREPAREDNESS, RESPONSE, MITIGATION/RISK REDUCTION, RECOVERY, REHABILITATION: • Finance & resource transfer requests • Safety net beneficiary identification • Food / cash distribution • Food reserves • HH Asset Transfer REACTIVE & PROACTIVE RESPONSE: • Emergency response to all Clients • Risk Financing • Core / transitory beneficiary screening • Accountability & Grievance • Mulit-agency comms & coordination • Monitoring & feedback • Food, nutrition, livelihood, NRM INPUTS • Livelihood Baselines • Seasonal Assessments • Fast onset loss & needs assessments • Agro-metdata • Agro-production estimates
  • 6. PROJECTCONTEXT WOLAYTA PROJECT CONTEXT 5 Wolayta zone (Figure 3) is situated approximately 300 kilometres south of Addis Ababa and is one of 13 zones in the Southern Nations and Nationalities Peoples Region (SNNPR). It encompasses an area of 4471.3 km2 and is home to a population of 1,750,569 persons of whom approximately 16% are children under five. Wolayta experiences a mixture of low, mid, and highland climatic conditions and is known to be part of the “green hunger zone” of Ethiopia. Similar to other areas of rural Ethiopia, the zone is characterized by recurrent droughts, high population density (386 p/km2), acute land shortages, land degradation, decreasing soil fertility, and inadequate resource management. Forty percent of the population lives below the poverty line and 45% suffer from food shortage4. The high population density results in very small landholdings (0.2- 0.5 hectares), which do not permit families to sustainably live off the land. It is calculated that at a minimum 1.5 hectares are needed per household. Typically, Wolayta has two harvest seasons: the Belg, which occurs between mid-March to mid-May, and the Meher, which occurs between July to September. Poverty and malnutrition are high with child malnutrition appearing to be as much related to issues of health (malaria) and hygiene (water) as with feeding practices and food availability5. The zone is further at-risk due to low institutional capacities for disaster risk management at woreda and kebele levels. Generally, levels of preparedness across the zone are insufficient to cope with repeated shocks. For decades, the zone has been targeted with emergency interventions in response to food insecurity and malnutrition. From 2011, two consecutive years of harvest failure and persistent drought have diminished food reserves and have led to a need for concerted nutrition programming to address chronic malnutrition. Delayed Belg rains, crop pests, livestock diseases, and malaria and meningitis outbreaks all struck the zone in 2012. These conditions resulted in significant increases in the number of people requiring relief assistance.
  • 7. PROJECTCONTEXT 6 In response, the GOE put in place a drought Early Warning System (EWS) and targeted more than 200,000 persons under a large-scale PSNP7. SNAPSHOT OF THE 2012 PROBLEMS OBSERVED IN WOLAYTA Key Sector Indicators Trends Nutrition April: Therapeutic feed program (TFP) admission increased by 200% For children between 6 to 59 months, moderate acute malnutrition (MAM) and severe acute malnutrition (SAM) based on middle upper arm circumference measurements (MUAC) and oedema was: 18.2 and 5.1% in Boloso Sore woreda 8.6 and 4.2% in Damot Pullasa woreda Health & WASH January- May 80,000 malaria cases detected in Boloso Sore and Damot Pullasa woredas Meningitis outbreaks Livelihoods 2,117 livestock affected by disease in Damot Pullasa 275 hectares of crop damage from hailstones in Boloso Sore woreda 255 hectares of crop damage from hailstones in Damot Pullasa woreda Yellow rust and sweet potato butterfly infestations destroying 112 hectares of crops in Boloso Sore and Damot Pullasa woredas
  • 8. PROGRAMMING With financial support (Euro 4.5M) from ECHO, between 2012 to 2014, a consortium of Concern Worldwide, International Medical Corps, and People in Need (PIN) implemented a 36-month integrated, multi-sectoral household resilience building program strategy targeting four emergency-prone woredas (districts) and an estimated 385,000 persons combined in two respective phases (130,000 in phase 1/255, 000 in phase 2). Under the program strategy interventions that sought to move target households from emergency relief through to longer term developmental assistance (LRRD – linking relief, rehabilitation, and development) were implemented. Identified target beneficiary households receive multi-year nutrition support; livelihood assistance (household asset transfer); primary health; water, sanitation, and hygiene (sanitation marketing); community preparedness; and disaster risk reduction (DRR) services and other capacity building interventions. International Medical Corps implemented its project interventions in Damot Pullasa and Boloso Sore, while Concern Worldwide and People in Need (PIN) implement in Dugna Fango and Kindo Koysha. PROGRAMMING 7 The conceptual evolution and pursuit of this integrated multi-level, multi-partner, multi-sector resilience- building program approach that focused on households and communities in emergency-prone woredas has been driven by a convergence of factors, including but not restricted to: >> GoE’s productive social safety net program (PSNP) specific remit to target vulnerable households >> Donor (ECHO) policy promoting an integrated, resilience-building, cluster-approaches >> Tripartite consensus between government, donors, and implementing partners regarding the demand for a step-wise need to address immediate, intermediate, and root causes of malnutrition >> International NGO consortium (Concern Worldwide, International Medical Corps, and PIN) preferred implementation modalities >> Past evaluation critiques which imply that previous emergency program responses have been less well coordinated, spatially dispersed, and sector-concentrated and failed to impart/achieve any significant residual capabilities for community resilience over the long-term to recurrent crises PROGRAM EVOLUTION & DESIGN
  • 10. OPERATIONALAPPROACH 9 OPERATIONAL APPROACH >> Providing multi-year support to PSNP targeted (“safety-net”) vulnerable households >> Executing multi-sector: primary health, nutrition, livelihood (household asset transfer), water, sanitation, and hygiene (sanitation marketing), and disaster risk reduction (DRR) interventions >> Facilitating continuous and routine intra-consortium coordination >> Promoting reflection, lessons learned reviews, and experience sharing among and between consortium institutional partners >> Consortium coordination with GoE >> Considering and including social behavioral change in intervention design and roll-out (Positive Deviance Hearth & Care groups) >> Encouraging and incentivizing community mobilization/engagement/ participation and neutralization of dependency Specifically,theprogrammingfocusedontheobjectiveofimprovingthenutritional status of vulnerable households in Wolayta zone and building resilience of the community to future shocks. This was implemented by:
  • 11. 10 International Medical Corps remains committed to the advancement, implementation, evaluation of integrated, multi-sector programming, including contextually relevant and appropriately adapted combinations of health; nutrition; mental health & psychosocial support (MPHSS); sexual reproductive health (SRH); gender based violence (GBV); water, sanitation & hygiene (WASH); disaster risk reduction; emergency response; and livelihood interventions, specifically targeted at building resilience of communities. RESULTS >> Community ownership created >> Transfer of assets achieved through cooperatives >> Improved saving and credit cultures >> Some beneficiaries started ensuring their HH food security >> Good relationships developed with local authorities >> Local institutional capacities have been enhanced through trainings and other support >> Potable water and sanitation coverage increased >> Vegetable gardening and food diversification practices increased >> Improvement in beneficiary, infant and young child feeding (IYCF) practices >> Severe acute malnutrition (SAM) and global acute malnutrition (GAM) rates significantly reduced >> Increased use of long acting and permanent methods (LAPM) of family planning (FP) and antenatal care (ANC) services >> Malaria and diarrheal disease burden reduced >> Immunization cold chain systems improved >> Early detection and control of epidemics enhanced In summary the main program results achieved were: OPERATIONALAPPROACH
  • 12. 1. Sewnet, Y. (2015) Causes and coping mechanisms of food insecurity in rural Ethiopia. Agric. Biol. J. N. Am., 2015, 6 (5): 123-133 2. Endalew, B.; Muche, M.; Tadesse, S. (2015) Assessment of food security situation in Ethiopia: a review. Asian J. Agric. Res.; 9(2): 55-68, 2015 3. European Union (2014) Terms of reference for situation analysis of the eight geographical clusters and development of strategy document under the EU resilience building program in Ethiopia (RESET) 4. Frankenberger, T. et. al. (2015) Ethiopia Pastoralist Areas and Resilience Improvement and Market Expansion. Project Impact Evaluation. Baseline Survey Report. Vol. I. 5. Olthof, W.; Svedin, S. (2014) Resilience in Practice. Ethiopia Case Study. A presentation made by ECHO & DEVCO officers to the European Commission. 6. Demisse, A.; Bawoke, T; Emebet, D. (2014) Case study on resilience building project. A presentation made to the Strategic Integration Meeting of International Medical Corps in Nairobi, Kenya. 7. Wolayta Zonal Agricultural Office (2013) www.InternationalMedicalCorps.org HEADQUARTERS INTERNATIONAL MEDICAL CORPS 12400 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 1500 Los Angeles, CA 90025 PHONE: 310-826-7800 FAX: 310-442-6622 CONTACT DETAILS: Dr. Tenaw Bawoke Program Coordinator TBawoke@InternationalMedicalCorps.org Yuri Chakalall Disaster Risk Reduction and Resilience Advisor YChakalall@InternationalMedicalCorps.org