Wisconsin
Elder Economic Security Initiative™
Supported by:
    The Retirement Research Foundation
    The Atlantic Philanthropies
    The Helen Bader Foundation

                                  Judy Karofsky
                                  Interim Administrator
                                  Wisconsin Women’s Network
                                  info@wiwomensnetwork.org
                                  608-255-9809
Wisconsin Women’s Network
Wider Opportunities for Women




        National and local
            programs
Wisconsin Elder Economic
    Security Initiative
Wisconsin Aging Statistics
                           13%




         87%




             Over 65   65 or younger


US as a whole: 12.4%, up from 7.9% in 1990
Wisconsin Annual Income
    Persons Over 65

                                  7%

35%

              65%
                         93%




 Below $35,000
 $35,000 or more    Below Federal Poverty Level
Federal Poverty Level


                            Food
                            33%




          "All other
          expenses"
            67%



                   1960’s
Federal Poverty Level = Food expenditures X 3
Federal Poverty Level

                                 Food
                                 14%

         Housing
          35%                      Transportation
                                        11%




                                  Miscellaneous
                                   Essentials
                                      16%

                   Health Care
                      24%

Food X 3
= only 42% of today’s needs
Federal
                          Poverty
                           Level
                           42%
   Today's
     Gap
    58%




               Today
Federal Poverty Level is meaningless
Wisconsin Elder Economic
     Security Index



          Not Federal
         Poverty Level’s
          deprivation


        Captures elders’
        actual expenses


   Used to benchmark against
    available income sources
Why do we need this Initiative?
Why do we need this Initiative?
What are the goals?
Change the public dialogue from “elder
  poverty” to “economic security”

         Elder
       Poverty          Economic
                       Security
WHAT are the goals?
Provide a framework decision guide for elders,
  their families, caregivers, aging boomers
  and service providers        Elders



                 Service
                                            Family
                Providers




                      Aging              Care
                     Boomers            Givers
What are the goals?

Influence the development and
  evaluation of public policies and
  programs
                   Public
                 Programs


       Public
       Policy
What are the goals?

                      Public
                      Policy



       Public
     Programs
How will the Initiative meet its
           goals?
              Coalition
              Building




   Research               Education




              Advocacy
Wisconsin Elder Economic
      Security Index
                 Housing




     Health
                                  Food
      Care




Transportation         Miscellaneous
                           Expenses
Wisconsin Elder
Economic Security
     Index
   Geographically
      specific
Wisconsin Elder Economic
     Security Index


       Marital     Housing
       Status




                 Health




       Useful Data
Wisconsin Statewide Average
    Single               Couple

                   Owners
Owners
                   without mortgage
without mortgage   $28,057
$18,154




                   Renters $29,145
Renters $19,242
Wisconsin Elder Economic
     Security Index
Dane County Average
    Single               Couple

                   Owners
Owners
                   without mortgage
without mortgage   $29,606
$19,829




                   Renters $30,553
Renters $20,777
Wisconsin Elder Economic
     Security Index

  Dane County
  $20,777
Elder Economic Security

         Social
        Security




              Investment
  Pension       Income
Social Security



                           Part-
                           time
                   Job 2

         At home


Job 1
Social Security



                           Part-
                           time
                   Job 2

         At home
Job 1
Pensions



                          Early retirement
                  Job 2   or annuitization


        At home


Job 1
Pensions



                          Early retirement
                  Job 2   or annuitization


        At home

Job 1
Savings/Investments


                Good
              Intentions




     Crises


                     Wall
                    Street
Elder Economic (In)Security
         20% in WI
           live on
            social
          security
   Less than
     ½ WI          No
    women       savings?
      will
    receive    No income
   pensions
Elder Economic Condition
                     Rely on
  Cut back on     families for
food, medicine,     financial
    utilities      assistance
Elder Economic Condition
                     Rely on
  Cut back on     families for
food, medicine,     financial
    utilities      assistance
Wisconsin Elder Economic
     Security Index

       Let’s start talking
       about the concept



                WiEESI is
                replacing FPL
Wisconsin Advisory Committee

                   Advocates




    Academics                   Planners




          Policy            Service
          makers           providers
Wisconsin Activities

                     Legislative
                      seminar

Financial
education
workshop                                Policy
                                   Recommendations




      Index report        Policy brief
Wisconsin Outreach
  and Education

               Providers




Consumers                      Families




      Policy
                           Funders
      makers
Wisconsin Outreach
  and Education

               Providers




Consumers                      Families




      Policy
                           Funders
      makers
Wisconsin Policy
                 Recommendations




Restore state-
  only SSI


                              Expand
                            support for
                              elderly
                          transportation
Wisconsin Outreach
Campaign for Elders
Problems with Benefit Programs




Income limits too    Asset limits too low
      low              (e.g., Medicaid,
   (e.g., SSI)               SSI)
Wisconsin Endorsements
AARP Wisconsin                             University of Wisconsin School of
                                              Nursing
AgeAdvantAge
                                           Wisconsin Alliance for Retired Americans
Alzheimer’s Association
                                           Wisconsin Association of Aging Unit
Black Women 50+ Health & Lifestyles
                                              Directors
    Magazine
                                           Wisconsin Association of Area Agencies
Care Wisconsin
                                              on Aging
Citizen Action of Wisconsin
                                           Wisconsin Association of Benefit
Coalition of Wisconsin Aging Groups           Specialists
Community Health Partnership               Wisconsin Board on Aging and
Dane County Area Agency on Aging              Long Term Care
Disability Rights Wisconsin                Wisconsin Council on Children and
Milwaukee County Department on Aging          Families
National Association of Social Workers –   Wisconsin Council of Churches
    Wisconsin Chapter                      Wisconsin Personal Services Association
 Older Women’s League – Milwaukee          Wisconsin Retired Educators Association
SAGE/Milwaukee                             YWCA – Madison
Next Steps in Wisconsin

                More
            endorsements



Continued                  Pursue policy
outreach                      agenda




      Research      Refine policy
      analysis       initiatives
WHAT CAN YOU DO?

           • To the media about the Elder Index
 Talk or
  write


           • To expand programs based on the Elder
             Index
Advocate



           • Other groups that can learn about the Elder
             Index
Identify
WHO should be involved?
AARP
Area Agencies on Aging (AAAs)
Elder, women’s and low-Income advocates
Senior membership organizations
State Older Women’s Leagues (OWL)
For-profit and nonprofit service providers
Academics and research organizations
Public entities
Philanthropists
Policymakers
State administrators
Budget and tax groups
Caregivers
Elders and their families
Other States are Involved

   Massachusetts             Pennsylvania


  Illinois
                   Connecticut



New Jersey                       New Mexico
Why support the Initiative?
                     Share
                    valuable
                    info and
                      data



                                    All persons,
    Seniors
                                    young and
   deserve to
                                    old, should
     age in
                        Wisconsin    be able to
   place with
                          Elder     meet basic
     dignity
                        Economic        needs
                         Security
                          Index
                 Become
                 part of a
                 national
                movement
We hope you will join our mission to
ensure Wisconsin elders can
age in place with dignity!

WIEESI 2009

  • 1.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic SecurityInitiative™ Supported by: The Retirement Research Foundation The Atlantic Philanthropies The Helen Bader Foundation Judy Karofsky Interim Administrator Wisconsin Women’s Network info@wiwomensnetwork.org 608-255-9809
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Wider Opportunities forWomen National and local programs
  • 4.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Initiative
  • 5.
    Wisconsin Aging Statistics 13% 87% Over 65 65 or younger US as a whole: 12.4%, up from 7.9% in 1990
  • 6.
    Wisconsin Annual Income Persons Over 65 7% 35% 65% 93% Below $35,000 $35,000 or more Below Federal Poverty Level
  • 7.
    Federal Poverty Level Food 33% "All other expenses" 67% 1960’s Federal Poverty Level = Food expenditures X 3
  • 8.
    Federal Poverty Level Food 14% Housing 35% Transportation 11% Miscellaneous Essentials 16% Health Care 24% Food X 3 = only 42% of today’s needs
  • 9.
    Federal Poverty Level 42% Today's Gap 58% Today Federal Poverty Level is meaningless
  • 10.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Index Not Federal Poverty Level’s deprivation Captures elders’ actual expenses Used to benchmark against available income sources
  • 11.
    Why do weneed this Initiative?
  • 12.
    Why do weneed this Initiative?
  • 13.
    What are thegoals? Change the public dialogue from “elder poverty” to “economic security” Elder Poverty Economic Security
  • 14.
    WHAT are thegoals? Provide a framework decision guide for elders, their families, caregivers, aging boomers and service providers Elders Service Family Providers Aging Care Boomers Givers
  • 15.
    What are thegoals? Influence the development and evaluation of public policies and programs Public Programs Public Policy
  • 16.
    What are thegoals? Public Policy Public Programs
  • 17.
    How will theInitiative meet its goals? Coalition Building Research Education Advocacy
  • 18.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Index Housing Health Food Care Transportation Miscellaneous Expenses
  • 19.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Index Geographically specific
  • 20.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Index Marital Housing Status Health Useful Data
  • 21.
    Wisconsin Statewide Average Single Couple Owners Owners without mortgage without mortgage $28,057 $18,154 Renters $29,145 Renters $19,242
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Dane County Average Single Couple Owners Owners without mortgage without mortgage $29,606 $19,829 Renters $30,553 Renters $20,777
  • 24.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Index Dane County $20,777
  • 25.
    Elder Economic Security Social Security Investment Pension Income
  • 26.
    Social Security Part- time Job 2 At home Job 1
  • 27.
    Social Security Part- time Job 2 At home Job 1
  • 28.
    Pensions Early retirement Job 2 or annuitization At home Job 1
  • 29.
    Pensions Early retirement Job 2 or annuitization At home Job 1
  • 30.
    Savings/Investments Good Intentions Crises Wall Street
  • 31.
    Elder Economic (In)Security 20% in WI live on social security Less than ½ WI No women savings? will receive No income pensions
  • 32.
    Elder Economic Condition Rely on Cut back on families for food, medicine, financial utilities assistance
  • 33.
    Elder Economic Condition Rely on Cut back on families for food, medicine, financial utilities assistance
  • 34.
    Wisconsin Elder Economic Security Index Let’s start talking about the concept WiEESI is replacing FPL
  • 35.
    Wisconsin Advisory Committee Advocates Academics Planners Policy Service makers providers
  • 36.
    Wisconsin Activities Legislative seminar Financial education workshop Policy Recommendations Index report Policy brief
  • 37.
    Wisconsin Outreach and Education Providers Consumers Families Policy Funders makers
  • 38.
    Wisconsin Outreach and Education Providers Consumers Families Policy Funders makers
  • 39.
    Wisconsin Policy Recommendations Restore state- only SSI Expand support for elderly transportation
  • 40.
  • 41.
    Problems with BenefitPrograms Income limits too Asset limits too low low (e.g., Medicaid, (e.g., SSI) SSI)
  • 42.
    Wisconsin Endorsements AARP Wisconsin University of Wisconsin School of Nursing AgeAdvantAge Wisconsin Alliance for Retired Americans Alzheimer’s Association Wisconsin Association of Aging Unit Black Women 50+ Health & Lifestyles Directors Magazine Wisconsin Association of Area Agencies Care Wisconsin on Aging Citizen Action of Wisconsin Wisconsin Association of Benefit Coalition of Wisconsin Aging Groups Specialists Community Health Partnership Wisconsin Board on Aging and Dane County Area Agency on Aging Long Term Care Disability Rights Wisconsin Wisconsin Council on Children and Milwaukee County Department on Aging Families National Association of Social Workers – Wisconsin Council of Churches Wisconsin Chapter Wisconsin Personal Services Association Older Women’s League – Milwaukee Wisconsin Retired Educators Association SAGE/Milwaukee YWCA – Madison
  • 43.
    Next Steps inWisconsin More endorsements Continued Pursue policy outreach agenda Research Refine policy analysis initiatives
  • 44.
    WHAT CAN YOUDO? • To the media about the Elder Index Talk or write • To expand programs based on the Elder Index Advocate • Other groups that can learn about the Elder Index Identify
  • 45.
    WHO should beinvolved? AARP Area Agencies on Aging (AAAs) Elder, women’s and low-Income advocates Senior membership organizations State Older Women’s Leagues (OWL) For-profit and nonprofit service providers Academics and research organizations Public entities Philanthropists Policymakers State administrators Budget and tax groups Caregivers Elders and their families
  • 46.
    Other States areInvolved Massachusetts Pennsylvania Illinois Connecticut New Jersey New Mexico
  • 47.
    Why support theInitiative? Share valuable info and data All persons, Seniors young and deserve to old, should age in Wisconsin be able to place with Elder meet basic dignity Economic needs Security Index Become part of a national movement
  • 48.
    We hope youwill join our mission to ensure Wisconsin elders can age in place with dignity!