SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Pacific Oyster Physiological Response to
 Disease under Variable Environmental
                               Regimes

Emma Timmins-Schiffman, Elene Dorfmeier, Paul McElhany, Shallin Busch,
                                  Steven Roberts & Carolyn Friedman
                                             University of Washington


                                                        PCSGA 2010
Objective
    How do environmental stressors, such as ocean
     acidification (OA) and elevated temperature, affect
     oyster larvae survival and physiology when
     challenged by disease?
Experimental Plan
  How do environmental changes affect the host-pathogen relationship?


                                                        High
            OA
                                                       Temp.

                                Host




                              Pathogen




                                              Vibrio photo: Waldor & RayChaudhuri, 2000, Nature
Outline
    Ocean acidification
    Environmental stress and physiology
    Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii
     relationship
    OA effects on C. gigas
    Current work: OA & V. tubiashii
                                                 Hi
                                         OA
                                                 T
Outline
    Ocean acidification
    Environmental stress and physiology
    Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii
     relationship
    OA effects on C. gigas
    Current work: OA & V. tubiashii
                                                 Hi
                                         OA
                                                 T
Ocean Acidification
                                                     1000 ppm




     Increased CO2 in atmosphere


                                           380 ppm




Increased oceanic CO2 = lower oceanic pH
Environmental Stress
         Growth           Reproduction

                                    Normal Environment



Immune response           General metabolism




 Environmental Stress          Growth            Reproduction




                       Immune response             General metabolism
                  pH
Outline
    Ocean acidification
    Environmental stress and physiology
    Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii
     relationship
    OA effects on C. gigas
    Current work: OA & V. tubiashii
                                                 Hi
                                         OA
                                                 T
Temperature & V. tubiashii
    Two temperatures: 12oC & 25oC
    V. tubiashii challenge in both temperatures
    3 day trial
    Immune response genes:
         C-jun kinase
         NfkB




                                 Up-regulate immune defenses:
                                 -ROS
                                 -inflammatory response
Temperature & V. tubiashii
                                     = 12oC
                                     = 25oC
                                 *
                                     =12oC + Vt
                        *            =25oC + Vt




           1        2        3
Temperature & V. tubiashii

                       Assay Development




                 n=4
                                                    n=4




  n=3    n=4              n=2
                                      n=3    n=2           n=2


  12oC    25oC   12oC     25oC        12oC   25oC   12oC   25oC
Outline
    Ocean acidification
    Environmental stress and physiology
    Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii
     relationship
    OA effects on C. gigas
    Current work: OA & V. tubiashii
                                                 Hi
                                         OA
                                                 T
Effects of OA on Development
    Strip-spawned and pooled sperm and eggs
    Fertilized eggs in pCO2-equilibrated water
         380 ppm
         840 ppm
    Time to developmental stage at
         1 hour (2-cell)
         2 hours (>4-cell)
         5 hours (hatched)
         17 hours
         24 hours
Effects of OA on Development
                     Timeline of C. gigas Larval Development
Fertilization   2-cell
0h
                                                      Developmental Stage
                            4-cell
     1h

                                        hatching
                     2h

                                5h
Time Post-Fertilization
                                                                   veliger
                                              17h


                                                       24h
Effects of OA on Development
=380 ppm
=840 ppm
           Proportion Eggs in Cleavage




                                         *
Effects of OA on Development
=380 ppm
=840 ppm
       Proportion Larvae Hatched




                                   *
Effects of OA on Development
    A smaller proportion of larvae in elevated pCO2
     develop at the “normal” rate
    Implications for physiological anomalies and
     calcification




                                                   SEM Photo: Carla Stehr
Effects of OA on Development
    General stress response genes
         Cytochrome P450 oxidase (CytP450)
         Peroxiredoxin 6 (Prx6)
         Heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70)




                                                             1.0
                                                             0.8
                                        Proportion Hatched
                                                             0.6
                                                             0.4
                                                             0.2
                                                             0.0




                                                                   5   5          17    17          24   24
                                                                       Time Post Fertilization (Hours)
Outline
    Ocean acidification
    Environmental stress and physiology
    Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii
     relationship
    OA effects on C. gigas
    Current work: OA & V. tubiashii
                                                 Hi
                                         OA
                                                 T
OA & V. tubiashii
    Study in progress in collaboration with NWFSC (P.
     McElhany et al.)
    Planned 3 weeks: spawning through settlement
    4 pCO2 treatments
         280, 380, 750, 2000 ppm
    24-hour V. tubiashii exposure
    Data collection:
         Mortality
         Physiology (gene expression)
         Morphology & calcification
         Genotype-linked survival
= calcified
OA & V. tubiashii                                   = partially
                                                    calcified
    Calcification at 48 hours post-fertilization   = uncalcified
Conclusions
    Ocean acidification has significant effects on C.
     gigas larval development.
    OA may inhibit and depress larval response to other
     environmental stressors, including disease.
    Elevated temperatures, such as 25oC, have effects
     on the host-pathogen interaction.
Acknowledgements
    Funding: Saltonstall-Kennedy Grant (NOAA),
     NOAA Aquaculture Program student support
    University of Washington
         Moose O’Donnell
         Sam White
    Taylor Shellfish
          Joth Davis
          Ed Jones
          Vicki Jones
    NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center
         Jason Miller
         Mike Maher
         Sarah Norberg

More Related Content

Similar to Timmins schiffmanpcsga 2010

Antarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace Saba
Antarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace SabaAntarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace Saba
Antarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace Saba
coseenow
 
Metzger MS defense
Metzger MS defenseMetzger MS defense
Metzger MS defensedmetzger1
 
FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)
FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)
FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)sr320
 
GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...
GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...
GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...
Zobayer Rahman
 
Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)
Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)
Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)
Prachee Rajput
 
Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...
Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...
Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...
John Blue
 
Esa09 Burks Post Version
Esa09 Burks Post VersionEsa09 Burks Post Version
Esa09 Burks Post Version
burksr
 
Penta aquaticf ate and effects
Penta aquaticf ate and effectsPenta aquaticf ate and effects
Penta aquaticf ate and effects
bann11f
 
Barshop Talk
Barshop TalkBarshop Talk
Barshop Talk
Sky Lar
 
Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...
Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...
Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...
National Pork Board
 
Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980
Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980
Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980
KevinCrofton
 
Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...
Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...
Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...
Mushafau Adebayo Oke
 
Wilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paper
Wilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paperWilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paper
Wilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paperTanya Kapes
 
Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...
Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...
Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...
Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries, Republic of Indonesia
 
Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)
Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)
Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)Jermaine Dorsey
 

Similar to Timmins schiffmanpcsga 2010 (20)

MEEC poster final
MEEC poster finalMEEC poster final
MEEC poster final
 
Poster2
Poster2Poster2
Poster2
 
Antarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace Saba
Antarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace SabaAntarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace Saba
Antarctica, Climate Change, and Krill: Dr. Grace Saba
 
Metzger MS defense
Metzger MS defenseMetzger MS defense
Metzger MS defense
 
FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)
FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)
FISH441 Group Project (Oysters)
 
Bill Dewey presentation on ocean acidification
Bill Dewey presentation on ocean acidificationBill Dewey presentation on ocean acidification
Bill Dewey presentation on ocean acidification
 
GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...
GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...
GONADAL HISTOPATHOLOGY IN ADULT OLIVE BARB Puntius sarana EXPOSED TO ENDOCRIN...
 
Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)
Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)
Responses to temperature stress (heat and cold)
 
Laporan kemajuan tugas belajar kelautan dan perikanan
Laporan kemajuan tugas belajar kelautan dan perikananLaporan kemajuan tugas belajar kelautan dan perikanan
Laporan kemajuan tugas belajar kelautan dan perikanan
 
Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...
Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...
Dr. Jason Ross - Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop...
 
Esa09 Burks Post Version
Esa09 Burks Post VersionEsa09 Burks Post Version
Esa09 Burks Post Version
 
Copepod reproduction poster
Copepod reproduction posterCopepod reproduction poster
Copepod reproduction poster
 
Penta aquaticf ate and effects
Penta aquaticf ate and effectsPenta aquaticf ate and effects
Penta aquaticf ate and effects
 
Barshop Talk
Barshop TalkBarshop Talk
Barshop Talk
 
Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...
Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...
Understanding the Biology of Seasonal Infertility to Develop Mitigation Strat...
 
Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980
Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980
Crofton MS Thesis Lead Dvelopmental Neurotoxicity 1980
 
Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...
Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...
Effect of centrifugal pretreatment, p h and water activity on the production ...
 
Wilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paper
Wilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paperWilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paper
Wilde Zhou et al. Zika Inactivation paper
 
Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...
Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...
Aquaherb conditioners the silver bullet for asian seabass and silver pompnao ...
 
Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)
Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)
Vp ABRCMS Poster 2012 (2)
 

Timmins schiffmanpcsga 2010

  • 1. Pacific Oyster Physiological Response to Disease under Variable Environmental Regimes Emma Timmins-Schiffman, Elene Dorfmeier, Paul McElhany, Shallin Busch, Steven Roberts & Carolyn Friedman University of Washington PCSGA 2010
  • 2. Objective   How do environmental stressors, such as ocean acidification (OA) and elevated temperature, affect oyster larvae survival and physiology when challenged by disease?
  • 3. Experimental Plan How do environmental changes affect the host-pathogen relationship? High OA Temp. Host Pathogen Vibrio photo: Waldor & RayChaudhuri, 2000, Nature
  • 4. Outline   Ocean acidification   Environmental stress and physiology   Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii relationship   OA effects on C. gigas   Current work: OA & V. tubiashii Hi OA T
  • 5. Outline   Ocean acidification   Environmental stress and physiology   Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii relationship   OA effects on C. gigas   Current work: OA & V. tubiashii Hi OA T
  • 6. Ocean Acidification 1000 ppm Increased CO2 in atmosphere 380 ppm Increased oceanic CO2 = lower oceanic pH
  • 7. Environmental Stress Growth Reproduction Normal Environment Immune response General metabolism Environmental Stress Growth Reproduction Immune response General metabolism pH
  • 8. Outline   Ocean acidification   Environmental stress and physiology   Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii relationship   OA effects on C. gigas   Current work: OA & V. tubiashii Hi OA T
  • 9. Temperature & V. tubiashii   Two temperatures: 12oC & 25oC   V. tubiashii challenge in both temperatures   3 day trial   Immune response genes:   C-jun kinase   NfkB Up-regulate immune defenses: -ROS -inflammatory response
  • 10. Temperature & V. tubiashii = 12oC = 25oC * =12oC + Vt * =25oC + Vt 1 2 3
  • 11. Temperature & V. tubiashii Assay Development n=4 n=4 n=3 n=4 n=2 n=3 n=2 n=2 12oC 25oC 12oC 25oC 12oC 25oC 12oC 25oC
  • 12. Outline   Ocean acidification   Environmental stress and physiology   Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii relationship   OA effects on C. gigas   Current work: OA & V. tubiashii Hi OA T
  • 13. Effects of OA on Development   Strip-spawned and pooled sperm and eggs   Fertilized eggs in pCO2-equilibrated water   380 ppm   840 ppm   Time to developmental stage at   1 hour (2-cell)   2 hours (>4-cell)   5 hours (hatched)   17 hours   24 hours
  • 14. Effects of OA on Development Timeline of C. gigas Larval Development Fertilization 2-cell 0h Developmental Stage 4-cell 1h hatching 2h 5h Time Post-Fertilization veliger 17h 24h
  • 15. Effects of OA on Development =380 ppm =840 ppm Proportion Eggs in Cleavage *
  • 16. Effects of OA on Development =380 ppm =840 ppm Proportion Larvae Hatched *
  • 17. Effects of OA on Development   A smaller proportion of larvae in elevated pCO2 develop at the “normal” rate   Implications for physiological anomalies and calcification SEM Photo: Carla Stehr
  • 18. Effects of OA on Development   General stress response genes   Cytochrome P450 oxidase (CytP450)   Peroxiredoxin 6 (Prx6)   Heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70) 1.0 0.8 Proportion Hatched 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 5 5 17 17 24 24 Time Post Fertilization (Hours)
  • 19. Outline   Ocean acidification   Environmental stress and physiology   Temperature and the C. gigas-V. tubiashii relationship   OA effects on C. gigas   Current work: OA & V. tubiashii Hi OA T
  • 20. OA & V. tubiashii   Study in progress in collaboration with NWFSC (P. McElhany et al.)   Planned 3 weeks: spawning through settlement   4 pCO2 treatments   280, 380, 750, 2000 ppm   24-hour V. tubiashii exposure   Data collection:   Mortality   Physiology (gene expression)   Morphology & calcification   Genotype-linked survival
  • 21. = calcified OA & V. tubiashii = partially calcified   Calcification at 48 hours post-fertilization = uncalcified
  • 22. Conclusions   Ocean acidification has significant effects on C. gigas larval development.   OA may inhibit and depress larval response to other environmental stressors, including disease.   Elevated temperatures, such as 25oC, have effects on the host-pathogen interaction.
  • 23. Acknowledgements   Funding: Saltonstall-Kennedy Grant (NOAA), NOAA Aquaculture Program student support   University of Washington   Moose O’Donnell   Sam White   Taylor Shellfish Joth Davis Ed Jones Vicki Jones   NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center   Jason Miller   Mike Maher   Sarah Norberg