SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Download to read offline
SYSTEMATIC STOCK
PICKING STRATEGY
Summary
• Fully systematic strategy based on scoring algorithm to
assemble stocks for long and short portfolios
• Short only-part of the portfolio substantially reduces
drawdowns during turbulent times.
• Regime switching indicator to switch on and off short
component.
• Two independently profitable substrategies, to get the
final more robust portfolio.
• Simulated performance from 1996 of
• CAGR: 30%
• Sharpe: 1.71
Alpha Generation
• Long-only part of the portfolio generates 22% vs SPX
generates 7.59%
• Short only part of the portfolio generates 8.6% vs
benchmark of 1.13%
• Combining long and short reduces drawdowns and
achieves the total performance of 30% with Sharpe 1.71
Alpha Generation
Portfolio Components CAGR,
%
Bench Excess
Return
Sharpe MaxDD,
%
Long Only Part 21.94 7.59 14.35 1.11 45.41
Short Only with RS 8.6 1.13 7.47 0.59 32.46
Short Only Part
without RS(zero costs)
-2 -7.59 5.59 -0.1 62
Final Portfolio 30.55 7.59 22.96 1.71 24.9
Strategy Performance vs. S&P 500 Index
Strategy / SPX Index yearly performance
Ann. Return: 30.55% Sharpe: 1.71
range TR CAGR Sharpe MDD A.Trnv T.trnv
Y1 1996/08; 1996/12 4.2% / 14.23% 10% / 32.31% 1.43 / 2.71 2.47% / 3.75% 156.28% / 0% 65.94% / 0%
Y2 1997/01; 1997/12 54% / 23.74% 44.17% / 22.56% 3.7 / 1.46 3.97% / 8.76% 263.22% / 0% 262.5% / 0%
Y3 1998/01; 1999/01 28.19% / 31.26% 26.46% / 28.54% 1.31 / 1.53 19.86% / 17.94% 235.4% / 0% 239.27% / 0%
Y4 1999/01; 1999/12 47.8% / 19.81% 39.79% / 19.48% 2.52 / 1.06 8.64% / 12.08% 247.06% / 0% 251.13% / 0%
Y5 2000/01; 2000/12 53.24% / -10.14% 45.23% / -8.15% 2.1 / -0.36 10.12% / 14.5% 283.94% / 0% 283.16% / 0%
Y6 2001/01; 2001/12 86.34% / -12.06% 64.59% / -10.35% 3.36 / -0.46 11.28% / 28.72% 283.78% / 0% 283% / 0%
Y7 2002/01; 2002/12 69.01% / -24.6% 54.53% / -26.26% 2.95 / -1.31 10.76% / 31.72% 254.05% / 0% 253.36% / 0%
Y8 2003/01; 2003/12 45.63% / 25.19% 38.98% / 23.71% 2.54 / 1.55 8.7% / 10.64% 307.44% / 0% 306.6% / 0%
Y9 2004/01; 2004/12 39.67% / 10.59% 33.59% / 10.46% 2.97 / 0.99 3.75% / 8.03% 308.08% / 0% 313.14% / 0%
Y10 2005/01; 2005/12 22.76% / 3% 21.27% / 3.43% 1.81 / 0.35 8.65% / 6.51% 236.99% / 0% 236.34% / 0%
Y11 2006/01; 2006/12 12.8% / 13.62% 13.14% / 13.29% 0.9 / 1.35 9.52% / 6.76% 225.75% / 0% 225.13% / 0%
Y12 2007/01; 2007/12 -4.36% / 4.24% -3.49% / 5.09% -0.25 / 0.37 17.96% / 7.75% 293.05% / 0% 292.25% / 0%
Y13 2008/01; 2008/12 31.78% / -40.97% 32.09% / -46.96% 1.08 / -1.41 21.39% / 43.87% 271.3% / 0% 270.55% / 0%
Y14 2009/01; 2010/01 47.9% / 27.76% 42.83% / 27.45% 1.46 / 1.06 21.57% / 26.66% 147.61% / 0% 150.04% / 0%
Y15 2010/01; 2010/12 19.49% / 11.64% 18.72% / 12.31% 1.21 / 0.71 8.39% / 15.99% 200.01% / 0% 203.3% / 0%
Y16 2011/01; 2011/12 30.22% / 0% 28.45% / 2.3% 1.46 / 0.11 17.46% / 17.61% 199.62% / 0% 199.07% / 0%
Y17 2012/01; 2012/12 0.01% / 11.52% 0.78% / 11.63% 0.06 / 0.98 12.27% / 9.26% 163.48% / 0% 163.03% / 0%
Y18 2013/01; 2013/12 34% / 31.3% 30.04% / 27.87% 2.68 / 2.78 5.71% / 4.5% 136.67% / 0% 136.3% / 0%
All 1996/08; 2013/12 15277% / 177.95% 30.55% / 7.59% 1.71 / 0.41 24.9% / 56.24% 236.89% / 0% 4129.61% / 0%
First 1996/08; 2006/12 3809.67% / 114.09% 36.53% / 8.73% 2.27 / 0.52 20.24% / 47.59% 260.43% / 0% 2717.06% / 0%
Second 2007/01; 2013/12 293.31% / 29.83% 21.62% / 5.91% 1.07 / 0.28 24.9% / 56.24% 201.79% / 0% 1412.55% / 0%
Regime Switching
Sentiment Indicator is good at detecting market regimes:
Long/Short Annual return 10.55% vs. 7.59% Buy and Hold S&P Index
Sentiment indicator summary
• Using Sentiment Indicator to Open/Close short only portfolio
depending on the market sentiment
• Calculating the composite index from:
• VIX Index, Put-Call ratio, NYSE Margin Debt, NYSE Volume , AAII
sentiment, Dividend Premium, Closed-end funds premium, first-year
IPO return.
• Controlling for the economic cycle by regressing the index to
macro data:
• Industrial production; Consumer consumption – non-durables,
durables, services; Payments; Utility rate.
• Use the residuals from the regressions to determine sentiment
phase of market as:
• “BEAR”
• “BULL”
This indicator allows to increase the annual performance of the
short only portfolio from -5% to 8%
Testing the strategy on historical data
• Analyzing about 3000 companies at any point in time
• Using the historical data from S&P Capital IQ (Compustat DB)
• No survivorship bias
• Point-in-time data: fundamental and macro data as they were seen on
any particular date
• Quarterly financial data from 1990
• Standardized data
• Weekly rebalancing
• Equal weighted portfolio with max. weight 7% per position
• Conservative commission of 0.2%
• Borrowing costs: 5%
• Sentiment Indicator for Regime Switching
• Using official data from FRED
• Trailing 5-years window
Strategy Details: Score Calculations
• Create composite value score as sum of four individual scores
• derived from fundamentals: profitability, growth, safety, payout,
• using about 40 corporate fundamentals from standardized reports
• filter out the companies with capitalization less then median.
• Long Only Portfolio
• Pick up companies with the highest overall composite score and
lowest P/B
• Short-Only Portfolio
• Pick up companies with the lowest individual scores and highest P/B
for short-side portfolio
• Move to cash depending on the current market regime
For each company in the asset universe we derive a score which
defines its position relative to the others.
ADDITIONAL STATISTICS
Drawdowns
Market Cap Distributions:
largest 100 mcap steps 14%
20%
34%
24%
8%
Long
26%
32%
25%
14%
3%
Short
17%
24%
31%
21%
7%
Total Portfolio
1-5
6-10
11-15
16-20
21-25
Current possible lowest cap at 1.6 bln
Long Portfolio vs. S&P 500 Index
Statistics: Long Portfolio / SPX Index
Ann. Return: 21.94 Sharpe: 1.11
range TR CAGR Sharpe MDD A.Trnv T.trnv
Y1 1996/08; 1996/12 2.95% / 14.23% 7.06% / 32.31% 1.18 / 2.71 1.68% / 3.75% 108.17% / 0% 45.64% / 0%
Y2 1997/01; 1997/12 41.34% / 23.74% 35.28% / 22.56% 3.6 / 1.46 5.98% / 8.76% 141.79% / 0% 141.4% / 0%
Y3 1998/01; 1999/01 13.79% / 31.26% 14.94% / 28.54% 0.7 / 1.53 27.79% / 17.94% 189.95% / 0% 193.07% / 0%
Y4 1999/01; 1999/12 18.15% / 19.81% 17.56% / 19.48% 1.15 / 1.06 11.74% / 12.08% 174.11% / 0% 176.97% / 0%
Y5 2000/01; 2000/12 22.25% / -10.14% 21.36% / -8.15% 1.37 / -0.36 6.86% / 14.5% 164.34% / 0% 163.89% / 0%
Y6 2001/01; 2001/12 60.17% / -12.06% 50.29% / -10.35% 2.14 / -0.46 18.9% / 28.72% 129.12% / 0% 128.77% / 0%
Y7 2002/01; 2002/12 12.85% / -24.6% 13.78% / -26.26% 0.75 / -1.31 17.38% / 31.72% 173.9% / 0% 173.42% / 0%
Y8 2003/01; 2003/12 56.04% / 25.19% 45.89% / 23.71% 3.08 / 1.55 6.56% / 10.64% 186.21% / 0% 185.7% / 0%
Y9 2004/01; 2004/12 40.11% / 10.59% 34.42% / 10.46% 2.27 / 0.99 8.64% / 8.03% 152.24% / 0% 154.74% / 0%
Y10 2005/01; 2005/12 21.27% / 3% 20.11% / 3.43% 1.65 / 0.35 5.77% / 6.51% 126.08% / 0% 125.74% / 0%
Y11 2006/01; 2006/12 17.88% / 13.62% 17.27% / 13.29% 1.4 / 1.35 9.52% / 6.76% 172.54% / 0% 172.06% / 0%
Y12 2007/01; 2007/12 3.44% / 4.24% 4.75% / 5.09% 0.29 / 0.37 12.41% / 7.75% 172.12% / 0% 171.65% / 0%
Y13 2008/01; 2008/12 -14.86% / -40.97% -6.78% / -46.96% -0.16 / -1.41 45.41% / 43.87% 190.58% / 0% 190.05% / 0%
Y14 2009/01; 2010/01 51.1% / 27.76% 45.01% / 27.45% 1.53 / 1.06 21.57% / 26.66% 144.86% / 0% 147.24% / 0%
Y15 2010/01; 2010/12 23.56% / 11.64% 22.74% / 12.31% 1.16 / 0.71 17.63% / 15.99% 124.75% / 0% 126.8% / 0%
Y16 2011/01; 2011/12 11.35% / 0% 12.95% / 2.3% 0.62 / 0.11 17.46% / 17.61% 130.83% / 0% 130.47% / 0%
Y17 2012/01; 2012/12 2.08% / 11.52% 2.94% / 11.63% 0.22 / 0.98 14.43% / 9.26% 126.98% / 0% 126.63% / 0%
Y18 2013/01; 2013/12 34% / 31.3% 30.04% / 27.87% 2.68 / 2.78 5.71% / 4.5% 136.67% / 0% 136.3% / 0%
All 1996/08; 2013/12 3138.79% / 177.95% 21.94% / 7.59% 1.11 / 0.41 45.41% / 56.24% 154.08% / 0% 2686.05% / 0%
First 1996/08; 2006/12 1178.17% / 114.09% 25.76% / 8.73% 1.62 / 0.52 27.79% / 47.59% 159.01% / 0% 1658.9% / 0%
Second 2007/01; 2013/12 153.39% / 29.83% 16.26% / 5.91% 0.67 / 0.28 45.41% / 56.24% 146.73% / 0% 1027.14% / 0%
Short Portfolio vs. Short S&P 500 Index
Statistics: Short Strategy / Short SPX Index
Ann. Return: 8.6% Sharpe: 0.59
range TR CAGR Sharpe MDD A.Trnv T.trnv
Y1 1996/08; 1996/12 1.22% / -10.94% 2.94% / -27.23% 0.76 / -2.74 2.01% / 14.47% 48.11% / 0% 20.3% / 0%
Y2 1997/01; 1997/12 8.31% / -15.96% 8.89% / -16.66% 0.67 / -1.37 13.24% / 21.71% 121.43% / 0% 121.1% / 0%
Y3 1998/01; 1999/01 12.13% / 10.9% 11.53% / 10.73% 1.58 / 1.23 0.84% / 3.24% 45.45% / 0% 46.2% / 0%
Y4 1999/01; 1999/12 24.66% / 2.04% 22.23% / 2.34% 2.19 / 0.3 2.62% / 9.95% 72.96% / 0% 74.15% / 0%
Y5 2000/01; 2000/12 23.98% / 11.53% 23.87% / 11.56% 1.1 / 1.08 9.93% / 5.29% 119.6% / 0% 119.27% / 0%
Y6 2001/01; 2001/12 11.93% / 10.94% 14.3% / 12.27% 0.58 / 0.63 24.59% / 16.62% 154.65% / 0% 154.23% / 0%
Y7 2002/01; 2002/12 47.58% / 18.58% 40.75% / 18.99% 2.25 / 0.97 8.1% / 14.44% 80.16% / 0% 79.94% / 0%
Y8 2003/01; 2003/12 -6.89% / -0.57% -6.91% / -0.43% -1 / -0.08 8.31% / 3.56% 121.23% / 0% 120.9% / 0%
Y9 2004/01; 2004/12 -2.36% / -8.26% -0.83% / -8.2% -0.05 / -0.9 20.1% / 12.74% 155.84% / 0% 158.4% / 0%
Y10 2005/01; 2005/12 0.73% / -4.57% 1.17% / -4.33% 0.12 / -0.49 11.67% / 11.83% 110.9% / 0% 110.6% / 0%
Y11 2006/01; 2006/12 -4.34% / -4.21% -4.12% / -4.27% -0.5 / -1.08 6.45% / 4.61% 53.21% / 0% 53.07% / 0%
Y12 2007/01; 2007/12 -8.62% / -4.01% -8.25% / -3.29% -0.65 / -0.25 15.28% / 14.69% 120.93% / 0% 120.6% / 0%
Y13 2008/01; 2008/12 42.27% / 35.74% 38.87% / 38.95% 1.47 / 0.95 14.09% / 19.87% 80.72% / 0% 80.5% / 0%
Y14 2009/01; 2010/01 -2.2% / -0.91% -2.17% / -0.82% -1.4 / -0.18 0.94% / 0.78% 2.75% / 0% 2.8% / 0%
Y15 2010/01; 2010/12 -5.91% / -13.02% -4.02% / -12.63% -0.2 / -0.75 10.82% / 19.8% 75.27% / 0% 76.51% / 0%
Y16 2011/01; 2011/12 16.05% / -4.7% 15.5% / -4.03% 1.46 / -0.31 4.26% / 8.91% 68.79% / 0% 68.6% / 0%
Y17 2012/01; 2012/12 -2.44% / -6.42% -2.16% / -6.31% -0.27 / -0.77 3.76% / 10.21% 36.5% / 0% 36.4% / 0%
Y18 2013/01; 2013/12 0% / 0% 0% / 0% NaN / NaN 0% / 0% 0% / 0% 0% / 0%
All 1996/08; 2013/12 272.38% / 3.75% 8.6% / 1.3% 0.59 / 0.09 32.46% / 41.29% 82.81% / 0% 1443.56% / 0%
First 1996/08; 2006/12 174.93% / 3.6% 10.78% / 1.01% 0.73 / 0.09 27.53% / 31.26% 101.43% / 0% 1058.16% / 0%
Second 2007/01; 2013/12 35.45% / 0.15% 5.36% / 1.72% 0.37 / 0.09 18.63% / 41.29% 55.06% / 0% 385.41% / 0%

More Related Content

What's hot

Harmonizing 900 MHz band
Harmonizing 900 MHz bandHarmonizing 900 MHz band
Harmonizing 900 MHz bandParag Kar
 
Tabela de conversao z-dpmo
Tabela de conversao   z-dpmoTabela de conversao   z-dpmo
Tabela de conversao z-dpmoHugo Oliveira
 
Resultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistas
Resultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistasResultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistas
Resultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistasRoberto Dias Duarte
 
Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008
Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008
Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008mensa25
 
ECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paper
ECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paperECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paper
ECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paperSamiya Yesmin
 
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013Lincoln Crowne & Company
 
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013Nick Assef
 
03.3 homogeneous debt portfolios
03.3   homogeneous debt portfolios03.3   homogeneous debt portfolios
03.3 homogeneous debt portfolioscrmbasel
 
Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013
Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013
Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013Lincoln Crowne & Company
 
Prieto ma jo nasdaq
Prieto ma jo   nasdaqPrieto ma jo   nasdaq
Prieto ma jo nasdaqedinson2018
 
Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...
Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...
Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...BCV
 
20.3 regulatory credit exposures
20.3   regulatory credit exposures20.3   regulatory credit exposures
20.3 regulatory credit exposurescrmbasel
 

What's hot (19)

Harmonizing 900 MHz band
Harmonizing 900 MHz bandHarmonizing 900 MHz band
Harmonizing 900 MHz band
 
Active duty quotas 2011
Active duty quotas 2011Active duty quotas 2011
Active duty quotas 2011
 
Tabela de conversao z-dpmo
Tabela de conversao   z-dpmoTabela de conversao   z-dpmo
Tabela de conversao z-dpmo
 
Resultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistas
Resultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistasResultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistas
Resultado do Exame de Suficiência 2011 - contabilistas
 
Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008
Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008
Corporate Venture Capital Group Investment Analysis 1995 to Q2 2008
 
CorrelationMIDWPV
CorrelationMIDWPVCorrelationMIDWPV
CorrelationMIDWPV
 
ECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paper
ECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paperECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paper
ECO303- Introduction to Econometrics- term paper
 
NbaPythagoreanTest pdf
NbaPythagoreanTest pdfNbaPythagoreanTest pdf
NbaPythagoreanTest pdf
 
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
 
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
Lincoln crowne engineering mining services 30 august 2013
 
03.3 homogeneous debt portfolios
03.3   homogeneous debt portfolios03.3   homogeneous debt portfolios
03.3 homogeneous debt portfolios
 
Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013
Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013
Lincoln Crowne Engineering & Mining Services Report 31052013
 
NbaPythagoreanTest pdf
NbaPythagoreanTest pdfNbaPythagoreanTest pdf
NbaPythagoreanTest pdf
 
Consumer report
Consumer reportConsumer report
Consumer report
 
Cob 20080617 1
Cob 20080617 1Cob 20080617 1
Cob 20080617 1
 
Excel Model for Banking
Excel Model for Banking Excel Model for Banking
Excel Model for Banking
 
Prieto ma jo nasdaq
Prieto ma jo   nasdaqPrieto ma jo   nasdaq
Prieto ma jo nasdaq
 
Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...
Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...
Fundamental Analysis & Recommendations - OEX Index - The Standard & Poor's 10...
 
20.3 regulatory credit exposures
20.3   regulatory credit exposures20.3   regulatory credit exposures
20.3 regulatory credit exposures
 

Viewers also liked

H2O Big Data Environments
H2O Big Data EnvironmentsH2O Big Data Environments
H2O Big Data EnvironmentsSri Ambati
 
Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015
Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015
Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015Sri Ambati
 
Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...
Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...
Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...Sri Ambati
 
Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu
 Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu
Visual Machine Learning - Tony ChuSri Ambati
 
H2O Big Join Slides
H2O Big Join SlidesH2O Big Join Slides
H2O Big Join SlidesSri Ambati
 

Viewers also liked (6)

H2O Big Data Environments
H2O Big Data EnvironmentsH2O Big Data Environments
H2O Big Data Environments
 
Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015
Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015
Machine Learning with H2O, Spark, and Python at Strata 2015
 
Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...
Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...
Building a Real-Time Security Application Using Log Data and Machine Learning...
 
Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu
 Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu
Visual Machine Learning - Tony Chu
 
H20: A platform for big math
H20: A platform for big math H20: A platform for big math
H20: A platform for big math
 
H2O Big Join Slides
H2O Big Join SlidesH2O Big Join Slides
H2O Big Join Slides
 

Similar to Systematic Stock picking strategy

SPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTM
SPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTMSPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTM
SPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTMStefan Bolta
 
Valuation Of ASHOK LEYLAND
Valuation Of ASHOK LEYLANDValuation Of ASHOK LEYLAND
Valuation Of ASHOK LEYLANDAakash Singh
 
Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10
Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10
Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10Walid Saafan
 
Lesco Sales Results
Lesco Sales ResultsLesco Sales Results
Lesco Sales ResultsSteve Frank
 
This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)
This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)
This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)Giuseppe Piazzolla
 
Opportunity Cost to Your Operation
Opportunity Cost to Your OperationOpportunity Cost to Your Operation
Opportunity Cost to Your OperationNational Pork Board
 
Ratio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of Bangladesh
Ratio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of BangladeshRatio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of Bangladesh
Ratio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of BangladeshAL Babur Rahman
 
2Q13 Results Presentation
2Q13 Results Presentation2Q13 Results Presentation
2Q13 Results PresentationAluparRI
 
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013claudiusinhos
 
Problem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdf
Problem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdfProblem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdf
Problem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdfarrowcomputers8700
 
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015claudiusinhos
 
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013claudiusinhos
 

Similar to Systematic Stock picking strategy (20)

SPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTM
SPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTMSPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTM
SPX (1990-2012) - Long Straddle, Strangle & Deep OTM
 
Valuation Of ASHOK LEYLAND
Valuation Of ASHOK LEYLANDValuation Of ASHOK LEYLAND
Valuation Of ASHOK LEYLAND
 
Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10
Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10
Egypt pharma market performance ws-04.10
 
Global Weekly
Global WeeklyGlobal Weekly
Global Weekly
 
Lesco Sales Results
Lesco Sales ResultsLesco Sales Results
Lesco Sales Results
 
Presentation Correlation and Volatility Eurex
Presentation Correlation and Volatility EurexPresentation Correlation and Volatility Eurex
Presentation Correlation and Volatility Eurex
 
This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)
This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)
This is my scorecard, what I infer from my simplified worksheet (...)
 
Monthly Review April-2023.pptx
Monthly Review April-2023.pptxMonthly Review April-2023.pptx
Monthly Review April-2023.pptx
 
Super Commodity
Super CommoditySuper Commodity
Super Commodity
 
Amit Monthly Review Template.pptx
Amit Monthly Review Template.pptxAmit Monthly Review Template.pptx
Amit Monthly Review Template.pptx
 
Mantenimiento
MantenimientoMantenimiento
Mantenimiento
 
SGMT2016APR
SGMT2016APRSGMT2016APR
SGMT2016APR
 
Opportunity Cost to Your Operation
Opportunity Cost to Your OperationOpportunity Cost to Your Operation
Opportunity Cost to Your Operation
 
Ratio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of Bangladesh
Ratio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of BangladeshRatio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of Bangladesh
Ratio analysis on Pharmaceutical Companies: A study of Bangladesh
 
2Q13 Results Presentation
2Q13 Results Presentation2Q13 Results Presentation
2Q13 Results Presentation
 
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários julho 2013
 
AZN/ALXN
AZN/ALXNAZN/ALXN
AZN/ALXN
 
Problem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdf
Problem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdfProblem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdf
Problem 1 (50 points) All Financial Data should only be obtained from.pdf
 
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários setembro 2015
 
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013
Rentabilidade acumulada fundos imobiliários junho 2013
 

Systematic Stock picking strategy

  • 2. Summary • Fully systematic strategy based on scoring algorithm to assemble stocks for long and short portfolios • Short only-part of the portfolio substantially reduces drawdowns during turbulent times. • Regime switching indicator to switch on and off short component. • Two independently profitable substrategies, to get the final more robust portfolio. • Simulated performance from 1996 of • CAGR: 30% • Sharpe: 1.71
  • 3. Alpha Generation • Long-only part of the portfolio generates 22% vs SPX generates 7.59% • Short only part of the portfolio generates 8.6% vs benchmark of 1.13% • Combining long and short reduces drawdowns and achieves the total performance of 30% with Sharpe 1.71
  • 4. Alpha Generation Portfolio Components CAGR, % Bench Excess Return Sharpe MaxDD, % Long Only Part 21.94 7.59 14.35 1.11 45.41 Short Only with RS 8.6 1.13 7.47 0.59 32.46 Short Only Part without RS(zero costs) -2 -7.59 5.59 -0.1 62 Final Portfolio 30.55 7.59 22.96 1.71 24.9
  • 5. Strategy Performance vs. S&P 500 Index
  • 6. Strategy / SPX Index yearly performance Ann. Return: 30.55% Sharpe: 1.71 range TR CAGR Sharpe MDD A.Trnv T.trnv Y1 1996/08; 1996/12 4.2% / 14.23% 10% / 32.31% 1.43 / 2.71 2.47% / 3.75% 156.28% / 0% 65.94% / 0% Y2 1997/01; 1997/12 54% / 23.74% 44.17% / 22.56% 3.7 / 1.46 3.97% / 8.76% 263.22% / 0% 262.5% / 0% Y3 1998/01; 1999/01 28.19% / 31.26% 26.46% / 28.54% 1.31 / 1.53 19.86% / 17.94% 235.4% / 0% 239.27% / 0% Y4 1999/01; 1999/12 47.8% / 19.81% 39.79% / 19.48% 2.52 / 1.06 8.64% / 12.08% 247.06% / 0% 251.13% / 0% Y5 2000/01; 2000/12 53.24% / -10.14% 45.23% / -8.15% 2.1 / -0.36 10.12% / 14.5% 283.94% / 0% 283.16% / 0% Y6 2001/01; 2001/12 86.34% / -12.06% 64.59% / -10.35% 3.36 / -0.46 11.28% / 28.72% 283.78% / 0% 283% / 0% Y7 2002/01; 2002/12 69.01% / -24.6% 54.53% / -26.26% 2.95 / -1.31 10.76% / 31.72% 254.05% / 0% 253.36% / 0% Y8 2003/01; 2003/12 45.63% / 25.19% 38.98% / 23.71% 2.54 / 1.55 8.7% / 10.64% 307.44% / 0% 306.6% / 0% Y9 2004/01; 2004/12 39.67% / 10.59% 33.59% / 10.46% 2.97 / 0.99 3.75% / 8.03% 308.08% / 0% 313.14% / 0% Y10 2005/01; 2005/12 22.76% / 3% 21.27% / 3.43% 1.81 / 0.35 8.65% / 6.51% 236.99% / 0% 236.34% / 0% Y11 2006/01; 2006/12 12.8% / 13.62% 13.14% / 13.29% 0.9 / 1.35 9.52% / 6.76% 225.75% / 0% 225.13% / 0% Y12 2007/01; 2007/12 -4.36% / 4.24% -3.49% / 5.09% -0.25 / 0.37 17.96% / 7.75% 293.05% / 0% 292.25% / 0% Y13 2008/01; 2008/12 31.78% / -40.97% 32.09% / -46.96% 1.08 / -1.41 21.39% / 43.87% 271.3% / 0% 270.55% / 0% Y14 2009/01; 2010/01 47.9% / 27.76% 42.83% / 27.45% 1.46 / 1.06 21.57% / 26.66% 147.61% / 0% 150.04% / 0% Y15 2010/01; 2010/12 19.49% / 11.64% 18.72% / 12.31% 1.21 / 0.71 8.39% / 15.99% 200.01% / 0% 203.3% / 0% Y16 2011/01; 2011/12 30.22% / 0% 28.45% / 2.3% 1.46 / 0.11 17.46% / 17.61% 199.62% / 0% 199.07% / 0% Y17 2012/01; 2012/12 0.01% / 11.52% 0.78% / 11.63% 0.06 / 0.98 12.27% / 9.26% 163.48% / 0% 163.03% / 0% Y18 2013/01; 2013/12 34% / 31.3% 30.04% / 27.87% 2.68 / 2.78 5.71% / 4.5% 136.67% / 0% 136.3% / 0% All 1996/08; 2013/12 15277% / 177.95% 30.55% / 7.59% 1.71 / 0.41 24.9% / 56.24% 236.89% / 0% 4129.61% / 0% First 1996/08; 2006/12 3809.67% / 114.09% 36.53% / 8.73% 2.27 / 0.52 20.24% / 47.59% 260.43% / 0% 2717.06% / 0% Second 2007/01; 2013/12 293.31% / 29.83% 21.62% / 5.91% 1.07 / 0.28 24.9% / 56.24% 201.79% / 0% 1412.55% / 0%
  • 7. Regime Switching Sentiment Indicator is good at detecting market regimes: Long/Short Annual return 10.55% vs. 7.59% Buy and Hold S&P Index
  • 8. Sentiment indicator summary • Using Sentiment Indicator to Open/Close short only portfolio depending on the market sentiment • Calculating the composite index from: • VIX Index, Put-Call ratio, NYSE Margin Debt, NYSE Volume , AAII sentiment, Dividend Premium, Closed-end funds premium, first-year IPO return. • Controlling for the economic cycle by regressing the index to macro data: • Industrial production; Consumer consumption – non-durables, durables, services; Payments; Utility rate. • Use the residuals from the regressions to determine sentiment phase of market as: • “BEAR” • “BULL” This indicator allows to increase the annual performance of the short only portfolio from -5% to 8%
  • 9. Testing the strategy on historical data • Analyzing about 3000 companies at any point in time • Using the historical data from S&P Capital IQ (Compustat DB) • No survivorship bias • Point-in-time data: fundamental and macro data as they were seen on any particular date • Quarterly financial data from 1990 • Standardized data • Weekly rebalancing • Equal weighted portfolio with max. weight 7% per position • Conservative commission of 0.2% • Borrowing costs: 5% • Sentiment Indicator for Regime Switching • Using official data from FRED • Trailing 5-years window
  • 10. Strategy Details: Score Calculations • Create composite value score as sum of four individual scores • derived from fundamentals: profitability, growth, safety, payout, • using about 40 corporate fundamentals from standardized reports • filter out the companies with capitalization less then median. • Long Only Portfolio • Pick up companies with the highest overall composite score and lowest P/B • Short-Only Portfolio • Pick up companies with the lowest individual scores and highest P/B for short-side portfolio • Move to cash depending on the current market regime For each company in the asset universe we derive a score which defines its position relative to the others.
  • 13. Market Cap Distributions: largest 100 mcap steps 14% 20% 34% 24% 8% Long 26% 32% 25% 14% 3% Short 17% 24% 31% 21% 7% Total Portfolio 1-5 6-10 11-15 16-20 21-25 Current possible lowest cap at 1.6 bln
  • 14. Long Portfolio vs. S&P 500 Index
  • 15. Statistics: Long Portfolio / SPX Index Ann. Return: 21.94 Sharpe: 1.11 range TR CAGR Sharpe MDD A.Trnv T.trnv Y1 1996/08; 1996/12 2.95% / 14.23% 7.06% / 32.31% 1.18 / 2.71 1.68% / 3.75% 108.17% / 0% 45.64% / 0% Y2 1997/01; 1997/12 41.34% / 23.74% 35.28% / 22.56% 3.6 / 1.46 5.98% / 8.76% 141.79% / 0% 141.4% / 0% Y3 1998/01; 1999/01 13.79% / 31.26% 14.94% / 28.54% 0.7 / 1.53 27.79% / 17.94% 189.95% / 0% 193.07% / 0% Y4 1999/01; 1999/12 18.15% / 19.81% 17.56% / 19.48% 1.15 / 1.06 11.74% / 12.08% 174.11% / 0% 176.97% / 0% Y5 2000/01; 2000/12 22.25% / -10.14% 21.36% / -8.15% 1.37 / -0.36 6.86% / 14.5% 164.34% / 0% 163.89% / 0% Y6 2001/01; 2001/12 60.17% / -12.06% 50.29% / -10.35% 2.14 / -0.46 18.9% / 28.72% 129.12% / 0% 128.77% / 0% Y7 2002/01; 2002/12 12.85% / -24.6% 13.78% / -26.26% 0.75 / -1.31 17.38% / 31.72% 173.9% / 0% 173.42% / 0% Y8 2003/01; 2003/12 56.04% / 25.19% 45.89% / 23.71% 3.08 / 1.55 6.56% / 10.64% 186.21% / 0% 185.7% / 0% Y9 2004/01; 2004/12 40.11% / 10.59% 34.42% / 10.46% 2.27 / 0.99 8.64% / 8.03% 152.24% / 0% 154.74% / 0% Y10 2005/01; 2005/12 21.27% / 3% 20.11% / 3.43% 1.65 / 0.35 5.77% / 6.51% 126.08% / 0% 125.74% / 0% Y11 2006/01; 2006/12 17.88% / 13.62% 17.27% / 13.29% 1.4 / 1.35 9.52% / 6.76% 172.54% / 0% 172.06% / 0% Y12 2007/01; 2007/12 3.44% / 4.24% 4.75% / 5.09% 0.29 / 0.37 12.41% / 7.75% 172.12% / 0% 171.65% / 0% Y13 2008/01; 2008/12 -14.86% / -40.97% -6.78% / -46.96% -0.16 / -1.41 45.41% / 43.87% 190.58% / 0% 190.05% / 0% Y14 2009/01; 2010/01 51.1% / 27.76% 45.01% / 27.45% 1.53 / 1.06 21.57% / 26.66% 144.86% / 0% 147.24% / 0% Y15 2010/01; 2010/12 23.56% / 11.64% 22.74% / 12.31% 1.16 / 0.71 17.63% / 15.99% 124.75% / 0% 126.8% / 0% Y16 2011/01; 2011/12 11.35% / 0% 12.95% / 2.3% 0.62 / 0.11 17.46% / 17.61% 130.83% / 0% 130.47% / 0% Y17 2012/01; 2012/12 2.08% / 11.52% 2.94% / 11.63% 0.22 / 0.98 14.43% / 9.26% 126.98% / 0% 126.63% / 0% Y18 2013/01; 2013/12 34% / 31.3% 30.04% / 27.87% 2.68 / 2.78 5.71% / 4.5% 136.67% / 0% 136.3% / 0% All 1996/08; 2013/12 3138.79% / 177.95% 21.94% / 7.59% 1.11 / 0.41 45.41% / 56.24% 154.08% / 0% 2686.05% / 0% First 1996/08; 2006/12 1178.17% / 114.09% 25.76% / 8.73% 1.62 / 0.52 27.79% / 47.59% 159.01% / 0% 1658.9% / 0% Second 2007/01; 2013/12 153.39% / 29.83% 16.26% / 5.91% 0.67 / 0.28 45.41% / 56.24% 146.73% / 0% 1027.14% / 0%
  • 16. Short Portfolio vs. Short S&P 500 Index
  • 17. Statistics: Short Strategy / Short SPX Index Ann. Return: 8.6% Sharpe: 0.59 range TR CAGR Sharpe MDD A.Trnv T.trnv Y1 1996/08; 1996/12 1.22% / -10.94% 2.94% / -27.23% 0.76 / -2.74 2.01% / 14.47% 48.11% / 0% 20.3% / 0% Y2 1997/01; 1997/12 8.31% / -15.96% 8.89% / -16.66% 0.67 / -1.37 13.24% / 21.71% 121.43% / 0% 121.1% / 0% Y3 1998/01; 1999/01 12.13% / 10.9% 11.53% / 10.73% 1.58 / 1.23 0.84% / 3.24% 45.45% / 0% 46.2% / 0% Y4 1999/01; 1999/12 24.66% / 2.04% 22.23% / 2.34% 2.19 / 0.3 2.62% / 9.95% 72.96% / 0% 74.15% / 0% Y5 2000/01; 2000/12 23.98% / 11.53% 23.87% / 11.56% 1.1 / 1.08 9.93% / 5.29% 119.6% / 0% 119.27% / 0% Y6 2001/01; 2001/12 11.93% / 10.94% 14.3% / 12.27% 0.58 / 0.63 24.59% / 16.62% 154.65% / 0% 154.23% / 0% Y7 2002/01; 2002/12 47.58% / 18.58% 40.75% / 18.99% 2.25 / 0.97 8.1% / 14.44% 80.16% / 0% 79.94% / 0% Y8 2003/01; 2003/12 -6.89% / -0.57% -6.91% / -0.43% -1 / -0.08 8.31% / 3.56% 121.23% / 0% 120.9% / 0% Y9 2004/01; 2004/12 -2.36% / -8.26% -0.83% / -8.2% -0.05 / -0.9 20.1% / 12.74% 155.84% / 0% 158.4% / 0% Y10 2005/01; 2005/12 0.73% / -4.57% 1.17% / -4.33% 0.12 / -0.49 11.67% / 11.83% 110.9% / 0% 110.6% / 0% Y11 2006/01; 2006/12 -4.34% / -4.21% -4.12% / -4.27% -0.5 / -1.08 6.45% / 4.61% 53.21% / 0% 53.07% / 0% Y12 2007/01; 2007/12 -8.62% / -4.01% -8.25% / -3.29% -0.65 / -0.25 15.28% / 14.69% 120.93% / 0% 120.6% / 0% Y13 2008/01; 2008/12 42.27% / 35.74% 38.87% / 38.95% 1.47 / 0.95 14.09% / 19.87% 80.72% / 0% 80.5% / 0% Y14 2009/01; 2010/01 -2.2% / -0.91% -2.17% / -0.82% -1.4 / -0.18 0.94% / 0.78% 2.75% / 0% 2.8% / 0% Y15 2010/01; 2010/12 -5.91% / -13.02% -4.02% / -12.63% -0.2 / -0.75 10.82% / 19.8% 75.27% / 0% 76.51% / 0% Y16 2011/01; 2011/12 16.05% / -4.7% 15.5% / -4.03% 1.46 / -0.31 4.26% / 8.91% 68.79% / 0% 68.6% / 0% Y17 2012/01; 2012/12 -2.44% / -6.42% -2.16% / -6.31% -0.27 / -0.77 3.76% / 10.21% 36.5% / 0% 36.4% / 0% Y18 2013/01; 2013/12 0% / 0% 0% / 0% NaN / NaN 0% / 0% 0% / 0% 0% / 0% All 1996/08; 2013/12 272.38% / 3.75% 8.6% / 1.3% 0.59 / 0.09 32.46% / 41.29% 82.81% / 0% 1443.56% / 0% First 1996/08; 2006/12 174.93% / 3.6% 10.78% / 1.01% 0.73 / 0.09 27.53% / 31.26% 101.43% / 0% 1058.16% / 0% Second 2007/01; 2013/12 35.45% / 0.15% 5.36% / 1.72% 0.37 / 0.09 18.63% / 41.29% 55.06% / 0% 385.41% / 0%