SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Following Precedent:R v Dawson 1985 R v Watson 1989R v Carey 2006Prior Precedent:R v Franklin 1883 R v Larkin 1943R v Thabo-Meli 1954 Ratio:Constructive act manslaughter will require an unlawful actThe act must be such as all sober and reasonable people would inevitably recognise must subject the other person to, at least, the risk of some harm therefrom.R v Church 1966<br />Following Precedent:R v Evans (Gemma) 2009R v Khan & Khan 1998R v Misra 2004Prior Precedent:Andrews v DPP 1937R v Bateman 1925 R v Seymour 1983Ratio:Liability is based on the ordinary rules of negligenceEstablishes the test for gross negligence manslaughterThe jury’s role to decide whether D’s actions amounting to gross negligence, which is deserving of criminal punishment. R v Adomako<br />,[object Object],Following Precedent:Attorney-General’s Reference No2 of 1999 (2000)R v Misra 2004<br />Prior Precedent:R v Adomako 1994 R v Seymour 1983Law Commission 1994Ratio:Allows the jury to be instructed on recklessness.Confirms that subjective recklessness may be enough for manslaughterA vague definition for the jury is necessary in manslaughter.R v Lidar 2000<br />Following Precedent:Andrews v DPP 1937R v Adomako 1994R v Misra 2004Prior Precedent:Cashill v. Wright 1856Ratio:Did D go beyond a mere matter of compensation between subjects and show such a disregard for life and safety of others as amounts to a crime deserving of punishment.Establishes the difference between the civil and criminal standards of negligenceJury determines negligence, and the judge may use eords such as recklessness in ‘its ordinary connotation’ to instruct themR v Bateman 1925<br />,[object Object]
Following Precedent:R v Kennedy No 2 2007R v Dias 2001Following Precedent:Evans (Gemma)Prior Precedent:R v Cunningham 1957Prior Precedent:R v Dalby 1999R v Dias 2001R v Rogers 2003Ratio:V’s consent is not ordinarily a defence to manslaughterD’s actions must be more than de minimus. Simply being one cause is not enough, although it can accelerate deathAdministration of drug under s.23 of the OAPA is enough for an unlawful act.Supply of heroin is not an unlawful act.Ratio:Supply of drugs is an unlawful act, but not a dangerous one.The volitional act of V will ordinarily break the chain of causation.Administer is to be interpreted narrowly, and does not include preparationR v Cato 1976R v Kennedy (No2) 2007
Synoptic cases 2010 11
Synoptic cases 2010 11

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

White stone rv
White stone rvWhite stone rv
White stone rv
victorrudyakov
 
Causation & other issues 2011 12
Causation & other issues 2011 12Causation & other issues 2011 12
Causation & other issues 2011 12
Miss Hart
 
End of unit assessment 2012
End of unit assessment 2012End of unit assessment 2012
End of unit assessment 2012
Miss Hart
 
Free UK Law Sources
Free UK Law SourcesFree UK Law Sources
Free UK Law Sources
Jennifer Winterburn
 
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared ResourceLaw-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
lawexchange.co.uk
 
Online assignment saranya
Online assignment saranyaOnline assignment saranya
Online assignment saranya
Saranya S Varadarajan
 
Law & order
Law & orderLaw & order
Law & order
mattbentley34
 
law and order
law and orderlaw and order
law and order
Saad Bin Sadaqat
 
PI 1.1 the law, customs and rules
PI 1.1 the law, customs and rulesPI 1.1 the law, customs and rules
PI 1.1 the law, customs and rules
Alisa Stephens
 
1.3 just laws and the nature of justice
1.3 just laws and the nature of justice1.3 just laws and the nature of justice
1.3 just laws and the nature of justice
Alisa Stephens
 
A2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studies
A2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studiesA2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studies
A2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studies
itskit
 
Common law UK resources
Common law UK resourcesCommon law UK resources
Common law UK resources
Bodleian Law Library
 
Unit 3 revision handbook
Unit 3 revision handbookUnit 3 revision handbook
Unit 3 revision handbook
mattbentley34
 
2.1 sources of law british common law
2.1 sources of law british common law2.1 sources of law british common law
2.1 sources of law british common law
Alisa Stephens
 
Law and order big challenge for pakistan
Law and order big challenge for pakistanLaw and order big challenge for pakistan
Law and order big challenge for pakistan
saleem khan
 
Natural law revision notes
Natural law revision notesNatural law revision notes
Natural law revision notes
FAROUQ
 
Jurisprudence - Natural Law
Jurisprudence - Natural LawJurisprudence - Natural Law
Jurisprudence - Natural Law
FAROUQ
 
AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1
AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1
AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1
mattbentley34
 
Law And Order
Law And OrderLaw And Order
Law And Order
Brayton College
 
Presentation on Consumer protection act new
Presentation on Consumer protection act newPresentation on Consumer protection act new
Presentation on Consumer protection act new
satya pal
 

Viewers also liked (20)

White stone rv
White stone rvWhite stone rv
White stone rv
 
Causation & other issues 2011 12
Causation & other issues 2011 12Causation & other issues 2011 12
Causation & other issues 2011 12
 
End of unit assessment 2012
End of unit assessment 2012End of unit assessment 2012
End of unit assessment 2012
 
Free UK Law Sources
Free UK Law SourcesFree UK Law Sources
Free UK Law Sources
 
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared ResourceLaw-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
Law-Exchange.co.uk Shared Resource
 
Online assignment saranya
Online assignment saranyaOnline assignment saranya
Online assignment saranya
 
Law & order
Law & orderLaw & order
Law & order
 
law and order
law and orderlaw and order
law and order
 
PI 1.1 the law, customs and rules
PI 1.1 the law, customs and rulesPI 1.1 the law, customs and rules
PI 1.1 the law, customs and rules
 
1.3 just laws and the nature of justice
1.3 just laws and the nature of justice1.3 just laws and the nature of justice
1.3 just laws and the nature of justice
 
A2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studies
A2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studiesA2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studies
A2 Edexcel Government & Politics Unit 4 examples and case studies
 
Common law UK resources
Common law UK resourcesCommon law UK resources
Common law UK resources
 
Unit 3 revision handbook
Unit 3 revision handbookUnit 3 revision handbook
Unit 3 revision handbook
 
2.1 sources of law british common law
2.1 sources of law british common law2.1 sources of law british common law
2.1 sources of law british common law
 
Law and order big challenge for pakistan
Law and order big challenge for pakistanLaw and order big challenge for pakistan
Law and order big challenge for pakistan
 
Natural law revision notes
Natural law revision notesNatural law revision notes
Natural law revision notes
 
Jurisprudence - Natural Law
Jurisprudence - Natural LawJurisprudence - Natural Law
Jurisprudence - Natural Law
 
AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1
AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1
AS Politics - Revision Guide: Unit 1
 
Law And Order
Law And OrderLaw And Order
Law And Order
 
Presentation on Consumer protection act new
Presentation on Consumer protection act newPresentation on Consumer protection act new
Presentation on Consumer protection act new
 

More from Miss Hart

Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]
Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]
Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]
Miss Hart
 
IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)
IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)
IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)
Miss Hart
 
Igcse reading paper
Igcse reading paperIgcse reading paper
Igcse reading paper
Miss Hart
 
L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014
L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014
L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014
Miss Hart
 
L3 (qu3 summary)
L3 (qu3 summary)L3 (qu3 summary)
L3 (qu3 summary)
Miss Hart
 
L1 (intro to paper & qu2)
L1 (intro to paper & qu2)L1 (intro to paper & qu2)
L1 (intro to paper & qu2)
Miss Hart
 
iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2
iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2
iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2
Miss Hart
 
iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]
iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]
iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]
Miss Hart
 
iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"
iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"
iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"
Miss Hart
 
Loss Of Control Intro Lesson
Loss Of Control Intro LessonLoss Of Control Intro Lesson
Loss Of Control Intro Lesson
Miss Hart
 
Attempts
AttemptsAttempts
Attempts
Miss Hart
 
Mens Rea
Mens ReaMens Rea
Mens Rea
Miss Hart
 
Causation
Causation Causation
Causation
Miss Hart
 
Actus Reus
Actus ReusActus Reus
Actus Reus
Miss Hart
 
Causation End of Unit Assessment
Causation End of Unit AssessmentCausation End of Unit Assessment
Causation End of Unit Assessment
Miss Hart
 
Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014
Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014
Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014
Miss Hart
 
Duress & Necessity
Duress & NecessityDuress & Necessity
Duress & Necessity
Miss Hart
 
Involuntary Manslaughter
Involuntary ManslaughterInvoluntary Manslaughter
Involuntary Manslaughter
Miss Hart
 
Loss of Control
Loss of ControlLoss of Control
Loss of Control
Miss Hart
 
Diminished Responsibility
Diminished ResponsibilityDiminished Responsibility
Diminished Responsibility
Miss Hart
 

More from Miss Hart (20)

Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]
Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]
Catcher [AQA B Lang Lit Cwk Notes]
 
IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)
IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)
IGCSE (San Bushmen Qu3 iGCSE)
 
Igcse reading paper
Igcse reading paperIgcse reading paper
Igcse reading paper
 
L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014
L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014
L4 (qu1 empathetic interview) iGCSE summer 2014
 
L3 (qu3 summary)
L3 (qu3 summary)L3 (qu3 summary)
L3 (qu3 summary)
 
L1 (intro to paper & qu2)
L1 (intro to paper & qu2)L1 (intro to paper & qu2)
L1 (intro to paper & qu2)
 
iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2
iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2
iGCSE Quiz on the Skills for Paper 2
 
iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]
iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]
iGCSE Jan Mock Prep Lesson [Question 2 Extended]
 
iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"
iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"
iGCSE Extended "Create your own Paper"
 
Loss Of Control Intro Lesson
Loss Of Control Intro LessonLoss Of Control Intro Lesson
Loss Of Control Intro Lesson
 
Attempts
AttemptsAttempts
Attempts
 
Mens Rea
Mens ReaMens Rea
Mens Rea
 
Causation
Causation Causation
Causation
 
Actus Reus
Actus ReusActus Reus
Actus Reus
 
Causation End of Unit Assessment
Causation End of Unit AssessmentCausation End of Unit Assessment
Causation End of Unit Assessment
 
Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014
Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014
Mechanics of Precedent EoU 2014
 
Duress & Necessity
Duress & NecessityDuress & Necessity
Duress & Necessity
 
Involuntary Manslaughter
Involuntary ManslaughterInvoluntary Manslaughter
Involuntary Manslaughter
 
Loss of Control
Loss of ControlLoss of Control
Loss of Control
 
Diminished Responsibility
Diminished ResponsibilityDiminished Responsibility
Diminished Responsibility
 

Synoptic cases 2010 11

  • 1.
  • 2. Following Precedent:R v Kennedy No 2 2007R v Dias 2001Following Precedent:Evans (Gemma)Prior Precedent:R v Cunningham 1957Prior Precedent:R v Dalby 1999R v Dias 2001R v Rogers 2003Ratio:V’s consent is not ordinarily a defence to manslaughterD’s actions must be more than de minimus. Simply being one cause is not enough, although it can accelerate deathAdministration of drug under s.23 of the OAPA is enough for an unlawful act.Supply of heroin is not an unlawful act.Ratio:Supply of drugs is an unlawful act, but not a dangerous one.The volitional act of V will ordinarily break the chain of causation.Administer is to be interpreted narrowly, and does not include preparationR v Cato 1976R v Kennedy (No2) 2007