President Obama took some serious heat last year when insurers started dropping millions of American...

1. Study: Obamacare didn't necessarily lead to health plan
cancellations
President Obama took some serious heat last year when insurers started dropping millions of
Americans from health plans that were no longer Obamacare-compliant, seemingly breaking his
promise, "If you have insurance that you like, then you will be able to keep that insurance."
A new study, however, backs up the administration's claims that the cancellations were part of the
normal churn of the individual health market.
After analyzing patterns in the nongroup health coverage market from 2008 to 2011, Harvard
professor Benjamin Sommers found that the market was characterized by high turnover before the
Affordable Care Act was implemented. Additionally, Summers found that most people who left the
nongroup market acquired other insurance within, suggesting that the cancellations attributed to
Obamacare are unlikely to have a significant impact on overall coverage rates.
Relying on data from the Census Bureau's Survey of Income and Program Participation for his study,
Sommers used a sample of 4,199 respondents under 65 years old with nongroup coverage in their
first month in the survey.
Over one-third of those respondents no longer had nongroup insurance coverage after just four
months, Sommers found. Just 42 percent had stable nongroup coverage after one year. After two
years, just 27 percent had stable coverage.
Given that there were an estimated 10.8 million people in the nongroup market in 2012, as many as
6.2 million people could be leaving that market place in a given year, Sommers notes. "This suggests
that the nongroup market was characterized by frequent disruptions in coverage before the ACA and
that the effects of the recent cancellations are not necessarily out of the norm," he wrote in the
study's abstract.
Additionally, Sommers found that most people leaving the market found coverage elsewhere: Fifty
percent of people who experienced a coverage change found employer-sponsored insurance by the
study's first year. Another 20 percent had regained nongroup coverage, 6 percent had Medicare or
Medicaid, and 4 percent had other coverage. The remaining 20 percent were uninsured a year into
the study.
Given that two-thirds of the sample had incomes at or below 400 percent of the poverty line, the
study suggests that most people in the nongroup market would be eligible for federal subsidies on
the new Obamacare marketplaces or Medicaid coverage.
Sommers' study is the first to take a nationwide look at stability in the pre-Obamacare, nongroup
health insurance market. Other research focused on the nongroup market at the state level, but
there has been significant variation across different regions.
When news started trickling out about consumers losing coverage -- presumably because their bare-
bones insurance plans on the individual market did not meet Obamacare's minimum coverage
standards -- Mr. Obama defended his law, pointing out that insurers "routinely dropped thousands of

2. Americans every single year."
Yet after continued public outcry, Mr. Obama enacted an administrative policy change allowing
insurers to extend existing plans on the individual and small-group markets. By the time this
transitional policy fix ends in 2017, the administration expects most people on the nongroup market
will have found stable coverage on the Obamacare marketplace or elsewhere.
"By the time it gets to 2016, I don't think under any circumstances there's going to be a wave of
cancellation notices," an administration official told reporters in March.
© 2014 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.