SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Strategic Estate Planning
Development & Healthcare
Case Studies
Lester Wagman
2
NHS Cavell Centre
We are currently advising Spelthorne Borough Council on the development of one of the new integrated
multi-disciplinary Cavell centres as mart of an exciting mixed-use town centre regeneration scheme
• Appraisal of development potential
• Negotiation of capital values best value advice
• Structuring of lease and development agreements
• Asset management of completed scheme
Staines, Middlesex
3
Integrated Health Care Centre
We are currently advising the private landlord of a large modern integrated healthcare centre in North East
London, originally constructed under NHS LIFT and leased to the NHS on a Lease+
• Liaison with NHS occupiers and head tenant NHS Property Services
• Co-ordination of life-cycle repairs to the building
• Financially modelling different options for asset disposal
• Negotiations with NHS around lease restructure to support longer term operational viability
Ilford, Essex
4
Pre-disposal – Housing Amenity Land
Working with Rona London we are currently advising Enfield Council on the disposal of a number
of small land parcels from their Housing Revenue Account
• Liaison with tenants, homeowners and Council team
• Advice on values and conditions for disposal
• Consideration of wider asset management opportunities
• Advice on tenure and protective covenants
Enfield
5
Primary Healthcare Developments
In 2020 we are advising public and private sector landowner and developer clients on the creation of 5
separate new NHS primary care hubs. The context and brief is different in each case but all projects involve
• Appraisal of development potential
• Negotiation of rental values and support through business case process
• Structuring of lease and development agreements
• Valuation and/or forward sale of completed asset
Croydon, West Sussex, Milton Keynes, Oxfordshire
6
Primary Healthcare Business Case
We authored the CCG’s combined outline and full business case (FBC) for the development and fit of a new
1,181 sq.m integrated health and wellness centre, forming part of Poplar HARCA’s regeneration of the
Aberfeldy estate.
The new centre is a cornerstone of the WellOne intiative, part of the NHS Five Year Forward View, to meet
needs of a local population with high levels of deprivation which is forecast to double by 2040. The
premises will be leased to the NHS healthcare practice and the £3.5m fit out will be largely funded by
developers’ s.106 contributions from other schemes in the locality.
Aberfeldy New Village, Poplar, East London
7
Land option & development agreement
In 2020 we advised three individual co-owners of approx. 1.5 acres of land adjoining a major development
site for 500 homes adjacent to a junction on a major arterial route. However as well as having no rights of
access the land in question had been designated as greenbelt in the local authority’s recent plan review.
With two of the owners being past retirement age they wished to realise the optimum value for their asset.
Having approached a number of promoter-developers none of whom were keen to commit much early
capital we persuaded the owners of the adjoining development to pay a significant fee/premium for a
leasehold development agreement with future value-sharing agreed and final freehold acquisition option.
Working closely with the lawyers the resulting arrangement proved tax efficient for both the vendors’ IHT
planning and the developer's future CGT liability.
Hillingdon, West London
8
Development Consultancy
Context
Barnet Enfield & Haringey Mental Health NHS
Foundation Trust had declared the property
surplus to operational requirements. Haringey
Council wished to acquire the site for a local
public service project.
Challenge
To support local services the Trust wished to
transfer the property to the Council for market
value in a solus transaction without a full
market externalisation process. The agreed
transfer cost needed to be supported by 2
concurring professional valuations. The Council
benefited from an historic title covenant
restricting the use of the property.
Approach
Having undertaken our own valuation we
negotiated with DVS for them to take adequate
account of the effect of the covenant.
Results
Successfully negotiated a substantial capital
receipt for the Trust within tight timescale
Canning Crescent Centre – Wood Green
9
Estate Development Strategy
Context
This busy acute and community Trust in a densely
populated area sought to reconfigure and
modernise its estate to support the vital role it had
carved out for itself in the local health economy.
Challenge
Although residential property values in Croydon are
not as strong as other parts of the capital this site
fronts a main arterial close to a large commercial
centre and main transport connections.
Approach
We worked with master planners to quantify and
optimise development opportunity from parcelling
land for disposal. This work has supported the
development of the Trust’s main site Development
Control Plan which involves the construction of a
multi-storey car park and relocation of its existing
maternity wing as enabling development.
Results
Successfully re-planned site to inform estate
strategy options.
Croydon Health Services NHS Foundation Trust
10
Site Strategy
Context
Following the transfer of some teaching activities
to its new Colindale campus the College was
looking to rationalise its activities at Southgate
with a view to releasing land to generate capital.
Challenge
Site constraints included main access to the site
shared with local public library site (also surplus
for development), a very narrow secondary
access to the site, part shared access with local
Royal Mail depot and sorting office and
underground railway (Piccadilly Line) passing
under part of the site at shallow depth.
Approach
We worked with the College’s master planners to
devise and appraise alternative use development
options for three different parcels of land
including one for high density student housing
Results
Successfully re-planned site to inform estate
strategy options.
Barnet & Southgate College – Southgate Campus
11
Development Consultancy
Context
The College had previously agreed to sell
surplus land from its new campus in
Colindale, London NW9, to a major house
builder. Its original agreement with the
developer included a substantial overage
provision but despite there having been
significant house price growth, the property
market had since stalled/cooled.
Challenge
The developer was looking to crystallise and
make an early settlement of its overage
liability to offset this for tax against large
surpluses it had made in that financial year.
Approach
We undertook a detailed analysis of the
developer's construction programme, plotting
this against projected indices for house price
growth with varying confidence intervals.
Results
Successfully negotiated a substantial capital
payment for the college.
Barnet & Southgate College – Colindale Campus
12
Building Utilisation Review
Context
To inform bids under the NHS Estates & Infrastructure
Transformation Fund, CHP commissioned utilisation reviews
of a large number of primary care practices in North Central
London. Working under sub contract from Capita Property &
Infrastructure, Ambercycle undertook the surveys and
analysed the data.
Challenge
To design a generic survey for a variety of premises types
offering a wide range of services that would help identify
underutilisation/capacity and provide useful data to help
inform strategic estate planning. Not all practices were keen
to participate so there were logistical challenges too.
Approach
The survey, undertaken on site but consultatively with
practice staff, examined utilisation by room type and service
from 8am-8pm over a 7-day week in 1-hour sessions.
Results
Successfully surveyed 78 primary care premises over 10 week
period. Undertook analysis of over 10,000 data records and
provided reports at practice, borough/CCG and sub-regional
levels.
Community Health Partnerships
13
Feasibility Study – Bingfield
Context
The CCG commissions a wide range of healthcare
services across one of inner London’s most socially
diverse boroughs, with large areas of deprivation and
some regeneration.
Challenge
Committed to one of the most expensive and
underutilised LIFT assets in a socially deprived area of
inner London, the CCG sought ideas to revitalise the
building and improve recovery of costs.
Approach
Having carried out a detailed utilisation review and
examination of the building layout we identified
opportunities to convert two large offices and a
meeting room into six multi-service, bookable
consulting rooms and entered dialogue with range of
local healthcare service providers to use them.
Results
A detailed report and business case to support the
capital funding application (ETTF) for the works.
Negotiations commenced with landlord and service
providers.
NHS Islington CCG
14
Feasibility Study - Archway
Context
The CCG commissions a wide range of healthcare
services across one of inner London’s most socially
diverse boroughs, with large areas of deprivation and
some regeneration.
Challenge
The CCG, working closely with Islington Council
sought to integrate and replace and a poorly
accessible primary care practice with poor quality
premises together with a new library as part of a
regeneration scheme in a landmark location.
Approach
We led negotiations with the developer and brokered
dialogue with the council to act as lead tenant and
secure a workable building envelope for an integrated
facility with adequate means of access and circulation
and a floor plate that could deliver a flexible model.
Results
Negotiations are ongoing but Stage 1 report
concluded there was positive potential benefit from
such an approach. Next stage will be to finalise the
development agreement and terms of occupation.
NHS Islington CCG
15
Estate Consultancy
Context
The CCG commissions a wide range of healthcare
services across London’s most populous borough,
with one of the highest retired cohorts and some
areas of deprivation and regeneration.
Challenge
The organisation was financially stretched and one
of the greatest challenges it faced was to meet
liabilities for subsidies in expensive [LIFT] buildings
and cover the cost of void areas.
Approach
Working under sub contract from Carter Jonas, we
worked with Community Health Partnerships and
NHS Property Services to renegotiate costs and with
a range of other healthcare providers and
stakeholders to devise a more robust local estate
strategy.
Results
Secured annual recurrent savings of £4m, played a
key role in Barnet Council’s One public Estate 3 bid
[£350m], resolved local estate management issues
and laid foundations for a healthier NHS estate.
NHS Barnet CCG
16
The Forum
Context
Cambridge University Hospital Partners’ 2020 vision
is already becoming reality for the development of
the Addenbrookes site into the Cambridge
Biomedical Park with the arrival of the UK Medical
Research Council and the new Papworth Hospital
due to open in 2016.
Challenge
CUH were seeking an innovative solution for an
integrated commercial hub for the site providing
retail, hotel & conferencing facilities, a learning hub,
private patient centre and car parking.
Approach
Ambercycle played an important part in John Laing’s
bid team for the project, helping to balance the
Trust’s needs and aspirations with those of
prospective commercial funding partners.
Results
A lease structure able to support an institutional
forward funding approach while adapting to mixed-
risk income streams from different elements of the
scheme. John Laing selected as preferred partner.
John Laing Plc & Cambridge University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
Lucille van Geest MH Unit
17
Peterborough & Stamford Hospitals Foundation NHS Trust
Context
Trust had relocated to new PFI at Bretton. Peterborough District
Hospital site mainly surplus and Trust planning development
partnership to optimise value.
Challenge
Cambridgeshire Partnership Trust (MH) occupied LVG day centre
and in-patient unit and other offices on site under separate long-
term leases. Services could not be relocated without consulting
with the Trust, service users and families.
Approach
We worked with the service providers to assess different options
for providing the service in different ways and timescales for site
withdrawal. We also assessed the financial cost of reprovision
and identified ways to mitigate the impact on our client.
Results
We worked with the client to identify part of the Bretton hospital
site, release the Trust from an option agreement and negotiate
access from the PFI provider.
18
Estate Solutions Review (Stage 1)
Context
Acute trust, PCT & County Council with diverse and
disparate asset holdings (incl. a major hospital PFI)
working together to secure provision of locally
managed, joined-up services.
Challenge
The trusts and council wanted to explore ways
releasing efficiency savings and optimising capital
returns from the estate to fund joint service
improvements.
Approach
Undertook first stage investigation and financial
modelling of land value potential & profit-sharing
from development of trust estate using an asset-
backed joint venture structure.
Results
Stage 1 report concluded there was positive potential
benefit from such an approach. Next stage review
pending advice from Strategic Health Authority on
partnership structuring in light of DH guidance on PCT
estate.’
Wye Valley NHS Trust & NHS Herefordshire
19
Project Arkansas (Stage 1)
Context
Acute trust operating from two in-patient hospitals and
multiple outpatient sites leading to inefficiency and
compromising position in wider health economy.
Challenge
Devise and evaluate options for rationalising estate to
help release cost savings and improve operational
efficiency.
Approach
Undertook demographic & travel-time studies and
engaged with sub-contracted specialist healthcare
planners to model clinical activity and assess effects of
alternative estate & service-delivery configurations
using 15-year financial model.
Results
Stage 1 report considering positive, innovative and
radical options alongside more conventional
rationalisation plans welcomed by Trust board and
being taken forward in Stage 2 as part of ‘Shaping the
Future of East Berkshire’
Heatherwood & Wexham Park Hospitals Foundation NHS Trust
20
Estate Strategy Review (Stage 1)
Context
Acute trust operating from three in-patient hospitals
seeking to unlock surplus land to benefit its local
partnerships for education, R&D and other
complementary uses and secure its position in wider
health economy.
Challenge
Thwarted by parliamentary commission from closing an
outpost hospital and with operations split between two
main campuses 1 mile apart, one suffering from poor
road access, the trust was seeking ways to rationalise
its estate.
Approach
We parcelled and appraised the land according to
complementary alternative use potential,
commissioning a traffic management review to unlock
inaccessible areas.
Results
Stage 1 report concluded identified significant
development potential and the ensuing engagement in
UDP consultation has resulted in a flexible development
brief.
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust
[Heart of East] Greenwich Square
21
Context
Acute trust operating from 3 in-patient hospitals.
Former hospital replaced by major PFI on alternative
site. Site sold for redevelopment subject to overage
provisions.
Challenge
Market had changed since development agreement
with HCA and [time-limited] overage provisions in
favour now punitive. HCA made cash offer to buy out
overage provisions to kick-start development
Approach
Liaised with lawyers to assess implications and
reviewed Heart of East Greenwich place-making
development plans, appraised site value relative to
development agreement and modelled alternative
phasing/implementation programmes to increase value.
Results
Delivered successfully against 3-week timescale to
advise Trust board on negotiating strategy.
South London Hospitals Foundation NHS Trust
22
Site Strategy Review
Context
Major educational charity with remote, potentially high
value but highly constrained campus and listed building in
parkland setting adjacent to golf course and executive
housing.
Challenge
Some day facilities on site still appropriate but the
organisation’s modus operandi had changed over time and
providing institutional residential care no longer met best
practice nor it’s clients’ needs. They wanted to explore
ways releasing this restrictive asset to reinvest in modern
non-residential facilities in more urban settings.
Approach
Undertook a detailed appraisal of campus in parcels
considering a range of land use and delivery options that
could let RLSB remain in occupation of operational
facilities during phased withdrawal.
Results
Identified that residential care village development offered
best returns, use of listed building and phased
implementation. Deal now struck with developer/operator.
Royal London Society for Blind People

More Related Content

Similar to Strategic estate planning v2 6

Strategic Estate Planning - case studies
Strategic Estate Planning - case studiesStrategic Estate Planning - case studies
Strategic Estate Planning - case studies
Ambercycle Consulting
 
PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]
PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]
PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]Michael Walton
 
Place north west social housing forum 2011
Place north west social  housing forum 2011Place north west social  housing forum 2011
Place north west social housing forum 2011
Place North West
 
Ebbsfleet Garden City
 Ebbsfleet Garden City Ebbsfleet Garden City
Ebbsfleet Garden City
KentEstates
 
Leeds city region green deal barnsley college
Leeds city region green deal barnsley collegeLeeds city region green deal barnsley college
Leeds city region green deal barnsley collegeScott Buckler
 
Place RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma Inpartnership
Place RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma InpartnershipPlace RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma Inpartnership
Place RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma InpartnershipPlace North West
 
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
jelutharas
 
CV Matt Bodley 2015pdf
CV Matt Bodley 2015pdfCV Matt Bodley 2015pdf
CV Matt Bodley 2015pdfMatthew Bodley
 
CHP Business Plan 2015_16_Summary
CHP Business Plan 2015_16_SummaryCHP Business Plan 2015_16_Summary
CHP Business Plan 2015_16_SummaryJane Batchelor
 
Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...
Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...
Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...
Association for Project Management
 
Funding and Delivering Development and Renewal
Funding and Delivering Development and RenewalFunding and Delivering Development and Renewal
Funding and Delivering Development and Renewal
futureoflondon
 
Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...
Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...
Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...
ACX
 
PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...
PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...
PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...
Institution of Lighting Professionals
 
Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015
Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015
Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015Adrian Taylor
 
CBRE Office Fit Out Track Record Reduced
CBRE Office Fit Out Track Record ReducedCBRE Office Fit Out Track Record Reduced
CBRE Office Fit Out Track Record ReducedNora Vera Jarauta
 
PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...
PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...
PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...
Place North West
 
Development Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds Bank
Development Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds BankDevelopment Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds Bank
Development Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds Bank
Place North West
 
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPDCommunity Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Design South East
 

Similar to Strategic estate planning v2 6 (20)

Strategic Estate Planning - case studies
Strategic Estate Planning - case studiesStrategic Estate Planning - case studies
Strategic Estate Planning - case studies
 
PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]
PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]
PDR Housing estate renewal capability.FINAL[1]
 
Place north west social housing forum 2011
Place north west social  housing forum 2011Place north west social  housing forum 2011
Place north west social housing forum 2011
 
Ebbsfleet Garden City
 Ebbsfleet Garden City Ebbsfleet Garden City
Ebbsfleet Garden City
 
Leeds city region green deal barnsley college
Leeds city region green deal barnsley collegeLeeds city region green deal barnsley college
Leeds city region green deal barnsley college
 
Planning Brochure
Planning BrochurePlanning Brochure
Planning Brochure
 
Place RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma Inpartnership
Place RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma InpartnershipPlace RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma Inpartnership
Place RESI 2014: Duncan Sutherland, Sigma Inpartnership
 
CV - July 15
CV - July 15CV - July 15
CV - July 15
 
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
 
CV Matt Bodley 2015pdf
CV Matt Bodley 2015pdfCV Matt Bodley 2015pdf
CV Matt Bodley 2015pdf
 
CHP Business Plan 2015_16_Summary
CHP Business Plan 2015_16_SummaryCHP Business Plan 2015_16_Summary
CHP Business Plan 2015_16_Summary
 
Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...
Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...
Establishing the Programme Delivery Arrangements for a Major Infrastructure P...
 
Funding and Delivering Development and Renewal
Funding and Delivering Development and RenewalFunding and Delivering Development and Renewal
Funding and Delivering Development and Renewal
 
Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...
Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...
Sizing Renewable Energy Systems for Different Facilities and Translation to C...
 
PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...
PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...
PLS 2018: Interest-free financing for energy efficient Street lighting (Kent ...
 
Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015
Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015
Adrians Job ApplicationRecent 2015
 
CBRE Office Fit Out Track Record Reduced
CBRE Office Fit Out Track Record ReducedCBRE Office Fit Out Track Record Reduced
CBRE Office Fit Out Track Record Reduced
 
PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...
PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...
PlaceEXPO City Region Investment Strategies: Greater Manchester Investment St...
 
Development Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds Bank
Development Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds BankDevelopment Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds Bank
Development Finance Lunch | Glen Wilson, Lloyds Bank
 
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPDCommunity Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
Community Infrastructure Levy- Helen Martin, RTPI West Midlands CPD
 

Recently uploaded

How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!
How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!
How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!
BelgiumManagement
 
The KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing Turkey
The KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing TurkeyThe KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing Turkey
The KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing Turkey
Listing Turkey
 
Optimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better Results
Optimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better ResultsOptimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better Results
Optimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better Results
Lead Generation Media
 
Torun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing Turkey
Torun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing TurkeyTorun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing Turkey
Torun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing Turkey
Listing Turkey
 
Simpolo Company Profile & Corporate Logo
Simpolo Company Profile & Corporate LogoSimpolo Company Profile & Corporate Logo
Simpolo Company Profile & Corporate Logo
simpolosparkteam
 
BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...
BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...
BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...
BrickAndBolt
 
Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24
Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24
Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24
Deutsche EuroShop AG
 
SVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN International Corp.
 
2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.
2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.
2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.
aashiyanastardevelop
 
One FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction Update
One FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction UpdateOne FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction Update
One FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction Update
One FNG
 
Omaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive Guide
Omaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive GuideOmaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive Guide
Omaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive Guide
omaxesportscitydwark
 
Killer Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing Turkey
Killer Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing TurkeyKiller Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing Turkey
Killer Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing Turkey
Listing Turkey
 
Biography and career about Lixin Azarmehr
Biography and career about Lixin AzarmehrBiography and career about Lixin Azarmehr
Biography and career about Lixin Azarmehr
Lixin Azarmehr
 
Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...
Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...
Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...
JagadishKR1
 
Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...
Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...
Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...
JagadishKR1
 
Rixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdf
Rixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdfRixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdf
Rixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdf
Listing Turkey
 
Riverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune Brochure
Riverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune BrochureRiverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune Brochure
Riverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune Brochure
kishor21012022
 
How to keep your Home naturally Cool and Warm
How to keep your Home naturally Cool and WarmHow to keep your Home naturally Cool and Warm
How to keep your Home naturally Cool and Warm
Vinra Construction
 
Architectural & Interior design portfolio.pdf
Architectural & Interior design portfolio.pdfArchitectural & Interior design portfolio.pdf
Architectural & Interior design portfolio.pdf
susantebinum
 
Brigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdf
Brigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdfBrigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdf
Brigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdf
SachinChauhan191
 

Recently uploaded (20)

How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!
How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!
How to Scan Tenants in NYC - You Should Know!
 
The KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing Turkey
The KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing TurkeyThe KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing Turkey
The KA Housing - Catalogue - Listing Turkey
 
Optimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better Results
Optimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better ResultsOptimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better Results
Optimizing Your MCA Lead Capture Process for Better Results
 
Torun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing Turkey
Torun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing TurkeyTorun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing Turkey
Torun Center Residences Istanbul - Listing Turkey
 
Simpolo Company Profile & Corporate Logo
Simpolo Company Profile & Corporate LogoSimpolo Company Profile & Corporate Logo
Simpolo Company Profile & Corporate Logo
 
BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...
BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...
BricknBolt Understanding Load-Bearing Walls and Their Structural Support in H...
 
Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24
Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24
Deutsche EuroShop | Company Presentation | 06/24
 
SVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 6.3.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
 
2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.
2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.
2BHK-3BHK NEW FLAT FOR SALE IN TUPUDANA,RANCHI.
 
One FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction Update
One FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction UpdateOne FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction Update
One FNG by Group 108 Sector 142 Noida Construction Update
 
Omaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive Guide
Omaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive GuideOmaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive Guide
Omaxe Sports City Dwarka A Comprehensive Guide
 
Killer Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing Turkey
Killer Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing TurkeyKiller Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing Turkey
Killer Referans Bahcesehir Catalog Listing Turkey
 
Biography and career about Lixin Azarmehr
Biography and career about Lixin AzarmehrBiography and career about Lixin Azarmehr
Biography and career about Lixin Azarmehr
 
Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...
Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...
Urbanrise Paradise on Earth - Unveiling Unprecedented Luxury in Exquisite Vil...
 
Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...
Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...
Elegant Evergreen Homes - Luxury Apartments Redefining Comfort in Yelahanka, ...
 
Rixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdf
Rixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdfRixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdf
Rixos Tersane Istanbul Residences Brochure_May2024_ENG.pdf
 
Riverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune Brochure
Riverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune BrochureRiverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune Brochure
Riverview City Loni Kalbhor Pune Brochure
 
How to keep your Home naturally Cool and Warm
How to keep your Home naturally Cool and WarmHow to keep your Home naturally Cool and Warm
How to keep your Home naturally Cool and Warm
 
Architectural & Interior design portfolio.pdf
Architectural & Interior design portfolio.pdfArchitectural & Interior design portfolio.pdf
Architectural & Interior design portfolio.pdf
 
Brigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdf
Brigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdfBrigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdf
Brigade Insignia at Yelahanka Brochure.pdf
 

Strategic estate planning v2 6

  • 1. Strategic Estate Planning Development & Healthcare Case Studies Lester Wagman
  • 2. 2 NHS Cavell Centre We are currently advising Spelthorne Borough Council on the development of one of the new integrated multi-disciplinary Cavell centres as mart of an exciting mixed-use town centre regeneration scheme • Appraisal of development potential • Negotiation of capital values best value advice • Structuring of lease and development agreements • Asset management of completed scheme Staines, Middlesex
  • 3. 3 Integrated Health Care Centre We are currently advising the private landlord of a large modern integrated healthcare centre in North East London, originally constructed under NHS LIFT and leased to the NHS on a Lease+ • Liaison with NHS occupiers and head tenant NHS Property Services • Co-ordination of life-cycle repairs to the building • Financially modelling different options for asset disposal • Negotiations with NHS around lease restructure to support longer term operational viability Ilford, Essex
  • 4. 4 Pre-disposal – Housing Amenity Land Working with Rona London we are currently advising Enfield Council on the disposal of a number of small land parcels from their Housing Revenue Account • Liaison with tenants, homeowners and Council team • Advice on values and conditions for disposal • Consideration of wider asset management opportunities • Advice on tenure and protective covenants Enfield
  • 5. 5 Primary Healthcare Developments In 2020 we are advising public and private sector landowner and developer clients on the creation of 5 separate new NHS primary care hubs. The context and brief is different in each case but all projects involve • Appraisal of development potential • Negotiation of rental values and support through business case process • Structuring of lease and development agreements • Valuation and/or forward sale of completed asset Croydon, West Sussex, Milton Keynes, Oxfordshire
  • 6. 6 Primary Healthcare Business Case We authored the CCG’s combined outline and full business case (FBC) for the development and fit of a new 1,181 sq.m integrated health and wellness centre, forming part of Poplar HARCA’s regeneration of the Aberfeldy estate. The new centre is a cornerstone of the WellOne intiative, part of the NHS Five Year Forward View, to meet needs of a local population with high levels of deprivation which is forecast to double by 2040. The premises will be leased to the NHS healthcare practice and the £3.5m fit out will be largely funded by developers’ s.106 contributions from other schemes in the locality. Aberfeldy New Village, Poplar, East London
  • 7. 7 Land option & development agreement In 2020 we advised three individual co-owners of approx. 1.5 acres of land adjoining a major development site for 500 homes adjacent to a junction on a major arterial route. However as well as having no rights of access the land in question had been designated as greenbelt in the local authority’s recent plan review. With two of the owners being past retirement age they wished to realise the optimum value for their asset. Having approached a number of promoter-developers none of whom were keen to commit much early capital we persuaded the owners of the adjoining development to pay a significant fee/premium for a leasehold development agreement with future value-sharing agreed and final freehold acquisition option. Working closely with the lawyers the resulting arrangement proved tax efficient for both the vendors’ IHT planning and the developer's future CGT liability. Hillingdon, West London
  • 8. 8 Development Consultancy Context Barnet Enfield & Haringey Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust had declared the property surplus to operational requirements. Haringey Council wished to acquire the site for a local public service project. Challenge To support local services the Trust wished to transfer the property to the Council for market value in a solus transaction without a full market externalisation process. The agreed transfer cost needed to be supported by 2 concurring professional valuations. The Council benefited from an historic title covenant restricting the use of the property. Approach Having undertaken our own valuation we negotiated with DVS for them to take adequate account of the effect of the covenant. Results Successfully negotiated a substantial capital receipt for the Trust within tight timescale Canning Crescent Centre – Wood Green
  • 9. 9 Estate Development Strategy Context This busy acute and community Trust in a densely populated area sought to reconfigure and modernise its estate to support the vital role it had carved out for itself in the local health economy. Challenge Although residential property values in Croydon are not as strong as other parts of the capital this site fronts a main arterial close to a large commercial centre and main transport connections. Approach We worked with master planners to quantify and optimise development opportunity from parcelling land for disposal. This work has supported the development of the Trust’s main site Development Control Plan which involves the construction of a multi-storey car park and relocation of its existing maternity wing as enabling development. Results Successfully re-planned site to inform estate strategy options. Croydon Health Services NHS Foundation Trust
  • 10. 10 Site Strategy Context Following the transfer of some teaching activities to its new Colindale campus the College was looking to rationalise its activities at Southgate with a view to releasing land to generate capital. Challenge Site constraints included main access to the site shared with local public library site (also surplus for development), a very narrow secondary access to the site, part shared access with local Royal Mail depot and sorting office and underground railway (Piccadilly Line) passing under part of the site at shallow depth. Approach We worked with the College’s master planners to devise and appraise alternative use development options for three different parcels of land including one for high density student housing Results Successfully re-planned site to inform estate strategy options. Barnet & Southgate College – Southgate Campus
  • 11. 11 Development Consultancy Context The College had previously agreed to sell surplus land from its new campus in Colindale, London NW9, to a major house builder. Its original agreement with the developer included a substantial overage provision but despite there having been significant house price growth, the property market had since stalled/cooled. Challenge The developer was looking to crystallise and make an early settlement of its overage liability to offset this for tax against large surpluses it had made in that financial year. Approach We undertook a detailed analysis of the developer's construction programme, plotting this against projected indices for house price growth with varying confidence intervals. Results Successfully negotiated a substantial capital payment for the college. Barnet & Southgate College – Colindale Campus
  • 12. 12 Building Utilisation Review Context To inform bids under the NHS Estates & Infrastructure Transformation Fund, CHP commissioned utilisation reviews of a large number of primary care practices in North Central London. Working under sub contract from Capita Property & Infrastructure, Ambercycle undertook the surveys and analysed the data. Challenge To design a generic survey for a variety of premises types offering a wide range of services that would help identify underutilisation/capacity and provide useful data to help inform strategic estate planning. Not all practices were keen to participate so there were logistical challenges too. Approach The survey, undertaken on site but consultatively with practice staff, examined utilisation by room type and service from 8am-8pm over a 7-day week in 1-hour sessions. Results Successfully surveyed 78 primary care premises over 10 week period. Undertook analysis of over 10,000 data records and provided reports at practice, borough/CCG and sub-regional levels. Community Health Partnerships
  • 13. 13 Feasibility Study – Bingfield Context The CCG commissions a wide range of healthcare services across one of inner London’s most socially diverse boroughs, with large areas of deprivation and some regeneration. Challenge Committed to one of the most expensive and underutilised LIFT assets in a socially deprived area of inner London, the CCG sought ideas to revitalise the building and improve recovery of costs. Approach Having carried out a detailed utilisation review and examination of the building layout we identified opportunities to convert two large offices and a meeting room into six multi-service, bookable consulting rooms and entered dialogue with range of local healthcare service providers to use them. Results A detailed report and business case to support the capital funding application (ETTF) for the works. Negotiations commenced with landlord and service providers. NHS Islington CCG
  • 14. 14 Feasibility Study - Archway Context The CCG commissions a wide range of healthcare services across one of inner London’s most socially diverse boroughs, with large areas of deprivation and some regeneration. Challenge The CCG, working closely with Islington Council sought to integrate and replace and a poorly accessible primary care practice with poor quality premises together with a new library as part of a regeneration scheme in a landmark location. Approach We led negotiations with the developer and brokered dialogue with the council to act as lead tenant and secure a workable building envelope for an integrated facility with adequate means of access and circulation and a floor plate that could deliver a flexible model. Results Negotiations are ongoing but Stage 1 report concluded there was positive potential benefit from such an approach. Next stage will be to finalise the development agreement and terms of occupation. NHS Islington CCG
  • 15. 15 Estate Consultancy Context The CCG commissions a wide range of healthcare services across London’s most populous borough, with one of the highest retired cohorts and some areas of deprivation and regeneration. Challenge The organisation was financially stretched and one of the greatest challenges it faced was to meet liabilities for subsidies in expensive [LIFT] buildings and cover the cost of void areas. Approach Working under sub contract from Carter Jonas, we worked with Community Health Partnerships and NHS Property Services to renegotiate costs and with a range of other healthcare providers and stakeholders to devise a more robust local estate strategy. Results Secured annual recurrent savings of £4m, played a key role in Barnet Council’s One public Estate 3 bid [£350m], resolved local estate management issues and laid foundations for a healthier NHS estate. NHS Barnet CCG
  • 16. 16 The Forum Context Cambridge University Hospital Partners’ 2020 vision is already becoming reality for the development of the Addenbrookes site into the Cambridge Biomedical Park with the arrival of the UK Medical Research Council and the new Papworth Hospital due to open in 2016. Challenge CUH were seeking an innovative solution for an integrated commercial hub for the site providing retail, hotel & conferencing facilities, a learning hub, private patient centre and car parking. Approach Ambercycle played an important part in John Laing’s bid team for the project, helping to balance the Trust’s needs and aspirations with those of prospective commercial funding partners. Results A lease structure able to support an institutional forward funding approach while adapting to mixed- risk income streams from different elements of the scheme. John Laing selected as preferred partner. John Laing Plc & Cambridge University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
  • 17. Lucille van Geest MH Unit 17 Peterborough & Stamford Hospitals Foundation NHS Trust Context Trust had relocated to new PFI at Bretton. Peterborough District Hospital site mainly surplus and Trust planning development partnership to optimise value. Challenge Cambridgeshire Partnership Trust (MH) occupied LVG day centre and in-patient unit and other offices on site under separate long- term leases. Services could not be relocated without consulting with the Trust, service users and families. Approach We worked with the service providers to assess different options for providing the service in different ways and timescales for site withdrawal. We also assessed the financial cost of reprovision and identified ways to mitigate the impact on our client. Results We worked with the client to identify part of the Bretton hospital site, release the Trust from an option agreement and negotiate access from the PFI provider.
  • 18. 18 Estate Solutions Review (Stage 1) Context Acute trust, PCT & County Council with diverse and disparate asset holdings (incl. a major hospital PFI) working together to secure provision of locally managed, joined-up services. Challenge The trusts and council wanted to explore ways releasing efficiency savings and optimising capital returns from the estate to fund joint service improvements. Approach Undertook first stage investigation and financial modelling of land value potential & profit-sharing from development of trust estate using an asset- backed joint venture structure. Results Stage 1 report concluded there was positive potential benefit from such an approach. Next stage review pending advice from Strategic Health Authority on partnership structuring in light of DH guidance on PCT estate.’ Wye Valley NHS Trust & NHS Herefordshire
  • 19. 19 Project Arkansas (Stage 1) Context Acute trust operating from two in-patient hospitals and multiple outpatient sites leading to inefficiency and compromising position in wider health economy. Challenge Devise and evaluate options for rationalising estate to help release cost savings and improve operational efficiency. Approach Undertook demographic & travel-time studies and engaged with sub-contracted specialist healthcare planners to model clinical activity and assess effects of alternative estate & service-delivery configurations using 15-year financial model. Results Stage 1 report considering positive, innovative and radical options alongside more conventional rationalisation plans welcomed by Trust board and being taken forward in Stage 2 as part of ‘Shaping the Future of East Berkshire’ Heatherwood & Wexham Park Hospitals Foundation NHS Trust
  • 20. 20 Estate Strategy Review (Stage 1) Context Acute trust operating from three in-patient hospitals seeking to unlock surplus land to benefit its local partnerships for education, R&D and other complementary uses and secure its position in wider health economy. Challenge Thwarted by parliamentary commission from closing an outpost hospital and with operations split between two main campuses 1 mile apart, one suffering from poor road access, the trust was seeking ways to rationalise its estate. Approach We parcelled and appraised the land according to complementary alternative use potential, commissioning a traffic management review to unlock inaccessible areas. Results Stage 1 report concluded identified significant development potential and the ensuing engagement in UDP consultation has resulted in a flexible development brief. Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust
  • 21. [Heart of East] Greenwich Square 21 Context Acute trust operating from 3 in-patient hospitals. Former hospital replaced by major PFI on alternative site. Site sold for redevelopment subject to overage provisions. Challenge Market had changed since development agreement with HCA and [time-limited] overage provisions in favour now punitive. HCA made cash offer to buy out overage provisions to kick-start development Approach Liaised with lawyers to assess implications and reviewed Heart of East Greenwich place-making development plans, appraised site value relative to development agreement and modelled alternative phasing/implementation programmes to increase value. Results Delivered successfully against 3-week timescale to advise Trust board on negotiating strategy. South London Hospitals Foundation NHS Trust
  • 22. 22 Site Strategy Review Context Major educational charity with remote, potentially high value but highly constrained campus and listed building in parkland setting adjacent to golf course and executive housing. Challenge Some day facilities on site still appropriate but the organisation’s modus operandi had changed over time and providing institutional residential care no longer met best practice nor it’s clients’ needs. They wanted to explore ways releasing this restrictive asset to reinvest in modern non-residential facilities in more urban settings. Approach Undertook a detailed appraisal of campus in parcels considering a range of land use and delivery options that could let RLSB remain in occupation of operational facilities during phased withdrawal. Results Identified that residential care village development offered best returns, use of listed building and phased implementation. Deal now struck with developer/operator. Royal London Society for Blind People