SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
Using Blogs to Teach Source Citation
as a Rhetorical Act
Elizabeth Kleinfeld
Metropolitan State University of Denver
ekleinfe@msudenver.edu
Slides are at http://www.slideshare.net/lizkleinfeld
When we focus on
• what sources do,
• what we do when we cite them, and
• what source citations themselves do
the conversation shifts from “here
is the template for a works cited
entry” to “How does this source
citation direct readers’ attention?”
and “How does this source citation
reflect upon the author?”
source citation =
“cover your ass” move
source citation =
“cover your ass” move
Barbara Fister
“When our students are distracted by arcane
citation rules, when they spend more time creating
a list of works cited than they do composing a
paper, they won’t be inspired to see themselves as
people who can make meaning. Instead, they will
focus on avoiding punishment by carefully
describing the containers of other people’s ideas.
They’ll miss the whole point.”
By shifting the question from “how am I
supposed to cite this source?” to “what
happens when I cite this source in a
particular way?”, we can move our students
(and ourselves) from a CYA attitude toward
source citation to one in which source
citation is seen as
epistemic, situated, contingent, and
interactional.
• Experiments in Lifestyle Design
http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/
• We Make Money Not Art
http://we-make-money-not-art.com/
• Salty Running
http://www.saltyrunning.com/
Experiments in Lifestyle Design
We Make Money Not Art
Salty Running
Read 3-5 entries from each blog, then
answer the following questions:
1. How does the blogger signal to you, the reader, that source
material is being referred to?
2. What types of sources does the blogger cite?
3. To what degree does the blogger rely on paraphrase, summary, and
quotation?
4. What does the blogger do with those sources? Elaborate on the
source material? Interpret the source material? Something else?
5. How do the citations make you feel toward the source material?
For example, do you feel invited to go to the source material?
6. How do the citations make you feel toward the blogger? Do you
feel close or distant?
7. Describe the blogger’s voice. How do the citations contribute to the
blogger’s voice?
8. How does the blogger come across
(serious, trustworthy, goofy, etc.)? How do the citations contribute
to this impression?

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (20)

Blog Como Herramienta Pedagogica
Blog Como Herramienta PedagogicaBlog Como Herramienta Pedagogica
Blog Como Herramienta Pedagogica
 
07ppt gestión del marketing y rrhh (1)
07ppt gestión del marketing y rrhh (1)07ppt gestión del marketing y rrhh (1)
07ppt gestión del marketing y rrhh (1)
 
Table quiz ppt
Table quiz pptTable quiz ppt
Table quiz ppt
 
2008 Geography Projects
2008 Geography Projects2008 Geography Projects
2008 Geography Projects
 
LET PR
LET PRLET PR
LET PR
 
Día Mundial del Agua (Angela Lenzi) .
Día Mundial del Agua (Angela Lenzi) .Día Mundial del Agua (Angela Lenzi) .
Día Mundial del Agua (Angela Lenzi) .
 
Time Bomb Magazine Cover
Time Bomb Magazine CoverTime Bomb Magazine Cover
Time Bomb Magazine Cover
 
Rock
RockRock
Rock
 
Motivación 1
Motivación 1Motivación 1
Motivación 1
 
Seminarium 12
Seminarium 12Seminarium 12
Seminarium 12
 
Hockey
HockeyHockey
Hockey
 
Redes sociales version final mejorada
Redes sociales version final mejoradaRedes sociales version final mejorada
Redes sociales version final mejorada
 
Zákonomat na #projektovatastavet
Zákonomat  na #projektovatastavetZákonomat  na #projektovatastavet
Zákonomat na #projektovatastavet
 
Zpráva o konání dobra na českém internetu (Czech Internet Forum 2012)
Zpráva o konání dobra na českém internetu (Czech Internet Forum 2012)Zpráva o konání dobra na českém internetu (Czech Internet Forum 2012)
Zpráva o konání dobra na českém internetu (Czech Internet Forum 2012)
 
Ppt pres
Ppt presPpt pres
Ppt pres
 
Quarentenário iac e os transgênicos syngenta 2012
Quarentenário iac e os transgênicos   syngenta 2012Quarentenário iac e os transgênicos   syngenta 2012
Quarentenário iac e os transgênicos syngenta 2012
 
RHS Laptops Rollout Presentation
RHS Laptops Rollout PresentationRHS Laptops Rollout Presentation
RHS Laptops Rollout Presentation
 
Bez tytułu 1
Bez tytułu 1Bez tytułu 1
Bez tytułu 1
 
T10 ilustración infantil
T10 ilustración infantilT10 ilustración infantil
T10 ilustración infantil
 
NuVal
NuValNuVal
NuVal
 

Similar to Using Blogs to Teach Source Citation as a Rhetorical Act

RMMLA: Teach Source Citation as Rhetorical
RMMLA: Teach Source Citation as RhetoricalRMMLA: Teach Source Citation as Rhetorical
RMMLA: Teach Source Citation as RhetoricalElizabeth Kleinfeld
 
Citing evidence
Citing evidenceCiting evidence
Citing evidencessinger05
 
Annotated Bibliographies
Annotated BibliographiesAnnotated Bibliographies
Annotated Bibliographieskhornberger
 
Doing a literature review
Doing a literature reviewDoing a literature review
Doing a literature reviewMarcus Leaning
 
Referencing made easy
Referencing made easy Referencing made easy
Referencing made easy makeyes
 
Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...
Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...
Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...The Language Centre at Queen's
 
Plagiarism
PlagiarismPlagiarism
Plagiarismcorndogs
 
What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses
What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses
What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses Holly Singleton
 
Active ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docx
Active ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docxActive ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docx
Active ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docxAMMY30
 
Task Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docx
Task Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docxTask Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docx
Task Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docxjosies1
 
Amy Vailwebquest Template0
Amy Vailwebquest Template0Amy Vailwebquest Template0
Amy Vailwebquest Template0avail
 
Essay #1Taking a Position on Food Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docx
Essay #1Taking a Position on Food  Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docxEssay #1Taking a Position on Food  Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docx
Essay #1Taking a Position on Food Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docxSALU18
 
Outline 1 Outline Student Name C.docx
Outline     1 Outline Student Name C.docxOutline     1 Outline Student Name C.docx
Outline 1 Outline Student Name C.docxgerardkortney
 
Using quotations effectively
Using quotations effectivelyUsing quotations effectively
Using quotations effectivelyvlequire
 
Annotated works cited explain
Annotated works cited explainAnnotated works cited explain
Annotated works cited explainDorothy Minor
 

Similar to Using Blogs to Teach Source Citation as a Rhetorical Act (19)

RMMLA: Teach Source Citation as Rhetorical
RMMLA: Teach Source Citation as RhetoricalRMMLA: Teach Source Citation as Rhetorical
RMMLA: Teach Source Citation as Rhetorical
 
Citing evidence
Citing evidenceCiting evidence
Citing evidence
 
Annotated Bibliographies
Annotated BibliographiesAnnotated Bibliographies
Annotated Bibliographies
 
Using sources
Using sourcesUsing sources
Using sources
 
Doing a literature review
Doing a literature reviewDoing a literature review
Doing a literature review
 
Referencing made easy
Referencing made easy Referencing made easy
Referencing made easy
 
Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...
Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...
Common questions arising from Chinese postgraduates in writing a reasearch pr...
 
Citation
CitationCitation
Citation
 
Plagiarism
PlagiarismPlagiarism
Plagiarism
 
What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses
What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses
What is an annotated bibliography? For student nurses
 
Citation 101
Citation 101Citation 101
Citation 101
 
Active ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docx
Active ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docxActive ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docx
Active ReadingWhy Good Readers Make Better Writers.by An.docx
 
Task Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docx
Task Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docxTask Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docx
Task Your task is to follow a conversation in society right now .docx
 
Amy Vailwebquest Template0
Amy Vailwebquest Template0Amy Vailwebquest Template0
Amy Vailwebquest Template0
 
Essay #1Taking a Position on Food Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docx
Essay #1Taking a Position on Food  Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docxEssay #1Taking a Position on Food  Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docx
Essay #1Taking a Position on Food Due by 1159pm on Sunday.docx
 
Outline 1 Outline Student Name C.docx
Outline     1 Outline Student Name C.docxOutline     1 Outline Student Name C.docx
Outline 1 Outline Student Name C.docx
 
Using quotations effectively
Using quotations effectivelyUsing quotations effectively
Using quotations effectively
 
Annotated works cited explain
Annotated works cited explainAnnotated works cited explain
Annotated works cited explain
 
bblio
bbliobblio
bblio
 

More from Elizabeth Kleinfeld

Building Community across Constituent Groups with Evernote
Building Community across Constituent Groups with EvernoteBuilding Community across Constituent Groups with Evernote
Building Community across Constituent Groups with EvernoteElizabeth Kleinfeld
 
Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...
Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...
Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...Elizabeth Kleinfeld
 
From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...
From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...
From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...Elizabeth Kleinfeld
 

More from Elizabeth Kleinfeld (7)

Building Community across Constituent Groups with Evernote
Building Community across Constituent Groups with EvernoteBuilding Community across Constituent Groups with Evernote
Building Community across Constituent Groups with Evernote
 
Slides 4 cs 3 15-14 ab
Slides 4 cs 3 15-14 abSlides 4 cs 3 15-14 ab
Slides 4 cs 3 15-14 ab
 
Slides 4 cs 3 10-14
Slides 4 cs 3 10-14Slides 4 cs 3 10-14
Slides 4 cs 3 10-14
 
Cccc2014presentation
Cccc2014presentationCccc2014presentation
Cccc2014presentation
 
Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...
Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...
Making Your Courses Accessible: Best Practices For Creating an Inclusive Lear...
 
From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...
From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...
From Citation Consumer to Citation Producer: Working with Students on Source ...
 
Next Generation Writing Center
Next Generation Writing CenterNext Generation Writing Center
Next Generation Writing Center
 

Using Blogs to Teach Source Citation as a Rhetorical Act

  • 1. Using Blogs to Teach Source Citation as a Rhetorical Act Elizabeth Kleinfeld Metropolitan State University of Denver ekleinfe@msudenver.edu Slides are at http://www.slideshare.net/lizkleinfeld
  • 2.
  • 3. When we focus on • what sources do, • what we do when we cite them, and • what source citations themselves do
  • 4. the conversation shifts from “here is the template for a works cited entry” to “How does this source citation direct readers’ attention?” and “How does this source citation reflect upon the author?”
  • 5. source citation = “cover your ass” move
  • 6. source citation = “cover your ass” move
  • 7. Barbara Fister “When our students are distracted by arcane citation rules, when they spend more time creating a list of works cited than they do composing a paper, they won’t be inspired to see themselves as people who can make meaning. Instead, they will focus on avoiding punishment by carefully describing the containers of other people’s ideas. They’ll miss the whole point.”
  • 8. By shifting the question from “how am I supposed to cite this source?” to “what happens when I cite this source in a particular way?”, we can move our students (and ourselves) from a CYA attitude toward source citation to one in which source citation is seen as epistemic, situated, contingent, and interactional.
  • 9. • Experiments in Lifestyle Design http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/ • We Make Money Not Art http://we-make-money-not-art.com/ • Salty Running http://www.saltyrunning.com/
  • 11. We Make Money Not Art
  • 13. Read 3-5 entries from each blog, then answer the following questions: 1. How does the blogger signal to you, the reader, that source material is being referred to? 2. What types of sources does the blogger cite? 3. To what degree does the blogger rely on paraphrase, summary, and quotation? 4. What does the blogger do with those sources? Elaborate on the source material? Interpret the source material? Something else? 5. How do the citations make you feel toward the source material? For example, do you feel invited to go to the source material? 6. How do the citations make you feel toward the blogger? Do you feel close or distant? 7. Describe the blogger’s voice. How do the citations contribute to the blogger’s voice? 8. How does the blogger come across (serious, trustworthy, goofy, etc.)? How do the citations contribute to this impression?