SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 19-26 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
19 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
Rapid Review of Social Protection; a
Gender Perspective
Joyce Maina
St. Pauls University
Type of the Paper: Research Paper.
Type of Review: Peer Reviewed.
Indexed in: worldwide web.
Google Scholar Citation: AIJMR
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR)
A Refereed International Journal of OIRC JOURNALS.
© OIRC JOURNALS.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 4.0
International License subject to proper citation to the publication source of the work.
Disclaimer: The scholarly papers as reviewed and published by the OIRC JOURNALS, are
the views and opinions of their respective authors and are not the views or opinions of the
OIRC.
How to Cite this Paper:
Maina, J. (2018). Rapid Review of Social Protection; a Gender Perspective. Africa
International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR), 2 (6), 19-26.
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
20 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
Rapid Review of Social Protection; a Gender
Perspective
Joyce Maina
St. Pauls University
Abstract
This rapid assessment examines the literature
on social protection to determine the gender
considerations made in social protection
research and the gendered areas of future
research in the field. This review was
conducted between May and August 2018.
Electronic databases were searched to identify
records that were published in English
between the period of 2008 and 2018. Studies were eligible for inclusion if they were empirical and had both the
search terms ‘social’ and ‘protection’ or their various combinations, appearing in the titles of the articles. Grey
literature, reports and other non-academic writings were excluded as only empirical studies were eligible. Twelve
studies were reviewed and synthesised. The results of this study show that social protection research makes gender
considerations and most of the social protection interventions were protective, preventive or promotive measures.
Future studies should therefore explore transformative social protection with respect to gender equality and partly
because gendered social protection is poorly developed. This rapid review also affirms that despite criticisms,
social protection continues to be valuable in addressing poverty and inequalities. However, against this backdrop
it is worth noting that social protection is not a panacea and its gender considerations are necessary only to the
extent that they do not exacerbate inequalities.
1.0 Introduction
Although many of the articles studied in this
literature review hardly provide concrete definitions
and conceptual underpinnings of social protection, it
is important as a first step to establish the meaning
of the subject of this rapid review in order to
determine the scope of this exercise. As with the
term development to which social protection is
closely associated, there appears to be no consensus
in literature on how to define the subject but the two
attempts that are commonly fronted consider social
protection to be an ‘action’ (Norton et al., 2001) and
‘initiative’ (Devereux and Sabates-Wheeler 2004).
Central to the different definitions of social
protection is an intention to respond to deprivation
in poor, vulnerable and marginalized populations in
which women with respect to gender are sometimes
disproportionately represented.
The gendered vulnerabilities faced by girls for
example dropping out of school, early marriages and
child bearing have serious ramifications on their
future although adolescent boys are also predisposed
to unique challenges (Cluver et al., 2016). Women
on the other hand are often limited by their primary
care giving responsibilities, domestic work as well
as cultural restrictions; and since they often tend to
be concentrated in the informal sectors, they are
predisposed to particular health risks (Namsomboon
and Kusakabe 2011), insecure employment and are
therefore less likely to save and contribute to
pension schemes. Consequently, social security
systems particularly in developing countries
therefore often comprise a male dominated section
of the workforce in formal state and private sector
and some studies in evaluating enrolment in West
Africa have made recommendations for fees to be
eliminated and more elderly women to be enrolled
into social health protection schemes (Parmar et al.,
2014). This is particularly important because
women’s vulnerabilities are further compounded by
the fact that across the world, they live longer than
men, are at risk of widowhood, greater poverty and
insecurity.
There are a number of strategies that are used to
address these gendered forms of vulnerability in
social protection. The life cycle approach can lead to
giants in equity and poverty reduction by targeting
adolescents (Cluver et al., 2016); women in
childbearing (Rosenberg et al., 2015); the elderly
(Parmar et al., 2014) and other gender specific
categories that are related to household economic
risks, social exclusion, health risks (Richardson et
ARTICLE INFO
Received 1st September, 2018
Received in Revised Form 26th October, 2018
Accepted 1st November, 2018
Published online 11th November 2018
Key words: Social Protection, Gender, Rapid Review,
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
21 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
al., 2017; Mendola, 2017). Gender strategies
towards equity on the other hand usually involve
gender-mainstreaming and gender specific actions.
In social protection programs this may include
decisions to transfer grants to selected gender often
women to stimulate investments and ensure better
distribution of resources within the household as is
the case in Child Support Grant in South Africa that
is evaluated by two articles in this review
(Rosenberg et al., 2015; Cluver et al., 2016). While
the merits and demerits have been debated, even
informal social protection strategies gravitate
towards this gender approach as evidenced by
migrant women within their family transnational
networks, show solidarity to ensure that money
intended for supporting family or meeting specific
needs is used for the intended purposed (Lafleur and
Romero, 2018). This gendered social protection
strategies confirm that socio-economic risks and
vulnerabilities are inherently influenced by gender
relations and reflected in the different coping
mechanisms that are selected (Domingo et al.,
2015). It is also worth noting that the range of social
protection instruments have specific gender related
risks and impact (Kabeer, 2008).
2.0 Literature Review
A total number of 189 records were identified from
these electronic databases and 20 records from other
sources. After the duplicates records were removed
there remained 164 records for screening of which
102 records were excluded as they comprised of
grey literature, theses, essays and other unpublished
materials. The manuscripts assessed further for
eligibility were 61 and of these 39 were excluded
because they were non-empirical studies. The
manuscripts eligible for the review were 22 of which
12 were included in this rapid review as preliminary
findings.
Description of the Studies
Some of the studies were conducted in Africa (n=5)
among which two were from South Africa while
none were conducted in North or East Africa
(Parmar et al., 2014; Rosenberg et al., 2015; Cluver
et al., 2016; Mendola, 2017; Richardson et al. 2017).
Other studies that were reviewed originated from
Europe (Netoiu and Carstina, 2014; Loopstra et al.,
2016; Lafleur and Romero, 2018) and (n=3) from
Asia (Namsomboon and Kusakabe 2011; Annear et
al., 2013; Kosec and Mo, 2017). There were also
studies that were conducted in more than one
country for instance in Senegal and Ghana (Parmar
et al., 2014) and in Belgium, Colombia and Peru
(Lafleur and Romero, 2018). Few studies among
those that were analysed were designed to have
mixed methodologies (Namsomboon and Kusakabe,
2011; Annear et al., 2013, Richardson et al., 2017)
and only one was purely qualitative (Lafleur and
Romero, 2018). Most of the other studies (n=8),
applied a quantitative methodology and were
designed as quasi-experiments (Parmar et al., 2014;
Rosenberg et al., 2015; Cluver et al., 2016; Loopstra
et al., 2016; Kosec and Mo, 2017; Mendola, 2017;
Richardson et al., 2017).
Gender Considerations in Social Protection
Research
A gender perspective was introduced in some of
studies (n=2) assessed in this rapid review by
targeting women as the research participants. In one
of these studies conducted in South Africa, the
researchers sort to establish the relationship between
social protection programs and fertility because the
incentive and income effects of the two were
unknown. The authors investigated the potential for
the Child Support Grant (a form of cash transfer
program) to incentivize second pregnancy rates
(Rosenberg et al., 2015). A total of 4845 women
responded to this study, reporting on whether or not
they were recipients to the Child Support Grants as
well as pregnant specific information for recently or
currently pregnant women. The other study that
targeted women as research participants was
conducted in Bangkok to determine how the
Kingdom’s universal healthcare responded to the
needs of women home workers because the
information of this new social protection program in
Thailand, was lacking (Namsomboon and
Kusakabe, 2011). A total of 415 women home
workers drawn from 76 communities and across 16
out of the 29 districts of Bangkok, participated in the
study that identified the reasons why women home
workers do not use the universal healthcare scheme
and how they access their healthcare.
Although it was not the subject of the remaining
studies (n=10) some researchers considered gender
in their research designs. In a study concerning
immigrants’ social protection with regards to their
access to health, Lafleur and Romero (2018)
selected participants through a snowballing
technique in various immigrant entry points in
Brussels and as part of their recruitment strategy
they contacted female migrants first. This is because
they argued that women tend to be the majority
Peruvians and Colombians in Brussels and of greater
significance to the study, are concerned over their
access to social protection as well as that of their
families. Some of the other remaining studies (n=5)
applied gender as a core variable to disaggregate
their analysis of whether the elderly are aware of and
enrolling into social health protection schemes in
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
22 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
West Africa (Parmar et al., 2014); whether the
provision of social protection can impact 17
indicators of five key health related Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs) among adolescent in
South Africa (Cluver et al., 2016); the role of social
protection in restoring and raising citizen aspirations
following shocks such as natural disasters (Kosec
and Mo, 2017); examining the extent to which
dispatching family labour abroad is a source of
informal social protection for households left behind
(Mendola, 2017); and evaluating of the impact of
social protection on the wellbeing of the Ebola
survivor (Richardson et al. 2017).
Gendered Areas of Future Studies in Social
Protection
In their investigation of whether social protection
programs issuing cash transfers to caregivers
influenced fertility, Rosenberg et al., (2015), found
that second pregnancy rates were significantly
longer among recipients of the grant than non-
recipients, and it was suggested that the associated
economic independence could result in decreased
transactional sex, improved agency for the women
or through job prospects and education, increased
opportunity costs of pregnancy and motherhood.
However a qualitative study is necessary to establish
the reasons underlying these findings as well as the
lack of association between loss of the child support
grant and pregnancy incidence. Although the study
essentially established that cash transfers do not
incentivize pregnancy, the authors recommended
further investigation into the CSG program to find
out whether the grants incentivize the first
pregnancy instead, and more broadly, the unplanned
outcomes of social protection programs. On the
other hand, Namsomboon and Kusakabe’s (2011)
study of women home workers established that less
than half the respondents accessed Thailand’s
Universal Healthcare Scheme. It was found that
contract workers caring for children had difficulty
balancing work deadlines; household
responsibilities as well as care demands and that
financial constraints, also limited the women’s
access to government provided health services.
These two authors made several programmatic
recommendations, and in relation to gendered social
protection research they suggested that future
studies should assess the impact of strengthening
gender norms which in the Thai setting delineates
care work as women’s work.
Cluver et al., (2016) found that social protection was
associated with significant adolescent risk reduction
in twelve out of the seventeen gender disaggregated
SDG indicators, while in six out of the seventeen
indicators, combined forms of social protection
(cash and care through psychosocial support to
adolescents) showed enhanced risk reduction
effects. With respect to the significance of gender, it
was found that the effect of care varied by poverty
levels for boys’ hunger (SDG target 2.1) and girls’
drop out from school (SDG target 4.1). This study
also established that there were no statistically
significant associations between different forms of
social protection and indicators of boy’s sexual
exploitation (SDG target 5.2), girls’ mental health
(SDG target 3.4) or violence perpetration (SDG
target 16.1). However, because this study analysed
very large data sets the authors acknowledged the
possibility that the interactions recorded could be
attributed to chance, therefore warranting
confirmatory studies for these results. Further
research across other low and middle income
countries is also necessary in understanding whether
this South African experience is indicative of other
regional contexts.
In contrast, Parmar et al., (2014) focused on a
different age group in a study conducted in West
Africa to analyse whether the elderly were aware of
and enrolling into social health protection schemes
in Senegal (Plan Sesame) and Ghana (NHIS). They
found that the elderly were vulnerable to all
dimensions of social exclusion in Senegal and were
less likely to enrol into Plan Sesame, while in Ghana,
it was the elderly who were politically excluded that
were less likely to enrol in NHIS. Unexpectedly, the
elderly who were socially excluded were more likely
to enrol into NHIS a result that generates qualitative
research questions as to the plausible reasons. In the
same vein, it was also unexpected that men and
households headed by men increased the odds of
enrolling in the Plan Sesame Scheme although these
gender variables were not similarly determinants of
enrolment in the NHIS Scheme. The authors
recommended that among other factors, the two
social health protection schemes should enrol more
women.
Richardson et al., (2017), on the other hand,
evaluated the impact of social protection on the
wellbeing of Ebola Virus Disease (EVD) Survivors
in Sierra Leone. Through a bivariate GEE analysis,
the study found that gender was not associated with
the wellbeing of EVD survivors. Instead, there was
evidence that moderate to extensive forms of social
protection were significantly associated with higher
wellbeing scores compared to minimal social
protection. Given the recent EVD outbreaks and the
lack of understanding of the biosocial complexity of
the epidemic, further studies should examine the
socioeconomic challenges experienced by the EVD
survivors and recommend optimal interventions in
response to EVD. With respect to this particular
study, it was proposed that research should establish
the ramifications of the different ways in which
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
23 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
description was Ebola. Further, it is deemed
important to establish whether the transient attention
on EVD survivors attenuates the demands for
reparations, by obscuring the fact that many can
claim to have survived the disease, because this has
potential policy implications on social protection
programs.
Mendola (2017) also collected gender disaggregated
data to interrogate the relation between migration,
remittances and community group participation.
According to this study, migration that was
associated with remittances increased participation
in groups within the community in Mozambique.
Moreover, since recipients were more likely to join
social insurance groups these results were
interpreted to mean that migration is a source for
preventive measure of social protection. It was also
found that the higher the number of women in a
household the lower the likelihood of joining the
social insurance group. The author suggested that
the supply of female labour in a home performed an
insurance function at the household level, reducing
the need for risk-pooling arrangements from the
community, although this should be ascertained
through a qualitative study.
3.0 Methods
This rapid review intended to explore the breadth of
research in social protection with a general view to
establish the theories underlying the discourse of
social protection literature and to determine the
field’s current research agenda. With respect to the
gender perspective, this rapid assessment aimed to
respond to the following questions:
a) In what ways, if any, is research in social
protection gendered?
b) What are some of the gendered areas of future
study in social protection research?
This rapid review was conducted between May and
August 2018 and its processes were in accordance
with the steps of the Preferred Reporting Items for
Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (Moher et
al., 2009). Electronic databases including EBSCO,
SCOPUS, AJOL, DOAJ and Google Scholar were
searched using two key words and combinations
thereof for ‘social’ and ‘protection’ to identify the
eligible studies for the review. Studies were included
if the full text was published in English and during
the period between 2008 and 2018. Studies were
eligible for inclusion if both the search terms ‘social’
and ‘protection’ or their combinations appeared in
the titles of the articles. Only empirical academic
journals were included in the final review and the
papers included in the rapid review were
independently validated as meeting this criterion.
Data was extracted from each study based on
authors, publication year, research problem, context,
methods and results of the study. A standard form
was utilised in this process and the data extracted
was also verified independently.
4.0 Discussion
Social Protection is Here to Stay!
Social protection is not without critics. This is
apparent in debates that occur in countries, where its
formal practice has been entrenched over time.
Although it is has largely been perceived to be
valuable in Europe, it is associated with a derogative
connotation in the United States made clear with
references to ‘welfare dependency’ and ‘bums on
welfare’ (Guy, 2007). Other criticisms of social
protection are derived from structural functionalist
views that poverty and inequalities may have
positive functions in society (Gans, 1971) and
arguments are likely to be in favour of policies that
reduce government expenditure on social protection
programs, often with detrimental effects e.g.
increased food insecurity in Europe as captured in
this review (Loopstra et al., 2016). It is therefore
worth giving special consideration to the study
conducted in South Africa by Rosenberg et al.,
(2015) who brings this debate to the fore in a setting
where formal social protection is currently taking
shape. In response to critics of the Child Support
Grant who suggest that the cash transfers
encouraged families to expand with the intention to
receive more money, the findings of the study
proved that the grants did not incentivize second
pregnancy rates. We propose that this study needs to
be expanded beyond examining whether the grant
incentivizes first pregnancy rates as recommended
by the authors, and instead to broader concerns of
whether social protection is a fuel for the culture of
poverty within the African context. While that is
pending, it is important to emphasize that social
protection is here to stay, owing to its value. This
review highlights the impact of social protection in
reducing significant adolescent health risks (Cluver
et al., 2016) and improving the wellbeing scores of
EVD survivors (Richardson et al., 2017). As long as
migrants continue to seek and provide support
within families (Lafleur and Romeo, 2018),
communities (Mendola, 2017) and governments
remain responsible for the wellbeing and aspirations
of their citizens (Kosec and Mo, 2017) social
protection will be an essential vehicle for realising
significant outcomes. More importantly, social
protection has now been entrenched in global social
policy through the Agenda 2030 SDGs. With
particular reference to the eradication of poverty,
goal 1.3 prescribes the implementation of nationally
appropriate social protection systems and measures
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
24 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
for all, including floors and by 2030 achieve
substantial coverage of the poor and vulnerable.
Gender Considerations are Necessary
Gender in this rapid assessment as well as the
articles reviewed appears to be synonymous with
and focussed on women, probably because this
population is more predisposed to socio-economic
risks and deprivation which makes it a target group
for social protection. This predisposition is evident
from the gender disaggregated results of the
different studies. Cluver et al., (2016) for instance
records that girls living in severe deprivation were
more likely to drop out of school but that
psychosocial support substantially reduces this risk
perhaps through providing sanitary towels, and other
forms of parenting support. In another study, Parmar
et al., (2014) reports that men and household headed
by men increased the odds of the elderly enrolling
for social health protection in Senegal, indicating
disadvantage that women, who are
disproportionately represented among the elderly,
face in accessing health even in their later years.
However it is worth noting that these gender
variables were not significant in the parallel study
conducted in Ghana and that other studies have
previously shown that female headed households
tend to have higher levels of enrolment into social
health protection schemes and utilisation of
healthcare (Jehu-Appiah et al., 2011; Chankova et
al., 2008).
Although further studies may be necessary to
confirm some of the results, the systemic gender
constraints within society that are certainly reflected
across literature that was reviewed and which can be
organised by Kabeer’s typology of gender specific
constraints (Cluver et al., 2016); gender intensified
constraints (Parmar et al., 2014; Mendola, 2017).
With respect to gender imposed constraints,
Namsomboon and Kusakabe (2011), argue that it is
necessary to link Thai’s universal health coverage
scheme to community groups to increase women
home workers’ access to health. Research in social
protection does necessarily make considerations for
women, but risks neglecting gender specific, gender
intensified and gender imposed constraints that are
unique to men. Does universal health coverage from
the study of Namsomboon and Kusakabe (2011), for
instance, respond to the needs of men home workers
in their access healthcare services in Thailand? Why
is care provision associated with reduced hunger
(Cluver et al., 2016) but for boys at lower levels of
poverty in South Africa? Gender considerations are
not just necessary in research, but also in social
protection programs and studies therefore
recommended for increased awareness about men’s
role as care-givers in the family to change the rigid
gender norms which are stressful to women and
increase their workload and an increase in the
elderly women enrolled in the Plan Sesame and
NHIS schemes in Senegal and Ghana respectively
(Namsomboon and Kusakabe, 2011; Parmar, 2014).
In summary, social protection needs to be gender
sensitive in both research and programs but to the
extent that it does not further exacerbate gender
inequalities.
Gendered Social Protection is Poorly Developed
A gender approach to social protection research is
poorly developed and thus there were few studies
(n=2) in which gender was a significant
consideration in the overall research study
(Namsomboon and Kusakabe, 2011; Rosenberg et
al., 2015). This may be attributed to the fact that
most social protection research tend to be program
evaluations that primarily focus on the poor and
those predisposed through categories age (Parmar et
al., 2014; Cluver et al., 2016); health (Richardson et
al. 2017); food insecurity and economic crisis
(Loopstra et al., 2016) rather than gender.
At the same time, the range of social protection
interventions commonly applied are protective
measures such as the Citizen’s Damage
Compensation (Watan Card) in Pakistan (Kosec and
Mo, 2017) and forms of consumption smoothing e.g.
in Europe following the economic crisis (Loopstra et
al., 2016). In addition to the protective measures,
studies also analysed programs with preventive
measures such as the pension schemes in west Africa
(Parmar et al., 2014) and promotive measures in
programs like the Child Support Grant (Rosenberg
et al., 2015 and Cluver et al., 2016) but none
included an evaluation of transformative measures
that primarily addressing concerns of social equity
and exclusion (Deveureux and Sabates, 2004). As a
result, and with respect to gender, it is possible to
perceive social protection as gender-blind. Jones and
Holmes (2011) in particular argue that this results in
the tendency for gender dynamics to be integrated
into institutions, actor interests and ideas only in a
partial or subordinate way. In light of the same, it is
possible for gender equitable outcomes to be
achieved in social protection programs with no
significant change in gender relations. Nonetheless,
following previous arguments, social protection
needs to be gender sensitive and the gender
disaggregated studies (Parmar et al., 2014; Cluver et
al., 2016; Kosec and Mo, 2017; Mendola, 2017;
Richardson et al., 2017) are instrumental in creating
a better understanding of the impact of changing
risks and vulnerabilities, implications of social
protection responses on men and women, and
ultimately helping to identify ways to strengthen
social protection programmes. In addition to the
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
25 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
potential areas of future research, this rapid review
recommends studies that can broaden the evidence
base on gender and social protection by evaluating
programs that relate not just to cash transfers (Cluver
et al., 2016), Child Care support (Rosenberg et al.,
2015); Social Pensions (Parmar et al., 2014) but
including legislation, employment generating
programs, secondary school programs, school
feeding programs and the variety of instruments that
have gender specific risks and impacts (Kabeer,
2008). Finally, this review takes cognisance that
social protection is not a panacea and studies that
critique the field and provide alternative views
should also significantly shape the critical direction
of research in the field.
4. Conclusion
Despite structural functionalist criticisms, the
findings in this rapid review show that social
protection is valuable in research, practice as well as
global policy having been incorporated into key
documents such as Agenda 2030 that outlines the
Sustainable Development Goals and is therefore
here to stay. Gendered considerations in social
protection are necessary in programs to the extent
that they do not exacerbate inequalities and in
research yield findings that can inform practice.
Generally, though research reflects the gendered
forms of vulnerabilities within society which in this
assessment could be linked to either of Kabeer’s
(2008) three constraints namely gender-specific,
gender-intensified and gender-imposed, while also
indicative of the male specific constraints in relation
to the health of adolescent (Cluver et al., 2016). This
review concludes that gendered social protection is
poorly developed because there were few studies in
which gender was the primary subject of
examination and none of the programs evaluated
applied transformative measures. Therefore
although gender equitable outcomes could be
assessed and even achieved from the programs that
were evaluated in this rapid review, it was unlikely
that any significant change in gender relations could
be realised. In light of this partial or subordinate
integration of gender, social protection can be
described as gender blind.
References
Anear, P. L., Ahmeda, S., Ros, C. E. and Ir, P. (2013)
Strengthening institutional and organizational
capacity for social health protection of the informal
sector in lesser-developed countries: A study of
policy barriers and opportunities in Cambodia.
Social Science & Medicine, 96: pp. 223 to 231
Chankova, S., Sulzbach, S., Diop, F., (2008). Impact
of mutual health organizations: evidence from West
Africa. Health Policy Plan, 23: pp. 264-276.
Cluver, L. D., Orkin, M, F., Meinck, F., Mark E. B.,
Alexa R. Y., and Sherr, L. (2016) Can Social
Protection Improve Sustainable Development Goals
for Adolescent Health, PLoS ONE 11(10):
e0164808
Devereux S, Sabates-Wheeler R. (2004).
Transformative Social Protection. Sussex: Institute
of Development Studies
Domingo, P., Holmes, R., O’Neil, T. Jones, N., Bird,
K.m Larson, A., Presler-Marshall, E., and Valters,
C. (2015). Women’s voice and leadership in
decision-making Assessing the evidence, London:
Overseas Development Institute
Guy, S. (2007) Social Protection. Development in
Practice, 17, (4/5) pp. 511-522
Jehu-Appiah, C., Aryeetey, G., Spaan, E., De Hoop,
T., Agyepong, I., Baltussen, R., (2011). Equity
aspects of the National Health Insurance Scheme in
Ghana: who is enrolling, who is not and why? Social
Science Medicine, 72: pp.157-165.
Jones, A. N. and Holmes, R. (2011) Why is Social
Protection Gender-Blind? The politics of Gender
and Social Protection, IDS bulletin, 42 (6) 45-52
Kabeer, N. (2008), Mainstreaming Gender in Social
Protection for the Informal Economy. London:
Commonwealth Secretariat
Kosec, K. and Mo, C. H. (2017). Aspirations and the
Role of Social Protection: Evidence from a Natural
Disaster in Rural Pakistan, World Development, 97:
pp. 49-66
Lafleur, J. and Romero, M.V. (2018) Combining
transnational and intersectional approaches to
immigrants' social protection: The case of Andean
families' access to health, Comparative Migration
Studies 6:14
Loopstra, R., Reeves, A., McKee, M. and Stuckler,
D. (2016) Food insecurity and social protection in
Europe: Quasi-natural experiment of Europe's Great
Recessions. Preventive Medicine, 89: pp. 44–50
Luttrell, C. and Moser, C., (2004) ‘Gender and
Social Protection’. London: Overseas Development
Institute
Mendola, M (2017) International migration and
informal social protection in rural Mozambique.
Research in Economics, 71, pp. 282–290
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G.,
& PRISMA Group (2009). Preferred reporting items
for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The
PRISMA statement. British Medical Journal,
032BMJ, 33(9) pp 25-35.
Namsomboon, B., and Kusakabe, K. (2011). Social
protection for women Homeworkers: A case of
healthcare services in Thailand. International
Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 31 (1/ 2) pp.
123-136
Netoiu, L. and Cârstina, S. (2014). Analysis of the
correlation between minimum wage levels in the
Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN:
2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2
(6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org
26 | P a g e
Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org
country, indicators of social protection and poverty
threshold. Procedia Economics and Finance, 8:
pp.505 – 509
Norton, A. Conway, T. Foster, M. (2001) Social
Protection Concepts and Approaches: Implications
for Policy and Practice in International
Development. WP. 143 Centre for Aid and Public
Expenditure. London: Overseas Development
Institute
Parmar, D., Williams, G., Dkhimi, F., Ndiaye, A.,
Asante, F. A., Arhinful, D. K., and Mladovsky, P.
(2014) Enrolment of older people in social health
protection programs in West Africa e Does social
exclusion play a part? Social Science & Medicine,
119: 36-44
Pitruzzello, S. (2004) Trade Globalization,
Economic Performance, and Social Protection:
Nineteenth Century British Laissez-Faire and Post-
World War II U.S.-Embedded Liberalism.
International Organization, 58, (4) pp. 705-744
Richardson, E. T., Kelly, D., Sesay, O., Drasherb,
M.D., Desaia, K. I., Frankfurterd, R. Farmer, E. P.
and Barriea, B. M (2017) The symbolic violence of
‘outbreak’: A mixed-methods, quasi-experimental
impact evaluation of social protection on Ebola
survivor wellbeing. Social Science & Medicine, 195:
pp. 77–82
Rosenberg, M., Pettifor, A., Nguyen, N., Westreich,
D., Bor, J., Bärnighausen, T., Mee, P., Twine, R.,
Tollman, S., and Kahn, K., (2015). Relationship
between Receipt of a Social Protection Grant for a
Child and Second Pregnancy Rates among South
African Women: A Cohort Study. PLoS ONE,
10(9): e0137352

More Related Content

What's hot

A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...
A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...
A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...KarinaBorges32
 
Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...
Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...
Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...Dr. Brenda C Williams
 
NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)
NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)
NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)Deena Nardi
 
MAG Conference special talk nov 2014
MAG Conference special talk nov 2014MAG Conference special talk nov 2014
MAG Conference special talk nov 2014Ernest C de Run
 
Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...
Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...
Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...paperpublications3
 

What's hot (7)

A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...
A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...
A psychological autopsy of an intellectually gifted student with attention de...
 
Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...
Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...
Transition from College to Employment: Lived Employment Experiences and Perce...
 
NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)
NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)
NArdi and GYurko SRGlobal NUrsing Faculty SHortage (1)
 
Generation Cohort
Generation CohortGeneration Cohort
Generation Cohort
 
MAG Conference special talk nov 2014
MAG Conference special talk nov 2014MAG Conference special talk nov 2014
MAG Conference special talk nov 2014
 
Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...
Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...
Community Resilience Mechanisms in Prevention, Control and Management of HIV/...
 
The mainstreaming of par in health care final version
The mainstreaming of par in health care final versionThe mainstreaming of par in health care final version
The mainstreaming of par in health care final version
 

Similar to Rapid review explores gender considerations in social protection research

Ageism In Working Life A Scoping Review On Discursive Approaches
Ageism In Working Life  A Scoping Review On Discursive ApproachesAgeism In Working Life  A Scoping Review On Discursive Approaches
Ageism In Working Life A Scoping Review On Discursive ApproachesMichele Thomas
 
Qualitative Research Appraisal
Qualitative Research AppraisalQualitative Research Appraisal
Qualitative Research AppraisalAlexis Naranjo
 
Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...
Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...
Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...AJHSSR Journal
 
EDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ Youth
EDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ YouthEDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ Youth
EDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ YouthStephanie Gariscsak
 
Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)
Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)
Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)Dr Ghaiath Hussein
 
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptxResearch or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptxDr Ghaiath Hussein
 
A Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social Work
A Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social WorkA Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social Work
A Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social WorkLiz Adams
 
A Study On Livelihood Frameworks
A Study On Livelihood FrameworksA Study On Livelihood Frameworks
A Study On Livelihood FrameworksNat Rice
 
Children With Special Health Care
Children With Special Health CareChildren With Special Health Care
Children With Special Health CareToya Shamberger
 
Some ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docx
Some ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docxSome ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docx
Some ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docxmckellarhastings
 
D0rp00106f
D0rp00106fD0rp00106f
D0rp00106fyansen14
 
Design patterns barriers to social entrepreneurship
Design patterns barriers to social entrepreneurshipDesign patterns barriers to social entrepreneurship
Design patterns barriers to social entrepreneurshipAlexander Decker
 
Guidelines article review 1) please select one article from th
Guidelines article review 1) please select one article from thGuidelines article review 1) please select one article from th
Guidelines article review 1) please select one article from thsimba35
 
Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015
Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015
Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015Marie Sophie Pettersson
 
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docxContents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docxmelvinjrobinson2199
 
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docxContents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docxbobbywlane695641
 
Qualitative Research-Grounded Theory
Qualitative Research-Grounded TheoryQualitative Research-Grounded Theory
Qualitative Research-Grounded TheoryTina Jordan
 
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docx
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docxRunning Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docx
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docxwlynn1
 

Similar to Rapid review explores gender considerations in social protection research (20)

Ageism In Working Life A Scoping Review On Discursive Approaches
Ageism In Working Life  A Scoping Review On Discursive ApproachesAgeism In Working Life  A Scoping Review On Discursive Approaches
Ageism In Working Life A Scoping Review On Discursive Approaches
 
Qualitative Research Appraisal
Qualitative Research AppraisalQualitative Research Appraisal
Qualitative Research Appraisal
 
Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...
Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...
Social Capital and Fear of Crime: A Test of Organizational Participation Effe...
 
EDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ Youth
EDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ YouthEDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ Youth
EDRD 6000: Ethics when working with LGBTQ+ Youth
 
Entre and Family role.pdf
Entre and Family role.pdfEntre and Family role.pdf
Entre and Family role.pdf
 
Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)
Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)
Research or not research (jcb 17.11.21)
 
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptxResearch or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
Research or not research (JCB 17.11.21).pptx
 
Pilot article oct 2013
Pilot article oct 2013Pilot article oct 2013
Pilot article oct 2013
 
A Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social Work
A Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social WorkA Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social Work
A Critical Review Of Resilience Theory And Its Relevance For Social Work
 
A Study On Livelihood Frameworks
A Study On Livelihood FrameworksA Study On Livelihood Frameworks
A Study On Livelihood Frameworks
 
Children With Special Health Care
Children With Special Health CareChildren With Special Health Care
Children With Special Health Care
 
Some ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docx
Some ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docxSome ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docx
Some ethical standards to remember when conducting internet resear.docx
 
D0rp00106f
D0rp00106fD0rp00106f
D0rp00106f
 
Design patterns barriers to social entrepreneurship
Design patterns barriers to social entrepreneurshipDesign patterns barriers to social entrepreneurship
Design patterns barriers to social entrepreneurship
 
Guidelines article review 1) please select one article from th
Guidelines article review 1) please select one article from thGuidelines article review 1) please select one article from th
Guidelines article review 1) please select one article from th
 
Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015
Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015
Gender Equality Update No 7 - 30th November 2015
 
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docxContents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
 
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docxContents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirectSocial Science & .docx
 
Qualitative Research-Grounded Theory
Qualitative Research-Grounded TheoryQualitative Research-Grounded Theory
Qualitative Research-Grounded Theory
 
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docx
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docxRunning Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docx
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW1LITERATURE REVIEW6.docx
 

More from oircjournals

Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...
Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...
Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...oircjournals
 
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...oircjournals
 
Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...
Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...
Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...oircjournals
 
An assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particular
An assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particularAn assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particular
An assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particularoircjournals
 
Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...
Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...
Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...oircjournals
 
Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...
Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...
Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...oircjournals
 
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...oircjournals
 
Land use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchment
Land use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchmentLand use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchment
Land use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchmentoircjournals
 
Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...
Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...
Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...oircjournals
 
Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...
Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...
Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...oircjournals
 
Utilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-county
Utilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-countyUtilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-county
Utilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-countyoircjournals
 
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...oircjournals
 
The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...
The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...
The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...oircjournals
 
Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...
Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...
Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...oircjournals
 
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...oircjournals
 
Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...
Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...
Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...oircjournals
 
Influence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabonon
Influence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabononInfluence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabonon
Influence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabononoircjournals
 
Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...
Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...
Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...oircjournals
 
Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...
Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...
Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...oircjournals
 

More from oircjournals (20)

Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...
Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...
Effect of-buyer-supplier-development-on-management-unit-in-uasin-gishu-county...
 
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
 
Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...
Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...
Influence of-instructional-drama-on-the-development-of-ecde-learners-in-elgey...
 
An assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particular
An assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particularAn assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particular
An assessment-of-the-gender-in-general-and-trousers-for-women-in-particular
 
Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...
Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...
Perceived contribution-of-school-learning-extra-county-secondary-schools-in-n...
 
Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...
Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...
Influence of budgetary allocation on performance of youth group project in th...
 
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
School effectiveness-and-improvement-contribution-of-teacher-qualification-to...
 
Land use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchment
Land use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchmentLand use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchment
Land use-cover-trends-climate-variability-nexus-in-the-njoro-river-catchment
 
Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...
Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...
Psychosocial challenges-facing-orphans-and-vulnerable-children-attending-publ...
 
Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...
Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...
Factors influencing-gender-equality-among-multi-sectoral-workers-in-meru-coun...
 
Utilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-county
Utilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-countyUtilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-county
Utilization of-media-resources-policy-and-centers-in-elgeyo-marakwet-county
 
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
 
The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...
The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...
The influence-of-monitoring-and-evaluation-on-water-project-performance-in-mi...
 
Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...
Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...
Effect of-stakeholder-analysis-on-performance-of-road-construction-projects-i...
 
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
Monitoring intensity-and-procurement-performance-emprical-evidence-from-elgey...
 
Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...
Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...
Building information-modeling-and-construction-projects-performance-the-effec...
 
Influence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabonon
Influence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabononInfluence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabonon
Influence of-stakeholder-communication-on-performance-of-kabonon
 
Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...
Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...
Effect of-product-creation-strategy-on-performance-of-small-and-medium-enterp...
 
Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...
Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...
Influence of-sustainability-management-systems-csr-on-firm-performance-of-sug...
 
Phylis
PhylisPhylis
Phylis
 

Recently uploaded

Angela Killian | Operations Director | Dallas
Angela Killian | Operations Director | DallasAngela Killian | Operations Director | Dallas
Angela Killian | Operations Director | DallasAngela Killian
 
Spotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of Florida
Spotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of FloridaSpotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of Florida
Spotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of Floridajorirz24
 
GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...
GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...
GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...Mona Rathore
 
Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...
Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...
Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...baharayali
 
Ready to get noticed? Partner with Sociocosmos
Ready to get noticed? Partner with SociocosmosReady to get noticed? Partner with Sociocosmos
Ready to get noticed? Partner with SociocosmosSocioCosmos
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...
c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...
c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...gurkirankumar98700
 
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageYour LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageSocioCosmos
 
Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...
Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...
Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...SejarahLokal
 
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCRStunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCRDelhi Call girls
 
Online Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary Study
Online Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary StudyOnline Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary Study
Online Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary StudyAJHSSR Journal
 
Call Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts ServiceCall Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts ServiceSapana Sha
 
MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.
MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.
MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.AFFFILIATE
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...anilsa9823
 
Call^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call Me
Call^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call MeCall^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call Me
Call^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call MeMs Riya
 
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Angela Killian | Operations Director | Dallas
Angela Killian | Operations Director | DallasAngela Killian | Operations Director | Dallas
Angela Killian | Operations Director | Dallas
 
Spotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of Florida
Spotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of FloridaSpotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of Florida
Spotify AI DJ Deck - The Agency at University of Florida
 
GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...
GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...
GREAT OPORTUNITY Russian Call Girls Kirti Nagar 9711199012 Independent Escort...
 
Vip Call Girls Tilak Nagar ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 No Advance 24HRS Live
Vip Call Girls Tilak Nagar ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 No Advance 24HRS LiveVip Call Girls Tilak Nagar ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 No Advance 24HRS Live
Vip Call Girls Tilak Nagar ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 No Advance 24HRS Live
 
Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...
Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...
Top Astrologer, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi Ar...
 
Ready to get noticed? Partner with Sociocosmos
Ready to get noticed? Partner with SociocosmosReady to get noticed? Partner with Sociocosmos
Ready to get noticed? Partner with Sociocosmos
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 121 Call Me: 8448380779
 
🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli Escort Service Delhi NCR
🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli  Escort Service Delhi NCR🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli  Escort Service Delhi NCR
🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli Escort Service Delhi NCR
 
Delhi 99530 vip 56974 Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
Delhi  99530 vip 56974  Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in MasudpurDelhi  99530 vip 56974  Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
Delhi 99530 vip 56974 Genuine Escort Service Call Girls in Masudpur
 
c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...
c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...
c Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts Service 👩🏽‍❤️‍💋‍👨🏿 8923113531 ♢ Boo...
 
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageYour LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
 
Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...
Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...
Add more information to your upload Tip: Better titles and descriptions lead ...
 
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCRStunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
 
Online Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary Study
Online Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary StudyOnline Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary Study
Online Social Shopping Motivation: A Preliminary Study
 
Call Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts ServiceCall Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts Service
Call Girls In Patel Nagar Delhi 9654467111 Escorts Service
 
MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.
MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.
MODERN PODCASTING ,CREATING DREAMS TODAY.
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
 
Call^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call Me
Call^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call MeCall^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call Me
Call^ Girls Delhi Independent girls Chanakyapuri 9711199012 Call Me
 
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
 

Rapid review explores gender considerations in social protection research

  • 1. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 19-26 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 19 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org Rapid Review of Social Protection; a Gender Perspective Joyce Maina St. Pauls University Type of the Paper: Research Paper. Type of Review: Peer Reviewed. Indexed in: worldwide web. Google Scholar Citation: AIJMR Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) A Refereed International Journal of OIRC JOURNALS. © OIRC JOURNALS. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 4.0 International License subject to proper citation to the publication source of the work. Disclaimer: The scholarly papers as reviewed and published by the OIRC JOURNALS, are the views and opinions of their respective authors and are not the views or opinions of the OIRC. How to Cite this Paper: Maina, J. (2018). Rapid Review of Social Protection; a Gender Perspective. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR), 2 (6), 19-26.
  • 2. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 20 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org Rapid Review of Social Protection; a Gender Perspective Joyce Maina St. Pauls University Abstract This rapid assessment examines the literature on social protection to determine the gender considerations made in social protection research and the gendered areas of future research in the field. This review was conducted between May and August 2018. Electronic databases were searched to identify records that were published in English between the period of 2008 and 2018. Studies were eligible for inclusion if they were empirical and had both the search terms ‘social’ and ‘protection’ or their various combinations, appearing in the titles of the articles. Grey literature, reports and other non-academic writings were excluded as only empirical studies were eligible. Twelve studies were reviewed and synthesised. The results of this study show that social protection research makes gender considerations and most of the social protection interventions were protective, preventive or promotive measures. Future studies should therefore explore transformative social protection with respect to gender equality and partly because gendered social protection is poorly developed. This rapid review also affirms that despite criticisms, social protection continues to be valuable in addressing poverty and inequalities. However, against this backdrop it is worth noting that social protection is not a panacea and its gender considerations are necessary only to the extent that they do not exacerbate inequalities. 1.0 Introduction Although many of the articles studied in this literature review hardly provide concrete definitions and conceptual underpinnings of social protection, it is important as a first step to establish the meaning of the subject of this rapid review in order to determine the scope of this exercise. As with the term development to which social protection is closely associated, there appears to be no consensus in literature on how to define the subject but the two attempts that are commonly fronted consider social protection to be an ‘action’ (Norton et al., 2001) and ‘initiative’ (Devereux and Sabates-Wheeler 2004). Central to the different definitions of social protection is an intention to respond to deprivation in poor, vulnerable and marginalized populations in which women with respect to gender are sometimes disproportionately represented. The gendered vulnerabilities faced by girls for example dropping out of school, early marriages and child bearing have serious ramifications on their future although adolescent boys are also predisposed to unique challenges (Cluver et al., 2016). Women on the other hand are often limited by their primary care giving responsibilities, domestic work as well as cultural restrictions; and since they often tend to be concentrated in the informal sectors, they are predisposed to particular health risks (Namsomboon and Kusakabe 2011), insecure employment and are therefore less likely to save and contribute to pension schemes. Consequently, social security systems particularly in developing countries therefore often comprise a male dominated section of the workforce in formal state and private sector and some studies in evaluating enrolment in West Africa have made recommendations for fees to be eliminated and more elderly women to be enrolled into social health protection schemes (Parmar et al., 2014). This is particularly important because women’s vulnerabilities are further compounded by the fact that across the world, they live longer than men, are at risk of widowhood, greater poverty and insecurity. There are a number of strategies that are used to address these gendered forms of vulnerability in social protection. The life cycle approach can lead to giants in equity and poverty reduction by targeting adolescents (Cluver et al., 2016); women in childbearing (Rosenberg et al., 2015); the elderly (Parmar et al., 2014) and other gender specific categories that are related to household economic risks, social exclusion, health risks (Richardson et ARTICLE INFO Received 1st September, 2018 Received in Revised Form 26th October, 2018 Accepted 1st November, 2018 Published online 11th November 2018 Key words: Social Protection, Gender, Rapid Review,
  • 3. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 21 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org al., 2017; Mendola, 2017). Gender strategies towards equity on the other hand usually involve gender-mainstreaming and gender specific actions. In social protection programs this may include decisions to transfer grants to selected gender often women to stimulate investments and ensure better distribution of resources within the household as is the case in Child Support Grant in South Africa that is evaluated by two articles in this review (Rosenberg et al., 2015; Cluver et al., 2016). While the merits and demerits have been debated, even informal social protection strategies gravitate towards this gender approach as evidenced by migrant women within their family transnational networks, show solidarity to ensure that money intended for supporting family or meeting specific needs is used for the intended purposed (Lafleur and Romero, 2018). This gendered social protection strategies confirm that socio-economic risks and vulnerabilities are inherently influenced by gender relations and reflected in the different coping mechanisms that are selected (Domingo et al., 2015). It is also worth noting that the range of social protection instruments have specific gender related risks and impact (Kabeer, 2008). 2.0 Literature Review A total number of 189 records were identified from these electronic databases and 20 records from other sources. After the duplicates records were removed there remained 164 records for screening of which 102 records were excluded as they comprised of grey literature, theses, essays and other unpublished materials. The manuscripts assessed further for eligibility were 61 and of these 39 were excluded because they were non-empirical studies. The manuscripts eligible for the review were 22 of which 12 were included in this rapid review as preliminary findings. Description of the Studies Some of the studies were conducted in Africa (n=5) among which two were from South Africa while none were conducted in North or East Africa (Parmar et al., 2014; Rosenberg et al., 2015; Cluver et al., 2016; Mendola, 2017; Richardson et al. 2017). Other studies that were reviewed originated from Europe (Netoiu and Carstina, 2014; Loopstra et al., 2016; Lafleur and Romero, 2018) and (n=3) from Asia (Namsomboon and Kusakabe 2011; Annear et al., 2013; Kosec and Mo, 2017). There were also studies that were conducted in more than one country for instance in Senegal and Ghana (Parmar et al., 2014) and in Belgium, Colombia and Peru (Lafleur and Romero, 2018). Few studies among those that were analysed were designed to have mixed methodologies (Namsomboon and Kusakabe, 2011; Annear et al., 2013, Richardson et al., 2017) and only one was purely qualitative (Lafleur and Romero, 2018). Most of the other studies (n=8), applied a quantitative methodology and were designed as quasi-experiments (Parmar et al., 2014; Rosenberg et al., 2015; Cluver et al., 2016; Loopstra et al., 2016; Kosec and Mo, 2017; Mendola, 2017; Richardson et al., 2017). Gender Considerations in Social Protection Research A gender perspective was introduced in some of studies (n=2) assessed in this rapid review by targeting women as the research participants. In one of these studies conducted in South Africa, the researchers sort to establish the relationship between social protection programs and fertility because the incentive and income effects of the two were unknown. The authors investigated the potential for the Child Support Grant (a form of cash transfer program) to incentivize second pregnancy rates (Rosenberg et al., 2015). A total of 4845 women responded to this study, reporting on whether or not they were recipients to the Child Support Grants as well as pregnant specific information for recently or currently pregnant women. The other study that targeted women as research participants was conducted in Bangkok to determine how the Kingdom’s universal healthcare responded to the needs of women home workers because the information of this new social protection program in Thailand, was lacking (Namsomboon and Kusakabe, 2011). A total of 415 women home workers drawn from 76 communities and across 16 out of the 29 districts of Bangkok, participated in the study that identified the reasons why women home workers do not use the universal healthcare scheme and how they access their healthcare. Although it was not the subject of the remaining studies (n=10) some researchers considered gender in their research designs. In a study concerning immigrants’ social protection with regards to their access to health, Lafleur and Romero (2018) selected participants through a snowballing technique in various immigrant entry points in Brussels and as part of their recruitment strategy they contacted female migrants first. This is because they argued that women tend to be the majority Peruvians and Colombians in Brussels and of greater significance to the study, are concerned over their access to social protection as well as that of their families. Some of the other remaining studies (n=5) applied gender as a core variable to disaggregate their analysis of whether the elderly are aware of and enrolling into social health protection schemes in
  • 4. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 22 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org West Africa (Parmar et al., 2014); whether the provision of social protection can impact 17 indicators of five key health related Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) among adolescent in South Africa (Cluver et al., 2016); the role of social protection in restoring and raising citizen aspirations following shocks such as natural disasters (Kosec and Mo, 2017); examining the extent to which dispatching family labour abroad is a source of informal social protection for households left behind (Mendola, 2017); and evaluating of the impact of social protection on the wellbeing of the Ebola survivor (Richardson et al. 2017). Gendered Areas of Future Studies in Social Protection In their investigation of whether social protection programs issuing cash transfers to caregivers influenced fertility, Rosenberg et al., (2015), found that second pregnancy rates were significantly longer among recipients of the grant than non- recipients, and it was suggested that the associated economic independence could result in decreased transactional sex, improved agency for the women or through job prospects and education, increased opportunity costs of pregnancy and motherhood. However a qualitative study is necessary to establish the reasons underlying these findings as well as the lack of association between loss of the child support grant and pregnancy incidence. Although the study essentially established that cash transfers do not incentivize pregnancy, the authors recommended further investigation into the CSG program to find out whether the grants incentivize the first pregnancy instead, and more broadly, the unplanned outcomes of social protection programs. On the other hand, Namsomboon and Kusakabe’s (2011) study of women home workers established that less than half the respondents accessed Thailand’s Universal Healthcare Scheme. It was found that contract workers caring for children had difficulty balancing work deadlines; household responsibilities as well as care demands and that financial constraints, also limited the women’s access to government provided health services. These two authors made several programmatic recommendations, and in relation to gendered social protection research they suggested that future studies should assess the impact of strengthening gender norms which in the Thai setting delineates care work as women’s work. Cluver et al., (2016) found that social protection was associated with significant adolescent risk reduction in twelve out of the seventeen gender disaggregated SDG indicators, while in six out of the seventeen indicators, combined forms of social protection (cash and care through psychosocial support to adolescents) showed enhanced risk reduction effects. With respect to the significance of gender, it was found that the effect of care varied by poverty levels for boys’ hunger (SDG target 2.1) and girls’ drop out from school (SDG target 4.1). This study also established that there were no statistically significant associations between different forms of social protection and indicators of boy’s sexual exploitation (SDG target 5.2), girls’ mental health (SDG target 3.4) or violence perpetration (SDG target 16.1). However, because this study analysed very large data sets the authors acknowledged the possibility that the interactions recorded could be attributed to chance, therefore warranting confirmatory studies for these results. Further research across other low and middle income countries is also necessary in understanding whether this South African experience is indicative of other regional contexts. In contrast, Parmar et al., (2014) focused on a different age group in a study conducted in West Africa to analyse whether the elderly were aware of and enrolling into social health protection schemes in Senegal (Plan Sesame) and Ghana (NHIS). They found that the elderly were vulnerable to all dimensions of social exclusion in Senegal and were less likely to enrol into Plan Sesame, while in Ghana, it was the elderly who were politically excluded that were less likely to enrol in NHIS. Unexpectedly, the elderly who were socially excluded were more likely to enrol into NHIS a result that generates qualitative research questions as to the plausible reasons. In the same vein, it was also unexpected that men and households headed by men increased the odds of enrolling in the Plan Sesame Scheme although these gender variables were not similarly determinants of enrolment in the NHIS Scheme. The authors recommended that among other factors, the two social health protection schemes should enrol more women. Richardson et al., (2017), on the other hand, evaluated the impact of social protection on the wellbeing of Ebola Virus Disease (EVD) Survivors in Sierra Leone. Through a bivariate GEE analysis, the study found that gender was not associated with the wellbeing of EVD survivors. Instead, there was evidence that moderate to extensive forms of social protection were significantly associated with higher wellbeing scores compared to minimal social protection. Given the recent EVD outbreaks and the lack of understanding of the biosocial complexity of the epidemic, further studies should examine the socioeconomic challenges experienced by the EVD survivors and recommend optimal interventions in response to EVD. With respect to this particular study, it was proposed that research should establish the ramifications of the different ways in which
  • 5. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 23 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org description was Ebola. Further, it is deemed important to establish whether the transient attention on EVD survivors attenuates the demands for reparations, by obscuring the fact that many can claim to have survived the disease, because this has potential policy implications on social protection programs. Mendola (2017) also collected gender disaggregated data to interrogate the relation between migration, remittances and community group participation. According to this study, migration that was associated with remittances increased participation in groups within the community in Mozambique. Moreover, since recipients were more likely to join social insurance groups these results were interpreted to mean that migration is a source for preventive measure of social protection. It was also found that the higher the number of women in a household the lower the likelihood of joining the social insurance group. The author suggested that the supply of female labour in a home performed an insurance function at the household level, reducing the need for risk-pooling arrangements from the community, although this should be ascertained through a qualitative study. 3.0 Methods This rapid review intended to explore the breadth of research in social protection with a general view to establish the theories underlying the discourse of social protection literature and to determine the field’s current research agenda. With respect to the gender perspective, this rapid assessment aimed to respond to the following questions: a) In what ways, if any, is research in social protection gendered? b) What are some of the gendered areas of future study in social protection research? This rapid review was conducted between May and August 2018 and its processes were in accordance with the steps of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (Moher et al., 2009). Electronic databases including EBSCO, SCOPUS, AJOL, DOAJ and Google Scholar were searched using two key words and combinations thereof for ‘social’ and ‘protection’ to identify the eligible studies for the review. Studies were included if the full text was published in English and during the period between 2008 and 2018. Studies were eligible for inclusion if both the search terms ‘social’ and ‘protection’ or their combinations appeared in the titles of the articles. Only empirical academic journals were included in the final review and the papers included in the rapid review were independently validated as meeting this criterion. Data was extracted from each study based on authors, publication year, research problem, context, methods and results of the study. A standard form was utilised in this process and the data extracted was also verified independently. 4.0 Discussion Social Protection is Here to Stay! Social protection is not without critics. This is apparent in debates that occur in countries, where its formal practice has been entrenched over time. Although it is has largely been perceived to be valuable in Europe, it is associated with a derogative connotation in the United States made clear with references to ‘welfare dependency’ and ‘bums on welfare’ (Guy, 2007). Other criticisms of social protection are derived from structural functionalist views that poverty and inequalities may have positive functions in society (Gans, 1971) and arguments are likely to be in favour of policies that reduce government expenditure on social protection programs, often with detrimental effects e.g. increased food insecurity in Europe as captured in this review (Loopstra et al., 2016). It is therefore worth giving special consideration to the study conducted in South Africa by Rosenberg et al., (2015) who brings this debate to the fore in a setting where formal social protection is currently taking shape. In response to critics of the Child Support Grant who suggest that the cash transfers encouraged families to expand with the intention to receive more money, the findings of the study proved that the grants did not incentivize second pregnancy rates. We propose that this study needs to be expanded beyond examining whether the grant incentivizes first pregnancy rates as recommended by the authors, and instead to broader concerns of whether social protection is a fuel for the culture of poverty within the African context. While that is pending, it is important to emphasize that social protection is here to stay, owing to its value. This review highlights the impact of social protection in reducing significant adolescent health risks (Cluver et al., 2016) and improving the wellbeing scores of EVD survivors (Richardson et al., 2017). As long as migrants continue to seek and provide support within families (Lafleur and Romeo, 2018), communities (Mendola, 2017) and governments remain responsible for the wellbeing and aspirations of their citizens (Kosec and Mo, 2017) social protection will be an essential vehicle for realising significant outcomes. More importantly, social protection has now been entrenched in global social policy through the Agenda 2030 SDGs. With particular reference to the eradication of poverty, goal 1.3 prescribes the implementation of nationally appropriate social protection systems and measures
  • 6. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 24 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org for all, including floors and by 2030 achieve substantial coverage of the poor and vulnerable. Gender Considerations are Necessary Gender in this rapid assessment as well as the articles reviewed appears to be synonymous with and focussed on women, probably because this population is more predisposed to socio-economic risks and deprivation which makes it a target group for social protection. This predisposition is evident from the gender disaggregated results of the different studies. Cluver et al., (2016) for instance records that girls living in severe deprivation were more likely to drop out of school but that psychosocial support substantially reduces this risk perhaps through providing sanitary towels, and other forms of parenting support. In another study, Parmar et al., (2014) reports that men and household headed by men increased the odds of the elderly enrolling for social health protection in Senegal, indicating disadvantage that women, who are disproportionately represented among the elderly, face in accessing health even in their later years. However it is worth noting that these gender variables were not significant in the parallel study conducted in Ghana and that other studies have previously shown that female headed households tend to have higher levels of enrolment into social health protection schemes and utilisation of healthcare (Jehu-Appiah et al., 2011; Chankova et al., 2008). Although further studies may be necessary to confirm some of the results, the systemic gender constraints within society that are certainly reflected across literature that was reviewed and which can be organised by Kabeer’s typology of gender specific constraints (Cluver et al., 2016); gender intensified constraints (Parmar et al., 2014; Mendola, 2017). With respect to gender imposed constraints, Namsomboon and Kusakabe (2011), argue that it is necessary to link Thai’s universal health coverage scheme to community groups to increase women home workers’ access to health. Research in social protection does necessarily make considerations for women, but risks neglecting gender specific, gender intensified and gender imposed constraints that are unique to men. Does universal health coverage from the study of Namsomboon and Kusakabe (2011), for instance, respond to the needs of men home workers in their access healthcare services in Thailand? Why is care provision associated with reduced hunger (Cluver et al., 2016) but for boys at lower levels of poverty in South Africa? Gender considerations are not just necessary in research, but also in social protection programs and studies therefore recommended for increased awareness about men’s role as care-givers in the family to change the rigid gender norms which are stressful to women and increase their workload and an increase in the elderly women enrolled in the Plan Sesame and NHIS schemes in Senegal and Ghana respectively (Namsomboon and Kusakabe, 2011; Parmar, 2014). In summary, social protection needs to be gender sensitive in both research and programs but to the extent that it does not further exacerbate gender inequalities. Gendered Social Protection is Poorly Developed A gender approach to social protection research is poorly developed and thus there were few studies (n=2) in which gender was a significant consideration in the overall research study (Namsomboon and Kusakabe, 2011; Rosenberg et al., 2015). This may be attributed to the fact that most social protection research tend to be program evaluations that primarily focus on the poor and those predisposed through categories age (Parmar et al., 2014; Cluver et al., 2016); health (Richardson et al. 2017); food insecurity and economic crisis (Loopstra et al., 2016) rather than gender. At the same time, the range of social protection interventions commonly applied are protective measures such as the Citizen’s Damage Compensation (Watan Card) in Pakistan (Kosec and Mo, 2017) and forms of consumption smoothing e.g. in Europe following the economic crisis (Loopstra et al., 2016). In addition to the protective measures, studies also analysed programs with preventive measures such as the pension schemes in west Africa (Parmar et al., 2014) and promotive measures in programs like the Child Support Grant (Rosenberg et al., 2015 and Cluver et al., 2016) but none included an evaluation of transformative measures that primarily addressing concerns of social equity and exclusion (Deveureux and Sabates, 2004). As a result, and with respect to gender, it is possible to perceive social protection as gender-blind. Jones and Holmes (2011) in particular argue that this results in the tendency for gender dynamics to be integrated into institutions, actor interests and ideas only in a partial or subordinate way. In light of the same, it is possible for gender equitable outcomes to be achieved in social protection programs with no significant change in gender relations. Nonetheless, following previous arguments, social protection needs to be gender sensitive and the gender disaggregated studies (Parmar et al., 2014; Cluver et al., 2016; Kosec and Mo, 2017; Mendola, 2017; Richardson et al., 2017) are instrumental in creating a better understanding of the impact of changing risks and vulnerabilities, implications of social protection responses on men and women, and ultimately helping to identify ways to strengthen social protection programmes. In addition to the
  • 7. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 25 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org potential areas of future research, this rapid review recommends studies that can broaden the evidence base on gender and social protection by evaluating programs that relate not just to cash transfers (Cluver et al., 2016), Child Care support (Rosenberg et al., 2015); Social Pensions (Parmar et al., 2014) but including legislation, employment generating programs, secondary school programs, school feeding programs and the variety of instruments that have gender specific risks and impacts (Kabeer, 2008). Finally, this review takes cognisance that social protection is not a panacea and studies that critique the field and provide alternative views should also significantly shape the critical direction of research in the field. 4. Conclusion Despite structural functionalist criticisms, the findings in this rapid review show that social protection is valuable in research, practice as well as global policy having been incorporated into key documents such as Agenda 2030 that outlines the Sustainable Development Goals and is therefore here to stay. Gendered considerations in social protection are necessary in programs to the extent that they do not exacerbate inequalities and in research yield findings that can inform practice. Generally, though research reflects the gendered forms of vulnerabilities within society which in this assessment could be linked to either of Kabeer’s (2008) three constraints namely gender-specific, gender-intensified and gender-imposed, while also indicative of the male specific constraints in relation to the health of adolescent (Cluver et al., 2016). This review concludes that gendered social protection is poorly developed because there were few studies in which gender was the primary subject of examination and none of the programs evaluated applied transformative measures. Therefore although gender equitable outcomes could be assessed and even achieved from the programs that were evaluated in this rapid review, it was unlikely that any significant change in gender relations could be realised. In light of this partial or subordinate integration of gender, social protection can be described as gender blind. References Anear, P. L., Ahmeda, S., Ros, C. E. and Ir, P. (2013) Strengthening institutional and organizational capacity for social health protection of the informal sector in lesser-developed countries: A study of policy barriers and opportunities in Cambodia. Social Science & Medicine, 96: pp. 223 to 231 Chankova, S., Sulzbach, S., Diop, F., (2008). Impact of mutual health organizations: evidence from West Africa. Health Policy Plan, 23: pp. 264-276. Cluver, L. D., Orkin, M, F., Meinck, F., Mark E. B., Alexa R. Y., and Sherr, L. (2016) Can Social Protection Improve Sustainable Development Goals for Adolescent Health, PLoS ONE 11(10): e0164808 Devereux S, Sabates-Wheeler R. (2004). Transformative Social Protection. Sussex: Institute of Development Studies Domingo, P., Holmes, R., O’Neil, T. Jones, N., Bird, K.m Larson, A., Presler-Marshall, E., and Valters, C. (2015). Women’s voice and leadership in decision-making Assessing the evidence, London: Overseas Development Institute Guy, S. (2007) Social Protection. Development in Practice, 17, (4/5) pp. 511-522 Jehu-Appiah, C., Aryeetey, G., Spaan, E., De Hoop, T., Agyepong, I., Baltussen, R., (2011). Equity aspects of the National Health Insurance Scheme in Ghana: who is enrolling, who is not and why? Social Science Medicine, 72: pp.157-165. Jones, A. N. and Holmes, R. (2011) Why is Social Protection Gender-Blind? The politics of Gender and Social Protection, IDS bulletin, 42 (6) 45-52 Kabeer, N. (2008), Mainstreaming Gender in Social Protection for the Informal Economy. London: Commonwealth Secretariat Kosec, K. and Mo, C. H. (2017). Aspirations and the Role of Social Protection: Evidence from a Natural Disaster in Rural Pakistan, World Development, 97: pp. 49-66 Lafleur, J. and Romero, M.V. (2018) Combining transnational and intersectional approaches to immigrants' social protection: The case of Andean families' access to health, Comparative Migration Studies 6:14 Loopstra, R., Reeves, A., McKee, M. and Stuckler, D. (2016) Food insecurity and social protection in Europe: Quasi-natural experiment of Europe's Great Recessions. Preventive Medicine, 89: pp. 44–50 Luttrell, C. and Moser, C., (2004) ‘Gender and Social Protection’. London: Overseas Development Institute Mendola, M (2017) International migration and informal social protection in rural Mozambique. Research in Economics, 71, pp. 282–290 Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G., & PRISMA Group (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. British Medical Journal, 032BMJ, 33(9) pp 25-35. Namsomboon, B., and Kusakabe, K. (2011). Social protection for women Homeworkers: A case of healthcare services in Thailand. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 31 (1/ 2) pp. 123-136 Netoiu, L. and Cârstina, S. (2014). Analysis of the correlation between minimum wage levels in the
  • 8. Africa International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (AIJMR) ISSN: 2523-9430 (Online Publication) ISSN: 2523-9422 (Print Publication) Vol. 2 (6) 1-18 November, 2018 www.oircjournals.org 26 | P a g e Maina (2018) www.oircjournals.org country, indicators of social protection and poverty threshold. Procedia Economics and Finance, 8: pp.505 – 509 Norton, A. Conway, T. Foster, M. (2001) Social Protection Concepts and Approaches: Implications for Policy and Practice in International Development. WP. 143 Centre for Aid and Public Expenditure. London: Overseas Development Institute Parmar, D., Williams, G., Dkhimi, F., Ndiaye, A., Asante, F. A., Arhinful, D. K., and Mladovsky, P. (2014) Enrolment of older people in social health protection programs in West Africa e Does social exclusion play a part? Social Science & Medicine, 119: 36-44 Pitruzzello, S. (2004) Trade Globalization, Economic Performance, and Social Protection: Nineteenth Century British Laissez-Faire and Post- World War II U.S.-Embedded Liberalism. International Organization, 58, (4) pp. 705-744 Richardson, E. T., Kelly, D., Sesay, O., Drasherb, M.D., Desaia, K. I., Frankfurterd, R. Farmer, E. P. and Barriea, B. M (2017) The symbolic violence of ‘outbreak’: A mixed-methods, quasi-experimental impact evaluation of social protection on Ebola survivor wellbeing. Social Science & Medicine, 195: pp. 77–82 Rosenberg, M., Pettifor, A., Nguyen, N., Westreich, D., Bor, J., Bärnighausen, T., Mee, P., Twine, R., Tollman, S., and Kahn, K., (2015). Relationship between Receipt of a Social Protection Grant for a Child and Second Pregnancy Rates among South African Women: A Cohort Study. PLoS ONE, 10(9): e0137352