SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Policy Matters :   Perspectives on Automotive  Technology and Fuel Economy John M. DeCicco  School of Natural Resources and Environment   & Energy Institute    University of Michigan Center for Automotive Research Management Briefing Seminars Traverse City, Michigan    August 2011
Why are we doing this?  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Policy rationales for fuel economy regulation:
A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for  U.S. Automobiles  (study released September 2010) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Goal: Result:  A tripling of new fleet efficiency is feasible and cost-effective by ~2035, without "plugging in"
Family Haulers Then and Now 1975 Mercury Marquis ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
1990 Ford Aerostar ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
2005 Ford Freestyle ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
New fleet average fuel economy New U.S. Light Duty Combined Fleet Source: U.S. EPA Fuel Economy Trends report 2010 On-road MPG Horsepower  to Weight Ratio Test Weight 2.6%/yr 2004-10 4.4%/yr 1975-87
Engine specific output trends Source: EPA Fuel Economy Trends report; selections from Ward's 10 Best Engines, 2006-10 53 kW/L
MIT simulation results Source: Kasseris & Heywood, SAE 2007-01-1605; to convert kJ/m to CAFE MPG, divide into 94.6.     A factor of three reduction (i.e., 3x fuel economy) is in sight.
Automobile efficiency is best viewed as a matter of  design priority ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Technical  vs.  Compatible  Design Strategies for Vehicle Efficiency ,[object Object],[object Object],COMPATIBLE TECHNICAL ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Efficiency Horizon Cost Model ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost curves New fleet average Retail Price Equivalent (RPE) Source:  A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles  (September 2010)
Costs vs. Benefits of Higher Efficiency Efficiency Horizon  model technology costs and discounted lifetime benefits (2010$)
White House CAFE Proposal 40 * *Plausible window-sticker rating, accounting for A/C credits and MPG shortfall.
Comparing Cost Estimates Projected cost of 56 mpg (nominal) in 2025 over MY 2010 fleet RPE in 2010$ Retail Price Equivalent (RPE) estimates from each study were adjusted relative to a common MY2010 baseline using costs from published CAFE rules and to 2010$ using GDP price deflator. Agency Report (Joint TAR, Sept 2010) value works from the estimate of $2,100 (2007$) for the lowest cost technology case (Path C), inflated to 2010$ and then adjusted upward by $997 to account for cumulative regulatory costs through the MY2012-16 Joint Rule.  *BCG-based estimate is extrapolation from their stated cost of ~$2,200 for a 40% CO 2  reduction. $2,700 $3,300 $6,800 For 54.5 mpg target,  a preliminary cost  estimate is ~$3,100 $3,100
New Car Price Trends Source: BEA Average Transaction Price per New Car, via Ward's Yearbook 2011 2010$ Dollars of the day
Cost    Price! ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Relative Technology Benefits and Costs GASOLINE HYBRID H 2  FUEL CELL PLUG-IN HYBRID BATTERY ELECTRIC Projected cost impacts and GHG reductions for efficiency- optimized midsize cars in 2035 relative to a 2005 baseline DIESEL TDI GASOLINE GASOLINE TDI An evolutionary path can carry the U.S. automobile fleet quite far with manageable costs for technology and minimal risks for customer acceptance.  Baseline Vehicle 
Conclusions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Thank you! ,[object Object],[object Object],John M. DeCicco, Ph.D.   Faculty Fellow • Michigan Memorial Phoenix Energy Institute (MMPEI)  Senior Lecturer • School of Natural Resources and Environment (SNRE)  University of Michigan, Ann Arbor email: DeCicco@umich.edu  http://www.snre.umich.edu/profile/decicco   http://www.energy.umich.edu/res/fac_10/fac_DeCiccoJ10.html

More Related Content

What's hot

CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09
CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09
CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09CALSTART
 
CALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 Final
CALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 FinalCALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 Final
CALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 FinalCALSTART
 
Global uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy system
Global uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy systemGlobal uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy system
Global uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy systemIEA-ETSAP
 
SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...
SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...
SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...SSCG Consulting
 
CALSTART Plug In Sources Of Power
CALSTART Plug In Sources Of PowerCALSTART Plug In Sources Of Power
CALSTART Plug In Sources Of PowerCALSTART
 
Electric vehicle battery recycling industry
Electric vehicle battery recycling industryElectric vehicle battery recycling industry
Electric vehicle battery recycling industrymaheshb73
 
Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...
Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...
Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...Umicore
 
Profit Potential of Green Airport Strategies
Profit Potential of Green Airport StrategiesProfit Potential of Green Airport Strategies
Profit Potential of Green Airport StrategiesJawad Rachami
 
Strategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief Summary
Strategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief SummaryStrategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief Summary
Strategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief SummarySandeep Kar
 
Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015
Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015
Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015Evan Yoo
 
Herc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock Pitch
Herc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock PitchHerc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock Pitch
Herc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock PitchMatthew Stackhouse
 
Remanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMs
Remanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMsRemanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMs
Remanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMsRon Giuntini
 
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3SustainableEnergyAut
 
From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...
From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...
From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...Leonardo ENERGY
 
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2SustainableEnergyAut
 
NCD5-Brief Summary
NCD5-Brief SummaryNCD5-Brief Summary
NCD5-Brief SummarySandeep Kar
 
CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem
 CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem
CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problemLeonardo ENERGY
 
Brief Summary_ND32_18
Brief Summary_ND32_18Brief Summary_ND32_18
Brief Summary_ND32_18Sandeep Kar
 
EV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction Initiative
EV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction InitiativeEV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction Initiative
EV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction Initiativelouisegosling
 

What's hot (20)

CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09
CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09
CALSTART Biomethane AB 118 Biofuels Workshop 9 09
 
CALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 Final
CALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 FinalCALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 Final
CALSTART Van Amburg Mobility 2030 8 18 09 Final
 
Global uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy system
Global uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy systemGlobal uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy system
Global uptake of electric vehicles to 2050 in a decarbonizing energy system
 
SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...
SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...
SSCG Auto Outlook - Global Electric Vehicle (EV) Market and Economic Mega Tre...
 
CALSTART Plug In Sources Of Power
CALSTART Plug In Sources Of PowerCALSTART Plug In Sources Of Power
CALSTART Plug In Sources Of Power
 
Electric vehicle battery recycling industry
Electric vehicle battery recycling industryElectric vehicle battery recycling industry
Electric vehicle battery recycling industry
 
Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...
Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...
Umicore Capital Markets Day 2015 : Energy & Surface Technologies | Rechargeab...
 
Profit Potential of Green Airport Strategies
Profit Potential of Green Airport StrategiesProfit Potential of Green Airport Strategies
Profit Potential of Green Airport Strategies
 
Strategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief Summary
Strategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief SummaryStrategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief Summary
Strategic Analysis of Global Low-cost Truck Maket: A Brief Summary
 
Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015
Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015
Greenbrier Companies CRC Stock Pitch Competition Spring 2015
 
Herc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock Pitch
Herc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock PitchHerc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock Pitch
Herc Rentals (NYSE:HRI) Stock Pitch
 
Remanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMs
Remanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMsRemanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMs
Remanufactured Products: A New Business Model For Light-Vehicle OEMs
 
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 3
 
Global Lightweight Vehicle Developments and Policy Design Implications - Nic ...
Global Lightweight Vehicle Developments and Policy Design Implications - Nic ...Global Lightweight Vehicle Developments and Policy Design Implications - Nic ...
Global Lightweight Vehicle Developments and Policy Design Implications - Nic ...
 
From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...
From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...
From EU Project to Market Enabler: Creating the Marketplace for Sustainable E...
 
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2
SEAI - National Energy Research and Policy Conference 2021 - Session 2
 
NCD5-Brief Summary
NCD5-Brief SummaryNCD5-Brief Summary
NCD5-Brief Summary
 
CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem
 CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem
CO2 emissions of vehicles: a broad and persistent problem
 
Brief Summary_ND32_18
Brief Summary_ND32_18Brief Summary_ND32_18
Brief Summary_ND32_18
 
EV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction Initiative
EV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction InitiativeEV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction Initiative
EV Battery Tech: 5th Global Cost Reduction Initiative
 

Viewers also liked

Power Pointa
Power PointaPower Pointa
Power PointaEider85
 
Grey Street Studios Portfolio
Grey Street Studios PortfolioGrey Street Studios Portfolio
Grey Street Studios PortfolioGreyStreetStudios
 
Presentatie ervaringen lesthema
Presentatie ervaringen lesthemaPresentatie ervaringen lesthema
Presentatie ervaringen lesthemaAnnebet Neef
 
Edi Remittance Sample
Edi Remittance SampleEdi Remittance Sample
Edi Remittance Sampleamartyaghosh
 
Sensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig Intergebruik
Sensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig IntergebruikSensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig Intergebruik
Sensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig Intergebruikevyanyssa
 
CMI Business Continuity Report 2008
CMI Business Continuity Report 2008CMI Business Continuity Report 2008
CMI Business Continuity Report 2008Navneet Shrivastava
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Power Pointa
Power PointaPower Pointa
Power Pointa
 
Open House
Open HouseOpen House
Open House
 
Grey Street Studios Portfolio
Grey Street Studios PortfolioGrey Street Studios Portfolio
Grey Street Studios Portfolio
 
Cortex
CortexCortex
Cortex
 
Presentatie ervaringen lesthema
Presentatie ervaringen lesthemaPresentatie ervaringen lesthema
Presentatie ervaringen lesthema
 
Edi Remittance Sample
Edi Remittance SampleEdi Remittance Sample
Edi Remittance Sample
 
Sensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig Intergebruik
Sensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig IntergebruikSensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig Intergebruik
Sensibiliseringcampagne Voor Veilig Intergebruik
 
CMI Business Continuity Report 2008
CMI Business Continuity Report 2008CMI Business Continuity Report 2008
CMI Business Continuity Report 2008
 

Similar to Policy Matters: Automotive Tech & Fuel Economy

A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles
A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. AutomobilesA Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles
A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobilesjmdecicco
 
Advanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icct
Advanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icctAdvanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icct
Advanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icctCALSTART
 
Toward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate Policy
Toward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate PolicyToward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate Policy
Toward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate Policyjmdecicco
 
Fuel car cell fuel car
Fuel car cell fuel carFuel car cell fuel car
Fuel car cell fuel carSANJAY DURAI
 
Scenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance Costs
Scenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance CostsScenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance Costs
Scenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance CostsJoel Wenger
 
Report on hybird 26sep
Report on hybird  26sepReport on hybird  26sep
Report on hybird 26sepshubham saini
 
“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...
“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...
“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...BHOMA RAM
 
Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...
Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...
Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...Forth
 
Ford Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John Viera
Ford Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John VieraFord Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John Viera
Ford Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John VieraSustainable Brands
 
Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...
Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...
Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...FIA Foundation
 
PowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docx
PowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docxPowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docx
PowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docxpauline234567
 
Lucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsession
Lucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsessionLucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsession
Lucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsessiontehamoud
 
SA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINAL
SA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINALSA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINAL
SA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINALBrian James
 
SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)
SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)
SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)Brian James
 
Forecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving Innovation
Forecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving InnovationForecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving Innovation
Forecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving InnovationAndrew Wilhelm
 

Similar to Policy Matters: Automotive Tech & Fuel Economy (20)

A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles
A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. AutomobilesA Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles
A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles
 
Advanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icct
Advanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icctAdvanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icct
Advanced clean-vehicles-john-german-icct
 
Toward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate Policy
Toward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate PolicyToward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate Policy
Toward New Frameworks for Transportation Climate Policy
 
Vehicle fuel economy standards and feebates
Vehicle fuel economy standards and feebatesVehicle fuel economy standards and feebates
Vehicle fuel economy standards and feebates
 
Fuel Economy or Fool Economy?
Fuel Economy or Fool Economy?Fuel Economy or Fool Economy?
Fuel Economy or Fool Economy?
 
Fuel car cell fuel car
Fuel car cell fuel carFuel car cell fuel car
Fuel car cell fuel car
 
Scenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance Costs
Scenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance CostsScenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance Costs
Scenaria Perspective #1 - 2025 CAFE Compliance Costs
 
Report on hybird 26sep
Report on hybird  26sepReport on hybird  26sep
Report on hybird 26sep
 
“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...
“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...
“Comparative analysis of consumer preference between Hyundai’s i-10 and Marut...
 
Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...
Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...
Mike Tinskey, Ford -- "Trends in 'Energi': Impacting the Way we Refuel our Ve...
 
Ford Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John Viera
Ford Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John VieraFord Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John Viera
Ford Motor Company's Road to Sustainability - John Viera
 
Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...
Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...
Global Trends in Passenger Vehicle Fuel Economy Standards Drew Kodjak, Execut...
 
PowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docx
PowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docxPowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docx
PowerPoint_3E_Garden_Instructions.docxGrader - InstructionsPP.docx
 
Hec final
Hec finalHec final
Hec final
 
The Electric Car Tipping Point
The Electric Car Tipping PointThe Electric Car Tipping Point
The Electric Car Tipping Point
 
Lucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsession
Lucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsessionLucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsession
Lucintel globalcompositemarketanalysis-acma2012-educationalsession
 
SA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINAL
SA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINALSA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINAL
SA 2014 Transportation Cost Analysis Final Report Revision 1- FINAL
 
SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)
SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)
SA 2015 Transportation Fuel Cell Cost Analysis (Auto and Bus)
 
Forecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving Innovation
Forecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving InnovationForecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving Innovation
Forecasting Hybrid Aircraft: How Changing Policy is Driving Innovation
 
Moving Cooler: Study Findings
Moving Cooler: Study FindingsMoving Cooler: Study Findings
Moving Cooler: Study Findings
 

Policy Matters: Automotive Tech & Fuel Economy

  • 1. Policy Matters : Perspectives on Automotive Technology and Fuel Economy John M. DeCicco School of Natural Resources and Environment & Energy Institute  University of Michigan Center for Automotive Research Management Briefing Seminars Traverse City, Michigan  August 2011
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. New fleet average fuel economy New U.S. Light Duty Combined Fleet Source: U.S. EPA Fuel Economy Trends report 2010 On-road MPG Horsepower to Weight Ratio Test Weight 2.6%/yr 2004-10 4.4%/yr 1975-87
  • 8. Engine specific output trends Source: EPA Fuel Economy Trends report; selections from Ward's 10 Best Engines, 2006-10 53 kW/L
  • 9. MIT simulation results Source: Kasseris & Heywood, SAE 2007-01-1605; to convert kJ/m to CAFE MPG, divide into 94.6.  A factor of three reduction (i.e., 3x fuel economy) is in sight.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. Cost curves New fleet average Retail Price Equivalent (RPE) Source: A Fuel Efficiency Horizon for U.S. Automobiles (September 2010)
  • 14. Costs vs. Benefits of Higher Efficiency Efficiency Horizon model technology costs and discounted lifetime benefits (2010$)
  • 15. White House CAFE Proposal 40 * *Plausible window-sticker rating, accounting for A/C credits and MPG shortfall.
  • 16. Comparing Cost Estimates Projected cost of 56 mpg (nominal) in 2025 over MY 2010 fleet RPE in 2010$ Retail Price Equivalent (RPE) estimates from each study were adjusted relative to a common MY2010 baseline using costs from published CAFE rules and to 2010$ using GDP price deflator. Agency Report (Joint TAR, Sept 2010) value works from the estimate of $2,100 (2007$) for the lowest cost technology case (Path C), inflated to 2010$ and then adjusted upward by $997 to account for cumulative regulatory costs through the MY2012-16 Joint Rule. *BCG-based estimate is extrapolation from their stated cost of ~$2,200 for a 40% CO 2 reduction. $2,700 $3,300 $6,800 For 54.5 mpg target, a preliminary cost estimate is ~$3,100 $3,100
  • 17. New Car Price Trends Source: BEA Average Transaction Price per New Car, via Ward's Yearbook 2011 2010$ Dollars of the day
  • 18.
  • 19. Relative Technology Benefits and Costs GASOLINE HYBRID H 2 FUEL CELL PLUG-IN HYBRID BATTERY ELECTRIC Projected cost impacts and GHG reductions for efficiency- optimized midsize cars in 2035 relative to a 2005 baseline DIESEL TDI GASOLINE GASOLINE TDI An evolutionary path can carry the U.S. automobile fleet quite far with manageable costs for technology and minimal risks for customer acceptance. Baseline Vehicle 
  • 20.
  • 21.

Editor's Notes

  1. Updated using 2010 FE Trends report: http://www.epa.gov/otaq/cert/mpg/fetrends/420s10002-exec-sum-tables.xls (acc 24 Nov 2010) Note large single-year MPG jump by 6.7% 2008-09
  2. Source: historical data from EPA FE Trends report; leading engines selected from recent Ward's "10 Best Engines" award winners As of 2010, average specific power reached 53 kW/L Various Calcs WKG.xls [Eng]
  3. Efficiency Horizons study Tech & Cost WKG, normalized adjusted costs (21 Jan 2011)