MANAGEMENT SERVICES
Organisational Effectiveness2A (OEF22A2)
Work Measurement Techniques and Applications
Mr. V . Lukonga
University of Johannesburg
South Africa
Auckland Park Campus Bunting Road
Concowan Building
2.
2
RULES
• YOUR ATTENDANCEIS CRUCIAL (VERY IMPORTANT)
• TESTS RESULTS ARE ONLY SUBMITTED IN THE CLASS NOT
IN THE OFFICE
• NO CHANGES WILL MADE ON THE MARKS FOR THE TEST
YOU WROTE DURING THE ISSUING OF RESULTS IN THE
CLASS IF YOU WERE NOT IN THE CLASS
• YOUR PROBLEM IS NOT MY PROBLEM
• NO EXCUSE WILL BE TAKEN
• RESPECT FOR OTHERS, STAFF AND FACILITIES
• TEAMWORK NOT GROUP WORK
• TEST DATES ARE NOT POSPONED
• I DO NOT BELIEVE IN A SCOPE (BECAUSE THIS IS
MAGAZINE THAT IS FICTITIOUS)
4
Introduction
• In OrganisationalEffectiveness 1A the term
“Management Services,” was defined as a selection of
people with the knowledge and skills that, generally,
advise the Management of any organisation on better
and more efficient ways of working. The module
focused on a part of management services, namely,
work study, which is broadly divided into method
study and work measurement.
• Most of the aspects discussed in Organisational
Effectiveness 1A were based on method study as one
of the techniques of work study.
5.
5
Introduction (Cont.)
• Whereasin Organisational Effectiveness 1B focused
on work measurement as the second technique of
work study which is regarded as the application of
techniques designed to establish the time for a
qualified worker to carry out a task at a defined rate of
working. (See Kanawaty, p. 249).
• Now Organisational Effectiveness 2 will continue with
Work measurement including direct and indirect work
measurement techniques.
6.
6
Introduction (Cont.)
• TheO&W profession in SA existed under the auspices
(support) of the SA Institute of Organization and
Methods (SAIOM) since its establishment on 3 May
1960.
• SAIOM provided the infrastructure to facilitate training
and it gave recognition to its members. It also
provided a forum for the development of organization
and work study techniques and the dissemination of
information to its members.
7.
7
Introduction (Cont.)
•By October1993, the Institute transformed itself into
The Southern Africa Institute of Management Services
(SAIMAS).
•This was in reaction to the general development in
knowledge and technology and in various fields of
business.
•Many of these fields were regarded as part of
Management Services.
•It was realized that O&W was too a restricted
description of what the people concerned were actually
doing and the name Management Services was chosen
as a replacement.
8.
8
Introduction (Cont.)
• Thisdevelopment made the professional field wider
and more accessible to other related functions within
the management services field, thus rendering a more
comprehensive service to its members.
9.
9
1. Role ofManagement
Services (MS)
• Definition
• Areas of the business where MS is applied
• Benefits in management services
• Techniques used by MS practitioners
• MS as a tool in strategic management
• Skills acquired by MS
10.
10
Definition
• MS iswidely used, but with different meanings
• MS(s) are generally used by those groups of activities, which assist
management in the improvement, and control of effective and
efficient work practices
• Work practices take place in the following areas:
- System
- Structure
- Methods
- Procedures
- Environment
15
Procedures (Cont.)
Procedures maybe different:
1) Some are in sequence – one step follow the other
Process
A
Final
Product
Start End
Process
D
Process
C
Process
B
Inputs
16.
16
Procedures (Cont.)
2) Somemay be parallel at the beginning – first two steps happen simultaneously
Process
A
Process
B
Process
C
Process
D
Final
Product
Start End
Inputs
18
Areas of thebusiness where
MS is applied
• Business Development and Design;
• Financial Management;
• Information Management;
• Organisational Transformation;
• Human Resource Management;
• Operations Management
• Quality Management, etc.
20
Qualities Of MS
Rememberqualities of MS which support the
benefits:
• Sincerity and honesty
• Self confidence
• Tact
• Enthusiasm
• Interest
• Good appearance
- Educational background
- Experience
21.
21
Techniques used byMS
practitioners
• Work Study
• Organisation and Methods
• Operation Research
• Data Processing
• Ergonomics
• Economic Forecasting
• Business process reengineering
• Job Evaluation, etc.
23
2. Methods, standards,and
work design : Productivity Ch1
• Productivity and basic human needs
• Definition of productivity
• Productivity improvement
• Productivity measurement
• Misunderstanding concerning Productivity
• Factors leading to Efficient Production
• Guides in Productivity Improvement
• Five Step Method Improvement Plan
24.
24
Productivity (Cont.)
• DefineSpecific Resource Productivity and Total
Resource Productivity
• Calculate Specific Resource Productivity and Total
Resource Productivity
• Interpret results and make appropriate
recommendations
25.
Productivity Importance
(Worldwide) Freivalds(2009)
• Certain changes continually take place in the industrial and
business environment must be considered both economically
and practically.
• These include globalisation of both the market and producer,
the growth of the service sector, the computerisation of all facets
of an enterprise, and the ever expanding applications of the
Internet and Web.
• The only way the business or enterprise can grow and increase
its profitability is by increasing productivity.
• The fundamental tools that result in increased productivity are:
methods, time study standards (work measurement
techniques) and work design.
25
26.
Productivity Importance
(Worldwide) Freivalds(2009)
26
• Over the last 100 years (from 1909), productivity in the United
State (US) has increased approximately 4% per year.
• In the last ten years the U.S. rate or productivity has been
exceeded by that of Japan, Korea, and Germany, and it may be
soon challenged by China.
• Of the total cost of typical metal products manufacturing
enterprise, 12 % is direct labour, 45% is direct material, and
43% is overhead (e.g. rent, lighting, insurance, and wages).
• Sales, finance, production, engineering, cost, maintenance
and management provide fertile areas for the application of
methods, standards, and work design.
27.
Productivity Importance
(Worldwide) Freivalds(2009)
• Today U.S. businesses and industries are, by necessity,
restructuring themselves by downsizing, to operate more
effectively in an increasingly competitive worlds.
• U.S. now is addressing cost reduction and quality
improvement through productivity improvement.
• U.S. is also critically examining all non value business
components (those that do not contribute to their profitability).
They are: maintenance, transportation, sales and
management.
27
28.
Traditional Areas Contributingto
Productivity Improvement - Freivalds
(2009)
Traditional Areas (Disciplines):
• Engineering
• Industrial management
• Management Services
• Business administration
• Industrial psychology
• Labour management relations
28
29.
Traditional Areas Contributingto
Productivity Improvement - Freivalds
(2009)
• These areas of opportunity are not only contributing to
manufacturing industries but also equally important in service
industries.
• These service industries include department stores, hotels,
educational institutions, hospitals, banks, airlines, insurance
offices, military service centers, government agencies, and
retirement complexes.
• In U.S. 10% of the total labour force is employed in
manufacturing.
• The remaining 90% is engaged in service industries.
• Similarly, methods, standards, and work design activity are also
the key part of productivity improvement in service industries.
29
30.
Techniques used byMS (and
other disciplines) - Freivalds (2009)
• Work measurement
• Work methods and design
• Production engineering
• Manufacturing analysis and control
• Facilities planning
• Wage administration
• Ergonomics and safety
• Production and inventory control
• Quality control
30
31.
31
Productivity and basichuman
needs
• Recall from the 1st unit (introduction and history of
work-study) how needs motivated the Egyptians,
Romans and Chinese to build structures to satisfy
those needs. (Read that part again).
• Today still, needs are the driving forces or
motivation for people to do things to satisfy those
needs. Only in the less civilised and most poor
countries today, people will work to only sustain
themselves from day to day.
32.
32
Productivity and basichuman
needs (Cont.)
• In our modern, competitive and civilised world,
people cannot work on their own to satisfy only
personal needs. There simply is no suitable land in
say, Johannesburg, to cultivate maize or potatoes
or whatever a person needs to survive.
• The only (acceptable) way people can satisfy needs, is
to join a group and work with others in an organised
manner. This means joining a business or starting your
own. Working together for the same goal creates
wealth for many people and also the country as a
whole.
33.
33
Productivity and basichuman
needs (Cont.)
• Wealth creation basically is the process by which people
and the State earn money that is used to create more
means such as hospitals, schools, roads, etc. It means that
more people earn money with which basic human needs
such as food and clothing can be bought. Because people
work together, businesses can survive, make a profit and
eventually, the state can collect taxes that are used to run
the country.
• The question is: How does all this concern the work-
study official? The reason is that one must understand
why people work and what businesses must do to
remain in business.
35
Definition of productivity
•Is the ratio of output to input
• Is a yardstick of efficiency whereby the output/input performance
of an economy, a sector, a business, or a function of a business
is measured against the performance in a previous period or
against the performance of other businesses or against set
standards.
37
Concepts involved in
productivityCont.)
• Output – includes all goods and services that meet
human needs. Output may be expressed in physical
units or in terms of money.
38.
38
Concepts involved in
productivityCont.)
• Economic motive – is man’s striving to satisfy a
tremendous (great) and indeed almost unlimited
needs.
• Economic principle – is to obtain the greatest
possible satisfaction of needs with limited resources.
• Effectiveness – implies the attainment of a desired
goal (in other words the right job has been done,
irrespective of the method or techniques used in so
doing – doing the right thing).
39.
39
Concepts involved in
productivityCont.)
• Efficiency – implies the right technique or method has
been used for doing the job or achieving a goal (doing
things right)
• Profitability – is the relationship expressed as a
percentage between profits made during a specific
period and the capital used to make the profits.
• Turnover – if the turnover of a business has
increased, it means that a business has produced
more of a specific product or service in a certain
period, than in the previous corresponding period.
40.
40
Productivity Improvement
•Is theoptimum combination and maximum utilization of all
the
productive resources engaged in the business, so that only
the economically unavoidable costs are retained in the
business in order to maximize the profitability of the business
in the long-term.
• Refers to the increase in output per work-hour or time expended,
(Freivalds, 2009:1)
•Let suppose the company produces 2000 tables for 8 man hours
for this year and decides to increase production by 100 tables the
following year, but still using the same hours (8 man hours) still
productivity increases.
41.
41
Productivity Improvement
This yearFollowing year
Manpower SRP: Units of
Output/ Man hours
2000/8 man hours
= 250 units/ man hour
2100/ 8 Man hours
= 263 units/ man hour
PI = R2/ R1
= 263/ 250
= 105% , Therefore 105 – 100 = 5% increase or improvement in
productivity
42.
42
Productivity Measurement
• Meansif you measure what you are talking about and are
able to express it in numbers, you know what you are talking
about, but if you cannot measure it or express it in numbers,
your knowledge is incomplete and unsatisfactory.
• e.g. if there is no time table that the lecturer cannot use to attend
his venues on expected time
• he/ she cannot be able to control the situation in terms of his or
her job as a lecturer.
43.
43
Objectives of Productivity
Measurement
•To control the extent to which various functions,
departments, groups operations and individual workers
are efficient.
• To cast light on the remuneration that should be
allocated to the various factors of production.
• To make proper planning and business forecasting
possible.
• To determine which factors in the organisation,
particularly influence productivity.
44.
44
Objectives of Productivity
Measurement(Cont.)
•To detect changes in output in respect of alternative
inputs, in order to correct undesirable action and to
exploit desirable methods/ techniques.
• To serve as a psychological stimulus towards better
performance by management, supervisors and
workers.
45.
45
Misunderstanding concerning
Productivity
(1)Higher productiondoes not necessarily mean higher
productivity.
(2)Higher profits does not necessarily mean higher
productivity.
(3)Cost reduction does not necessarily mean higher
productivity.
(4)Productivity improvement does not necessarily mean
harder work.
(5)Productivity improvement does not necessarily mean
unemployment.
46.
46
Misunderstanding concerning
Productivity (Cont.)
Output/Input Performance: Current Situation Changes
Misunderstanding (1) Output = 200 units
Input = 10 material units
Output = 220 units
Input = 15 material units
Misunderstanding (2) Output = R2000 value
Input = R1500 cost
R2000 = R1.33/R1
R1500
Output = R2200 value
Input = R1800 cost
R2200 = R1.22/R1
R1800
Misunderstanding (3) Output = R2000 value
Input = R1500 cost
R2000 = R1.33/R1
R1500
Output = R2200 value
Input = R1750 cost
R2200 = R1.26/R1
R1750
47.
47
Misunderstanding concerning
Productivity (Cont.)
Output/Input Performance: Current Situation Changes
Misunderstanding (4) Carrying heavy material using
hands
Simplifying the job by
using machine (e.g.
forklift)
Misunderstanding (5) Redundant workers Training is needed to
develop employees
48.
48
Factors leading toEfficient
Production
• Individual – the organization must ensure there is
clear work specifications and aptitude testing for
the employee. Training and practice is also
essential to build the employee’s skill.
• Supervisor – the supervisor must make ensure that
communication is enhanced and feedback is given
to employees on regular basis.
• The physical environment – processes and
conditions must be optimized.
49.
49
Factors leading toEfficient
Production (Cont.)
• Individual + Supervisor + physical environment = skill,
the will to do the, job which must lead to efficient
work
50.
50
Guides in Productivity
Improvement
1)Eliminate non productive work
- Proper training
- Improve layout
- Correct equipment
2) Eliminate Spoils material
- Correct handling method
- Material-economic design
3) Eliminate non productive time
- Appropriate planning for workflow
- Regular measurement of employee performance
51.
51
Guides in Productivity
Improvement(Cont.)
4) Eliminate delays in material supply
Just in time delivery
5) Eliminate losses
• Improve quality material
• Correct machines/ equipment essential
• Install preventive maintenance plans
• Security improvement
• Safety practice monitoring
52.
52
Guides in Productivity
Improvement(Cont.)
6) Labour quality improvement
• Select and test against job specifications
• Train employees
7) Improve communication
• Clear instructions
• Ensure feedback
• Distribute comprehensive job guides with standards
53.
53
Guides in Productivity
Improvement(Cont.)
8) Minimise de-motivators
• Proper administrative practices
• Correct adverse working conditions
• Train supervisors in labour relations
• Improved relationships
• Improve incorrect wages
9) Maximise motivators
• Recognition
• Achievement
• Advancement
54.
54
Five Step Method
ImprovementPlan
1) Challenge the necessity of the operation
• Critical questioning Matrix(4W’s & H)
• Eliminate or combine activities
2) Analyse the work done
• Inspect work
• Identify chart – use the relevant chart for each step
• Inspect step after chart has been used
55.
55
Five Step MethodImprovement
Plan (Cont.)
3) Question every step
• Use analysis Sheet for elimination of unnecessary
steps
• Eliminate delays
• Check if training is acquired by the employees
• Review area
• Revise method
56.
56
Five Step MethodImprovement
Plan (Cont.)
4) Develop a new method
• Check the objective of the operation
• Eliminate unnecessary work
• Make changes
• Check against the guides to productivity improvement
• Test the new method and adjust if necessary
57.
57
Five Step MethodImprovement
Plan (Cont.)
5) Apply the new method
• Submit proposal
• Obtain approval
• Train workers in the new method
• Increase supervision
• Get participation
58.
Methods and standardsscope:
Productivity - Freivalds (2009)
Opportunities for saving through the applications of
methods engineering (Method Study) and time
study:
• Work content added by defects in design or specification of
product.
• Work content added by inefficient work design and methods of
manufacture or operation.
• Time added due to shortcoming of management.
• Time added due to shortcoming of worker.
58
59.
(A)Work content addedby defects in design
or specification of product
59
• Bad design
•Lack of standardisation
•Incorrect quality standards
•Design demands
60.
(B)Work content addedby inefficient work
design and methods of manufacture or
operation
60
• Wrong machine used
• Process not operated correctly
• Wrong tools used
• Bad layout
• Operators’ bad working methods
61.
(C) Time addeddue to shortcoming of
management
61
• Excessive product variety
• Lack of standardisation
• Design changes
• Bad planning of work
• Lack of raw material
• Plant breakdowns
• Plant/ factory in bad conditions
• Accidents, ineffective time
• Weak supervision
62.
(D)Time added dueto shortcoming of
worker
62
• Working less than normal pace
• Taking excessive allowances
• Careless workmanship
• Accidents and ineffective time
63.
Methods and standardsscope:
Productivity - Freivalds (2009)
• Methods engineering
• Standards
• Work design
63
64.
Methods engineering -Freivalds
(2009)
• Select the project (job to be studied)
• Get and present the data (recording data)
• Analyse the data (Examine the data critically)
• Develop the ideal method (new method)
• Present and Install (implement) the new method
• Develop a job analysis (new method)
• Establish time standards
• Follow up (maintain) the method
64
65.
Standards - Freivalds(2009)
• Standards are the end results of time study or work measurement.
• This technique establishes a time standard allowed to perform a
given task based on the following: measurement of work content
considering also fatigue, personal allowance, and unavoidable
delays.
• Management services analysts (and other analysts in other areas
for opportunity) use several techniques to a establish a standard.
• The following MS techniques are used: 1) stopwatch time study,
2) computerised data collection, 3) standard data,
• 4) predetermined time systems, 5) work sampling, and 6)
estimates based on historical data.
•
65
66.
Standards (Continues) -Freivalds
(2009)
• Wage payment activities also is performed in concert with those
responsible for conducting job analyses and job evaluations, so
that these closely related activities function smoothly.
66
67.
Work design (Humanfactor/
Ergonomics) - Freivalds (2009)
Chapter 4 to Chapter 7 of Freivalds (2009):
• Manual Work
• Equipment
• Machine Work
• Work Environmental Design
• Cognitive Work
67
68.
Objectives of Methods,Standards
and Work design Freivalds (2009)
• To minimise the time required to perform tasks
• To continually improve the quality and reliability of products and
services
• To conserve resources and minimise cost by specifying the most
appropriate direct and indirect materials for the production of
goods and services
• To consider the cost and availability of power
• To maximise the safety, health, and well being of all employees
• To produce with an increasing concern for protecting the
environment
• To follow a human program of management that results in job
interest and satisfaction for each employee.
68