SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
notes on informal
urban livelihoods
      jorge carrillo-rodriguez
  {   11th March 2013
Dimensions
     Lack of income and productive assets

     Lack of basic services

     Lack of power


    Barriers
     Physical: distance, accessibility
     Financial: fees, regulations
     Legal: registrations, citizenship
     Socio-cultural discrimination
     Political


poverty and vulnerability
   Monetized economy
       Exclusion by design
       Informal costs
       Opportunity costs
       Urban penalty
       Eviction and environmental hazards
       Social capital
       Information




urban living
“Informality is a term that has the dubious distinction
of combining maximum policy importance and political
salience with minimal conceptual clarity and coherence
in the analytical literature.” (Kanbur, 2009)

           terms used interchangeably, i.e. informal
            economy, informal sector, informal
            employment, etc.
           difficulty in identifying the boundaries between
            formal and informal
           misconceptions on the role, contribution and
            impact


informality
   Informal economy
       Informal sector
       Informal employment

       Informal work
       Informal workers

    Related terms
     Shadow/underground economy

     Informal settings




defining terms
Basic     {
Complementary     {
     “Holistic”
                  {

  finding boundaries
   Informality  poverty
       Large IE = weak FE
       Small size limits dynamism & growth
       Exploitative

       Safety net
       Low entry cost
       Flexible and heterogeneous
       Local knowledge/innovation




perspectives
   Capabilities
       Assets (material and social)
       Strategies



    A livelihood is sustainable when it can cope with and
    recover from external stresses and shocks, maintain or
    enhance its capabilities and assets now and in the future
    while not undermining the natural resource base.




livelihood
 Human: skills, knowledge, ability to work,
     health
    Financial: savings, credit, remittances,

     transfers
    Social: networks, trust, services

    Physical: infrastructure, transport, shelter




capabilities and assets
 More income
     Increased well-being

     Reduced vulnerability

     Increased resilience

     Sustainable living standard




livelihood outcomes
Mainly urban                                               Urban and rural
                                                  Income raising
•   domestic service - e.g. cleaning and childcare (esp.   •   home gardening
    girls and women)                                       •   processing, hawking, vending transporting goods
•   urban agriculture                                      •   casual labour/piece work
•   renting out rooms                                      •   specialised occupations (e.g. tinkering, food
•   multiple jobs (formal/informal)                            preparation, shoe-shining)
                                                           •   mortgaging and selling assets
                                                           •   migration for seasonal work

                                              Lowering expenditure
• scavenging                                               • changes in purchasing habits (e.g. small frequent
• reduce transport costs                                     purchases, rather than cheap bulk buys, and/or poorer
                                                             quality food)
                                                           • discrimination and triage (e.g. giving less food to
                                                             weaker/ less favoured household members).


                                                   Social capital
• shared childcare and for elders                          • mutual help e.g. loans from friends or saving groups
• informal worker’s associations                           • family splitting
• collective action                                        • remittances from household members working away




    Strategies
   Worldwide: around 66% of total employment
       Developed Countries: 25-40% of total
        employment

       Developing Countries: 50-90% of total
        employment
           Highest: Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia
            (as high as 90% in many countries)
           Medium: South East and East Asia + Latin
            America (around 65% in most countries)
           Lowest: North Africa and West Asia (around
            50% in most countries)


informal is normal
It does not mean
     Simple regulation and taxation



    but also
     getting registered and paying taxes

     being covered by legal and social protection

     receiving support to become productive and
      remunerative
     becoming organized and gaining voice and
      power
                                           (Chen, 2009)


formalization
Formalizing the Informal: not just regulation + taxation but
  also…
        assets + opportunities + productivity-enhancing support
        economic rights: commercial + labor + property
        social protection
        organization and representative voice

  “Informalizing” the Formal: reform of economic policies
  and institutions to include the informal economy/workforce
  as legitimate…
        part of the total economy
        target of economic policies + incentives
        stakeholder in policy-making and rule-setting
         institutions

                                                         (Chen, 2009)

new urban economy
Thank you


www.readingdevelopment.info

More Related Content

Similar to Notes on informal urban livelihoods

Gender, agriculture, and assets conceptual framework
Gender, agriculture, and assets conceptual frameworkGender, agriculture, and assets conceptual framework
Gender, agriculture, and assets conceptual frameworkgenderassets
 
Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1
Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1
Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1drshirleyt
 
Urban economy literature study
Urban economy literature studyUrban economy literature study
Urban economy literature studyAditi Garg
 
Sarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert Meeting
Sarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert MeetingSarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert Meeting
Sarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert MeetingOECD Development Centre, Paris
 
Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5mlabhand
 
Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5mlabhand
 
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industryLesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industryMervyn Maico Aldana
 
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industryLesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industryMervyn Maico Aldana
 
Systems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGM
Systems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGMSystems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGM
Systems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGMVolunteerScotland
 
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls Migrating out of Poverty
 
Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...
Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...
Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...Sustainable Lifestyles Research Group
 
Measures of development_ppt
Measures of development_pptMeasures of development_ppt
Measures of development_pptcindipatten
 
Sustainable Development
Sustainable DevelopmentSustainable Development
Sustainable DevelopmentUNDP Eurasia
 
Changing The Disability Poverty Paradigm(1)
Changing The  Disability    Poverty  Paradigm(1)Changing The  Disability    Poverty  Paradigm(1)
Changing The Disability Poverty Paradigm(1)Allison Wohl
 

Similar to Notes on informal urban livelihoods (20)

Livelihoods
LivelihoodsLivelihoods
Livelihoods
 
Theory of Labour
Theory of LabourTheory of Labour
Theory of Labour
 
Gender, agriculture, and assets conceptual framework
Gender, agriculture, and assets conceptual frameworkGender, agriculture, and assets conceptual framework
Gender, agriculture, and assets conceptual framework
 
Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1
Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1
Foodsecurityandsustainablelivelihoods1
 
Urban economy literature study
Urban economy literature studyUrban economy literature study
Urban economy literature study
 
P3
P3P3
P3
 
Sarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert Meeting
Sarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert MeetingSarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert Meeting
Sarah Gammage's presentation - OECD - PGD Expert Meeting
 
Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5
 
Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5Rural Sourcing_v5
Rural Sourcing_v5
 
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industryLesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
 
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industryLesson 6   environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
Lesson 6 environmental scanning & forces shaping the industry
 
Lesson 7 CMICE
Lesson 7 CMICELesson 7 CMICE
Lesson 7 CMICE
 
Systems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGM
Systems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGMSystems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGM
Systems change and collaboration​ Presentation VS AGM
 
Demographic. Social, and Economic Drivers (CPWF-GD workshop, Sept 2011)
Demographic. Social, and Economic Drivers (CPWF-GD workshop, Sept 2011)Demographic. Social, and Economic Drivers (CPWF-GD workshop, Sept 2011)
Demographic. Social, and Economic Drivers (CPWF-GD workshop, Sept 2011)
 
Gender Equality in Rural Africa
Gender Equality in Rural AfricaGender Equality in Rural Africa
Gender Equality in Rural Africa
 
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
Supporting the livelihood transition: jobs, migration, women and girls
 
Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...
Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...
Tim Jackson - The Altruist Within: in pursuit of sustainability and justice i...
 
Measures of development_ppt
Measures of development_pptMeasures of development_ppt
Measures of development_ppt
 
Sustainable Development
Sustainable DevelopmentSustainable Development
Sustainable Development
 
Changing The Disability Poverty Paradigm(1)
Changing The  Disability    Poverty  Paradigm(1)Changing The  Disability    Poverty  Paradigm(1)
Changing The Disability Poverty Paradigm(1)
 

More from Jorge Carrillo

Urban communities - Class notes
Urban communities - Class notesUrban communities - Class notes
Urban communities - Class notesJorge Carrillo
 
Development Challenges in South-East Asia
Development Challenges in South-East AsiaDevelopment Challenges in South-East Asia
Development Challenges in South-East AsiaJorge Carrillo
 
Notes on participation
Notes on participationNotes on participation
Notes on participationJorge Carrillo
 
Development challenges of income support and social protection
Development challenges of income support and social protectionDevelopment challenges of income support and social protection
Development challenges of income support and social protectionJorge Carrillo
 
Notes on social protection and social justice
Notes on social protection and social justiceNotes on social protection and social justice
Notes on social protection and social justiceJorge Carrillo
 

More from Jorge Carrillo (6)

Urbanization in Asia
Urbanization in AsiaUrbanization in Asia
Urbanization in Asia
 
Urban communities - Class notes
Urban communities - Class notesUrban communities - Class notes
Urban communities - Class notes
 
Development Challenges in South-East Asia
Development Challenges in South-East AsiaDevelopment Challenges in South-East Asia
Development Challenges in South-East Asia
 
Notes on participation
Notes on participationNotes on participation
Notes on participation
 
Development challenges of income support and social protection
Development challenges of income support and social protectionDevelopment challenges of income support and social protection
Development challenges of income support and social protection
 
Notes on social protection and social justice
Notes on social protection and social justiceNotes on social protection and social justice
Notes on social protection and social justice
 

Notes on informal urban livelihoods

  • 1. notes on informal urban livelihoods jorge carrillo-rodriguez { 11th March 2013
  • 2. Dimensions  Lack of income and productive assets  Lack of basic services  Lack of power Barriers  Physical: distance, accessibility  Financial: fees, regulations  Legal: registrations, citizenship  Socio-cultural discrimination  Political poverty and vulnerability
  • 3. Monetized economy  Exclusion by design  Informal costs  Opportunity costs  Urban penalty  Eviction and environmental hazards  Social capital  Information urban living
  • 4. “Informality is a term that has the dubious distinction of combining maximum policy importance and political salience with minimal conceptual clarity and coherence in the analytical literature.” (Kanbur, 2009)  terms used interchangeably, i.e. informal economy, informal sector, informal employment, etc.  difficulty in identifying the boundaries between formal and informal  misconceptions on the role, contribution and impact informality
  • 5. Informal economy  Informal sector  Informal employment  Informal work  Informal workers Related terms  Shadow/underground economy  Informal settings defining terms
  • 6. Basic { Complementary { “Holistic” { finding boundaries
  • 7. Informality  poverty  Large IE = weak FE  Small size limits dynamism & growth  Exploitative  Safety net  Low entry cost  Flexible and heterogeneous  Local knowledge/innovation perspectives
  • 8. Capabilities  Assets (material and social)  Strategies A livelihood is sustainable when it can cope with and recover from external stresses and shocks, maintain or enhance its capabilities and assets now and in the future while not undermining the natural resource base. livelihood
  • 9.  Human: skills, knowledge, ability to work, health  Financial: savings, credit, remittances, transfers  Social: networks, trust, services  Physical: infrastructure, transport, shelter capabilities and assets
  • 10.  More income  Increased well-being  Reduced vulnerability  Increased resilience  Sustainable living standard livelihood outcomes
  • 11. Mainly urban Urban and rural Income raising • domestic service - e.g. cleaning and childcare (esp. • home gardening girls and women) • processing, hawking, vending transporting goods • urban agriculture • casual labour/piece work • renting out rooms • specialised occupations (e.g. tinkering, food • multiple jobs (formal/informal) preparation, shoe-shining) • mortgaging and selling assets • migration for seasonal work Lowering expenditure • scavenging • changes in purchasing habits (e.g. small frequent • reduce transport costs purchases, rather than cheap bulk buys, and/or poorer quality food) • discrimination and triage (e.g. giving less food to weaker/ less favoured household members). Social capital • shared childcare and for elders • mutual help e.g. loans from friends or saving groups • informal worker’s associations • family splitting • collective action • remittances from household members working away Strategies
  • 12. Worldwide: around 66% of total employment  Developed Countries: 25-40% of total employment  Developing Countries: 50-90% of total employment  Highest: Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia (as high as 90% in many countries)  Medium: South East and East Asia + Latin America (around 65% in most countries)  Lowest: North Africa and West Asia (around 50% in most countries) informal is normal
  • 13. It does not mean  Simple regulation and taxation but also  getting registered and paying taxes  being covered by legal and social protection  receiving support to become productive and remunerative  becoming organized and gaining voice and power (Chen, 2009) formalization
  • 14. Formalizing the Informal: not just regulation + taxation but also…  assets + opportunities + productivity-enhancing support  economic rights: commercial + labor + property  social protection  organization and representative voice “Informalizing” the Formal: reform of economic policies and institutions to include the informal economy/workforce as legitimate…  part of the total economy  target of economic policies + incentives  stakeholder in policy-making and rule-setting institutions (Chen, 2009) new urban economy