SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Part 1: Understanding the Big
Picture
1. Outreach to maternal health groups
2. Interviews with 30+ near-miss survivors
3. Targeted outreach to black women on
Facebook
4. Interviews with researchers, clinicians & other
experts
Patient Advocacy Resources
• Preeclampsia & HELLP syndrome: Preeclampsia Foundation
• AFE: Amniotic Fluid Embolism Foundation
• Hemorrhage & placental issues: National Accreta Foundation &
Hope for Accreta
• Blood clots & pulmonary embolism: National Blood Clot Alliance, The
Shane Foundation & Pregnancy/Postpartum Blood Clots FB group
• Infection: Sepsis Alliance
• Heart-related issues: SCAD Alliance & The Fight Against Peripartum
Cardiomyopathy
• Mental health issues: Postpartum Support International & The Emily Effect
• Life-threatening complications (general): The Unexpected Project &
Maternal Near-Miss Survivors open FB group
Part 2: Putting a Face to
Maternal Mortality
• Surprisingly few deaths on Nexis, Google
• Obituaries rarely mention cause of death
• Families are conditioned to see maternal deaths as
private tragedies
• This lets hospitals, regulators, policymakers act as
if there isn’t a problem
Surprise: The deaths we did find often didn’t
fit the stereotype
The defining question: How does a healthy NICU nurse
die at the hospital where she worked?
Key Insights:
• The medical system is often more focused on baby’s
health & safety than mom’s
• Lack of standards/protocols in treating obstetric
emergencies is a major factor in many maternal
deaths & near-deaths
• These systemic problems endanger not just SOME
women but ALL women
• Because maternal deaths are almost invisible,
lessons are lost
Aha! moment: Many families use crowdfunding sites
to honor loved ones
Part 3: Finding the Lost Mothers
Find names on GoFundMe & YouCaring,
verify with obits & Facebook
The best tool to monitor recent deaths:
Facebook Signal for journalists
To fill in the gaps, ask the community for help
Who we found:
160+ Lost Mothers in 2016 alone
The really hard part: Persuading loved ones
to tell their story
• Maternal deaths often cause major rifts in families
• Mothers, sisters & other close female relatives are
often more responsive than husbands...
• …But the dead woman’s relatives may not have
complete info
• Many families see the hospital staff as heroes and
won’t want to criticize
• Black families may not want to talk about race
What we published in July 2017: 120 names, 50 photos
Oct. 2017 update: 134 names, 54 photos
Part 4: What Did We Learn From
the Lost Mothers?
• Postpartum deaths & heart-related fatalities are very
common
• Mental health issues & substance abuse are major
factors in many deaths
• Many deaths are preventable
• Often families never find out what happened
• When a mother dies, many lives are destroyed
The Lost Mothers Gallery
More Lost Mothers
More Lost Mothers
Part 5: Lessons for Local Reporters
• Maternal deaths are more than human interest
stories. They’re a public health issue
• Don’t treat maternal deaths as anecdotal leads
• Understand the underlying medical conditions and
the preventability of deaths
• Work extra hard to include women of color — and
give yourself (and their families) extra time
Lessons for Local Reporters, cont’d
• Ask: What happened at the hospital? What protocols
were in place to handle a crisis?
• Ask: Was there an autopsy?
• Ask: What is your state’s process for investigating
maternal deaths?
• Ask: If your state has a maternal mortality review
committee, what does it actually do?
Lessons for Local Reporters, cont’d
• Find out: How does your community care for
pregnant women and postpartum mothers?
• Understand the sensitivities: race, religion, stigma,
guilt
• In reporting about maternal deaths, also find the
near-misses
• GET THE MEDICAL RECORDS!
The Lost Mothers Team
Nina Martin
Nina.Martin@propublica.org
Adriana Gallardo
Adriana.Gallardo@propublica.org
Renee Montagne/NPR
Rmontagne@npr.org
Special thanks to NYU journalism grad students: Emma Cillekens, Alessandra Freitas,
Clare Church, Alexander Gonzalez, Lauren Gurley, Nina Hedevang, Eli Kurland &
Razi Syed
Please share our call-out: Bit.ly/lostmothers

More Related Content

Similar to Nina martin: "Lost Mothers" 10.04.17_

Wrd111
Wrd111Wrd111
20090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.0
20090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.020090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.0
20090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.0
Fishtank
 
Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022
Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022
Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022
Maureen Trask
 
Teen pregnancy
Teen pregnancyTeen pregnancy
Teen pregnancy
lizleandrasanchez
 
Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3
Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3
Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3
The Hunter-Miller Group, Inc
 
Universality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who Lose Children to Adoption
Universality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who  Lose Children to AdoptionUniversality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who  Lose Children to Adoption
Universality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who Lose Children to Adoption
Mirah Riben
 
BHM 2021
BHM 2021BHM 2021
BHM 2021
Megan Kealy
 
BHM 2021
BHM 2021BHM 2021
BHM 2021
Megan Kealy
 
Suicide: Risk Assessment and Prevention
Suicide: Risk Assessment and PreventionSuicide: Risk Assessment and Prevention
Suicide: Risk Assessment and Prevention
Imran Waheed
 
Lynn violence against women1
Lynn  violence against women1Lynn  violence against women1
Lynn violence against women1
Sameer1786
 
Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012
Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012 Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012
Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012
Dawn Farm
 
Caring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptx
Caring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptxCaring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptx
Caring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptx
Ann Shea
 
1.2 sec a journey of hearts- student's copy
1.2  sec a journey of hearts- student's copy1.2  sec a journey of hearts- student's copy
1.2 sec a journey of hearts- student's copy
Gerinorth
 
SGP- Depression
SGP- DepressionSGP- Depression
SGP- Depression
Tiana Gooden
 
How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...
How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...
How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...
University of Calgary
 
LGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure: Utah
LGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure:  UtahLGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure:  Utah
LGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure: Utah
MarianEAllen
 
Hospice ethics presentation
Hospice ethics presentationHospice ethics presentation
Hospice ethics presentation
lp384531
 
Stress in the Time of COVID-19
Stress in the Time of COVID-19Stress in the Time of COVID-19
Stress in the Time of COVID-19
ADAMH Board of Franklin County
 
Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")
Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")
Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")
Emily Coffey
 
MIDDLE ADULTHOOD
MIDDLE ADULTHOODMIDDLE ADULTHOOD

Similar to Nina martin: "Lost Mothers" 10.04.17_ (20)

Wrd111
Wrd111Wrd111
Wrd111
 
20090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.0
20090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.020090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.0
20090703 prestentation how endorse and improve v1.0
 
Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022
Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022
Treaty 3 Training Feb 9 2022
 
Teen pregnancy
Teen pregnancyTeen pregnancy
Teen pregnancy
 
Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3
Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3
Slide share critical cond miller&taylor nov2009edit3
 
Universality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who Lose Children to Adoption
Universality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who  Lose Children to AdoptionUniversality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who  Lose Children to Adoption
Universality of the Grief Experienced by Mothers Who Lose Children to Adoption
 
BHM 2021
BHM 2021BHM 2021
BHM 2021
 
BHM 2021
BHM 2021BHM 2021
BHM 2021
 
Suicide: Risk Assessment and Prevention
Suicide: Risk Assessment and PreventionSuicide: Risk Assessment and Prevention
Suicide: Risk Assessment and Prevention
 
Lynn violence against women1
Lynn  violence against women1Lynn  violence against women1
Lynn violence against women1
 
Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012
Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012 Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012
Addiction and Suicide Prevention - December 2012
 
Caring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptx
Caring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptxCaring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptx
Caring for Aging Parents While Working Full-Time.pptx
 
1.2 sec a journey of hearts- student's copy
1.2  sec a journey of hearts- student's copy1.2  sec a journey of hearts- student's copy
1.2 sec a journey of hearts- student's copy
 
SGP- Depression
SGP- DepressionSGP- Depression
SGP- Depression
 
How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...
How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...
How Childhood Cancer Affects Children and Families – Dr. Nancy Moules, Univer...
 
LGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure: Utah
LGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure:  UtahLGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure:  Utah
LGBTQ Youth Suicide Brochure: Utah
 
Hospice ethics presentation
Hospice ethics presentationHospice ethics presentation
Hospice ethics presentation
 
Stress in the Time of COVID-19
Stress in the Time of COVID-19Stress in the Time of COVID-19
Stress in the Time of COVID-19
 
Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")
Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")
Health and Society (Chapter 11, "You May Ask Yourself")
 
MIDDLE ADULTHOOD
MIDDLE ADULTHOODMIDDLE ADULTHOOD
MIDDLE ADULTHOOD
 

More from reportingonhealth

Tom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New Rule
Tom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New RuleTom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New Rule
Tom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New Rule
reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
reportingonhealth
 
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
reportingonhealth
 
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
reportingonhealth
 
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
reportingonhealth
 
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
reportingonhealth
 
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
reportingonhealth
 
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
reportingonhealth
 
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
reportingonhealth
 
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
reportingonhealth
 
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
reportingonhealth
 
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
reportingonhealth
 
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
reportingonhealth
 
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
reportingonhealth
 
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
reportingonhealth
 
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
reportingonhealth
 
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
reportingonhealth
 

More from reportingonhealth (20)

Tom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New Rule
Tom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New RuleTom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New Rule
Tom Wong: Public Charge: Immigrant Health Under Trump’s New Rule
 
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Dr. Arnie Milstein: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
 
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
Larry Levitt: Is Employee Health Insurance Failing Americans?
 
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
Barbara Laker & Wendy Ruderman: "Toxic Cities: Telling Big Stories on Hidden ...
 
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Betsy McKay: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
 
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
Dr. Katy Kozhimannil: "What’s at Stake as Rural America Loses Its Hospitals"
 
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Elissa Epel: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
 
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
Dr. Anthony Iton: "How Our Environment Gets Under Our Skin"
 
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Daniel Chang: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
 
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
Victoria Colliver: "Master Class: Reporting on Health Policy"
 
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Dylan Scott: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
 
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Angela Rachidi: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
 
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
Judith Solomon: "Putting Medicaid to Work"
 
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Stephanie Armour: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
 
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
Timothy Jost: "Will Obamacare survive the latest Trump maneuver?"
 
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Dr. Aaron Kesselheim: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
 
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
Katie Thomas: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
 
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
David Mitchell: "Runaway Train: America’s Drug Price Problem"
 
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
Lois Beckett: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
 
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
David Hemenway: "Outgunned: America’s Public Health Crisis"
 

Recently uploaded

CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer RehabpptxCCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
Canadian Cancer Survivor Network
 
Champions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdf
Champions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdfChampions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdf
Champions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdf
eurohealthleaders
 
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured ApproachBringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Brian Frerichs
 
Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...
Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...
Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...
Levi Shapiro
 
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdfMBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
bkling
 
Comprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdf
Comprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdfComprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdf
Comprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdf
Dr Rachana Gujar
 
Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...
Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...
Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...
Ear Solutions (ESPL)
 
Luxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage Center
Luxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage CenterLuxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage Center
Luxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage Center
Chandrima Spa Ajman
 
Bath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptx
Bath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptxBath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptx
Bath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptx
MianProductions
 
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATION
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATIONMYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATION
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATION
blessyjannu21
 
Sheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptx
Sheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptxSheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptx
Sheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptx
National academy of medical science,Bir hospital
 
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
nktiacc3
 
Unlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdfUnlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdf
Lift Ability
 
FACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVEFACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVE
aditigupta1117
 
PrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and Engagement
PrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and EngagementPrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and Engagement
PrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and Engagement
PrudentRx Program
 
COPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar Doshi
COPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar DoshiCOPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar Doshi
COPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar Doshi
Dr Kumar Doshi
 
2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers
2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers
2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers
Conference Panel
 
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COMHUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
priyabhojwani1200
 
Innovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdf
Innovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdfInnovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdf
Innovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdf
eurohealthleaders
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Chandrima Spa Ajman
 

Recently uploaded (20)

CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer RehabpptxCCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
CCSN_June_06 2024_jones. Cancer Rehabpptx
 
Champions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdf
Champions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdfChampions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdf
Champions of Health Spotlight On Leaders Shaping Germany's Healthcare.pdf
 
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured ApproachBringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
Bringing AI into a Mid-Sized Company: A structured Approach
 
Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...
Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...
Michigan HealthTech Market Map 2024 with Policy Makers, Academic Innovation C...
 
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdfMBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
MBC Support Group for Black Women – Insights in Genetic Testing.pdf
 
Comprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdf
Comprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdfComprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdf
Comprehensive Rainy Season Advisory: Safety and Preparedness Tips.pdf
 
Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...
Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...
Exploring the Benefits of Binaural Hearing: Why Two Hearing Aids Are Better T...
 
Luxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage Center
Luxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage CenterLuxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage Center
Luxurious Spa In Ajman Chandrima Massage Center
 
Bath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptx
Bath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptxBath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptx
Bath patient Fundamental of Nursing.pptx
 
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATION
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATIONMYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATION
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS POWER POINT PRESENTATION
 
Sheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptx
Sheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptxSheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptx
Sheard's criterion and Percival criterion.pptx
 
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
NKTI Annual Report - Annual Report FY 2022
 
Unlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdfUnlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdf
Unlocking the Secrets to Safe Patient Handling.pdf
 
FACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVEFACIAL NERVE
FACIAL NERVE
 
PrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and Engagement
PrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and EngagementPrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and Engagement
PrudentRx: A Resource for Patient Education and Engagement
 
COPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar Doshi
COPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar DoshiCOPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar Doshi
COPD Treatment in Ghatkopar,Mumbai. Dr Kumar Doshi
 
2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers
2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers
2024 HIPAA Compliance Training Guide to the Compliance Officers
 
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COMHUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
HUMAN BRAIN.pptx.PRIYA BHOJWANI@GAMIL.COM
 
Innovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdf
Innovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdfInnovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdf
Innovative Minds France's Most Impactful Healthcare Leaders.pdf
 
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima  SpaTop massage center in ajman chandrima  Spa
Top massage center in ajman chandrima Spa
 

Nina martin: "Lost Mothers" 10.04.17_

  • 1.
  • 2. Part 1: Understanding the Big Picture 1. Outreach to maternal health groups 2. Interviews with 30+ near-miss survivors 3. Targeted outreach to black women on Facebook 4. Interviews with researchers, clinicians & other experts
  • 3. Patient Advocacy Resources • Preeclampsia & HELLP syndrome: Preeclampsia Foundation • AFE: Amniotic Fluid Embolism Foundation • Hemorrhage & placental issues: National Accreta Foundation & Hope for Accreta • Blood clots & pulmonary embolism: National Blood Clot Alliance, The Shane Foundation & Pregnancy/Postpartum Blood Clots FB group • Infection: Sepsis Alliance • Heart-related issues: SCAD Alliance & The Fight Against Peripartum Cardiomyopathy • Mental health issues: Postpartum Support International & The Emily Effect • Life-threatening complications (general): The Unexpected Project & Maternal Near-Miss Survivors open FB group
  • 4. Part 2: Putting a Face to Maternal Mortality • Surprisingly few deaths on Nexis, Google • Obituaries rarely mention cause of death • Families are conditioned to see maternal deaths as private tragedies • This lets hospitals, regulators, policymakers act as if there isn’t a problem
  • 5. Surprise: The deaths we did find often didn’t fit the stereotype
  • 6. The defining question: How does a healthy NICU nurse die at the hospital where she worked?
  • 7. Key Insights: • The medical system is often more focused on baby’s health & safety than mom’s • Lack of standards/protocols in treating obstetric emergencies is a major factor in many maternal deaths & near-deaths • These systemic problems endanger not just SOME women but ALL women • Because maternal deaths are almost invisible, lessons are lost
  • 8. Aha! moment: Many families use crowdfunding sites to honor loved ones
  • 9. Part 3: Finding the Lost Mothers
  • 10. Find names on GoFundMe & YouCaring, verify with obits & Facebook
  • 11. The best tool to monitor recent deaths: Facebook Signal for journalists
  • 12. To fill in the gaps, ask the community for help
  • 13. Who we found: 160+ Lost Mothers in 2016 alone
  • 14. The really hard part: Persuading loved ones to tell their story • Maternal deaths often cause major rifts in families • Mothers, sisters & other close female relatives are often more responsive than husbands... • …But the dead woman’s relatives may not have complete info • Many families see the hospital staff as heroes and won’t want to criticize • Black families may not want to talk about race
  • 15. What we published in July 2017: 120 names, 50 photos Oct. 2017 update: 134 names, 54 photos
  • 16. Part 4: What Did We Learn From the Lost Mothers? • Postpartum deaths & heart-related fatalities are very common • Mental health issues & substance abuse are major factors in many deaths • Many deaths are preventable • Often families never find out what happened • When a mother dies, many lives are destroyed
  • 17. The Lost Mothers Gallery
  • 20. Part 5: Lessons for Local Reporters • Maternal deaths are more than human interest stories. They’re a public health issue • Don’t treat maternal deaths as anecdotal leads • Understand the underlying medical conditions and the preventability of deaths • Work extra hard to include women of color — and give yourself (and their families) extra time
  • 21. Lessons for Local Reporters, cont’d • Ask: What happened at the hospital? What protocols were in place to handle a crisis? • Ask: Was there an autopsy? • Ask: What is your state’s process for investigating maternal deaths? • Ask: If your state has a maternal mortality review committee, what does it actually do?
  • 22. Lessons for Local Reporters, cont’d • Find out: How does your community care for pregnant women and postpartum mothers? • Understand the sensitivities: race, religion, stigma, guilt • In reporting about maternal deaths, also find the near-misses • GET THE MEDICAL RECORDS!
  • 23. The Lost Mothers Team Nina Martin Nina.Martin@propublica.org Adriana Gallardo Adriana.Gallardo@propublica.org Renee Montagne/NPR Rmontagne@npr.org Special thanks to NYU journalism grad students: Emma Cillekens, Alessandra Freitas, Clare Church, Alexander Gonzalez, Lauren Gurley, Nina Hedevang, Eli Kurland & Razi Syed Please share our call-out: Bit.ly/lostmothers