New York state education leaders, in collaboration with the teachers' union, have unveiled a proposed overhaul to the teacher evaluation system, aiming to shift away from the reliance on standardized test scores.

1. New York Education Leaders
Propose Teacher Evaluation
Overhaul, Moving Away from
Standardized Tests
S
H
A
R
E
Source – Chalkbeat
New York state education leaders, in collaboration with the teachers’ union, have unveiled a proposed
overhaul to the teacher evaluation system, aiming to shift away from the reliance on standardized test
scores. The proposed changes come as a response to long-standing concerns over the fairness and
effectiveness of using students’ test performance to evaluate educators.
State Education Department Commissioner Betty Rosa and New York State United Teachers President
Melinda Person presented the drafted legislation to lawmakers on Wednesday, marking a significant step
towards revamping the evaluation process. The proposed law, which has yet to be officially introduced in
the Legislature, seeks to create a new system that prioritizes a more holistic approach to evaluating
teachers and principals, one that does not penalize them based on students’ standardized test scores.

2. The current teacher evaluation system, known as the Annual Professional Performance Review (APPR),
was modified in the 2015 budget to place greater emphasis on standardized test scores. However, the
proposed legislation aims to remove this requirement and provide a more equitable and supportive
evaluation framework for educators.
According to Commissioner Rosa, the proposed changes are grounded in research and aimed at ensuring
that teachers and principals have the necessary tools to provide high-quality education to students. The
move signifies a shift towards connecting research-based practices with real-world classroom strategies,
ultimately benefiting both educators and students.
Advocating for Fairness: NYSUT President’s Call for Equitable
Evaluation
NYSUT President Melinda Person emphasized the need for a fair and just evaluation system that supports
educators in their professional growth. Under the proposed legislation, school districts would have eight
years to transition to the new evaluation system, although they could opt to make the changes more rapidly
if desired. Person argued that the proposed changes would alleviate the burden of paperwork often faced
by new teachers and foster a more conducive environment for professional development.
The proposed legislation has garnered widespread support from various stakeholders, including state
superintendents, principals, school boards, and parent-teacher associations. The collaborative effort reflects
a consensus among New York state education leaders that the current evaluation system is in need of
reform.
Senate Education chair Shelley Mayer praised the agreement reached among stakeholders, highlighting the
rarity of such consensus in Albany. Assembly Education chair Michael Benedetto echoed her sentiments,
emphasizing the importance of stability and clarity in the evaluation process for educators.
A Fairer Approach to Teacher Evaluation
Lawmakers have committed to reviewing the proposal and drafting legislation in the coming weeks, with
assurances that the changes will be implemented before the end of the legislative session in June. The
proposed overhaul is not expected to be included in the budget but remains a top priority for the
Legislature.
The proposed changes come amid ongoing discussions on improving teacher quality and addressing
learning loss resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. Commissioner Rosa expressed confidence in
securing Governor Kathy Hochul’s support for the proposed legislation, citing the governor’s commitment
to teacher development and quality education.
As New York state education leaders take steps towards reimagining its teacher evaluation system,
educators and stakeholders alike are hopeful that the proposed changes will lead to a more equitable,
supportive, and effective evaluation process, ultimately benefiting students and educators across the state.
Also Read: Top Film Schools in the World: Creating Cinematic Excellence