Mobile Apps for Drug Discovery

  Antony J. Williams1, Sean Ekins 2,3,4 and Alex M. Clark5


                          1
                           Royal Society of Chemistry, Wake Forest, NC 27587
                      2
                          Collaborations in Chemistry, Fuquay Varina, NC 27526.
3
  Department of Pharmacology, University of Medicine & Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson
                                      Medical School, Piscataway, NJ.
 4
   School of Pharmacy, Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Maryland, Baltimore, MD.
      5
        Molecular Materials Informatics, 1900 St. Jacques #302, Montreal Quebec, Canada H3J 2S1
A LITTLE BACKGROUND : computer aided drug design

                                                 Accelrys UGM 2003



                       1999




2010 – I consult for a company and say it will not be long before we tweet molecules
2011 – I buy an iPhone
2012 – This presentation is what has happened since
                                                      www.scimobileapps.com
Mobile computing – an opportunity to exploit
                      Everything is mobile - Devices smaller
      Chemists move from e-notebook – tablet pc – to smart phones / devices
                                    iPhone etc
             What apps could we provide for data, collaboration etc?




  Williams et al., In collaborative computational technologies for biomedical research 2011
  Williams – chemistry world May 2010

www.scimobileapps.com
What stimulated this effort?




      Williams et al DDT 16:928-939, 2011
www.scimobileapps.com
There are many areas for mobile devices / software to impact R&D




  Williams et al., In collaborative computational technologies for biomedical research 2011
  Arnold and Ekins, PharmacoEconomics 28: 1-5, 2010 Williams et al DDT 16:928-939, 2011

www.scimobileapps.com
Impact on computer aided drug design

      Sophisticated software may eventually be available as Apps
      So far ..just simple drawing and properties
      No docking Apps?
      No pharmacophores or similar Apps?
      No Apps to compete with major products
      Issues – size of viewing area – less so with iPad
      But.. it will change..
      Phone enables anyone to draw a molecule and predict
       properties
      Just think of the possibilities



www.scimobileapps.com
         Copyright Sean Ekins 2010
Why are science Apps important?

        Exposure to huge audience with “smart phones”
        Make science more accessible = >communication
        Hardware is powerful
        Mobile – take a phone into field and do science
         more readily than a laptop
        Sturdy
        Apps can be a subset of a desktop solution
        Bite size chunk of program


www.scimobileapps.com
Chemistry Apps
     Structure Drawing
     Database Access
     Chemical Reactions
     Biological Data
     Biomolecule visualization
     Publishers, publications and their management
     eBooks



www.scimobileapps.com
How do you find useful science apps?
       Search in App store
       Returns a myriad of Apps many not even
        be appropriate
       Many are flashcards when you want an
        App that does something else
       How do you find the right App quickly
       No definitive Encyclopedia of Science
        Apps
       No book on science Apps!!!!

       So we started a wiki – stimulate others –
        easier to update than a paper
                                            http://slidesha.re/lhyq8s
www.scimobileapps.com
http://slidesha.re/lhyq8s




   Public Launch
   June 21 2011
   via chemconnector blog
   Twitter, facebook etc.

   8 contributers to date!




www.scimobileapps.com
www.scimobileapps.com
Green Solvents – idea
  to app in a week
      http://slidesha.re/iHbg73
The Solvent Selection Guide
                                       23rd June SE attends a session @
     Text…                             this conference




Dr I. Mergelsberg (Merck) described a consortia for solvent selection
which resulted in a document (PDF) hidden on ACS website
The Solvent Selection Guide
                       Lots of data
                       but how to
                       make it useful
                       for chemists?

                       Chemists see
                       structures

                       PDF not
                       accessible,
                       small text- too
                       much data


http://bit.ly/GzQ5ty
Making the Free App a Reality
      Alex Clark made the App in 3 days
Making the Free App a Reality




          Bad             Good


                > 2500 downloads
App - connectivity




      Clark et al., submitted 2012
Open Drug
Discovery Teams
    (ODDT)
  http://slidesha.re/xzGhFH
A New Challenge
  Mid January Pistoia Alliance Ask for volunteers
   to present in a Dragon’s Den Scenario Feb 8th at
   the RSC
 Ideas that will transform Pharma R&D in 2014

 So my natural response was :

“If I am going to take part I want to create
   something real”

    http://bit.ly/wImJtH
http://pistoiaalliance.org/
Could an app transform R&D ?
   Tuberculosis Kills 1.6-1.7m/yr (~1 every 8 seconds) equivalent to malaria
   No new drugs in over 40 yrs
   Pipeline is thin and weak BMGF & NIH do not coordinate TB efforts, not
    mandating open data.

   > 7000 rare diseases
   e.g. Jill Wood started a foundation, raises money, awareness, funds
    ground breaking research happening globally.

   She is in a race against time – what can we do to translate ideas from
    bench to patient faster?

   How can we help parents and families ?
Inspiration
   There are many 1000s of diseases
     and few with cures

   Science Online 2012 on open notebooks and data
    overload

   Flipboard

  Could we create an app
for science like Flipboard?
http://slidesha.re/why7gg
Within about 10 days Alex Clark Created
     ODDT to present at the Pistoia meeting




Focused on Tuberculosis, Malaria, HIV/AIDS, Huntington’s Disease,
Sanfilippo Syndrome, and Green Chemistry as topics in version 1

We did not win the competition but had useful feedback – the need to
articulate the value proposition
                               http://slidesha.re/GzVSPr
The Value Proposition
   The project is intended to bring together open data in a single aggregated
    collection, and then facilitate forming open research teams around this data

   Disseminate important information to a highly relevant target audience

   Network and discover other researchers with complementary interests, and
    opportunities to collaborate

   Team members will be able to borrow and reuse a growing collection of
    existing Open data.
   The community as a whole can debate, contest or endorse data based on
    its quality.

   The app could also be used as a type of “lab notebook” whereby individual
    researchers share links (URLs) to content and the app aggregates these.


                          http://slidesha.re/weDFLg
Latest Layout
9 Panels includes one
on ODDT information




Can use multiple
Twitter accounts
Here is my icon


 Stats summary

  About App
Tap on a panel and look at
   Incoming contents
                        Click here to
                        endorse or
                        disapprove

                        Click here to
                        follow hyperlink




                        Incoming is
                        sorted by time
                        of creation
Browse through multiple pages of
            tweets
Endorse, Disapprove and
      Comment
Recent contents


                  Click on image to
                  open it




                  Recent is
                  factoids with
                  a vote count
                  of +1 or
                  better
Content   Click on image to
          open it

          Ranked content




          Content is
          currently
          anything with
          a vote
          count of +1 or
          better, sorted
          by most
          popular first
Tap on a link or image
Be able to download
      content
Look at your own statistics
Exposing rare diseases – creating
communities of researchers and sparking
              discussion




                                My tweets on
                                recent analyses
                                and ideas



                                  My Retweets
Coming Soon
   From idea to alpha testing version in a month
   Well on way to delivering a tool for R&D and the
    general public
   Future versions will allow user to specify topics
   Rewards – badges
   Image handling – HTML web crawling
   Beta version
   General release – Post ACS meeting
   More ideas that may need funding to cover server etc
   - Would you fund us if we posted ODDT on Kickstarter or
    Petridish.org or IndieGoGo??
   Are there sponsors for specific pages or content?
Thank you Alpha
          testers
      Antony J. Williams
      Hans De Winter
      Chris Swain
      Andrew Lang
      Carlo Yuvienco
      Paul Reinheimer
      Michael S. Lajiness
      Nancy Connell
      Greta Beekhuis
      Joe Hupcey III
      Freundlich, Joel
      Tanya Parrish
      Peter Olinga


                                          ODDT
      Peter Caduff
Photo for San Fillipo Syndrome courtesy
of Jill Wood www.jonasjustbegun.org
More Information
   Please contact us for further details or suggestions at:
    aclark@molmatinf.com and ekinssean@yahoo.com

   You can learn more about the ODDT app at:
     http://www.scimobileapps.com/index.php?
    title=Open_Drug_Discovery_Teams

And frequent blogs at http://www.collabchem.com and
  http://cheminf20.org/

Mobile apps for drug discovery

  • 1.
    Mobile Apps forDrug Discovery Antony J. Williams1, Sean Ekins 2,3,4 and Alex M. Clark5 1 Royal Society of Chemistry, Wake Forest, NC 27587 2 Collaborations in Chemistry, Fuquay Varina, NC 27526. 3 Department of Pharmacology, University of Medicine & Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, Piscataway, NJ. 4 School of Pharmacy, Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Maryland, Baltimore, MD. 5 Molecular Materials Informatics, 1900 St. Jacques #302, Montreal Quebec, Canada H3J 2S1
  • 2.
    A LITTLE BACKGROUND: computer aided drug design Accelrys UGM 2003 1999 2010 – I consult for a company and say it will not be long before we tweet molecules 2011 – I buy an iPhone 2012 – This presentation is what has happened since www.scimobileapps.com
  • 3.
    Mobile computing –an opportunity to exploit Everything is mobile - Devices smaller Chemists move from e-notebook – tablet pc – to smart phones / devices iPhone etc What apps could we provide for data, collaboration etc? Williams et al., In collaborative computational technologies for biomedical research 2011 Williams – chemistry world May 2010 www.scimobileapps.com
  • 4.
    What stimulated thiseffort? Williams et al DDT 16:928-939, 2011 www.scimobileapps.com
  • 5.
    There are manyareas for mobile devices / software to impact R&D Williams et al., In collaborative computational technologies for biomedical research 2011 Arnold and Ekins, PharmacoEconomics 28: 1-5, 2010 Williams et al DDT 16:928-939, 2011 www.scimobileapps.com
  • 6.
    Impact on computeraided drug design  Sophisticated software may eventually be available as Apps  So far ..just simple drawing and properties  No docking Apps?  No pharmacophores or similar Apps?  No Apps to compete with major products  Issues – size of viewing area – less so with iPad  But.. it will change..  Phone enables anyone to draw a molecule and predict properties  Just think of the possibilities www.scimobileapps.com Copyright Sean Ekins 2010
  • 7.
    Why are scienceApps important?  Exposure to huge audience with “smart phones”  Make science more accessible = >communication  Hardware is powerful  Mobile – take a phone into field and do science more readily than a laptop  Sturdy  Apps can be a subset of a desktop solution  Bite size chunk of program www.scimobileapps.com
  • 8.
    Chemistry Apps  Structure Drawing  Database Access  Chemical Reactions  Biological Data  Biomolecule visualization  Publishers, publications and their management  eBooks www.scimobileapps.com
  • 9.
    How do youfind useful science apps?  Search in App store  Returns a myriad of Apps many not even be appropriate  Many are flashcards when you want an App that does something else  How do you find the right App quickly  No definitive Encyclopedia of Science Apps  No book on science Apps!!!!  So we started a wiki – stimulate others – easier to update than a paper http://slidesha.re/lhyq8s www.scimobileapps.com
  • 10.
    http://slidesha.re/lhyq8s Public Launch June 21 2011 via chemconnector blog Twitter, facebook etc. 8 contributers to date! www.scimobileapps.com
  • 11.
  • 12.
    Green Solvents –idea to app in a week http://slidesha.re/iHbg73
  • 13.
    The Solvent SelectionGuide 23rd June SE attends a session @  Text… this conference Dr I. Mergelsberg (Merck) described a consortia for solvent selection which resulted in a document (PDF) hidden on ACS website
  • 14.
    The Solvent SelectionGuide Lots of data but how to make it useful for chemists? Chemists see structures PDF not accessible, small text- too much data http://bit.ly/GzQ5ty
  • 15.
    Making the FreeApp a Reality Alex Clark made the App in 3 days
  • 16.
    Making the FreeApp a Reality Bad Good > 2500 downloads
  • 17.
    App - connectivity Clark et al., submitted 2012
  • 18.
    Open Drug Discovery Teams (ODDT) http://slidesha.re/xzGhFH
  • 19.
    A New Challenge  Mid January Pistoia Alliance Ask for volunteers to present in a Dragon’s Den Scenario Feb 8th at the RSC  Ideas that will transform Pharma R&D in 2014  So my natural response was : “If I am going to take part I want to create something real” http://bit.ly/wImJtH http://pistoiaalliance.org/
  • 20.
    Could an apptransform R&D ?  Tuberculosis Kills 1.6-1.7m/yr (~1 every 8 seconds) equivalent to malaria  No new drugs in over 40 yrs  Pipeline is thin and weak BMGF & NIH do not coordinate TB efforts, not mandating open data.  > 7000 rare diseases  e.g. Jill Wood started a foundation, raises money, awareness, funds ground breaking research happening globally.  She is in a race against time – what can we do to translate ideas from bench to patient faster?  How can we help parents and families ?
  • 21.
    Inspiration  There are many 1000s of diseases and few with cures  Science Online 2012 on open notebooks and data overload  Flipboard  Could we create an app for science like Flipboard?
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Within about 10days Alex Clark Created ODDT to present at the Pistoia meeting Focused on Tuberculosis, Malaria, HIV/AIDS, Huntington’s Disease, Sanfilippo Syndrome, and Green Chemistry as topics in version 1 We did not win the competition but had useful feedback – the need to articulate the value proposition http://slidesha.re/GzVSPr
  • 24.
    The Value Proposition  The project is intended to bring together open data in a single aggregated collection, and then facilitate forming open research teams around this data  Disseminate important information to a highly relevant target audience  Network and discover other researchers with complementary interests, and opportunities to collaborate  Team members will be able to borrow and reuse a growing collection of existing Open data.  The community as a whole can debate, contest or endorse data based on its quality.  The app could also be used as a type of “lab notebook” whereby individual researchers share links (URLs) to content and the app aggregates these. http://slidesha.re/weDFLg
  • 25.
    Latest Layout 9 Panelsincludes one on ODDT information Can use multiple Twitter accounts Here is my icon Stats summary About App
  • 26.
    Tap on apanel and look at Incoming contents Click here to endorse or disapprove Click here to follow hyperlink Incoming is sorted by time of creation
  • 27.
    Browse through multiplepages of tweets
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Recent contents Click on image to open it Recent is factoids with a vote count of +1 or better
  • 30.
    Content Click on image to open it Ranked content Content is currently anything with a vote count of +1 or better, sorted by most popular first
  • 31.
    Tap on alink or image
  • 32.
    Be able todownload content
  • 33.
    Look at yourown statistics
  • 34.
    Exposing rare diseases– creating communities of researchers and sparking discussion My tweets on recent analyses and ideas My Retweets
  • 35.
    Coming Soon  From idea to alpha testing version in a month  Well on way to delivering a tool for R&D and the general public  Future versions will allow user to specify topics  Rewards – badges  Image handling – HTML web crawling  Beta version  General release – Post ACS meeting  More ideas that may need funding to cover server etc  - Would you fund us if we posted ODDT on Kickstarter or Petridish.org or IndieGoGo??  Are there sponsors for specific pages or content?
  • 36.
    Thank you Alpha testers  Antony J. Williams  Hans De Winter  Chris Swain  Andrew Lang  Carlo Yuvienco  Paul Reinheimer  Michael S. Lajiness  Nancy Connell  Greta Beekhuis  Joe Hupcey III  Freundlich, Joel  Tanya Parrish  Peter Olinga ODDT  Peter Caduff Photo for San Fillipo Syndrome courtesy of Jill Wood www.jonasjustbegun.org
  • 37.
    More Information  Please contact us for further details or suggestions at: aclark@molmatinf.com and ekinssean@yahoo.com  You can learn more about the ODDT app at: http://www.scimobileapps.com/index.php? title=Open_Drug_Discovery_Teams And frequent blogs at http://www.collabchem.com and http://cheminf20.org/