SlideShare a Scribd company logo
MASTER THESIS 
Accomplished by: 
Renata MOKROVA 
Supervised by: 
Boris DURISIN 
Differences between 
Vichy Brand Image & Vichy Brand Identity 
in Russian and in French Markets
The Framework 
Relevance of the topic chosen 
• Increasing importance of brand management 
• Mismatch between company’s and consumers’ perception of the brand 
• Room for research in active cosmetics/cross-country analysis 
• Mismatch of the Vichy brand identity and brand image in Russia 
• Vichy brand identity recent renewal 
Object: Vichy brand (L’Oréal Groupe) 
Subject: Gap between brand image and brand identity 
Research Question 
What are the differences in the gap between Vichy brand image and 
Vichy brand identity in Russian and French markets? 
Paris, 
2014
1. Theoretical background 
1. Defining the notions 
Broad definition: The core brand sense in its perfect state, like the 
company wants it to be (Aaker, Bivainiene, Domnin) 
Narrow definition: The set of brand characteristics that allow for brand 
identification and differentiation by maintaining its core (Kapferer) 
• to identify the brand 
• to differentiate the brand 
Key findings 
BRAND IDENTITY 
BRAND IMAGE 
The perception of the brand by consumers, constructed from unique set of associations, 
created in the memory of consumers in the process of the communication with the brand 
(Aaker, Keller, Janonis and Virvilaite). 
Types of associations: 
1. ATTRIBUTES 
2. BENEFITS 
3. PERSONALITY 
• Non-product related 
• Product-related 
• Functional 
• Experiential 
• Symbolic 
Source: [Keller, 2005; Korchia, 2005] 
• Brand character 
• Personal traits 
Paris, 
2014
1. Theoretical background 
Key findings 
2. Brand Wheel structural model, Bates Worldwide 
Brand 
essence 
Personality 
Values 
Benefits 
A9ributes 
Physical 
characteris<cs 
(color, 
package, 
aroma) 
In 
comparison 
to 
other 
brands 
Principles, 
guidelines, 
key 
pillars 
Human 
traits, 
characteris<cs 
Key 
idea, 
core 
Source: [Domnin, 2009; Starov, 2008] 
Paris, 
2014
1. Theoretical background 
Key findings 
3. Brand identity communication process 
6 obstacles for BR ID 
communication 
Sender 
Company 
Source: 
[Doyle, 
2001; 
Starov, 
2010] 
Mean of communication Receiver 
Consumer 
Brand 
iden)ty 
Brand 
image 
Reac<on 
Other 
signals 
Coding 
Decoding 
Feedback 
Message 
• Other factors 
• External brand-related signals 
• Inappropriate communication 
channel 
• Competitors’ activities 
• Inappropriate BR ID 
• Inefficient messages 
Paris, 
2014
2. Research Methodology 
1. 
Qualita<ve 
research: 
STAGE 
In-­‐depth 
interview 
with 
a 
Vichy 
representa<ve 
Vichy 
brand 
iden<ty 
2. 
Quan<ta<ve 
research: 
Survey, 
200 
consumers 
(poten<al/previous/ 
current) 
• 100 
in 
Russia 
• 100 
in 
France 
RESULT 
Vichy 
brand 
image-­‐id 
gap 
• in 
Russia 
• in 
France 
Cross-­‐country 
comparison 
of 
the 
brand 
image-­‐id 
gap 
Goal: 
reveal 
the 
differences 
in 
the 
brand 
iden<ty-­‐image 
gap 
between 
Russian 
and 
French 
markets 
Research 
Ques)ons: 
1. How 
Vichy 
brand 
iden<ty 
is 
defined? 
2. Are 
new 
Vichy 
logos 
(both 
visual 
and 
textual) 
are 
known 
and 
being 
recognized 
by 
consumers 
and 
can 
be 
considered 
as 
strong 
brand 
a9ributes? 
3. Do 
consumers 
perceive 
the 
emo<onal 
and 
func<onal 
benefits 
stated 
in 
brand 
iden<ty 
model 
as 
the 
ones 
offered 
by 
Vichy 
brand? 
4. If 
Vichy 
would 
be 
a 
person, 
would 
have 
consumers 
described 
it 
with 
exactly 
the 
same 
traits 
as 
stated 
in 
the 
brand 
iden<ty 
model? 
How 
strong 
the 
stated 
traits 
are 
recognized 
in 
Vichy 
by 
consumers? 
5. Could 
consumers 
recognize 
indirectly 
the 
values 
and 
the 
essence 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
specified 
in 
its 
iden<ty 
model? 
6. How 
similar 
is 
Vichy 
brand 
image 
in 
general 
from 
the 
point 
of 
view 
of 
Russian 
and 
French 
consumers 
to 
its 
compe<tors? 
7. How 
different 
is 
the 
nature 
of 
the 
iden<ty-­‐image 
gap 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France? 
8. What 
are 
the 
differences 
in 
consumer 
behavior 
in 
ac<ve 
cosme<cs 
category 
between 
Russia 
and 
France? 
Paris, 
2014
2. Research Methodology 
Qualitative research 
HOW 
• In-depth interview using the interview guideline, based on the 
structure of Brand Wheel model 
• 1h, language: Russian, recorded 
WHO 
• Vichy brand-manager, responsible for the sub-brands: Normaderm, 
Vichy Homme, axe deodorants and recent general brand campaign 
WHEN/WHERE 
• 19th of April, 2014 
• Anti-Café, 10 rue de Richelieu, Paris 
RESULT 
• Vichy brand identity wheel 
• Hypotheses for the qualitative stage 
Paris, 
2014
Questionnaire design 
2. Research Methodology 
Qualitative research 
• 20 questions, multi-choice / scaled questions 
• 6 parts: 
1. Consumer behavior and involvement in the category 
2. Vichy attributes (logos and images): recognition with/without a hint 
3. Vichy benefits (emotional and functional): Likert scale 
4. Vichy personality: chose 3 traits and assess the intensity of given traits for Vichy 
5. Vichy values & essence: implicit, defined through association with the image 
6. Socio-demographic 
• Created in English, translated into Russian and French, checked with a bilingual 
• It was based on the existing study on brand identity/image gap (Janonis, Dovalienė, Virvilaitė, 2007) 
Sampling 
• Sample size: 200, scope: France and Russia 
• Intentionally non-representative: Vichy target audience as defined by Vichy brand-manager 
• Convenience and judgmental sampling methods 
• On-line distribution of the survey: acquaintances, woman forums, direct messages to brand pages 
followers in social networks 
• To motivate respondents: there was a chance to get Vichy product for free (6 products were allocated) 
Methods of data analysis 
• SPSS package 
• Vichy brand wheel in each country: Central tendency measures analysis 
• Cross-country comparison: hypotheses testing 
• Parametric test: Student t-test / Non-parametric: Mann-Whitney U test for 2 independent samples 
• Chi-Square test for nominal variables (measure of association) 
Paris, 
2014
H0: 
The 
country 
of 
the 
residence 
and 
the 
level 
of 
recogni<on 
of 
visual 
Vichy 
logo 
are 
sta<s<cally 
independent. 
H0: 
The 
country 
of 
the 
residence 
and 
the 
level 
of 
recogni<on 
of 
textual 
Vichy 
logo 
are 
sta<s<cally 
independent. 
H0: 
The 
country 
of 
the 
residence 
and 
the 
level 
of 
recogni<on 
of 
Vichy 
visuals 
are 
sta<s<cally 
independent. 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
emo<onal 
benefits 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0a: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘feeling 
more 
confident 
as 
emo<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0b: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘feeling 
more 
charisma<c’ 
as 
emo<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0c: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘feeling 
that 
skin 
becomes 
flawless’ 
as 
emo<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0d: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘feeling 
of 
keeping 
everything 
under 
control’ 
as 
emo<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
func<onal 
benefits 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0a: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘efficacy’ 
as 
the 
func<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0b: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘safety’ 
as 
the 
func<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0c: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘textures’ 
as 
the 
func<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0d: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
percep<on 
of 
‘deep 
ac<on’ 
as 
the 
func<onal 
benefit 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
percep<on 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
personality 
between 
Russia 
and 
France. 
H0a: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
percep<on 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
as 
reliable 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France. 
H0b: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
percep<on 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
as 
stylish 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France. 
H0c: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
percep<on 
of 
Vichy 
brand 
as 
intelligent 
brand 
between 
Russia 
and 
France. 
H0: 
The 
country 
of 
residence 
and 
the 
level 
of 
recogni<on 
of 
Vichy 
essence 
and 
values 
are 
sta<s<cally 
independent. 
A9ributes 
Emot. 
Benefits 
Func. 
Benefits 
Personality 
Essence 
2. Research Methodology 
Qualitative research: Br Id Hypotheses
3. Empirical context 
Vichy brand: 
• France in 1931, owned by L’Oréal Groupe (since 1955) 
• Cosmetique Active department of L’Oréal + La-Roche Posay, Sanoflore, Roget & 
Gallet and Skin Ceuticals 
• Distribution channel: pharmacies 
• Expert’s advice (pharmacist) and complete skin care routine 
• 15 sub-brands. Communication by sub-brand. 
• Renewal of identity: from ‘Health is beautiful’ to ‘You ideal skin’ 
Russia 
France 
1.6 bln EUR (2012) 
Expected CAGR (5y): 5% 
Skin care 
Market* 
3 bln EUR (2012) 
Expected CAGR (5y): 1% 
Active cosmetics: Avéne, Bioderma, 
Uriage, LRP 
(Mass market:Kalina, Avon, Oriflame, L’Oréal) 
Competition 
*Source: Euromonitor Internation report, 2013 
Active cosmetics: Avéne, Nuxe, LRP 
(Mass market: Biersdorf, Yves Rocher, L’Oréal) 
N1 in active cosmetics, 3.5% MS 
The only from AC in TOP-10 SC 
LRP: 0.6% 
Vichy 
performance 
N3 in active cosmetics, 2.5% MS 
LRP: 4.7% 
Retail design&experience in POS on the 
initial stage/ 
Income growth, less educated 
Retail channel/ 
Consumers 
More developed, less concentrated. 
Parashops/ 
More knowledgeable, sophisticated
4. Results 
1. Vichy Brand IdentityYOUR IDEAL SKIN 
Reliable, stylish/sophisticated, 
intelligent 
Skinlife science 
Safety 
Origins: Vichy thermal water 
Pleasure 
Efficacy 
Safety 
Textures 
Deep action 
Feel self-confident 
Feel charismatic 
Flawless skin 
Feel on the top of 
things (in control) 
Brand 
essence 
Paris, 
2014
R: 62%, S: 45%, I: 45% 
3% negative traits 
Unprof: 3% previous users 
Outdated: 3% never/3% previous users 
Current users: ‘friendly’ instead ‘intelligent’ 
Users score higher the presence of traits 
84% recognized 
Least gap never-users (93%), 
largest: previous users (77%) 
FUNC average: 4.9/7; #1: Safety 
In general scores are lower for never-users 
EMO average: 3.5/7; #1: Flawless skin 
For current users: #1: Confidence 
Visual logo: 65%, 
max recognition: current users (83%) 
Textual: 66%; Confusion with old logo 20% 
max recognition: never users (71%) 
Visuals: 37%, confusion with LRP 
min confusion: current users 
YOUR 
IDEAL 
SKIN 
4. Results 
2. Vichy Brand Id-Image gap, Russia 
• Largest 
gap 
in: 
A9ributes 
(Visuals) 
and 
benefits 
(Emo<onal). 
Total 
match: 
values 
and 
personality. 
• Current 
users 
have 
Vichy 
brand 
image 
closest 
to 
the 
iden<ty. 
Never 
users 
tend 
to 
have 
closer 
image 
to 
iden<ty, 
since 
they 
have 
their 
impression 
created 
only 
by 
communica<ons, 
without 
using 
the 
product. 
• The 
highest 
perceived 
similarity 
of 
Vichy 
is 
with 
LRP 
(4.7/7), 
the 
lowest 
is 
with 
Nivea 
(2.1/7). 
15% 
didn’t 
know 
LRP 
Paris, 
2014
YOUR 
IDEAL 
SKIN 
4. Results 
3. Vichy Brand Id-Image gap, France 
R: 65%, S: 51%, I: 20%, Organized: 47% 
R: lowest for never-users (44%) 
Unprof.: 4% never/ 2% previous users 
Outdated: 4% never / 3% previous users 
The highest scores for reliable & elegant: 
current users; for intelligent: prev.users 
83% recognized 
Least gap with previous users 
(95%), largest: never users 
(72%) 
FUNC aver.4.7/7; #1: Textures 
Current users: highest scores 
Never users: lowest scores 
Never-users ranking – total match 
Users: textures 1st 
EMO aver.3.2/7; #1: Flawless skin 
Visual logo: 45%, textual: 60% 
Confusion with previous: 29% 
Visuals: 38%, confusion with Nivea 
Highest recogn. Level: current users 
• Largest 
gap: 
a9ributes, 
benefits, 
personality 
(‘intelligent’ 
trait 
is 
not 
associated). 
Match: 
values, 
2 
personality 
traits 
• Current 
users 
perceive 
a9ributes 
and 
benefits 
be9er 
than 
non-­‐users 
and 
previous 
users. 
• The 
highest 
perceived 
similarity 
is 
with 
LRP 
(4.5), 
the 
lowest 
with 
Nivea 
(2.4). 
5% 
didn’t 
know 
LRP. 
• Overall 
similarity 
of 
Vichy 
with 
LRP 
is 
lower 
in 
France 
than 
in 
RUS, 
and 
with 
Nivea 
is 
higher 
than 
in 
RUS 
Paris, 
2014
4. Results 
4. Differences between Russia and France 
Consumer behavior 
1. Regularity of cosmetic products usage 
2. Love looking soigné 
3. Level of care how the skin looks like 
4. Interest in the category 
5. $ spent on purchase 
Parametric 
test 
Non-­‐parametric 
test 
Overall similarities 
.00 
.00 
.02 
.27 
.24 
.00 
.00 
.00 
.17 
.02 
H0 
H0 
• In 
Russia 
consumers 
use 
cosme<c 
products 
more 
regularly 
than 
in 
France 
• In 
Russia 
consumers 
care 
more 
about 
how 
they 
and 
their 
skin 
look 
like 
than 
in 
France 
• In 
France 
consumers 
spend 
more 
on 
cosme<c 
products 
than 
in 
Russia: 
EUR39 
vs 
EUR46. 
*The 
difference 
is 
significant 
only 
when 
non-­‐parametric 
test 
is 
applied. 
1. L’Oréal Paris 
2. Nivea 
3. La Roche-Posay 
Parametric 
test 
Non-­‐parametric 
test 
.25 
.34 
.79 
.14 
.00 
.48 
H0 
H0 
• In 
France 
Nivea 
is 
perceived 
much 
more 
similar 
to 
Vichy 
in 
comparison 
with 
Russia 
if 
non-­‐parametric 
test 
is 
applied.
4. Results 
Attributes 
1. Visual logo 
2. Textual logo 
3. Visuals 
Chi-­‐Square 
.00 
.21 
.01 
.00 
.21 
.01 
H0 
Phi 
Cramer’s 
V 
H0 
Benefits 
1. Emotional all 
2. Feeling confident 
3. Feeling charismatic 
4. Feeling of flawless skin 
5. Feeling of control 
6. Functional all 
7. Efficacy 
8. Safety 
9. Textures 
10. Deep action 
Parametric 
test 
.05 
.00 
.28 
.58 
.79 
.28 
.24 
.01 
.19 
.65 
H0 
Non-­‐parametric 
test 
H0 
4. Differences between Russia and France 
.08 
.00 
.54 
.95 
.07 
.10 
.18 
.00 
.06 
.08 
Paris, 
2014
4. Results 
4. Differences between Russia and France 
Personality 
1. Personality all 3 
2. Reliable 
3. Stylish 
4. Intelligent 
* In FR: no ‘intelligent’ trait 
Parametric 
test 
.00 
.00 
.06 
.00 
.00 
.00 
.01 
.00 
H0 
H0 
Values 
1. Flower image 
.10 
Non-­‐parametric 
test 
Chi-­‐Square 
H0 
Phi 
Cramer’s 
V 
H0 
.10 
Paris, 
2014
Conclusion 
In RUS Vichy image is closer to Vichy identity than in FR. 
Current users have Vichy image closer to Vichy identity. 
The differences between countries are observed in Attributes, Benefits and Personality: 
• Textual logo: stronger association in Russia 
• Visual logo: in Russia confused with LRP, in France with Nivea 
• Confidence as emotional benefit: stronger in Russia 
• Safety as functional benefit: stronger in Russia 
• Brand personality is perceived closer to the original one in Russia 
• Vichy is seen as reliable more in Russia than in France 
• Vichy is seen as stylish in Russia rather than in France (if non-parametric test is applied) 
• In France Vichy brand is not seen as intelligent as it compared to Russia
MARKETING IMPLICATIONS 
• In both countries attributes are recognized poorly: revise key messages and statements 
• In both countries benefits are not highly associated with the brand (esp. emotional) 
• Invest in general brand support: attributes are recognized on the aver/below aver level 
• In Russia Vichy is confused with LRP: create marketing activities aimed to stress the 
difference with LRP. 
• In France Vichy is perceived being similar to Nivea: highlight the medical expertise of 
Vichy, position itself within the right category (active cosmetics and not mass market) 
LIMITATIONS 
• Lack of representativeness due to the sampling method 
• Different samples structure 
• Biggest cities mostly 
• Research not on the image, but on the perception of given characteristics 
Paris, 
2014
THANK 
YOU 
FOR 
YOUR 
ATTENTION
Back-­‐up
Structure 
of 
the 
paper 
Introduc)on 
ROLE 
OF 
BRAND 
IDENTITY 
IN 
THE 
BRAND 
MANAGEMENT 
PROCESS 
7 
§1. 
BRAND 
IDENTITY 
AS 
THE 
CORE 
OF 
BRAND 
§2. 
BRAND 
IDENTITY 
COMMUNICATION 
PROCESS 
§3. 
INTERRELATION 
OF 
BRAND 
IMAGE 
AND 
BRAND 
IDENTITY 
THEORETICAL 
BACKGROUND: 
KEY 
FINDINGS 
EMPIRICAL 
CONTEXT 
40 
§1. 
VICHY 
BRAND 
PROFILE 
§2. 
ENVIRONMENTAL 
ANALYSIS 
METHODOLOGY: 
STUDY 
ON 
VICHY 
BRAND 
IDENTITY 
IN 
RUSSIA 
AND 
IN 
FRANCE 
50 
§1. 
RESEARCH 
DESIGN 
§2. 
QUALITATIVE 
RESEARCH 
§3. 
QUANTITATIVE 
RESEARCH 
RESULTS 
AND 
DISCUSSION 
65 
§1. 
DIFFERENCES 
BETWEEN 
VICHY 
IMAGE 
AND 
IDENTITY 
IN 
RUSSIA 
§2. 
DIFFERENCES 
BETWEEN 
VICHY 
IMAGE 
AND 
IDENTITY 
IN 
FRANCE 
§3. 
COMPARISON 
OF 
CONSUMER 
BEHAVIOR 
IN 
RUSSIA 
AND 
IN 
FRANCE 
§4. 
DIFFERENCES 
IN 
IDENTITY-­‐IMAGE 
GAP 
BETWEEN 
RUSSIA 
AND 
FRANCE 
§5. 
MARKETING 
IMPLICATIONS 
§6. 
LIMITATIONS 
CONCLUSION 
85 
BIBLIOGRAPHY 
89 
APPENDIX 
93 
AFFIDAVIT 
107 
Paris, 
2014
Author Definition 
Aaker D. Unique set of brand associations that the 
creator of the brand strives to develop-maintain. 
These associations reflect the 
meaning of the brand and its promises 
given by the company to its consumers. 
This is the ideal brand perception that the 
company wants the customers to have. 
Bichun Y. Ideal brand essence given by the brand 
creator. 
Bivainiene L. The way the creators of the brand want the 
consumers to 
perceive the brand. 
De Cherantoni L. Brand character, goals and values that 
allow for brand differentiation. 
Domnin V. It is the brand meaning. This concept aims 
to identify and differentiate a bran in order 
to influence customer behavior. It is the 
ideal state of brand: the way brand creators 
want the brand to be perceived by 
stakeholders. 
Kapferer J.-N. Brand identity is necessary for 
differentiation and identification functions 
of the brand. It sets the framework of brand 
values and uniqueness. 
Pertsia V. and Mamleeva L. Unique complex of brand connected 
features, that substantiates why brand is 
exists, and includes the promise of the 
company to its customers. 
Starov S. Set of associations about one brand that the 
company strives to create. 
Source: 
[Bivainiene, 
2007 
; 
Domnin, 
2009 
; 
Nandan, 
2005 
; 
Starov, 
2010]
2. Structural models of brand identity 
J.-N. Kapferer 
Brand identity prism 
Paris, 2014 
D. Aaker 
Brand identity system 
• Br Id develo 
pment stage 
• Core/extended identity 
• 6 interrelated facets 
• Stimulus-reaction model 
• Externalization/ 
internalization 
de Chernatony 
Brand identity model 
• 5 elements 
• Brand vision and culture 
Thompson Total 
Branding, J. Walter 
Thompson 
Brand Platform 
model Young& 
Rubicam 
• Reason 
to trust 
• 4 levels 
• Brand personification 
Brand Key 
Unilever 
• 9 elements 
• Competition analysis 
• Key feature 
Brand Pyramid 
Mars 
• 7 elements 
• USP 
• Consumer values 
2. Theoretical background 
Key findings
2. Theoretical background 
Key findings 
4. Brand identity/brand image: conceptual difference 
IDENTITY 
IMAGE 
Owner/creator 
Sender: 
company 
(brand-­‐manager, 
marke<ng-­‐manager) 
Paris, 
2014 
Receiver: 
target 
audience 
(consumer) 
Related 
ac<on 
Crea<on/coding 
Interpreta<on/ 
decoding 
Concept 
Absolu<on 
Reality 
Exposure 
to 
external 
Indirect 
Direct 
factors 
Level 
of 
control 
by 
the 
brand 
owner 
Strong 
Weak 
Source: 
[Chernatony, 
1999; 
Driesener 
& 
Romaniuk, 
2006; 
Janonis 
& 
Virvilaitė, 
2007; 
Kapferer, 
2008; 
Keller, 
2005; 
Roy 
& 
Barenjee, 
2007; 
Srivastava, 
2010; 
Stock, 
2009; 
Domnin, 
2009]
Novelty: 
• Systematization of the differences between the notions of brand image and 
Tasks: 
1. Specification of the definitions of brand identity on the basis of already 
existing; 
2. Analysis of the structural models of brand identity; 
3. Defining the process of brand identity communication and brand image 
formation; 
4. Constructing Vichy brand identity in Russian and in French markets through 
the qualitative research of the brand’s representatives; 
5. Studying the perception of Vichy brand identity, i.e. brand image, in Russian 
and in French markets through the consumer research, determining the gaps 
between them; 
6. Formulating the differences in the nature of the gap between France and 
Russia. 
1. The Framework 
Paris, 
2014 
brand identity 
• Study of the brand image-brand identity gap in the cosmetics market 
• Comparison of the nature of the gap between 2 countries
H0: 
3. Research Methodology 
Quantitative research: Consumer behavior Hypotheses 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
regularity 
of 
usage 
of 
cosme<c 
products 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
loving 
looking 
sogné 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
level 
of 
care 
about 
the 
appearance 
of 
the 
skin 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
level 
of 
interest 
in 
the 
category 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
preference 
towards 
buying 
cosme<c 
products 
on-­‐line 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France 
H0: 
There 
is 
no 
difference 
in 
the 
amount 
of 
money 
spent 
per 
purchase 
in 
Russia 
and 
in 
France 
Paris, 
2014
Split by groups in 2 countries 
28 
36 
36 
Never 
used 
Previously 
used 
Currently 
using 
25 
29 
46 
Never 
used 
Previously 
used 
Currently 
using 
Paris, 
2014
Structural 
models 
of 
brand 
iden<ty 
Aaker D. Kapfereer 
J.-N. 
De 
Chernaton 
y (1) 
De 
Chernaton 
y (2) 
Keller 
K. 
Brand 
Wheel 
Brand 
Platform 
Thompson 
Total 
Branding 
(1) 
Thompson 
Total 
Branding 
(2) 
Brand 
Key 
Brand 
Pyramid 
Physical 
traits/attributes + + + + + + 
Personality + + + + + + + + + 
Relationship + + + 
Culture + + 
Self-reflection + 
Self-image + 
Essence + + + + + 
Gains (rational) 
/functional benefits + + + + + + + 
Emotional benefits + + + + + + + 
Values/principles + + + + 
Positioning + + + + 
Codes + 
USP/Reason to 
trust + + + + 
Products + 
TA + + 
Competition + 
Consumer insight + 
Key feature + 
Ценности 
потребителя + 
Presentation + 
Vision + 
Symbolic benefits + 
Paris, 
2014
Aaker 
Paris, 
2014
Kapferer 
Paris, 
2014
De 
Chernatony 
Paris, 
2014
Brand 
plaworm, 
Young&Rubicam 
Paris, 
2014
Sources 
• Data 
bases: 
EBSCO, 
JSTOR, 
ProQuest, 
Emerald. 
• Euromonitor 
Interna<onal 
• Authors: 
Aaker, 
Domnin, 
Kapferer, 
Kotler, 
Starov, 
de 
Chernatony 
& 
etc. 
Paris, 
2014
Vichy 
visuals: 
change 
Paris, 
2014
Survey: 
distribu<on 
Paris, 
2014
Essence 
& 
values 
images 
Paris, 
2014
Q 
on 
visuals
Visual 
logo 
for 
different 
subbrands 
Paris, 
2014
AQUALIA 
THERMAL 
Hydration, 
max 
concentratio 
n of 
Thermal 
water 
CAPITAL 
SOLEIL 
Sun 
protection 
UVA & 
UVB 
DEODORANT DERCOS 
Shampoos and hair 
care 
DERMABLEND 
Correction Fondation 
CELLU 
DESTOCK 
Body care : 
correction 
IDEALIA 
Perfect skin 
tone and 
quality 
LIFTACTIV 
Against deep 
wrinkles 
NEOVADIOL 
Imporves skin density 
NORMADERM 
Problematic skin 
(acne, redness…) 
NUTRIEXT 
RA 
Deep 
nutrition : 
body 
NUTRILO 
GIE 
Deep 
nutrition : 
face 
PURETE 
THERMAL 
Cleansing 
products 
TEINT 
Fondation 
VICHY HOMME 
Products for men 
Sub-­‐brands
Web-­‐site: 
product 
descrip<on 
Paris, 
2014
Textual 
logo 
Frequency, % Russia France 
Valid 
very old 20 1 
not existing 4 9 
official 66 60 
previous 9 29 
vichy town 1 1 
Total 100 100 
Visual 
logo 
% of respondents Russia France 
Valid 
LRP 37.0 18.0 
NIVEA 22.0 41.0 
CLARINS 4.0 3.0 
VICHY 37.0 38.0 
Total 100.0 100.0 
% of respondents Russia France 
Never used Valid 
very old 
Not existing 
official 
previous 
vichy town 
Total 
very old 
17.9 
0 
71.4 
7.1 
3.6 
100.0 
27.8 
0 
4.0 
52.0 
40.0 
4.0 
100.0 
0 
Previously Valid not existing 2.8 17.2 
official 61.1 55.2 
previous 8.3 27.6 
Total 100.0 100.0 
Currently Valid 
very old 13.9 2.2 
not existing 8.3 6.5 
official 66.7 67.4 
previous 11.1 23.9 
Total 100.0 100.0 
% of respondents Russia France 
Never used Valid 
LRP 39.3 8.0 
NIVEA 21.4 56.0 
CLARINS 7.1 12.0 
VICHY 32.1 24.0 
Total 100.0 100.0 
Previously Valid 
LRP 38.9 20.7 
NIVEA 25.0 37.9 
CLARINS 0 
VICHY 36.1 41.4 
Total 100.0 100.0 
Currently Valid 
LRP 33.3 21.7 
NIVEA 19.4 34.8 
CLARINS 5.6 0 
VICHY 41.7 43.5 
Total 100.0 100.0

More Related Content

What's hot

Analyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en France
Analyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en FranceAnalyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en France
Analyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en France
Marta.B
 
Stratégie de Marque Levi's
Stratégie de Marque Levi'sStratégie de Marque Levi's
Stratégie de Marque Levi's
ADELINE LABOUYSSE
 
Auchan
AuchanAuchan
Silk Soymilk Advertising Plan
Silk Soymilk Advertising PlanSilk Soymilk Advertising Plan
Silk Soymilk Advertising Plan
Holly Van Wyck
 
International Strategy LVMH
International Strategy LVMHInternational Strategy LVMH
International Strategy LVMH
Prashanth Ramachandran
 
Fish sauce usage in Vietnam
Fish sauce usage in VietnamFish sauce usage in Vietnam
Fish sauce usage in Vietnam
DI Marketing
 
Le renouveau d’Oasis
Le renouveau d’OasisLe renouveau d’Oasis
Le renouveau d’Oasis
IONIS Education Group
 
Louis vuitton mini case
Louis vuitton mini caseLouis vuitton mini case
Louis vuitton mini case
Rhythm Tyagi
 
Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3
Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3
Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3
Giang Nguyễn
 
The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...
The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...
The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...
diana_vardanyan
 
Stratégie marketing du Club Med
Stratégie marketing du Club MedStratégie marketing du Club Med
Stratégie marketing du Club Med
Nicholas Roy
 
Louis Vuitton Digital Marketing Strategy
Louis Vuitton Digital Marketing StrategyLouis Vuitton Digital Marketing Strategy
Louis Vuitton Digital Marketing Strategy
Olliver Joseph
 
Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette
Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette
Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette
Rebecca JAÏS, Master Digital Business
 
Asos case slides
Asos case slidesAsos case slides
Asos case slides
Davidson Peetala
 
Strategie des marques: épiceries du luxe
Strategie des marques: épiceries du luxeStrategie des marques: épiceries du luxe
Strategie des marques: épiceries du luxefleruyet
 
Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...
Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...
Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...
Alexandre Lasserre
 
Food delivery demand after covid 19
Food delivery demand after covid 19Food delivery demand after covid 19
Food delivery demand after covid 19
Q&Me Vietnam Market Research
 
Challenge auchan dossier_2
Challenge auchan dossier_2Challenge auchan dossier_2
Challenge auchan dossier_2Charles Richard
 
Merchandising produit frais halal auchan la défense
Merchandising produit frais halal auchan la défenseMerchandising produit frais halal auchan la défense
Merchandising produit frais halal auchan la défenseNawel Dehiri
 

What's hot (20)

Asos final
Asos finalAsos final
Asos final
 
Analyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en France
Analyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en FranceAnalyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en France
Analyse de stratégie de communication de la marque Lee Cooper en France
 
Stratégie de Marque Levi's
Stratégie de Marque Levi'sStratégie de Marque Levi's
Stratégie de Marque Levi's
 
Auchan
AuchanAuchan
Auchan
 
Silk Soymilk Advertising Plan
Silk Soymilk Advertising PlanSilk Soymilk Advertising Plan
Silk Soymilk Advertising Plan
 
International Strategy LVMH
International Strategy LVMHInternational Strategy LVMH
International Strategy LVMH
 
Fish sauce usage in Vietnam
Fish sauce usage in VietnamFish sauce usage in Vietnam
Fish sauce usage in Vietnam
 
Le renouveau d’Oasis
Le renouveau d’OasisLe renouveau d’Oasis
Le renouveau d’Oasis
 
Louis vuitton mini case
Louis vuitton mini caseLouis vuitton mini case
Louis vuitton mini case
 
Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3
Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3
Young Marketers Graduation - Canifa Repositioning - Nhóm 3
 
The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...
The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...
The features of the global marketing of luxury products (on the example of lo...
 
Stratégie marketing du Club Med
Stratégie marketing du Club MedStratégie marketing du Club Med
Stratégie marketing du Club Med
 
Louis Vuitton Digital Marketing Strategy
Louis Vuitton Digital Marketing StrategyLouis Vuitton Digital Marketing Strategy
Louis Vuitton Digital Marketing Strategy
 
Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette
Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette
Challenge Agorize: Galeries Lafayette
 
Asos case slides
Asos case slidesAsos case slides
Asos case slides
 
Strategie des marques: épiceries du luxe
Strategie des marques: épiceries du luxeStrategie des marques: épiceries du luxe
Strategie des marques: épiceries du luxe
 
Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...
Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...
Présentation du marché des Vins & Spiritueux en Afrique du Sud à l'occasion d...
 
Food delivery demand after covid 19
Food delivery demand after covid 19Food delivery demand after covid 19
Food delivery demand after covid 19
 
Challenge auchan dossier_2
Challenge auchan dossier_2Challenge auchan dossier_2
Challenge auchan dossier_2
 
Merchandising produit frais halal auchan la défense
Merchandising produit frais halal auchan la défenseMerchandising produit frais halal auchan la défense
Merchandising produit frais halal auchan la défense
 

Viewers also liked

Brandstorm
BrandstormBrandstorm
Literature review brand building
Literature review   brand buildingLiterature review   brand building
Literature review brand buildingbrandsynapse
 
Brand Management Project - Nissan
Brand Management Project - NissanBrand Management Project - Nissan
Brand Management Project - Nissan
Edward Roberts
 
Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)
Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)
Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)
Thierry Cellerin
 
Greek Tourism - UNCOVERED
Greek Tourism - UNCOVEREDGreek Tourism - UNCOVERED
Greek Tourism - UNCOVERED
TOPOSOPHY
 
Estee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPoint
Estee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPointEstee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPoint
Estee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPoint
Joshua Dopkowski
 
e-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailand
e-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailande-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailand
e-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailand
Wishtrend Thailand
 
Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy
Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy
Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy
Taylor Clayton
 
Benefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's market
Benefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's marketBenefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's market
Benefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's marketAmiirah Camall Saib
 
L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation
L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation
L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation
Christina Chen
 
Brandstorm 2017 Competition Presentation
Brandstorm 2017 Competition PresentationBrandstorm 2017 Competition Presentation
Brandstorm 2017 Competition Presentation
L'Oréal Talent
 
Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016
Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016
Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016
Rahul Gulaganji
 
Economical analysis of Cosmetic Industry
Economical analysis of Cosmetic IndustryEconomical analysis of Cosmetic Industry
Economical analysis of Cosmetic IndustryLovneet Singh
 
Skin care product PPT
Skin care product PPTSkin care product PPT
Skin care product PPT
Anu James
 
The Art of Branding by Guy Kawasaki
The Art of Branding by Guy KawasakiThe Art of Branding by Guy Kawasaki
The Art of Branding by Guy Kawasaki
Guy Kawasaki
 
Intro to Branding & Brand management - Elkottab
Intro to Branding & Brand management - ElkottabIntro to Branding & Brand management - Elkottab
Intro to Branding & Brand management - Elkottab
Muhammad Omar
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Brandstorm
BrandstormBrandstorm
Brandstorm
 
Literature review brand building
Literature review   brand buildingLiterature review   brand building
Literature review brand building
 
Brand Management Project - Nissan
Brand Management Project - NissanBrand Management Project - Nissan
Brand Management Project - Nissan
 
Sebamed pitch
Sebamed pitchSebamed pitch
Sebamed pitch
 
Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)
Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)
Rating of 143 Cosmetic & Beauty Brands on Digital (Russia 2012)
 
Greek Tourism - UNCOVERED
Greek Tourism - UNCOVEREDGreek Tourism - UNCOVERED
Greek Tourism - UNCOVERED
 
Estee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPoint
Estee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPointEstee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPoint
Estee Lauder Companies Strategic Audit PowerPoint
 
Estee Lauder analysis
Estee Lauder analysisEstee Lauder analysis
Estee Lauder analysis
 
e-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailand
e-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailande-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailand
e-Commerce and Cosmetics in Thailand - Market brieffing by Wishtrend Thailand
 
Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy
Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy
Victoria's Secret South Korean Market Entry Strategy
 
Organic Market in Greece
Organic Market in GreeceOrganic Market in Greece
Organic Market in Greece
 
Greek Fashion
Greek FashionGreek Fashion
Greek Fashion
 
Benefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's market
Benefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's marketBenefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's market
Benefit-based segmentation of cosmetic product's market
 
L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation
L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation
L'Oréal Brandstorm 2015 Presentation
 
Brandstorm 2017 Competition Presentation
Brandstorm 2017 Competition PresentationBrandstorm 2017 Competition Presentation
Brandstorm 2017 Competition Presentation
 
Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016
Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016
Cosmetic Industry Analysis Report 2015-2016
 
Economical analysis of Cosmetic Industry
Economical analysis of Cosmetic IndustryEconomical analysis of Cosmetic Industry
Economical analysis of Cosmetic Industry
 
Skin care product PPT
Skin care product PPTSkin care product PPT
Skin care product PPT
 
The Art of Branding by Guy Kawasaki
The Art of Branding by Guy KawasakiThe Art of Branding by Guy Kawasaki
The Art of Branding by Guy Kawasaki
 
Intro to Branding & Brand management - Elkottab
Intro to Branding & Brand management - ElkottabIntro to Branding & Brand management - Elkottab
Intro to Branding & Brand management - Elkottab
 

Similar to Master thesis defense.compressed

Dior Addict - Club of Notes
Dior Addict - Club of NotesDior Addict - Club of Notes
Dior Addict - Club of Notes
Julie Macé
 
Dove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand Extension
Dove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand ExtensionDove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand Extension
Dove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand Extension
Sameer Mathur
 
Brand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_Delhi
Brand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_DelhiBrand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_Delhi
Brand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_DelhiSukesh Chandra Gain
 
A Case study on Brand Loreal
A Case study on Brand LorealA Case study on Brand Loreal
A Case study on Brand Loreal
Aditya Raghavan
 
Dove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelp
Dove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelpDove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelp
Dove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelp
Andrew Robert
 
Enu global brands 090912
Enu global brands 090912Enu global brands 090912
Enu global brands 090912
Stephen Ong
 
Loreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledge
Loreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledgeLoreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledge
Loreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledge
Jibin Joseph
 
Fragrance Brand Identity
Fragrance Brand IdentityFragrance Brand Identity
Fragrance Brand Identity
Christelle Clairville Pierre-Joseph
 
Principles of Marketing
Principles of MarketingPrinciples of Marketing
Principles of Marketing
Yuki Hana
 
L'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel Retail
L'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel RetailL'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel Retail
L'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel Retail
Pierandrea Miglietta
 
Luxury brands report
 Luxury brands report Luxury brands report
Luxury brands report
Think Ethnic
 
Brand Equity of Dove
Brand Equity of DoveBrand Equity of Dove
Brand Equity of Dove
Ridhima Arora
 
Brand Personality
Brand Personality Brand Personality
Brand Personality
TanyaGupta888342
 
Luxury Brand Management Course
Luxury Brand Management CourseLuxury Brand Management Course
Luxury Brand Management CourseClaudio Diniz
 
Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...
Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...
Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...
www.marketingPlanMODE.com
 
Masterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielle
Masterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielleMasterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielle
Masterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielle
BARBARA LEGRAS
 
Amore pacific
Amore pacificAmore pacific
Amore pacific
Gunwoong
 
Dove Hips Feel Good
Dove Hips Feel GoodDove Hips Feel Good
Dove Hips Feel GoodArief Akbar
 
Comparative Brand Audit Sample
Comparative Brand Audit SampleComparative Brand Audit Sample
Comparative Brand Audit Sample
Daniel McKean
 

Similar to Master thesis defense.compressed (20)

Dior Addict - Club of Notes
Dior Addict - Club of NotesDior Addict - Club of Notes
Dior Addict - Club of Notes
 
Dove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand Extension
Dove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand ExtensionDove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand Extension
Dove Whitenening Deodrant- Brand Extension
 
Brand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_Delhi
Brand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_DelhiBrand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_Delhi
Brand building and category expansion_ITC Interrobang Case Competition FMS_Delhi
 
Loreal
Loreal Loreal
Loreal
 
A Case study on Brand Loreal
A Case study on Brand LorealA Case study on Brand Loreal
A Case study on Brand Loreal
 
Dove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelp
Dove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelpDove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelp
Dove beauty bar in china assignment help by No1AssignmentHelp
 
Enu global brands 090912
Enu global brands 090912Enu global brands 090912
Enu global brands 090912
 
Loreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledge
Loreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledgeLoreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledge
Loreal HBR case analysis- Global brand local knowledge
 
Fragrance Brand Identity
Fragrance Brand IdentityFragrance Brand Identity
Fragrance Brand Identity
 
Principles of Marketing
Principles of MarketingPrinciples of Marketing
Principles of Marketing
 
L'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel Retail
L'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel RetailL'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel Retail
L'Oreal Brandstorm - Lancome in Travel Retail
 
Luxury brands report
 Luxury brands report Luxury brands report
Luxury brands report
 
Brand Equity of Dove
Brand Equity of DoveBrand Equity of Dove
Brand Equity of Dove
 
Brand Personality
Brand Personality Brand Personality
Brand Personality
 
Luxury Brand Management Course
Luxury Brand Management CourseLuxury Brand Management Course
Luxury Brand Management Course
 
Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...
Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...
Free marketing plan sample of Philips, Hair Streamers, by www.marketingPlanNO...
 
Masterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielle
Masterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielleMasterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielle
Masterclass escp du 221015 version confidentielle
 
Amore pacific
Amore pacificAmore pacific
Amore pacific
 
Dove Hips Feel Good
Dove Hips Feel GoodDove Hips Feel Good
Dove Hips Feel Good
 
Comparative Brand Audit Sample
Comparative Brand Audit SampleComparative Brand Audit Sample
Comparative Brand Audit Sample
 

Master thesis defense.compressed

  • 1. MASTER THESIS Accomplished by: Renata MOKROVA Supervised by: Boris DURISIN Differences between Vichy Brand Image & Vichy Brand Identity in Russian and in French Markets
  • 2. The Framework Relevance of the topic chosen • Increasing importance of brand management • Mismatch between company’s and consumers’ perception of the brand • Room for research in active cosmetics/cross-country analysis • Mismatch of the Vichy brand identity and brand image in Russia • Vichy brand identity recent renewal Object: Vichy brand (L’Oréal Groupe) Subject: Gap between brand image and brand identity Research Question What are the differences in the gap between Vichy brand image and Vichy brand identity in Russian and French markets? Paris, 2014
  • 3. 1. Theoretical background 1. Defining the notions Broad definition: The core brand sense in its perfect state, like the company wants it to be (Aaker, Bivainiene, Domnin) Narrow definition: The set of brand characteristics that allow for brand identification and differentiation by maintaining its core (Kapferer) • to identify the brand • to differentiate the brand Key findings BRAND IDENTITY BRAND IMAGE The perception of the brand by consumers, constructed from unique set of associations, created in the memory of consumers in the process of the communication with the brand (Aaker, Keller, Janonis and Virvilaite). Types of associations: 1. ATTRIBUTES 2. BENEFITS 3. PERSONALITY • Non-product related • Product-related • Functional • Experiential • Symbolic Source: [Keller, 2005; Korchia, 2005] • Brand character • Personal traits Paris, 2014
  • 4. 1. Theoretical background Key findings 2. Brand Wheel structural model, Bates Worldwide Brand essence Personality Values Benefits A9ributes Physical characteris<cs (color, package, aroma) In comparison to other brands Principles, guidelines, key pillars Human traits, characteris<cs Key idea, core Source: [Domnin, 2009; Starov, 2008] Paris, 2014
  • 5. 1. Theoretical background Key findings 3. Brand identity communication process 6 obstacles for BR ID communication Sender Company Source: [Doyle, 2001; Starov, 2010] Mean of communication Receiver Consumer Brand iden)ty Brand image Reac<on Other signals Coding Decoding Feedback Message • Other factors • External brand-related signals • Inappropriate communication channel • Competitors’ activities • Inappropriate BR ID • Inefficient messages Paris, 2014
  • 6. 2. Research Methodology 1. Qualita<ve research: STAGE In-­‐depth interview with a Vichy representa<ve Vichy brand iden<ty 2. Quan<ta<ve research: Survey, 200 consumers (poten<al/previous/ current) • 100 in Russia • 100 in France RESULT Vichy brand image-­‐id gap • in Russia • in France Cross-­‐country comparison of the brand image-­‐id gap Goal: reveal the differences in the brand iden<ty-­‐image gap between Russian and French markets Research Ques)ons: 1. How Vichy brand iden<ty is defined? 2. Are new Vichy logos (both visual and textual) are known and being recognized by consumers and can be considered as strong brand a9ributes? 3. Do consumers perceive the emo<onal and func<onal benefits stated in brand iden<ty model as the ones offered by Vichy brand? 4. If Vichy would be a person, would have consumers described it with exactly the same traits as stated in the brand iden<ty model? How strong the stated traits are recognized in Vichy by consumers? 5. Could consumers recognize indirectly the values and the essence of Vichy brand specified in its iden<ty model? 6. How similar is Vichy brand image in general from the point of view of Russian and French consumers to its compe<tors? 7. How different is the nature of the iden<ty-­‐image gap in Russia and in France? 8. What are the differences in consumer behavior in ac<ve cosme<cs category between Russia and France? Paris, 2014
  • 7. 2. Research Methodology Qualitative research HOW • In-depth interview using the interview guideline, based on the structure of Brand Wheel model • 1h, language: Russian, recorded WHO • Vichy brand-manager, responsible for the sub-brands: Normaderm, Vichy Homme, axe deodorants and recent general brand campaign WHEN/WHERE • 19th of April, 2014 • Anti-Café, 10 rue de Richelieu, Paris RESULT • Vichy brand identity wheel • Hypotheses for the qualitative stage Paris, 2014
  • 8. Questionnaire design 2. Research Methodology Qualitative research • 20 questions, multi-choice / scaled questions • 6 parts: 1. Consumer behavior and involvement in the category 2. Vichy attributes (logos and images): recognition with/without a hint 3. Vichy benefits (emotional and functional): Likert scale 4. Vichy personality: chose 3 traits and assess the intensity of given traits for Vichy 5. Vichy values & essence: implicit, defined through association with the image 6. Socio-demographic • Created in English, translated into Russian and French, checked with a bilingual • It was based on the existing study on brand identity/image gap (Janonis, Dovalienė, Virvilaitė, 2007) Sampling • Sample size: 200, scope: France and Russia • Intentionally non-representative: Vichy target audience as defined by Vichy brand-manager • Convenience and judgmental sampling methods • On-line distribution of the survey: acquaintances, woman forums, direct messages to brand pages followers in social networks • To motivate respondents: there was a chance to get Vichy product for free (6 products were allocated) Methods of data analysis • SPSS package • Vichy brand wheel in each country: Central tendency measures analysis • Cross-country comparison: hypotheses testing • Parametric test: Student t-test / Non-parametric: Mann-Whitney U test for 2 independent samples • Chi-Square test for nominal variables (measure of association) Paris, 2014
  • 9. H0: The country of the residence and the level of recogni<on of visual Vichy logo are sta<s<cally independent. H0: The country of the residence and the level of recogni<on of textual Vichy logo are sta<s<cally independent. H0: The country of the residence and the level of recogni<on of Vichy visuals are sta<s<cally independent. H0: There is no difference in the percep<on of emo<onal benefits of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0a: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘feeling more confident as emo<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0b: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘feeling more charisma<c’ as emo<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0c: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘feeling that skin becomes flawless’ as emo<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0d: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘feeling of keeping everything under control’ as emo<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0: There is no difference in the percep<on of func<onal benefits of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0a: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘efficacy’ as the func<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0b: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘safety’ as the func<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0c: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘textures’ as the func<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0d: There is no difference in the percep<on of ‘deep ac<on’ as the func<onal benefit of Vichy brand between Russia and France H0: There is no difference in percep<on of Vichy brand personality between Russia and France. H0a: There is no difference in percep<on of Vichy brand as reliable brand between Russia and France. H0b: There is no difference in percep<on of Vichy brand as stylish brand between Russia and France. H0c: There is no difference in percep<on of Vichy brand as intelligent brand between Russia and France. H0: The country of residence and the level of recogni<on of Vichy essence and values are sta<s<cally independent. A9ributes Emot. Benefits Func. Benefits Personality Essence 2. Research Methodology Qualitative research: Br Id Hypotheses
  • 10. 3. Empirical context Vichy brand: • France in 1931, owned by L’Oréal Groupe (since 1955) • Cosmetique Active department of L’Oréal + La-Roche Posay, Sanoflore, Roget & Gallet and Skin Ceuticals • Distribution channel: pharmacies • Expert’s advice (pharmacist) and complete skin care routine • 15 sub-brands. Communication by sub-brand. • Renewal of identity: from ‘Health is beautiful’ to ‘You ideal skin’ Russia France 1.6 bln EUR (2012) Expected CAGR (5y): 5% Skin care Market* 3 bln EUR (2012) Expected CAGR (5y): 1% Active cosmetics: Avéne, Bioderma, Uriage, LRP (Mass market:Kalina, Avon, Oriflame, L’Oréal) Competition *Source: Euromonitor Internation report, 2013 Active cosmetics: Avéne, Nuxe, LRP (Mass market: Biersdorf, Yves Rocher, L’Oréal) N1 in active cosmetics, 3.5% MS The only from AC in TOP-10 SC LRP: 0.6% Vichy performance N3 in active cosmetics, 2.5% MS LRP: 4.7% Retail design&experience in POS on the initial stage/ Income growth, less educated Retail channel/ Consumers More developed, less concentrated. Parashops/ More knowledgeable, sophisticated
  • 11. 4. Results 1. Vichy Brand IdentityYOUR IDEAL SKIN Reliable, stylish/sophisticated, intelligent Skinlife science Safety Origins: Vichy thermal water Pleasure Efficacy Safety Textures Deep action Feel self-confident Feel charismatic Flawless skin Feel on the top of things (in control) Brand essence Paris, 2014
  • 12. R: 62%, S: 45%, I: 45% 3% negative traits Unprof: 3% previous users Outdated: 3% never/3% previous users Current users: ‘friendly’ instead ‘intelligent’ Users score higher the presence of traits 84% recognized Least gap never-users (93%), largest: previous users (77%) FUNC average: 4.9/7; #1: Safety In general scores are lower for never-users EMO average: 3.5/7; #1: Flawless skin For current users: #1: Confidence Visual logo: 65%, max recognition: current users (83%) Textual: 66%; Confusion with old logo 20% max recognition: never users (71%) Visuals: 37%, confusion with LRP min confusion: current users YOUR IDEAL SKIN 4. Results 2. Vichy Brand Id-Image gap, Russia • Largest gap in: A9ributes (Visuals) and benefits (Emo<onal). Total match: values and personality. • Current users have Vichy brand image closest to the iden<ty. Never users tend to have closer image to iden<ty, since they have their impression created only by communica<ons, without using the product. • The highest perceived similarity of Vichy is with LRP (4.7/7), the lowest is with Nivea (2.1/7). 15% didn’t know LRP Paris, 2014
  • 13. YOUR IDEAL SKIN 4. Results 3. Vichy Brand Id-Image gap, France R: 65%, S: 51%, I: 20%, Organized: 47% R: lowest for never-users (44%) Unprof.: 4% never/ 2% previous users Outdated: 4% never / 3% previous users The highest scores for reliable & elegant: current users; for intelligent: prev.users 83% recognized Least gap with previous users (95%), largest: never users (72%) FUNC aver.4.7/7; #1: Textures Current users: highest scores Never users: lowest scores Never-users ranking – total match Users: textures 1st EMO aver.3.2/7; #1: Flawless skin Visual logo: 45%, textual: 60% Confusion with previous: 29% Visuals: 38%, confusion with Nivea Highest recogn. Level: current users • Largest gap: a9ributes, benefits, personality (‘intelligent’ trait is not associated). Match: values, 2 personality traits • Current users perceive a9ributes and benefits be9er than non-­‐users and previous users. • The highest perceived similarity is with LRP (4.5), the lowest with Nivea (2.4). 5% didn’t know LRP. • Overall similarity of Vichy with LRP is lower in France than in RUS, and with Nivea is higher than in RUS Paris, 2014
  • 14. 4. Results 4. Differences between Russia and France Consumer behavior 1. Regularity of cosmetic products usage 2. Love looking soigné 3. Level of care how the skin looks like 4. Interest in the category 5. $ spent on purchase Parametric test Non-­‐parametric test Overall similarities .00 .00 .02 .27 .24 .00 .00 .00 .17 .02 H0 H0 • In Russia consumers use cosme<c products more regularly than in France • In Russia consumers care more about how they and their skin look like than in France • In France consumers spend more on cosme<c products than in Russia: EUR39 vs EUR46. *The difference is significant only when non-­‐parametric test is applied. 1. L’Oréal Paris 2. Nivea 3. La Roche-Posay Parametric test Non-­‐parametric test .25 .34 .79 .14 .00 .48 H0 H0 • In France Nivea is perceived much more similar to Vichy in comparison with Russia if non-­‐parametric test is applied.
  • 15. 4. Results Attributes 1. Visual logo 2. Textual logo 3. Visuals Chi-­‐Square .00 .21 .01 .00 .21 .01 H0 Phi Cramer’s V H0 Benefits 1. Emotional all 2. Feeling confident 3. Feeling charismatic 4. Feeling of flawless skin 5. Feeling of control 6. Functional all 7. Efficacy 8. Safety 9. Textures 10. Deep action Parametric test .05 .00 .28 .58 .79 .28 .24 .01 .19 .65 H0 Non-­‐parametric test H0 4. Differences between Russia and France .08 .00 .54 .95 .07 .10 .18 .00 .06 .08 Paris, 2014
  • 16. 4. Results 4. Differences between Russia and France Personality 1. Personality all 3 2. Reliable 3. Stylish 4. Intelligent * In FR: no ‘intelligent’ trait Parametric test .00 .00 .06 .00 .00 .00 .01 .00 H0 H0 Values 1. Flower image .10 Non-­‐parametric test Chi-­‐Square H0 Phi Cramer’s V H0 .10 Paris, 2014
  • 17. Conclusion In RUS Vichy image is closer to Vichy identity than in FR. Current users have Vichy image closer to Vichy identity. The differences between countries are observed in Attributes, Benefits and Personality: • Textual logo: stronger association in Russia • Visual logo: in Russia confused with LRP, in France with Nivea • Confidence as emotional benefit: stronger in Russia • Safety as functional benefit: stronger in Russia • Brand personality is perceived closer to the original one in Russia • Vichy is seen as reliable more in Russia than in France • Vichy is seen as stylish in Russia rather than in France (if non-parametric test is applied) • In France Vichy brand is not seen as intelligent as it compared to Russia
  • 18. MARKETING IMPLICATIONS • In both countries attributes are recognized poorly: revise key messages and statements • In both countries benefits are not highly associated with the brand (esp. emotional) • Invest in general brand support: attributes are recognized on the aver/below aver level • In Russia Vichy is confused with LRP: create marketing activities aimed to stress the difference with LRP. • In France Vichy is perceived being similar to Nivea: highlight the medical expertise of Vichy, position itself within the right category (active cosmetics and not mass market) LIMITATIONS • Lack of representativeness due to the sampling method • Different samples structure • Biggest cities mostly • Research not on the image, but on the perception of given characteristics Paris, 2014
  • 19. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION
  • 21. Structure of the paper Introduc)on ROLE OF BRAND IDENTITY IN THE BRAND MANAGEMENT PROCESS 7 §1. BRAND IDENTITY AS THE CORE OF BRAND §2. BRAND IDENTITY COMMUNICATION PROCESS §3. INTERRELATION OF BRAND IMAGE AND BRAND IDENTITY THEORETICAL BACKGROUND: KEY FINDINGS EMPIRICAL CONTEXT 40 §1. VICHY BRAND PROFILE §2. ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY: STUDY ON VICHY BRAND IDENTITY IN RUSSIA AND IN FRANCE 50 §1. RESEARCH DESIGN §2. QUALITATIVE RESEARCH §3. QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 65 §1. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN VICHY IMAGE AND IDENTITY IN RUSSIA §2. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN VICHY IMAGE AND IDENTITY IN FRANCE §3. COMPARISON OF CONSUMER BEHAVIOR IN RUSSIA AND IN FRANCE §4. DIFFERENCES IN IDENTITY-­‐IMAGE GAP BETWEEN RUSSIA AND FRANCE §5. MARKETING IMPLICATIONS §6. LIMITATIONS CONCLUSION 85 BIBLIOGRAPHY 89 APPENDIX 93 AFFIDAVIT 107 Paris, 2014
  • 22. Author Definition Aaker D. Unique set of brand associations that the creator of the brand strives to develop-maintain. These associations reflect the meaning of the brand and its promises given by the company to its consumers. This is the ideal brand perception that the company wants the customers to have. Bichun Y. Ideal brand essence given by the brand creator. Bivainiene L. The way the creators of the brand want the consumers to perceive the brand. De Cherantoni L. Brand character, goals and values that allow for brand differentiation. Domnin V. It is the brand meaning. This concept aims to identify and differentiate a bran in order to influence customer behavior. It is the ideal state of brand: the way brand creators want the brand to be perceived by stakeholders. Kapferer J.-N. Brand identity is necessary for differentiation and identification functions of the brand. It sets the framework of brand values and uniqueness. Pertsia V. and Mamleeva L. Unique complex of brand connected features, that substantiates why brand is exists, and includes the promise of the company to its customers. Starov S. Set of associations about one brand that the company strives to create. Source: [Bivainiene, 2007 ; Domnin, 2009 ; Nandan, 2005 ; Starov, 2010]
  • 23. 2. Structural models of brand identity J.-N. Kapferer Brand identity prism Paris, 2014 D. Aaker Brand identity system • Br Id develo pment stage • Core/extended identity • 6 interrelated facets • Stimulus-reaction model • Externalization/ internalization de Chernatony Brand identity model • 5 elements • Brand vision and culture Thompson Total Branding, J. Walter Thompson Brand Platform model Young& Rubicam • Reason to trust • 4 levels • Brand personification Brand Key Unilever • 9 elements • Competition analysis • Key feature Brand Pyramid Mars • 7 elements • USP • Consumer values 2. Theoretical background Key findings
  • 24. 2. Theoretical background Key findings 4. Brand identity/brand image: conceptual difference IDENTITY IMAGE Owner/creator Sender: company (brand-­‐manager, marke<ng-­‐manager) Paris, 2014 Receiver: target audience (consumer) Related ac<on Crea<on/coding Interpreta<on/ decoding Concept Absolu<on Reality Exposure to external Indirect Direct factors Level of control by the brand owner Strong Weak Source: [Chernatony, 1999; Driesener & Romaniuk, 2006; Janonis & Virvilaitė, 2007; Kapferer, 2008; Keller, 2005; Roy & Barenjee, 2007; Srivastava, 2010; Stock, 2009; Domnin, 2009]
  • 25. Novelty: • Systematization of the differences between the notions of brand image and Tasks: 1. Specification of the definitions of brand identity on the basis of already existing; 2. Analysis of the structural models of brand identity; 3. Defining the process of brand identity communication and brand image formation; 4. Constructing Vichy brand identity in Russian and in French markets through the qualitative research of the brand’s representatives; 5. Studying the perception of Vichy brand identity, i.e. brand image, in Russian and in French markets through the consumer research, determining the gaps between them; 6. Formulating the differences in the nature of the gap between France and Russia. 1. The Framework Paris, 2014 brand identity • Study of the brand image-brand identity gap in the cosmetics market • Comparison of the nature of the gap between 2 countries
  • 26. H0: 3. Research Methodology Quantitative research: Consumer behavior Hypotheses There is no difference in the regularity of usage of cosme<c products in Russia and in France H0: There is no difference in the loving looking sogné in Russia and in France H0: There is no difference in the level of care about the appearance of the skin in Russia and in France H0: There is no difference in the level of interest in the category in Russia and in France H0: There is no difference in the preference towards buying cosme<c products on-­‐line in Russia and in France H0: There is no difference in the amount of money spent per purchase in Russia and in France Paris, 2014
  • 27. Split by groups in 2 countries 28 36 36 Never used Previously used Currently using 25 29 46 Never used Previously used Currently using Paris, 2014
  • 28. Structural models of brand iden<ty Aaker D. Kapfereer J.-N. De Chernaton y (1) De Chernaton y (2) Keller K. Brand Wheel Brand Platform Thompson Total Branding (1) Thompson Total Branding (2) Brand Key Brand Pyramid Physical traits/attributes + + + + + + Personality + + + + + + + + + Relationship + + + Culture + + Self-reflection + Self-image + Essence + + + + + Gains (rational) /functional benefits + + + + + + + Emotional benefits + + + + + + + Values/principles + + + + Positioning + + + + Codes + USP/Reason to trust + + + + Products + TA + + Competition + Consumer insight + Key feature + Ценности потребителя + Presentation + Vision + Symbolic benefits + Paris, 2014
  • 33. Sources • Data bases: EBSCO, JSTOR, ProQuest, Emerald. • Euromonitor Interna<onal • Authors: Aaker, Domnin, Kapferer, Kotler, Starov, de Chernatony & etc. Paris, 2014
  • 34. Vichy visuals: change Paris, 2014
  • 36. Essence & values images Paris, 2014
  • 38. Visual logo for different subbrands Paris, 2014
  • 39. AQUALIA THERMAL Hydration, max concentratio n of Thermal water CAPITAL SOLEIL Sun protection UVA & UVB DEODORANT DERCOS Shampoos and hair care DERMABLEND Correction Fondation CELLU DESTOCK Body care : correction IDEALIA Perfect skin tone and quality LIFTACTIV Against deep wrinkles NEOVADIOL Imporves skin density NORMADERM Problematic skin (acne, redness…) NUTRIEXT RA Deep nutrition : body NUTRILO GIE Deep nutrition : face PURETE THERMAL Cleansing products TEINT Fondation VICHY HOMME Products for men Sub-­‐brands
  • 41. Textual logo Frequency, % Russia France Valid very old 20 1 not existing 4 9 official 66 60 previous 9 29 vichy town 1 1 Total 100 100 Visual logo % of respondents Russia France Valid LRP 37.0 18.0 NIVEA 22.0 41.0 CLARINS 4.0 3.0 VICHY 37.0 38.0 Total 100.0 100.0 % of respondents Russia France Never used Valid very old Not existing official previous vichy town Total very old 17.9 0 71.4 7.1 3.6 100.0 27.8 0 4.0 52.0 40.0 4.0 100.0 0 Previously Valid not existing 2.8 17.2 official 61.1 55.2 previous 8.3 27.6 Total 100.0 100.0 Currently Valid very old 13.9 2.2 not existing 8.3 6.5 official 66.7 67.4 previous 11.1 23.9 Total 100.0 100.0 % of respondents Russia France Never used Valid LRP 39.3 8.0 NIVEA 21.4 56.0 CLARINS 7.1 12.0 VICHY 32.1 24.0 Total 100.0 100.0 Previously Valid LRP 38.9 20.7 NIVEA 25.0 37.9 CLARINS 0 VICHY 36.1 41.4 Total 100.0 100.0 Currently Valid LRP 33.3 21.7 NIVEA 19.4 34.8 CLARINS 5.6 0 VICHY 41.7 43.5 Total 100.0 100.0