Key Tactics to Compete and Win in
Today’s Transparent Marketplace
Kerri Wise – VP, Dealer Marketing
@kkwise11
Source: Forbes.com article “The New World Of The 'Empowered Consumer” July 16, 2015
Mobile
Hands On
SmartCommitted
Global The
Empowered
Consumer
Today’s Car Buyer has Mixed Emotions
about the Car Buying Process
Car Buyer Pain Points
Convenience Transparency Validation
“I did my research before
going to the dealership, but I
ended up buying a different
car. I think I paid too much –
the dealer didn’t show me
any information to prove the
price was good.”
“I wish I knew how much the
dealer was making on the
car. Then, I could give them
a fair commission but still get
a good price. Not knowing
makes me trust them less.”
“I didn’t like the handoff. I
had to give them the same
information over and over
again, like I was starting
over.”
“I really don’t like the
waiting. I don’t like the way
they put me off.”
Customization
“I didn’t like the way they
tried to push me into a car I
didn’t want.”
“I felt like I was on a
conveyer process. The
whole process was about
them, not me.”
“They kept bringing up
things I didn’t care about.”
“There was no financial
explanation at all, and it
seemed like my payment
came from some mystery
algorithm, because they did
the math in the other room.”
“Unless you ask all the
questions, they don’t tell you
what you should know.”
“I would have trusted the
dealer more if they had given
me a roadmap or menu
showing all aspects of the
deal.”
Source: TrueCar Research
How much profit do car buyers think
you make?
21%
14%
3%
Consumers think
you Make
They are willing to
pay
Actual Dealer Profit
Consumer Perception of Dealer Profit
Perception vs. Reality
Source: 2015 Strategic Vision NVES W1-W3
Right Vehicle
Right Dealer
Right Price/
Deal
Vehicle Info, Photos,
Reviews
Ratings/Reviews, Inventory,
Salespeople Profiles
Vehicle Pricing, Mkt Supply, 3rd
Party Benchmarks, Dealer Offers,
Calculators
Right Vehicle Right Dealer Right Price/Deal
Car Shoppers use Online Research to Inform
and Validate their Decisions
Vehicle	
  Info,	
  Photos,	
  
Reviews	
  
Ra4ngs/Reviews,	
  Inventory,	
  
Salespeople	
  Profiles	
  
Vehicle	
  Pricing,	
  Mkt	
  Supply,	
  3rd	
  Party	
  
Benchmarks,	
  Dealer	
  Offers,	
  Calculators	
  
Right	
  Vehicle	
   Right	
  Dealer	
   Right	
  Price/Deal	
  
ONLINE	
  
Product	
  Knowledge/	
  
Consulta4on	
  
Efficient	
  and	
  
Streamlined	
  Process	
  
Transparency,	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  
Price	
  valida4on,	
  Value	
  
OFFLINE	
  
Top Dealers build off the online experience,
to deliver a Superior in-store experience
… and as a result Experience Higher Close Rates
2xHigher Close Rates
than the Competition
Streamlined
Process
Pricing
Strategy
Validation Value
Source: Top Performing Dealer Study
Key Differentiators of Top Dealers
Streamlined Process
2.5XFaster response than the
competition
Top Performing 20 mins
Competitors 52 mins
1st Custom Response Time
Top dealers respond significantly faster to leads than their competition, setting the stage for a
streamlined process.
Source: Mystery Shops
Expedite the Process
Source: Mystery Shops
79%send a Custom Email vs. 66%
of the Competition
Top dealers are more likely to personalize their lead responses, sending customized emails and
using more personal contact methods, such as a phone call, text and video.
Personalize Lead Response
Leverage Trusted Consumer Affiliations
Top Dealers acknowledge the consumer’s online journey and leverage their affiliations to
trusted sources
Source: Mystery Shops
robert@email.com
(555)500-5000
120 Broadway St.
Santa Monica, CA 90401
Robert Smith
Example Call:
“Hi Major Smith. This is Travis
Pennington, the USAA
representative here at Hometown
Nissan. I want to thank you for
choosing the 2015 Nissan Rogue
through the USAA car buying
program. It looks like we have one
in Tan and White like you
selected…”
67% of TrueCar prospects buy a different vehicle (make/model/trim) than they originally
configured.
Source: Website Metrics
Vehicle Choice
What % of Internet leads switch to a
different make or trim?
Same	
  Make,	
  
Model	
  and	
  Trim	
  
33%	
  
[CATEGORY	
  
NAME]	
  
[VALUE]	
  
Same	
  
Make	
  only	
  
10%	
  
Different	
  make	
  
13%	
  
NEW	
  Vehicle	
  Purchased	
  by	
  	
  
TrueCar	
  Prospects	
  
Top	
  dealers	
  keep	
  the	
  purchase	
  process	
  moving	
  by	
  proac4vely	
  sending	
  custom	
  price	
  
offers	
  on	
  alterna4ve	
  vehicles.	
  
Source: Dealer Performance Data
Suggest Alternatives
Close rate increases by
32%
when a consumer receives a price
offer on a specific vehicle
Pricing Strategy
Source: Dealer Interview
Embrace Transparency
73%Of Top Dealers will give a price
quote over the phone
“Our process is designed to engage & include
the customer in every step of the process.
Transparency is our culture & the tools we use
in the sales process support transparency.”
- Honda Dealer (Salt Lake City)
“We have to be because of this day and age.”
- Chevrolet Dealer (Denver)
Top dealers avoid a “set it and forget it” pricing strategy, frequently evaluating their pricing
strategy against the market.
Source: Dealer Performance Data and Website Metrics
Offer Market Based Pricing
ü  Evaluate Pricing 1.5x
More Often Than Average
ü  Pricing is typically in-line
with other Dealers
Source: Dealer Interviews
Offer Market Based Pricing
“Until recently our pricing strategy has been
lowest price for new cars. However, we recently
changed that strategy and have been focused
more on the TrueCar “curve” – fair market
pricing. The results have been far better gross
and volume has not yet been affected.”
- Nissan Dealer (Los Angeles)
Validation
Source: Dealer Interviews
Validate the Vehicle
“Credibility is one thing that
separates my dealer from
others and the condition report
just goes deeper into creating
a credible experience for me
as an independent dealer.”
- Independent Dealer (Indiana)
Used Vehicle Shoppers that see a 3rd Party Price Rating on a vehicle are 24% more likely to
submit a lead to a dealer
Source: Website Metrics
Validate the Price
5.2%
5.6%
4.3%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
3.5%
4.0%
4.5%
5.0%
5.5%
6.0%
Great Good No Price Rating
Price Rating
Lead Conversion
Top Dealers use 3rd party benchmarks to help validate the competitiveness of their price.
Source: Dealer Interviews
Validate the Price
Value
Source: Study referenced in book titled “Absolute Value”
Which camera would you buy?
$170 $240 $470
People and Process
Showcase Value
John Wilson
Subaru Product
Specialist
Showcase Value
Ownership Benefits
Showcase Value
Why Buy
Messaging
Showcase Value
I understand that our dealership may seem far away but here are a
few reasons why people make the trip out to us:
1. You will be dealing directly with either our General Manager or
Sales Manager who WON'T keep going back and forth with numbers.
2. Our TAX RATE is lower
3. We do not have ADVERTISING FEES on our INVOICES as Clark
Country dealerships do (ranging between $500-$1,000 depending on
vehicle.)
4. We WILL NOT do the bait-and-switch on you; the vehicle we do
the numbers on will be the same vehicle when you get to us (our
TRUECAR PROMISE).
5. If we cannot come to an agreement we will fill your vehicle up to
$50 for taking the time to see us.
6. When you do purchase from us we will send you and a friend to
THE WINERY for either lunch or dinner on us.
7. “Buyers Bonus” benefits including Auto Repair and Deductible
Reimbursement
Benefits of Driving a
Long Distance
Showcase Value
Profit Share
Program
Showcase Value
Charitable
Efforts
Questions?
kwise@truecar.com
@kkwise11

Key Tactics to Compete and Win in Today’s Transparent Marketplace

  • 1.
    Key Tactics toCompete and Win in Today’s Transparent Marketplace Kerri Wise – VP, Dealer Marketing @kkwise11
  • 2.
    Source: Forbes.com article“The New World Of The 'Empowered Consumer” July 16, 2015 Mobile Hands On SmartCommitted Global The Empowered Consumer
  • 3.
    Today’s Car Buyerhas Mixed Emotions about the Car Buying Process
  • 4.
    Car Buyer PainPoints Convenience Transparency Validation “I did my research before going to the dealership, but I ended up buying a different car. I think I paid too much – the dealer didn’t show me any information to prove the price was good.” “I wish I knew how much the dealer was making on the car. Then, I could give them a fair commission but still get a good price. Not knowing makes me trust them less.” “I didn’t like the handoff. I had to give them the same information over and over again, like I was starting over.” “I really don’t like the waiting. I don’t like the way they put me off.” Customization “I didn’t like the way they tried to push me into a car I didn’t want.” “I felt like I was on a conveyer process. The whole process was about them, not me.” “They kept bringing up things I didn’t care about.” “There was no financial explanation at all, and it seemed like my payment came from some mystery algorithm, because they did the math in the other room.” “Unless you ask all the questions, they don’t tell you what you should know.” “I would have trusted the dealer more if they had given me a roadmap or menu showing all aspects of the deal.” Source: TrueCar Research
  • 5.
    How much profitdo car buyers think you make? 21% 14% 3% Consumers think you Make They are willing to pay Actual Dealer Profit Consumer Perception of Dealer Profit Perception vs. Reality Source: 2015 Strategic Vision NVES W1-W3
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Vehicle Info, Photos, Reviews Ratings/Reviews,Inventory, Salespeople Profiles Vehicle Pricing, Mkt Supply, 3rd Party Benchmarks, Dealer Offers, Calculators Right Vehicle Right Dealer Right Price/Deal Car Shoppers use Online Research to Inform and Validate their Decisions
  • 8.
    Vehicle  Info,  Photos,   Reviews   Ra4ngs/Reviews,  Inventory,   Salespeople  Profiles   Vehicle  Pricing,  Mkt  Supply,  3rd  Party   Benchmarks,  Dealer  Offers,  Calculators   Right  Vehicle   Right  Dealer   Right  Price/Deal   ONLINE   Product  Knowledge/   Consulta4on   Efficient  and   Streamlined  Process   Transparency,                           Price  valida4on,  Value   OFFLINE   Top Dealers build off the online experience, to deliver a Superior in-store experience
  • 9.
    … and asa result Experience Higher Close Rates 2xHigher Close Rates than the Competition
  • 10.
    Streamlined Process Pricing Strategy Validation Value Source: TopPerforming Dealer Study Key Differentiators of Top Dealers
  • 11.
  • 12.
    2.5XFaster response thanthe competition Top Performing 20 mins Competitors 52 mins 1st Custom Response Time Top dealers respond significantly faster to leads than their competition, setting the stage for a streamlined process. Source: Mystery Shops Expedite the Process
  • 13.
    Source: Mystery Shops 79%senda Custom Email vs. 66% of the Competition Top dealers are more likely to personalize their lead responses, sending customized emails and using more personal contact methods, such as a phone call, text and video. Personalize Lead Response
  • 14.
    Leverage Trusted ConsumerAffiliations Top Dealers acknowledge the consumer’s online journey and leverage their affiliations to trusted sources Source: Mystery Shops robert@email.com (555)500-5000 120 Broadway St. Santa Monica, CA 90401 Robert Smith Example Call: “Hi Major Smith. This is Travis Pennington, the USAA representative here at Hometown Nissan. I want to thank you for choosing the 2015 Nissan Rogue through the USAA car buying program. It looks like we have one in Tan and White like you selected…”
  • 15.
    67% of TrueCarprospects buy a different vehicle (make/model/trim) than they originally configured. Source: Website Metrics Vehicle Choice What % of Internet leads switch to a different make or trim? Same  Make,   Model  and  Trim   33%   [CATEGORY   NAME]   [VALUE]   Same   Make  only   10%   Different  make   13%   NEW  Vehicle  Purchased  by     TrueCar  Prospects  
  • 16.
    Top  dealers  keep  the  purchase  process  moving  by  proac4vely  sending  custom  price   offers  on  alterna4ve  vehicles.   Source: Dealer Performance Data Suggest Alternatives Close rate increases by 32% when a consumer receives a price offer on a specific vehicle
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Source: Dealer Interview EmbraceTransparency 73%Of Top Dealers will give a price quote over the phone “Our process is designed to engage & include the customer in every step of the process. Transparency is our culture & the tools we use in the sales process support transparency.” - Honda Dealer (Salt Lake City) “We have to be because of this day and age.” - Chevrolet Dealer (Denver)
  • 19.
    Top dealers avoida “set it and forget it” pricing strategy, frequently evaluating their pricing strategy against the market. Source: Dealer Performance Data and Website Metrics Offer Market Based Pricing ü  Evaluate Pricing 1.5x More Often Than Average ü  Pricing is typically in-line with other Dealers
  • 20.
    Source: Dealer Interviews OfferMarket Based Pricing “Until recently our pricing strategy has been lowest price for new cars. However, we recently changed that strategy and have been focused more on the TrueCar “curve” – fair market pricing. The results have been far better gross and volume has not yet been affected.” - Nissan Dealer (Los Angeles)
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Source: Dealer Interviews Validatethe Vehicle “Credibility is one thing that separates my dealer from others and the condition report just goes deeper into creating a credible experience for me as an independent dealer.” - Independent Dealer (Indiana)
  • 23.
    Used Vehicle Shoppersthat see a 3rd Party Price Rating on a vehicle are 24% more likely to submit a lead to a dealer Source: Website Metrics Validate the Price 5.2% 5.6% 4.3% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 3.5% 4.0% 4.5% 5.0% 5.5% 6.0% Great Good No Price Rating Price Rating Lead Conversion
  • 24.
    Top Dealers use3rd party benchmarks to help validate the competitiveness of their price. Source: Dealer Interviews Validate the Price
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Source: Study referencedin book titled “Absolute Value” Which camera would you buy? $170 $240 $470
  • 27.
    People and Process ShowcaseValue John Wilson Subaru Product Specialist
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Showcase Value I understandthat our dealership may seem far away but here are a few reasons why people make the trip out to us: 1. You will be dealing directly with either our General Manager or Sales Manager who WON'T keep going back and forth with numbers. 2. Our TAX RATE is lower 3. We do not have ADVERTISING FEES on our INVOICES as Clark Country dealerships do (ranging between $500-$1,000 depending on vehicle.) 4. We WILL NOT do the bait-and-switch on you; the vehicle we do the numbers on will be the same vehicle when you get to us (our TRUECAR PROMISE). 5. If we cannot come to an agreement we will fill your vehicle up to $50 for taking the time to see us. 6. When you do purchase from us we will send you and a friend to THE WINERY for either lunch or dinner on us. 7. “Buyers Bonus” benefits including Auto Repair and Deductible Reimbursement Benefits of Driving a Long Distance
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.