SlideShare a Scribd company logo
2012
Abstract:
Current World Health Organization (WHO) estimates give a case fatality rate of 50-80% for
people infected with H5N1. Molecular studies into the virulence displayed by H5N1 provide
some basis for an increased case fatality rate, however they cannot explain it completely.
Criteria for reporting H5N1 infections are currently too stringent to allow accurate and
representative reporting of true H5N1 case fatality rates. Molecular studies can, however,
explain the abnormal symptoms of primary viral pneumonia and Acute Respiratory Distress
Syndrome (ARDS) displayed by patients infected with H5N1. Limited human cell tropism is
currently thought to be responsible for preventing human-human H5N spread, preventing
further fatalities beyond the 603 witnessed as of May, 2012. Intense interest in producing an
adaptable or universal H5N1 vaccine has lead to an ever improving field of H5N1 vaccine
production.
Introduction:
A highly virulent pathogen, H5N1 is yet to display a high degree of pathogenicity in humans,
the few infections observed thus far often resulting in fatal acute respiratory distress
syndrome (ARDS) (Lee et al, 2009). Current epidemiology suggests an extremely high
mortality rate amongst humans, though estimates are skewed by monitoring methods. There
is sufficient molecular evidence to raise concerns on the potential for H5N1 to achieve a
human-human transmissible form and cause a pandemic. As a result there have been a
number of recent varied studies undertaken to determine the molecular basis of H5N1
virulence. Due to the current public concern surrounding H5N1 there have been a number of
efforts targeted at producing an H5N1 vaccine and prospects for an H5N1 vaccine produced
in time to immunise against a pandemic strain are constantly improving.
Reasons for the absence of a human H5N1 pandemic
Influenza pathogenicity (the ability to cause disease in a host) is dependent on the tropism of
the viral haemmagglutinnin for host cell surface sialic acid-galactose linkages (Siaα-2,3 or
2,6Gal) and is potentially limited by compatibility with essential host enzymatic systems (van
Riel et al, 2012). H5N1 haemagglutinin (HA) is specific for Siaα-2,3Gal cell surface
linkages which are present in some cells of the human respiratory tract but which are also
largely outnumbered by the predominant Siaα-2,6Gal linkages.
Cells binding MAA agglutinin (recognises Siaα-2,3Gal) appear red, those binding SNA agglutinin (recognises Siaα-2,6Gal) appear green,
cells were counterstained with blue DAPI (Shinya et al, 2006).
The distribution of Siaα-2,3Gal linkages on the surfaces of human respiratory cells was
confirmed with the aid of lectin histochemsitry, using fluorescently tagged tree –derived
agglutinins specific for Siaα-2,6Gal and Siaα-2,3Gal (Shinya et al, 2006). The data shown
2012
above displays the relative paucity of cells displaying Siaα-2,3Gal linkages on their cell
surfaces in the lower respiratory tract relative to those which display Siaα-2,6Gal.
Considering Siaα-2,3Gal linkages are generally restricted to the lower respiratory tract, this
shows the overall lack of Siaα-2,3Gal in the human respiratory system. Viral histochemistry
has since confirmed that host cell range in the lower respiratory tract is predominantly limited
to type II pneumocytes and alveolar macrophages as well as Clara cells and non-ciliated
epithelial cells in the terminal bronchioles (van Riel et al, 2007), binding to the upper
respiratory tract cells occurring as well but only relatively rarely (Nicholls, 2007 and van Riel
et al, 2012).
Attachment of human and avian viruses to ciliated epithelial cells, goblet cells, and submucosal glands in the human URT, Upper respiratory
tract cells to which the virus bound display a red border which is indicative of virus-cell binding and thus virus-cell recognition. (van Riel
et al, 2010)
Virus histochemistry (use of labelled virus) has confirmed that tropism is associated with
sialic acid distribution and that tropism is associated with ability to spread (van Riel et al.,
2010). H5N1 has a different cell binding profile relative to seasonal (H1N1 and H3N2) and
pandemic (H1N1) forms of human influenza. As can be seen, H5N1 does not display a clear
binding to upper respiratory tract cells, with the exception of cells of the submucosal glands.
The human influenza strains tested are much more widespread amongst humans than H5N1
and so it is currently thought that tropism to upper respiratory tract epithelia may allow an
increased ability to undergo human-human spread (van Riel et al, 2010).
H5N1 human-human transmission may require compatible enzyme systems in human cells
allowing viral function and replication to occur (Webster et al,2006). This is not true in the
case of limited proteolysis of HA during the maturation of H5N1 (an extremely important
step in influenza replication) because the proteases responsible are virtually ubiquitous in our
cell membranes, more so than those responsible for seasonal and pandemic influenza HA
cleavage (Kido et al, 2012) suggesting that host proteases do not limit H5N1 as much as was
previously thought.
Thus, H5N1 has not caused more deaths in the human population probably because it is not
currently adapted to our upper respiratory tract, although adaptation is possible through
antigenic drift, as was seen in a reassorted H5N1 virus in ferrets (Kawaoka et al, 2012), or
antigenic shift through reassortment with human-adapted strains in intermediate reservoirs
2012
such as pigs (Cong et al, 2010). Both processes are currently occurring in native H5N1
populations (Kawaoka et al 2012 and Ibid.) and so monitoring of the situation is a key factor
in our preparedness for a potential H5N1 pandemic.
General Molecular mechanisms of H5N1 virulence:
Rapidly progressive primary viral pneumonia is a major feature of most reported H5N1-
related fatalities, a relatively rare event in other forms of influenza (Abdel-Ghafar,2008).
Resulting acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) is associated with damage to the
alveoli and is the main source of mortality amongst H5N1 patients (Peiris et al, 2009).
Molecular studies have sought to find the answers behind these abnormal symptoms, an
important and much-studied virulence factor being the H5N1 NS1 protein. H5N1 NS1 is
implicated in caspase-dependent apoptosis (Zhang et al, 2010) and hypercytokinemia (Lam et
al, 2011), allowing the symptoms of viral infection to extend far beyond a localised area in
the lungs (deJong et al, 2006). Systems-level comparisons between the H5N1 and the
seasonal form of H1N1 have found that H5N1 induces a similar pro-inflammatory cytokine
response to human-adapted influenza in vitro but that this response is quantitatively stronger
(Lee et al, 2009). Further study has also implicated NS1 in this response in vitro (Lam et al,
2011).
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) on normal (left) and plasmid transfected cells (right) X5,000 magnification (Zhang et al, 2010).
NS1 is a non-structural protein which normally has the role of inhibiting the host
interferon(IFN)-mediated innate immune response by binding double-stranded RNA, thereby
preventing the activation of the downstream cytosolic viral-detection machinery (Peiris et al,
2009). The role of H5N1 NS1 in triggering apoptosis was discovered with the use of
plasmid transfection on carcinomic alveolar epithelial cells. Use of recombinant techniques
and generation of an Escherichia coli (E. coli) library lead to the production of plasmids
encoding H5NS1. The cells were transfected with these plasmids as a surrogate for viral
infection and incubated for 24 hours (Zhang et al, 2010). Shown above are two transmission
electron micrographs on non-transfected and H5N1 NS1-transfected cells. Note how the
transfected cells are characteristic of post-apoptotic cells with condensed chromatin
aggregated along the nuclear membrane (red arrow) and apoptotic bodies (orange arrow).
2012
Enzyme activities of caspase-3 and caspase-9 in NS1-transfected alveolar epithelial cell line. Enzyme activities based on transformed y-axis
indicating levels of caspase activity based on absorbance according to Caspase detection kits(Zhang et al, 2010)
Western blotting showed that Caspases 3 and 9 (two downstream effectors of apoptosis in
mammalian cells) were present in transfected cells. Subsequent colorimetric assays for
activities indicated that both were activated during the infection of the alveolar epithelial cells
(Zhang et al, 2010). This study was done on an immortal cell line rather than primary ex vivo
alveolar epithelium in addition to only the NS1 gene in a modified form being substituted for
a native H5N1 particle with its associated myriad of virulence factors, limiting how
applicable these findings would be to the role of NS1 in a whole virus infection. However a
causative link between the presence of NS1 and caspase-dependent apoptosis has been
established (Zhang et al, 2010), providing a further clue into the molecular basis of H5N1
virulence as apoptosis on other forms of cell lines has also been observed and found to be an
essential mechanism for viral propagation (Wurzer et al, 2003) as well as being a contributing
factor to the viral pneumonia in fatal cases of H5N1 infection (Peiris, 2009).
Heatmap for averaged microarray gene expression profiles of H1N1 and H5N1 infected primary human macrophages. Results are averaged
across macrophages from three different individuals (Lee et al, 2009).
A systems-level approach showed that an infection of primary alveolar macrophages from 3
different individuals by a native H5N1 virus strain in vitro led to a much more pronounced
pro-inflammatory cytokine response than for a low-pathogenicity seasonal H1N1 subtype
2012
inoculated at an equivalent multiplicity of infection (Lee et al, 2009). This study came in lieu
of a number of studies which collectively showed that H5N1 infection caused a hyper-
induction of the cytokine response by alveolar macrophages and alveolar epithelial cells (Lee
et al, 2009). Global gene expression of macrophages infected with either H5N1 or H1N1 was
recorded using GeneChip arrays. A heat map of the relative gene expression between two
sets of alveolar macrophages, those infected with H1N1 and those with H5N1, shows that
similar pathways were upregulated at similar time points but that H5N1 infection caused a
much more intense upregulation. Overall it was found that components of cytokine pathways
for IFN-β and TNF-α were hyper-expressed in vitro (Lee et al, 2009) indicating the H5N1
viral particle was responsible for the hypercytokinemia seen in H5N1 patients (deJong et al,
2006).
Proportion overall cells displaying signs of early apoptosis upon transfection with influenza NS1 mRNA. (CC= non transfected controls).
(Lam et al, 2011)
Transfection of a lung epithelial cell line with mRNA encoding viral NS1 confirmed that
H5N1 NS1 is involved in the induction of apoptosis and inducing the abnormal pro-
inflammatory cytokine response behind ARDS (Lam et al, 2011). The proportion of early
apoptotic cells sampled at irregular intervals was determined flow cytometrically with the aid
of a fluorescent dye specific for early apoptotic cells. Note how large the difference between
H5 and other influenza subtype NS1 is in terms of both biological and statistical significance,
especially at 6 hours. H5 subtype NS1 mRNA transfection resulted in a maximum proportion
of early apoptotic cells double any other influenza NS1 in addition to having a 95%
confidence interval which was not overlapping any of the other ones, indicating a statistically
as well as biologically significant difference (Lam et al, 2011). This increase in apoptosis
could explain why primary viral pneumonia with diffuse alveolar damage is so common in
H5N1 infections, especially considering that the virus is generally limited to the lower
respiratory tract.
2012
Cytometric bead array was used to quantify the levels of relevant cytokines and chemokines.
As shown below, all influenza subtype NS1 mRNA transfections lead to levels of cytokine
both biologically and statistically significantly different from non-transfected cells, however
H5 subtype NS1 mRNA clearly caused a greater amount of expression of the pro-
inflammatory cytokines measured, indicating that it the hypercytokinemia displayed in
ARDS is at least partially due to the effect of H5N1 NS1(Lam et al, 2011).
Cytokines/chemokines induced by transfection of NS1 mRNA of different influenza subtypes. H5 subtype NS1 mRNA transfected cells are
shown in purple. Cytokine/chemokine levels are expressed as fold-changes compared to the non-transfected cell controls measured at the
same time points (Lam et al, 2011).
High case fatality rate
The current case fatality rate for reported H5N1 infections is between 50-80% (“WHO:
Cumulative number of H5N1 cases”, accessed 18.5.2012), extremely high compared to the
1918 H1N1-attributed case fatality rate of 2.5% (Marks et al, 1976). The difference between
case fatality rates is highly unlikely to be due to differences in virulence at the molecular
level alone. A good point has been made that the case fatality rate may be falsely high
because the WHO requires a very stringent number of conditions to be met before confirming
a case of H5N1 (Palesea,2012). A patient must report to a hospital with a laboratory
advanced enough to allow for serological or genetic testing with advanced symptoms of
influenza infection (“WHO: H5N1 Case definition”, accessed 14.05.12). These selection
criteria may provide a skewness towards patients who are severely ill (Peiris et al, 2009),
leaving little room for those who may have an asymptomatic H5N1 infection (if this is
possible) or people who cannot reach a hospital with the necessary facilities. Rural areas
where waterfowl and other reservoir species are abundant are also under-represented,
meaning that this stringent method is very likely giving a non-representative estimate of true
fatality rates amongst those infected with H5N1.
2012
Cumulative number of confirmed human cases for avian influenza A(H5N1) reported to WHO, 2003-2012 (“WHO: Cumulative
number of H5N1 cases”, accessed 18.5.2012)
Presence of unreported H5N1 infection with a successful outcome is possible as shown by the
discovery of anti-H5N1 HA antibodies in a sample of the poultry workers in the Chinese
province of Jiangsu where previous H5N1 infections and a death attributed to H5N1 had
occurred (Huo et al, 2012). Amongst the sample taken there were no people with prior severe
respiratory illness and the poultry in the villages sampled were not vaccinated against H5-
subtype avian influenza. Hemagglutination inhibition assays on blood samples for anti-H5N1
HA antibodies showed that seropositivity was present in two of the three villages and that
that the true population seropositivity rate for these two villages concerned was significantly
higher than zero (as high as between 2.19% and 10.78% in Gaoyou (95% confidence)). If
we take the number of H5N1 seropositive individuals just from Gaoyou (n=7) and added it to
all reported cases in China at the time of the study (n=46 from the above table) then we can
see that the case fatality rate for China shifts immediately from 66.6% (100*[28/42]) down
roughly 10% to 57.1% (100*[28/49]) if we assume that the anti-H5N1 antibodies came from
H5N1 infection with a successful outcome. This crude calculation serves to show that
making case fatality rate calculations with such stringent selection criteria leads to the
generation of inaccurate and error-prone statistics. This study was limited by a number of
factors, not the least of which being the restricted geography of sampling and a small sample
size, but it showed that it is possible to have H5N1 infections which do not result in
extremely adverse effects and that go unreported (Huo et al, 2012). Therefore WHO
estimates of case fatality rate may be skewed and more research into the true rate of H5N1
infection worldwide must be done before any reliable estimate of the true worldwide case
fatality rate of H5N1 can be determined.
Prospects for H5N1 vaccine:
H5N1 is constantly and quickly evolving, meaning that genetic diversification may occur so
quickly that even geographically close isolates of H5N1 may differ sufficiently to prevent
immunological cross-recognition of these strains should a vaccine based on either virus be
produced (Balish et al, 2010). Thus a vaccine must be adaptable with an ability to be
produced in large quantitites in a small amount of time (Zhou et al, 2012). Widespread, rapid
deployment and mass production of such a vaccine also pose major challenges to the
production of an H5N1 vaccine (McKenna, 2007).
As H5N1 is constantly evolving, it does not make financial or practical sense to mass produce
a standard vaccine based on any particular strain of H5N1 as such a vaccine may be made
irrelevant in the space of a few years or may not be relevant to a pandemic strain. Biannnual
WHO reports on global monitoring of H5N1 clades and their antigenic and epidemiological
properties allows for constant adjustment, depending on the storage of many different
2012
candidate viruses so that in the case of a pandemic it might be possible for the mass
production of any of these viruses, one of which would hopefully be close or identical to the
pandemic strain. As of February 2012 there were 20 known and available candidate viruses
for vaccines with 3 pending full development (“WHO: Antigenic and genetic properties of
zoonotic viruses”, 2012).
Production of a vaccine in large enough amounts to matter and whether this vaccine would
generate sufficient immunogenicity is another matter. Cell culture in bioreactors would allow
for a great increase in production capacity of an H5N1 vaccine without having to rely on the
low-yield and potentially at-risk embryonated hen egg techniques, a high-yield production
method based on the use of the continuous Vero cell line (kidney epithelium isolated from
Chlorocebus spp.) being recently developed (Zhou et al, 2012). The strength behind pairing
this production technique with an existing candidate virus and reverse genetics technology is
that this would allow high-level production of virtually tailor-made live attenuated viruses for
use in an inactivated or split virus vaccine based on relevant pandemic H5N1 antigens
(Watanabe, 2012).
H5N1 vaccines cause poor immunogenicity in patients and animal models inoculated and so
novel adjuvants increasing immunogenicity are sought after (McKenna, 2007). Multiple
different adjuvants are currently being trialled and developed. An alum-based adjuvant
showed a good immunogenic response in Japanese adults but induced febrile reactions in
minors (Nakayama, 2012) whereas a novel silver nanoparticle-based adjuvant has also been
developed (Jazayeri et al, 2012). The latter inducing pro-inflammatory cytokine release and
enhanced antibody and cell-mediated immune responses in chicks, however this adjuvant has
not yet been trialled in humans (Ibid., 2012).
There are several candidate H5N1vaccines which have been developed, however they are not
yet ready for widespread use (WHO: FAQs, accessed 18.5.12). Much work remains to be
done on an H5N1 vaccine. With constant monitoring and improved production capacities
coupled to reverse genetics, in addition to continuing development of improved novel
adjuvants, the outlook for an H5N1 vaccine and our ability to respond quickly to a pandemic
is looking better as time progresses.
Conclusion:
It is apparent that H5N1 could be the basis for a future pandemic, albeit at a true case fatality
rate likely to be less than 50-80%. This paper has only captured very few of the many
molecular studies on H5N1 virulence, focusing on the role of the multifunctional NS1. It
should be remembered that H5N1 virulence is a polygenic trait (Lam et al, 2011) not
dependent on NS1 function or cellular tropism alone. Epidemiology on H5N1 is currently
error-prone and should not be trusted as the sole measure on which predictions of an H5N1
pandemic should be based. However, the clearly increased molecular virulence has caused
enough concern and sparked enough fear and interest that the outlook for production of a
successful H5N1 vaccine in a short amount of time is constantly improving.
Word count (not counting abstract, figure legends and titles): 2,740 words.
2012
Bibliography:
Reasons for the absence of a human H5N1 pandemic
Cong Y., Wang G., GuanZ., Chang S., Zhang Q, Yang G., Wang W., Meng Q., Ren W.,
Wang C., Ding Z. (2010) Reassortant between Human-Like H3N2 and Avian H5
Subtype Influenza A Viruses in Pigs: A Potential Public Health Risk PLoS ONE 5(9); e12591
Kawaoka Y., Imai M., Watanabe T., Hatta M., Das S.C, Ozawa M., Shinya K., Zhong
Hanson A., Katsura H., Watanabe S., Li S., Kawakami E., Yamada S., Kiso M.,
Suzuki Y., Maher E.A. and Neumann G. Experimental adaptation of an influenza H5 HA
confers respiratory droplet transmission to a reassortant H5 HA/H1N1 virus in ferrets. Nature
(doi:10.1038/nature10831)
Kido H., Okumura Y., Takahashi E., Pan H.Y., Wang S., Yao D., Yao M., Chida J., YanoM.
(2012) Role of host cellular proteases in the pathogenesis of influenza and influenza-induced
multiple organ failure Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 1824: 186–194
Nicholls J.M., Chan M.C.W., Chan W.Y., Wong H.K., Cheung C.Y., Kwong D.L.W., Wong
M.P., Chui W.H., Poon L.L.M., Tsao S.W., GuanY. & Peiris J.S.M. Tropism of avian
influenza A (H5N1) in the upper and lower respiratory tract. Nature medicine 13(2);147-149
Shinya K., Ebina M., Yamada S., Ono M., Kasai N., Kawaoka Y. (2006) Influenza virus
receptors in the human airway. Nature 440 (doi:10.1038/440435a)
van Riel D., Munster V.J., de Wit E., Rimmelzwaan G.F., Fouchier R.A.M., Osterhaus
A.D.M.E., Kuiken T. (2007) Human and avian influenza viruses target different cells in the
lower respiratory tract of humans and other mammals. American Journal of Pathology
171( 4); 1215-1223
van Riel D., den Bakker M.A., Leijten L.M., Chutinimitkul S., Munster V.J., de Wit E.,
Rimmelzwaan G.F., Fouchier R.A.M, Osterhaus A.D.M.E. and Kuiken T. (2010) Seasonal
and pandemic human influenza viruses attach better to human upper respiratory tract
epithelium than avian influenza viruses. Am. J. Pathol. 176; 1614–1618.
van Riel D. and Kuiken T. (2012) The role of cell tropism for the pathogenesis of influenza in
humans Future Virol. 7(3)
Webster R.G and Govorkova E.A. (2006) H5N1:Continuing Evolution and Spread New
England Journal of Medicine 355(21):2174-2177
General Molecular mechanisms of H5N1 virulence:
Abdel-Ghafar A.N., Chotpitayasunondh T., Gao Z., Hayden F.G., Hien N.D., De Jong M.D.,
Naghdaliyev A., Peiris J.S.M., Shindo N., Soeroso S., Uyeki T.M. Update on avian influenza
A (H5N1) virus infection in humans. New England Journal of Medicine 358(3): 261-273
de Jong M.D., Simmons C.P., Thanh T.T., Hien V.M., Smith G.J.D., Chau T.N.B., Hoang
D.M., Chau N.V.V., Khanh T.H., Dong V.C., Qui P.T., Cam B.V., Ha D.Q., Guan Y., Peiris
2012
J.S.M., Chinh N.T., Hien T.T., Farrar J. (2006) Fatal outcome of human influenza A (H5N1)
is associated with high viral load and hypercytokinemia. Nature Medicine 12(10); 1203-1207
Lam W.Y., Yeung A.C.M., Chan P.K.S. (2011) Apoptosis, cytokine and chemokine
induction by non-structural 1 (NS1) proteins encoded by different influenza subtypes
Virology Journal 8:554
Lee S.M., Gardy J.L., Cheung C.Y., Cheung T.K., Hui K.P., Ip N.Y., Guan Y., Hancock
R.E., Peiris J.S. Systems-level comparison of host-responses elicited by avian H5N1 and
seasonal H1N1 influenza viruses in primary human macrophages. PloS ONE 4(12); e8072
Peiris J.S.M., Cheung C.Y., Leung C.Y.H., Nicholls J.M. (2009) Innate immune responses to
influenza A H5N1: friend or foe? Trends in Immunology 30(12); 574-584
Wurzer W.J., Planz O., Ehrhardt C., Giner M., Silberzahn T., Pleschka S., Ludwig S. (2003)
Caspase 3 activation is essential for efficient influenza virus propagation. The EMBO Journal
22:2717-2728.
Zhang C., Yang Y., Zhou X., Liu X., Song H., He Y., Huang P. (2010) Highly pathogenic
avian influenza A virus H5N1 NS1 protein induces caspase-dependent apoptosis in human
alveolar basal epithelial cells. Virology Journal 7:51
High case fatality rate
Huo, X.a
, Zu, R.a
, Qi, X.a
, Qin, Y.a
, Li, L.a
, Tang, F.a
, Hu, Z.b
, Zhu, F.a
(2012) Seroprevalence of avian influenza A (H5N1) virus among poultry workers in Jiangsu
Province, China: An observational study BMC Infectious Diseases 12; 93
Marks G., Beatty W.K. Epidemics. New York: Scribners; 1976.
Palesea P., Wanga T.T. (2012) H5N1 influenza viruses: Facts, not fear. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 109(7); 2211-2213
“WHO: H5N1 Case definition”:
(http://www.who.int/influenza/resources/documents/case_definition2006_08_29/en/index.ht
ml, accessed 14.05.12)
“WHO: Cumulative number of H5N1 cases”:
(http://www.who.int/influenza/human_animal_interface/EN_GIP_20120502CumulativeNum
berH5N1cases.pdf, accessed 18.5.2012)
Prospects for H5N1 vaccine:
Balish, A.L., Davis C.T., Saad M.D., El-Sayed N., Esmat H., Tjaden J.A., Earhart K.C.,
Ahmed L.E., El-Halem M.A., Ali A.H.M., Nassif S.A., El-Ebiary E.A., Taha M., Mona
M.A., Arafa A., O'Neill E., Xiyan X., Cox N.J., Donis R.O., Klimov A.I. (2010) Antigenic
and genetic diversity of highly pathogenic avian influenza A (H5N1) viruses isolated in
Egypt. Avian Diseases 54; 329–334
Jazayeri S.D., Ideris A., Zakaria Z., Shameli K., Moeini H., Omar A.R. (2012) Cytotoxicity
and immunological responses following oral vaccination of nanoencapsulated avian influenza
2012
virus H5 DNA vaccine with green synthesis silver nanoparticles Journal of Controlled
Release (Article in Press)
McKenna M. (2007), The Pandemic Vaccine Puzzle, Centre for Infectious Disease Research
and Policy.
(http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/cidrap/content/influenza/panflu/news/oct2507panvax1.html
,accessed 18.5.12)
Nakayama T., Kashiwagi Y., Kawashima H., Kumagai T., Ishii K.J., Ihara T.(2012) Alum-
adjuvanted H5N1 whole virion inactivated vaccine (WIV) enhanced inflammatory cytokine
productions. Vaccine 30; 3885– 3890
Steel, J. (2011) New strategies for the development of H5N1 subtype influenza vaccines:
Progress and challenges. BioDrugs 25(5); 285-298
Watanabe Y., Ibrahim M.S., Suzuki, Y., Ikuta, K. (2012) The changing nature of avian
influenza A virus (H5N1) Trends in Microbiology 20(1); 11-20
“WHO: Antigenic and genetic properties of zoonotic viruses”
(http://www.who.int/influenza/vaccines/virus/characteristics_virus_vaccines/en/index.html,
accessed 19.5.12)
“WHO: FAQs”
(http://www.who.int/influenza/human_animal_interface/avian_influenza/h5n1_research/faqs/
en/index.html, accessed 18.5.2012)
Zhou F., Zhou J., Ma L., Song S., Zhang X., Li W., Jiang S., Wang Y., Liao G. (2012) High-
yield production of a stable Vero cell-based vaccine candidate against the highly pathogenic
avian influenza virus H5N1 Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications (Article
in Press)

More Related Content

What's hot

10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed
10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed
10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed
Julio A. Diaz M.
 
Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003
Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003
Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003
Harm Kiezebrink
 
Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...
Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...
Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...
SSR Institute of International Journal of Life Sciences
 
Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29
Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29
Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29
Discover Health Global Initiative
 
Dossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza Virus to Dogs
Dossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza  Virus to DogsDossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza  Virus to Dogs
Dossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza Virus to Dogs
Harm Kiezebrink
 
Antimicrobial peptides and innate immunity
Antimicrobial peptides and innate immunityAntimicrobial peptides and innate immunity
Antimicrobial peptides and innate immunitySpringer
 
Spatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patterns
Spatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patternsSpatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patterns
Spatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patterns
Harm Kiezebrink
 
Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)
Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)
Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)Alan Moran
 
Supplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAI
Supplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAISupplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAI
Supplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAI
Harm Kiezebrink
 
JWeston-assignment-unit 9
JWeston-assignment-unit 9JWeston-assignment-unit 9
JWeston-assignment-unit 9Julia Weston
 
A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...
A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...
A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...
Guy Boulianne
 
Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2
Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2
Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2
Valentina Corona
 
Review on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic Organization
Review on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic OrganizationReview on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic Organization
Review on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic Organization
SSR Institute of International Journal of Life Sciences
 
04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)
04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)
04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)
Perez Eric
 
Mers, novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparedness
Mers,  novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparednessMers,  novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparedness
Mers, novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparedness
joanna remollino
 
The evolving definition of sepsis
The evolving definition of sepsis The evolving definition of sepsis
The evolving definition of sepsis
Damian R. Mingle, MBA
 
Oh et al 2014_Scientifica
Oh et al 2014_ScientificaOh et al 2014_Scientifica
Oh et al 2014_ScientificaDing Y Oh
 

What's hot (20)

10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed
10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed
10.1164@rccm.201701 0053 ed
 
Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003
Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003
Human-to-Human transmission of H7H7 in Holland 2003
 
Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...
Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...
Antimicrobial activity of Antibiotics and Antiseptics (Dettol and Betadine) a...
 
Duesberg Assignment
Duesberg AssignmentDuesberg Assignment
Duesberg Assignment
 
Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29
Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29
Dr. Obumneke Amadi-Onuoha Scripts-29
 
Dossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza Virus to Dogs
Dossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza  Virus to DogsDossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza  Virus to Dogs
Dossier transmission: Transmission of Avian Influenza Virus to Dogs
 
Antimicrobial peptides and innate immunity
Antimicrobial peptides and innate immunityAntimicrobial peptides and innate immunity
Antimicrobial peptides and innate immunity
 
McAlister_VME 158 Paper
McAlister_VME 158 Paper McAlister_VME 158 Paper
McAlister_VME 158 Paper
 
Spatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patterns
Spatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patternsSpatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patterns
Spatio temporal dynamics of global H5N1 outbreaks match bird migration patterns
 
Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)
Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)
Alan Moran_Thesis submission (1)
 
Supplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAI
Supplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAISupplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAI
Supplementary information wind mediated transmission HPAI
 
JWeston-assignment-unit 9
JWeston-assignment-unit 9JWeston-assignment-unit 9
JWeston-assignment-unit 9
 
Paper 2
Paper 2Paper 2
Paper 2
 
A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...
A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...
A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for huma...
 
Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2
Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2
Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2
 
Review on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic Organization
Review on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic OrganizationReview on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic Organization
Review on Newly Identified Coronavirus and its Genomic Organization
 
04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)
04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)
04 Ching-ho Wang (Taiwan)
 
Mers, novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparedness
Mers,  novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparednessMers,  novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparedness
Mers, novel coronovirus infection epidemiology & preparedness
 
The evolving definition of sepsis
The evolving definition of sepsis The evolving definition of sepsis
The evolving definition of sepsis
 
Oh et al 2014_Scientifica
Oh et al 2014_ScientificaOh et al 2014_Scientifica
Oh et al 2014_Scientifica
 

Viewers also liked

ESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.Λ
ESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.ΛESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.Λ
ESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.Λtroll1911
 
TimothyKayCareerPortfolio
TimothyKayCareerPortfolioTimothyKayCareerPortfolio
TimothyKayCareerPortfolioTimothy Kay
 
3 Apps for Law Enforcement
3 Apps for Law Enforcement3 Apps for Law Enforcement
3 Apps for Law EnforcementBarbara Phelps
 
Liveoneveryscreen
LiveoneveryscreenLiveoneveryscreen
Liveoneveryscreen
liveoneveryscreen
 
Pericarditis
PericarditisPericarditis
Pericarditis
Blanki5
 
Wheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refe
Wheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refeWheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refe
Wheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refe
Francisco Nava
 
й 2.2. с 2. к 2
й 2.2. с 2. к 2й 2.2. с 2. к 2
й 2.2. с 2. к 2timorevel
 
7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur
7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur
7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur
Financial Advisor, Entrepreneur, Ex-Banker
 
Acnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experiment
Acnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experimentAcnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experiment
Acnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experiment
AgileConsortiumINT
 
推荐信 已签名.PDF
推荐信 已签名.PDF推荐信 已签名.PDF
推荐信 已签名.PDFClaire ZENG
 
Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...
Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...
Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...
Global Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Thesis Final Presentation
Thesis Final PresentationThesis Final Presentation
Thesis Final Presentation
creacher
 
Sex determination
Sex determinationSex determination
Sex determination
vlmawia
 

Viewers also liked (14)

ESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.Λ
ESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.ΛESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.Λ
ESEL Ε.Σ.Ε.Λ
 
TimothyKayCareerPortfolio
TimothyKayCareerPortfolioTimothyKayCareerPortfolio
TimothyKayCareerPortfolio
 
3 Apps for Law Enforcement
3 Apps for Law Enforcement3 Apps for Law Enforcement
3 Apps for Law Enforcement
 
Liveoneveryscreen
LiveoneveryscreenLiveoneveryscreen
Liveoneveryscreen
 
Pericarditis
PericarditisPericarditis
Pericarditis
 
Wheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refe
Wheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refeWheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refe
Wheel loads from highway bridge strains field studies refe
 
Empédocles
EmpédoclesEmpédocles
Empédocles
 
й 2.2. с 2. к 2
й 2.2. с 2. к 2й 2.2. с 2. к 2
й 2.2. с 2. к 2
 
7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur
7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur
7 steps to becoming a successful entrepreneur
 
Acnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experiment
Acnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experimentAcnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experiment
Acnl2015 maarten hoppe-red bead experiment
 
推荐信 已签名.PDF
推荐信 已签名.PDF推荐信 已签名.PDF
推荐信 已签名.PDF
 
Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...
Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...
Perception And Support For Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus Patients: Study Amo...
 
Thesis Final Presentation
Thesis Final PresentationThesis Final Presentation
Thesis Final Presentation
 
Sex determination
Sex determinationSex determination
Sex determination
 

Similar to John Boikov H5N1 Essay, Mark - 95 out of 100

Controlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PC
Controlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PCControlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PC
Controlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PCDr. Raoul Nap, MD MSc PhD
 
Corona Virus Update
Corona Virus UpdateCorona Virus Update
Corona Virus Update
Dr Anand Singh
 
Will a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human race
Will a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human raceWill a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human race
Will a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human raceShona Redman
 
From Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological view
From Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological viewFrom Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological view
From Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological view
brnbarcelona
 
The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...
The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...
The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...
Texas Children's Hospital
 
Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...
Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...
Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...
EduardoViana92
 
Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...
Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...
Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...MerqurioEditore_redazione
 
Coronavirus report-23.3.2020
Coronavirus report-23.3.2020Coronavirus report-23.3.2020
Coronavirus report-23.3.2020
Dr. Nasir Mustafa
 
Human Genetic Variation poster
Human Genetic Variation posterHuman Genetic Variation poster
Human Genetic Variation posterRihan Islam
 
TBED-66-2517.pdf
TBED-66-2517.pdfTBED-66-2517.pdf
TBED-66-2517.pdf
NastyaPalamarova
 
Intersticial Lung Disease II.pdf
Intersticial Lung Disease II.pdfIntersticial Lung Disease II.pdf
Intersticial Lung Disease II.pdf
cuencamvz24
 
Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...
Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...
Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...Dr. Juan Rodriguez-Tafur
 
The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...
The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...
The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...
Alexander Decker
 
AIDS PRESANTATION.pptx
AIDS PRESANTATION.pptxAIDS PRESANTATION.pptx
AIDS PRESANTATION.pptx
Mkindi Mkindi
 
FINAL EXAM Poster
FINAL EXAM PosterFINAL EXAM Poster
FINAL EXAM PosterNicole Urh
 

Similar to John Boikov H5N1 Essay, Mark - 95 out of 100 (20)

Controlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PC
Controlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PCControlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PC
Controlling_Disease_Outbreaks-The_Changing_Role_of_Hospitals-PC
 
Corona Virus Update
Corona Virus UpdateCorona Virus Update
Corona Virus Update
 
Will a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human race
Will a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human raceWill a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human race
Will a zoonotic disease ever destroy the human race
 
From Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological view
From Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological viewFrom Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological view
From Systems Biology to Personalized Medicine: an epidemiological view
 
HunterThesis
HunterThesisHunterThesis
HunterThesis
 
The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...
The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...
The Significance of Bacterial and Fungal Coinfection in the Setting of Viral ...
 
Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...
Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...
Susceptibility of dendritic cells from individuals with schistosomiasis to in...
 
Respiratory epidemic impact on workers health
Respiratory epidemic impact on workers healthRespiratory epidemic impact on workers health
Respiratory epidemic impact on workers health
 
hd Subbarao
hd Subbaraohd Subbarao
hd Subbarao
 
Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...
Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...
Il ruolo dell'infezione da VRS nell’origine e nella progressione dell’asma: r...
 
Coronavirus report-23.3.2020
Coronavirus report-23.3.2020Coronavirus report-23.3.2020
Coronavirus report-23.3.2020
 
Human Genetic Variation poster
Human Genetic Variation posterHuman Genetic Variation poster
Human Genetic Variation poster
 
TBED-66-2517.pdf
TBED-66-2517.pdfTBED-66-2517.pdf
TBED-66-2517.pdf
 
Intersticial Lung Disease II.pdf
Intersticial Lung Disease II.pdfIntersticial Lung Disease II.pdf
Intersticial Lung Disease II.pdf
 
Journal Reviews
Journal ReviewsJournal Reviews
Journal Reviews
 
Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...
Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...
Associations of MHC Ancestral Haplotypes with Resistance/Susceptibility to AI...
 
AIJRSTEM16-244
AIJRSTEM16-244AIJRSTEM16-244
AIJRSTEM16-244
 
The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...
The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...
The association between hla drb alleles with pulmonary tuberculosis in babil ...
 
AIDS PRESANTATION.pptx
AIDS PRESANTATION.pptxAIDS PRESANTATION.pptx
AIDS PRESANTATION.pptx
 
FINAL EXAM Poster
FINAL EXAM PosterFINAL EXAM Poster
FINAL EXAM Poster
 

John Boikov H5N1 Essay, Mark - 95 out of 100

  • 1. 2012 Abstract: Current World Health Organization (WHO) estimates give a case fatality rate of 50-80% for people infected with H5N1. Molecular studies into the virulence displayed by H5N1 provide some basis for an increased case fatality rate, however they cannot explain it completely. Criteria for reporting H5N1 infections are currently too stringent to allow accurate and representative reporting of true H5N1 case fatality rates. Molecular studies can, however, explain the abnormal symptoms of primary viral pneumonia and Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS) displayed by patients infected with H5N1. Limited human cell tropism is currently thought to be responsible for preventing human-human H5N spread, preventing further fatalities beyond the 603 witnessed as of May, 2012. Intense interest in producing an adaptable or universal H5N1 vaccine has lead to an ever improving field of H5N1 vaccine production. Introduction: A highly virulent pathogen, H5N1 is yet to display a high degree of pathogenicity in humans, the few infections observed thus far often resulting in fatal acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) (Lee et al, 2009). Current epidemiology suggests an extremely high mortality rate amongst humans, though estimates are skewed by monitoring methods. There is sufficient molecular evidence to raise concerns on the potential for H5N1 to achieve a human-human transmissible form and cause a pandemic. As a result there have been a number of recent varied studies undertaken to determine the molecular basis of H5N1 virulence. Due to the current public concern surrounding H5N1 there have been a number of efforts targeted at producing an H5N1 vaccine and prospects for an H5N1 vaccine produced in time to immunise against a pandemic strain are constantly improving. Reasons for the absence of a human H5N1 pandemic Influenza pathogenicity (the ability to cause disease in a host) is dependent on the tropism of the viral haemmagglutinnin for host cell surface sialic acid-galactose linkages (Siaα-2,3 or 2,6Gal) and is potentially limited by compatibility with essential host enzymatic systems (van Riel et al, 2012). H5N1 haemagglutinin (HA) is specific for Siaα-2,3Gal cell surface linkages which are present in some cells of the human respiratory tract but which are also largely outnumbered by the predominant Siaα-2,6Gal linkages. Cells binding MAA agglutinin (recognises Siaα-2,3Gal) appear red, those binding SNA agglutinin (recognises Siaα-2,6Gal) appear green, cells were counterstained with blue DAPI (Shinya et al, 2006). The distribution of Siaα-2,3Gal linkages on the surfaces of human respiratory cells was confirmed with the aid of lectin histochemsitry, using fluorescently tagged tree –derived agglutinins specific for Siaα-2,6Gal and Siaα-2,3Gal (Shinya et al, 2006). The data shown
  • 2. 2012 above displays the relative paucity of cells displaying Siaα-2,3Gal linkages on their cell surfaces in the lower respiratory tract relative to those which display Siaα-2,6Gal. Considering Siaα-2,3Gal linkages are generally restricted to the lower respiratory tract, this shows the overall lack of Siaα-2,3Gal in the human respiratory system. Viral histochemistry has since confirmed that host cell range in the lower respiratory tract is predominantly limited to type II pneumocytes and alveolar macrophages as well as Clara cells and non-ciliated epithelial cells in the terminal bronchioles (van Riel et al, 2007), binding to the upper respiratory tract cells occurring as well but only relatively rarely (Nicholls, 2007 and van Riel et al, 2012). Attachment of human and avian viruses to ciliated epithelial cells, goblet cells, and submucosal glands in the human URT, Upper respiratory tract cells to which the virus bound display a red border which is indicative of virus-cell binding and thus virus-cell recognition. (van Riel et al, 2010) Virus histochemistry (use of labelled virus) has confirmed that tropism is associated with sialic acid distribution and that tropism is associated with ability to spread (van Riel et al., 2010). H5N1 has a different cell binding profile relative to seasonal (H1N1 and H3N2) and pandemic (H1N1) forms of human influenza. As can be seen, H5N1 does not display a clear binding to upper respiratory tract cells, with the exception of cells of the submucosal glands. The human influenza strains tested are much more widespread amongst humans than H5N1 and so it is currently thought that tropism to upper respiratory tract epithelia may allow an increased ability to undergo human-human spread (van Riel et al, 2010). H5N1 human-human transmission may require compatible enzyme systems in human cells allowing viral function and replication to occur (Webster et al,2006). This is not true in the case of limited proteolysis of HA during the maturation of H5N1 (an extremely important step in influenza replication) because the proteases responsible are virtually ubiquitous in our cell membranes, more so than those responsible for seasonal and pandemic influenza HA cleavage (Kido et al, 2012) suggesting that host proteases do not limit H5N1 as much as was previously thought. Thus, H5N1 has not caused more deaths in the human population probably because it is not currently adapted to our upper respiratory tract, although adaptation is possible through antigenic drift, as was seen in a reassorted H5N1 virus in ferrets (Kawaoka et al, 2012), or antigenic shift through reassortment with human-adapted strains in intermediate reservoirs
  • 3. 2012 such as pigs (Cong et al, 2010). Both processes are currently occurring in native H5N1 populations (Kawaoka et al 2012 and Ibid.) and so monitoring of the situation is a key factor in our preparedness for a potential H5N1 pandemic. General Molecular mechanisms of H5N1 virulence: Rapidly progressive primary viral pneumonia is a major feature of most reported H5N1- related fatalities, a relatively rare event in other forms of influenza (Abdel-Ghafar,2008). Resulting acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) is associated with damage to the alveoli and is the main source of mortality amongst H5N1 patients (Peiris et al, 2009). Molecular studies have sought to find the answers behind these abnormal symptoms, an important and much-studied virulence factor being the H5N1 NS1 protein. H5N1 NS1 is implicated in caspase-dependent apoptosis (Zhang et al, 2010) and hypercytokinemia (Lam et al, 2011), allowing the symptoms of viral infection to extend far beyond a localised area in the lungs (deJong et al, 2006). Systems-level comparisons between the H5N1 and the seasonal form of H1N1 have found that H5N1 induces a similar pro-inflammatory cytokine response to human-adapted influenza in vitro but that this response is quantitatively stronger (Lee et al, 2009). Further study has also implicated NS1 in this response in vitro (Lam et al, 2011). Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) on normal (left) and plasmid transfected cells (right) X5,000 magnification (Zhang et al, 2010). NS1 is a non-structural protein which normally has the role of inhibiting the host interferon(IFN)-mediated innate immune response by binding double-stranded RNA, thereby preventing the activation of the downstream cytosolic viral-detection machinery (Peiris et al, 2009). The role of H5N1 NS1 in triggering apoptosis was discovered with the use of plasmid transfection on carcinomic alveolar epithelial cells. Use of recombinant techniques and generation of an Escherichia coli (E. coli) library lead to the production of plasmids encoding H5NS1. The cells were transfected with these plasmids as a surrogate for viral infection and incubated for 24 hours (Zhang et al, 2010). Shown above are two transmission electron micrographs on non-transfected and H5N1 NS1-transfected cells. Note how the transfected cells are characteristic of post-apoptotic cells with condensed chromatin aggregated along the nuclear membrane (red arrow) and apoptotic bodies (orange arrow).
  • 4. 2012 Enzyme activities of caspase-3 and caspase-9 in NS1-transfected alveolar epithelial cell line. Enzyme activities based on transformed y-axis indicating levels of caspase activity based on absorbance according to Caspase detection kits(Zhang et al, 2010) Western blotting showed that Caspases 3 and 9 (two downstream effectors of apoptosis in mammalian cells) were present in transfected cells. Subsequent colorimetric assays for activities indicated that both were activated during the infection of the alveolar epithelial cells (Zhang et al, 2010). This study was done on an immortal cell line rather than primary ex vivo alveolar epithelium in addition to only the NS1 gene in a modified form being substituted for a native H5N1 particle with its associated myriad of virulence factors, limiting how applicable these findings would be to the role of NS1 in a whole virus infection. However a causative link between the presence of NS1 and caspase-dependent apoptosis has been established (Zhang et al, 2010), providing a further clue into the molecular basis of H5N1 virulence as apoptosis on other forms of cell lines has also been observed and found to be an essential mechanism for viral propagation (Wurzer et al, 2003) as well as being a contributing factor to the viral pneumonia in fatal cases of H5N1 infection (Peiris, 2009). Heatmap for averaged microarray gene expression profiles of H1N1 and H5N1 infected primary human macrophages. Results are averaged across macrophages from three different individuals (Lee et al, 2009). A systems-level approach showed that an infection of primary alveolar macrophages from 3 different individuals by a native H5N1 virus strain in vitro led to a much more pronounced pro-inflammatory cytokine response than for a low-pathogenicity seasonal H1N1 subtype
  • 5. 2012 inoculated at an equivalent multiplicity of infection (Lee et al, 2009). This study came in lieu of a number of studies which collectively showed that H5N1 infection caused a hyper- induction of the cytokine response by alveolar macrophages and alveolar epithelial cells (Lee et al, 2009). Global gene expression of macrophages infected with either H5N1 or H1N1 was recorded using GeneChip arrays. A heat map of the relative gene expression between two sets of alveolar macrophages, those infected with H1N1 and those with H5N1, shows that similar pathways were upregulated at similar time points but that H5N1 infection caused a much more intense upregulation. Overall it was found that components of cytokine pathways for IFN-β and TNF-α were hyper-expressed in vitro (Lee et al, 2009) indicating the H5N1 viral particle was responsible for the hypercytokinemia seen in H5N1 patients (deJong et al, 2006). Proportion overall cells displaying signs of early apoptosis upon transfection with influenza NS1 mRNA. (CC= non transfected controls). (Lam et al, 2011) Transfection of a lung epithelial cell line with mRNA encoding viral NS1 confirmed that H5N1 NS1 is involved in the induction of apoptosis and inducing the abnormal pro- inflammatory cytokine response behind ARDS (Lam et al, 2011). The proportion of early apoptotic cells sampled at irregular intervals was determined flow cytometrically with the aid of a fluorescent dye specific for early apoptotic cells. Note how large the difference between H5 and other influenza subtype NS1 is in terms of both biological and statistical significance, especially at 6 hours. H5 subtype NS1 mRNA transfection resulted in a maximum proportion of early apoptotic cells double any other influenza NS1 in addition to having a 95% confidence interval which was not overlapping any of the other ones, indicating a statistically as well as biologically significant difference (Lam et al, 2011). This increase in apoptosis could explain why primary viral pneumonia with diffuse alveolar damage is so common in H5N1 infections, especially considering that the virus is generally limited to the lower respiratory tract.
  • 6. 2012 Cytometric bead array was used to quantify the levels of relevant cytokines and chemokines. As shown below, all influenza subtype NS1 mRNA transfections lead to levels of cytokine both biologically and statistically significantly different from non-transfected cells, however H5 subtype NS1 mRNA clearly caused a greater amount of expression of the pro- inflammatory cytokines measured, indicating that it the hypercytokinemia displayed in ARDS is at least partially due to the effect of H5N1 NS1(Lam et al, 2011). Cytokines/chemokines induced by transfection of NS1 mRNA of different influenza subtypes. H5 subtype NS1 mRNA transfected cells are shown in purple. Cytokine/chemokine levels are expressed as fold-changes compared to the non-transfected cell controls measured at the same time points (Lam et al, 2011). High case fatality rate The current case fatality rate for reported H5N1 infections is between 50-80% (“WHO: Cumulative number of H5N1 cases”, accessed 18.5.2012), extremely high compared to the 1918 H1N1-attributed case fatality rate of 2.5% (Marks et al, 1976). The difference between case fatality rates is highly unlikely to be due to differences in virulence at the molecular level alone. A good point has been made that the case fatality rate may be falsely high because the WHO requires a very stringent number of conditions to be met before confirming a case of H5N1 (Palesea,2012). A patient must report to a hospital with a laboratory advanced enough to allow for serological or genetic testing with advanced symptoms of influenza infection (“WHO: H5N1 Case definition”, accessed 14.05.12). These selection criteria may provide a skewness towards patients who are severely ill (Peiris et al, 2009), leaving little room for those who may have an asymptomatic H5N1 infection (if this is possible) or people who cannot reach a hospital with the necessary facilities. Rural areas where waterfowl and other reservoir species are abundant are also under-represented, meaning that this stringent method is very likely giving a non-representative estimate of true fatality rates amongst those infected with H5N1.
  • 7. 2012 Cumulative number of confirmed human cases for avian influenza A(H5N1) reported to WHO, 2003-2012 (“WHO: Cumulative number of H5N1 cases”, accessed 18.5.2012) Presence of unreported H5N1 infection with a successful outcome is possible as shown by the discovery of anti-H5N1 HA antibodies in a sample of the poultry workers in the Chinese province of Jiangsu where previous H5N1 infections and a death attributed to H5N1 had occurred (Huo et al, 2012). Amongst the sample taken there were no people with prior severe respiratory illness and the poultry in the villages sampled were not vaccinated against H5- subtype avian influenza. Hemagglutination inhibition assays on blood samples for anti-H5N1 HA antibodies showed that seropositivity was present in two of the three villages and that that the true population seropositivity rate for these two villages concerned was significantly higher than zero (as high as between 2.19% and 10.78% in Gaoyou (95% confidence)). If we take the number of H5N1 seropositive individuals just from Gaoyou (n=7) and added it to all reported cases in China at the time of the study (n=46 from the above table) then we can see that the case fatality rate for China shifts immediately from 66.6% (100*[28/42]) down roughly 10% to 57.1% (100*[28/49]) if we assume that the anti-H5N1 antibodies came from H5N1 infection with a successful outcome. This crude calculation serves to show that making case fatality rate calculations with such stringent selection criteria leads to the generation of inaccurate and error-prone statistics. This study was limited by a number of factors, not the least of which being the restricted geography of sampling and a small sample size, but it showed that it is possible to have H5N1 infections which do not result in extremely adverse effects and that go unreported (Huo et al, 2012). Therefore WHO estimates of case fatality rate may be skewed and more research into the true rate of H5N1 infection worldwide must be done before any reliable estimate of the true worldwide case fatality rate of H5N1 can be determined. Prospects for H5N1 vaccine: H5N1 is constantly and quickly evolving, meaning that genetic diversification may occur so quickly that even geographically close isolates of H5N1 may differ sufficiently to prevent immunological cross-recognition of these strains should a vaccine based on either virus be produced (Balish et al, 2010). Thus a vaccine must be adaptable with an ability to be produced in large quantitites in a small amount of time (Zhou et al, 2012). Widespread, rapid deployment and mass production of such a vaccine also pose major challenges to the production of an H5N1 vaccine (McKenna, 2007). As H5N1 is constantly evolving, it does not make financial or practical sense to mass produce a standard vaccine based on any particular strain of H5N1 as such a vaccine may be made irrelevant in the space of a few years or may not be relevant to a pandemic strain. Biannnual WHO reports on global monitoring of H5N1 clades and their antigenic and epidemiological properties allows for constant adjustment, depending on the storage of many different
  • 8. 2012 candidate viruses so that in the case of a pandemic it might be possible for the mass production of any of these viruses, one of which would hopefully be close or identical to the pandemic strain. As of February 2012 there were 20 known and available candidate viruses for vaccines with 3 pending full development (“WHO: Antigenic and genetic properties of zoonotic viruses”, 2012). Production of a vaccine in large enough amounts to matter and whether this vaccine would generate sufficient immunogenicity is another matter. Cell culture in bioreactors would allow for a great increase in production capacity of an H5N1 vaccine without having to rely on the low-yield and potentially at-risk embryonated hen egg techniques, a high-yield production method based on the use of the continuous Vero cell line (kidney epithelium isolated from Chlorocebus spp.) being recently developed (Zhou et al, 2012). The strength behind pairing this production technique with an existing candidate virus and reverse genetics technology is that this would allow high-level production of virtually tailor-made live attenuated viruses for use in an inactivated or split virus vaccine based on relevant pandemic H5N1 antigens (Watanabe, 2012). H5N1 vaccines cause poor immunogenicity in patients and animal models inoculated and so novel adjuvants increasing immunogenicity are sought after (McKenna, 2007). Multiple different adjuvants are currently being trialled and developed. An alum-based adjuvant showed a good immunogenic response in Japanese adults but induced febrile reactions in minors (Nakayama, 2012) whereas a novel silver nanoparticle-based adjuvant has also been developed (Jazayeri et al, 2012). The latter inducing pro-inflammatory cytokine release and enhanced antibody and cell-mediated immune responses in chicks, however this adjuvant has not yet been trialled in humans (Ibid., 2012). There are several candidate H5N1vaccines which have been developed, however they are not yet ready for widespread use (WHO: FAQs, accessed 18.5.12). Much work remains to be done on an H5N1 vaccine. With constant monitoring and improved production capacities coupled to reverse genetics, in addition to continuing development of improved novel adjuvants, the outlook for an H5N1 vaccine and our ability to respond quickly to a pandemic is looking better as time progresses. Conclusion: It is apparent that H5N1 could be the basis for a future pandemic, albeit at a true case fatality rate likely to be less than 50-80%. This paper has only captured very few of the many molecular studies on H5N1 virulence, focusing on the role of the multifunctional NS1. It should be remembered that H5N1 virulence is a polygenic trait (Lam et al, 2011) not dependent on NS1 function or cellular tropism alone. Epidemiology on H5N1 is currently error-prone and should not be trusted as the sole measure on which predictions of an H5N1 pandemic should be based. However, the clearly increased molecular virulence has caused enough concern and sparked enough fear and interest that the outlook for production of a successful H5N1 vaccine in a short amount of time is constantly improving. Word count (not counting abstract, figure legends and titles): 2,740 words.
  • 9. 2012 Bibliography: Reasons for the absence of a human H5N1 pandemic Cong Y., Wang G., GuanZ., Chang S., Zhang Q, Yang G., Wang W., Meng Q., Ren W., Wang C., Ding Z. (2010) Reassortant between Human-Like H3N2 and Avian H5 Subtype Influenza A Viruses in Pigs: A Potential Public Health Risk PLoS ONE 5(9); e12591 Kawaoka Y., Imai M., Watanabe T., Hatta M., Das S.C, Ozawa M., Shinya K., Zhong Hanson A., Katsura H., Watanabe S., Li S., Kawakami E., Yamada S., Kiso M., Suzuki Y., Maher E.A. and Neumann G. Experimental adaptation of an influenza H5 HA confers respiratory droplet transmission to a reassortant H5 HA/H1N1 virus in ferrets. Nature (doi:10.1038/nature10831) Kido H., Okumura Y., Takahashi E., Pan H.Y., Wang S., Yao D., Yao M., Chida J., YanoM. (2012) Role of host cellular proteases in the pathogenesis of influenza and influenza-induced multiple organ failure Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 1824: 186–194 Nicholls J.M., Chan M.C.W., Chan W.Y., Wong H.K., Cheung C.Y., Kwong D.L.W., Wong M.P., Chui W.H., Poon L.L.M., Tsao S.W., GuanY. & Peiris J.S.M. Tropism of avian influenza A (H5N1) in the upper and lower respiratory tract. Nature medicine 13(2);147-149 Shinya K., Ebina M., Yamada S., Ono M., Kasai N., Kawaoka Y. (2006) Influenza virus receptors in the human airway. Nature 440 (doi:10.1038/440435a) van Riel D., Munster V.J., de Wit E., Rimmelzwaan G.F., Fouchier R.A.M., Osterhaus A.D.M.E., Kuiken T. (2007) Human and avian influenza viruses target different cells in the lower respiratory tract of humans and other mammals. American Journal of Pathology 171( 4); 1215-1223 van Riel D., den Bakker M.A., Leijten L.M., Chutinimitkul S., Munster V.J., de Wit E., Rimmelzwaan G.F., Fouchier R.A.M, Osterhaus A.D.M.E. and Kuiken T. (2010) Seasonal and pandemic human influenza viruses attach better to human upper respiratory tract epithelium than avian influenza viruses. Am. J. Pathol. 176; 1614–1618. van Riel D. and Kuiken T. (2012) The role of cell tropism for the pathogenesis of influenza in humans Future Virol. 7(3) Webster R.G and Govorkova E.A. (2006) H5N1:Continuing Evolution and Spread New England Journal of Medicine 355(21):2174-2177 General Molecular mechanisms of H5N1 virulence: Abdel-Ghafar A.N., Chotpitayasunondh T., Gao Z., Hayden F.G., Hien N.D., De Jong M.D., Naghdaliyev A., Peiris J.S.M., Shindo N., Soeroso S., Uyeki T.M. Update on avian influenza A (H5N1) virus infection in humans. New England Journal of Medicine 358(3): 261-273 de Jong M.D., Simmons C.P., Thanh T.T., Hien V.M., Smith G.J.D., Chau T.N.B., Hoang D.M., Chau N.V.V., Khanh T.H., Dong V.C., Qui P.T., Cam B.V., Ha D.Q., Guan Y., Peiris
  • 10. 2012 J.S.M., Chinh N.T., Hien T.T., Farrar J. (2006) Fatal outcome of human influenza A (H5N1) is associated with high viral load and hypercytokinemia. Nature Medicine 12(10); 1203-1207 Lam W.Y., Yeung A.C.M., Chan P.K.S. (2011) Apoptosis, cytokine and chemokine induction by non-structural 1 (NS1) proteins encoded by different influenza subtypes Virology Journal 8:554 Lee S.M., Gardy J.L., Cheung C.Y., Cheung T.K., Hui K.P., Ip N.Y., Guan Y., Hancock R.E., Peiris J.S. Systems-level comparison of host-responses elicited by avian H5N1 and seasonal H1N1 influenza viruses in primary human macrophages. PloS ONE 4(12); e8072 Peiris J.S.M., Cheung C.Y., Leung C.Y.H., Nicholls J.M. (2009) Innate immune responses to influenza A H5N1: friend or foe? Trends in Immunology 30(12); 574-584 Wurzer W.J., Planz O., Ehrhardt C., Giner M., Silberzahn T., Pleschka S., Ludwig S. (2003) Caspase 3 activation is essential for efficient influenza virus propagation. The EMBO Journal 22:2717-2728. Zhang C., Yang Y., Zhou X., Liu X., Song H., He Y., Huang P. (2010) Highly pathogenic avian influenza A virus H5N1 NS1 protein induces caspase-dependent apoptosis in human alveolar basal epithelial cells. Virology Journal 7:51 High case fatality rate Huo, X.a , Zu, R.a , Qi, X.a , Qin, Y.a , Li, L.a , Tang, F.a , Hu, Z.b , Zhu, F.a (2012) Seroprevalence of avian influenza A (H5N1) virus among poultry workers in Jiangsu Province, China: An observational study BMC Infectious Diseases 12; 93 Marks G., Beatty W.K. Epidemics. New York: Scribners; 1976. Palesea P., Wanga T.T. (2012) H5N1 influenza viruses: Facts, not fear. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 109(7); 2211-2213 “WHO: H5N1 Case definition”: (http://www.who.int/influenza/resources/documents/case_definition2006_08_29/en/index.ht ml, accessed 14.05.12) “WHO: Cumulative number of H5N1 cases”: (http://www.who.int/influenza/human_animal_interface/EN_GIP_20120502CumulativeNum berH5N1cases.pdf, accessed 18.5.2012) Prospects for H5N1 vaccine: Balish, A.L., Davis C.T., Saad M.D., El-Sayed N., Esmat H., Tjaden J.A., Earhart K.C., Ahmed L.E., El-Halem M.A., Ali A.H.M., Nassif S.A., El-Ebiary E.A., Taha M., Mona M.A., Arafa A., O'Neill E., Xiyan X., Cox N.J., Donis R.O., Klimov A.I. (2010) Antigenic and genetic diversity of highly pathogenic avian influenza A (H5N1) viruses isolated in Egypt. Avian Diseases 54; 329–334 Jazayeri S.D., Ideris A., Zakaria Z., Shameli K., Moeini H., Omar A.R. (2012) Cytotoxicity and immunological responses following oral vaccination of nanoencapsulated avian influenza
  • 11. 2012 virus H5 DNA vaccine with green synthesis silver nanoparticles Journal of Controlled Release (Article in Press) McKenna M. (2007), The Pandemic Vaccine Puzzle, Centre for Infectious Disease Research and Policy. (http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/cidrap/content/influenza/panflu/news/oct2507panvax1.html ,accessed 18.5.12) Nakayama T., Kashiwagi Y., Kawashima H., Kumagai T., Ishii K.J., Ihara T.(2012) Alum- adjuvanted H5N1 whole virion inactivated vaccine (WIV) enhanced inflammatory cytokine productions. Vaccine 30; 3885– 3890 Steel, J. (2011) New strategies for the development of H5N1 subtype influenza vaccines: Progress and challenges. BioDrugs 25(5); 285-298 Watanabe Y., Ibrahim M.S., Suzuki, Y., Ikuta, K. (2012) The changing nature of avian influenza A virus (H5N1) Trends in Microbiology 20(1); 11-20 “WHO: Antigenic and genetic properties of zoonotic viruses” (http://www.who.int/influenza/vaccines/virus/characteristics_virus_vaccines/en/index.html, accessed 19.5.12) “WHO: FAQs” (http://www.who.int/influenza/human_animal_interface/avian_influenza/h5n1_research/faqs/ en/index.html, accessed 18.5.2012) Zhou F., Zhou J., Ma L., Song S., Zhang X., Li W., Jiang S., Wang Y., Liao G. (2012) High- yield production of a stable Vero cell-based vaccine candidate against the highly pathogenic avian influenza virus H5N1 Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications (Article in Press)