Dan falls asleep while watching the film HP Massacre and awakens to find himself trapped inside the movie. He teams up with the film's characters Christopher and Cindy to survive encounters with the killer Victor Hemz. Dan uses his knowledge of the film to help the group evade Victor and find an escape. They ultimately defeat Victor by knocking him down the stairs. Though relieved to make it out alive, Dan is unsure if he has truly returned to reality when the credits roll for HP Massacre 2.