Cloud Innovation: Silver Lining for the Consumer Goods Industry
1. Cognizant 20-20 Insights
“Cloud Innovation:” Silver Lining
for the Consumer Goods Industry
Executive Summary The Need for Innovation
Amid increasing global competition, more Innovation is a cost of entry to the CG market, in
sophisticated shoppers and heightened price which power has shifted from manufacturers, to
pressure, consumer goods (CG) organizations retailers and consumers. However, many new CG
must tap every source of innovation available to products fail, costing the industry billions of
them, including employees, suppliers, customers dollars a year. During the recession, a high
and even outsiders with no link to the percentage of innovations were simply brand
organization. The challenge is creating a extensions, rather than broader innovation that
structured approach to correctly prioritize and drove growth and margins. And in the last year,
execute all potential innovation initiatives. most new product launches in the CG foods area
failed to make a significant dent in the market.
Even as CG organizations embrace “open
innovation” that encourages ideas from outside Without innovation, CG organizations risk losing
the organization, they must continue to generate sales. This makes it harder for them to gain
innovation from traditional sources, such as shelf space (and reduce pressure for price cuts)
employees and R&D. “Cloud innovation,” like the from the large retail chains that control access
“cloud” approach to IT services, helps accomplish to the market. Increasing costs for promotion,
this, as it provides a portfolio approach to both placement and shelf space further depresses
innovation requirements and the sources of margins, increasing the need for innovation to
innovation, matching diverse internal and maintain profitability. Innovation results in a
external resources dynamically to each specific more enjoyable place to work and creates a
business requirement (see Figure 1). “halo effect” that drives sales of other products.
Finally, innovation that aids “green” or other
Done right, cloud innovation can help CG causes increases pricing power by making
manufacturers regain pricing power that has consumers feel good about their purchase.
been lost to retailers, increase barriers to entry
for competitors, improve visibility into customer
The Evolution of Innovation
needs and help ensure that innovations can be
cost-effectively produced, distributed and sold. CG organizations have innovated as long as
there have been mass-produced consumer
20-20 insights
2. The Cloud Comes to Innovation
Just as cloud computing taps distributed resources, such as servers, storage and networks for multiple users…
Service CLOUD MANAGERS Menu of
on Demand Servers Storage Servers Services
Cloud Infrastructure Layer
PROCESS #1 PROCESS #2 PROCESS #3
Common and
Multiple Business Process Layer Different
Actors Objectives
BUSINESS BUSINESS
PROCESS #1 PROCESS #2
Customer #1 Customer #5
Customer #2 Customer #3 Customer #4
… cloud innovation taps multiple innovation sources to meet multiple business needs.
Skills Value
Actors Chain Area
Innovation
Customer Type
Need Area
Market
Maturity Objectives
Customer #1 Customer #3
Customer #2
Figure 1
goods. In the 1960s, they moved more The actors involved have also changed. At first,
aggressively into process innovation, especially innovation was largely the responsibility of the
in manufacturing (see Figure 2). In the 1970s, R&D organization. Over time, other employees
innovation began to spread to users (with more within the CG organization played a larger role,
advanced customer research), as well as to new, as well as business partners. Using the World
more advanced techniques for measuring the Wide Web, the public is now being tapped as a
effectiveness of advertising. Walmart and other source of innovation.
large retailers drove significant supply chain
innovation starting in the 1980s. New business
Cloud Innovation Defined
models such as direct-to customer – as well as
significant innovations in distribution and Cloud innovation unites many innovation ele-
marketing from vendors and distributors -- ments, including customer needs, various actors
emerged in the 1990s. In this decade, open and different types of innovation
innovation has become the order of the day. The and business objectives. It taps a Cloud innovation unites
next step toward more comprehensive and diverse pool of people, processes many innovation elements,
effective innovation is the cloud. and technology inside and out-
including customer needs,
side the organization to meet
The types of CG innovation have also changed. needs across internal and exter- various actors and different
Early on, the focus was on breakthrough nal value chains. Cloud innova- types of innovation and
innovations in products. As manufacturers tion also encompasses process, business objectives.
focused on process, they sought more channels, brand and business
incremental innovations. When they innovated in models, all of which are “structural” areas where
far-ranging areas, such as the user experience innovation can produce far-reaching and signifi-
and in business models, they sought more cant results (see Figure 3).
fundamental innovations.
20-20 insights 2
3. Evolution of Innovation
What next?
Open Innovation THE CLOUD?
Business Model & Partner
User & Supply Chain
Process I “No boundaries” innovation
G
R NIN
LEA I Innovating the business itself
Product I Technology as enabler
I Consumer rules the roost
I Do only what the customer pays for
I Innovation from across the organization
I Look beyond product innovation
Figure 2
For example, innovation aimed at reducing costs Cloud Innovation: A Portfolio Approach
would be considered a “sustaining” innovation, as
it is aimed at the input portion of the value chain, Cloud innovation is best leveraged by investing in
requiring innovation from the vendor and a portfolio of slower growth but more assured
involvement from finance, purchasing, marketing innovations, as well as higher potential but riskier
and R&D. Developing a radical new product, on the projects. This not only helps prioritize efforts, but
other hand, would require more breakthrough it also aids in managing risk while maximizing
innovation, focusing on the output (the product) benefits. The equivalent is a stock portfolio of
and requiring involvement from users, vendors, “large caps” (the largest firms with the highest
marketing, R&D and, possibly, external innovators. capitalizations), “mid-caps,” “small caps” and
“penny stocks.” The larger the company, the
For an organization to use cloud innovation, it safer the investment, but with higher safety
needs to define the combinations of elements comes a lower likelihood of spectacular returns.
that it plans to leverage. Each combination of
elements requires a different strategy, process, A large-cap investment might be innovation of
inputs and outputs. (See “Enablers of Cloud the product (changing the ingredients in an
Innovation: The Four Ps”.) existing shampoo), process (tweaking how
Elements of Cloud Innovation for a Consumer Goods Company
Customer needs Health and wellness, convenience, beauty, excitement, sustainability.
Actors in innovation Traditional R&D staff, other employees, suppliers, customers or “non-involved”
outsiders, such as those entering a product-naming contest.
Skills required Raw material and packaging, base chemicals, consumer understanding and knowledge
of markets or supply chain.
Types of innovation Radical, breakthrough, enhanced, sustaining.
Value chain areas Input, process and output.
Objectives Higher profit, revenue growth, increasing customer delight, social recognition
or reducing the cost of innovation.
Market maturity Growing, mature or declining.
Figure 3
3 20-20 insights
4. marketing dollars are distributed) or business new product in a new category, such as a
model (using the Web to distribute coupons.) shampoo to prevent hair loss. A process
The potential for success is relatively high, since innovation might outsource all the design,
the changes to production and other processes testing and production. A
are fairly minor. The likelihood of success is business model innovation Cloud innovation also
fairly high, since the product has a loyal might be buying a stake in an encompasses process,
customer base, but the chance of dramatic sales outside supplier rather than
or margin growth is relatively low. marketing the shampoo
channels, brand and
directly. The risks are greater, business models, all of
A mid-cap investment might be innovation of as the market is less familiar which are “structural”
the product (a new shampoo for a new market and the degree of innovation is areas where innovation
segment), process (outsourcing production) or greater, but the potential
business model (marketing the product through upside is also larger.
can produce far-reaching
home sales.) The changes required in and significant results.
marketing, development, production and The penny stock would be the
distribution might be somewhat higher, since least expensive, highest-risk but potentially
the innovation is more far-reaching. Chances for highest-return investment. Here, a product
success are somewhat lower than for the large- innovation might be entering a radical new
cap investment, but the growth potential is category, such as a shampoo that lets a
somewhat greater. customer grow different color hair. As with a
penny stock, the chances for success least
A still riskier investment would be a small-cap assured, but the possible upside is the greatest.
innovation. A product innovation might be a
The cloud approach to innovation involves
building a similar portfolio of varied innovation
initiatives ranging from minor
changes to business processes To tap the greatest range
Enablers of Cloud Innovation: to investing in radical ideas of insights and ideas, CG
The Four “Ps” that have the potential to companies should consider an
To achieve cloud innovation, a CG organi- change the entire industry.
“innovation cloud” approach
zation must focus on four areas.
that combines traditional
Summary
Prescribe means identifying various ele- R&D, plus innovation from
ments of cloud innovation the organiza- In a world of thin margins, employees, users and
tional needs, a strategy for each element, scarce shelf space and fickle
“uninvolved” outsiders, and
the cloud as a whole, and an implementa- consumers, CG organizations
tion approach. need innovation more than that incorporates innovation
ever. However, factors such as in business models and
People means finding, inside or outside of lack of consumer insight and processes.
the organization, people with an entrepre- stove-piped processes have
neurial drive and passion to push for their made it difficult for these organizations to
ideas and persevere despite obstacles. innovate consistently and successfully. To tap
the greatest range of insights and ideas, CG
Platform includes cloud sourcing and Web companies should consider an “innovation
2.0 tools that allow ideas to be shared and cloud” approach that combines traditional R&D,
implemented through links with ERP and plus innovation from employees, users and
other corporate systems. “uninvolved” outsiders, and that incorporates
innovation in business models and processes.
Processes are required to screen, qualify, Much like a compute cloud, an innovation cloud
analyze and present ideas in high volume and dynamically and flexibly matches resources to
measure and track innovation performance. needs to meet ever-changing business
requirements.
20-20 insights 4