This document provides a summary of a compliance report by GRECO (Group of States Against Corruption) regarding Spain.
The compliance report assesses Spain's implementation of recommendations from GRECO's Third Evaluation Round report on two themes: incriminations related to corruption offenses, and transparency of political party funding.
For incriminations, GRECO found that recommendations remained partly implemented, as draft amendments to criminalize foreign bribery and trading in influence had not yet been adopted. For party funding, GRECO noted that a new law addressed some recommendations by further regulating loans to parties and increasing transparency requirements. However, recommendations on publicity of information and sanctions remained partly implemented.
In conclusion, the compliance report found that
This document provides a summary of Spain's progress in implementing recommendations from GRECO (the Group of States Against Corruption) regarding transparency of political party funding and incriminations related to corruption. It finds that Spain has partly implemented recommendations regarding clarifying definitions related to foreign officials, criminalizing certain acts of bribery and trading of influence, and increasing transparency of political party loans. However, more work remains to fully implement recommendations regarding criminalizing bribery of foreign arbitrators and jurors and increasing sanctions and publicity requirements related to political party financing. The document was adopted by GRECO to assess Spain's implementation efforts.
The document discusses Form 3CEB which requires taxpayers to obtain an accountant's report certifying related party transactions over Rs. 1,000. Key details include:
1) Form 3CEB must be filed electronically by November 30th and includes details of international and specified domestic transactions with related parties.
2) The accountant preparing the form must meet certain criteria and is responsible for examining records and certifying transactions are documented and values are arm's length.
3) Non-compliance can result in penalties for the taxpayer and accountant. Caveats are that the accountant's examination is limited and transfer pricing rules may not apply to all related party transactions.
4) Many countries have similar
This presentation covers the new regime of service taxation in India, including the negative list of services, exempted services, declared services and valuation, and bundled services. It discusses the scope of services taxable under the new regime, including examples of new activities that may be taxed. It also summarizes the key aspects of the negative list of services, such as the sectors covered and considerations in developing the list. Specific services discussed in detail include those provided by government, Reserve Bank of India, foreign diplomatic missions, relating to agriculture, trading of goods, manufacturing, selling advertising space/time, access to roads/bridges via tolls, betting/gambling and lotteries.
The document discusses India's transition to a negative list regime for service tax, which taxes all services except those on an exemption list. Key points include:
1) Service tax will be levied at 12% on all services provided or agreed to be provided in India, except those on the negative list.
2) Important elements defining taxable services are the service provider, recipient, location of provision, and consideration.
3) "Declared services" are specifically included in the tax net and involve property rentals, IT services, and goods transferred via hire/lease without transferring use rights.
The document discusses the Madrid System for the international registration of trademarks. It provides details on the Madrid Agreement established in 1891 and the Madrid Protocol adopted in 1989, which together form the Madrid System. The key differences between the Agreement and Protocol are outlined. The procedures for filing an international trademark application via the Madrid System are also summarized, including requirements, certification by the office of origin, and processing by the International Bureau.
Chapter XII: Temporary entry for business persons chapterBalo English
This chapter establishes commitments on temporary entry of business persons between the parties. It defines key terms and establishes that the chapter applies to measures affecting temporary entry for business purposes but not permanent employment. Each party will specify commitments for different categories of business persons in an annex. The chapter establishes requirements for application procedures, granting temporary entry according to commitments, and refusal on limited grounds. It also covers provisions on business travel, transparency, cooperation on visa issues, and limitations on dispute settlement regarding refusals of temporary entry.
This document is a Commission Delegated Regulation that supplements Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 regarding regulatory technical standards on OTC derivatives contracts. It establishes criteria for determining when contracts between third country entities would have a direct and foreseeable effect within the EU or constitute evading EU rules. Specifically, it considers contracts covered by large guarantees from EU financial entities or entered into to avoid EU rules as within the scope of EU regulation. It also delays application of some provisions by 6 months to allow third country entities time to comply.
The Madrid Protocol allows trademark owners to protect their marks across multiple countries by filing one international application instead of separate applications in each country. It is administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization and became effective in the US in 2003. Under the Madrid Protocol, applicants can file for an international registration of their trademark with WIPO to automatically extend protection to the other 79 member countries if no refusals are issued within 18 months. This provides a more cost-effective way for individuals, businesses, and other entities to protect their trademarks internationally.
This document provides a summary of Spain's progress in implementing recommendations from GRECO (the Group of States Against Corruption) regarding transparency of political party funding and incriminations related to corruption. It finds that Spain has partly implemented recommendations regarding clarifying definitions related to foreign officials, criminalizing certain acts of bribery and trading of influence, and increasing transparency of political party loans. However, more work remains to fully implement recommendations regarding criminalizing bribery of foreign arbitrators and jurors and increasing sanctions and publicity requirements related to political party financing. The document was adopted by GRECO to assess Spain's implementation efforts.
The document discusses Form 3CEB which requires taxpayers to obtain an accountant's report certifying related party transactions over Rs. 1,000. Key details include:
1) Form 3CEB must be filed electronically by November 30th and includes details of international and specified domestic transactions with related parties.
2) The accountant preparing the form must meet certain criteria and is responsible for examining records and certifying transactions are documented and values are arm's length.
3) Non-compliance can result in penalties for the taxpayer and accountant. Caveats are that the accountant's examination is limited and transfer pricing rules may not apply to all related party transactions.
4) Many countries have similar
This presentation covers the new regime of service taxation in India, including the negative list of services, exempted services, declared services and valuation, and bundled services. It discusses the scope of services taxable under the new regime, including examples of new activities that may be taxed. It also summarizes the key aspects of the negative list of services, such as the sectors covered and considerations in developing the list. Specific services discussed in detail include those provided by government, Reserve Bank of India, foreign diplomatic missions, relating to agriculture, trading of goods, manufacturing, selling advertising space/time, access to roads/bridges via tolls, betting/gambling and lotteries.
The document discusses India's transition to a negative list regime for service tax, which taxes all services except those on an exemption list. Key points include:
1) Service tax will be levied at 12% on all services provided or agreed to be provided in India, except those on the negative list.
2) Important elements defining taxable services are the service provider, recipient, location of provision, and consideration.
3) "Declared services" are specifically included in the tax net and involve property rentals, IT services, and goods transferred via hire/lease without transferring use rights.
The document discusses the Madrid System for the international registration of trademarks. It provides details on the Madrid Agreement established in 1891 and the Madrid Protocol adopted in 1989, which together form the Madrid System. The key differences between the Agreement and Protocol are outlined. The procedures for filing an international trademark application via the Madrid System are also summarized, including requirements, certification by the office of origin, and processing by the International Bureau.
Chapter XII: Temporary entry for business persons chapterBalo English
This chapter establishes commitments on temporary entry of business persons between the parties. It defines key terms and establishes that the chapter applies to measures affecting temporary entry for business purposes but not permanent employment. Each party will specify commitments for different categories of business persons in an annex. The chapter establishes requirements for application procedures, granting temporary entry according to commitments, and refusal on limited grounds. It also covers provisions on business travel, transparency, cooperation on visa issues, and limitations on dispute settlement regarding refusals of temporary entry.
This document is a Commission Delegated Regulation that supplements Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 regarding regulatory technical standards on OTC derivatives contracts. It establishes criteria for determining when contracts between third country entities would have a direct and foreseeable effect within the EU or constitute evading EU rules. Specifically, it considers contracts covered by large guarantees from EU financial entities or entered into to avoid EU rules as within the scope of EU regulation. It also delays application of some provisions by 6 months to allow third country entities time to comply.
The Madrid Protocol allows trademark owners to protect their marks across multiple countries by filing one international application instead of separate applications in each country. It is administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization and became effective in the US in 2003. Under the Madrid Protocol, applicants can file for an international registration of their trademark with WIPO to automatically extend protection to the other 79 member countries if no refusals are issued within 18 months. This provides a more cost-effective way for individuals, businesses, and other entities to protect their trademarks internationally.
The document discusses import of services under GST and relevant statutory provisions. It defines import of services as services where the supplier is located outside India, the recipient is located in India, and the place of supply is in India. Import of services with consideration is taxable for any person regardless of registration status or business purpose. Import without consideration is taxable for a registered person importing from a related party for business purposes. Certain imported services are exempt such as those received by government entities or charitable organizations. Imported services received under reverse charge are also discussed.
GST Supply and Place of Supply - By Venkanna settyvenkanna setty
The document discusses key definitions and concepts related to supply and place of supply under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India. It defines supply, person, goods, composite supply, and place of supply of goods and services. Supply is broadly defined and includes all forms of supply of goods/services for consideration as well as activities specified in Schedules I and II. Place of supply of goods is generally where the goods are located at the time of delivery to the recipient. Place of supply of services rules consider location of both supplier and recipient.
The document discusses key aspects of the Consumer Protection Act 1986 and Information Technology Act 2000 in India.
The Consumer Protection Act was enacted to better protect consumer interests and established consumer dispute redressal agencies at district, state and national levels to address complaints. It defines terms like complaint, consumer and defect. The Information Technology Act provides legal recognition to electronic communications and records. It recognizes digital signatures authenticated by Certifying Authorities and aims to facilitate e-governance.
China customs enforcement of Intellectual Property rights 2013Riccardo Benussi
A comparison between the EU and China's Customs agencies and laws, concerning enforcement of trademark, patent and copyright protection at borders. Can serve as a guide to small and medium enterprises to choose adequate and timely strategies in Intellectual Property rights protection.
This document summarizes the key aspects of The Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act of 1970 in India. It establishes advisory boards at the central and state levels to advise on matters related to the administration of the act. It requires the registration of establishments that employ 20 or more contract laborers with the registering officer. The principal employer of an establishment must apply for registration within a fixed period. If all details are provided, the registering officer will issue a certificate of registration. Registration can also be revoked if obtained through misrepresentation. Principal employers must register their establishment and cannot employ contract laborers without registration.
The document summarizes key aspects of the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) including:
- The PCT allows filing a single international patent application in multiple countries rather than separate national applications.
- It establishes an international search and preliminary examination but national patent offices make final decisions on granting patents.
- India joined the PCT in 1998. The PCT process includes international filing, search, publication and preliminary examination before proceeding to national patent offices.
Bortoletti, pharmaceutical compliance congress, fight against corruption, bud...Maurizio Bortoletti
The fight against corruption and other offenses against public administration must be based on accurate and objective data to give citizens a realistic representation of the situation and not ultra sized, taking into account that it is evoking themes and sensational easily usable by this or that political party
What is the first thing to consider when you approach the theme of "corruption"?
That of the extreme confusion. In a matter so evocative and striking as that of corruption to be informed, and be properly and completely, as far as possible, it seems like the best strategy and, together, the best antidote to unnecessary alarm.
Need an objective representation, a "snapshot" that does not want to serve any preconceived position or ideological bias, recognizing that corruption should be tackled without "ifs" and "buts", without replacing the scalpel of prudence cleaver indignation: unfortunately, the answers that have been given to this problem are very different, and often follow or are influenced by current ideas, stereotypes, clichés, in a wavering movement in which the risk is to "repaint" the collective imagination, to clothe him, and endorse it, at the risk of perpetuating errors of perspective that have long hindered and complicated the formulation and implementation of consistent and effective responses to the phenomenon.
The document summarizes Italy's laws regarding the criminalization of bribery of domestic public officials according to the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption. It describes the relevant articles of Italy's criminal code that define the offenses of active and passive bribery, as well as incitement to bribery. It also discusses how the codes have been interpreted by Italian courts to broadly define "public officials" and the elements of bribery offenses.
The document discusses the PSI Directive and its implementation in Italy. It summarizes the key principles of the Directive, including encouraging public sector bodies to make documents available for re-use. It also discusses Italy's transposition of the Directive, related court cases brought by companies reusing cadastral data, and suggestions for ensuring neutrality and non-discrimination in access to public sector information.
Announcement MiFID II Main Changes for authorisationsAtoZForex.com
CySEC highlights the main changes introduced by MiFID II, MiFIR, and the relevant delegated and implementing regulations, which affect the authorisation
requirements for CIFs.
Informe OCDE Chile: Review of implementation of the convention and 1997 recom...EUROsociAL II
This document provides a review of Chile's implementation of Article 2 of the OECD Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions, which requires countries to establish liability of legal persons for foreign bribery. It summarizes Chile's Law No. 20,393 on Criminal Responsibility of Legal Persons for crimes including bribery, money laundering, and terrorism financing. The law introduces criminal liability of private legal entities and state companies for these offenses. It outlines the standard of liability, which requires that the offense be committed by a high-level representative of the company for its direct or indirect benefit. It also discusses applicable entities, proceedings against legal persons, available sanctions including fines, and statute
This document is a Supreme Court of India judgment regarding the constitutional validity of Section 45 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act of 2002. Section 45 imposes conditions for granting bail to those accused of offenses punishable for over 3 years under Schedule A of the Act. The Court provides background on money laundering and the objectives of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. It describes some key provisions of the Act regarding definitions, offenses, punishment, and attachment of property involved in money laundering. The Court will determine if Section 45's bail conditions violate constitutional rights.
This document summarizes GRETA's second evaluation of Slovakia's implementation of the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. It finds that while Slovakia has legislation and coordination mechanisms to combat trafficking, its institutional framework and identification of victims could be strengthened. GRETA evaluated Slovakia's efforts to prevent trafficking, protect victims, prosecute traffickers, and cooperate internationally. It concluded that Slovakia has made progress but needs to improve identification and assistance to all victims, including children and those exploited for labor. GRETA urged Slovakia to take further action to fully comply with the Convention.
The document discusses key provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) 2016 and its relationship with the Income Tax Act 1961. Some key points:
- IBC aims to consolidate insolvency laws and provide a time-bound resolution process for insolvent companies, individuals, and partnerships.
- IBC overrides any other inconsistent law due to its non-obstante clause. Amendments were made to the Income Tax Act to ensure consistency with IBC.
- Tax authorities can file claims under IBC like other operational creditors but do not have voting rights in the Committee of Creditors. Their claims also do not take precedence over secured creditors.
- During the corporate
This document provides summaries of recent developments in European financial services regulation and related areas in 3 sentences or less:
The European Parliament and EU states have broadly agreed on regulating high frequency trading as part of MiFID II proposals, excluding a minimum resting period requirement for orders. ESMA is consulting on procedural rules for imposing fines under EMIR on trade repositories. The European Commission has outlined its 2014 work program, identifying MiFID II, the single resolution mechanism, ELTIFs and the fourth money laundering directive as priority financial services legislative proposals.
Legal shorts 19.06.15 including MiFID II and ESMA launches new strategyCummings
The document provides a weekly legal briefing on developments in the financial services industry from Cummings Law. It summarizes recent statements, reports and consultations from various regulatory bodies including ESMA, IOSCO, the European Commission, the FCA and the EBA on topics such as MiFID II implementation, ESMA's new strategy, EMIR frontloading rules, the Capital Markets Union, FCA's Project Innovate, equivalence of third country GAAP standards, and responses to consultations on remuneration guidelines and securities financing transactions. Readers are invited to contact the firm to discuss any of the points raised.
The handout for the second module of my introduction to English patent law. This covers the sources of law, both legislation and the case law. The module focuses on the Patents Act 1977 and the European Patent Convention. It also introduces readers to the main sets of law reports for patent law, the Reports of Patent Cases ("RPC") and the Fleet Street Reports ("FSR").
This document summarizes a research essay about the case of Industrias Ceresita S.A., the first company prosecuted under Chile's Law 20,393 on criminal liability of legal persons. The essay describes how Industrias Ceresita paid a municipal official a bribe to obtain a permit, in violation of the law. It then discusses the agreement reached between the company and prosecutors, where the company's proceedings were conditionally suspended for two years subject to implementing compliance programs and donating land and resources to the community. The essay aims to analyze this implications of this landmark case in the context of OECD and Chilean policies on combating foreign bribery.
Draft Criminal Code and Commentary - as published Sept 2013Jane Mulcahy
This document provides an introduction and overview of the Draft Criminal Code and Commentary from May 2010. It discusses the structure and content of the code, which integrates existing criminal law into a single document. It is divided into a general part on principles of liability and special parts covering specific offenses. The document also describes the technique used in codifying offenses, which aims to restate existing law in a clear and consistent manner using an offense template, element analysis, and other standardizing elements. It notes some areas where limited law reform may be suggested.
The Sapin II Law aims to strengthen France's anti-corruption efforts on a global level. It establishes new regulations for French companies, including requiring companies over a certain size to implement anti-corruption compliance programs with eight mandatory measures. It also creates a new anti-bribery agency and allows for judicial agreements between prosecutors and companies accused of corruption to avoid long trials. The law marks a revolution for businesses that now face significant fines if they do not upgrade their practices to meet the new legal requirements.
These are the slides for a seminar on The Intellectual Property Act 1994 which I chaired n 19 May 2014.
The Intellectual Property Act 2014 received royal assent on 14 May 2014. The Act contains a number of welcome and important provisions such as the power for the Secretary of State to make regulations to enable the UK to implement the Agreement on the Unified Patent Court and to accede to the Hague Agreement. It also allows the Intellectual Property Office to share information on patent applications with other patent offices thereby reducing unnecessary delays in processing patent applications.
Part I of the Bill makes changes to Part III of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 and the Registered Designs Act 1949. Part II amends the Patents Act 1977. Part III excludes information about ongoing research from the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Part IV contains rule making and commencement provisions.
This fairly short bill contains one controversial provision, namely s.13 which inserted a new s.35ZA into the Registered Designs Act 1949 that created a new offence of intentional copying of a registered design. This provision horrified patent lawyers who saw it as the thin end of the wedge that would end with the importation of the criminal law into patents but failed to satisfy the design lobby or its supporters in Parliament who canvassed for the introduction of criminal liability for unregistered design infringement at every opportunity. In the end. the Act that emerged from the Commons in May 2014 was very little different from the Bill that was introduced into the Lords in May 2013.
These slides cover four topics:
(1) As introduction and overview of the Act
(2) The Act's legislative history.
(3) Section 13.
(4) The consequences for practitioners.
We shall be repeating this presentation in different parts of the country. If in the meantime anyone has any questions about the Act, he or she is welcome to call me or my colleague Alex Rozycki on +44 (0)20 7404 5252 or contact us through this website,
Deferred prosecution agreements (DPAs) were introduced in 2013 as a means for corporations to avoid criminal prosecution by making reparations, while avoiding reputational and financial damage from a conviction. Key aspects of DPAs include judicial oversight of negotiations and approval of terms, strict requirements the corporation must meet to avoid prosecution, and factors considered for and against prosecution. The first two DPAs in the UK involved Standard Bank and XYZ Ltd and revealed the importance of full cooperation with investigators throughout.
The document discusses import of services under GST and relevant statutory provisions. It defines import of services as services where the supplier is located outside India, the recipient is located in India, and the place of supply is in India. Import of services with consideration is taxable for any person regardless of registration status or business purpose. Import without consideration is taxable for a registered person importing from a related party for business purposes. Certain imported services are exempt such as those received by government entities or charitable organizations. Imported services received under reverse charge are also discussed.
GST Supply and Place of Supply - By Venkanna settyvenkanna setty
The document discusses key definitions and concepts related to supply and place of supply under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India. It defines supply, person, goods, composite supply, and place of supply of goods and services. Supply is broadly defined and includes all forms of supply of goods/services for consideration as well as activities specified in Schedules I and II. Place of supply of goods is generally where the goods are located at the time of delivery to the recipient. Place of supply of services rules consider location of both supplier and recipient.
The document discusses key aspects of the Consumer Protection Act 1986 and Information Technology Act 2000 in India.
The Consumer Protection Act was enacted to better protect consumer interests and established consumer dispute redressal agencies at district, state and national levels to address complaints. It defines terms like complaint, consumer and defect. The Information Technology Act provides legal recognition to electronic communications and records. It recognizes digital signatures authenticated by Certifying Authorities and aims to facilitate e-governance.
China customs enforcement of Intellectual Property rights 2013Riccardo Benussi
A comparison between the EU and China's Customs agencies and laws, concerning enforcement of trademark, patent and copyright protection at borders. Can serve as a guide to small and medium enterprises to choose adequate and timely strategies in Intellectual Property rights protection.
This document summarizes the key aspects of The Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act of 1970 in India. It establishes advisory boards at the central and state levels to advise on matters related to the administration of the act. It requires the registration of establishments that employ 20 or more contract laborers with the registering officer. The principal employer of an establishment must apply for registration within a fixed period. If all details are provided, the registering officer will issue a certificate of registration. Registration can also be revoked if obtained through misrepresentation. Principal employers must register their establishment and cannot employ contract laborers without registration.
The document summarizes key aspects of the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) including:
- The PCT allows filing a single international patent application in multiple countries rather than separate national applications.
- It establishes an international search and preliminary examination but national patent offices make final decisions on granting patents.
- India joined the PCT in 1998. The PCT process includes international filing, search, publication and preliminary examination before proceeding to national patent offices.
Bortoletti, pharmaceutical compliance congress, fight against corruption, bud...Maurizio Bortoletti
The fight against corruption and other offenses against public administration must be based on accurate and objective data to give citizens a realistic representation of the situation and not ultra sized, taking into account that it is evoking themes and sensational easily usable by this or that political party
What is the first thing to consider when you approach the theme of "corruption"?
That of the extreme confusion. In a matter so evocative and striking as that of corruption to be informed, and be properly and completely, as far as possible, it seems like the best strategy and, together, the best antidote to unnecessary alarm.
Need an objective representation, a "snapshot" that does not want to serve any preconceived position or ideological bias, recognizing that corruption should be tackled without "ifs" and "buts", without replacing the scalpel of prudence cleaver indignation: unfortunately, the answers that have been given to this problem are very different, and often follow or are influenced by current ideas, stereotypes, clichés, in a wavering movement in which the risk is to "repaint" the collective imagination, to clothe him, and endorse it, at the risk of perpetuating errors of perspective that have long hindered and complicated the formulation and implementation of consistent and effective responses to the phenomenon.
The document summarizes Italy's laws regarding the criminalization of bribery of domestic public officials according to the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption. It describes the relevant articles of Italy's criminal code that define the offenses of active and passive bribery, as well as incitement to bribery. It also discusses how the codes have been interpreted by Italian courts to broadly define "public officials" and the elements of bribery offenses.
The document discusses the PSI Directive and its implementation in Italy. It summarizes the key principles of the Directive, including encouraging public sector bodies to make documents available for re-use. It also discusses Italy's transposition of the Directive, related court cases brought by companies reusing cadastral data, and suggestions for ensuring neutrality and non-discrimination in access to public sector information.
Announcement MiFID II Main Changes for authorisationsAtoZForex.com
CySEC highlights the main changes introduced by MiFID II, MiFIR, and the relevant delegated and implementing regulations, which affect the authorisation
requirements for CIFs.
Informe OCDE Chile: Review of implementation of the convention and 1997 recom...EUROsociAL II
This document provides a review of Chile's implementation of Article 2 of the OECD Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions, which requires countries to establish liability of legal persons for foreign bribery. It summarizes Chile's Law No. 20,393 on Criminal Responsibility of Legal Persons for crimes including bribery, money laundering, and terrorism financing. The law introduces criminal liability of private legal entities and state companies for these offenses. It outlines the standard of liability, which requires that the offense be committed by a high-level representative of the company for its direct or indirect benefit. It also discusses applicable entities, proceedings against legal persons, available sanctions including fines, and statute
This document is a Supreme Court of India judgment regarding the constitutional validity of Section 45 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act of 2002. Section 45 imposes conditions for granting bail to those accused of offenses punishable for over 3 years under Schedule A of the Act. The Court provides background on money laundering and the objectives of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. It describes some key provisions of the Act regarding definitions, offenses, punishment, and attachment of property involved in money laundering. The Court will determine if Section 45's bail conditions violate constitutional rights.
This document summarizes GRETA's second evaluation of Slovakia's implementation of the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. It finds that while Slovakia has legislation and coordination mechanisms to combat trafficking, its institutional framework and identification of victims could be strengthened. GRETA evaluated Slovakia's efforts to prevent trafficking, protect victims, prosecute traffickers, and cooperate internationally. It concluded that Slovakia has made progress but needs to improve identification and assistance to all victims, including children and those exploited for labor. GRETA urged Slovakia to take further action to fully comply with the Convention.
The document discusses key provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) 2016 and its relationship with the Income Tax Act 1961. Some key points:
- IBC aims to consolidate insolvency laws and provide a time-bound resolution process for insolvent companies, individuals, and partnerships.
- IBC overrides any other inconsistent law due to its non-obstante clause. Amendments were made to the Income Tax Act to ensure consistency with IBC.
- Tax authorities can file claims under IBC like other operational creditors but do not have voting rights in the Committee of Creditors. Their claims also do not take precedence over secured creditors.
- During the corporate
This document provides summaries of recent developments in European financial services regulation and related areas in 3 sentences or less:
The European Parliament and EU states have broadly agreed on regulating high frequency trading as part of MiFID II proposals, excluding a minimum resting period requirement for orders. ESMA is consulting on procedural rules for imposing fines under EMIR on trade repositories. The European Commission has outlined its 2014 work program, identifying MiFID II, the single resolution mechanism, ELTIFs and the fourth money laundering directive as priority financial services legislative proposals.
Legal shorts 19.06.15 including MiFID II and ESMA launches new strategyCummings
The document provides a weekly legal briefing on developments in the financial services industry from Cummings Law. It summarizes recent statements, reports and consultations from various regulatory bodies including ESMA, IOSCO, the European Commission, the FCA and the EBA on topics such as MiFID II implementation, ESMA's new strategy, EMIR frontloading rules, the Capital Markets Union, FCA's Project Innovate, equivalence of third country GAAP standards, and responses to consultations on remuneration guidelines and securities financing transactions. Readers are invited to contact the firm to discuss any of the points raised.
The handout for the second module of my introduction to English patent law. This covers the sources of law, both legislation and the case law. The module focuses on the Patents Act 1977 and the European Patent Convention. It also introduces readers to the main sets of law reports for patent law, the Reports of Patent Cases ("RPC") and the Fleet Street Reports ("FSR").
This document summarizes a research essay about the case of Industrias Ceresita S.A., the first company prosecuted under Chile's Law 20,393 on criminal liability of legal persons. The essay describes how Industrias Ceresita paid a municipal official a bribe to obtain a permit, in violation of the law. It then discusses the agreement reached between the company and prosecutors, where the company's proceedings were conditionally suspended for two years subject to implementing compliance programs and donating land and resources to the community. The essay aims to analyze this implications of this landmark case in the context of OECD and Chilean policies on combating foreign bribery.
Draft Criminal Code and Commentary - as published Sept 2013Jane Mulcahy
This document provides an introduction and overview of the Draft Criminal Code and Commentary from May 2010. It discusses the structure and content of the code, which integrates existing criminal law into a single document. It is divided into a general part on principles of liability and special parts covering specific offenses. The document also describes the technique used in codifying offenses, which aims to restate existing law in a clear and consistent manner using an offense template, element analysis, and other standardizing elements. It notes some areas where limited law reform may be suggested.
The Sapin II Law aims to strengthen France's anti-corruption efforts on a global level. It establishes new regulations for French companies, including requiring companies over a certain size to implement anti-corruption compliance programs with eight mandatory measures. It also creates a new anti-bribery agency and allows for judicial agreements between prosecutors and companies accused of corruption to avoid long trials. The law marks a revolution for businesses that now face significant fines if they do not upgrade their practices to meet the new legal requirements.
These are the slides for a seminar on The Intellectual Property Act 1994 which I chaired n 19 May 2014.
The Intellectual Property Act 2014 received royal assent on 14 May 2014. The Act contains a number of welcome and important provisions such as the power for the Secretary of State to make regulations to enable the UK to implement the Agreement on the Unified Patent Court and to accede to the Hague Agreement. It also allows the Intellectual Property Office to share information on patent applications with other patent offices thereby reducing unnecessary delays in processing patent applications.
Part I of the Bill makes changes to Part III of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 and the Registered Designs Act 1949. Part II amends the Patents Act 1977. Part III excludes information about ongoing research from the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Part IV contains rule making and commencement provisions.
This fairly short bill contains one controversial provision, namely s.13 which inserted a new s.35ZA into the Registered Designs Act 1949 that created a new offence of intentional copying of a registered design. This provision horrified patent lawyers who saw it as the thin end of the wedge that would end with the importation of the criminal law into patents but failed to satisfy the design lobby or its supporters in Parliament who canvassed for the introduction of criminal liability for unregistered design infringement at every opportunity. In the end. the Act that emerged from the Commons in May 2014 was very little different from the Bill that was introduced into the Lords in May 2013.
These slides cover four topics:
(1) As introduction and overview of the Act
(2) The Act's legislative history.
(3) Section 13.
(4) The consequences for practitioners.
We shall be repeating this presentation in different parts of the country. If in the meantime anyone has any questions about the Act, he or she is welcome to call me or my colleague Alex Rozycki on +44 (0)20 7404 5252 or contact us through this website,
Deferred prosecution agreements (DPAs) were introduced in 2013 as a means for corporations to avoid criminal prosecution by making reparations, while avoiding reputational and financial damage from a conviction. Key aspects of DPAs include judicial oversight of negotiations and approval of terms, strict requirements the corporation must meet to avoid prosecution, and factors considered for and against prosecution. The first two DPAs in the UK involved Standard Bank and XYZ Ltd and revealed the importance of full cooperation with investigators throughout.
Respective scopes of european and national laws concerning crowdfunding opera...FinPart
This document discusses the legal frameworks governing crowdfunding at both the EU and national levels in France. At the EU level, crowdfunding activities may be subject to directives around payments, e-money, markets in financial instruments, and anti-money laundering. National laws in France further regulate areas like collecting money from the public and specific investment vehicles. The document proposes creating a new crowdfunding services provider status and exemptions for certain investments and loans to better accommodate crowdfunding within the existing legal structures.
The document discusses a proposed EU directive on allowing companies to transfer their registered office across borders within the EU in a tax-neutral manner while maintaining corporate identity. It would allow companies to relocate without liquidating. The proposal outlines administrative processes for the transfer, including informing employees, submitting reports to shareholders on the implications, and approval by shareholders. It aims to balance free movement rights with legal and tax obligations. The directive could help realize freedom of establishment in the EU single market by facilitating cross-border corporate mobility.
Presented by Adrian Sarchet, Senior Associate at Carey Olsen, and Alan Bougourd, Registrar of the Guernsey Registry, attendees learnt about the effect of the new amendments to the Guernsey Company Law 2008 (the Companies Law).
Similar to Informe Greco rc3(2013)20 second_spain_en (20)
Este documento presenta los resultados preliminares de la encuesta "Barómetro de Diciembre 2013" realizada por el Centro de Investigaciones Sociológicas (CIS) en España. La encuesta incluyó 2,466 entrevistas realizadas entre el 1 y el 13 de diciembre de 2013. Los resultados muestran que la mayoría de los encuestados califican la situación económica y política de España como mala o muy mala, y creen que las condiciones han empeorado en el último año. El paro es vista como el principal problema del país, seguid
Este documento es la memoria anual presentada por el Fiscal General del Estado al Gobierno de España. Consta de dos volúmenes que describen la actividad del Ministerio Fiscal en 2012, incluyendo estadísticas e informes de las diferentes fiscalías territoriales y especializadas. El documento analiza cuestiones como la evolución de la criminalidad, la corrupción y propone reformas legislativas.
(parte corrupción) Memoria Fiscalía General del Estado 2013TheDailyCorruption
Este documento resume la actividad de la Fiscalía Especial contra la Corrupción y la Criminalidad Organizada durante el año 2012. En 2012, la Fiscalía asumió varios casos relacionados con cajas de ahorro en crisis y aumentó las investigaciones sobre criminalidad organizada. La Fiscalía presentó varias querellas y escritos de acusación, y se dictaron 22 sentencias, 19 de ellas condenatorias. Algunos de los casos más importantes investigados por la Fiscalía fueron el caso Forum Filatélico, la Operación Troika sobre blanqueo de capital
AUTO Registro Sede PP DP 275/2008 Pieza Separada Informe UDEF-BLA Nº22.510/13...TheDailyCorruption
1) La policía presentó un informe analizando documentos de una empresa contratada por el Partido Popular.
2) El informe indica pagos irregulares a la empresa que no estaban en la contabilidad oficial del partido.
3) El juez ordenó más investigaciones sobre posibles delitos financieros cometidos.
DIL PREV 2081/2012 AUTO Juzgado 1ª Instancia e Instrucción Nº5 Estepona (16 d...TheDailyCorruption
La Unión Europea ha propuesto un nuevo paquete de sanciones contra Rusia que incluye un embargo al petróleo ruso. El embargo se aplicaría gradualmente durante seis meses para el petróleo crudo y ocho meses para los productos refinados. Este paquete de sanciones requiere la aprobación unánime de los 27 estados miembros de la UE.
La sentencia se refiere a un caso de delito contra la Hacienda Pública relacionado con la venta de INTERINVEST (propietaria de las aerolíneas argentinas ARSA y AUSTRAL) de SEPI a AIR COMET. SEPI vendió INTERINVEST por 1 dólar y asumió pasivos de hasta 300 millones, pero los fondos fueron usados por AIR COMET para adquirir créditos de ARSA que no fueron contabilizados correctamente, lo que supuso un fraude fiscal de 99 millones de euros.
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdfTechSoup
"Learn about all the ways Walmart supports nonprofit organizations.
You will hear from Liz Willett, the Head of Nonprofits, and hear about what Walmart is doing to help nonprofits, including Walmart Business and Spark Good. Walmart Business+ is a new offer for nonprofits that offers discounts and also streamlines nonprofits order and expense tracking, saving time and money.
The webinar may also give some examples on how nonprofits can best leverage Walmart Business+.
The event will cover the following::
Walmart Business + (https://business.walmart.com/plus) is a new shopping experience for nonprofits, schools, and local business customers that connects an exclusive online shopping experience to stores. Benefits include free delivery and shipping, a 'Spend Analytics” feature, special discounts, deals and tax-exempt shopping.
Special TechSoup offer for a free 180 days membership, and up to $150 in discounts on eligible orders.
Spark Good (walmart.com/sparkgood) is a charitable platform that enables nonprofits to receive donations directly from customers and associates.
Answers about how you can do more with Walmart!"
This presentation includes basic of PCOS their pathology and treatment and also Ayurveda correlation of PCOS and Ayurvedic line of treatment mentioned in classics.
A workshop hosted by the South African Journal of Science aimed at postgraduate students and early career researchers with little or no experience in writing and publishing journal articles.
How to Build a Module in Odoo 17 Using the Scaffold MethodCeline George
Odoo provides an option for creating a module by using a single line command. By using this command the user can make a whole structure of a module. It is very easy for a beginner to make a module. There is no need to make each file manually. This slide will show how to create a module using the scaffold method.
Main Java[All of the Base Concepts}.docxadhitya5119
This is part 1 of my Java Learning Journey. This Contains Custom methods, classes, constructors, packages, multithreading , try- catch block, finally block and more.
हिंदी वर्णमाला पीपीटी, hindi alphabet PPT presentation, hindi varnamala PPT, Hindi Varnamala pdf, हिंदी स्वर, हिंदी व्यंजन, sikhiye hindi varnmala, dr. mulla adam ali, hindi language and literature, hindi alphabet with drawing, hindi alphabet pdf, hindi varnamala for childrens, hindi language, hindi varnamala practice for kids, https://www.drmullaadamali.com
RPMS TEMPLATE FOR SCHOOL YEAR 2023-2024 FOR TEACHER 1 TO TEACHER 3
Informe Greco rc3(2013)20 second_spain_en
1. Adoption : 21 June 2013
Publication : 11 July 2013
Public
Greco RC-III (2013) 20E
Third Evaluation Round
Second
Compliance Report
on Spain
”Incriminations (ETS 173 and 191, GPC 2)”
***
”Transparency of Party Funding”
Adopted by GRECO
at its 60th Plenary Meeting
(Strasbourg, 17-21 June 2013)
GRECO Secretariat
Council of Europe
www.coe.int/greco
F-67075 Strasbourg Cedex
+33 3 88 41 20 00
Fax +33 3 88 41 27 05
Directorate General I
Human Rights and Rule of Law
Information Society and Action against
Crime Directorate
2. I.
INTRODUCTION
1.
The Second Compliance Report assesses further measures taken, by the authorities of Spain
since the adoption of the Compliance Report in respect of the recommendations issued by
GRECO in its Third Round Evaluation Report on Spain. It is recalled that the Third Evaluation
Round covers two distinct themes, namely
-
Theme I – Incriminations: Articles 1a and 1b, 2-12, 15-17, 19 paragraph 1 of the Criminal
Law Convention on Corruption ETS 173), Articles 1-6 of its Additional Protocol (ETS 191)
and Guiding Principle 2 (criminalisation of corruption).
-
Theme II – Transparency of party funding: Articles 8, 11, 12, 13b, 14 and 16 of
Recommendation Rec(2003)4 on Common Rules against Corruption in the Funding of
Political Parties and Electoral Campaigns, and - more generally - Guiding Principle 15
(financing of political parties and election campaigns).
2.
The Third Round Evaluation Report was adopted at GRECO’s 42nd Plenary Meeting (15 May
2009) and made public on 28 May 2009, following authorisation by Spain (Greco Eval III
Rep (2008) 3E, Theme I and Theme II). The subsequent Compliance Report was adopted at
GRECO’s 50th Plenary meeting (1 April 2011) and made public on 12 April 2011, following
authorisation by Spain (Greco RC-III (2011) 5E).
3.
As required by GRECO's Rules of Procedure, the Spanish authorities submitted their Second
Situation Report with additional information regarding action taken to implement the
recommendations that were partly implemented or not implemented, according to the Compliance
Report. This report, which was received on 31 October 2012, served as a basis for the Second
Compliance Report.
4.
GRECO selected Estonia and Italy to appoint Rapporteurs for the compliance procedure. The
Rapporteurs appointed for the Second Compliance Report were Mr Urvo KLOPETS (Estonia) and
Mr Alessio SCARCELLA (Italy). They were assisted by GRECO’s Secretariat in drawing up the
Second Compliance Report.
II.
ANALYSIS
Theme I: Incriminations
5.
It is recalled that GRECO in its Evaluation Report addressed 9 recommendations to Spain in
respect of Theme I. Recommendations i, ii, vii, viii and ix were considered satisfactorily
implemented or dealt with in a satisfactory manner. Recommendations iii, iv, v and vi were
considered as partly implemented.
Recommendation iii.
6.
GRECO recommended to (i) clarify the notion of foreign public official; (ii) enlarge the scope of
Article 445 PC concerning active bribery of foreign officials and officials of international
organisations beyond situations involving international business transactions; (iii) criminalise
passive bribery of foreign officials and officials of international organisations; and (iv) ensure that
bribery of members of foreign public assemblies, international parliamentary assemblies (other
2
3. than members of the European Parliament), as well as judges and officials of international courts
(other than those serving in the International Criminal Court) is criminalised.
7.
GRECO recalls that in the RC-report it welcomed the amendments introduced to the Penal Code
(PC) to reformulate bribery offences and the particular changes introduced with respect to the
offence of bribery of foreign officials and officials or agents of public international organisations.
The recommendation was assessed as partly implemented since GRECO remained dubious as
to whether active bribery of foreign officials and international organisations beyond situations
involving international business transactions (recommendation iii, part ii), as well as passive
bribery of those categories of officials (recommendation iii, part iii), were indeed covered in
legislation.
8.
The authorities of Spain now report on recent efforts undertaken in this area: amendments to the
PC have been drafted, pursuant to which there is a new Article 426 that includes a definition of
foreign public officials and officials of international organisations – which comprises the different
categories of persons covered by the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption (ETS 173), cf.
paragraph 19 RC-Report – and extends the application of Articles 419 to 452 on active and
passive bribery of domestic public officials to foreign officials and officials of international
organisations. In addition, the aforementioned draft amendments provide for a separate
autonomous offence of bribery of foreign public officials in international business transactions in
Article 286quater, which is then governed by specific jurisdiction provisions in Article
286quinquies.
9.
GRECO is pleased to note that the authorities have paid due consideration to the outstanding
concerns raised in recommendation iii and that new amendments to the PC have been drafted to
cover unequivocally all instances of active and passive bribery of foreign officials and officials or
agents of public international organisations.
10.
Pending adoption of the reported draft amendments to the PC, GRECO can only conclude that
recommendation iii remains partly implemented.
Recommendation iv.
11.
GRECO recommended to (i) review Article 422 (bribery of jurors and arbitrators) of the Penal
Code to ensure that the criminalisation of bribery of jurors and arbitrators is in line with the
Additional Protocol to the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption (ETS 191); and (ii) criminalise
bribery of foreign arbitrators and jurors.
12.
GRECO welcomed in the RC-report the new wording of the Penal Code (PC) which, in
Article 423, specifically criminalised bribery of domestic jurors and arbitrators. GRECO noted the
intention of the authorities to introduce further legislative changes to criminalise bribery of foreign
jurors and arbitrators.
13.
The authorities of Spain reiterate their plans to introduce amendments to the Penal Code in order
to provide for the criminalisation of bribery of foreign jurors and arbitrators.
14.
GRECO urges the authorities to criminalise bribery of foreign jurors and arbitrators; until this is
done, GRECO can only conclude that recommendation iv remains partly implemented.
3
4. Recommendation v.
15.
GRECO recommended to criminalise bribery in the private sector in accordance with Articles 7
and 8 of the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption (ETS 173).
16.
GRECO positively assessed in the RC-Report the amendments introduced in legislation to
criminalise bribery in the private sector (an area where specific provisions were lacking in the
past), pursuant to Article 286bis PC. GRECO, however, remained dubious as to whether the
aforementioned offence of bribery in the private sector covered the request, receipt or acceptance
of the promise of an undue advantage. Consequently, GRECO assessed recommendation v as
partly implemented.
17.
The authorities of Spain refer to Article 286bis PC and the way in which the offence of passive
bribery (Article 286bis, paragraph 2) has been crafted to mirror the active side which clearly
criminalises the promising, offering or giving of an undue advantage (Article 286bis, paragraph 1).
Therefore, according to the authorities, there is no doubt that the offence of bribery in the private
sector covered the request, receipt or acceptance of the promise of an undue advantage.
Moreover, the authorities indicate that the draft amendments to the PC which criminalise the
offence of abuse of position in the private sector (Article 252) should suffice, since the perpetrator
of the offence would cover anyone who has management powers in the company concerned.
18.
GRECO takes note of the clarification of the Spanish authorities re-stating that the provision on
passive bribery in the private sector (Article 286bis(2)) mirrors that of active bribery in the private
sector (Article 286bis(1)) and thereby covers the request, receipt or acceptance of the promise of
an undue advantage. However, as this conclusion diverges from the clear letter of the law, which
describes the conducts of active and passive bribery in autonomous provisions, it remains to be
seen whether jurisprudence will endorse this interpretation by analogy. As to the information
provided by the authorities concerning the offence of abuse of authority in the private sector and
its pertinence to address recommendation v, GRECO notes that the Criminal Law Convention on
Corruption (ETS 173) is clear as to the coverage of the perpetrators of the offence of bribery in
the private sector, i.e. “any persons, who direct or work for, in any capacity, private sector
entities”; therefore, not restricting its scope to just those who are entrusted with management
positions.
19.
GRECO concludes that recommendation v remains partly implemented.
Recommendation vi.
20.
GRECO recommended to (i) criminalise active trading in influence as a principal offence;
(ii) criminalise trading in influence in relation to foreign public officials, members of foreign public
assemblies, officials of international organisations, members of international parliamentary
assemblies and judges and officials of international courts; and (iii) clarify beyond doubt that
immaterial advantages are covered by the relevant trading in influence provisions in the Penal
Code.
21.
GRECO gave credit in the RC-Report to the efforts made by the authorities to align the offence of
trading in influence in Articles 428 and 429 PC with the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption
(ETS 173). It remained dubious, however, as to the criminalisation of active trading in influence
and the coverage of the relevant trading in influence provisions with respect to foreign and
international officials. In the absence of additional clarifications on the aforementioned misgivings,
4
5. referring to parts (i) and (ii) of recommendation vi, GRECO considered the recommendation as
partly implemented.
22.
The authorities of Spain explain that it is possible to punish a trader in influence by virtue of
Article 428 PC (which criminalises the exertion of influence “the public official or authority that
influences another public official or authority”) and Articles 28 and 65(3) PC (general rules on
participation which would allow the punishment of any individual who promises, gives or offers an
undue advantage, as an instigator of the offence). As to whether trading in influence of foreign
and international officials is criminalised, the authorities sustain that this is possible by reference
to the provisions and jurisprudence on domestic public officials; they add that, pursuant to the
draft amendments to the PC, in particular Article 426 (see also paragraph xx), it would be
possible to apply the provisions of trading in influence of domestic public officials to foreign and
international officials.
23.
With respect to recommendation vi (i), GRECO takes note of the arguments presented by the
authorities, but notes that they do not differ from those submitted on the occasion of the First
Compliance Report and do not sufficiently address the question of the punishment of the active
trader in influence who is not a public official and who does not effectively exert his/her influence.
With respect to recommendation vi (ii), i.e. the criminalisation of trading in influence of foreign and
international officials, GRECO is not fully convinced yet. As explained before (see also
paragraph 9), GRECO has difficulties in accepting the interpretation of the authorities that the
provisions on domestic public officials would be applicable to foreign and international officials.
No case/court decision has been cited to corroborate the argumentation of the authorities in this
regard. Moreover, GRECO notes that the reported draft amendments to the PC – extending the
applicability of the provisions on domestic public officials to foreign and international officials –
only refer to the offences of bribery (Articles 419 to 425 PC), and therefore, leave out of their
scope the offence of trading in influence (which is regulated later in Articles 428 and 429 PC).
24.
GRECO concludes that recommendation vi remains partly implemented.
Theme II: Transparency of Party Funding
25.
It is recalled that GRECO in its Evaluation Report addressed 6 recommendations to Spain in
respect of Theme II. Recommendations iii, v and vi were considered as partly implemented.
Recommendations i, ii and iv were not implemented.
26.
The main legislative instrument governing political finance, i.e. Law 8/2007 on Political Parties
Funding, was amended by Law 5/2012 of 22 October 2012. This amendment reduces, in the
context of the current economic and financial crisis affecting Spain, the amount of public funding
allocated for party funding. It also introduces changes enhancing the transparency of political
accounts (e.g. obligation to report donations over 50,000 EUR and donations of real estate to the
Court of Audit within three months of reception of the donation) and requiring political parties to
publish relevant information on their accounts online. Furthermore, Law 5/2012 places additional
restrictions on private funding (i.e. ban on donations from companies, including subsidiaries, that
have signed contracts with public authorities; ban on donations from foundations, associations
and other entities receiving public funds) and loans (i.e. establishing a maximum permissible
amount of 100,000 EUR per year for debt cancellation). Finally, it further develops the procedure
by which the Court of Audit decides on serious infringements of the law.
5
6. Recommendation i.
27.
GRECO recommended to take appropriate measures to ensure that loans granted to political
parties are not used to circumvent political financing regulations.
28.
GRECO concluded, in the absence of any concrete improvement to better regulate loans, that
recommendation i was not implemented.
29.
The authorities of Spain now report that the recently adopted Law 5/2012 abolishes the provision
of Law 8/2007 under which loans were exempted from the applicable thresholds on private
donations. According to the amendments introduced (Article 4), the conditions under which loans
are granted can be negotiated among the contractors (credit institution-political party) in
accordance with law. The main novelty introduced by Law 5/2012 is that debt cancellation by a
credit institution cannot exceed 100,000 EUR (principal amount and interests) per year. Finally,
political parties are under a clear obligation to report to the Court of Audit (and the Bank of Spain,
as applicable) the terms and conditions under which loans have been granted; these cannot
deviate from the general market conditions on loans that are otherwise provided by law. If a
political party does not reimburse the loan within the stipulated timeframe, it can renegotiate its
debt with the credit institution, but only in accordance with the applicable general market
conditions; any renegotiation of the loan must be duly communicated to the Court of Audit. If the
Court of Audit spots any irregularity in this area, it will document it in its annual reports and raise it
before Parliament, as adequate. Moreover, the sanction established in Article 17 of Law 8/2007
applies whenever infringements of limits and restrictions on donations occur, i.e. a fine equalling
twice the contribution received may be deducted from future public subsidies. Political parties
must publish on their website, following the adoption of the relevant Court of Audit monitoring
report on a given fiscal exercise, details on the value of loans, the identity of the lender and
forgiveness of the loan, as applicable.
30.
GRECO takes note of the action initiated by the authorities to further regulate on loans, which is a
step forward in infusing transparency into the system. It is recalled that the situation of political
parties being in debt, and the potential that such a situation could have on the vulnerability of
political parties vis-à-vis credit institutions, is an important source of concern in Spain. GRECO
notes that, pursuant to the new Law 5/2012, loans are considered a source of private funding
which are no longer exempted from the thresholds on contributions from individual donors. In
particular, the current limit on written-off loans (100,000 EUR) equals the cap on donations from
individual donors per year. Furthermore, GRECO welcomes the measures taken to improve
transparency on the terms and conditions of contracted loans: in addition to the requirement for
political parties to disclose loan conditions to the Court of Audit and the Bank of Spain (Banco de
España), political parties must publish on their websites, details on the value of the loan and the
identity of the lender, as well as information on written-off loans. GRECO nevertheless regrets
that the law has failed to ensure more certainty as regards the publication obligation of political
parties, including clear deadlines and sanctions for failure to publish. Furthermore, the latest
report of the Court of Audit on party funding, including details on contracted loans by political
parties, dates from 2008; clearly, more needs to be done to provide better information to the
public on this sensitive matter. GRECO has dealt with these two pending problems in
recommendations iii and vi addressing publicity and sanctioning requirements, respectively.
31.
GRECO concludes that recommendation i has been partly implemented.
6
7. Recommendation ii.
32.
GRECO recommended to take measures to increase the transparency of income and
expenditure of (i) political parties at local level; (ii) entities, related directly or indirectly, to political
parties or otherwise under their control.
33.
GRECO recalls that, in the RC-Report, no evidence had been supplied showing that the
transparency of the accounts of political parties at (i) local level and (ii) entities, related directly or
indirectly, to political parties or otherwise under their control, had been increased in any
meaningful manner. Consequently, recommendation ii was assessed as not implemented.
34.
The authorities of Spain report on a series of new developments in this domain. In particular, Law
5/2012, in its Additional Provision No. 7, specifically refers to foundations and associations linked
to political parties. They are subject to the same oversight mechanisms as those applied to
political parties.
35.
The law states that they are also subject to the limits on private donations placed on political
parties, with some exceptions: (i) they are not subject to the applicable cap on the value of
donations (and debt cancellation) that political parties are entitled to receive per donor and per
year; and (ii) they are not subject to the ban on donations from private companies that have
signed contracts with public authorities. Any donation received from a legal person is (i) to be
approved by the governing body of the donor; and (ii) certified in a notarised document, if
exceeding 120,000 EUR and if with a monetary nature (donations below 120,000 EUR or in-kind
must nevertheless be documented with a concrete reference to the identity of the donor and the
irrevocable nature of the donation made). Donations are subsequently defined as any
contribution, whether monetary or in kind, which is intended to “generically” finance general
expenditure of the political foundation or association. Assets or monetary donations, which are
given to finance a specific project or activity of the political foundation or association, when the
said project or activity responds to a “common objective” of both the donor and the recipient (as
specified in their respective governing statutes), fall out of the scope of the aforementioned
definition.
36.
Furthermore, political foundations and associations must keep their accounts in due form and
undergo annual audit of their income and expenditure. They are required to publish their accounts
online (on their respective websites), once the Court of Audit has issued its annual report on
political accounts. They must also inform the Ministry of Finance and Public Administrations of the
donations received. The Court of Audit is now empowered with full inspection capacity as regards
income (any income and not only donations received) of connected entities. Moreover, any
donation from a legal person must be reported to the Court of Audit within three months following
their receipt.
37.
With respect to local branches, the Court of Audit has recommended, in its latest annual report
corresponding to the 2007 fiscal exercise, that political parties provide consolidated reports
including local branches. This recommendation was also extensible to related entities.
38.
GRECO takes note of the information provided. It welcomes the steps taken to subject political
foundations and associations to tighter accounting and reporting obligations of both their income
and their expenditure. GRECO has however misgivings as to the possibilities that the law opens
up, by virtue of the applicable exceptions, to funnel “interested” money to political foundations or
associations. GRECO notes that the exceptions provided by Law 5/2012 with respect to the
7
8. permissible sources of income, which a political association/foundation may receive, are much
broader than those available under the former law.
39.
Moreover, GRECO recalls that Article 11 of Recommendation Rec(2003)4 requires party
accounts to be consolidated so as to include the accounts of entities related, directly or indirectly,
to political parties, or otherwise under their control. GRECO notes that the Court of Audit has
recommended political parties to consolidate their accounts in line with the above, but it does not
appear that such a practice has developed so far. Further, while political foundations and
associations are required to publish their accounts online, no sanction is provided by law for
failure to do so.
40.
GRECO also notes that much more needs to be done to ensure the transparency of party
accounts at local level. It is recalled that the accounts presented by political parties to the Court of
Audit are only consolidated up to the provincial level, but have not included to-date any
information on local branches. The Third Evaluation Report (paragraph 75) reflected on the
corruption risks at local level, where an important volume of economic operations are performed
(e.g. with respect to procurement and licensing procedures).
41.
In GRECO’s view, it is important that citizens are provided with meaningful information on the
identity of the donations made to political parties, their branches and related entities, to better
help identify questionable financial ties and possible corruption in the party funding system.
42.
GRECO concludes that recommendation ii has been partly implemented.
Recommendation iii.
43.
GRECO recommended to establish a common format for parties’ accounts and returns (at both
head office and local level) with a view to ensuring that the information made available to the
public is consistent and comparable to the greatest extent possible, and that it is disclosed in a
timely manner within the deadlines prescribed in Law 8/2007 on Political Parties Funding, thus
allowing a meaningful comparison both over time and between parties.
44.
GRECO assessed this recommendation as partly implemented since, although there were plans
in the pipeline to establish a common accounting plan for political parties, these plans had yet to
materialise in practice. Moreover, no information had been provided concerning the timeliness of
financial reports.
45.
The authorities of Spain explain that the Court of Audit has made endeavours to improve both the
comparability and the timeliness of financial reports. In particular, the Court of Audit has been
working, since 2011, with the Accountancy and Auditing Institute on the elaboration of an
accounting plan for political parties. It is expected that the said plan will be adopted in 2013 and
already applicable to the 2014 fiscal exercise. Likewise, the Court of Audit issued, on 24 June
2010, guidance for political parties on their accounting obligations and the way in which political
finances must be presented. Moreover, Law 5/2012 imposes an obligation on political parties to
publish financial information (balance sheet, amount of loans received, details on the credit
institution which has granted the loan and details on written-off loans, as applicable), following the
adoption of the annual report of the Court of Audit on party finances.
46.
GRECO takes note of the on-going efforts of the authorities to provide for uniform accounting
formats for parties’ accounts and returns. GRECO understands that guidance and models have
8
9. been issued to this end, but that the enforceability of a common format would only take effect
once the accounting plan is adopted by the end of 2013. GRECO trusts that the authorities will
proceed with their reported plans in an expeditious manner.
47.
GRECO welcomes the obligation placed on political parties to publish on their respective
websites, information on their finances. This was a weakness of the system specifically
highlighted in the Third Round Evaluation Report (paragraph 76) which has now been specifically
regulated by law. GRECO however notes that this obligation is not coupled with effective
deadlines, nor with any sanction in case of non-compliance. These gaps still need to be
addressed.
48.
GRECO notes that, pursuant to the new Law 5/2012, the obligation for political parties to publish
their accounts comes into play after the adoption by the Court of Audit of its annual reports on
party funding. GRECO recalls its concern that the Court of Audit monitoring reports were not
being released in a timely manner. Although a reporting deadline for the Court of Audit is
provided by law (within six months of the submission of financial reports by political parties), the
Court of Audit reports were generally being released several years after the actual financial
reporting from political parties took place. The latest report issued by the Court of Audit dates
from 2008, although the Court of Audit has indicated to GRECO that it expects to be publishing
the reports from 2009 to 2011 in the coming months. GRECO is hopeful that the current
reinforcement of the personnel of the Court of Audit (see paragraph 60) will significantly
ameliorate this unsatisfactory situation.
49.
As reiterated by GRECO throughout the Third Round Evaluation process, timely disclosure
(financial reports and monitoring results being published as close as possible to the fiscal/election
exercise) is key to helping identify questionable financial ties and possible corruption in the party
funding system. GRECO encourages the authorities to keep the practical application of the
legislative provisions on transparency under close review in order to maximise the level of
information which can be acquired by the citizen in this sensitive domain.
50.
GRECO concludes that recommendation iii remains partly implemented.
Recommendation iv.
51.
GRECO recommended to take measures to enhance the system of internal audit of political
parties in order to ensure the independence of this type of control.
52.
GRECO noted in the RC-Report that very limited action had taken place to enhance the system
of internal audit of political parties. The Court of Audit had contacted political parties to encourage
them to set in place internal control mechanisms, but no indication was provided as to the effect
of such an initiative. GRECO assessed recommendation iv as not implemented.
53.
The authorities of Spain now report that Law 5/2012 requires political parties to subject their
accounts to audit and to submit the corresponding auditing report to the Court of Audit (Article 5).
Furthermore, the authorities refer to plans underway to draft a law on the control of the economic
activity of political parties which should subject the latter to tighter internal discipline and
accountability rules.
54.
GRECO welcomes the legislative amendments geared towards reinforcing the financial discipline
of political parties, in particular, by specifically requiring audits of their accounts. This goes in the
9
10. direction of GRECO’s considerations (as outlined in paragraph 77 of the Third Evaluation Round
Report) and could well serve to facilitate the oversight task of the Court of Audit further down the
line. That said, GRECO recalls that the law not only requires submission of the relevant audit
reports on party accounts to the Court of Audit, but also an obligation on political parties to put in
place internal control mechanisms. Therefore, it remains essential that the aforementioned
reporting obligation on the audits performed over political finances is coupled with a genuine
system to share information with the public on all other measures taken by political parties
themselves to strengthen internal control and increase accountability.
55.
Moreover, Law 5/2012 does not establish any penalty for failure to comply with the requirement of
political parties to develop a system of internal control. This was a loophole in former regulation
which GRECO also criticised. GRECO regrets that nothing has been done to address this
concern.
56.
Given the series of scandals that have emerged in recent years in connection with the irregular
financing of political activity and that have led to fierce public outcry, GRECO considers the
implementation of this recommendation as crucial to the credibility of the system and its
effectiveness in practice. GRECO welcomes the fact that some additional reflection on the matter
has been initiated and that further legislation is anticipated to tighten the rules concerning internal
discipline and accountability of political parties; GRECO urges the authorities to take prompt
action in this respect.
57.
GRECO concludes that recommendation iv has been partly implemented.
Recommendation v.
58.
GRECO recommended to increase the financial and personnel resources dedicated to the Court
of Audit so that it is better equipped to perform effectively its monitoring and enforcement tasks
concerning political financing, including by ensuring a more substantial supervision of political
parties’ financial reports.
59.
GRECO recalls that this recommendation was assessed as partly implemented since it
considered that more could be done to increase the resources of the Court of Audit devoted to
the monitoring of party finances. Furthermore, the authorities refer to plans underway to devote
additional resources to the Court of Audit for monitoring party finances, as well as to better
articulate its cooperation and information exchange with other authorities with related
competencies in this area (e.g. fiscal authorities, social security officials, the Office of Conflicts of
Interest, etc.)
60.
The authorities of Spain refer to new developments concerning the allocation of personnel in the
Court of Audit which has been increased by 150%: there are currently 36 financial analysts and 6
persons working to support tasks in relation to party funding oversight.
61.
GRECO welcomes the efforts made by the Spanish authorities, in the current context of
budgetary austerity, to deploy additional resources to the Court of Audit so that it can better cope
with its important monitoring and enforcement attributions concerning political financing. GRECO
trusts that the temporary allocation of personnel will be confirmed in the long run given the key
priority that the citizens in Spain attach to the issue of political corruption and the need to better
address it. GRECO is also trustful that the Court of Audit is adequately empowered, not only in
terms of staff resources, but also tools, to assure a substantial supervision of political parties’
10
11. financial reports, including through swift mechanisms to exchange data with other institutions
(e.g. tax authorities, police, etc.), as needed.
62.
GRECO concludes that recommendation v has been dealt with in a satisfactory manner.
Recommendation vi.
63.
GRECO recommended to clearly define infringements of political finance rules and to introduce
effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for these infringements, in particular, by
extending the range of penalties available and by enlarging the scope of the sanctioning
provisions to cover all persons/entities (including individual donors) upon which Organic
Law 8/2007 imposes obligations.
64.
GRECO acknowledged the improvements made to strengthen the sanctioning regime for
violations of campaign rules under Law 5/1985. That said, GRECO assessed this
recommendation as partly implemented and called for additional steps to extend the range of
penalties and enlarge the scope of the penalty provisions to cover all persons/entities subject to
obligations under Law 8/2007.
65.
The authorities of Spain indicate that Law 5/2012 further articulates the procedure under which
the Court of Audit may impose sanctions, including by putting in place due safeguards in the
process (e.g. hearing of infringer, right of appeal). The law refers back to the general
administrative sanctioning regime in this respect. In addition, the provisions quoted in the RCReport (paragraph 78) as regards infringements to campaign funding regulations apply.
66.
GRECO takes note of the information provided and the steps taken to regulate in detail
enforcement proceedings. However, GRECO can only recall the misgivings it raised in the Third
Evaluation Round Report as all of them remain pertinent under the reviewed legislative
framework: there are no sanctions on donors, the sanctions are exclusively financial in nature and
not all possible infringements are coupled with sanctions.
67.
GRECO concludes that recommendation vi remains partly implemented.
III.
CONCLUSIONS
68.
In view of the conclusions contained in the Third Round Compliance Report and in light of
the analysis contained in the present report, GRECO concludes that Spain has
implemented satisfactorily or dealt with in a satisfactory manner in total six of the fifteen
recommendations contained in the Third Round Evaluation Report. With respect to Theme I
– Incriminations, recommendations i, ii, vii, viii and ix have been implemented satisfactorily;
recommendations iii, iv, v and vi remain partly implemented. Regarding Theme II – Transparency
of Party Funding, recommendation v has been dealt with in a satisfactory manner;
recommendations i, ii, iii, iv and vi remain partly implemented.
69.
Concerning incriminations, following the adoption of the Third Round Evaluation Report, Spain
ratified the Criminal Law Convention on Corruption (ETS 173) and its Additional Protocol
(ETS 191). This was an important step forward which also led to several amendments in the
formulation of corruption offences in domestic legislation. At present, the criminalisation of bribery
and trading in influence in the Spanish Penal Code is largely in line with the Council of Europe
standards. The authorities are encouraged to pay further attention to the international dimension
11
12. of corruption, notably, with respect to bribery and trading in influence of foreign and international
officials, foreign jurors and arbitrators, and to the particular coverage of passive bribery in the
private sector.
70.
In so far as the transparency of political funding is concerned, Law 5/2012 introduces a series of
amendments aimed at improving transparency, oversight and enforcement in this domain. It
includes additional bans on the sources of funding to political parties and further regulates loans.
It also lays out certain publication requirements for political parties and related
associations/foundations. It is too early to assess whether the recent legislative changes
effectively result in improvements in an area which is acknowledged to constitute a major source
of citizens’ concern in Spain. In particular, it would be essential to ensure that political foundations
and associations are not used as a parallel avenue for funding routine and campaign activities of
political parties in spite of the applicable restrictions and thresholds set by law for the latter.
Moreover, steps must be taken by political parties themselves to put in place efficient
mechanisms for internal control and to improve the transparency of the financial operations
performed at local level. It is important that citizens are provided with meaningful information on
the identity of the donations made to political parties, their branches and related entities, to better
help identify questionable financial ties and possible corruption in the party funding system. The
Court of Audit continues to have a key role to play in performing substantial supervision of party
accounts and in making its findings available for public scrutiny in a timely manner; it must be
provided with sufficient resources and powers to do so. The sanctioning regime for irregular
financing of political parties needs to be strengthened significantly. It is crucial for the credibility of
the system that the law does not remain dead letter but that it is properly monitored and enforced;
GRECO urges the Spanish authorities to take all possible steps in this respect.
71.
In view of the fact that still nine out of fifteen recommendations concerning both themes are yet to
be implemented, GRECO in accordance with Rule 31, paragraph 9 of its Rules of Procedure
requests the Head of the delegation of Spain to submit additional information, namely information
regarding the implementation of recommendations iii, iv, v and vi (Theme I – Incriminations) and
recommendations i, ii, iii, iv and vi (Theme II – Transparency of Party Funding) by 31 March 2014.
72.
GRECO invites the authorities of Spain to authorise, as soon as possible, the publication of the
report, to translate the report into the national language and to make this translation public.
12