Improving EMRs   Problems with Current EMRs Thoughts on Future EMRs   April, 2009 Lyle Berkowitz, MD, FHIMSS Program Director, Szollosi Healthcare Innovation Program ( www.TheSHIPHome.org )  Email:  [email_address] Web:  www.DrLyle.com
 
Usability Problems The NRC Report (Jan, 2009) Summary: Built to resemble paper charts Overly focused on Compliance, not Care Too much clinician data entry and searching Problems with Data sharing and integration Transaction systems with decision support bolted on - rather than as thinking systems with transactions built in Computational Technology for Effective Health Care: Immediate Steps and Strategic Directions . Authors: Willam W. Stead and Herbert S. Lin, editors; Committee on Engaging the Computer Science Research Community in Health Care Informatics; National Research Council.  http:// books.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id =12572
Current vs. Future EMRs Future EMR Metaphor: iPhone, Web Graphical representation Information Visualization Interactive/Actionable View Workflow oriented Context is Critical One Click Documentation as byproduct User control Data separated from App Open API Current EMR Metaphor: Paper Word/Excel Information Overload Static View Task oriented Data and Fx Silos Too Many Clicks Documentation as end product Vendor control Tightly bound 3-Tier Closed system
What will the Future look like?
Short-Term: 0-5 years Compare: Traditional vs. Future Breaking up the 3-Tier Monopoly Examples Information Visualization Context Sensitive Screens Widgets
The Current 3-Tier Monopoly  of EMR Vendors “ Get those vendors to separate their data from their application .” – Dr. William Stead (Jan, 2009) Data Storage Application Processing User Interface
Separating The Data  from the  Applications The Data “Platform” Physician Workflow Tools Data Storage Application Processing User Interface Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface
Another way to look at it Multiple Care Settings Single Care Setting EHR EMR PWT EMR PWT PWT PWT
Potential Future for EMR Vendors Good Higher adoption More widgets to sell Bad They become commoditized to Data storage experts Users start consolidating
New Ways to Look at Information
Problem List: Current View
Problem List – Future View #1
Problem List – Future View #2
Problem List – Future View #3
A New Way to Look at Results
A New Way to Look at Results
Context-Sensitive Screens and Widgets
Problem Details
Problem Details
Med Refill Widget
Patient Name: Joe Kind DOB: 01-01-60 Medical Record #: 123456789 Allergies:  Penicillin (Rash) Active Med List Norvasc 10mg Lisinopril 20mg Zocor 20mg   Appointment Data Date of last visit:  1/17/09 Date of next visit: none   Notes Actions Contact patient to review  Repeat K in one week Increase cholesterol medication RTC in 6 weeks IM Cardiology More CHEM PANEL Creatinine: 2.2 Potassium 5.4 LFTs - WNL   Cholesterol Profile LDL 124 (Goal < 100) HDL 44 (Goal > 45) TG 122 (Goal < 150)   CBC Hb 14.1 (Normal range: 13-15; Pt Range 13.9-14.8) within normal range 0.3 (2%) below average of last 2 years Other:  WNL Cr K LDL HDL
Future: 5-15 years Transform the Computer From a machine that simply  responds to your actions To the best assistant you ever had
“ Patient-centered cognitive support” The authors said the “overarching, grand research challenge” of the computer science research community is developing “ patient-centered cognitive support .” Computer systems need to build virtual models of a patient’s status, models that depict and simulate a theory about interactions going on in the patient similar to those models going on in the head of a physician working unaided by a computer.   - NRC Report (Jan, 2009)
A robot that understands…
Current EMR Workflow   Patient and EMR wait for Physician Physician does all data review and input
Future EMR Workflow EMR gathers data, creates documentation and suggests a plan Physician reviews and edits EMR summary and plan
Potential Time Savings Physician then has more time to spend with patient for tough diagnostic analyses, education, etc…
This presentation was sponsored by… www.TheSHIPHome.org
SHIP Description Mission Use creative thinking and diverse technologies to produce a better healthcare experience for patients, physicians and others associated with their care.   Vision Develop, test, and use innovative solutions within the real world of Northwestern Memorial Physicians Group, and then spread these ideas and solutions outside our organization.
Thoughts on Innovation Innovation is a systemic process that draws insights and ideas from inter-disciplinary groups… in a  conscious, purposeful search for innovation opportunities . - Peter Drucker The oldest habit in the world for resisting change is to complain that unless the remedy to the disease should be universally applied, it should not be applied at all.  But you must start somewhere. -Winston Churchill Don’t tell me what you can’t do.   - Peter Szollosi

Improving EMRs 2009

  • 1.
    Improving EMRs Problems with Current EMRs Thoughts on Future EMRs April, 2009 Lyle Berkowitz, MD, FHIMSS Program Director, Szollosi Healthcare Innovation Program ( www.TheSHIPHome.org ) Email: [email_address] Web: www.DrLyle.com
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Usability Problems TheNRC Report (Jan, 2009) Summary: Built to resemble paper charts Overly focused on Compliance, not Care Too much clinician data entry and searching Problems with Data sharing and integration Transaction systems with decision support bolted on - rather than as thinking systems with transactions built in Computational Technology for Effective Health Care: Immediate Steps and Strategic Directions . Authors: Willam W. Stead and Herbert S. Lin, editors; Committee on Engaging the Computer Science Research Community in Health Care Informatics; National Research Council. http:// books.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id =12572
  • 4.
    Current vs. FutureEMRs Future EMR Metaphor: iPhone, Web Graphical representation Information Visualization Interactive/Actionable View Workflow oriented Context is Critical One Click Documentation as byproduct User control Data separated from App Open API Current EMR Metaphor: Paper Word/Excel Information Overload Static View Task oriented Data and Fx Silos Too Many Clicks Documentation as end product Vendor control Tightly bound 3-Tier Closed system
  • 5.
    What will theFuture look like?
  • 6.
    Short-Term: 0-5 yearsCompare: Traditional vs. Future Breaking up the 3-Tier Monopoly Examples Information Visualization Context Sensitive Screens Widgets
  • 7.
    The Current 3-TierMonopoly of EMR Vendors “ Get those vendors to separate their data from their application .” – Dr. William Stead (Jan, 2009) Data Storage Application Processing User Interface
  • 8.
    Separating The Data from the Applications The Data “Platform” Physician Workflow Tools Data Storage Application Processing User Interface Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing Application Processing User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface User Interface
  • 9.
    Another way tolook at it Multiple Care Settings Single Care Setting EHR EMR PWT EMR PWT PWT PWT
  • 10.
    Potential Future forEMR Vendors Good Higher adoption More widgets to sell Bad They become commoditized to Data storage experts Users start consolidating
  • 11.
    New Ways toLook at Information
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Problem List –Future View #1
  • 14.
    Problem List –Future View #2
  • 15.
    Problem List –Future View #3
  • 16.
    A New Wayto Look at Results
  • 17.
    A New Wayto Look at Results
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Patient Name: JoeKind DOB: 01-01-60 Medical Record #: 123456789 Allergies: Penicillin (Rash) Active Med List Norvasc 10mg Lisinopril 20mg Zocor 20mg   Appointment Data Date of last visit: 1/17/09 Date of next visit: none   Notes Actions Contact patient to review Repeat K in one week Increase cholesterol medication RTC in 6 weeks IM Cardiology More CHEM PANEL Creatinine: 2.2 Potassium 5.4 LFTs - WNL   Cholesterol Profile LDL 124 (Goal < 100) HDL 44 (Goal > 45) TG 122 (Goal < 150)   CBC Hb 14.1 (Normal range: 13-15; Pt Range 13.9-14.8) within normal range 0.3 (2%) below average of last 2 years Other: WNL Cr K LDL HDL
  • 23.
    Future: 5-15 yearsTransform the Computer From a machine that simply responds to your actions To the best assistant you ever had
  • 24.
    “ Patient-centered cognitivesupport” The authors said the “overarching, grand research challenge” of the computer science research community is developing “ patient-centered cognitive support .” Computer systems need to build virtual models of a patient’s status, models that depict and simulate a theory about interactions going on in the patient similar to those models going on in the head of a physician working unaided by a computer. - NRC Report (Jan, 2009)
  • 25.
    A robot thatunderstands…
  • 26.
    Current EMR Workflow Patient and EMR wait for Physician Physician does all data review and input
  • 27.
    Future EMR WorkflowEMR gathers data, creates documentation and suggests a plan Physician reviews and edits EMR summary and plan
  • 28.
    Potential Time SavingsPhysician then has more time to spend with patient for tough diagnostic analyses, education, etc…
  • 29.
    This presentation wassponsored by… www.TheSHIPHome.org
  • 30.
    SHIP Description MissionUse creative thinking and diverse technologies to produce a better healthcare experience for patients, physicians and others associated with their care. Vision Develop, test, and use innovative solutions within the real world of Northwestern Memorial Physicians Group, and then spread these ideas and solutions outside our organization.
  • 31.
    Thoughts on InnovationInnovation is a systemic process that draws insights and ideas from inter-disciplinary groups… in a conscious, purposeful search for innovation opportunities . - Peter Drucker The oldest habit in the world for resisting change is to complain that unless the remedy to the disease should be universally applied, it should not be applied at all. But you must start somewhere. -Winston Churchill Don’t tell me what you can’t do. - Peter Szollosi