SlideShare a Scribd company logo
THE GAME OF TIME: REFLECTING
VARIETIES OF SOVIET IN POST-
SOVIET NATION-BUILDING VIA
TEXTBOOKS’
COMPARISONS
Marharyta Fabrykant
Alla Marchenko
Nataliya Tregubova
41st World Congress
International Institute of Sociology
Uppsala, June 9-10, 2013
Outline
1. Methodological issues: a version of
mixed methods design in history
textbooks .
2. Comparative research design:
selection and ‘Reconstruction’ of
Cases
3. A research outcome: M.Gorbachev as
protagonist of textbook discourse(s) of
perestroika
Mixed Methods Design in Textbook
Research
Game theory:
quantitative modeling of
authors’ strategic
choices
+
Narrative analysis:
qualitative modeling of
the mode of storytelling
=
relating story to history
The Trick-or-Treat Game:
Post-Soviet Historian vs. the System
 Rule 1: There is no neutral outcome for a historian.
Reason: Little consensus on recent history.
 Rule 2: Trick - punishment for an undesirable story - is
unpredictable.
Reason: The system is in flux/”transition”.
 Rule 3: Treat - award for the desirable story – is crucial
for a historian.
Reason: lack of alternative sources of income.
 Rule 4: All outcomes for the system are neutral, unless a
critical number of historians cooperate.
Reason: the target audience of textbooks does not play
this game.
Modeling the Trick-or-treat Game
Historian
Attempting
a desirable
story
Diversificat
ion of
storylines
Trying to
enter the
system
System
Punish
ment
Loss of face
& sanctions /
---
Second
chance / ---
Entering
another
system / ---
Award Path-
dependence
& privileges /
---
Permit to
continue
working / ---
Dictating
the rules /
---
Resulting Textbooks Narrative
Complex and multilinear (diversification).
Different interpretations of the same
events, both on purpose and unintended.
Actors portrayed as strategic game
players competing with each other and the
initial conditions, hence belief in rationality
results in conspirology, as the main mode
of narration.
Comparative Research Design:
Qualitative vs Quantitative Strategy
Qualitative (case-
oriented) strategy

Quantitative
(variable-oriented)
strategy

Problematization
Preliminary selection of
cases
Case studies / definition
of criteria for
comparison /
'reconstruction' of cases
Conclusions
Formulation of research
question
Theory
Hypothesis (variables
as criteria for
comparison)
Hypothesis’ test for
cases compared
Conclusions
Sampling
Comparative Research Design:
Qualitative Strategy
 Initial problematization:
 How is the perestroika period
represented in post-Soviet textbooks?
 Ultimate research question:
 How is the problem of nation-building
after the SU collapse being solved through
textbooks’ representations of perestroika
period in post-Soviet space?
Comparative Research Design:
Qualitative Strategy
Preliminary cases:
 Belarus, Russia, Ukraine as the most
similar cases (due to socio-historical
context):
Resulting cases:
 Belarus, Russia, Ukraine (states) +
Chechnya and Tatarstan (Russian regions)
with pretty different representations of
perestroika
Conclusions: A Textbook Case?
 Preliminary generalizations:

?
Case
USSR
Russia /
RSFSR
The discursive logic is
embedded in answers
to the primary
questions:
 What is the status of the
case “whose” history is
narrated?
 What are the relations
between the case,
USSR and Russia/
RSFSR?
??
?
Conclusions: A Textbook Case?
Limits and limitations:
 The focus on case studies did not allow
to reveal the typical case of post-Soviet
nation-building
Prospectives:
 These results demand new
comparisons with a new principle of case
selection (not the most similar but the most
different) to look for patterns in the
seeming diversity
Gorbachev as a protagonist of
perestroika: mean score of personalities’
mentioning
Gorbachev and Game Theory
Separate plays of Gorbachev’s appearance,
activities and disappearance with perestroika
final.
Reconstructed rather as a symbol than a
person.
Shown as a front of mostly anonymous “team”,
closely connected to external meanings (e.g.
reconstructed meanings of the USSR decline).
Ambivalent comparisons (e.g. to old system,
democratic forces, Yeltsin, Kerensky)
Mikhail Gorbachev vs
general depersonalization
control vs uncontrol
over situation
deeds within the USSR vs
external activities
regressive
vs
progressive
self-oriented vs
others-oriented
collective vs
individual actor
“Various cases – different faces”
Ukraine’s meanings:
 victim of the system, most sacralized,
though populist
Belarus’ meanings:
 overall tragicomism, “transitive” actor
Russia’s meanings:
 as embodiment of the USSR - in most
part of Russia,
 formal figure - in Tatarstan and Chechnya.
Prospectives for historical textbook
analysis in Sociology
Suitable for comparative research aimed to
reveal the official schemes of History for study of
nation-building processes.
Demanding researcher being embedded in
social context of textbook creation, reproduction
and distribution as well as in historical context.
Relevant for trying different versions of content
analysis and discourse analysis to deconstruct
the ideological engagement of narration.
Thank you for your attention!

More Related Content

Similar to The Game of Time: Reflecting Varieties of Soviet in Post-Soviet Nation-building via Textbooks’ Comparisons

A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES A MEANS TO AN END
A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES  A MEANS TO AN ENDA STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES  A MEANS TO AN END
A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES A MEANS TO AN END
Andrea Erdman
 
Literary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notesLiterary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notes
missustaris
 
Literary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notesLiterary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notes
missustaris
 
Feministic Perspective in God of small things
Feministic Perspective in God of small thingsFeministic Perspective in God of small things
Feministic Perspective in God of small things
HaiderAli989
 
New_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptx
New_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptxNew_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptx
New_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptx
IdonKnow5
 
II New Historicism
II New HistoricismII New Historicism
II New Historicism
pvillacanas
 
Contemporary Literary Theory _ Study Material
Contemporary Literary Theory _ Study MaterialContemporary Literary Theory _ Study Material
Contemporary Literary Theory _ Study Material
Dr. Aareena Nazneen
 
Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener...
 Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener... Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener...
Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener...
English Literature and Language Review ELLR
 
English 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docx
English 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docxEnglish 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docx
English 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docx
YASHU40
 
Critical lenses final posters_claxton
Critical lenses final posters_claxtonCritical lenses final posters_claxton
Critical lenses final posters_claxton
mson5676
 
New Historicism
New HistoricismNew Historicism
New Historicism
Maitri Munjpara
 
Assignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docx
Assignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docxAssignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docx
Assignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docx
simba35
 
Saoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discovery
Saoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discoverySaoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discovery
Saoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discovery
Saoni Banerjee
 
Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO 6471
Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO  6471Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO  6471
Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO 6471
Zahid Mehmood
 
To Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist University
To Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist UniversityTo Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist University
To Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist University
Amanda Love
 
Literary Theory: Crash Course
Literary Theory: Crash CourseLiterary Theory: Crash Course
Literary Theory: Crash Course
jdarnell
 
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docxDiscuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
sdfghj21
 
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docxDiscuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
bkbk37
 
Take the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docx
Take the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docxTake the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docx
Take the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docx
briankimberly26463
 
Autobiographical Narrative
Autobiographical NarrativeAutobiographical Narrative
Autobiographical Narrative
Lori Moore
 

Similar to The Game of Time: Reflecting Varieties of Soviet in Post-Soviet Nation-building via Textbooks’ Comparisons (20)

A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES A MEANS TO AN END
A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES  A MEANS TO AN ENDA STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES  A MEANS TO AN END
A STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF FOLKTALES A MEANS TO AN END
 
Literary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notesLiterary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notes
 
Literary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notesLiterary theory 101 with notes
Literary theory 101 with notes
 
Feministic Perspective in God of small things
Feministic Perspective in God of small thingsFeministic Perspective in God of small things
Feministic Perspective in God of small things
 
New_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptx
New_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptxNew_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptx
New_Historicism_ background_ criticism_pptx.pptx
 
II New Historicism
II New HistoricismII New Historicism
II New Historicism
 
Contemporary Literary Theory _ Study Material
Contemporary Literary Theory _ Study MaterialContemporary Literary Theory _ Study Material
Contemporary Literary Theory _ Study Material
 
Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener...
 Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener... Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener...
Elements of Dystopian Science Fiction in David Mitchell's Cloud Atlas: Gener...
 
English 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docx
English 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docxEnglish 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docx
English 205Masterworks of English LiteratureHANDOUTSCritica.docx
 
Critical lenses final posters_claxton
Critical lenses final posters_claxtonCritical lenses final posters_claxton
Critical lenses final posters_claxton
 
New Historicism
New HistoricismNew Historicism
New Historicism
 
Assignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docx
Assignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docxAssignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docx
Assignment InstructionsWrite a 500-750 word essay on one of the fo.docx
 
Saoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discovery
Saoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discoverySaoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discovery
Saoni banerjee joint experience in crisis~a self discovery
 
Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO 6471
Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO  6471Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO  6471
Unit 9, ENGLISH IV CODE NO 6471
 
To Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist University
To Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist UniversityTo Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist University
To Kill A Mockingbird Racism Essay. Washington Adventist University
 
Literary Theory: Crash Course
Literary Theory: Crash CourseLiterary Theory: Crash Course
Literary Theory: Crash Course
 
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docxDiscuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
 
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docxDiscuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
Discuss what forces Sundiata and the Hero Twins Hunahpu and.docx
 
Take the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docx
Take the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docxTake the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docx
Take the quiz to discover what poem you have been assigned to discus.docx
 
Autobiographical Narrative
Autobiographical NarrativeAutobiographical Narrative
Autobiographical Narrative
 

More from comparsociology

Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...
Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...
Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...
comparsociology
 
Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...
Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...
Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...
comparsociology
 
An inquiry into comparative sociology
An inquiry into comparative sociologyAn inquiry into comparative sociology
An inquiry into comparative sociology
comparsociology
 
Labor Migrants’ Discontent
Labor Migrants’ DiscontentLabor Migrants’ Discontent
Labor Migrants’ Discontent
comparsociology
 
Comparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching Discipline
Comparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching DisciplineComparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching Discipline
Comparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching Discipline
comparsociology
 
Качественный сравнительный анализ
Качественный сравнительный анализКачественный сравнительный анализ
Качественный сравнительный анализ
comparsociology
 
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...
comparsociology
 
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in ActionSocial Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action
comparsociology
 
Неравенство в городе Сестрорецк
Неравенство в городе СестрорецкНеравенство в городе Сестрорецк
Неравенство в городе Сестрорецкcomparsociology
 
Rаково быть мигрантом
Rаково быть мигрантомRаково быть мигрантом
Rаково быть мигрантомcomparsociology
 

More from comparsociology (11)

Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...
Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...
Взаимоотношения трудовых мигрантов и работодателя: анализ результатов полевых...
 
Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...
Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...
Транснационализм и современная трудовая миграция: проблемы теории и методолог...
 
An inquiry into comparative sociology
An inquiry into comparative sociologyAn inquiry into comparative sociology
An inquiry into comparative sociology
 
Labor Migrants’ Discontent
Labor Migrants’ DiscontentLabor Migrants’ Discontent
Labor Migrants’ Discontent
 
Comparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching Discipline
Comparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching DisciplineComparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching Discipline
Comparative Sociology as an Inquiry and Teaching Discipline
 
Качественный сравнительный анализ
Качественный сравнительный анализКачественный сравнительный анализ
Качественный сравнительный анализ
 
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action: So...
 
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in ActionSocial Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action
Social Exclusion and Social Inclusion of Transnational Migrants in Action
 
презентация
презентацияпрезентация
презентация
 
Неравенство в городе Сестрорецк
Неравенство в городе СестрорецкНеравенство в городе Сестрорецк
Неравенство в городе Сестрорецк
 
Rаково быть мигрантом
Rаково быть мигрантомRаково быть мигрантом
Rаково быть мигрантом
 

Recently uploaded

18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
FIRST INDIA
 
ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...
ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...
ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...
SABC News
 
Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"
Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"
Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"
ScyllaDB
 
Organisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhn
Organisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhnOrganisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhn
Organisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhn
bhavenpr
 
Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024
Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024
Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024
Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, Oxford University
 
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdfMarkakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Abraham Lebeza
 
Shark Tank Jargon | Operational Profitability
Shark Tank Jargon | Operational ProfitabilityShark Tank Jargon | Operational Profitability
Shark Tank Jargon | Operational Profitability
TheUnitedIndian
 
16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
FIRST INDIA
 
在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样
在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样
在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样
ckn2izdm
 
The Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdf
The Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdfThe Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdf
The Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdf
blueshagoo1
 
A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022
A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022
A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022
dynamo777
 
On the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | News
On the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | NewsOn the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | News
On the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | News
Harsh Kumar
 
projet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdf
projet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdfprojet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdf
projet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdf
EdouardHusson
 
15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
FIRST INDIA
 
Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75
Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75
Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75
LUMINATIVE MEDIA/PROJECT COUNSEL MEDIA GROUP
 
#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...
#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm  Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm  Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...
#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...
rittaajmal71
 
17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
FIRST INDIA
 
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdf
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdfThe Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdf
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdf
ECSPE - Saving the Persecuted and Enslaved
 
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic CountriesThe Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries
ECSPE - Saving the Persecuted and Enslaved
 
लालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHY
लालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHYलालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHY
लालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHY
VoterMood
 

Recently uploaded (20)

18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
18062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...
ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...
ACSA confirms operational readiness ahead the arrival of Heads of State at OR...
 
Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"
Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"
Why We Chose ScyllaDB over DynamoDB for "User Watch Status"
 
Organisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhn
Organisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhnOrganisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhn
Organisations.pdf k[poikdip-jhhohuhejhnjhn
 
Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024
Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024
Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2024
 
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdfMarkakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
 
Shark Tank Jargon | Operational Profitability
Shark Tank Jargon | Operational ProfitabilityShark Tank Jargon | Operational Profitability
Shark Tank Jargon | Operational Profitability
 
16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样
在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样
在线办理(latrobe毕业证书)拉筹伯大学毕业证Offer一模一样
 
The Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdf
The Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdfThe Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdf
The Impact of Imperial Mode of Living on Migration.pdf
 
A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022
A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022
A draft Ukraine-Russia treaty from April 2022
 
On the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | News
On the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | NewsOn the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | News
On the Wrong Track | Recent Increasing Train Accidents in India | News
 
projet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdf
projet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdfprojet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdf
projet de traité négocié à Istanbul (anglais).pdf
 
15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
15062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75
Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75
Howard Fineman, Veteran Political Journalist and TV Pundit, Dies at 75
 
#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...
#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm  Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm  Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...
#WenguiGuo#WashingtonFarm Guo Wengui Wolf son ambition exposed to open a far...
 
17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
17062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdf
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdfThe Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdf
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries (1).pdf
 
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic CountriesThe Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries
The Rise of Christian Persecution In Islamic Countries
 
लालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHY
लालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHYलालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHY
लालू यादव की जीवनी LALU PRASAD YADAV BIOGRAPHY
 

The Game of Time: Reflecting Varieties of Soviet in Post-Soviet Nation-building via Textbooks’ Comparisons

  • 1. THE GAME OF TIME: REFLECTING VARIETIES OF SOVIET IN POST- SOVIET NATION-BUILDING VIA TEXTBOOKS’ COMPARISONS Marharyta Fabrykant Alla Marchenko Nataliya Tregubova 41st World Congress International Institute of Sociology Uppsala, June 9-10, 2013
  • 2. Outline 1. Methodological issues: a version of mixed methods design in history textbooks . 2. Comparative research design: selection and ‘Reconstruction’ of Cases 3. A research outcome: M.Gorbachev as protagonist of textbook discourse(s) of perestroika
  • 3. Mixed Methods Design in Textbook Research Game theory: quantitative modeling of authors’ strategic choices + Narrative analysis: qualitative modeling of the mode of storytelling = relating story to history
  • 4. The Trick-or-Treat Game: Post-Soviet Historian vs. the System  Rule 1: There is no neutral outcome for a historian. Reason: Little consensus on recent history.  Rule 2: Trick - punishment for an undesirable story - is unpredictable. Reason: The system is in flux/”transition”.  Rule 3: Treat - award for the desirable story – is crucial for a historian. Reason: lack of alternative sources of income.  Rule 4: All outcomes for the system are neutral, unless a critical number of historians cooperate. Reason: the target audience of textbooks does not play this game.
  • 5. Modeling the Trick-or-treat Game Historian Attempting a desirable story Diversificat ion of storylines Trying to enter the system System Punish ment Loss of face & sanctions / --- Second chance / --- Entering another system / --- Award Path- dependence & privileges / --- Permit to continue working / --- Dictating the rules / ---
  • 6. Resulting Textbooks Narrative Complex and multilinear (diversification). Different interpretations of the same events, both on purpose and unintended. Actors portrayed as strategic game players competing with each other and the initial conditions, hence belief in rationality results in conspirology, as the main mode of narration.
  • 7. Comparative Research Design: Qualitative vs Quantitative Strategy Qualitative (case- oriented) strategy  Quantitative (variable-oriented) strategy  Problematization Preliminary selection of cases Case studies / definition of criteria for comparison / 'reconstruction' of cases Conclusions Formulation of research question Theory Hypothesis (variables as criteria for comparison) Hypothesis’ test for cases compared Conclusions Sampling
  • 8. Comparative Research Design: Qualitative Strategy  Initial problematization:  How is the perestroika period represented in post-Soviet textbooks?  Ultimate research question:  How is the problem of nation-building after the SU collapse being solved through textbooks’ representations of perestroika period in post-Soviet space?
  • 9. Comparative Research Design: Qualitative Strategy Preliminary cases:  Belarus, Russia, Ukraine as the most similar cases (due to socio-historical context): Resulting cases:  Belarus, Russia, Ukraine (states) + Chechnya and Tatarstan (Russian regions) with pretty different representations of perestroika
  • 10. Conclusions: A Textbook Case?  Preliminary generalizations:  ? Case USSR Russia / RSFSR The discursive logic is embedded in answers to the primary questions:  What is the status of the case “whose” history is narrated?  What are the relations between the case, USSR and Russia/ RSFSR? ?? ?
  • 11. Conclusions: A Textbook Case? Limits and limitations:  The focus on case studies did not allow to reveal the typical case of post-Soviet nation-building Prospectives:  These results demand new comparisons with a new principle of case selection (not the most similar but the most different) to look for patterns in the seeming diversity
  • 12. Gorbachev as a protagonist of perestroika: mean score of personalities’ mentioning
  • 13. Gorbachev and Game Theory Separate plays of Gorbachev’s appearance, activities and disappearance with perestroika final. Reconstructed rather as a symbol than a person. Shown as a front of mostly anonymous “team”, closely connected to external meanings (e.g. reconstructed meanings of the USSR decline). Ambivalent comparisons (e.g. to old system, democratic forces, Yeltsin, Kerensky)
  • 14. Mikhail Gorbachev vs general depersonalization control vs uncontrol over situation deeds within the USSR vs external activities regressive vs progressive self-oriented vs others-oriented collective vs individual actor
  • 15. “Various cases – different faces” Ukraine’s meanings:  victim of the system, most sacralized, though populist Belarus’ meanings:  overall tragicomism, “transitive” actor Russia’s meanings:  as embodiment of the USSR - in most part of Russia,  formal figure - in Tatarstan and Chechnya.
  • 16. Prospectives for historical textbook analysis in Sociology Suitable for comparative research aimed to reveal the official schemes of History for study of nation-building processes. Demanding researcher being embedded in social context of textbook creation, reproduction and distribution as well as in historical context. Relevant for trying different versions of content analysis and discourse analysis to deconstruct the ideological engagement of narration.
  • 17. Thank you for your attention!

Editor's Notes

  1. Quantity of mentioning (Ukraine, Belarus, Russia)
  2. , compliant to meanings transformation (close to C.Schmitt’s concept of “enemy-friend”).
  3. Concentrating upon each issue – though, fifferently shown or not shown at all depending on perestroika stage reconstruction Picture showing the absence of Gorbachev’s external vision as a “dove of peace” with the Nobel prize winning
  4. Symbolic meaning of Gorbachev in three cases, each exploits it along with the discourses found in the textbooks of three countries. Only a few mentioning of external context in Ukraine (role of disarmament). Absence of external context - where is the Noble prize in the textbooks?
  5. Non-Western material