1. Hiring Outside Counsel
ABA New Partners and In-House Counsel Conference
March 2, 2012
Steven H. Shapiro
Pircher, Nichols & Meeks
sshapiro@pircher.com
2. Background of Steven H. Shapiro
• In-House
– Deputy General Counsel - FMC / FMC Technologies
– General Counsel of:
• First Midwest Bancorp
• eLoyalty Corporation
• Cole Taylor Bank
• Private practice
– Pircher, Nichols & Meeks (currently)
– Before being in-house, 12 years of private
practice in Chicago
3. WHY YOU HIRE OUTSIDE
COUNSEL
• Expertise you need
– Special cases - bet the company & white
collar matters
• Extra manpower
• Industry / Broader expertise
• Provide “Backstop”
• Other considerations
– Diversity
4. WHY OTHERS MAY HIRE
OUTSIDE COUNSEL
• Relationships with executives or Board
members
• Long-term relationship with company
– Legal
– Business
• Others to backstop you
5. Value versus Cost
• Which do you care about?
– Think of personal purchases
• Price combined with effectiveness
– Lowest price better?
– How evaluate effectiveness?
• Pricing (and acting) to get value
6. What Should Companies Do To
Manage Costs?
• Get organized
– Involve lawyers earlier
– Decide what care about
• Reduce points of contact
• Avoid over-insurance
• Eliminate company silos
7. Calculating Savings
• Why do it?
– Personal justification in a business world
– Recurring cycle of in-house hiring
• How do it?
– Knowledgeable consumer
– Lower on rates
– What you do that need not be farmed out
– Speed (less time)
– Responsiveness
8. Hourly Rates versus AFA: How Big
of a Deal?
• Is how you are charged that important?
• What’s really going on?
• How well do the alternatives work?
– Methodology?
• Is the hourly rate really “dead”?
9. Engagement Letters
• What client gets out of it?
• Frequent terms
– Scope
– Fees / Rates / Costs
– Staffing / Equipment
– Termination of Services / Files
– Conflicts
– Independent Counsel
– Arbitration Provisions
10. Billing Guidelines
• What contain?
– Rates / Expenses – Engagement of
– Budgets Third Parties
– Confidentiality – Third Party
– Communications Technology
– Form of Bills – Research
– Staffing – Non-Billing Items
• Enforcement
11. Conflict Issues
• Why companies should care?
– Representing your interest
– Relationship management
• Why law firms care?
– Liability issues
• Waivers
– Who reviews and signs?
– What it should say and not say