Baseball and softball officials sometimes accept multiple game assignments or assigner schedule these tournament games over a long weekend. Heat stress plays a critical toll depending on environmental conditions throughout the day. The outcome can affect physical and mental performance of every pitch or thrown ball. The model provides a risk assessment during the summer months, when heat stress is critical. By calculating the total point value using an Excel spreadsheet, the information can determine if additional staff is needed to properly officiate these games and/or whether an official should accept multiple game assignments during adverse weather conditions. The use of this tool will provide insight before scheduling or accepting game assignments. It will also insist that everyone has a good understanding of heat stress outcomes and defining a proper work-rest regimen for adequate recovery.
Italy vs Albania Tickets: Italy's Quest for Euro Cup Germany History, Defendi...
Heat Stress Risk Assessment for Baseball and Softball Assigners
1. Heat Stress Risk Assessment Model
for Baseball and Softball Assignors
1
Presented by:
Bernard L. Fontaine, Jr., CIH, CSP, FAIHA
The Windsor Consulting Group, Inc.
3. Heat-related Risk for Game Assigners
3
Officials assigned multiple game
assignments during the summer months
(tournaments on holiday weekends)
Assigners fail evaluate weather when
assigning plate and field assignments
Officials are under significant duress
working in hot and humid conditions
Model evaluates heat stress index
before scheduling umpires
Model designed to prevent heat illness
4. Heat-related Risk for Officials
4
Model determines the total number of
game assignments during the summer
months
Applies to only healthy officials without
a medical or psychological condition
exacerbated by heat stress
Consider other confounding factors like
individual age, travel distance, gender,
nutrition, physical and mental condition
Officials must understand heat stress
signs and symptoms of exposure
5. Heat-related Risk for Officials
5
Model constructed for assigners to use
when scheduling officials
Excel spreadsheet based on hypothesis
and heat-related illness charts
Use only for multiple game assignments
on one or more consecutive days
Establish a work-rest regimen with time
or days off before reassigning more
games
Schedule games early and late during
the day during peak summer season
8. Color Code and Risk Analysis
8
Very low
0- 5
Low risk
5- 10
Moderate
10- 15
High risk
15- 20
Very high
20- 25
9. Example of Heat Stress for Plate Umpires
9
1-game 2-games 3-games
10. Example of Excel Spreadsheet Calculation
10
Games =
6 value
0 Sum 0
Games =
5 value
0 Sum 0
Games =
4 value
3 Sum 12
Games =
3 value
2 Sum 6
Games =
2 value
0 Sum 0
Games =
1 value
1 Sum 1
Total 19
Color codes:
Risk analysis
Very low 0- 5
Scheduling Calculation
Low risk 5- 10
Moderate 10- 15
High risk 15- 20
Very high 20- 25
11. Recommended Work-Rest Schedule
11
One Day Assignment
Risk 0-5 – No time off
Risk 5-10 – 12-hour rest
Risk 10-15 – 1 day rest
Risk 15-20 – 1 day rest
Risk 20-25 - 2 days rest
Two Day Assignment
Risk 0-5 – No time off
Risk 5-10 – 12-hour rest
Risk 10-15 – 1 day rest
Risk 15-20 – 2 day rest
Risk 20-25 - 3 days rest
Three Day Assignment
Risk 0-5 – 12-hour rest
Risk 5-10 – 1 day rest
Risk 10-15 – 2 day rest
Risk 15-20 – 3 day rest
Risk 20-25 - 4 days rest
12. Model Use for All Outdoor Sports
Email: windsgroup@aol.com for copy of the Excel spreadsheet
Model can be used for assignors of other sports like lacrosse,
soccer, football, rugby, etc. played during the summer months
Use for seasonal variations and climates across the USA
Use heat stress monitors to evaluate environmental conditions
Use weather forecasting websites to get air temperature and
relative humidity information hourly
http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/heat-index-heat-category/id370913314?mt=8
http://www.nws.noaa.gov/os/heat/index.shtml
12
13. Risk Prevention of Heat-related Illness
13
Questions
Thank you for your participation in the course. We hope that baseball and softball
assigners planning for tournaments and officials accepting multiple game assignments
understand the hazard, risk, and methods to help prevent heat-related illness during the
summer months. Please have a safe and enjoyable baseball and/or softball season this
year and keep yourself and crew safe. This information used correctly could save an
official’s life or prevent serious heat-related illness from occurring.
Editor's Notes
Baseball is our national pastime. For many officials, it’s an opportunity to share their expertise and officiate games for teams seeking to compete in tournaments throughout the summer months.
However, assigners fail to consider heat-related illness when stacking the schedule with game assignments. We are aware that some baseball and softball officials can officiate 11 or more games in a two day period (e.g., Saturday and Sunday). Sometimes the scheduling is extended beyond this timeframe into holidays. Baseball and softball officials also have a responsibility when accepting these extended work assignments. If the level of effort is beyond the normal work capacity; these assignments should not be accepted by the official. Trying to extend your capability of officiating more games than usual can put people health and lives at risk.
Working these many games puts officials at risk of heat-related illness during the summer months. Elevated air temperatures in combination with elevated relative humidity while wearing protective clothing and equipment can put significant strain on the body. Hydration, nutrition, and short rest periods are not enough to offset the effects of heat-related illness.
This presentation is designed to consider the environmental factors that could place officials’ health in jeopardy or the ability to cognitively officiate the game correctly. Too often officials are counting the number of outs to finish the game rather than being ready for what might happen on the field. Officials need to be ready to make the call on each pitch or thrown ball.
In 2015, a presentation was made regarding the health effects associated with heat-stress for baseball and softball officials. Nearly 3,300 people reviewed this information and thought it was help to protect themselves. Proper precautions are needed both on- and off-the-field. Without carefully understanding the hazard of heat stress and the associated risks; fellow officials can succumb to heat-related illness no matter their physical conditioning or age. Hence, the signs and symptoms of heat stress will not be discussed herein but they should be reviewed and understood.
There is no scientific evidence collected on the heat-stress effect of officials. While this is a certainty of the risk, it doesn't rank high enough for graduate students or other scientists to accurately study.
As a practicing board certified occupational health and safety professional and fellow umpire,; it is was important to construct a model for assignors to follow when scheduling games for tournaments.
The following presentation is designed to protect baseball and softball umpires accepting multiple assignments and for assigners to consider when assigning these games during the summer.
Most assignors and fellow officials fail to consider the environmental conditions when assigning or accepting multiple game assignments.
When officials are under such duress, they cannot officiate the game properly as intended. They are not ready for the next pitch or thrown ball. This is unfair to the teams, coaches, spectators, and other stakeholders. The outcome of the game could be vastly different by making the wrong call or missing an opportunity to make the right call.
Both physical capacity and cognitive skills are affected by heat stress. As an official continues to officiate more games during the same day or subsequent days; the heat-related effects take an unwanted toll. Only those watching the official can tell when the official is exhausted or worse. This presentation is designed to help reduce the risk and improve official performance.
By creating a model using an Excel spreadsheet, the risk of heat stress can be evaluated over multiple game assignments based on ambient weather conditions throughout the day. The model is easy to use with forecasting information provided by various reputable sources of weather information.
If the model provides several recommendations for time off or days away from officiating other games, baseball and softball officials can reduce their risk of heat-related illness. While the model has not be validated, it can be a useful tool.
This is a simple model to determine the total number of game assignments within any particular day. It gives assignors and officials a quick indication of the risk for heat-related illness.
It is important to understand that the model only applies to healthy individuals. Anyone who is taking medication, suffering from any medical or psychiatric condition that could be exacerbated by the summer heat is not to be considered herein. If an official decides to accept multiple game assignments without consulting their physician does so at their own peril.
Both assignors and officials need to be real when considering their age, travel to- and from the game, gender, nutrition, physical and mental health. If an official is injured or ill from other outside influence, this information should be considered before returning to a full game schedule.
Without a doubt, officials and assignors must understand the signs and symptoms of heat-related illness from heat rash to stroke. Depending on circumstances, officials could go from exhaustion to stroke in a matter of minutes. This information is not to be taken lightly.
The model for determining heat risk index was constructed on a Excel spreadsheet. It’s very easy to use. Putting the point values into a simple calculation can determine the level of risk for assigned individual. Assigners can use this tool when scheduling games and officials can use it before accepting the game assignments.
The information used in developing this model used vetted sources of information that didn’t consider the level of protective clothing and equipment worn (Co) by plate umpires. Assignors are urged to consider scheduling plate and field assignments in succession to reduce the risk. Officials are urged to communicate with their partners on plate and field assignments.
Whenever possible, all stakeholders should schedule games early or late in the day. Using a combination of early/late schedules in combination with mid-day schedules will help reduce the risk and complete the assigned schedule of games. The risk is lower for both the officials and players alike.
Coaches and league officials should be consulted on this initiative so that everyone can enjoy the game in a competitive spirit. There is nothing worse than pressing officials to achieve an unreasonable number of games assignments because of scheduling difficulties.
Water and electrolyte beverages should be made available at no cost to officials by the teams during mid-day assignments. This is done at some upper level parks but not often enough to assist with the process of heat stress prevention. The minimal cost most definitely outweighs the risk and the outcome of the game.
The following is a matrix for plate umpires. As you can see, air temperature along the x-axis and relative humidity along the x-axis. Wind speed could not be used in this two dimensional model. Inserting this information would have increased the complexity of understanding the business value of the model.
Wind can be used as a tool to reduce the heat around the head by temporarily removing the baseball cap during innings and between games. While there is a difference between baseball and softball officials actual risk, this information is not considered in this model. There is an overall assumption that both types of officials experience approximately the same level of risk.
How do we use this model? Using the anticipated forecasting information in your area of the US and scheduling game time; the assignor can select the appropriate point value. The point value is inserted into the Excel spreadsheet automatically calculates the level of risk and suggests the appropriate work-rest regimen for officials doing multiple game assignments.
This model can be used for each game assignment throughout the day. The number of games is inserted into the table and the total risk is calculated for that official.
Whenever the risk become unacceptable, alternative arrangements should be considered to prevent heat-related illness. Such alternative arrangements might be splitting the day with different officials or rescheduling certain officials to do early and late day game assignments. It is important to be considerate to all officials because some officials only want to work the easy game assignments. This places a strain on the assignors as well as the other officials having to do all of the mid-day assignments.
There is a upper limit of unacceptable risk when no baseball or softball games should be played during the day. In essence, the level of relative humidity is too high for any heat loss due to convection. The internal sweating mechanism will stop and the risk of heat stroke become very real. This evidence is also true for the players.
The heat stress index for field umpires is different from the plate umpire. The field umpire doesn’t have to wear the protective equipment of the plate umpire so the level of risk changes slightly.
As in the previous slide, the calculation can be made similarly to determine the level of heat-related illness. Assignors should use this chart in making a more realistic determination before making their final determination. Entering the number of games for each point value into the table will calculate the level of risk.
For example, if an assignor wants an official to work the plate for two games early in the day, two games in the field mid-day, and a final plate appearance in the early evening; both risk charts must be used. The total point evaluation should be additive as part of the final risk assessment.
The higher the total point value for the day’s game assignments requires additional time off or days away for rest. This consideration should be evaluated with assigning games in the summer.
The model shows five level of risk
Total point values 0-5 are considered a very low risk
Total point values 5-10 are considered a low risk
Total point values 10-15 are considered a moderate risk
Total point values 15-20 are considered a high risk
Total point values 20-25 are considered a very high risk.
Anything above 25 total points is an unacceptable risk for anyone
Here is how to use the model for plate umpire scheduling.
Select the approximate relative humidity for the games. In this case, a 50% RH value will be used in this example.
Officials and assigners can look at websites and weather information to view the anticipated air temperature throughout the day.
By selecting the appropriate point value for the number of games throughout the day, we can calculate the level of risk.
In this example, the assigner has scheduled 1-game with a point value of 1; two games with a point value of 3; and three games with a point value of 4.
Let’s calculate the additive value for all six game assignments in the next slide.
As you can see, the total point value for all six game assignments is 19. This means the official is a high risk of heat-related illness. Only selected officials with past experience working ins such conditions should be selected for these game assignments. Assigning the plate and field positions should be considered carefully to help further reduce the risk of exposure.
If the total point value is too high, the assignor may consider scaling back some higher risk games to lower the level of risk. These other game assignments could be performed by other officials with the capacity to deal with high temperature and relative humidity conditions.
As part of any heat stress protocol, a work-rest regimen should be considered for officials with variable levels of risk. While this information is not yet been validated, these are only suggestions provided by the author to protect fellow umpires from exacerbating medical and psychological conditions that would affect performance. Additional rest should be taken by the official, it recovery is not complete or there is a sense of being fatigued physically or mentally.
Remember it’s not about just calling strikes and outs; it’s about officiating the game correctly with a clear mindset. Over burdening officials or over eager official can lead to complaints by coaches, players, and spectators. People are always watching the sport, especially today with the use of electronic recording media. It can be easy to determine if an official is on or off-their game.
With multiple game assignments, heat stress can quickly lower both the cognitive and physical capacity to make a call or play.
As we conclude this presentation, a copy of the Excel spreadsheet can be obtained by email: windsgroup@aol.com. The Windsor Consulting Group, Inc. developed this information. Our staff of seasoned board certified Industrial Hygienists (CIHs) and board certified Safety Professionals (CSPs) provide helpful information and advice to customers seeking to protect their most valued asset: their employees, profits, and planet. For more information about our occupational and environmental health and safety services, please visit: http://windsgroup.wixsite.com/windsconsultingroup
This model can be adapted for other summer outdoor sports where officials and their assignors can learn from the evaluation process. Such sports include, but not limited to, lacrosse, football, soccer, rugby, etc. Some officials may not wear protective equipment but they may be running or sprinting throughout the contest. The physical exertion must be considered in making a proper heat stress determination.
Ambient heat stress monitors also can be rented and used to evaluate summertime weather conditions besides using the available websites. Determining the outdoor wet globe bulb temperature (WBGT outdoors) may be useful in remote locations of the US or where current weather information may be unavailable. Assumptions without validated information may prove useless and increase the risk of physical and mental harm to officials.
Finally, we thank everyone associated with this project. It our goal to assist baseball and softball officials and their assigners by using this information wisely as well as the clearly understanding the signs and symptoms of heat-related illness. The objective to illness prevention and officiating the game as intended.
The life that you save may be yours and/or the physical or mental harm caused by heat-related illness could be prevented by understanding the hazard and quantifying the risk. Let’s have a safe and enjoyable summer season of baseball and softball.
Feel free to address any comments or questions to: windsgroup@aol.com.