SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
Download to read offline
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 1/13
Saji Koduvath Associates
For all your legal queries
Apr 15 2022
Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala.
Government Need Not Pay ‘Land-Value’, as such, if such Lands are Acquired.
A tenant who got ‘fixity’ over such land cannot ‘sell’ it as his absolute
property.
Purchase certificate cannot be given by the LT for land beyond ceiling limit.
Saji Koduvath, Advocate, Kottayam.
1. Abstract
Chapter II
Chapter II of the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963 pertains to
‘fixity’ (to tenants),
vesting of property in Govt.,
purchase of landlord’s rights by cultivating tenants,
issuance of ‘certificate of purchase’,
rights and liabilities of Kudikidappukars etc.; and
Chapter II shall not apply [Sec. 3(1)] to
leases of lands belonging to or vested in the Govt,
Leases of private forests,
tenancies of plantations exceeding 30 acres, etc.
Chapter III
Chapter III pertains to
ceiling limit,
surrender,
vesting of excess land in Govt. etc.; and
Chapter III shall not apply [Sec. 81(1) ] to
lands owned or held by the Government,
private forests,
plantations, etc.
Fixity of Tenants and Assignment of land to Tenants
Sec. 13 of the KLR Act, 1963 proclaims that every tenant shall have fixity of tenure
in respect of his holding.
Sec. 72 of the Act declares that the title of a land is vested in Government free
from all encumbrances created by the landowners and intermediaries and subsisting
thereon if
(i) it is held by a cultivating tenant and
(ii) the tenant is entitled to fixity of tenure.
Sec. 72B enables ‘cultivating tenants’ to get the assignment of leasehold
land within ceiling area (by purchase certificate provided in Sec. 72K).
Sec. 81 exempts plantation from ceiling limits.
Plantation Land Cannot be Assigned to a Tenant
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 2/13
From the above, it is clear:
. Tenants who hold the plantation lands are entitled to fixity of tenure under Sec. 13.
. As the tenants who hold the plantation land are cultivating tenants, such lands
are vested in Government.
. The plantation land, above ceiling limit [under Sec. 72B], cannot be assigned (by the
Land Tribunal) to a tenant.
Therefore, the OWNER of the (exempted) Leasehold-Plantation-Lands in Kerala is
the Government of Kerala.
2. Provisions as to Fixity, Purchase Certificate,  Plantation-Exemption, Ceiling
Area, etc.
Tenant & Fixity –
Section 13(1) reads as under:
13. Right of tenants to fixity of tenure.  (1) Notwithstanding any thing to the contrary
contained in any law, custom, usage or contract or in any decree or order of
court, every tenant, shall have fixity of tenure in respect of his holding, and no land
from the holding shall be Limited except as provided in Sections 14 to 22.”
Tenant is defined in Sec 2 (57) as under:
(57) “tenant“ moans any person who has paid or has agreed to pay rent or other
consideration for his being allowed to possess and to enjoy any land by a person
entitled to lease that land, and includes- …. ….. ….. “
Cultivating Tenant & Vesting of land in Government –
Section 72(1) reads:
“72. Vesting of landlord’s rights in Government: (1) On a date to be notified by the
Government in this behalf in the Gazette, all right, title and interest of the
landowners and intermediaries in respect of holdings held by cultivating
tenants (including holders of kudiyirippus and holders karaimas) entitled to fixity of
tenure under Section 13, and in respect of which certificates of purchase under Sub-
section (2) of Section 59 have not been issued, shall, subject to the provisions of this
section, vest in the government free from all encumbrances created by the
landowners and intermediaries and subsisting thereon the said date”
It provides (automatic) vesting of leasehold properties in Govt. Conditions thereof
are:
(i) the land must be held by cultivating tenants;
(ii) they should be entitled to fixity of tenure under Sec. 13.
Sec. 2(8) defines cultivating tenant as under:
“cultivating tenant“ means a tenant who is in actual possession of, and is entitled to
cultivate, the land comprised in his holding.”
Issue of Purchase Certificate
Section 72B, 72C and 72K(1) & (2) read as under:
“72B. Cultivating tenants right to assignment. – (1) The cultivating tenant of any
holding or part of a holding, the right, title and interest in respect of which
have vested in the Government under Section 72, shall be entitled to assignment of
such right, title and interest:
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 3/13
Provided that
(a) no cultivating tenant shall be entitled to assignment of the right, title and interest
in respect of any holding or part of a holding under this Section if he, or if he is a
member of a family, such family, owns an extent of land not less than-the ceiling
area.
(b) where the cultivating tenant or, if he is a member of a family, such family, does
not own any land or owns an extent of land which is less than the ceiling area, he
shall be entitled to the assignment of the right, title and interest in respect of only
such extent of land as will, together with the land, if any, owned by him or his family,
as the case may be, be equal to the ceiling area.
Explanation. – In calculating the extent of land owned by the cultivating tenant or,
where he is a member of a family, by such family, for the purposes of clauses (a)
and (b) of the foregoing proviso, the portion of the land owned by such cultivating
tenant or by the family, which is liable to be assigned to the cultivating tenants
holding under him or such family, shall not be taken into account.
(2) The provisions of Section 82 shall, so far as may be, apply to the calculation of
the ceiling area for the purposes of the proviso to Sub-section (1);
Provided that if no date has been notified under Section 83, the date notified under
Section 72 shall be deemed to be the date notified under Section 83.
(3) Any cultivating tenant entitled to assignment of the right, title and interest in
respect of a holding or part of a holding under Sub-section (1) may apply to the Land
Tribunal within whose jurisdiction such holding or part is situate within two years
from the dote of vesting of such right, title and interest in the Government under
Section 72, or such further time as may be allowed by the Government in this behalf,
for such assignment to him.
(4) An application under Sub-section (3) shall contain the following particulars,
namely:(a) the village, survey number and extent of the holding or part to which the
assignment relates.(b) the name and address of the landowner and intermediaries
and also of every other person interested in the land and the nature of their interest
so far as they arc known to him;(c) the particulars regarding the other lands owned
or held by him or if he is a member of a family; by such family; and(d) such other
particulars as may be prescribed.
(5) Where a cultivating tenant is entitled to the assignment of the right, title and
interest in respect of only a portion of the holding held by him, he may indicate in the
application under Sub-section (3) his choice of the portion to which the assignment
shall relate.”
“72C. Assignment where application is not made by cultivating
tenant.  Notwithstanding anything contained in Sub-section (3) of Section 72B [or
Section 72BB], the Land tribunal may, subject to such rules as may be made by the
Government in this behalf, at any time after the vesting of the right, title and interest
of the landowners and intermediaries in tile Government under Section 72, assign
such right, title and interest to the cultivating tenants entitled thereto, and the
cultivating tenants shall be bound to accept such assignment.”
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 4/13
“72K. Issue of certificate of purchase. – (1) As soon as may be after the
determination of the purchase price under Section 72F [or the passing of an order
under Sub-section (3) of Section 72MM] the Land Tribunal shall issue a certificate of
purchase to the cultivating tenant, and thereupon the right, title and interest of the
landowner and the intermediaries, if any, in respect of the holding or part thereof to
which the certificate relates, shall vest in the cultivating tenant free from all
encumbrances created by the landowner or the intermediaries, if any.
(2) The certificate of purchase issued under Sub-section (1) shall be conclusive
proof of the assignment to the tenant of the right, title and interest of the landowner
and the intermediaries, if any, over the holding or portion thereof to which the
assignment relates.”
Note: Sec. 72F speaks as to ‘Land Tribunal to issue notices and determine the
compensation and purchase price; and Sec. 72MM provides for jointly applying, by
the cultivating tenant, the landowner, the intermediary, the holders of encumbrances,
etc, to the Land Tribunal, for an order for ‘assignment by mutual agreement’ to the
cultivating tenant.
3. The Tenant is Liable to pay ‘Rent‘ and Land Tax
The land being vest in Govt. under Sec. 72, Sec. 72E casts duty on the ‘cultivating
tenant’ to pay ‘rent‘ to the Government.
In Jagannath Temple Managing Committee v. Siddha Math,  (2015) 16 SCC 542,
while dealing with the ‘vesting’ under Land Acquisition Act,1894, it is held that ‘it is a
settled principle of law that once a property is vested by an Act of legislature, to
achieve the laudable object, the same cannot be divested by the enactment of any
subsequent general law and vest such property under such law.’
(LA Act, 1894, Sec. 16 reads as under: Power to take possession. When the
Collector has made an award under section 11, he may take possession of the land,
which shall thereupon vest absolutely in the Government, free from all
encumbrances.)
The concept of ‘vesting’ was also considered in The Fruit & Vegetable Merchants
Union v. The Delhi Improvement Trust, AIR 1957 SC 344. In this decision it is held
as under:
“(19) That the word “vest” is a word of variable import is shown by provisions of
Indian statutes also. For example, S. 56 of the Provincial Insolvency Act (5 of 1920)
empowers the Court at the time of the making of the order of adjudication or
thereafter to appoint a receiver for the property of the insolvent and further provides
that “such property shall thereupon vest in such receiver”. The property vests in the
receiver for the purpose of administering the estate of the insolvent for the payment
of his debts after realising his assets. The property of the insolvent vests in the
receiver not for all purposes but only for the purpose of the Insolvency Act and the
receiver has no interest of his own in the property. On the other hand, Ss. 16 and 17
of the Land Acquisition Act (Act 1 of LA), provide that the property so acquired, upon
the happening of certain events, shall “vest absolutely in the Government free from
all encumbrances”. In the cases contemplated by Ss. 16 and 17 the property
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 5/13
acquired becomes the property of Government without any conditions or limitations
either as to title or possession. The legislature has made it clear that the vesting of
the property is not for any limited purpose or limited duration. It would thus appear
that the word “vest” has not got a fixed connotation meaning in all cases that the
property is owned by the person or the authority in whom it vests. It may vest in title,
or it may vest in possession, or it may vest in a limited sense, as indicated in the
context in which it may have been used in a particular piece of legislation. The
provisions of the Improvement Act, particularly Ss. 45 to 49 and 54 and 54-A when
they speak of a certain building or street or square or other land vesting in a
municipality or other local body or in a trust, do not necessarily mean that ownership
has passed to any of them.” [Quoted in Indore Development Authority vs Manoharlal
(Arun Mishra, J.), (2020) 8 SCC 129.]
Sec. 72E reads as under:
72E. Rent of holdings vested in Government but not assigned to cultivating
tenants. – Where in respect of any holding or part thereof, the right, title and interest
of the landowner and intermediaries have vested in the Government under Section
72 and the cultivating tenant is not entitled to the assignment of such right, title and
interest by virtue of Sub-section (1) of Section 72, the cultivating tenant shall
be liable to pay to the Government the rent payable under this Act from the date of
vesting under Section 72.
With respect to payment of tax it is stated as under in Sec. 72S:
72S. Liability for assessment alter the date of vesting under Section
72. (1)] Notwithstanding anything contained in the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961, or in
any other law for the time being in force, or in any contract, where the right, title and
interest of the landowner and the intermediaries, if any, in respect of a holding have
vested in the Government under Section 72, the cultivating tenant of that
holding shall be liable to pay the basic tax payable in respect of that holding under
the said Act and other taxes and cesses due in respect of that holding.
(2) In the case of a holding or part of a holding in respect of which an application for
resumption under the provisions of this Act is rejected, the cultivating tenant shall be
liable to pay the basic tax and other taxes and cesses in respect of such holding or
part of the holding, as the case may be, with effect on and from the date notified
under Sub-section (1) of Section 72.
4. Provisions as to Excess, Ceiling Return, Surrender, Exemption, Etc.
Section 81 – exemptions:
S. 81, the first Section in Chapter III deals with exemption from ceiling limit of
plantation, industrial land, etc. Sec. 81(1)(e) reads as under:
“Exemptions: (1) The provisions of this Chapter shall not apply to–
(a) lands owned or held by the Government ….
…. …..
(e) plantations;
…………”
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 6/13
Plantation: Under Sec. 2, clause (44), plantation means any land used by a person
principally for the cultivation of tea, coffee, cocoa, rubber, cardamom or cinnamon.
Section 82 & 83 – ceiling area:
S. 82 & 83 deal with ceiling area and bars holding land excess of ceiling fixed.
Sec. 83 reads as under:
“83. No person to hold land in excess of the ceiling area. With effect from such dates
as may be notified by the Government in the Gazette, no person shall be entitled to
own or hold or to possess under a mortgage lands in the aggregate in excess of the
ceiling area.”
Section 85(1) – surrender of excess land:
85. Surrender of excess land. (1) Where a person owns or holds land excess of the
ceiling area on the date notified under Section 83, such excess land shall be
surrendered as hereinafter provided: …. ….”
Read Blog: Relevant provisions of Kerala Land Reforms Act in a Nutshell
5. Effect of Conversion or Sale of A Portion of Exempted Land
Section 87 reads as under:
“S.87. Excess land obtained by gift, etc. to be surrendered – (1) Where any person
acquires any land dafter the date notified under Section 83 by gift, purchase,
mortgage with possession, lease, surrender or any other kind of transfer inter vivos
or by bequest or inheritance or otherwise and in consequence thereof the total
extent of land owned or held by such person exceeds the ceiling area, such excess
shall be surrendered to such authority as may be prescribed.
       Explanation 1 – Where any land is exempted by or under Section 81 and such
exemption is in force on the date notified under Section 83, such land shall, with
effect from the date on which it ceases to be exempted, be deemed to be land
acquired after the date notified under Section 83.
       Explanation II – Where, after the date notified under Section 83, any class of
land specified in Schedule II has been converted into any other class of land
specified in that Schedule or any land exempt under Section 81 from the provisions
of this Chapter is converted into any class of land not so exempt and in
consequence thereof the total extent of land owned or held by a person exceeds the
ceiling area, so much extent of land as is in excess of the ceiling area, shall be
deemed to be land acquired after the said date.
Explanation II is explained by the Full Bench of the Kerala High Court in Mathew K.
Jacob v. District Environmental Impact Assessment Authority,2018-4 KLT 913, as
under:
“The consequence is that the benefit of the exemption would be lost and the extent
added to the account of the assessee or the declarant in determination of his ceiling
area.”
That is, if a person converts any portion of his exempted land to any other class, that
converted extent will be added to his account in determining his ceiling limit; and the
Taluk Land Board can proceed upon that (excess) land. In short, the exemption will
be lost for that portion.
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 7/13
6. Fragmentation has to be Treated as Conversion for Non-exempted Category
The decision in One Earth One Life v. State of Kerala, 2019-2 KHC(SN) 10; 2019-1
KLT 985, arose from the Writ Petition filed for a declaration that the fragmentation
and sale of a Rubber Plantation for non-plantation purposes was illegal as it
defeated the purpose of the Kerala Land Reforms Act. When the matter was placed
before the Taluk Land Board under Sec 87, KLR Act, it found that there was no
change in classification of the land and therefore dropped the proceedings. The High
Court held as under:
“34. Section 81 of the KLR Act is in pith and substance a special provision, with
its main objective of giving exemption to certain lands including the lands maintained
as plantations is to prevent fragmentation of the land and to keep it as plantation
itself to improve the economy of the state for welfare of people as a whole while the
Act creates a regime, the State is under an obligation to safeguard, the intended
purpose of the provisions of the Act in its spirit. ….. …… It could be gathered from
the records that the proposal to transfer 1.03 acres of land to each workers in
discharge of their service or retrenchment benefits will definitely divide the plantation
into separate slots and that would definitely change the character/nature of the
plantation, which could be termed as ‘conversion’ and that will be against the
provisions of the Act.”
“37. …. Fragmentation of the estate and transfer of it has to be treated as a case of
conversion of plantation into some other category of land. Such being the scenario,
fragmentation amounts to serious violation of the provisions of KLR Act. Hence, we
are not impressed by the argument of the learned counsel for the respondent No.18
that the fragmented plots will be maintained as plantation by the transferees, so as
to extend/avail the benefit of HMT’s case (supra). Taking into account of all the
relevant aspects, we have no hesitation in holding that dropping of the suo motu
proceedings initiated under Section 87 of KLR Act by the TLB in a cursory
manner, is not at all reasonable or justifiable when tested on the touchstone of the
object and intention, which the legislation seeks to achieve and beyond what is
required, in the interest of the public.”
7. Can a Tenant of Plantation Transfer his Rights, Fragmenting the Plantation
Possession by itself is a substantive right recognised by law. It is heritable and
transferable. (Kuttan Narayanan v. Thomman Mathayi, AIR 1966 Ker 179; Phirayalal
Kapur Vs. Jia Rani, AIR 1973 Delhi 186; Nallammal Vs. Ayisha Beevi, 2017-5 Mad
LJ 864). 
See Blog: POSSESSION is a Substantive Right in Indian Law
Therefore, a tenant of plantation having rights of fixity (Sec. 13) may have the right
to transfer it to another. In any case, the change of character or nature of the
plantation by fragmentation being amount to ‘conversion’ that will be against the
provisions of the Act, as pointed out in One Earth One Life v. State of Kerala, 2019-2
KHC(SN) 10; 2019-1 KLT 985.
9. Conclusion
Who is the OWNER of Exempted (Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala?
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 8/13
It is Government itself. Because,
1. Plantation (lease) lands VEST in GOVT, automatically
For the reason – Sec. 72 provides for mandatory and involuntary vesting of
leasehold lands in Govt., if the conditions in Sec. 72 are satisfied; that is,
(i) held by cultivating tenants;
(ii) tenants thereof are entitled to fixity of tenure under Sec. 13.
2. Govt. is the Owner
For the reasons –
Title is declared to be vested in Government (Sec. 72).
The plantation land cannot be assigned to the tenants for the area being
above ceiling limit [Sec. 72B(2)]; and no purchase certificate can be issued.
Plantation land cannot be fragmented (Sec. 87 Explanation II).
Such tenant is liable to pay rent to the Government (Sec. 72E).
3. ‘Exemption’ in Chapter III Cannot be read into Sec. 72B(2)
Sec. 72B(2) specifies that the provisions of Section 82 as to ceiling limit
shall apply (when assignment is given).
The exemption provision in Sec. 81 (Chapter III) cannot be brought-forth or read-
into Sec. 72B.
Because:
Sec. 82 (ceiling limit) itself is not applicable to plantation lands (as Sec. 81 exempts
plantation from the provisions of Chapter III).
That is, Sec. 82 is an independent provision, not controlled by the exemption
provision in Sec. 81.
When an independent provision in a Chapter is relied on (or read) in a section of
another Chapter, it cannot be said – the colour, light or smell of the entire Chapter of
the invitee section is reflected.
Further:
Chapter II of the KLR Act is exclusive and exhaustive as to ‘fixity’ and ‘vesting’ of
land in Government.
Proviso to Sec. 72B(1) also show it is an an independent provision.
It is not stated anywhere in the Act – the right and title of the (leased-plantation)
land vested in Government under Sec. 72, will be divested in any manner (to the
previous owner, or to the tenant or to anybody else).
Sec. 72E provides for collection of ‘rent‘ from the holders of the plantation, for the
reason that the land vests in Govt.
In other words, under the KLR Act, the holders of such ‘Plantation-Lease-Lands’ are
only ‘Tenants of Government’.
Proceedings initiated by Taluk Land Board under Chapter III do not confer title.
Therefore,
. The Government Need Not Pay ‘Land-Value‘, as such, if such Lands are Acquired.
. A tenant who got ‘fixity’ over such land cannot ‘sell’ this land as his absolute
property.
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 9/13
. Purchase certificate cannot be given by the Land Tribunal for land beyond ceiling
limit.
Read in this Cluster (Click on the Topic):
Book No. 1.   Handbook of a Civil Lawyer
Civil Procedure & CPC
Civil Rights and Jurisdiction of Civil Courts
Pleadings Should be Specific; Why?
Best Evidence Rule in Indian Law
Declaration and Injunction
Res Judicata and Constructive Res Judicata
Order II, Rule 2 CPC – Not to Vex Defendants Twice 
Notice to Produce Documents in Civil Cases
Production of Documents: Order 11, Rule 14 & Rule 12
Modes of Proof – Admission, Expert Evidence, Presumption etc.
Marking Documents Without Objection – Do Contents Proved
Production, Admissibility & Proof Of Documents
Sec. 91 CPC and Suits Against Wrongful Acts
Remedies Under Sec. 92 CPC
Mandatory Injunction – Law and Principles 
Interrogatories: When Court Allows, When Rejects?
Can a Party to Suit Examine Opposite Party, as of Right?
Decree in OI R8 CPC-Suit & Eo-Nomine Parties
Power of attorney
No Adjudication If Power of Attorney is Sufficiently Stamped
Notary Attested Power-of-Attorney Sufficient for Registration 
Permission when a Power of Attorney Holder Files Suit
Stamp Act
Adjudication as to Proper Stamp under Stamp Act
Unstamped & Unregistered Documents and Collateral Purpose
Title and Possession
Adverse Possession: An Evolving Concept
Adverse Possession: Burden to Plead Sabotaged 
When ‘Possession Follows Title’; ‘Title Follows Possession’?
Civil Procedure – General
‘Mutation’ by Revenue Authorities will not Confer ‘Title’
Does Alternate Remedy Bar Civil Suits and Writ Petitions?
Void, Voidable, Ab Initio Void, and Sham Transactions
Can Courts Award Interest on Equitable Grounds?
Natural Justice – Not an Unruly Horse
‘Sound-mind’ and ‘Unsound-Mind’ 
Forfeiture of Earnest Money and Reasonable Compensation
Who has to fix Damages in Tort and Contract?
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 10/13
Notary-Attested Documents: Presumption, Rebuttable
Relevant provisions of Kerala Land Reforms Act in a Nutshell
Evidence Act – General
Expert Evidence and Appreciation of Evidence
How to Contradict a Witness under Sec. 145, Evidence Act
Rules on Burden of proof and Adverse Inference
Best Evidence Rule in Indian Law
Modes of Proof – Admission, Expert Evidence, Presumption etc.
Significance of Scientific Evidence in Judicial Process
Polygraphy, Narco Analysis and Brain Mapping Tests 
Sec. 65B
Sections 65A & 65B, Evidence Act and Arjun Panditrao: in Nutshell
Sec. 65B, Evidence Act: Arjun Paditrao Criticised.
Sec. 65B Evidence Act Simplified
‘STATEMENTS’ alone can be proved by ‘CERTIFICATE’ u/s. 65B 
Sec. 65B,  Evidence Act: Certificate for Computer Output
Certificate is Required Only for ‘Computer Output’; Not for ‘Electronic
Records’: Arjun Panditrao Explored.
Documents
Oral Evidence on Contents of Document, Irrelevant
Marking Documents Without Objection – Do Contents Stand Proved?
Proof of Documents & Objections To Admissibility – How & When? 
Notary-Attested Documents: Presumption, Rebuttable
Presumptions on Registered Documents & Collateral Purpose
Notice to Produce Documents in Civil Cases
Production of Documents: Order 11, Rule 14 & Rule 12
Modes of Proof – Admission, Expert Evidence, Presumption etc.
Marking Documents Without Objection – Do Contents Proved
Production, Admissibility & Proof Of Documents
Substantive Documents, and Documents used for Refreshing Memory and
Contradicting 
Visual and Audio Evidence (Including Photographs, Cassettes, Tape-
recordings, Films, CCTV Footage, CDs, e-mails, Chips, Hard-discs, Pen-drives)
Relevancy, Admissibility and Proof of Documents
Contract Act
‘Sound-mind’ and ‘Unsound-Mind’ in Indian Civil Laws
Forfeiture of Earnest Money and Reasonable Compensation
Who has to fix Damages in Tort and Contract?
Easement
What is Easement?
Does Right of Easement Allow to ‘Enjoy’ After Making a Construction?
What is “period ending within two years next before the institution of the
suit”?
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 11/13
Is the Basis of Every Easement, Theoretically, a Grant
Extent of Easement (Width of Way) in Easement of Necessity
Village Pathways and Right to Bury are not Easements.
Custom & Customary Easements in Indian Law
‘Additional Burden Loses Lateral Support’ – Incorrect Proposition
Book No. 2: A Handbook on Constitutional Issues
Judicial & Legislative Activism in India: Principles and Instances
Can Legislature Overpower Court Decisions by an Enactment?
Separation of Powers: Who Wins the Race – Legislature or Judiciary?
Kesavananda Bharati Case: Never Ending Controversy
Mullaperiyar Dam: Disputes and Adjudication of Legal Issues
Article 370: Is There Little Chance for Supreme Court Interference
Maratha Backward Community Reservation: SC Fixed Limit at 50%.
Polygraphy, Narco Analysis and Brain Mapping Tests 
CAA Challenge: Divergent Views
Religious issues
Secularism and Art. 25 & 26 of the Indian Constitution
Secularism & Freedom of Religion in Indian Panorama
‘Ban on Muslim Women to Enter Mosques, Unconstitutional’
No Reservation to Muslim and Christian SCs/STs (Dalits) Why?
Parsi Women – Excommunication for Marrying Outside 
Sabarimala Review Petitions & Reference to 9-Judge Bench
Ayodhya Disputes: M. Siddiq case –Pragmatic Verdict 
Book No. 3: Common Law of CLUBS and SOCIETIES in India
General Features
Bye Laws Fundamental
Effect of Registration of Societies and Incorporation of Clubs
Societies and Branches
Vesting of Property in Societies and Clubs
Juristic Personality of Societies and Clubs
Incidents of Trust in Clubs and Societies
Legal Personality of Trustees and Office Bearers 
Suits By or Against Societies, Clubs and Companies
Court’s Jurisdiction to Interfere in the Internal Affairs 
How to Sue Societies, Clubs and Companies
Amendment of Bye laws of Societies and Clubs
Dissolution of Societies and Clubs
Rights & Liabilities of Members of Clubs and Societies
Management – Powers of General Body and Governing Body
Expulsion of Members & Removal of Office-Bearers
Election & Challenge in Societies and Clubs
Court Interference in Election Process
Individual Membership Rights in Societies & Clubs
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 12/13
State-Interference in Affairs of Societies & Clubs
Law on Meetings: An Overview
Book No. 4: Common Law of TRUSTS in India
General Principles
What is Trust in Indian Law?
Public & Private Trusts in India.
Public Trusts and Indian Trusts Act – An Overview
Incidents of Trust in Clubs and Societies
Public Trusts and (State) Endowments/Trusts Acts
Trust is ‘An Obligation’; Not a Legal Entity
Dedication and Vesting
Dedication of Property in Public Trusts
Vesting of Property in Trusts
Indian Law Does Not Accept Salmond, as to Dual Ownership
Trustees and Management
Trustees and Administration of Public Trusts
Alienation of Public Trust Property
Extinction, Discharge, Revocation, etc. of Public Trusts
Breach of Trust
Breach of Trust and Removal of Trustees
Suits by or against Trusts
Suits By or Against Trusts and Trustees
Remedies Under Sec. 92 CPC
Law on Religious Trusts & Trustees
Philosophy of Idol Worship
Is an Idol a Perpetual Minor?
Hindu Temples & Law of Trusts
Law of Mutts and Other Hindu Endowments
Legal Personality of Temples, Gurudwaras, Churches and Mosques
Shebaits & Mahants and Law of Trustees
Ayodhya Disputes: M. Siddiq case – Pragmatic Verdict
Sabarimala Review Petitions & Reference to 9-Judge Bench
Secularism and Art. 25 & 26 of the Indian Constitution
Secularism & Freedom of Religion in Indian Panorama
‘Muslim Women: Ban to Enter Mosques, Is it Unconstitutional 
Parsi Women Excommunication, Unconstitutional.
General
State & Court – Protectors of All Charities
Business by Charitable Trusts & Institutions
Published by
sajikoduvath
5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates
https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 13/13
Leave a Comment
Saji Koduvath Associates, Blog at WordPress.com.
View all posts by sajikoduvath
Enter your comment here...
Enter your comment here...

More Related Content

What's hot

Removal of rock material
Removal of rock materialRemoval of rock material
Removal of rock materialFAROUQ
 
Land Acquisition Flow Chart
Land Acquisition Flow ChartLand Acquisition Flow Chart
Land Acquisition Flow ChartAvijeet Lala
 
Introduction to Land Law of Malaysia
Introduction to Land Law of MalaysiaIntroduction to Land Law of Malaysia
Introduction to Land Law of MalaysiaTaufikk94
 
Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013
Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013
Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013Husna Rodzi
 
Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987
Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987
Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987Tuan Syahmi Matter
 
ലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunals
ലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunalsലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunals
ലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunalsJamesadhikaram land matter consultancy 9447464502
 
Title Verification under Transfer of Property Act
Title Verification under Transfer of Property ActTitle Verification under Transfer of Property Act
Title Verification under Transfer of Property ActKonark Gupta
 
Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...
Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...
Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...surrenderyourthrone
 
General Concepts of Land Ownership
General Concepts of Land OwnershipGeneral Concepts of Land Ownership
General Concepts of Land Ownershipa_sophi
 
Conditions and restrictions in interest
Conditions and restrictions in interestConditions and restrictions in interest
Conditions and restrictions in interestFAROUQ
 
Land acquisition act
Land acquisition actLand acquisition act
Land acquisition actNoor Atikah
 
Registrar's Caveat
Registrar's CaveatRegistrar's Caveat
Registrar's Caveata_sophi
 
Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1
Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1
Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1xareejx
 
Economic Offences
Economic OffencesEconomic Offences
Economic Offencescpjcollege
 
Grounds for challenging compulsory land acquisition
Grounds for challenging compulsory land acquisitionGrounds for challenging compulsory land acquisition
Grounds for challenging compulsory land acquisitionHafizul Mukhlis
 

What's hot (20)

Removal of rock material
Removal of rock materialRemoval of rock material
Removal of rock material
 
National land code 1965
National land code 1965National land code 1965
National land code 1965
 
Land Acquisition Flow Chart
Land Acquisition Flow ChartLand Acquisition Flow Chart
Land Acquisition Flow Chart
 
land-notes-all.pdf
land-notes-all.pdfland-notes-all.pdf
land-notes-all.pdf
 
Introduction to Land Law of Malaysia
Introduction to Land Law of MalaysiaIntroduction to Land Law of Malaysia
Introduction to Land Law of Malaysia
 
Prohibitory orders
Prohibitory ordersProhibitory orders
Prohibitory orders
 
Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013
Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013
Land law ii (lien) as at mac 2013
 
Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987
Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987
Internet service provider Copyright Act 1987
 
ലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunals
ലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunalsലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunals
ലാൻഡ് ട്രിബുണലുകളുടെ ചുമതലകൾ -Role and functions of land tribunals
 
Mutation of land
Mutation of landMutation of land
Mutation of land
 
Title Verification under Transfer of Property Act
Title Verification under Transfer of Property ActTitle Verification under Transfer of Property Act
Title Verification under Transfer of Property Act
 
Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...
Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...
Undang undang Tanah - Lesen Pendudukan Sementara atau Temporary Occupational ...
 
General Concepts of Land Ownership
General Concepts of Land OwnershipGeneral Concepts of Land Ownership
General Concepts of Land Ownership
 
Conditions and restrictions in interest
Conditions and restrictions in interestConditions and restrictions in interest
Conditions and restrictions in interest
 
Land acquisition act
Land acquisition actLand acquisition act
Land acquisition act
 
Registrar's Caveat
Registrar's CaveatRegistrar's Caveat
Registrar's Caveat
 
Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1
Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1
Ll1 slides extent of ownership and enjoyment of land part 1
 
Kerala Building tax act - One time tax and Luxury to be paid in village offi...
Kerala Building tax act  - One time tax and Luxury to be paid in village offi...Kerala Building tax act  - One time tax and Luxury to be paid in village offi...
Kerala Building tax act - One time tax and Luxury to be paid in village offi...
 
Economic Offences
Economic OffencesEconomic Offences
Economic Offences
 
Grounds for challenging compulsory land acquisition
Grounds for challenging compulsory land acquisitionGrounds for challenging compulsory land acquisition
Grounds for challenging compulsory land acquisition
 

Similar to Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates (1).pdf

Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014xareejx
 
Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014xareejx
 
Land Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptx
Land Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptxLand Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptx
Land Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptxsrikarna235
 
Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969
Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969
Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969Naila Noor
 
Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...
Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...
Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...bansi default
 
Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972
Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972
Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972ApnaComplex
 
2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure
2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure
2011 VREB Website Residential Property DisclosureMatthew Rathbun
 
The UP Apartment Rules, 2011
The UP Apartment Rules, 2011The UP Apartment Rules, 2011
The UP Apartment Rules, 2011Suprio Nandy
 
Smartcitylease
SmartcityleaseSmartcitylease
SmartcityleaseRupal Garg
 
Virginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 Version
Virginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 VersionVirginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 Version
Virginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 VersionMatthew Rathbun
 
Taxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural Land
Taxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural LandTaxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural Land
Taxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural Landtaxguru5
 
Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972
Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972
Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972ADDA
 
Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009
Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009
Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009ezLandlordForms
 
Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)
Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)
Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)Robert StGenis
 
Alienation of Land
Alienation of LandAlienation of Land
Alienation of LandFAROUQ
 
Alienation of Land
Alienation of LandAlienation of Land
Alienation of LandFAROUQ
 

Similar to Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates (1).pdf (20)

Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014
 
Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014Land law 1 alienation 2014
Land law 1 alienation 2014
 
TNRRRLT Act,2017
TNRRRLT Act,2017TNRRRLT Act,2017
TNRRRLT Act,2017
 
Land Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptx
Land Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptxLand Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptx
Land Acquisition Claim, Process PPT.pptx
 
Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969
Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969
Dhaka improvement trust_rules_1969
 
Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...
Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...
Rev ms 243 -Land Acquisition- Payment of ex-gratia to various categories of e...
 
Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972
Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972
Karanataka Apartment Ownership Act 1972
 
2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure
2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure
2011 VREB Website Residential Property Disclosure
 
The UP Apartment Rules, 2011
The UP Apartment Rules, 2011The UP Apartment Rules, 2011
The UP Apartment Rules, 2011
 
Alienation
AlienationAlienation
Alienation
 
Smartcitylease
SmartcityleaseSmartcitylease
Smartcitylease
 
Virginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 Version
Virginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 VersionVirginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 Version
Virginia Residential Property Disclosure 2010 Version
 
Taxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural Land
Taxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural LandTaxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural Land
Taxability of Capital Gain on Transfer of Agricultural Land
 
Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972
Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972
Apartment Management: The Karnataka Apartment Ownership Act, 1972
 
Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009
Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009
Protecting tenants at_foreclosure_act_of_2009
 
ByeLaws.pdf
ByeLaws.pdfByeLaws.pdf
ByeLaws.pdf
 
2015 rev ms123 LA
2015 rev ms123  LA2015 rev ms123  LA
2015 rev ms123 LA
 
Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)
Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)
Amended LA Homesharing Ordinance 14 1635-s2 (01-7-2016)
 
Alienation of Land
Alienation of LandAlienation of Land
Alienation of Land
 
Alienation of Land
Alienation of LandAlienation of Land
Alienation of Land
 

More from Jamesadhikaram land matter consultancy 9447464502

More from Jamesadhikaram land matter consultancy 9447464502 (20)

Handbook for Presiding Officers Election 2024 James Joseph Adhikarathil Joi...
Handbook for Presiding Officers  Election 2024  James Joseph Adhikarathil Joi...Handbook for Presiding Officers  Election 2024  James Joseph Adhikarathil Joi...
Handbook for Presiding Officers Election 2024 James Joseph Adhikarathil Joi...
 
Land tribunal Pattayam citeria for the issue
Land tribunal Pattayam citeria for the issueLand tribunal Pattayam citeria for the issue
Land tribunal Pattayam citeria for the issue
 
Resurvey area prevails over document area
Resurvey area prevails over document areaResurvey area prevails over document area
Resurvey area prevails over document area
 
shanavas Land Tax new rate 2022- Basic Tax 1-04-2022 (1).pdf
shanavas Land Tax new rate 2022- Basic Tax 1-04-2022 (1).pdfshanavas Land Tax new rate 2022- Basic Tax 1-04-2022 (1).pdf
shanavas Land Tax new rate 2022- Basic Tax 1-04-2022 (1).pdf
 
Bhoomi tharam mattom no fee for family property below 25 cents - James Josep...
Bhoomi tharam mattom no fee for  family property below 25 cents - James Josep...Bhoomi tharam mattom no fee for  family property below 25 cents - James Josep...
Bhoomi tharam mattom no fee for family property below 25 cents - James Josep...
 
Revenue Guide 2024 ILDM Kerala James Joseph Adhikarathil Land Consultant 944...
Revenue Guide 2024 ILDM Kerala  James Joseph Adhikarathil Land Consultant 944...Revenue Guide 2024 ILDM Kerala  James Joseph Adhikarathil Land Consultant 944...
Revenue Guide 2024 ILDM Kerala James Joseph Adhikarathil Land Consultant 944...
 
kbt
kbtkbt
kbt
 
Training to Prospective Tahsildars Kerala ILDM James Joseph Adhikarathil 94...
Training to Prospective Tahsildars Kerala   ILDM James Joseph Adhikarathil 94...Training to Prospective Tahsildars Kerala   ILDM James Joseph Adhikarathil 94...
Training to Prospective Tahsildars Kerala ILDM James Joseph Adhikarathil 94...
 
Michabhoomi Clarification Pattayam
Michabhoomi Clarification PattayamMichabhoomi Clarification Pattayam
Michabhoomi Clarification Pattayam
 
Kerala Building tax act 1975 modified 2023 James Joseph Adhikarathil
Kerala Building tax act 1975 modified 2023 James Joseph AdhikarathilKerala Building tax act 1975 modified 2023 James Joseph Adhikarathil
Kerala Building tax act 1975 modified 2023 James Joseph Adhikarathil
 
Family member certificate not needed for registration James Joseph Adhikara...
Family member certificate not needed for registration   James Joseph Adhikara...Family member certificate not needed for registration   James Joseph Adhikara...
Family member certificate not needed for registration James Joseph Adhikara...
 
michabhoomi KLR Act Land Board procedures James Joseph Adhikarathil
michabhoomi KLR Act Land Board procedures  James Joseph Adhikarathilmichabhoomi KLR Act Land Board procedures  James Joseph Adhikarathil
michabhoomi KLR Act Land Board procedures James Joseph Adhikarathil
 
Michabhoomi distribution Clarification circular
Michabhoomi distribution Clarification circularMichabhoomi distribution Clarification circular
Michabhoomi distribution Clarification circular
 
ജന്മിത്തം (2).pdf
ജന്മിത്തം (2).pdfജന്മിത്തം (2).pdf
ജന്മിത്തം (2).pdf
 
Land tax note
Land tax noteLand tax note
Land tax note
 
AAY- BPL ration card income and other criteria orders. pdf13-10-2023 (1).Jam...
AAY- BPL ration card income and other  criteria orders. pdf13-10-2023 (1).Jam...AAY- BPL ration card income and other  criteria orders. pdf13-10-2023 (1).Jam...
AAY- BPL ration card income and other criteria orders. pdf13-10-2023 (1).Jam...
 
Paddy and and wetland aCT - Contempt of court - sub collector fort Cochin fin...
Paddy and and wetland aCT - Contempt of court - sub collector fort Cochin fin...Paddy and and wetland aCT - Contempt of court - sub collector fort Cochin fin...
Paddy and and wetland aCT - Contempt of court - sub collector fort Cochin fin...
 
Taluk vikasana samithi taluk sabha kerala guidelines James joseph adhikarathil
Taluk vikasana samithi taluk sabha  kerala guidelines James joseph adhikarathilTaluk vikasana samithi taluk sabha  kerala guidelines James joseph adhikarathil
Taluk vikasana samithi taluk sabha kerala guidelines James joseph adhikarathil
 
Michabhumi clarification circular James Joseph adhikarathil
Michabhumi clarification circular James Joseph adhikarathilMichabhumi clarification circular James Joseph adhikarathil
Michabhumi clarification circular James Joseph adhikarathil
 
Land tribunal pattayam registration in SRO - Certified copy of pattayam from...
Land tribunal pattayam registration in SRO  - Certified copy of pattayam from...Land tribunal pattayam registration in SRO  - Certified copy of pattayam from...
Land tribunal pattayam registration in SRO - Certified copy of pattayam from...
 

Recently uploaded

Test Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptx
Test Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptxTest Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptx
Test Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptxsrikarna235
 
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptFINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptjudeplata
 
如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书
如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书
如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书FS LS
 
Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126
Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126
Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126Oishi8
 
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptxA Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptxPKrishna18
 
Key Factors That Influence Property Tax Rates
Key Factors That Influence Property Tax RatesKey Factors That Influence Property Tax Rates
Key Factors That Influence Property Tax RatesHome Tax Saver
 
一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书E LSS
 
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...Dr. Oliver Massmann
 
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptxPOLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptxAbhishekchatterjee248859
 
定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一st Las
 
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKINGOffences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKINGPRAKHARGUPTA419620
 
QUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptx
QUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptxQUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptx
QUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptxnibresliezel23
 
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书SS A
 
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书FS LS
 
Arbitration, mediation and conciliation in India
Arbitration, mediation and conciliation in IndiaArbitration, mediation and conciliation in India
Arbitration, mediation and conciliation in IndiaNafiaNazim
 
如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书
 如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书 如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书Fir sss
 
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书Sir Lt
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Test Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptx
Test Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptxTest Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptx
Test Identification Parade & Dying Declaration.pptx
 
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.pptFINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
FINALTRUEENFORCEMENT OF BARANGAY SETTLEMENT.ppt
 
如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书
如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书
如何办理伦敦南岸大学毕业证(本硕)LSBU学位证书
 
young Call Girls in Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Service
young Call Girls in  Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Serviceyoung Call Girls in  Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Service
young Call Girls in Pusa Road🔝 9953330565 🔝 escort Service
 
Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126
Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126
Indemnity Guarantee Section 124 125 and 126
 
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptxA Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
A Short-ppt on new gst laws in india.pptx
 
Key Factors That Influence Property Tax Rates
Key Factors That Influence Property Tax RatesKey Factors That Influence Property Tax Rates
Key Factors That Influence Property Tax Rates
 
一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版利兹大学毕业证学位证书
 
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...
 
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptxPOLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
POLICE ACT, 1861 the details about police system.pptx
 
定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
定制(BU文凭证书)美国波士顿大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKINGOffences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
Offences against property (TRESPASS, BREAKING
 
QUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptx
QUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptxQUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptx
QUASI-JUDICIAL-FUNCTION AND QUASI JUDICIAL AGENCY.pptx
 
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书 一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
一比一原版旧金山州立大学毕业证学位证书
 
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
如何办理密德萨斯大学毕业证(本硕)Middlesex学位证书
 
Arbitration, mediation and conciliation in India
Arbitration, mediation and conciliation in IndiaArbitration, mediation and conciliation in India
Arbitration, mediation and conciliation in India
 
Russian Call Girls Service Gomti Nagar \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service...
Russian Call Girls Service Gomti Nagar \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service...Russian Call Girls Service Gomti Nagar \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service...
Russian Call Girls Service Gomti Nagar \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service...
 
Old Income Tax Regime Vs New Income Tax Regime
Old  Income Tax Regime Vs  New Income Tax   RegimeOld  Income Tax Regime Vs  New Income Tax   Regime
Old Income Tax Regime Vs New Income Tax Regime
 
如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书
 如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书 如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理佛蒙特大学毕业证学位证书
 
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书 如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
如何办理(MSU文凭证书)密歇根州立大学毕业证学位证书
 

Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates (1).pdf

  • 1. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 1/13 Saji Koduvath Associates For all your legal queries Apr 15 2022 Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. Government Need Not Pay ‘Land-Value’, as such, if such Lands are Acquired. A tenant who got ‘fixity’ over such land cannot ‘sell’ it as his absolute property. Purchase certificate cannot be given by the LT for land beyond ceiling limit. Saji Koduvath, Advocate, Kottayam. 1. Abstract Chapter II Chapter II of the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963 pertains to ‘fixity’ (to tenants), vesting of property in Govt., purchase of landlord’s rights by cultivating tenants, issuance of ‘certificate of purchase’, rights and liabilities of Kudikidappukars etc.; and Chapter II shall not apply [Sec. 3(1)] to leases of lands belonging to or vested in the Govt, Leases of private forests, tenancies of plantations exceeding 30 acres, etc. Chapter III Chapter III pertains to ceiling limit, surrender, vesting of excess land in Govt. etc.; and Chapter III shall not apply [Sec. 81(1) ] to lands owned or held by the Government, private forests, plantations, etc. Fixity of Tenants and Assignment of land to Tenants Sec. 13 of the KLR Act, 1963 proclaims that every tenant shall have fixity of tenure in respect of his holding. Sec. 72 of the Act declares that the title of a land is vested in Government free from all encumbrances created by the landowners and intermediaries and subsisting thereon if (i) it is held by a cultivating tenant and (ii) the tenant is entitled to fixity of tenure. Sec. 72B enables ‘cultivating tenants’ to get the assignment of leasehold land within ceiling area (by purchase certificate provided in Sec. 72K). Sec. 81 exempts plantation from ceiling limits. Plantation Land Cannot be Assigned to a Tenant
  • 2. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 2/13 From the above, it is clear: . Tenants who hold the plantation lands are entitled to fixity of tenure under Sec. 13. . As the tenants who hold the plantation land are cultivating tenants, such lands are vested in Government. . The plantation land, above ceiling limit [under Sec. 72B], cannot be assigned (by the Land Tribunal) to a tenant. Therefore, the OWNER of the (exempted) Leasehold-Plantation-Lands in Kerala is the Government of Kerala. 2. Provisions as to Fixity, Purchase Certificate,  Plantation-Exemption, Ceiling Area, etc. Tenant & Fixity – Section 13(1) reads as under: 13. Right of tenants to fixity of tenure.  (1) Notwithstanding any thing to the contrary contained in any law, custom, usage or contract or in any decree or order of court, every tenant, shall have fixity of tenure in respect of his holding, and no land from the holding shall be Limited except as provided in Sections 14 to 22.” Tenant is defined in Sec 2 (57) as under: (57) “tenant“ moans any person who has paid or has agreed to pay rent or other consideration for his being allowed to possess and to enjoy any land by a person entitled to lease that land, and includes- …. ….. ….. “ Cultivating Tenant & Vesting of land in Government – Section 72(1) reads: “72. Vesting of landlord’s rights in Government: (1) On a date to be notified by the Government in this behalf in the Gazette, all right, title and interest of the landowners and intermediaries in respect of holdings held by cultivating tenants (including holders of kudiyirippus and holders karaimas) entitled to fixity of tenure under Section 13, and in respect of which certificates of purchase under Sub- section (2) of Section 59 have not been issued, shall, subject to the provisions of this section, vest in the government free from all encumbrances created by the landowners and intermediaries and subsisting thereon the said date” It provides (automatic) vesting of leasehold properties in Govt. Conditions thereof are: (i) the land must be held by cultivating tenants; (ii) they should be entitled to fixity of tenure under Sec. 13. Sec. 2(8) defines cultivating tenant as under: “cultivating tenant“ means a tenant who is in actual possession of, and is entitled to cultivate, the land comprised in his holding.” Issue of Purchase Certificate Section 72B, 72C and 72K(1) & (2) read as under: “72B. Cultivating tenants right to assignment. – (1) The cultivating tenant of any holding or part of a holding, the right, title and interest in respect of which have vested in the Government under Section 72, shall be entitled to assignment of such right, title and interest:
  • 3. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 3/13 Provided that (a) no cultivating tenant shall be entitled to assignment of the right, title and interest in respect of any holding or part of a holding under this Section if he, or if he is a member of a family, such family, owns an extent of land not less than-the ceiling area. (b) where the cultivating tenant or, if he is a member of a family, such family, does not own any land or owns an extent of land which is less than the ceiling area, he shall be entitled to the assignment of the right, title and interest in respect of only such extent of land as will, together with the land, if any, owned by him or his family, as the case may be, be equal to the ceiling area. Explanation. – In calculating the extent of land owned by the cultivating tenant or, where he is a member of a family, by such family, for the purposes of clauses (a) and (b) of the foregoing proviso, the portion of the land owned by such cultivating tenant or by the family, which is liable to be assigned to the cultivating tenants holding under him or such family, shall not be taken into account. (2) The provisions of Section 82 shall, so far as may be, apply to the calculation of the ceiling area for the purposes of the proviso to Sub-section (1); Provided that if no date has been notified under Section 83, the date notified under Section 72 shall be deemed to be the date notified under Section 83. (3) Any cultivating tenant entitled to assignment of the right, title and interest in respect of a holding or part of a holding under Sub-section (1) may apply to the Land Tribunal within whose jurisdiction such holding or part is situate within two years from the dote of vesting of such right, title and interest in the Government under Section 72, or such further time as may be allowed by the Government in this behalf, for such assignment to him. (4) An application under Sub-section (3) shall contain the following particulars, namely:(a) the village, survey number and extent of the holding or part to which the assignment relates.(b) the name and address of the landowner and intermediaries and also of every other person interested in the land and the nature of their interest so far as they arc known to him;(c) the particulars regarding the other lands owned or held by him or if he is a member of a family; by such family; and(d) such other particulars as may be prescribed. (5) Where a cultivating tenant is entitled to the assignment of the right, title and interest in respect of only a portion of the holding held by him, he may indicate in the application under Sub-section (3) his choice of the portion to which the assignment shall relate.” “72C. Assignment where application is not made by cultivating tenant.  Notwithstanding anything contained in Sub-section (3) of Section 72B [or Section 72BB], the Land tribunal may, subject to such rules as may be made by the Government in this behalf, at any time after the vesting of the right, title and interest of the landowners and intermediaries in tile Government under Section 72, assign such right, title and interest to the cultivating tenants entitled thereto, and the cultivating tenants shall be bound to accept such assignment.”
  • 4. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 4/13 “72K. Issue of certificate of purchase. – (1) As soon as may be after the determination of the purchase price under Section 72F [or the passing of an order under Sub-section (3) of Section 72MM] the Land Tribunal shall issue a certificate of purchase to the cultivating tenant, and thereupon the right, title and interest of the landowner and the intermediaries, if any, in respect of the holding or part thereof to which the certificate relates, shall vest in the cultivating tenant free from all encumbrances created by the landowner or the intermediaries, if any. (2) The certificate of purchase issued under Sub-section (1) shall be conclusive proof of the assignment to the tenant of the right, title and interest of the landowner and the intermediaries, if any, over the holding or portion thereof to which the assignment relates.” Note: Sec. 72F speaks as to ‘Land Tribunal to issue notices and determine the compensation and purchase price; and Sec. 72MM provides for jointly applying, by the cultivating tenant, the landowner, the intermediary, the holders of encumbrances, etc, to the Land Tribunal, for an order for ‘assignment by mutual agreement’ to the cultivating tenant. 3. The Tenant is Liable to pay ‘Rent‘ and Land Tax The land being vest in Govt. under Sec. 72, Sec. 72E casts duty on the ‘cultivating tenant’ to pay ‘rent‘ to the Government. In Jagannath Temple Managing Committee v. Siddha Math,  (2015) 16 SCC 542, while dealing with the ‘vesting’ under Land Acquisition Act,1894, it is held that ‘it is a settled principle of law that once a property is vested by an Act of legislature, to achieve the laudable object, the same cannot be divested by the enactment of any subsequent general law and vest such property under such law.’ (LA Act, 1894, Sec. 16 reads as under: Power to take possession. When the Collector has made an award under section 11, he may take possession of the land, which shall thereupon vest absolutely in the Government, free from all encumbrances.) The concept of ‘vesting’ was also considered in The Fruit & Vegetable Merchants Union v. The Delhi Improvement Trust, AIR 1957 SC 344. In this decision it is held as under: “(19) That the word “vest” is a word of variable import is shown by provisions of Indian statutes also. For example, S. 56 of the Provincial Insolvency Act (5 of 1920) empowers the Court at the time of the making of the order of adjudication or thereafter to appoint a receiver for the property of the insolvent and further provides that “such property shall thereupon vest in such receiver”. The property vests in the receiver for the purpose of administering the estate of the insolvent for the payment of his debts after realising his assets. The property of the insolvent vests in the receiver not for all purposes but only for the purpose of the Insolvency Act and the receiver has no interest of his own in the property. On the other hand, Ss. 16 and 17 of the Land Acquisition Act (Act 1 of LA), provide that the property so acquired, upon the happening of certain events, shall “vest absolutely in the Government free from all encumbrances”. In the cases contemplated by Ss. 16 and 17 the property
  • 5. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 5/13 acquired becomes the property of Government without any conditions or limitations either as to title or possession. The legislature has made it clear that the vesting of the property is not for any limited purpose or limited duration. It would thus appear that the word “vest” has not got a fixed connotation meaning in all cases that the property is owned by the person or the authority in whom it vests. It may vest in title, or it may vest in possession, or it may vest in a limited sense, as indicated in the context in which it may have been used in a particular piece of legislation. The provisions of the Improvement Act, particularly Ss. 45 to 49 and 54 and 54-A when they speak of a certain building or street or square or other land vesting in a municipality or other local body or in a trust, do not necessarily mean that ownership has passed to any of them.” [Quoted in Indore Development Authority vs Manoharlal (Arun Mishra, J.), (2020) 8 SCC 129.] Sec. 72E reads as under: 72E. Rent of holdings vested in Government but not assigned to cultivating tenants. – Where in respect of any holding or part thereof, the right, title and interest of the landowner and intermediaries have vested in the Government under Section 72 and the cultivating tenant is not entitled to the assignment of such right, title and interest by virtue of Sub-section (1) of Section 72, the cultivating tenant shall be liable to pay to the Government the rent payable under this Act from the date of vesting under Section 72. With respect to payment of tax it is stated as under in Sec. 72S: 72S. Liability for assessment alter the date of vesting under Section 72. (1)] Notwithstanding anything contained in the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961, or in any other law for the time being in force, or in any contract, where the right, title and interest of the landowner and the intermediaries, if any, in respect of a holding have vested in the Government under Section 72, the cultivating tenant of that holding shall be liable to pay the basic tax payable in respect of that holding under the said Act and other taxes and cesses due in respect of that holding. (2) In the case of a holding or part of a holding in respect of which an application for resumption under the provisions of this Act is rejected, the cultivating tenant shall be liable to pay the basic tax and other taxes and cesses in respect of such holding or part of the holding, as the case may be, with effect on and from the date notified under Sub-section (1) of Section 72. 4. Provisions as to Excess, Ceiling Return, Surrender, Exemption, Etc. Section 81 – exemptions: S. 81, the first Section in Chapter III deals with exemption from ceiling limit of plantation, industrial land, etc. Sec. 81(1)(e) reads as under: “Exemptions: (1) The provisions of this Chapter shall not apply to– (a) lands owned or held by the Government …. …. ….. (e) plantations; …………”
  • 6. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 6/13 Plantation: Under Sec. 2, clause (44), plantation means any land used by a person principally for the cultivation of tea, coffee, cocoa, rubber, cardamom or cinnamon. Section 82 & 83 – ceiling area: S. 82 & 83 deal with ceiling area and bars holding land excess of ceiling fixed. Sec. 83 reads as under: “83. No person to hold land in excess of the ceiling area. With effect from such dates as may be notified by the Government in the Gazette, no person shall be entitled to own or hold or to possess under a mortgage lands in the aggregate in excess of the ceiling area.” Section 85(1) – surrender of excess land: 85. Surrender of excess land. (1) Where a person owns or holds land excess of the ceiling area on the date notified under Section 83, such excess land shall be surrendered as hereinafter provided: …. ….” Read Blog: Relevant provisions of Kerala Land Reforms Act in a Nutshell 5. Effect of Conversion or Sale of A Portion of Exempted Land Section 87 reads as under: “S.87. Excess land obtained by gift, etc. to be surrendered – (1) Where any person acquires any land dafter the date notified under Section 83 by gift, purchase, mortgage with possession, lease, surrender or any other kind of transfer inter vivos or by bequest or inheritance or otherwise and in consequence thereof the total extent of land owned or held by such person exceeds the ceiling area, such excess shall be surrendered to such authority as may be prescribed.        Explanation 1 – Where any land is exempted by or under Section 81 and such exemption is in force on the date notified under Section 83, such land shall, with effect from the date on which it ceases to be exempted, be deemed to be land acquired after the date notified under Section 83.        Explanation II – Where, after the date notified under Section 83, any class of land specified in Schedule II has been converted into any other class of land specified in that Schedule or any land exempt under Section 81 from the provisions of this Chapter is converted into any class of land not so exempt and in consequence thereof the total extent of land owned or held by a person exceeds the ceiling area, so much extent of land as is in excess of the ceiling area, shall be deemed to be land acquired after the said date. Explanation II is explained by the Full Bench of the Kerala High Court in Mathew K. Jacob v. District Environmental Impact Assessment Authority,2018-4 KLT 913, as under: “The consequence is that the benefit of the exemption would be lost and the extent added to the account of the assessee or the declarant in determination of his ceiling area.” That is, if a person converts any portion of his exempted land to any other class, that converted extent will be added to his account in determining his ceiling limit; and the Taluk Land Board can proceed upon that (excess) land. In short, the exemption will be lost for that portion.
  • 7. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 7/13 6. Fragmentation has to be Treated as Conversion for Non-exempted Category The decision in One Earth One Life v. State of Kerala, 2019-2 KHC(SN) 10; 2019-1 KLT 985, arose from the Writ Petition filed for a declaration that the fragmentation and sale of a Rubber Plantation for non-plantation purposes was illegal as it defeated the purpose of the Kerala Land Reforms Act. When the matter was placed before the Taluk Land Board under Sec 87, KLR Act, it found that there was no change in classification of the land and therefore dropped the proceedings. The High Court held as under: “34. Section 81 of the KLR Act is in pith and substance a special provision, with its main objective of giving exemption to certain lands including the lands maintained as plantations is to prevent fragmentation of the land and to keep it as plantation itself to improve the economy of the state for welfare of people as a whole while the Act creates a regime, the State is under an obligation to safeguard, the intended purpose of the provisions of the Act in its spirit. ….. …… It could be gathered from the records that the proposal to transfer 1.03 acres of land to each workers in discharge of their service or retrenchment benefits will definitely divide the plantation into separate slots and that would definitely change the character/nature of the plantation, which could be termed as ‘conversion’ and that will be against the provisions of the Act.” “37. …. Fragmentation of the estate and transfer of it has to be treated as a case of conversion of plantation into some other category of land. Such being the scenario, fragmentation amounts to serious violation of the provisions of KLR Act. Hence, we are not impressed by the argument of the learned counsel for the respondent No.18 that the fragmented plots will be maintained as plantation by the transferees, so as to extend/avail the benefit of HMT’s case (supra). Taking into account of all the relevant aspects, we have no hesitation in holding that dropping of the suo motu proceedings initiated under Section 87 of KLR Act by the TLB in a cursory manner, is not at all reasonable or justifiable when tested on the touchstone of the object and intention, which the legislation seeks to achieve and beyond what is required, in the interest of the public.” 7. Can a Tenant of Plantation Transfer his Rights, Fragmenting the Plantation Possession by itself is a substantive right recognised by law. It is heritable and transferable. (Kuttan Narayanan v. Thomman Mathayi, AIR 1966 Ker 179; Phirayalal Kapur Vs. Jia Rani, AIR 1973 Delhi 186; Nallammal Vs. Ayisha Beevi, 2017-5 Mad LJ 864).  See Blog: POSSESSION is a Substantive Right in Indian Law Therefore, a tenant of plantation having rights of fixity (Sec. 13) may have the right to transfer it to another. In any case, the change of character or nature of the plantation by fragmentation being amount to ‘conversion’ that will be against the provisions of the Act, as pointed out in One Earth One Life v. State of Kerala, 2019-2 KHC(SN) 10; 2019-1 KLT 985. 9. Conclusion Who is the OWNER of Exempted (Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala?
  • 8. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 8/13 It is Government itself. Because, 1. Plantation (lease) lands VEST in GOVT, automatically For the reason – Sec. 72 provides for mandatory and involuntary vesting of leasehold lands in Govt., if the conditions in Sec. 72 are satisfied; that is, (i) held by cultivating tenants; (ii) tenants thereof are entitled to fixity of tenure under Sec. 13. 2. Govt. is the Owner For the reasons – Title is declared to be vested in Government (Sec. 72). The plantation land cannot be assigned to the tenants for the area being above ceiling limit [Sec. 72B(2)]; and no purchase certificate can be issued. Plantation land cannot be fragmented (Sec. 87 Explanation II). Such tenant is liable to pay rent to the Government (Sec. 72E). 3. ‘Exemption’ in Chapter III Cannot be read into Sec. 72B(2) Sec. 72B(2) specifies that the provisions of Section 82 as to ceiling limit shall apply (when assignment is given). The exemption provision in Sec. 81 (Chapter III) cannot be brought-forth or read- into Sec. 72B. Because: Sec. 82 (ceiling limit) itself is not applicable to plantation lands (as Sec. 81 exempts plantation from the provisions of Chapter III). That is, Sec. 82 is an independent provision, not controlled by the exemption provision in Sec. 81. When an independent provision in a Chapter is relied on (or read) in a section of another Chapter, it cannot be said – the colour, light or smell of the entire Chapter of the invitee section is reflected. Further: Chapter II of the KLR Act is exclusive and exhaustive as to ‘fixity’ and ‘vesting’ of land in Government. Proviso to Sec. 72B(1) also show it is an an independent provision. It is not stated anywhere in the Act – the right and title of the (leased-plantation) land vested in Government under Sec. 72, will be divested in any manner (to the previous owner, or to the tenant or to anybody else). Sec. 72E provides for collection of ‘rent‘ from the holders of the plantation, for the reason that the land vests in Govt. In other words, under the KLR Act, the holders of such ‘Plantation-Lease-Lands’ are only ‘Tenants of Government’. Proceedings initiated by Taluk Land Board under Chapter III do not confer title. Therefore, . The Government Need Not Pay ‘Land-Value‘, as such, if such Lands are Acquired. . A tenant who got ‘fixity’ over such land cannot ‘sell’ this land as his absolute property.
  • 9. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 9/13 . Purchase certificate cannot be given by the Land Tribunal for land beyond ceiling limit. Read in this Cluster (Click on the Topic): Book No. 1.   Handbook of a Civil Lawyer Civil Procedure & CPC Civil Rights and Jurisdiction of Civil Courts Pleadings Should be Specific; Why? Best Evidence Rule in Indian Law Declaration and Injunction Res Judicata and Constructive Res Judicata Order II, Rule 2 CPC – Not to Vex Defendants Twice  Notice to Produce Documents in Civil Cases Production of Documents: Order 11, Rule 14 & Rule 12 Modes of Proof – Admission, Expert Evidence, Presumption etc. Marking Documents Without Objection – Do Contents Proved Production, Admissibility & Proof Of Documents Sec. 91 CPC and Suits Against Wrongful Acts Remedies Under Sec. 92 CPC Mandatory Injunction – Law and Principles  Interrogatories: When Court Allows, When Rejects? Can a Party to Suit Examine Opposite Party, as of Right? Decree in OI R8 CPC-Suit & Eo-Nomine Parties Power of attorney No Adjudication If Power of Attorney is Sufficiently Stamped Notary Attested Power-of-Attorney Sufficient for Registration  Permission when a Power of Attorney Holder Files Suit Stamp Act Adjudication as to Proper Stamp under Stamp Act Unstamped & Unregistered Documents and Collateral Purpose Title and Possession Adverse Possession: An Evolving Concept Adverse Possession: Burden to Plead Sabotaged  When ‘Possession Follows Title’; ‘Title Follows Possession’? Civil Procedure – General ‘Mutation’ by Revenue Authorities will not Confer ‘Title’ Does Alternate Remedy Bar Civil Suits and Writ Petitions? Void, Voidable, Ab Initio Void, and Sham Transactions Can Courts Award Interest on Equitable Grounds? Natural Justice – Not an Unruly Horse ‘Sound-mind’ and ‘Unsound-Mind’  Forfeiture of Earnest Money and Reasonable Compensation Who has to fix Damages in Tort and Contract?
  • 10. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 10/13 Notary-Attested Documents: Presumption, Rebuttable Relevant provisions of Kerala Land Reforms Act in a Nutshell Evidence Act – General Expert Evidence and Appreciation of Evidence How to Contradict a Witness under Sec. 145, Evidence Act Rules on Burden of proof and Adverse Inference Best Evidence Rule in Indian Law Modes of Proof – Admission, Expert Evidence, Presumption etc. Significance of Scientific Evidence in Judicial Process Polygraphy, Narco Analysis and Brain Mapping Tests  Sec. 65B Sections 65A & 65B, Evidence Act and Arjun Panditrao: in Nutshell Sec. 65B, Evidence Act: Arjun Paditrao Criticised. Sec. 65B Evidence Act Simplified ‘STATEMENTS’ alone can be proved by ‘CERTIFICATE’ u/s. 65B  Sec. 65B,  Evidence Act: Certificate for Computer Output Certificate is Required Only for ‘Computer Output’; Not for ‘Electronic Records’: Arjun Panditrao Explored. Documents Oral Evidence on Contents of Document, Irrelevant Marking Documents Without Objection – Do Contents Stand Proved? Proof of Documents & Objections To Admissibility – How & When?  Notary-Attested Documents: Presumption, Rebuttable Presumptions on Registered Documents & Collateral Purpose Notice to Produce Documents in Civil Cases Production of Documents: Order 11, Rule 14 & Rule 12 Modes of Proof – Admission, Expert Evidence, Presumption etc. Marking Documents Without Objection – Do Contents Proved Production, Admissibility & Proof Of Documents Substantive Documents, and Documents used for Refreshing Memory and Contradicting  Visual and Audio Evidence (Including Photographs, Cassettes, Tape- recordings, Films, CCTV Footage, CDs, e-mails, Chips, Hard-discs, Pen-drives) Relevancy, Admissibility and Proof of Documents Contract Act ‘Sound-mind’ and ‘Unsound-Mind’ in Indian Civil Laws Forfeiture of Earnest Money and Reasonable Compensation Who has to fix Damages in Tort and Contract? Easement What is Easement? Does Right of Easement Allow to ‘Enjoy’ After Making a Construction? What is “period ending within two years next before the institution of the suit”?
  • 11. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 11/13 Is the Basis of Every Easement, Theoretically, a Grant Extent of Easement (Width of Way) in Easement of Necessity Village Pathways and Right to Bury are not Easements. Custom & Customary Easements in Indian Law ‘Additional Burden Loses Lateral Support’ – Incorrect Proposition Book No. 2: A Handbook on Constitutional Issues Judicial & Legislative Activism in India: Principles and Instances Can Legislature Overpower Court Decisions by an Enactment? Separation of Powers: Who Wins the Race – Legislature or Judiciary? Kesavananda Bharati Case: Never Ending Controversy Mullaperiyar Dam: Disputes and Adjudication of Legal Issues Article 370: Is There Little Chance for Supreme Court Interference Maratha Backward Community Reservation: SC Fixed Limit at 50%. Polygraphy, Narco Analysis and Brain Mapping Tests  CAA Challenge: Divergent Views Religious issues Secularism and Art. 25 & 26 of the Indian Constitution Secularism & Freedom of Religion in Indian Panorama ‘Ban on Muslim Women to Enter Mosques, Unconstitutional’ No Reservation to Muslim and Christian SCs/STs (Dalits) Why? Parsi Women – Excommunication for Marrying Outside  Sabarimala Review Petitions & Reference to 9-Judge Bench Ayodhya Disputes: M. Siddiq case –Pragmatic Verdict  Book No. 3: Common Law of CLUBS and SOCIETIES in India General Features Bye Laws Fundamental Effect of Registration of Societies and Incorporation of Clubs Societies and Branches Vesting of Property in Societies and Clubs Juristic Personality of Societies and Clubs Incidents of Trust in Clubs and Societies Legal Personality of Trustees and Office Bearers  Suits By or Against Societies, Clubs and Companies Court’s Jurisdiction to Interfere in the Internal Affairs  How to Sue Societies, Clubs and Companies Amendment of Bye laws of Societies and Clubs Dissolution of Societies and Clubs Rights & Liabilities of Members of Clubs and Societies Management – Powers of General Body and Governing Body Expulsion of Members & Removal of Office-Bearers Election & Challenge in Societies and Clubs Court Interference in Election Process Individual Membership Rights in Societies & Clubs
  • 12. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 12/13 State-Interference in Affairs of Societies & Clubs Law on Meetings: An Overview Book No. 4: Common Law of TRUSTS in India General Principles What is Trust in Indian Law? Public & Private Trusts in India. Public Trusts and Indian Trusts Act – An Overview Incidents of Trust in Clubs and Societies Public Trusts and (State) Endowments/Trusts Acts Trust is ‘An Obligation’; Not a Legal Entity Dedication and Vesting Dedication of Property in Public Trusts Vesting of Property in Trusts Indian Law Does Not Accept Salmond, as to Dual Ownership Trustees and Management Trustees and Administration of Public Trusts Alienation of Public Trust Property Extinction, Discharge, Revocation, etc. of Public Trusts Breach of Trust Breach of Trust and Removal of Trustees Suits by or against Trusts Suits By or Against Trusts and Trustees Remedies Under Sec. 92 CPC Law on Religious Trusts & Trustees Philosophy of Idol Worship Is an Idol a Perpetual Minor? Hindu Temples & Law of Trusts Law of Mutts and Other Hindu Endowments Legal Personality of Temples, Gurudwaras, Churches and Mosques Shebaits & Mahants and Law of Trustees Ayodhya Disputes: M. Siddiq case – Pragmatic Verdict Sabarimala Review Petitions & Reference to 9-Judge Bench Secularism and Art. 25 & 26 of the Indian Constitution Secularism & Freedom of Religion in Indian Panorama ‘Muslim Women: Ban to Enter Mosques, Is it Unconstitutional  Parsi Women Excommunication, Unconstitutional. General State & Court – Protectors of All Charities Business by Charitable Trusts & Institutions Published by sajikoduvath
  • 13. 5/22/22, 7:05 PM Government is the OWNER of (All Leasehold) Plantation Lands in Kerala. – Saji Koduvath Associates https://indianlawlive.net/2022/04/15/who-is-the-owner-of-plantation-lands-in-kerala/ 13/13 Leave a Comment Saji Koduvath Associates, Blog at WordPress.com. View all posts by sajikoduvath Enter your comment here... Enter your comment here...