SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Petroleum
Canada’sFuel
FUEL 2014
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 2014ii
THE VOICE OF CANADA’S TRANSPORTATION FUELS INDUSTRY.
canadianfuels.ca 1
The Canadian Fuels Association represents the industry that produces,
distributes and markets petroleum products in Canada—including 95 percent
of the transportation fuels Canadians rely on to remain mobile and globally
competitive. The fuels sector contributes $5.6 billion to Canada’s GDP each
year and employs nearly 100,000 Canadians at 18 refineries, 21 primary fuel
distribution terminals and 12,000 retail and commercial sites throughout Canada.
Contents
MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR AND PRESIDENT	 2
PETROLEUM. CANADA’S FUEL.	 4
BUILDING ON A HISTORY OF PROGRESS	 10
CRYSTAL BALLS AND SILVER BULLETS	 18
SECTOR PERFORMANCE	 24
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20142
Canada’spetroleumfuels.Poweringtransportation
todayandtomorrow.
The petroleum fuels industry has long played a pivotal role in
building Canada’s transportation capacity. Our members have
established a comprehensive nationwide infrastructure that produces
and delivers the 85 billion litres of high quality transportation fuels
that keep Canada on the move each year. We continually lend our
expertise to policy discussions about the essential role of transpor-
tation energy in this country. Fuel refining contributes $5.6 billion
to Canada’s annual GDP. The fuels sector provides jobs for nearly
100,000 Canadians. It’s a record of achievement that Canadians have
recognizedbymakingourproductstheirtransportationfuelsofchoice.
This consumer preference comes with great responsibility. It falls on
Canadian Fuels Association members to ensure that we continue
fuelling Canada’s travel and trade to help keep our country competi-
tive and contribute to our standard of living.
Webelieveit’simportantforallCanadianstounderstandthefundamental
connection between transportation energy and prosperity. Over the
past year and a half, our association has actively engaged stake­holders
in an open discussion about the vital importance and future of
transportation fuels. As part of this work, we commissioned two of
Canada’s leading independent public-policy think tanks to conduct
a series of roundtables across the country.
The effort has struck a chord and fostered thoughtful discussions. Many
fascinating and important points have been raised. It came as no
surprise to us that amid the dialogue about the social, environmental
and economic challenges of various fuel and vehicle technologies, it
iswellunderstoodthatpetroleumisvitallyimportantnotonlyfortoday,
but also for the central role it will continue to play in years to come.
The research concurs. In September, the U.S. Energy Information
Administration published its International Energy Outlook 2014. The
report examines the global future of petroleum and other liquid
fuels to 2040. It characterizes global markets as very dynamic—
especially in China, India and the Middle East—and projects
petroleum fuels will remain the dominant energy source for
transportation in Canada throughout the forecast period.
This is not simply the opinion of those in the petroleum sector. It is a
position held by many experts who are eminently knowledgeable
about transportation energy in Canada—past, present and future.
TheCanadianFuelsAssociationwelcomestheinsightsoffouraccom-
plishedexperts in this report. Interspersed throughout, you’ll read the
opinionsandpredictionsofDavidBradley,CEOoftheCanadianTrucking
Alliance and president of the Ontario Trucking Association; Mark
Nantais, president of the CanadianVehicle Manufacturers’Association;
Bob Oliver, executive director of Pollution Probe; and Dr. Heather
MacLean, professor of civil engineering at the University of Toronto.
They all believe that an increasing number of innovative fuel and
vehicle technologies will populate Canadian roads in the future.
While no expert can be precise about when that future will arrive—or
what the technological mix will be—the best information we have
today clearly indicates that a major transformation will take decades.
This underscores an important point. Petroleum is more than the
fuel of choice for Canadians today; it is the transportation energy
source that will power Canada—and the world, for that matter—
well into the future, underpinning an increasingly diverse fuel and
vehicle mix.
To remain viable and competitive, Canada’s petroleum fuels and
vehicle manufacturing industries are taking bold and determined
steps—and making major investments—to improve overall
product performance. No single technology has a monopoly on
innovation, and the advances being made in petroleum fuels and
conventional vehicle technologies are truly remarkable.
Progress through innovation makes for a healthy, competitive
market today, and ensures consumers—individual and commer-
cial—will have greater choice when it comes to transportation
options tomorrow. 
Message from the Chair and President
canadianfuels.ca 3
Bob I. Baird
CHAIR
Canadian Fuels Association
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, DOWNSTREAM
Husky Energy Inc.
Peter Boag
PRESIDENT and CEO
Canadian Fuels Association
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20144
Section 1
Petroleum. Canada’s fuel.
Transportation fuels hold deep value for Canadians.
We depend on them.
A long road in any weather
Canadians are well aware of the crucial role transportation plays in connecting us to each other and
the world. Our quality of life has risen steadily as marine, railway, road and aviation arteries have
threaded their way across the country and into many of its most remote regions. Today, transporta-
tion accounts for about 30 percent of our total energy use, making Canadians among the highest
per capita users of transportation fuels in the world. Our level of fuel consumption comes as no
surprise given our relatively small and widely dispersed population, as well as the extreme distances
and varieties of terrains and climatic conditions we face when travelling across Canada.
Truckers have perhaps the greatest appreciation for the challenges of Canada’s geography, and few
people have a better understanding of the vital importance of trucking than David Bradley.
FAST FACTS
•	 For-hire trucking accounts for 31% of the transportation services sector’s $53B share (4.2%) of Canada’s GDP—
greater than air, rail and water transport combined.
•	 Trucks move 90% of all consumer products and foodstuffs.
•	 Between 2011 and 2020, the for-hire trucking industry is expected to experience an output increase of 26% from
$17 billion annually to $21.4 billion in constant dollars.
•	 As a whole, the trucking industry (including for-hire carriers, private carriers, owner-operators and courier firms) generates
more than $65 billion in revenues per year, with the for-hire sector accounting for over $40 billion alone.
•	 There are more than 300,000 truck drivers in Canada today. Approximately 180,000 (60%) are employed in
the for-hire sector of the trucking industry.
•	 Nearly 1% of the Canadian population and more than 1.5% of the labour force are truck drivers.
•	 For-hire trucking accounts for 278,000 direct jobs and provides for almost 480,000 jobs overall, resulting in $24 billion in
personal income and $4.2 billion in personal income taxes.
•	 The total economic footprint of the for-hire trucking industry was almost $37 billion in 2011.
canadianfuels.ca 5
“I DON’T SEE ANY ALTERNATIVE DISPLACING DIESEL
AS THE PREDOMINANT FUEL FOR THE TRUCKING
INDUSTRY IN MOST OF OUR LIFETIMES.”
contributor
DAVID BRADLEY
CEO, Canadian Trucking Alliance
President, Ontario Trucking Association
David earned his master’s in economics from
Queen’s University following undergraduate
work at University of Toronto. Beginning his
career with roles in management consulting
and financial market analysis, he took over
leadership of the Ontario Trucking Association
in 1991, and the Canadian Trucking Alliance in
1997. David Bradley is passionate and outspoken
about the crucial value of truck transport, having
guided the industry in Canada and its largest
province through some of trucking’s most
turbulent and transformative times. His
expertise is regularly sought by federal,
provincial and international organizations to
ensure boards, committees and advisory groups
benefit from the industry’s vital perspective.
Canadian Trucking Alliance (CTA)
The CTA is a federation of the country’s
provincial trucking associations. Representing
approximately 4,500 carriers, owner-
operators and industry suppliers, the CTA
is the industry’s voice on national and
international policies, and on regulatory
and legislative matters that affect trucking.
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20146
“Without fuel the trucks don’t move,
and no other fuel compares to diesel in
terms of economy and energy output.”
-- David Bradley
canadianfuels.ca 7
If you got it, a truck brought it.
According to Bradley, that statement is as true today as it’s ever been. Approximately 90 percent of
all consumer products and foodstuffs in Canada are moved by truck.“The reason is that we provide
an efficient service,”says Bradley.“Trucking isn’t always the cheapest mode, but it’s the service that’s
able to provide the flexible, time-sensitive service most shippers need.”
Where railways’niche is the long distance transport of heavy bulk commodities, trucking is ideally suited
to the short distance, smaller-by-volume marketplace and moving high value-added manufactured
and consumer goods.
“Trucking is a hyper-competitive industry that’s been highly innovative in the constant pursuit
of efficiency,”adds Bradley. Little wonder that fuel efficiency has been a growing concern in
recent decades.
Truck manufacturers have responded with new fuel-efficient engines, advanced drivetrains and more
aerodynamic cabs and trailers. Fleets have optimized routing procedures and examined ways to
improve driver training and performance. Governments have introduced new fuel economy standards.
When it comes to fuel, diesel remains the trucking
industry’s first choice.
“It’s pretty basic,”says Bradley.“Without fuel the trucks don’t move, and no other fuel compares to
diesel in terms of economy and energy output.”
The trucking industry is Canada’s largest consumer of diesel fuel. Diesel accounts for between
15 and 40 percent of a company’s operating costs—and it’s the greatest single expense for the more
than 45,000 individual owner-operators.
“The petroleum producers operate to a very high standard and the quality of the fuel is very good,”
says Bradley.“I don’t see any alternative displacing diesel as the predominant fuel for the trucking
industry in most of our lifetimes.”
Bradley acknowledges close ties between the trucking and petroleum fuels industries. It’s a
relationship built over more than a century, and one he believes could be improved with greater
communication, particularly with regard to factors that influence fuel prices, and the need for
adequate Canadian refining infrastructure to consistently meet demand.
Figure 1.1: Shares of Canada-United States trade by mode, 2012
Trucks move more goods
(57%byvalue)toandfrom
the U.S.—our largest trading
partner—than all other
modes of transportation
combined.
Source: Transport Canada, Transportation in Canada 2013, Statistical Addendum
Total:
$
572,971
millionsof
dollars
Road $
324,870
56.7%
Rail $
102,227
17.8%
Marine $
31,538
5.5%
Air $
27,986
4.9%
Other $
86,350
15.1%
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20148
“Reliability of supply historically has not been an issue,”says Bradley,
“but when a refinery goes down for maintenance it can really have
an impact. And if something goes wrong at another one, then
we find ourselves quickly in a situation where companies are
scrambling for fuel.”
Canada’s petroleum refiners believe the key to a secure supply is
a viable and competitive Canadian refining industry, which will
ensure truckers won’t need to rely on imported fuels and find
themselves at the end of a long and potentially less reliable
foreign fuel supply chain.
Comparing the alternatives
Bradley supports all fuel solutions that work and reduce costs,
but he’s skeptical about bio-diesel.“I don’t believe bio-diesel is
an alternative in the true sense of the word,”says Bradley.“It’s not
where we want to go as an industry; it’s not where the manufac-
turers of heavy trucks want to go. We think it’s so 1990s. It’s
presented as part of an off-oil strategy and being good for the
environment. That’s nonsense. Bio-diesel was introduced in
North America as a gesture to the agricultural sector to create a
market for farmers. I don’t think it’s worked; and the concerns of
manufacturers and the trucking industry about the impact of
biofuels on engines and warranties have been virtually ignored.”
In Bradley’s opinion, electricity holds near-term promise as an
energy source only in smaller trucks and short-haul pick-up and
delivery applications.
“If you look at real alternative fuels, the one that has the most
potential for us is liquid natural gas [LNG],”says Bradley.“The
technology works, the fuel is plentiful, the technology is made
in Canada and the GHG impact is lower. But LNG has challenges
too. The distribution infrastructure isn’t there right now and LNG
tractors cost 60 to 100 percent more than traditional vehicles.
It’s going to take time, but certainly it is the alternative fuel with
the most potential.”
LNG is an attractive alternative partly due to its cost.“LNG is
cheaper than diesel right now,”acknowledges Bradley,“but it’s
not being taxed. That will change as fleets transition to LNG, and
governments see tax revenue decline. The price will go up. The
same thing happened with propane, which was supposed to be
the big solution 30 years ago.”
A partner in regulatory change
According to Bradley, truckers also want to see greater collabo-
ration with governments to develop new fuel economy standards.
“People may think,‘We did it for cars, we can do it for trucks,’”says
Bradley in reference to recent and successive tiers of federal fuel
and light-duty vehicle standards.“But they are two completely
different vehicle types. We can’t take the same approach as the
Americans to achieving greater fuel economy, nor can we
simply adopt U.S. standards in Canada. Our industry is different.
We face dramatically different conditions here; there’s a greater
range of equipment, engines and applications in Canada’s
heavy-duty fleet.”
Bradley emphasizes the trucking industry’s support for new
heavy-duty vehicle fuel standards, but this support is tempered
by a strong conviction that trucking’s expertise must be at the
table to inform an effective and realistic regulatory framework.
Greater government and industry partnership is key to achieve
mutual goals for greater efficiency and environmental perfor-
mance—while upholding trucking’s vital contribution to
Canada’s economy.
“We want to make sure these standards work,”says Bradley.“It’s in
our interest to improve fuel economy, but we’re going to have
to get more sophisticated in terms of how we approach these
things in Canada.” 
“There have been many attempts to sell the industry snake
oil over the years,”says David Bradley.“Truckers have a
natural skepticism about new fuels. They want to see
things in action.They want to see the horsepower and that
a solution works in all the conditions we face in Canada.”
canadianfuels.ca 9
The key to a secure supply of petroleum
fuels is a viable and competitive Canadian
refining industry.
Figure 1.2: Traffic volume by Canadian
for-hire carriers
Source: Transport Canada, Transportation in Canada 2013,
Statistical Addendum
Figure 1.3: Domestic sales of gasoline and diesel
Source: Statistics Canada
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Metrictonnes(millions)
Total international Total domestic
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Cubicmetres(millions)
Diesel fuel oil Motor gasoline
For-hire trucking traffic
is expected to continue
growing through at
least 2020.
While gasoline sales are
essentially flat to declining,
diesel sales are rising due
mainly to demand in
truck transport.
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201410
Section 2
Building on a history of progress
Pollution Probe’s Bob Oliver, and Mark Nantais of the CVMA,
talk about how transportation fuel formulations have
changed substantially over the years—and continue to
improve in response to changing vehicle and consumer
needs and expectations.
Exceeding emissions standards
“The light-duty on-road transportation sector is the only economic sector to demonstrate a
continuous and sustained reduction in smog-causing emissions year over year from 1985 to 2012,”
says the CVMA’s Mark Nantais.“It’s really quite a success story.”
During that time, the automotive and petroleum refining industries were subjected to a range of
successive government regulations aimed primarily at reducing levels of criteria air contaminants
including nitrogen oxides, sulphur oxides, volatile organic compounds and particulate matter.
In response, Canada’s new vehicle fleets have outperformed emissions-standard requirements, in
part through a history of collaboration.
“I’ve been in the business more than 30 years,”says Nantais,“and there’s always been a technical
forum where the oil and auto industries meet regularly throughout the year to identify appropriate
fuel quality for the efficient operation of engines and emissions-control technologies.”
FAST FACTS
•	 Canada is the world’s ninth largest vehicle producer, generating nearly 4% of global output.
•	 The automotive sector is Canada’s biggest contributor to manufacturing GDP.
•	 More than 20% of all trade with U.S. is associated with vehicle manufacturing—approximately $100B each year.
•	 Approximately 500,000 Canadian jobs are directly and indirectly associated with the automotive industry including
eight assembly plants, multiple components plants, more than 400 parts manufacturers, and nearly 3,700 dealerships.
•	 For every assembly line job, the industry creates nine others to benefit surrounding communities.
canadianfuels.ca 11
contributor
MARK NANTAIS
President, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’
Association (CVMA)
A native of Windsor, Ontario, Mark Nantais has a
long family history in the automotive industry on
both sides of the Canada-U.S. border. He joined the
CVMA in 1984 and has been president since 1994.
His responsibilities include policy development and
the overall strategic direction of the organization.
His educational background in biological and
environmental studies, computer science and
systems analysis has served him well in leading
the CVMA’s activities in the areas of engineering,
environmental performance, alternative fuels,
energy efficiency and technical standards
harmonization. A member of numerous boards
and councils, Nantais has served as the automotive
industry representative on several government
consultative groups, as well as Canada’s delegation
to the Canada-U.S. Air Quality Agreement
specifically in the area of ground level ozone.
CanadianVehicle Manufacturers’Association
For nearly a century, CVMA members have
helped ensure Canada enjoys the economic
and social advantages of a strong domestic
automotive industry.Today, the CVMA continues
to represent the Canadian auto industry’s
largest manufacturers, giving them a single voice
on issues of strategic national importance.
“The light-duty on-road transportation
sector is the only economic sector
that’s made continuous and sustained
reductions in smog-causing emissions
year over year from 1985 to 2012.”
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201412
Striking a fair balance
Pollution Probe’s Bob Oliver agrees that the joint achievements do constitute a success story.“It’s
clear that there’s a healthy and robust collaboration,”says Oliver.“There’s also a healthy tension, but
we end up with a fair balance between the burden on the automaker to make the vehicle that runs
as clean as possible, and the petroleum refiners to deliver the fuel that enables automakers to make
clean-running vehicles.”
According to Oliver, the distinction is important. When he delved into an examination of transpor-
tation fuels beginning in 2004, Oliver quickly realized that the goal wasn’t so much about cleaning
up the fuel as ensuring it enabled vehicles to achieve what was technically possible in terms of
emissions reductions.“Fuels are formulated specifically to enable the vehicle to limit emissions.”
“That’s what we call the total systems approach,”says Nantais,“where the technology is supported
concurrently by appropriate levels of fuel quality in the marketplace. That’s how you optimize
emissions reductions and emissions control efficiencies, and that’s what delivers the optimum
environmental benefits consumers expect.”
“In the context of regional air-quality
management and smog causing
pollutants, light-duty vehicles built to
the new standard are nearing the point
where their emissions could be
considered all but negligible.”
FAST FACTS
•	 Pollution Probe was instrumental in the passage of provincial legislation in the late 1990s that led to implementation
of Ontario’s Drive Clean program.
•	 In the early 2000s, the organization played a central role in supporting stringent sulphur-in-fuel regulations and tighter air
pollution standards for light- and heavy-duty vehicles.
•	 In 2004, Pollution Probe began significant research to explore ways to improve the fuel efficiency of new vehicles.
These efforts were instrumental in informing development of federal regulations to limit GHG emissions from all new
light-duty vehicles in Canada beginning with the 2011 model year.
-- Bob Oliver
canadianfuels.ca 13
“REDUCING SULPHUR CONTENT HAS
ALLOWED AUTOMAKERS TO BRING
FORWARD MORE EFFECTIVE EMISSIONS
CONTROL TECHNOLOGIES AND THUS
CONTRIBUTETO MUCH LOWER LEVELS
OF SMOG-FORMING POLLUTANTS.”
contributor
BOB OLIVER
Executive Director, Pollution Probe
Bob Oliver is a mechanical engineer with
more than 15 years experience managing
industrial projects and developing strategies
for energy efficiency and GHG reduction. At
the helm of Pollution Probe since 2008, he has
built strong relationships with governments
and industry to advance practical solutions
to environmental challenges. He is credited
with establishing Pollution Probe’s
Transportation Program through which the
organization launched effective campaigns
to help reduce transportation-related GHG
emissions across Canada. The researcher
and author behind several major reports
on transportation technology and policy,
Mr. Oliver is also a member of many expert
panels and committees including the National
Advisory Committee on Energy Efficiency and
the Steering Committee for Canada’s Electric
Vehicle Roadmap.
Pollution Probe
Pollution Probe is one of Canada’s longest-
serving and most respected non-profit
environmental organizations. Since 1969,
it has worked effectively to improve the
health and well being of Canadians by
advancing policies that achieve positive,
tangible environmental change.
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201414
Figure 2.2: Sulphur in gasoline and on-road diesel, Canada
Quarterly volume-weighted averages are shown. Source: Canadian Fuels member companies (excluding Husky Energy Inc.
and NOVA Chemicals (Canada) Ltd.). Data includes imports.
Figure 2.3: 1995–2012 Historical emissions for Canada for light-duty gasoline vehicles (in tonnes)
Source: Environment Canada, Pollutant Inventories and Reporting Division, 2013
Since 2005, petroleum refiners have invested
$5 billion to reduce sulphur levels in gasoline
by more than 90%, and in diesel by 97%.
The fuel and vehicle
industries‘ total systems
approach has delivered
dramatic reductions in
light-duty vehicle emis-
sions of sulphur oxides,
nitrous oxides and volatile
organic compounds. These
reductions were achieved
without any sacrifice to
the high energy output
of gasoline.
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
350,000
300,000
250,000
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
0
10,000
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
Tonnes(NOX
/VOCs)
Tonnes(SOX
)
NOX
VOCs SOX
Gasoline On-road diesel
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Sulphurcontent(partspermillion)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Figure 2.1: New motor vehicle sales, Canada
Source: Statistics Canada. Note: light trucks include minivans, sport-utility
vehicles, light trucks and vans.
2010 2011 2012 2013
2,000,000
1,800,000
1,600,000
1,400,000
1,200,000
1,000,000
800,000
600,000
400,000
200,000
0
Buses Light trucksHeavy trucks Passenger cars
2013 was a record year for
light vehicle sales in Canada,
with 1,743,112 vehicles sold.
2014 is on track to set a new
sales record.
canadianfuels.ca 15
Back in the 1980s, this meant eliminating lead from gasoline.
The heavy metal impeded the effectiveness of early automotive
catalytic converters, first introduced in 1975. In the past decade,
the main target was sulphur for much the same reason.
“Sulphur poisons the reaction in a catalytic converter,”explains
Oliver.“Reducing sulphur content has allowed automakers to
bring forward more effective emissions control technologies and
thus contribute to much lower levels of smog-forming pollutants.”
FederalSulphurinGasolineRegulations introduced in 2000 lowered
sulphur levels in gasoline from 150 parts per million (ppm) on
average in 2002 to less than 30 ppm by 2005. Sulphur in Diesel
Fuel Regulations implemented in 2006 cut sulphur in on-road
diesel from 500 ppm to 15 ppm (see Figure 2.2).
Both the automotive and petroleum fuel industries are now
preparing to meet new, tougher Tier 3 regulatory requirements,
which will reduce vehicle emissions another 80 percent from
the Tier 2 standards while cutting sulphur in gasoline to just
10 ppm beginning in 2017— approximately 97 percent lower
than in 2004.“The Tier 3 vehicle emissions standards will be the
most stringent of their kind in the world,”says Mark Nantais.
Driving emissions toward zero
“The Tier 3 standards will further reduce the contribution that
light-duty vehicles make to urban air pollution,”says Oliver.
“We are already seeing cleaner air as a result of lower vehicle
emissions, and we are looking at even cleaner air in the future.
In the context of regional air-quality management and smog
causing pollutants, light-duty vehicles built to the new standard
are nearing the point where their emissions could be considered
all but negligible.”
Mark Nantais agrees with Oliver’s assessment.“TheTier 3 standards
will take us down to virtually zero-emission vehicles.”
As impressive as those specifications may be, they pose technical
andinvestmentchallengestodevelopsophisticatednewemission-
control systems, since the vehicles, by regulation, will have to meet
the standard not just on the showroom floor, but also for their
full useful life—roughly 240,000 kilometres.
“Concurrently,”says Nantais,“new technology-forcing GHG emission
standards will basically double fuel efficiency over that which was
implemented in 2010. Every category of vehicle that a company
produces will have to meet stringent standards. That will take us
to 54 miles per gallon [4.4 l /100 km], roughly a five percent
year-over-year improvement, which is unprecedented in the
history of the automotive industry.”
Every option is on the table
According to Nantais, automakers will take a broad range of
approaches to meet fleet targets.“There’s no silver bullet,”says
Nantais.“We will see continued improvements to internal
combustion engines [ICE] and drive trains, changes to aerodyna­
mics, use of light-weight materials, even the way we manufacture
these vehicles. The ICE is going to be around for a long time, so
the need for petroleum fuels is ongoing, but there’s no single
technology pathway that is the solution here. Alternative fuels
must be part of the slate to help us meet upcoming standards.”
To that end, the industry continues to explore hybrid vehicles and
battery electric vehicles, as well as natural gas and biofuel options.
“We have to be careful that biofuel blends are properly formulated,”
says Nantais,“and that the distillation curve essentially mirrors
gasoline’s to ensure the vehicle can perform as intended.You
just can’t add more ethanol because you think it’s a good idea.”
Oliver notes that the emissions performance of vehicles depends
on an alignment of fuel formulation with the requirements of
emissions control systems.“Any change in the composition of
“Any change in the composition of fuels to accommodate
alternatives to gasoline and diesel … will require an
associated change in the design and operation of
engine emissions control technology.” -- Bob Oliver
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201416
fuels,”he says,“to accommodate alternatives to gasoline and
diesel, for example, will require an associated change inthedesign
andoperationofengineemissionscontroltechnology.So when
you’re talking about diversifying the mix of transportation fuels
available to consumers, your scope of change needs to
encompass vehicle specifications as well.”
Going forward together
This alignment of fuel and vehicle technology reflects an
increasingly integrated North American market. With the
formation of the United States–Canada Regulatory Cooperation
Council (RCC) in 2011, the two countries set out to align their
regulatory approaches, reduce red tape and make it easier for
companies to do business on both sides of the border. Tier 2
and 3 fuel and vehicle standards, for example, are harmonized
in Canada and the U.S.
“We are strong supporters of the RCC,”says Nantais.“Our vision
remains one product, tested once and certified once for sale
across one integrated U.S. and Canadian market.”
“I don’t think there is an alternative
to gasoline or diesel.”
The automakers’vision by extension means that fuels must also be
harmonized on a continental basis while correcting for seasonal dif‑
ferences.“It’s in support of the total systems approach,”says Nantais,
“where appropriate fuel quality supports vehicle performance and
emissions control technology concurrently in the marketplace.”
He feels the demand for boutique fuels as a result of varying
provincial fuel standards is troublesome.“Petroleum refiners
Mark Nantais feels the demand for boutique fuels
as a result of varying provincial fuel standards is
troublesome.“Petroleum refiners need consistent
requirements nationwide the same as we do.”
-- Bob Oliver
canadianfuels.ca 17
need consistent requirements nationwide the same as we do,”
says Nantais.“That consistency is presently driven by Canadian
General Standards Board specifications, but not all provinces
adhere to CGSB specs. We need to work on that to ensure a
consistent market.”
Uniquely Canadian challenges
As for other alternatives, Nantais sees most facing the same
hurdle—infrastructure—imposed in part by Canada’s formi­
dable geography and the long distances we must travel.
“It’s the total systems approach again,”says Nantais, “the
technology supported by the fuels and, in this case, the
infrastructure. We have very few E-85 filling stations in Canada.
Natural gas is a very good fuel with low emissions, but it’s always
had an infrastructure issue. Fuel cells: we know how to do that.
We have to get the cost down, but where is the infrastructure?
We are seeing increasing electrification of the fleet, but we need
the recharging infrastructure.”
Bob Oliver questions whether the word alternative is appropriate
to the fuel discussion. “I don’t think there is an alternative to
gasoline or diesel,”he says. “Technically speaking, the clean
substitute for gasoline is cleaner gasoline. Fuels are different and
each offers its own value proposition.You cannot simply drop
any alternative fuel into an engine and expect it to operate as
efficiently as on the fuel for which it was designed.”
Oliver is of the opinion that cleaner petroleum fuels and more
efficient conventionally powered vehicles challenge the appeal of
alternatives.“As you address air pollution and GHG emissions—
and both are going down as a result of sustained improvements
to the incumbent technology—the value proposition for natural
gas, electricity or biofuels will increasingly have to rest on
superior economic and technical performance, because
environmental performance is going to be a reduced advantage
over time.”
He points to electric vehicles, the focus of much of Pollution
Probe’s recent work. “We’re not pushing electric vehicles
exclusively as a clean-air solution,”says Oliver.“We’re interested in
them from an energy management perspective, too. When you
put gas in a car’s tank, there’s only one use for it. A plug-in electric
vehicle, however, can offer utilities a range of value-creation
opportunities in terms of power management and energy
storage capability, for example.”
Innovation through regulation
According to Oliver, the effect of government fuel and vehicle
regulations has been to motivate technological change within
the fuels and automotive sectors, and to drive the deploy-
ment of new, emissions-reducing and fuel-saving technolo-
gies in the marketplace. “These changes would not otherwise
happen in response to basic economic forces,”says Oliver.
“The result of increased, regulation-induced technological
sophistication in vehicles and fuels is cleaner air and mitigation
of greenhouse gas emissions.”
Oliver would like to see the regulatory momentum continue.
“Gasoline and diesel are going to be with us for some time,”says
Oliver.“The opportunity now is to replicate the success we’ve
had with the light-duty fleet throughout the transportation
sector: heavy-duty vehicles, off-road vehicles, small engines,
marine vessels, rail.”
Promoting a holistic view
Mark Nantais believes one of the major current challenges is to
ensure that governments don’t pick technology winners and
losers.“Particularly on the GHG side, there will be no one technical
solution,”says Nantais.“We’re encouraging governments to look
at things holistically.There are complementary technologies, and
there’s more diversification on the fuel side. It’s the combination
of all these things that’s ultimately going to drive greater
environmental benefits.” 
“The result of
increased, regulation-
induced technological
sophistication in vehicles
and fuels is cleaner air and
mitigation of greenhouse
gas emissions.” -- Bob Oliver
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201418
Crystal balls and silver bullets
All anyone can really predict about the future of transportation
fuels is that the options will continue to evolve, ensuring Canadians
have a greater variety of fuel choices in years to come.
An informed perspective
“No one can predict the future of fuel and vehicle development, so I won’t try,”says Dr. Heather MacLean.
Yet her experience may give her a clearer view into the crystal ball than many other experts in the
field of fuel and vehicle technology. Her perspective is based largely on exhaustive studies that
compare, from an interdisciplinary perspective, numerous fuel and vehicle options and combinations.
“Our research has evaluated a fairly wide set of options including conventional gasoline-powered
vehicles, hybrids, plug-in hybrids, and battery-powered vehicles,”says MacLean.“We’re also looking
at the production and use of biofuels in vehicles—primarily second generation ligno-cellulosic
biofuels rather than those produced from animal feed crops.”
MacLean and her colleagues rely on life cycle assessment (LCA) to conduct their evaluations. LCA
has emerged in recent years as the method best suited for making equitable comparisons of
different fuel and vehicle technologies.
“Life cycle assessment is frequently employed to evaluate and quantify the environmental implica-
tions of a product,”says MacLean. In the case of a conventional gasoline-powered vehicle, an LCA
would span extraction of the raw material—including oil—manufacturing, use and vehicle disposal.
Two LCA models currently dominate in North America. The U.S. Department of Energy developed
and uses GREET (greenhouse gases, regulated emissions, and energy use in transportation). GHGenius
is the primary model in Canada. Both address more than 100 fuel production pathways and more
than 70 vehicle/fuel combinations.
Section 3
“The second-generation biofuel option
will not cover a very large portion of
the vehicle fleet in the near term.”
-- Heather MacLean
canadianfuels.ca 19
contributor
DR. HEATHER MacLEAN
Professor of Civil Engineering, University of Toronto
Over the past 15 years Heather MacLean has worked closely with the public and
private sectors to evaluate conventional and alternative energy systems. Her
main research focus since studying for her doctorate and joining the faculty at
University of Toronto has been in the development and application of improved
methods to evaluate the environmental and techno-economic impacts of a
broad range of transportation fuel and vehicle technologies.
MacLean has been affiliated with Auto21 (see below) since 2002, leading a
variety of research projects. Collaborating with research partners at the University
of British Columbia and University of Windsor, she has examined technological
change in the automotive industry, the evolution of life cycle assessment, and
emerging automotive technologies. The research is interdisciplinary, involving
public and private sector partners and spanning the fields of public policy and
environmental, chemical and mechanical engineering.
MacLean received a degree in civil engineering from theTechnical University of
NovaScotia(now partofDalhousie University),andanMBA fromSt.Mary’sUniversity.
She earned her MSc. and Ph.D. at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh.
Research for a sustainable domestic automotive sector
Auto21 is a national research initiative supported by the Government
of Canada through the Networks of Centres of Excellence Secretariat.
The organization connects nearly 200 leading Canadian researchers
at 48 universities with more than 130 industry and government partners.
Focusing on six key themes, including powertrains, fuels and emissions,
Auto21’s goal is to create a dynamic R&D community that contributes
to a sustainable and globally competitive Canadian automotive sector.
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201420
Pursuing greater accuracy
LCA is far from a perfect science, but models are being
continually refined to improve their accuracy.“Comparing
conventional and alternative fuel vehicles is very complex,”says
MacLean, who feels that although the analysis models are well
maintained, there can always be improvement.
“The LCA models are generally focused only on environmental
impacts,”says MacLean.“There is a social component of LCA, but
it’s in its infancy. So if one is looking more broadly at sustainability—
balancing economic and environmental tradeoffs—LCA doesn’t
really provide a complete picture.”Her work is also addressing
financial and techno-economic aspects, which are critical to
evaluating the attractiveness of fuel and vehicle technologies.
The refinements to LCA are enabling analysis that’s exceptionally
granular.InarecentAuto21study,MacLeanandherteamdeter­
mined that ethanol (E85) use in a hybrid electric vehicle and
bioelectricity use in a fully electric vehicle can have similar life
cycle fossil energy use and net GHG emissions. The team’s
findings differ with those in the literature, which report better
bioelectricity performance on these metrics compared to ethanol.
Yet the results in a prior study were skewed by the use of vehicles
with demonstrably different performance characteristics that
favoured the bioelectricity option. Using simulation software, the
Auto21 team created vehicles that featured different power-
trains but were otherwise identical in size and acceleration
capability. The work shows the data sensitivity of LCA and the
significance of careful and accurate comparisons.
A vehicle for where you live and
the way you drive
Across years of complex fuel and vehicle comparisons and
analysis, MacLean and her collaborators have found there is no
overall winner; every option involves some trade-offs, be they
environmental or economic. She sees a gradually fragmenting
vehicle market in which various technological solutions have
their place depending on where you live and how you drive.
“A battery powered vehicle would be a good option for someone
with a short commute and living in a jurisdiction with a low-carbon
electricity grid,”says MacLean.“Someone who faces a lot of
stop-and-go traffic would be well served with a hybrid electric
vehicle. A diesel vehicle would be a better choice for driving
long distances.”
Regional geographic differences can create conditions under
which one option is preferred over another. MacLean believes
this is particularly true when considering electric vehicles.“The
regional electricity grid mix varies greatly across Canada,”says
MacLean.“From a GHG-emissions perspective, an electric vehicle
that draws on a hydro-electric grid is far more promising than
one that relies on electricity generated by the high carbon
intensity of coal.”
The main barrier facing electric vehicles is the absence of battery
technology breakthroughs.“There are promising options out
there,”says MacLean,“but electric vehicles still have limitations
with respect to performance, infrastructure and affordability.”
Across years of complex fuel and vehicle comparisons
and analysis, MacLean and her collaborators have found
there is no overall winner.
canadianfuels.ca 21
Tracking biofuel progress
For biofuels, MacLean notes that the variety of feedstocks,
production methods and sources of energy for production are
all very significant in determining life-cycle GHG performance.
“There continues to be a lot of focus on second-generation
biofuels,”says MacLean,“but development has been much
slower than people in the sector would hope to get commercial
scale facilities up and running.”
Progress has been made recently, but a number of challenges
have yet to be overcome, specifically with regard to clarifying
environmental aspects of the technology, as well as financing
and risk management.“The second-generation biofuel option
will not cover a very large portion of the vehicle fleet in the near
term,”says MacLean.
Improving conventional solutions
MacLean and her colleagues have studied petroleum fuels and
conventional internal combustion vehicles in many projects.
She expects the fuel economy and overall performance of these
vehicles will continue to improve. Some improvements will
depend on the use of new lightweight materials, changes to
vehicle size and power, and advances in powertrain technology.
(See Figure 3.1.)
“Some of these improvements may require tradeoffs from
a life cycle perspective,”observes MacLean.“For example,
increases in fuel economy could be offset by a greater amount
of energy required to manufacture lightweight materials that
enable higher efficiency.”
Manufacturing processes may also require highly specialized
materials for which recycling protocols have not yet been
established. Careful LCA provides valuable information about
many of these tradeoffs.
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201422
Figure 3.1: Incremental gains in efficiency of new light duty vehicles
The coming decades will deliver significant
efficiency improvements in conventional
gasoline and diesel powered vehicles
through powertrain innovations, use of
new lightweight materials and increased
hybridization, among other advances.
20
15
10
5
0
Milespergallon(MPG)
2010 2020 2030 2040
HYBRIDIZATION
VEHICLE
DOWNSIZING
BODY AND ACCESSORIES
ADVANCEMENTS
POWERTRAIN
IMPROVEMENTS
MacLean believes the use of petroleum-based fuels may face
challenges if carbon intensity or GHG emissions are a key regulatory
focus—even as emissions of conventional pollutants are virtually
eliminated through Tier 3 fuel and vehicle emission standards.
Nonetheless, she agrees that the movement away from
petroleum fuels will be slower than many people anticipate.
A healthy mix of technologies
When it comes to transportation fuel and vehicle technology,
there is no silver bullet.“I have to keep saying this and some
people consider it a downer, but there’s no clear or optimal
solution,”says MacLean, who sees the benefits of an increasing
number of fuel and vehicle options.“Choice encourages
development on a number of different fronts. There obviously
are some winners and some losers, but we should be careful not
to abandon any technological option prematurely.”
While she expects we will witness some breakthroughs in fuel
and vehicle technologies, various wild cards play havoc with
predictions. The future mix of technologies and the speed of
their adoption will depend on a range of factors including fuel
price and supply, and public policy—about which there’s
considerable uncertainty.
To reveal viable pathways, MacLean believes LCAs and supple-
mentary analyses must begin to address other environmental
impacts as well as financial, supply and logistical issues.
“Although I feel global climate change is an important issue, I’m
hoping that a lot more of the focus is on the overall perspective
and not just GHG emissions,”says MacLean.“There are other
considerations: water use and availability, bio-diversity, land use,
emissions other than GHGs, and efficiency of production—
energy use more generally.”
Promoting a broader approach
MacLean also believes an additional perspective is necessary to
further minimize the environmental impacts of the transporta-
tion sector. She is concerned the work to increase vehicle
efficiency and reduce emissions will be for naught if we don’t
address traffic congestion—a particular problem in urban North
America and transition economies where the number of
vehicles continues to rise.
“Even the most efficient, lowest polluting vehicles won’t
necessarily solve the larger issue if we’re just putting more and
Source: 2013 The Outlook for Energy: A View to 2040, Exxon Mobil.
canadianfuels.ca 23
more vehicles on the road,”says MacLean.“We need a broader
approach—beyond the questions of what fuels or vehicles we
should be using—to look at government policies, consumer
behaviour, infrastructure financing, public transit, land-use
planning and other issues over the next few years.” 
Dr. MacLean would like to acknowledge the support
of two University of Toronto collaborators in her
contribution to this section: Jason Luk, a Ph.D.
student in the Department of Civil Engineering;
and Bradley Saville, a professor in the Department
of Chemical Engineering & Applied Chemistry.
The future mix of technologies and the speed of their
adoption will depend on a range of factors including
fuel price and supply, and public policy—about which
there’s considerable uncertainty.
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201424
SECTOR
PERFORMANCE
Section 4
canadianfuels.ca 25
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201426
Production
To meet demand, Canada’s refineries operate around the clock, producing an average of more than 300 million litres of refined petroleum
products per day. They contribute $5.6 billion in direct GDP to the Canadian economy and employ over 18,000 highly skilled workers.
All numbers below extracted from Energy Markets Fact Book 2014–2015, Natural Resources Canada, 2014.
Canadian supply and demand, 2013
Canadian exports and imports of refined petroleum products
*Certain product shares are based on NRCan analysis.
Sales by product, 2013*
“Other”includes propane, butane, petro-chemical feedstocks, lubricating oils, petroleum
coke, asphalt, etc.
Gasoline 42%
Diesel 28%
Aviation fuels 7%
Heating oil 2%
Heavy fuel oil 3%
Other 18%
Crude oil intake at Canadian refineries
Refinery production
Refined product imports*
Refined product exports
Domestic sales of refined products*
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Billion litres
99 (1.7 MMb/d)
110
13
29
107
Canada is a net exporter of refined
petroleum products, with a production
that exceeds domestic demand.
Driven by increased freight transport,
diesel represents a growing share of
Canada’s petroleum product slate.
Canada has become less reliant on refined petroleum product
imports, while exports have gradually risen in recent years.
The U.S. represents 92 percent of Canada’s export market.
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Billionlitres
Exports Imports
canadianfuels.ca 27
Safety
Canadian Fuels members are continuously working to improve the sector’s safety record, which is one of the best in Canadian manufacturing.
In the past 10 years, total recordable injuries for refining, distribution and retail employees have decreased by 80 percent.
Data: Canadian Fuels Association member companies only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013.
Total employees – Total recordable injury frequencies
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0
Injuryfrequencyper100full-timeworkers
Medical treatment case frequency
Restricted work case frequency
Lost time injury frequency
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201428
CO2
emissions
The refining sector’s CO2 emissions have been reduced by 16 percent in the past 10 years, even while refining has become more intensive
to comply with new, more stringent fuel quality standards. The refining sector accounts for less than 2.5 percent of Canada’s total GHG
emissions. GHG emission reductions from refineries have been driven in part by a 14 percent drop in energy fuel consumption.
Energy fuel consumption of petroleum refineries, annual Total CO2
emissions, Canadian refining industry
350,000,000
340,000,000
330,000,000
320,000,000
310,000,000
300,000,000
290,000,000
280,000,000
270,000,000
2009 201320112010 2012
gigajoules
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
20
19
18
17
16
15
CO2
(Mt)
Environmental performance
Effective environmental stewardship is one of the core values of our members. Over the past 10 years, they have invested more than $7.2 billion
to improve the environmental performance of their refineries and the fuels they produce by reducing air emissions, GHGs and water use.
Data: Canadian Fuels Association member companies only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013.
Canadian Fuels members’total environmental expenditures
2,000
1,800
1,600
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
200
0
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
MillionsofCanadiandollars
Annual Total (left axis) Cumulative Total (right axis)
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Data: Canadian Industrial Energy End-Use Data and Analysis Centre (CIEEDAC),
Simon Fraser University.
Data: Statistics Canada
canadianfuels.ca 29
Air emissions
Canada’s refiners work continually to improve their processes, leading to significant improvements in air emissions.
Data: Environment Canada’s National Pollutant Release Inventory (NPRI).
Nitrogen oxides (NOX)  39%
Carbon monoxide (CO)  46% Sulphur oxides (SOX
)  45%
Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)  38%
Total particulate matter (TPM)  37%
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
35,000
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
Tonnes
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
18,000
16,000
14,000
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
Tonnes
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
Tonnes
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
80,000
70,000
60,000
50,000
40,000
30,000
20,000
10,000
0
Tonnes
120,000
100,000
80,000
60,000
40,000
20,000
0
Tonnes
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Benzene (C6H6)  29%
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Tonnes
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201430
Surplus site remediation
Since 2009, Canadian Fuels members have remediated 828 surplus sites, including 152 in 2013, making them available for industrial,
recreational, residential or commercial use.
Data: Canadian Fuels Association members only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013.
Total Canadian Fuels member sites remediated
Service stations Other sites
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Numberofsites
20132012201120102009
632
196
Water
Canadian Fuels members are committed to using less water and returning it to the environment in a cleaner state. Water intake is down
22 percent since 2005, while effluent deposits continue to be well below maximum allowable limits.
Data: Canadian Fuels Association member refineries only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013.
Refinery water usage Refinery effluent deposits
*Total suspended solids.
Effluent quality
is far better
than required
by regulation.
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
350,000,000
325,000,000
300,000,000
275,000,000
250,000,000
225,000,000
200,000,000
Cubicmetres(m3
)
Intake Discharge
Oil and
grease
Sulphide Ammonia
nitrogen
Phenol T.S.S.*
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
%ofRegulations
Regulations (100%)
canadianfuels.ca 31
500
400
300
200
100
0
Sulphurcontent(partspermillion)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Fuel quality
Fuels have changed significantly in the past decades. Lead was entirely phased out of gasoline and benzene was cut to less than 1 percent
of volume. Refiners have invested over $5 billion to cut sulphur to less than 30 ppm in gasoline and less than 15 ppm in diesel.
Data: Canadian Fuels member companies (excluding Husky Energy Inc. and NOVA Chemicals (Canada) Ltd.). Data includes imports. Quarterly volume-weighted averages are
shown for sulphur in gasoline and on-road diesel.
Benzene in gasoline
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
Benzenecontent(%volume)
Regulation 1.0% (by volume) flat limit
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Sulphur in gasoline
Sulphur in on-road diesel
Sulphur content in gasoline is
90 percent lower than it was
10 years ago. New Tier 3 regulations
will cut sulphur content in gasoline
by 97 percent in 2017 compared to
2004 levels.
Sulphur in Diesel Fuel Regulations
implemented in 2006 cut sulphur
in on-road diesel from 500 ppm
to 15 ppm.
Benzene content is far below the
maximum allowable.
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Sulphurcontent(partspermillion)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201432
Refining sector economic indicators
The refining sector is an important contributor to Canada’s economy, adding $5.6 billion to GDP.
Data: Statistics Canada, The Conference Board of Canada
Refining sector investments (millions of Canadian dollars)
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
Annualinvestments,structures,machineryandequipment
Investments,cumulativetotal
Structures (left axis) Machinery and equipment (left axis) Cumulative total (right axis)
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Refinery employment
20,000
10,000
0
Estimateofrefiningemployment
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Canada’s refining sector employs over
18,000 highly skilled workers, earning
70 percent more on average than the
overall manufacturing sector average.
Canadian refiners have invested over
$2.2 billion a year on average over the
past decade.
Welcome new members
The Canadian Fuels Association is pleased to have welcomed two new members in 2014.
Federated Co-operatives
Saskatoon-based Federated Co-operatives Limited (FCL) is the 45th largest company and the largest non-financial
co-operative in Canada. FCL’s Co-op Refinery Complex (CRC) was the world’s first co-operatively-owned petroleum
refinery. Located in Regina, the CRC manufactures and supplies petroleum products for FCL members through
the Co-operative Retailing System. With a total capacity of 130,000 barrels per day, the CRC is recognized as one of
Canada’s high value-added petroleum refining facilities. It employs more than 900 people.
Irving Oil
Founded in 1924, Irving Oil is a family-owned and privately-held regional energy processing, transporting and
marketing company with headquarters in Saint John, New Brunswick, and U.S. marketing operations in Portsmouth,
New Hampshire. The company operates Canada’s largest refinery, producing 320,000 barrels of finished products
per day. Operations include ten distribution terminals, a fleet of delivery trucks and more than 900 fuelling locations
serving wholesale, commercial and retail customers in Atlantic Canada, Quebec and New England.
For more information,
please visit our website,
canadianfuels.ca
To comment, contact
president@canadianfuels.ca
1000–275 Slater Street
Ottawa, ON  K1P 5H9
613 232 3709  |  canadianfuels.ca
© Canadian Fuels Association 2014
We’ll take you there.
Members

More Related Content

Similar to Canadian Fuels Association - Annual Review 2014

Railway operations in canada
Railway operations in canadaRailway operations in canada
Railway operations in canada
Majid Babaie, MBA, PMP
 
Provincial Outlook – Canada - 2018
Provincial Outlook – Canada  -  2018Provincial Outlook – Canada  -  2018
Provincial Outlook – Canada - 2018
paul young cpa, cga
 
Diane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable Transportation
Diane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable TransportationDiane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable Transportation
Diane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable Transportation
North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation
 
Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016
Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016
Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016
paul young cpa, cga
 
Colorado: Corridor Value and Advocacy
Colorado: Corridor Value and AdvocacyColorado: Corridor Value and Advocacy
Colorado: Corridor Value and AdvocacyPorts-To-Plains Blog
 
Fossil fuel-subsidies
Fossil fuel-subsidiesFossil fuel-subsidies
Fossil fuel-subsidies
Stefanos Diamantis
 
2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation
2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation
2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation
Wisconsin Clean Cities
 
Canadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination Sustainability
Canadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination SustainabilityCanadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination Sustainability
Canadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination Sustainability
North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation
 
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The BasicsAlliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
jkiely1
 
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The BasicsAlliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Joe Kiely
 
Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015
Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015
Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015
marketinglbcg
 
CALSTART Presentation - Boesel
CALSTART Presentation - BoeselCALSTART Presentation - Boesel
CALSTART Presentation - BoeselCALSTART
 
CCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINAL
CCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINALCCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINAL
CCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINALSarah Reid
 
Natural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business models
Natural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business modelsNatural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business models
Natural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business modelspiersfrench
 
GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program
GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program
GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program
GLOBE Series
 
Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...
Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...
Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...Graham Allen
 
The Future of Mobility by Hunter Lovins
The Future of Mobility by Hunter LovinsThe Future of Mobility by Hunter Lovins
The Future of Mobility by Hunter Lovins
sonomaraceway
 
Canadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum Refining
Canadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum RefiningCanadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum Refining
Canadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum Refining
Canadian Fuels Association
 
Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada
Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada
Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada
paul young cpa, cga
 

Similar to Canadian Fuels Association - Annual Review 2014 (20)

C.D.Howe _Institute_e-brief
C.D.Howe _Institute_e-briefC.D.Howe _Institute_e-brief
C.D.Howe _Institute_e-brief
 
Railway operations in canada
Railway operations in canadaRailway operations in canada
Railway operations in canada
 
Provincial Outlook – Canada - 2018
Provincial Outlook – Canada  -  2018Provincial Outlook – Canada  -  2018
Provincial Outlook – Canada - 2018
 
Diane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable Transportation
Diane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable TransportationDiane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable Transportation
Diane Gray - CentrePort Canada: Sustainable Transportation
 
Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016
Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016
Oil and Gas Industry - Commentary and Analysis - Canada - November 18, 2016
 
Colorado: Corridor Value and Advocacy
Colorado: Corridor Value and AdvocacyColorado: Corridor Value and Advocacy
Colorado: Corridor Value and Advocacy
 
Fossil fuel-subsidies
Fossil fuel-subsidiesFossil fuel-subsidies
Fossil fuel-subsidies
 
2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation
2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation
2015 Annual Stakeholder Meeting WSF Recognition Presentation
 
Canadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination Sustainability
Canadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination SustainabilityCanadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination Sustainability
Canadian Presentation of CEC Secretariat Report: Destination Sustainability
 
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The BasicsAlliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
 
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The BasicsAlliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
Alliance Reauthorization Recommendations … The Basics
 
Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015
Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015
Canadian Crude Marketing Cost Reduction Congress 2015
 
CALSTART Presentation - Boesel
CALSTART Presentation - BoeselCALSTART Presentation - Boesel
CALSTART Presentation - Boesel
 
CCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINAL
CCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINALCCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINAL
CCCE_2012_AR_Eng-FINAL
 
Natural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business models
Natural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business modelsNatural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business models
Natural Gas Vehicle Infrastructure business models
 
GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program
GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program
GLOBE 2014 Preliminary Conference Program
 
Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...
Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...
Working Group on Clean Technology, Innovation and Jobs Final Report Engl...
 
The Future of Mobility by Hunter Lovins
The Future of Mobility by Hunter LovinsThe Future of Mobility by Hunter Lovins
The Future of Mobility by Hunter Lovins
 
Canadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum Refining
Canadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum RefiningCanadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum Refining
Canadian Fuels Association - The Economics of Petroleum Refining
 
Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada
Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada
Trade and Foreign Relations| Canada
 

Recently uploaded

RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
BBPMedia1
 
Global Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdf
Global Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdfGlobal Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdf
Global Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdf
Henry Tapper
 
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
LR1709MUSIC
 
Taurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptx
Taurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptxTaurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptx
Taurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptx
my Pandit
 
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptxPutting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Cynthia Clay
 
Business Valuation Principles for Entrepreneurs
Business Valuation Principles for EntrepreneursBusiness Valuation Principles for Entrepreneurs
Business Valuation Principles for Entrepreneurs
Ben Wann
 
Cracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptx
Cracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptxCracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptx
Cracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptx
Workforce Group
 
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptxSet off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
HARSHITHV26
 
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social DreamingExploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Nicola Wreford-Howard
 
anas about venice for grade 6f about venice
anas about venice for grade 6f about veniceanas about venice for grade 6f about venice
anas about venice for grade 6f about venice
anasabutalha2013
 
Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...
Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...
Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...
PaulBryant58
 
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdfWhat are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
HumanResourceDimensi1
 
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop.com LTD
 
India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...
India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...
India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...
Kumar Satyam
 
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdfEnterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
KaiNexus
 
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
awaisafdar
 
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.pptMemorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
seri bangash
 
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
tjcomstrang
 
Improving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small businessImproving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small business
Ben Wann
 
chapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxation
chapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxationchapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxation
chapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxation
AUDIJEAngelo
 

Recently uploaded (20)

RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
 
Global Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdf
Global Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdfGlobal Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdf
Global Interconnection Group Joint Venture[960] (1).pdf
 
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
FINAL PRESENTATION.pptx12143241324134134
 
Taurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptx
Taurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptxTaurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptx
Taurus Zodiac Sign_ Personality Traits and Sign Dates.pptx
 
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptxPutting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
Putting the SPARK into Virtual Training.pptx
 
Business Valuation Principles for Entrepreneurs
Business Valuation Principles for EntrepreneursBusiness Valuation Principles for Entrepreneurs
Business Valuation Principles for Entrepreneurs
 
Cracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptx
Cracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptxCracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptx
Cracking the Workplace Discipline Code Main.pptx
 
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptxSet off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
 
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social DreamingExploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
 
anas about venice for grade 6f about venice
anas about venice for grade 6f about veniceanas about venice for grade 6f about venice
anas about venice for grade 6f about venice
 
Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...
Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...
Accpac to QuickBooks Conversion Navigating the Transition with Online Account...
 
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdfWhat are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
 
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
 
India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...
India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...
India Orthopedic Devices Market: Unlocking Growth Secrets, Trends and Develop...
 
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdfEnterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
 
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
The Parable of the Pipeline a book every new businessman or business student ...
 
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.pptMemorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
Memorandum Of Association Constitution of Company.ppt
 
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
 
Improving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small businessImproving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small business
 
chapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxation
chapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxationchapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxation
chapter 10 - excise tax of transfer and business taxation
 

Canadian Fuels Association - Annual Review 2014

  • 2. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 2014ii THE VOICE OF CANADA’S TRANSPORTATION FUELS INDUSTRY.
  • 3. canadianfuels.ca 1 The Canadian Fuels Association represents the industry that produces, distributes and markets petroleum products in Canada—including 95 percent of the transportation fuels Canadians rely on to remain mobile and globally competitive. The fuels sector contributes $5.6 billion to Canada’s GDP each year and employs nearly 100,000 Canadians at 18 refineries, 21 primary fuel distribution terminals and 12,000 retail and commercial sites throughout Canada. Contents MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR AND PRESIDENT 2 PETROLEUM. CANADA’S FUEL. 4 BUILDING ON A HISTORY OF PROGRESS 10 CRYSTAL BALLS AND SILVER BULLETS 18 SECTOR PERFORMANCE 24
  • 4. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20142 Canada’spetroleumfuels.Poweringtransportation todayandtomorrow. The petroleum fuels industry has long played a pivotal role in building Canada’s transportation capacity. Our members have established a comprehensive nationwide infrastructure that produces and delivers the 85 billion litres of high quality transportation fuels that keep Canada on the move each year. We continually lend our expertise to policy discussions about the essential role of transpor- tation energy in this country. Fuel refining contributes $5.6 billion to Canada’s annual GDP. The fuels sector provides jobs for nearly 100,000 Canadians. It’s a record of achievement that Canadians have recognizedbymakingourproductstheirtransportationfuelsofchoice. This consumer preference comes with great responsibility. It falls on Canadian Fuels Association members to ensure that we continue fuelling Canada’s travel and trade to help keep our country competi- tive and contribute to our standard of living. Webelieveit’simportantforallCanadianstounderstandthefundamental connection between transportation energy and prosperity. Over the past year and a half, our association has actively engaged stake­holders in an open discussion about the vital importance and future of transportation fuels. As part of this work, we commissioned two of Canada’s leading independent public-policy think tanks to conduct a series of roundtables across the country. The effort has struck a chord and fostered thoughtful discussions. Many fascinating and important points have been raised. It came as no surprise to us that amid the dialogue about the social, environmental and economic challenges of various fuel and vehicle technologies, it iswellunderstoodthatpetroleumisvitallyimportantnotonlyfortoday, but also for the central role it will continue to play in years to come. The research concurs. In September, the U.S. Energy Information Administration published its International Energy Outlook 2014. The report examines the global future of petroleum and other liquid fuels to 2040. It characterizes global markets as very dynamic— especially in China, India and the Middle East—and projects petroleum fuels will remain the dominant energy source for transportation in Canada throughout the forecast period. This is not simply the opinion of those in the petroleum sector. It is a position held by many experts who are eminently knowledgeable about transportation energy in Canada—past, present and future. TheCanadianFuelsAssociationwelcomestheinsightsoffouraccom- plishedexperts in this report. Interspersed throughout, you’ll read the opinionsandpredictionsofDavidBradley,CEOoftheCanadianTrucking Alliance and president of the Ontario Trucking Association; Mark Nantais, president of the CanadianVehicle Manufacturers’Association; Bob Oliver, executive director of Pollution Probe; and Dr. Heather MacLean, professor of civil engineering at the University of Toronto. They all believe that an increasing number of innovative fuel and vehicle technologies will populate Canadian roads in the future. While no expert can be precise about when that future will arrive—or what the technological mix will be—the best information we have today clearly indicates that a major transformation will take decades. This underscores an important point. Petroleum is more than the fuel of choice for Canadians today; it is the transportation energy source that will power Canada—and the world, for that matter— well into the future, underpinning an increasingly diverse fuel and vehicle mix. To remain viable and competitive, Canada’s petroleum fuels and vehicle manufacturing industries are taking bold and determined steps—and making major investments—to improve overall product performance. No single technology has a monopoly on innovation, and the advances being made in petroleum fuels and conventional vehicle technologies are truly remarkable. Progress through innovation makes for a healthy, competitive market today, and ensures consumers—individual and commer- cial—will have greater choice when it comes to transportation options tomorrow.  Message from the Chair and President
  • 5. canadianfuels.ca 3 Bob I. Baird CHAIR Canadian Fuels Association SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, DOWNSTREAM Husky Energy Inc. Peter Boag PRESIDENT and CEO Canadian Fuels Association
  • 6. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20144 Section 1 Petroleum. Canada’s fuel. Transportation fuels hold deep value for Canadians. We depend on them. A long road in any weather Canadians are well aware of the crucial role transportation plays in connecting us to each other and the world. Our quality of life has risen steadily as marine, railway, road and aviation arteries have threaded their way across the country and into many of its most remote regions. Today, transporta- tion accounts for about 30 percent of our total energy use, making Canadians among the highest per capita users of transportation fuels in the world. Our level of fuel consumption comes as no surprise given our relatively small and widely dispersed population, as well as the extreme distances and varieties of terrains and climatic conditions we face when travelling across Canada. Truckers have perhaps the greatest appreciation for the challenges of Canada’s geography, and few people have a better understanding of the vital importance of trucking than David Bradley. FAST FACTS • For-hire trucking accounts for 31% of the transportation services sector’s $53B share (4.2%) of Canada’s GDP— greater than air, rail and water transport combined. • Trucks move 90% of all consumer products and foodstuffs. • Between 2011 and 2020, the for-hire trucking industry is expected to experience an output increase of 26% from $17 billion annually to $21.4 billion in constant dollars. • As a whole, the trucking industry (including for-hire carriers, private carriers, owner-operators and courier firms) generates more than $65 billion in revenues per year, with the for-hire sector accounting for over $40 billion alone. • There are more than 300,000 truck drivers in Canada today. Approximately 180,000 (60%) are employed in the for-hire sector of the trucking industry. • Nearly 1% of the Canadian population and more than 1.5% of the labour force are truck drivers. • For-hire trucking accounts for 278,000 direct jobs and provides for almost 480,000 jobs overall, resulting in $24 billion in personal income and $4.2 billion in personal income taxes. • The total economic footprint of the for-hire trucking industry was almost $37 billion in 2011.
  • 7. canadianfuels.ca 5 “I DON’T SEE ANY ALTERNATIVE DISPLACING DIESEL AS THE PREDOMINANT FUEL FOR THE TRUCKING INDUSTRY IN MOST OF OUR LIFETIMES.” contributor DAVID BRADLEY CEO, Canadian Trucking Alliance President, Ontario Trucking Association David earned his master’s in economics from Queen’s University following undergraduate work at University of Toronto. Beginning his career with roles in management consulting and financial market analysis, he took over leadership of the Ontario Trucking Association in 1991, and the Canadian Trucking Alliance in 1997. David Bradley is passionate and outspoken about the crucial value of truck transport, having guided the industry in Canada and its largest province through some of trucking’s most turbulent and transformative times. His expertise is regularly sought by federal, provincial and international organizations to ensure boards, committees and advisory groups benefit from the industry’s vital perspective. Canadian Trucking Alliance (CTA) The CTA is a federation of the country’s provincial trucking associations. Representing approximately 4,500 carriers, owner- operators and industry suppliers, the CTA is the industry’s voice on national and international policies, and on regulatory and legislative matters that affect trucking.
  • 8. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20146 “Without fuel the trucks don’t move, and no other fuel compares to diesel in terms of economy and energy output.” -- David Bradley
  • 9. canadianfuels.ca 7 If you got it, a truck brought it. According to Bradley, that statement is as true today as it’s ever been. Approximately 90 percent of all consumer products and foodstuffs in Canada are moved by truck.“The reason is that we provide an efficient service,”says Bradley.“Trucking isn’t always the cheapest mode, but it’s the service that’s able to provide the flexible, time-sensitive service most shippers need.” Where railways’niche is the long distance transport of heavy bulk commodities, trucking is ideally suited to the short distance, smaller-by-volume marketplace and moving high value-added manufactured and consumer goods. “Trucking is a hyper-competitive industry that’s been highly innovative in the constant pursuit of efficiency,”adds Bradley. Little wonder that fuel efficiency has been a growing concern in recent decades. Truck manufacturers have responded with new fuel-efficient engines, advanced drivetrains and more aerodynamic cabs and trailers. Fleets have optimized routing procedures and examined ways to improve driver training and performance. Governments have introduced new fuel economy standards. When it comes to fuel, diesel remains the trucking industry’s first choice. “It’s pretty basic,”says Bradley.“Without fuel the trucks don’t move, and no other fuel compares to diesel in terms of economy and energy output.” The trucking industry is Canada’s largest consumer of diesel fuel. Diesel accounts for between 15 and 40 percent of a company’s operating costs—and it’s the greatest single expense for the more than 45,000 individual owner-operators. “The petroleum producers operate to a very high standard and the quality of the fuel is very good,” says Bradley.“I don’t see any alternative displacing diesel as the predominant fuel for the trucking industry in most of our lifetimes.” Bradley acknowledges close ties between the trucking and petroleum fuels industries. It’s a relationship built over more than a century, and one he believes could be improved with greater communication, particularly with regard to factors that influence fuel prices, and the need for adequate Canadian refining infrastructure to consistently meet demand. Figure 1.1: Shares of Canada-United States trade by mode, 2012 Trucks move more goods (57%byvalue)toandfrom the U.S.—our largest trading partner—than all other modes of transportation combined. Source: Transport Canada, Transportation in Canada 2013, Statistical Addendum Total: $ 572,971 millionsof dollars Road $ 324,870 56.7% Rail $ 102,227 17.8% Marine $ 31,538 5.5% Air $ 27,986 4.9% Other $ 86,350 15.1%
  • 10. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 20148 “Reliability of supply historically has not been an issue,”says Bradley, “but when a refinery goes down for maintenance it can really have an impact. And if something goes wrong at another one, then we find ourselves quickly in a situation where companies are scrambling for fuel.” Canada’s petroleum refiners believe the key to a secure supply is a viable and competitive Canadian refining industry, which will ensure truckers won’t need to rely on imported fuels and find themselves at the end of a long and potentially less reliable foreign fuel supply chain. Comparing the alternatives Bradley supports all fuel solutions that work and reduce costs, but he’s skeptical about bio-diesel.“I don’t believe bio-diesel is an alternative in the true sense of the word,”says Bradley.“It’s not where we want to go as an industry; it’s not where the manufac- turers of heavy trucks want to go. We think it’s so 1990s. It’s presented as part of an off-oil strategy and being good for the environment. That’s nonsense. Bio-diesel was introduced in North America as a gesture to the agricultural sector to create a market for farmers. I don’t think it’s worked; and the concerns of manufacturers and the trucking industry about the impact of biofuels on engines and warranties have been virtually ignored.” In Bradley’s opinion, electricity holds near-term promise as an energy source only in smaller trucks and short-haul pick-up and delivery applications. “If you look at real alternative fuels, the one that has the most potential for us is liquid natural gas [LNG],”says Bradley.“The technology works, the fuel is plentiful, the technology is made in Canada and the GHG impact is lower. But LNG has challenges too. The distribution infrastructure isn’t there right now and LNG tractors cost 60 to 100 percent more than traditional vehicles. It’s going to take time, but certainly it is the alternative fuel with the most potential.” LNG is an attractive alternative partly due to its cost.“LNG is cheaper than diesel right now,”acknowledges Bradley,“but it’s not being taxed. That will change as fleets transition to LNG, and governments see tax revenue decline. The price will go up. The same thing happened with propane, which was supposed to be the big solution 30 years ago.” A partner in regulatory change According to Bradley, truckers also want to see greater collabo- ration with governments to develop new fuel economy standards. “People may think,‘We did it for cars, we can do it for trucks,’”says Bradley in reference to recent and successive tiers of federal fuel and light-duty vehicle standards.“But they are two completely different vehicle types. We can’t take the same approach as the Americans to achieving greater fuel economy, nor can we simply adopt U.S. standards in Canada. Our industry is different. We face dramatically different conditions here; there’s a greater range of equipment, engines and applications in Canada’s heavy-duty fleet.” Bradley emphasizes the trucking industry’s support for new heavy-duty vehicle fuel standards, but this support is tempered by a strong conviction that trucking’s expertise must be at the table to inform an effective and realistic regulatory framework. Greater government and industry partnership is key to achieve mutual goals for greater efficiency and environmental perfor- mance—while upholding trucking’s vital contribution to Canada’s economy. “We want to make sure these standards work,”says Bradley.“It’s in our interest to improve fuel economy, but we’re going to have to get more sophisticated in terms of how we approach these things in Canada.”  “There have been many attempts to sell the industry snake oil over the years,”says David Bradley.“Truckers have a natural skepticism about new fuels. They want to see things in action.They want to see the horsepower and that a solution works in all the conditions we face in Canada.”
  • 11. canadianfuels.ca 9 The key to a secure supply of petroleum fuels is a viable and competitive Canadian refining industry. Figure 1.2: Traffic volume by Canadian for-hire carriers Source: Transport Canada, Transportation in Canada 2013, Statistical Addendum Figure 1.3: Domestic sales of gasoline and diesel Source: Statistics Canada 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Metrictonnes(millions) Total international Total domestic 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Cubicmetres(millions) Diesel fuel oil Motor gasoline For-hire trucking traffic is expected to continue growing through at least 2020. While gasoline sales are essentially flat to declining, diesel sales are rising due mainly to demand in truck transport.
  • 12. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201410 Section 2 Building on a history of progress Pollution Probe’s Bob Oliver, and Mark Nantais of the CVMA, talk about how transportation fuel formulations have changed substantially over the years—and continue to improve in response to changing vehicle and consumer needs and expectations. Exceeding emissions standards “The light-duty on-road transportation sector is the only economic sector to demonstrate a continuous and sustained reduction in smog-causing emissions year over year from 1985 to 2012,” says the CVMA’s Mark Nantais.“It’s really quite a success story.” During that time, the automotive and petroleum refining industries were subjected to a range of successive government regulations aimed primarily at reducing levels of criteria air contaminants including nitrogen oxides, sulphur oxides, volatile organic compounds and particulate matter. In response, Canada’s new vehicle fleets have outperformed emissions-standard requirements, in part through a history of collaboration. “I’ve been in the business more than 30 years,”says Nantais,“and there’s always been a technical forum where the oil and auto industries meet regularly throughout the year to identify appropriate fuel quality for the efficient operation of engines and emissions-control technologies.” FAST FACTS • Canada is the world’s ninth largest vehicle producer, generating nearly 4% of global output. • The automotive sector is Canada’s biggest contributor to manufacturing GDP. • More than 20% of all trade with U.S. is associated with vehicle manufacturing—approximately $100B each year. • Approximately 500,000 Canadian jobs are directly and indirectly associated with the automotive industry including eight assembly plants, multiple components plants, more than 400 parts manufacturers, and nearly 3,700 dealerships. • For every assembly line job, the industry creates nine others to benefit surrounding communities.
  • 13. canadianfuels.ca 11 contributor MARK NANTAIS President, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association (CVMA) A native of Windsor, Ontario, Mark Nantais has a long family history in the automotive industry on both sides of the Canada-U.S. border. He joined the CVMA in 1984 and has been president since 1994. His responsibilities include policy development and the overall strategic direction of the organization. His educational background in biological and environmental studies, computer science and systems analysis has served him well in leading the CVMA’s activities in the areas of engineering, environmental performance, alternative fuels, energy efficiency and technical standards harmonization. A member of numerous boards and councils, Nantais has served as the automotive industry representative on several government consultative groups, as well as Canada’s delegation to the Canada-U.S. Air Quality Agreement specifically in the area of ground level ozone. CanadianVehicle Manufacturers’Association For nearly a century, CVMA members have helped ensure Canada enjoys the economic and social advantages of a strong domestic automotive industry.Today, the CVMA continues to represent the Canadian auto industry’s largest manufacturers, giving them a single voice on issues of strategic national importance. “The light-duty on-road transportation sector is the only economic sector that’s made continuous and sustained reductions in smog-causing emissions year over year from 1985 to 2012.”
  • 14. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201412 Striking a fair balance Pollution Probe’s Bob Oliver agrees that the joint achievements do constitute a success story.“It’s clear that there’s a healthy and robust collaboration,”says Oliver.“There’s also a healthy tension, but we end up with a fair balance between the burden on the automaker to make the vehicle that runs as clean as possible, and the petroleum refiners to deliver the fuel that enables automakers to make clean-running vehicles.” According to Oliver, the distinction is important. When he delved into an examination of transpor- tation fuels beginning in 2004, Oliver quickly realized that the goal wasn’t so much about cleaning up the fuel as ensuring it enabled vehicles to achieve what was technically possible in terms of emissions reductions.“Fuels are formulated specifically to enable the vehicle to limit emissions.” “That’s what we call the total systems approach,”says Nantais,“where the technology is supported concurrently by appropriate levels of fuel quality in the marketplace. That’s how you optimize emissions reductions and emissions control efficiencies, and that’s what delivers the optimum environmental benefits consumers expect.” “In the context of regional air-quality management and smog causing pollutants, light-duty vehicles built to the new standard are nearing the point where their emissions could be considered all but negligible.” FAST FACTS • Pollution Probe was instrumental in the passage of provincial legislation in the late 1990s that led to implementation of Ontario’s Drive Clean program. • In the early 2000s, the organization played a central role in supporting stringent sulphur-in-fuel regulations and tighter air pollution standards for light- and heavy-duty vehicles. • In 2004, Pollution Probe began significant research to explore ways to improve the fuel efficiency of new vehicles. These efforts were instrumental in informing development of federal regulations to limit GHG emissions from all new light-duty vehicles in Canada beginning with the 2011 model year. -- Bob Oliver
  • 15. canadianfuels.ca 13 “REDUCING SULPHUR CONTENT HAS ALLOWED AUTOMAKERS TO BRING FORWARD MORE EFFECTIVE EMISSIONS CONTROL TECHNOLOGIES AND THUS CONTRIBUTETO MUCH LOWER LEVELS OF SMOG-FORMING POLLUTANTS.” contributor BOB OLIVER Executive Director, Pollution Probe Bob Oliver is a mechanical engineer with more than 15 years experience managing industrial projects and developing strategies for energy efficiency and GHG reduction. At the helm of Pollution Probe since 2008, he has built strong relationships with governments and industry to advance practical solutions to environmental challenges. He is credited with establishing Pollution Probe’s Transportation Program through which the organization launched effective campaigns to help reduce transportation-related GHG emissions across Canada. The researcher and author behind several major reports on transportation technology and policy, Mr. Oliver is also a member of many expert panels and committees including the National Advisory Committee on Energy Efficiency and the Steering Committee for Canada’s Electric Vehicle Roadmap. Pollution Probe Pollution Probe is one of Canada’s longest- serving and most respected non-profit environmental organizations. Since 1969, it has worked effectively to improve the health and well being of Canadians by advancing policies that achieve positive, tangible environmental change.
  • 16. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201414 Figure 2.2: Sulphur in gasoline and on-road diesel, Canada Quarterly volume-weighted averages are shown. Source: Canadian Fuels member companies (excluding Husky Energy Inc. and NOVA Chemicals (Canada) Ltd.). Data includes imports. Figure 2.3: 1995–2012 Historical emissions for Canada for light-duty gasoline vehicles (in tonnes) Source: Environment Canada, Pollutant Inventories and Reporting Division, 2013 Since 2005, petroleum refiners have invested $5 billion to reduce sulphur levels in gasoline by more than 90%, and in diesel by 97%. The fuel and vehicle industries‘ total systems approach has delivered dramatic reductions in light-duty vehicle emis- sions of sulphur oxides, nitrous oxides and volatile organic compounds. These reductions were achieved without any sacrifice to the high energy output of gasoline. 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 350,000 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 0 10,000 9,000 8,000 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 Tonnes(NOX /VOCs) Tonnes(SOX ) NOX VOCs SOX Gasoline On-road diesel 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Sulphurcontent(partspermillion) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Figure 2.1: New motor vehicle sales, Canada Source: Statistics Canada. Note: light trucks include minivans, sport-utility vehicles, light trucks and vans. 2010 2011 2012 2013 2,000,000 1,800,000 1,600,000 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,000,000 800,000 600,000 400,000 200,000 0 Buses Light trucksHeavy trucks Passenger cars 2013 was a record year for light vehicle sales in Canada, with 1,743,112 vehicles sold. 2014 is on track to set a new sales record.
  • 17. canadianfuels.ca 15 Back in the 1980s, this meant eliminating lead from gasoline. The heavy metal impeded the effectiveness of early automotive catalytic converters, first introduced in 1975. In the past decade, the main target was sulphur for much the same reason. “Sulphur poisons the reaction in a catalytic converter,”explains Oliver.“Reducing sulphur content has allowed automakers to bring forward more effective emissions control technologies and thus contribute to much lower levels of smog-forming pollutants.” FederalSulphurinGasolineRegulations introduced in 2000 lowered sulphur levels in gasoline from 150 parts per million (ppm) on average in 2002 to less than 30 ppm by 2005. Sulphur in Diesel Fuel Regulations implemented in 2006 cut sulphur in on-road diesel from 500 ppm to 15 ppm (see Figure 2.2). Both the automotive and petroleum fuel industries are now preparing to meet new, tougher Tier 3 regulatory requirements, which will reduce vehicle emissions another 80 percent from the Tier 2 standards while cutting sulphur in gasoline to just 10 ppm beginning in 2017— approximately 97 percent lower than in 2004.“The Tier 3 vehicle emissions standards will be the most stringent of their kind in the world,”says Mark Nantais. Driving emissions toward zero “The Tier 3 standards will further reduce the contribution that light-duty vehicles make to urban air pollution,”says Oliver. “We are already seeing cleaner air as a result of lower vehicle emissions, and we are looking at even cleaner air in the future. In the context of regional air-quality management and smog causing pollutants, light-duty vehicles built to the new standard are nearing the point where their emissions could be considered all but negligible.” Mark Nantais agrees with Oliver’s assessment.“TheTier 3 standards will take us down to virtually zero-emission vehicles.” As impressive as those specifications may be, they pose technical andinvestmentchallengestodevelopsophisticatednewemission- control systems, since the vehicles, by regulation, will have to meet the standard not just on the showroom floor, but also for their full useful life—roughly 240,000 kilometres. “Concurrently,”says Nantais,“new technology-forcing GHG emission standards will basically double fuel efficiency over that which was implemented in 2010. Every category of vehicle that a company produces will have to meet stringent standards. That will take us to 54 miles per gallon [4.4 l /100 km], roughly a five percent year-over-year improvement, which is unprecedented in the history of the automotive industry.” Every option is on the table According to Nantais, automakers will take a broad range of approaches to meet fleet targets.“There’s no silver bullet,”says Nantais.“We will see continued improvements to internal combustion engines [ICE] and drive trains, changes to aerodyna­ mics, use of light-weight materials, even the way we manufacture these vehicles. The ICE is going to be around for a long time, so the need for petroleum fuels is ongoing, but there’s no single technology pathway that is the solution here. Alternative fuels must be part of the slate to help us meet upcoming standards.” To that end, the industry continues to explore hybrid vehicles and battery electric vehicles, as well as natural gas and biofuel options. “We have to be careful that biofuel blends are properly formulated,” says Nantais,“and that the distillation curve essentially mirrors gasoline’s to ensure the vehicle can perform as intended.You just can’t add more ethanol because you think it’s a good idea.” Oliver notes that the emissions performance of vehicles depends on an alignment of fuel formulation with the requirements of emissions control systems.“Any change in the composition of “Any change in the composition of fuels to accommodate alternatives to gasoline and diesel … will require an associated change in the design and operation of engine emissions control technology.” -- Bob Oliver
  • 18. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201416 fuels,”he says,“to accommodate alternatives to gasoline and diesel, for example, will require an associated change inthedesign andoperationofengineemissionscontroltechnology.So when you’re talking about diversifying the mix of transportation fuels available to consumers, your scope of change needs to encompass vehicle specifications as well.” Going forward together This alignment of fuel and vehicle technology reflects an increasingly integrated North American market. With the formation of the United States–Canada Regulatory Cooperation Council (RCC) in 2011, the two countries set out to align their regulatory approaches, reduce red tape and make it easier for companies to do business on both sides of the border. Tier 2 and 3 fuel and vehicle standards, for example, are harmonized in Canada and the U.S. “We are strong supporters of the RCC,”says Nantais.“Our vision remains one product, tested once and certified once for sale across one integrated U.S. and Canadian market.” “I don’t think there is an alternative to gasoline or diesel.” The automakers’vision by extension means that fuels must also be harmonized on a continental basis while correcting for seasonal dif‑ ferences.“It’s in support of the total systems approach,”says Nantais, “where appropriate fuel quality supports vehicle performance and emissions control technology concurrently in the marketplace.” He feels the demand for boutique fuels as a result of varying provincial fuel standards is troublesome.“Petroleum refiners Mark Nantais feels the demand for boutique fuels as a result of varying provincial fuel standards is troublesome.“Petroleum refiners need consistent requirements nationwide the same as we do.” -- Bob Oliver
  • 19. canadianfuels.ca 17 need consistent requirements nationwide the same as we do,” says Nantais.“That consistency is presently driven by Canadian General Standards Board specifications, but not all provinces adhere to CGSB specs. We need to work on that to ensure a consistent market.” Uniquely Canadian challenges As for other alternatives, Nantais sees most facing the same hurdle—infrastructure—imposed in part by Canada’s formi­ dable geography and the long distances we must travel. “It’s the total systems approach again,”says Nantais, “the technology supported by the fuels and, in this case, the infrastructure. We have very few E-85 filling stations in Canada. Natural gas is a very good fuel with low emissions, but it’s always had an infrastructure issue. Fuel cells: we know how to do that. We have to get the cost down, but where is the infrastructure? We are seeing increasing electrification of the fleet, but we need the recharging infrastructure.” Bob Oliver questions whether the word alternative is appropriate to the fuel discussion. “I don’t think there is an alternative to gasoline or diesel,”he says. “Technically speaking, the clean substitute for gasoline is cleaner gasoline. Fuels are different and each offers its own value proposition.You cannot simply drop any alternative fuel into an engine and expect it to operate as efficiently as on the fuel for which it was designed.” Oliver is of the opinion that cleaner petroleum fuels and more efficient conventionally powered vehicles challenge the appeal of alternatives.“As you address air pollution and GHG emissions— and both are going down as a result of sustained improvements to the incumbent technology—the value proposition for natural gas, electricity or biofuels will increasingly have to rest on superior economic and technical performance, because environmental performance is going to be a reduced advantage over time.” He points to electric vehicles, the focus of much of Pollution Probe’s recent work. “We’re not pushing electric vehicles exclusively as a clean-air solution,”says Oliver.“We’re interested in them from an energy management perspective, too. When you put gas in a car’s tank, there’s only one use for it. A plug-in electric vehicle, however, can offer utilities a range of value-creation opportunities in terms of power management and energy storage capability, for example.” Innovation through regulation According to Oliver, the effect of government fuel and vehicle regulations has been to motivate technological change within the fuels and automotive sectors, and to drive the deploy- ment of new, emissions-reducing and fuel-saving technolo- gies in the marketplace. “These changes would not otherwise happen in response to basic economic forces,”says Oliver. “The result of increased, regulation-induced technological sophistication in vehicles and fuels is cleaner air and mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions.” Oliver would like to see the regulatory momentum continue. “Gasoline and diesel are going to be with us for some time,”says Oliver.“The opportunity now is to replicate the success we’ve had with the light-duty fleet throughout the transportation sector: heavy-duty vehicles, off-road vehicles, small engines, marine vessels, rail.” Promoting a holistic view Mark Nantais believes one of the major current challenges is to ensure that governments don’t pick technology winners and losers.“Particularly on the GHG side, there will be no one technical solution,”says Nantais.“We’re encouraging governments to look at things holistically.There are complementary technologies, and there’s more diversification on the fuel side. It’s the combination of all these things that’s ultimately going to drive greater environmental benefits.”  “The result of increased, regulation- induced technological sophistication in vehicles and fuels is cleaner air and mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions.” -- Bob Oliver
  • 20. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201418 Crystal balls and silver bullets All anyone can really predict about the future of transportation fuels is that the options will continue to evolve, ensuring Canadians have a greater variety of fuel choices in years to come. An informed perspective “No one can predict the future of fuel and vehicle development, so I won’t try,”says Dr. Heather MacLean. Yet her experience may give her a clearer view into the crystal ball than many other experts in the field of fuel and vehicle technology. Her perspective is based largely on exhaustive studies that compare, from an interdisciplinary perspective, numerous fuel and vehicle options and combinations. “Our research has evaluated a fairly wide set of options including conventional gasoline-powered vehicles, hybrids, plug-in hybrids, and battery-powered vehicles,”says MacLean.“We’re also looking at the production and use of biofuels in vehicles—primarily second generation ligno-cellulosic biofuels rather than those produced from animal feed crops.” MacLean and her colleagues rely on life cycle assessment (LCA) to conduct their evaluations. LCA has emerged in recent years as the method best suited for making equitable comparisons of different fuel and vehicle technologies. “Life cycle assessment is frequently employed to evaluate and quantify the environmental implica- tions of a product,”says MacLean. In the case of a conventional gasoline-powered vehicle, an LCA would span extraction of the raw material—including oil—manufacturing, use and vehicle disposal. Two LCA models currently dominate in North America. The U.S. Department of Energy developed and uses GREET (greenhouse gases, regulated emissions, and energy use in transportation). GHGenius is the primary model in Canada. Both address more than 100 fuel production pathways and more than 70 vehicle/fuel combinations. Section 3 “The second-generation biofuel option will not cover a very large portion of the vehicle fleet in the near term.” -- Heather MacLean
  • 21. canadianfuels.ca 19 contributor DR. HEATHER MacLEAN Professor of Civil Engineering, University of Toronto Over the past 15 years Heather MacLean has worked closely with the public and private sectors to evaluate conventional and alternative energy systems. Her main research focus since studying for her doctorate and joining the faculty at University of Toronto has been in the development and application of improved methods to evaluate the environmental and techno-economic impacts of a broad range of transportation fuel and vehicle technologies. MacLean has been affiliated with Auto21 (see below) since 2002, leading a variety of research projects. Collaborating with research partners at the University of British Columbia and University of Windsor, she has examined technological change in the automotive industry, the evolution of life cycle assessment, and emerging automotive technologies. The research is interdisciplinary, involving public and private sector partners and spanning the fields of public policy and environmental, chemical and mechanical engineering. MacLean received a degree in civil engineering from theTechnical University of NovaScotia(now partofDalhousie University),andanMBA fromSt.Mary’sUniversity. She earned her MSc. and Ph.D. at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh. Research for a sustainable domestic automotive sector Auto21 is a national research initiative supported by the Government of Canada through the Networks of Centres of Excellence Secretariat. The organization connects nearly 200 leading Canadian researchers at 48 universities with more than 130 industry and government partners. Focusing on six key themes, including powertrains, fuels and emissions, Auto21’s goal is to create a dynamic R&D community that contributes to a sustainable and globally competitive Canadian automotive sector.
  • 22. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201420 Pursuing greater accuracy LCA is far from a perfect science, but models are being continually refined to improve their accuracy.“Comparing conventional and alternative fuel vehicles is very complex,”says MacLean, who feels that although the analysis models are well maintained, there can always be improvement. “The LCA models are generally focused only on environmental impacts,”says MacLean.“There is a social component of LCA, but it’s in its infancy. So if one is looking more broadly at sustainability— balancing economic and environmental tradeoffs—LCA doesn’t really provide a complete picture.”Her work is also addressing financial and techno-economic aspects, which are critical to evaluating the attractiveness of fuel and vehicle technologies. The refinements to LCA are enabling analysis that’s exceptionally granular.InarecentAuto21study,MacLeanandherteamdeter­ mined that ethanol (E85) use in a hybrid electric vehicle and bioelectricity use in a fully electric vehicle can have similar life cycle fossil energy use and net GHG emissions. The team’s findings differ with those in the literature, which report better bioelectricity performance on these metrics compared to ethanol. Yet the results in a prior study were skewed by the use of vehicles with demonstrably different performance characteristics that favoured the bioelectricity option. Using simulation software, the Auto21 team created vehicles that featured different power- trains but were otherwise identical in size and acceleration capability. The work shows the data sensitivity of LCA and the significance of careful and accurate comparisons. A vehicle for where you live and the way you drive Across years of complex fuel and vehicle comparisons and analysis, MacLean and her collaborators have found there is no overall winner; every option involves some trade-offs, be they environmental or economic. She sees a gradually fragmenting vehicle market in which various technological solutions have their place depending on where you live and how you drive. “A battery powered vehicle would be a good option for someone with a short commute and living in a jurisdiction with a low-carbon electricity grid,”says MacLean.“Someone who faces a lot of stop-and-go traffic would be well served with a hybrid electric vehicle. A diesel vehicle would be a better choice for driving long distances.” Regional geographic differences can create conditions under which one option is preferred over another. MacLean believes this is particularly true when considering electric vehicles.“The regional electricity grid mix varies greatly across Canada,”says MacLean.“From a GHG-emissions perspective, an electric vehicle that draws on a hydro-electric grid is far more promising than one that relies on electricity generated by the high carbon intensity of coal.” The main barrier facing electric vehicles is the absence of battery technology breakthroughs.“There are promising options out there,”says MacLean,“but electric vehicles still have limitations with respect to performance, infrastructure and affordability.” Across years of complex fuel and vehicle comparisons and analysis, MacLean and her collaborators have found there is no overall winner.
  • 23. canadianfuels.ca 21 Tracking biofuel progress For biofuels, MacLean notes that the variety of feedstocks, production methods and sources of energy for production are all very significant in determining life-cycle GHG performance. “There continues to be a lot of focus on second-generation biofuels,”says MacLean,“but development has been much slower than people in the sector would hope to get commercial scale facilities up and running.” Progress has been made recently, but a number of challenges have yet to be overcome, specifically with regard to clarifying environmental aspects of the technology, as well as financing and risk management.“The second-generation biofuel option will not cover a very large portion of the vehicle fleet in the near term,”says MacLean. Improving conventional solutions MacLean and her colleagues have studied petroleum fuels and conventional internal combustion vehicles in many projects. She expects the fuel economy and overall performance of these vehicles will continue to improve. Some improvements will depend on the use of new lightweight materials, changes to vehicle size and power, and advances in powertrain technology. (See Figure 3.1.) “Some of these improvements may require tradeoffs from a life cycle perspective,”observes MacLean.“For example, increases in fuel economy could be offset by a greater amount of energy required to manufacture lightweight materials that enable higher efficiency.” Manufacturing processes may also require highly specialized materials for which recycling protocols have not yet been established. Careful LCA provides valuable information about many of these tradeoffs.
  • 24. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201422 Figure 3.1: Incremental gains in efficiency of new light duty vehicles The coming decades will deliver significant efficiency improvements in conventional gasoline and diesel powered vehicles through powertrain innovations, use of new lightweight materials and increased hybridization, among other advances. 20 15 10 5 0 Milespergallon(MPG) 2010 2020 2030 2040 HYBRIDIZATION VEHICLE DOWNSIZING BODY AND ACCESSORIES ADVANCEMENTS POWERTRAIN IMPROVEMENTS MacLean believes the use of petroleum-based fuels may face challenges if carbon intensity or GHG emissions are a key regulatory focus—even as emissions of conventional pollutants are virtually eliminated through Tier 3 fuel and vehicle emission standards. Nonetheless, she agrees that the movement away from petroleum fuels will be slower than many people anticipate. A healthy mix of technologies When it comes to transportation fuel and vehicle technology, there is no silver bullet.“I have to keep saying this and some people consider it a downer, but there’s no clear or optimal solution,”says MacLean, who sees the benefits of an increasing number of fuel and vehicle options.“Choice encourages development on a number of different fronts. There obviously are some winners and some losers, but we should be careful not to abandon any technological option prematurely.” While she expects we will witness some breakthroughs in fuel and vehicle technologies, various wild cards play havoc with predictions. The future mix of technologies and the speed of their adoption will depend on a range of factors including fuel price and supply, and public policy—about which there’s considerable uncertainty. To reveal viable pathways, MacLean believes LCAs and supple- mentary analyses must begin to address other environmental impacts as well as financial, supply and logistical issues. “Although I feel global climate change is an important issue, I’m hoping that a lot more of the focus is on the overall perspective and not just GHG emissions,”says MacLean.“There are other considerations: water use and availability, bio-diversity, land use, emissions other than GHGs, and efficiency of production— energy use more generally.” Promoting a broader approach MacLean also believes an additional perspective is necessary to further minimize the environmental impacts of the transporta- tion sector. She is concerned the work to increase vehicle efficiency and reduce emissions will be for naught if we don’t address traffic congestion—a particular problem in urban North America and transition economies where the number of vehicles continues to rise. “Even the most efficient, lowest polluting vehicles won’t necessarily solve the larger issue if we’re just putting more and Source: 2013 The Outlook for Energy: A View to 2040, Exxon Mobil.
  • 25. canadianfuels.ca 23 more vehicles on the road,”says MacLean.“We need a broader approach—beyond the questions of what fuels or vehicles we should be using—to look at government policies, consumer behaviour, infrastructure financing, public transit, land-use planning and other issues over the next few years.”  Dr. MacLean would like to acknowledge the support of two University of Toronto collaborators in her contribution to this section: Jason Luk, a Ph.D. student in the Department of Civil Engineering; and Bradley Saville, a professor in the Department of Chemical Engineering & Applied Chemistry. The future mix of technologies and the speed of their adoption will depend on a range of factors including fuel price and supply, and public policy—about which there’s considerable uncertainty.
  • 26. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201424 SECTOR PERFORMANCE Section 4
  • 28. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201426 Production To meet demand, Canada’s refineries operate around the clock, producing an average of more than 300 million litres of refined petroleum products per day. They contribute $5.6 billion in direct GDP to the Canadian economy and employ over 18,000 highly skilled workers. All numbers below extracted from Energy Markets Fact Book 2014–2015, Natural Resources Canada, 2014. Canadian supply and demand, 2013 Canadian exports and imports of refined petroleum products *Certain product shares are based on NRCan analysis. Sales by product, 2013* “Other”includes propane, butane, petro-chemical feedstocks, lubricating oils, petroleum coke, asphalt, etc. Gasoline 42% Diesel 28% Aviation fuels 7% Heating oil 2% Heavy fuel oil 3% Other 18% Crude oil intake at Canadian refineries Refinery production Refined product imports* Refined product exports Domestic sales of refined products* 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Billion litres 99 (1.7 MMb/d) 110 13 29 107 Canada is a net exporter of refined petroleum products, with a production that exceeds domestic demand. Driven by increased freight transport, diesel represents a growing share of Canada’s petroleum product slate. Canada has become less reliant on refined petroleum product imports, while exports have gradually risen in recent years. The U.S. represents 92 percent of Canada’s export market. 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Billionlitres Exports Imports
  • 29. canadianfuels.ca 27 Safety Canadian Fuels members are continuously working to improve the sector’s safety record, which is one of the best in Canadian manufacturing. In the past 10 years, total recordable injuries for refining, distribution and retail employees have decreased by 80 percent. Data: Canadian Fuels Association member companies only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013. Total employees – Total recordable injury frequencies 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0 Injuryfrequencyper100full-timeworkers Medical treatment case frequency Restricted work case frequency Lost time injury frequency
  • 30. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201428 CO2 emissions The refining sector’s CO2 emissions have been reduced by 16 percent in the past 10 years, even while refining has become more intensive to comply with new, more stringent fuel quality standards. The refining sector accounts for less than 2.5 percent of Canada’s total GHG emissions. GHG emission reductions from refineries have been driven in part by a 14 percent drop in energy fuel consumption. Energy fuel consumption of petroleum refineries, annual Total CO2 emissions, Canadian refining industry 350,000,000 340,000,000 330,000,000 320,000,000 310,000,000 300,000,000 290,000,000 280,000,000 270,000,000 2009 201320112010 2012 gigajoules 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 20 19 18 17 16 15 CO2 (Mt) Environmental performance Effective environmental stewardship is one of the core values of our members. Over the past 10 years, they have invested more than $7.2 billion to improve the environmental performance of their refineries and the fuels they produce by reducing air emissions, GHGs and water use. Data: Canadian Fuels Association member companies only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013. Canadian Fuels members’total environmental expenditures 2,000 1,800 1,600 1,400 1,200 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 8,000 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 MillionsofCanadiandollars Annual Total (left axis) Cumulative Total (right axis) 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Data: Canadian Industrial Energy End-Use Data and Analysis Centre (CIEEDAC), Simon Fraser University. Data: Statistics Canada
  • 31. canadianfuels.ca 29 Air emissions Canada’s refiners work continually to improve their processes, leading to significant improvements in air emissions. Data: Environment Canada’s National Pollutant Release Inventory (NPRI). Nitrogen oxides (NOX)  39% Carbon monoxide (CO)  46% Sulphur oxides (SOX )  45% Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)  38% Total particulate matter (TPM)  37% 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 35,000 30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 Tonnes 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 18,000 16,000 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 Tonnes 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 Tonnes 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 80,000 70,000 60,000 50,000 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 Tonnes 120,000 100,000 80,000 60,000 40,000 20,000 0 Tonnes 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Benzene (C6H6)  29% 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Tonnes
  • 32. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201430 Surplus site remediation Since 2009, Canadian Fuels members have remediated 828 surplus sites, including 152 in 2013, making them available for industrial, recreational, residential or commercial use. Data: Canadian Fuels Association members only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013. Total Canadian Fuels member sites remediated Service stations Other sites 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Numberofsites 20132012201120102009 632 196 Water Canadian Fuels members are committed to using less water and returning it to the environment in a cleaner state. Water intake is down 22 percent since 2005, while effluent deposits continue to be well below maximum allowable limits. Data: Canadian Fuels Association member refineries only. Canadian Fuels membership changed in 2012 and 2013. Refinery water usage Refinery effluent deposits *Total suspended solids. Effluent quality is far better than required by regulation. 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 350,000,000 325,000,000 300,000,000 275,000,000 250,000,000 225,000,000 200,000,000 Cubicmetres(m3 ) Intake Discharge Oil and grease Sulphide Ammonia nitrogen Phenol T.S.S.* 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 %ofRegulations Regulations (100%)
  • 33. canadianfuels.ca 31 500 400 300 200 100 0 Sulphurcontent(partspermillion) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Fuel quality Fuels have changed significantly in the past decades. Lead was entirely phased out of gasoline and benzene was cut to less than 1 percent of volume. Refiners have invested over $5 billion to cut sulphur to less than 30 ppm in gasoline and less than 15 ppm in diesel. Data: Canadian Fuels member companies (excluding Husky Energy Inc. and NOVA Chemicals (Canada) Ltd.). Data includes imports. Quarterly volume-weighted averages are shown for sulphur in gasoline and on-road diesel. Benzene in gasoline 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 Benzenecontent(%volume) Regulation 1.0% (by volume) flat limit 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Sulphur in gasoline Sulphur in on-road diesel Sulphur content in gasoline is 90 percent lower than it was 10 years ago. New Tier 3 regulations will cut sulphur content in gasoline by 97 percent in 2017 compared to 2004 levels. Sulphur in Diesel Fuel Regulations implemented in 2006 cut sulphur in on-road diesel from 500 ppm to 15 ppm. Benzene content is far below the maximum allowable. 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Sulphurcontent(partspermillion) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
  • 34. Canadian Fuels Association  |  Sector Review 201432 Refining sector economic indicators The refining sector is an important contributor to Canada’s economy, adding $5.6 billion to GDP. Data: Statistics Canada, The Conference Board of Canada Refining sector investments (millions of Canadian dollars) 3,000 2,500 2,000 1,500 1,000 500 0 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 Annualinvestments,structures,machineryandequipment Investments,cumulativetotal Structures (left axis) Machinery and equipment (left axis) Cumulative total (right axis) 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Refinery employment 20,000 10,000 0 Estimateofrefiningemployment 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Canada’s refining sector employs over 18,000 highly skilled workers, earning 70 percent more on average than the overall manufacturing sector average. Canadian refiners have invested over $2.2 billion a year on average over the past decade.
  • 35. Welcome new members The Canadian Fuels Association is pleased to have welcomed two new members in 2014. Federated Co-operatives Saskatoon-based Federated Co-operatives Limited (FCL) is the 45th largest company and the largest non-financial co-operative in Canada. FCL’s Co-op Refinery Complex (CRC) was the world’s first co-operatively-owned petroleum refinery. Located in Regina, the CRC manufactures and supplies petroleum products for FCL members through the Co-operative Retailing System. With a total capacity of 130,000 barrels per day, the CRC is recognized as one of Canada’s high value-added petroleum refining facilities. It employs more than 900 people. Irving Oil Founded in 1924, Irving Oil is a family-owned and privately-held regional energy processing, transporting and marketing company with headquarters in Saint John, New Brunswick, and U.S. marketing operations in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. The company operates Canada’s largest refinery, producing 320,000 barrels of finished products per day. Operations include ten distribution terminals, a fleet of delivery trucks and more than 900 fuelling locations serving wholesale, commercial and retail customers in Atlantic Canada, Quebec and New England. For more information, please visit our website, canadianfuels.ca To comment, contact president@canadianfuels.ca
  • 36. 1000–275 Slater Street Ottawa, ON  K1P 5H9 613 232 3709  |  canadianfuels.ca © Canadian Fuels Association 2014 We’ll take you there. Members