1. The document discusses the role and qualifications of food safety auditors in Indonesia. It notes the variety of standards and certification schemes auditors must be competent in, from national standards to private standards used by importers and retailers.
2. There is no consistent standard for auditor competency internationally or in Indonesia. Auditor competency varies between certification bodies and standards. The document calls for international harmonization of auditor competency standards.
3. Food safety auditors play an important role in strengthening Indonesia's national food safety system and building public confidence through impartial third-party assessments of compliance with various standards.
Ensuring Food Safety - The Role of Auditors in Indonesia's National Food Safety System
1. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Food Safety Auditor Di
Indonesia
Disampaikan Pada :
Two day Lecture – Certified Food Safety Assesors / Auditor
Appropriate With JAPAN Scheme
Oleh :
A. Iskandar, K
Auditor for : HACCP System, FSMS ISO 22000, GMP+ International – PDV
The Netherlands No. Reg. PER00000315, Organic System, PBSF-AQIS
Australia. ASQ Member No. 63863015
SURABAYA, 5 November 2009
3. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Apa itu ”Food Safety Auditor”?
• Kualifikasi apa yg dibutuhkan?
• Ahli Pangan?
• Regulasi yang mendukungnya?
• Pelatihan Audit yg perbah diikuti?
• Pelatihan ‘Recognized’ HACCP yg pernah
diikuti?
• Auditor Manajemen Mutu dengan
pengalaman industri?
• Berapa banyak pengalaman industri yg
diperlukan?
• Apakah Auditor SQF Auditor lebih baik dari
Auditor BRC?
• Apakah Auditor BRC lebih baik dari Auditor
Sistem HACCP Sucofindo-ICS?
• Bagaimana Standar Kompetensi Auditor
Keamaman Pangan Indonesia?
Bagian 1
pendahuluan
4. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Lembaga Sertifikasi, Auditor &
Audit Keamaman Pangan (BSN)
• Lembaga Sertifikasi adalah lembaga yg telah
di akreditasi oleh Komite Akreditasi Nasional
untuk melakukan sertifikasi HACCP
berdasarkan Pedoman BSN 1001-1999
• Auditor Sertifikasi Sistem HACCP adalah
seseorang yang telah memiliki kualifikasi untuk
melaksanakan asesmen dan audit HACCP.
• Audit Kecukupan adalah pemeriksaan atau
penilaian yg rinci atas suatu rencana HACCP
untuk memastikan bahwa semua unsur sistem
HACCP telah dimuat dalam rencana HACCP.
• Asesmen adalah penilaian lapangan pada
badan usaha untuk membuktikan apakah
rencana HACCP yang adaa secara teknis
maupun ilmiah adalah benar sesuai dengan
kondisi di badan usaha yg bersangkutan.
Bagian 2
pengertian
5. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Lembaga Sertifikasi, Auditor &
Audit Keamaman Pangan (others)
• CB: the body which is approved by the
Product Board as such under the BRC
certification scheme (BRC Global Standar)
• Auditor: a person approved as a food safety
auditor under the Act as a person competent
to audit the relevant class of food business (AS
• Audit: the systematic and independent
examination to determine whether food
hygiene and safety activities and related
results comply with planned arrangements
and whether these arrangements are
implemented effectively and are suitable to
achive objective. (AS-1985).
Bagian 2
pengertian
6. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Kriteria Auditor Sertifikasi HACCP
Pedoman 1003 – 1999, BSN
• Auditor Kepala :
• SMK/D1 : kimia, biologi, farmasi, pangan atau
pertanian. Pengalaman 5 tahun dibidang
keamaman pangan.
• D2/D3, pendidikan sda, pengalaman 3 tahun.
• S1/S2/S3, pendidikan sda, pengalaman 1 tahun.
• Lulus Pelatihan Auditor HACCP, dgn Audit Track
: 3x adequacy audit, 5x asesmen, 5x memimpin
tim asesmen dibawah supervisi Auditor Kepala
• Auditor :
• Kriteria umum sama dgn diatas, keculai audit
track : 2x Adequacy audit, 5x asesmen
• Calon Auditor :
• Tidak diwajibkan mempunyai pengalaman
asesmen.
Bagian 3
auditor
requirements
7. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Kriteria FS Auditor – RAB Quality
Society of Australia
Bagian 3
auditor
requirements
• Senior FS Auditor :
•Tertiar/On-the-job Training, Auditor
Training
•General Work Experience 4 years
•Food safety Work Experience 2 Years
•Auditing Experience 20 days on site + 5
audits as a team leader
• FS Auditor :
•General requirements similar to above,
different on auditing experience 20 days
auditing on-site
• Associate FS Auditor :
•General requirements similar to above, no
need auditing experience.
8. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Auditor for FS Management System
Requriements – IRCA/902
Bagian 3
auditor
requirements
• FS Provisional Auditor :
• Education - At least secondary education
• Work Experience -Five years, or 4 years with a degree
or neardegree; Two years of food safety work
experience
• Auditor Training - An IRCA certified Food Safety
Auditor/Lead Auditor course or acceptable
alternative
• Auditing Experience - None
• FS Auditor :
• Auditing experience Four audits as an auditor-in-
training totalling 20 days, 10 days minimum on-site.
• FS Lead Auditor :
• Audit Experience : Four audits as an auditor-in-
training totalling 20 days, 10 days minimum on-site,
Three audits as lead auditor-in-training totalling 15
days, 10 days minimum on-site.
9. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Standard Akreditasi Lembaga
Sertifikasi Keamaman Pangan
Bagian 3
auditor
requirements
• Pedoman BSN 1001 – 1999 : Persyaratan
Umum Lembaga Sertifikasi sistem HACCP,
berbasis ISO 19011:2002 (Auditing Standard)
• Disesuaikan setelah diterbitkannya ISO/IEC
17021 Conformity Assessment – Requirements
for bodies providing audit and certification of
management system.
• Private / Commercial Standard : BRC, IFS,
EFSIS, SQF, GMP+, QS, GlobalGAP, dll.),
menggunakan ISO Guide 65 dan saat ini
disesuaikan dengan ISO/IEC 17021
11. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Key Competence of FS Auditor
Bagian 3
auditor
competence
FS Auditor
Competence
General
Competence :
Manajemen,
Komunikasi, Teknik
Audit, Identifikasi,
Leadership
FS Competencies :
-Identifikasi bahaya pangan
potensial dalam rantai pangan
-Identifikasi efektivitas metode
pengendalian bahaya
pangan
-Pemahaman thd HACCP
- Pemahaman produk dan
proses
-Mengerti regulasi, standar,
PRP, dan code of practices
12. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Keragaman FS Auditor di Indonesia
Bagian 4
auditor variety
• Internal FS Auditor
• FS Auditor – Lembaga Sertifikasi yang
terakreditasi KAN
• FS Auditor – Lembaga Sertifikasi yang tidak /
belum terakreditasi oleh KAN
• FS Auditor – Lembaga Sertifikasi dari Standar-
standar private / komersial : GMP+, SQF, BRC,
IFS, QS, GlobalGAP, UTZ Certified, dll.
• FS Auditor – Lembaga Pemerintah :
• Badan POM
• Departemen Pertanian (Hortikultura,
Peternakan, Perkebunan)
• Departemen Kelautan dan Perikanan
• FS Auditor : Approved by National Regulatory
Body - Mis. : AQIS
13. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Keragaman Industri Pengguna Sistem
Keamaman Pangan
Bagian 4
organization
variety
FS (M)
System
Agricultural
Primary Industry
Packaging
Industry
Food Trader
Processing
Industry
Handling &
warehpousing
Industry
15. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
FS Auditor di Indonesia & Standard
Sistem Keamanan Pangan
Bagian 4
auditor
challenge
Indonesia
FS Auditor
Standar
Nasional
Indonesia
Standar Nasional
Negara
Pengimpor
Produk Pangan
Indonesia
Standar-standar
Private/Komersial yg
diterbitkan oleh
retailer
ISO Standard
16. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Kompetensi FS Auditor di Indonesia
Bagian 4
auditor
challenge
Indonesia
FS Auditor
Auditor
Sistem
HACCP – SNI
4852
FS Auditor of NSF,
AQIS, dll. JAPAN
SCHEME?
Food Inspector
for BRC global
Standard
Auditor ISO
22000:2005
Auditor
GMP+, IFS,
QS, IFIS, dll.
17. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Tantangan Kompetensi FS Auditor di
Indonesia
Bagian 4
auditor
competency
There is no internationally
accepted standard for auditors of
food safety management systems.
Rather than ‘best practice’ in food
safety auditing, there is instead a
variety of different practices and
pathways by which auditors are
‘approved’ as qualified to perform
a specific auditing task. (Bill Mc.
Bride, NCS International)
18. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Tantangan Kompetensi FS Auditor di
Indonesia
Bagian 4
auditor
competency
The existing systems seem to be based
on reliance on:
•International standards which are
generic and open to interpretation;
•Organisational competence of
certification bodies rather than
individual
•auditor competence; and Provision of
training rather than identification and
application of competence.
19. Company
LOGO
SUCOFINDO AGRICULTURALSERVICES
Masa Depan FS Auditor di Indonesia
Bagian 4
auditor
opportunity
There is a need for international definition and
harmonisation of the methods by which food safety
auditors acquire the skills and knowledge necessary to
assure public safety and system integrity.
(NCS International)
• Masalah umum dalam hal
kompetensi auditor harus
terpecahlan
• ISO Telah mengembangkan
pedoman FSA dalam rangkanan ISO
22000
• Untuk Meningkatkan Confidence
kalangan industri