SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Fossil Fraud Foisted, Later Foiled
www.aboutbone.com
Nobody would likely appreciate having the words
hoax and fraud permanently associated with the
name of their hometown. Yet in 1908, the
discovery of some bone fragments and teeth left
local residents of the English village of Piltdown
helpless as nationalism, tunnel vision, and wishful
thinking hoodwinked the specialists who pondered
the findings’ significance.
www.aboutbone.com
These bones certainly have much to teach, but not,
as it turns out, about the discovery of a missing
link in the evolution of man.
www.aboutbone.com
In the early 20th century, paleoanthropology, the
study of human-like fossils, was hardly 50 years
old. The discovery of fossilized bones that
resembled those of humans in the German
Neander Valley in 1856 caused museums to re-
examine their fossil collections.
www.aboutbone.com
These were bones that had been collected
previously over several decades. In many instances,
their fossils matched the recent discovery in
Germany, and so they were reclassified as
Neanderthals. In due time, scientists determined that
Neanderthals were an extinct species and not an
intermediary in the development of Homo sapiens.
www.aboutbone.com
Early on, however, this determination encountered
some resistance. One noted scientist and evolution
doubter, for instance, tried to explain away the
Neanderthals’ prominent brow ridges by saying
that Neanderthals were simply early humans who
frowned a lot.
www.aboutbone.com
This was an exciting time for the burgeoning field
of paleoanthropology. If Neanderthals were not
the missing link between small-brained, four-
footed apes and man, what was? Human-like
fossils were turning up in France and Germany
along with stone tools of a similar age, whereas
British investigators were finding tools but no
fossils.
www.aboutbone.com
At the same time nationalism, which eventually
led to The Great War, was stirring. It was 1912
and Charles Dawson’s timing was perfect. As an
accomplished amateur scientist, he was privileged
to announce his discoveries, beginning in 1908, to
the Geological Society of London.
www.aboutbone.com
Dawson had
discovered some
fossilized skull
fragments, a jaw bone,
and several teeth.
They came from a
gravel pit near
Piltdown, a village
about 40 miles south
of London. Was this
the missing link?
www.aboutbone.com
The prevailing opinion was that man’s direct
ancestors were ape-like creatures who first
developed large brains. Then later, modification in
the shapes of the jaw and pelvis allowed this smart
animal to manage a varied diet and to walk
upright. Civilization eventually ensued.
www.aboutbone.com
Dawson’s discovery fit this
opinion. His Piltdown Man
(or it could have been a
woman) had a large
braincase and a primitive
ape-like jaw with canine
teeth that were intermediate
between apes and modern
man. It was the missing
link.
www.aboutbone.com
The Piltdown fossils became a pivot point for any
evolutionary theory that followed, usually using
Dawson’s findings for support, but at least having
to address them if there was disagreement. The
discovery stirred national pride in both
paleoanthropologists and the British public.
Museum exhibits flourished.
www.aboutbone.com
Drawings and models of the
imagined living appearance
of Mr. Piltdown, however,
attracted far more attention
than the fossils themselves.
He became part of popular
culture and the subject of
numerous newspaper articles,
letters to the editor,
postcards, books, chapters,
and monographs. He was a
rock star.
www.aboutbone.com
His discoverer,
Charles
Dawson, basked
in Mr. P's
limelight, and
the glorious
reputation of
both remained
unsullied for
decades.
Skepticism about the fossils’ authenticity came
early and in several forms. The fragmented and
limited skeletal pieces were, perhaps conveniently,
missing their most diagnostic portions.
www.aboutbone.com
Was the gravel bed where
Dawson found the fossils as
ancient as he indicated, or were
the fossils from a more recent
era? Were the jaw and cranial
fragments from the same
species? From the same
individual? To seek answers,
many investigators had to resign
themselves to study casts of the
fossils rather than the originals.
In 1915, a Smithsonian scientist complained about
the inadequacy of studying the casts. Even so, he
remarked that the skull fragments and jaw were
too different from each other to assume that they
were from the same creature. He felt that the skull
came from a human, not old, and the jaw from a
species of ancient chimpanzee.
www.aboutbone.com
Discovery of other human-like fossils in China
and Africa in the decades that followed produced
conflicting information, and general agreement on
how it all fit together was lacking.
www.aboutbone.com
During this time, Dawson’s reputation and his
findings’ major significance remained intact,
although he died in 1916.
www.aboutbone.com
The dogma generally prevailed until mid century
when the bones were subjected to a new test,
fluorine analysis. Fluorine seeps into buried bones
from the surrounding groundwater, so fossils from
the same animal and resting next to each other
will have equal fluorine content. This testing was
not undertaken lightly, since small portions of the
bones had to be destroyed in the process.
www.aboutbone.com
The results showed that the skull and jaw
fragments contained different levels of fluorine.
Additional analyses indicated that the bones were
not nearly old enough to be the missing link.
Furthermore, the skull was human and the other
bones were not human, and under microscopic
scrutiny the teeth showed evidence of having been
filed down to obscure their origin.
www.aboutbone.com
If confirmatory evidence was needed, it came in
2009. Both computed tomographic scanning and
DNA analysis indicated that the teeth and jaw
were from an orangutan. The CT scan also
revealed an off-white putty covering the bones’
surfaces and sealing interior voids, which were
filled with grains of sand.
www.aboutbone.com
It is likely that the perpetrator weighted the
relatively modern bones with sand to give them
the heft an expert would expect from a fossil.
Finally, the fraudster had stained all the surfaces
brown to give the bones an ancient, homogeneous
appearance.
www.aboutbone.com
Who was the perpetrator? Nobody knows for sure.
Conspiracy theories abound. The most likely
suspect of course is Charles Dawson. He was an
accomplished amateur geologist and archaeologist
with knowledge and experience about how ancient
artifacts looked. He was discovered to be
responsible for some other, small time antiquarian
fakes.
Dawson also pined for acceptance within the
British scientific community and made persistent,
but futile attempts to join the Royal Society. He
also yearned for knighthood, an honor that
bypassed him because of his early death but which
was bestowed on several of his contemporaries
who studied the Piltdown fossils.
www.aboutbone.com
How did this happen and what can we learn? First,
as con artists do so well, this fraudster showed his
audience what it wanted to see. The experts
suspended critical judgement and discounted the
red flags in their zeal to accept a British treasure,
one that put Britain at the forefront of scientific
discovery.
www.aboutbone.com
Second, the hoax would have been uncovered
much earlier had more investigators been able to
examine the fossils themselves. By contrast, in
every scientific discipline today, there are calls to
make the raw data, from which investigators draw
their results and conclusions, available for all to
scrutinize.
www.aboutbone.com
Third, new means of testing, particularly
nondestructive ones, will be forthcoming and
capable of re-examining “facts” with intensified
scrutiny.
www.aboutbone.com
The lessons that the Piltdown fakes can teach are
far more relevant and timeless than if the
discovery had been real. It is human nature to see
what we want to see, especially when it
conforms to our preconceived notions. Instead
we should take the evidence for what it is and
then retest its validity from time to time as new
methods become available.
www.aboutbone.com
www.aboutbone.com
reflecting history, art,
literature, science,
engineering, business,
popular culture, health

More Related Content

What's hot

Curiosity Machine: Build a Balanced Dinosaur
Curiosity Machine: Build a Balanced DinosaurCuriosity Machine: Build a Balanced Dinosaur
Curiosity Machine: Build a Balanced Dinosaur
AnnMarie Ppl
 
The Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious BipedThe Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious BipedSomaya
 
The Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious BipedThe Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious BipedSomaya
 
NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2
NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2
NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2Deborah Burgam
 
Lecture 5 Darwin Vs. God Revised With Margins Final
Lecture 5   Darwin Vs. God   Revised With Margins   FinalLecture 5   Darwin Vs. God   Revised With Margins   Final
Lecture 5 Darwin Vs. God Revised With Margins Final
lasierrauniv
 
The ritual
The ritualThe ritual
The ritual
Vinod Sailes
 
How to be a better researcher
How to be a better researcherHow to be a better researcher
How to be a better researcherJacqui Sharp
 
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims
madgenius
 
Another world (1) The author Ilze
Another world (1) The author IlzeAnother world (1) The author Ilze
Another world (1) The author Ilze
Eva Vovka
 
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals
madgenius
 
Do you think we are alone in the galaxy
Do you think we are alone in the galaxyDo you think we are alone in the galaxy
Do you think we are alone in the galaxy
Tom Clarke
 
Who killed the ice mummy project
Who killed the ice mummy projectWho killed the ice mummy project
Who killed the ice mummy projectMaria Donohue
 
002# sample questions
002# sample questions002# sample questions
002# sample questions
AbdulGhafoor274162
 
Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...
Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...
Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...
Roberto Rocco
 
Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...
Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...
Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...
Steven Kolber
 
Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012
Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012
Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012
Dhruv Sharma
 

What's hot (20)

Curiosity Machine: Build a Balanced Dinosaur
Curiosity Machine: Build a Balanced DinosaurCuriosity Machine: Build a Balanced Dinosaur
Curiosity Machine: Build a Balanced Dinosaur
 
Cdl2010fringe
Cdl2010fringeCdl2010fringe
Cdl2010fringe
 
The Middle Finger Of Modernity
The Middle Finger Of ModernityThe Middle Finger Of Modernity
The Middle Finger Of Modernity
 
The Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious BipedThe Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious Biped
 
The Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious BipedThe Mysterious Biped
The Mysterious Biped
 
Fossils In Africa
Fossils In AfricaFossils In Africa
Fossils In Africa
 
NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2
NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2
NatGeo Kids one sheet - 2
 
Lecture 5 Darwin Vs. God Revised With Margins Final
Lecture 5   Darwin Vs. God   Revised With Margins   FinalLecture 5   Darwin Vs. God   Revised With Margins   Final
Lecture 5 Darwin Vs. God Revised With Margins Final
 
The ritual
The ritualThe ritual
The ritual
 
How to be a better researcher
How to be a better researcherHow to be a better researcher
How to be a better researcher
 
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Prelims
 
Another world (1) The author Ilze
Another world (1) The author IlzeAnother world (1) The author Ilze
Another world (1) The author Ilze
 
What is history
What is historyWhat is history
What is history
 
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals
2018 KQA Science Quiz -- Finals
 
Do you think we are alone in the galaxy
Do you think we are alone in the galaxyDo you think we are alone in the galaxy
Do you think we are alone in the galaxy
 
Who killed the ice mummy project
Who killed the ice mummy projectWho killed the ice mummy project
Who killed the ice mummy project
 
002# sample questions
002# sample questions002# sample questions
002# sample questions
 
Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...
Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...
Learning from Darwin: What can the man who wrote The Origin of Species teach ...
 
Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...
Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...
Gattaca - Historical - Social - Cultrual Background - Key dates and events pr...
 
Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012
Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012
Prelims- Science Quiz at NSF 2012
 

Similar to Fossil fraud foisted, later foiled

Killian history assignment 1
Killian history assignment 1Killian history assignment 1
Killian history assignment 1cometknight123
 
Kate early man ppt
Kate early man pptKate early man ppt
Kate early man pptMs Wilson
 
Minimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docx
Minimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docxMinimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docx
Minimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docx
clairbycraft
 
Early humans ppt
Early humans pptEarly humans ppt
Early humans pptkevinkacel
 
TechTryst - Finals
TechTryst - FinalsTechTryst - Finals
TechTryst - Finals
Shreyans Jain
 
Early humans
Early humansEarly humans
Early humans
Braydon92
 
* Early humans ppt
*  Early humans ppt*  Early humans ppt
* Early humans ppttemaynard
 
Miscellaneous facts powepoint
Miscellaneous facts powepointMiscellaneous facts powepoint
Miscellaneous facts powepointrolandroventa17
 
Paranthropus Boisei
Paranthropus BoiseiParanthropus Boisei
Paranthropus Boisei
Sharon Lee
 
Black history in europe a synopsis
Black history in europe   a synopsisBlack history in europe   a synopsis
Black history in europe a synopsis
SonniBlaq
 
140 as 1
140 as 1140 as 1
140 as 1kwag929
 
Human skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human species
Human skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human speciesHuman skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human species
Human skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human species
Marcos Neumann
 
Theme one
Theme oneTheme one
Theme one
tydevere
 
Life And Discoveries Of Louis Leakey
Life And Discoveries Of Louis LeakeyLife And Discoveries Of Louis Leakey
Life And Discoveries Of Louis Leakey
Ashley Davis
 
early_humans.ppt
early_humans.pptearly_humans.ppt
early_humans.ppt
ZerohourSolutions
 

Similar to Fossil fraud foisted, later foiled (20)

Killian history assignment 1
Killian history assignment 1Killian history assignment 1
Killian history assignment 1
 
Kate early man ppt
Kate early man pptKate early man ppt
Kate early man ppt
 
Minimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docx
Minimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docxMinimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docx
Minimum of 350 words with references.You have a modern lens thro.docx
 
Early humans ppt
Early humans pptEarly humans ppt
Early humans ppt
 
TechTryst - Finals
TechTryst - FinalsTechTryst - Finals
TechTryst - Finals
 
Early humans
Early humansEarly humans
Early humans
 
Early humans
Early humansEarly humans
Early humans
 
* Early humans ppt
*  Early humans ppt*  Early humans ppt
* Early humans ppt
 
Miscellaneous facts powepoint
Miscellaneous facts powepointMiscellaneous facts powepoint
Miscellaneous facts powepoint
 
Neanderthals powerpoint
Neanderthals powerpointNeanderthals powerpoint
Neanderthals powerpoint
 
Paranthropus Boisei
Paranthropus BoiseiParanthropus Boisei
Paranthropus Boisei
 
Black history in europe a synopsis
Black history in europe   a synopsisBlack history in europe   a synopsis
Black history in europe a synopsis
 
140 as 1
140 as 1140 as 1
140 as 1
 
Big history
Big historyBig history
Big history
 
Human skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human species
Human skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human speciesHuman skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human species
Human skulls of peru possible evidence of a lost human species
 
Theme one
Theme oneTheme one
Theme one
 
Early Humans
Early HumansEarly Humans
Early Humans
 
Early humans
Early humansEarly humans
Early humans
 
Life And Discoveries Of Louis Leakey
Life And Discoveries Of Louis LeakeyLife And Discoveries Of Louis Leakey
Life And Discoveries Of Louis Leakey
 
early_humans.ppt
early_humans.pptearly_humans.ppt
early_humans.ppt
 

Recently uploaded

Predicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdf
Predicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdfPredicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdf
Predicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdf
binhminhvu04
 
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATIONPRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
ChetanK57
 
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlandsRichard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard Gill
 
filosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptx
filosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptxfilosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptx
filosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptx
IvanMallco1
 
Penicillin...........................pptx
Penicillin...........................pptxPenicillin...........................pptx
Penicillin...........................pptx
Cherry
 
Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...
Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...
Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...
Sérgio Sacani
 
Richard's entangled aventures in wonderland
Richard's entangled aventures in wonderlandRichard's entangled aventures in wonderland
Richard's entangled aventures in wonderland
Richard Gill
 
Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...
Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...
Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...
Sérgio Sacani
 
Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA
 Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA
Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA
SAMIR PANDA
 
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
Health Advances
 
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Sérgio Sacani
 
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.pptgeneral properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
IqrimaNabilatulhusni
 
Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...
Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...
Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...
NathanBaughman3
 
In silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptx
In silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptxIn silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptx
In silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptx
AlaminAfendy1
 
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of Lipids
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of LipidsGBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of Lipids
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of Lipids
Areesha Ahmad
 
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate PathwayCancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
AADYARAJPANDEY1
 
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebratesComparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
sachin783648
 
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptxerythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
muralinath2
 
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technologyNutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Lokesh Patil
 
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWSOrion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Columbia Weather Systems
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Predicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdf
Predicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdfPredicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdf
Predicting property prices with machine learning algorithms.pdf
 
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATIONPRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
 
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlandsRichard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
Richard's aventures in two entangled wonderlands
 
filosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptx
filosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptxfilosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptx
filosofia boliviana introducción jsjdjd.pptx
 
Penicillin...........................pptx
Penicillin...........................pptxPenicillin...........................pptx
Penicillin...........................pptx
 
Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...
Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...
Observation of Io’s Resurfacing via Plume Deposition Using Ground-based Adapt...
 
Richard's entangled aventures in wonderland
Richard's entangled aventures in wonderlandRichard's entangled aventures in wonderland
Richard's entangled aventures in wonderland
 
Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...
Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...
Earliest Galaxies in the JADES Origins Field: Luminosity Function and Cosmic ...
 
Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA
 Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA
Seminar of U.V. Spectroscopy by SAMIR PANDA
 
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
 
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
 
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.pptgeneral properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
 
Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...
Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...
Astronomy Update- Curiosity’s exploration of Mars _ Local Briefs _ leadertele...
 
In silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptx
In silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptxIn silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptx
In silico drugs analogue design: novobiocin analogues.pptx
 
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of Lipids
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of LipidsGBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of Lipids
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 5) Chemistry of Lipids
 
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate PathwayCancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
 
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebratesComparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
 
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptxerythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
 
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technologyNutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
Nutraceutical market, scope and growth: Herbal drug technology
 
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWSOrion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
Orion Air Quality Monitoring Systems - CWS
 

Fossil fraud foisted, later foiled

  • 1. Fossil Fraud Foisted, Later Foiled
  • 2. www.aboutbone.com Nobody would likely appreciate having the words hoax and fraud permanently associated with the name of their hometown. Yet in 1908, the discovery of some bone fragments and teeth left local residents of the English village of Piltdown helpless as nationalism, tunnel vision, and wishful thinking hoodwinked the specialists who pondered the findings’ significance.
  • 3. www.aboutbone.com These bones certainly have much to teach, but not, as it turns out, about the discovery of a missing link in the evolution of man.
  • 4. www.aboutbone.com In the early 20th century, paleoanthropology, the study of human-like fossils, was hardly 50 years old. The discovery of fossilized bones that resembled those of humans in the German Neander Valley in 1856 caused museums to re- examine their fossil collections.
  • 5. www.aboutbone.com These were bones that had been collected previously over several decades. In many instances, their fossils matched the recent discovery in Germany, and so they were reclassified as Neanderthals. In due time, scientists determined that Neanderthals were an extinct species and not an intermediary in the development of Homo sapiens.
  • 6. www.aboutbone.com Early on, however, this determination encountered some resistance. One noted scientist and evolution doubter, for instance, tried to explain away the Neanderthals’ prominent brow ridges by saying that Neanderthals were simply early humans who frowned a lot.
  • 7. www.aboutbone.com This was an exciting time for the burgeoning field of paleoanthropology. If Neanderthals were not the missing link between small-brained, four- footed apes and man, what was? Human-like fossils were turning up in France and Germany along with stone tools of a similar age, whereas British investigators were finding tools but no fossils.
  • 8. www.aboutbone.com At the same time nationalism, which eventually led to The Great War, was stirring. It was 1912 and Charles Dawson’s timing was perfect. As an accomplished amateur scientist, he was privileged to announce his discoveries, beginning in 1908, to the Geological Society of London.
  • 9. www.aboutbone.com Dawson had discovered some fossilized skull fragments, a jaw bone, and several teeth. They came from a gravel pit near Piltdown, a village about 40 miles south of London. Was this the missing link?
  • 10. www.aboutbone.com The prevailing opinion was that man’s direct ancestors were ape-like creatures who first developed large brains. Then later, modification in the shapes of the jaw and pelvis allowed this smart animal to manage a varied diet and to walk upright. Civilization eventually ensued.
  • 11. www.aboutbone.com Dawson’s discovery fit this opinion. His Piltdown Man (or it could have been a woman) had a large braincase and a primitive ape-like jaw with canine teeth that were intermediate between apes and modern man. It was the missing link.
  • 12. www.aboutbone.com The Piltdown fossils became a pivot point for any evolutionary theory that followed, usually using Dawson’s findings for support, but at least having to address them if there was disagreement. The discovery stirred national pride in both paleoanthropologists and the British public. Museum exhibits flourished.
  • 13. www.aboutbone.com Drawings and models of the imagined living appearance of Mr. Piltdown, however, attracted far more attention than the fossils themselves. He became part of popular culture and the subject of numerous newspaper articles, letters to the editor, postcards, books, chapters, and monographs. He was a rock star.
  • 14. www.aboutbone.com His discoverer, Charles Dawson, basked in Mr. P's limelight, and the glorious reputation of both remained unsullied for decades.
  • 15. Skepticism about the fossils’ authenticity came early and in several forms. The fragmented and limited skeletal pieces were, perhaps conveniently, missing their most diagnostic portions. www.aboutbone.com
  • 16. Was the gravel bed where Dawson found the fossils as ancient as he indicated, or were the fossils from a more recent era? Were the jaw and cranial fragments from the same species? From the same individual? To seek answers, many investigators had to resign themselves to study casts of the fossils rather than the originals.
  • 17. In 1915, a Smithsonian scientist complained about the inadequacy of studying the casts. Even so, he remarked that the skull fragments and jaw were too different from each other to assume that they were from the same creature. He felt that the skull came from a human, not old, and the jaw from a species of ancient chimpanzee. www.aboutbone.com
  • 18. Discovery of other human-like fossils in China and Africa in the decades that followed produced conflicting information, and general agreement on how it all fit together was lacking. www.aboutbone.com
  • 19. During this time, Dawson’s reputation and his findings’ major significance remained intact, although he died in 1916. www.aboutbone.com
  • 20. The dogma generally prevailed until mid century when the bones were subjected to a new test, fluorine analysis. Fluorine seeps into buried bones from the surrounding groundwater, so fossils from the same animal and resting next to each other will have equal fluorine content. This testing was not undertaken lightly, since small portions of the bones had to be destroyed in the process. www.aboutbone.com
  • 21. The results showed that the skull and jaw fragments contained different levels of fluorine. Additional analyses indicated that the bones were not nearly old enough to be the missing link. Furthermore, the skull was human and the other bones were not human, and under microscopic scrutiny the teeth showed evidence of having been filed down to obscure their origin. www.aboutbone.com
  • 22. If confirmatory evidence was needed, it came in 2009. Both computed tomographic scanning and DNA analysis indicated that the teeth and jaw were from an orangutan. The CT scan also revealed an off-white putty covering the bones’ surfaces and sealing interior voids, which were filled with grains of sand. www.aboutbone.com
  • 23. It is likely that the perpetrator weighted the relatively modern bones with sand to give them the heft an expert would expect from a fossil. Finally, the fraudster had stained all the surfaces brown to give the bones an ancient, homogeneous appearance. www.aboutbone.com
  • 24. Who was the perpetrator? Nobody knows for sure. Conspiracy theories abound. The most likely suspect of course is Charles Dawson. He was an accomplished amateur geologist and archaeologist with knowledge and experience about how ancient artifacts looked. He was discovered to be responsible for some other, small time antiquarian fakes.
  • 25. Dawson also pined for acceptance within the British scientific community and made persistent, but futile attempts to join the Royal Society. He also yearned for knighthood, an honor that bypassed him because of his early death but which was bestowed on several of his contemporaries who studied the Piltdown fossils. www.aboutbone.com
  • 26. How did this happen and what can we learn? First, as con artists do so well, this fraudster showed his audience what it wanted to see. The experts suspended critical judgement and discounted the red flags in their zeal to accept a British treasure, one that put Britain at the forefront of scientific discovery. www.aboutbone.com
  • 27. Second, the hoax would have been uncovered much earlier had more investigators been able to examine the fossils themselves. By contrast, in every scientific discipline today, there are calls to make the raw data, from which investigators draw their results and conclusions, available for all to scrutinize. www.aboutbone.com
  • 28. Third, new means of testing, particularly nondestructive ones, will be forthcoming and capable of re-examining “facts” with intensified scrutiny. www.aboutbone.com
  • 29. The lessons that the Piltdown fakes can teach are far more relevant and timeless than if the discovery had been real. It is human nature to see what we want to see, especially when it conforms to our preconceived notions. Instead we should take the evidence for what it is and then retest its validity from time to time as new methods become available. www.aboutbone.com
  • 30. www.aboutbone.com reflecting history, art, literature, science, engineering, business, popular culture, health