SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 27
Changes to the
Michigan Bridge Card:
   Is it Worth the
      Sacrifice?
---------------------------------------
             Michael Bennett
             Kaleigh Lawrence
              Brian Veenstra
            Prof. Jenn DeHaan
               PA 307 - 01
FOOD ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
          (FAP)
 “The
Food
Assistance
Program
(FAP)

 supplements
the
food
purchasing
power
of

 low‐income
individuals
and
families”
(Food

 Assistance
Program
Overview,
2011).

 “The
U.S.
Department
of
Agriculture
funds

 100
percent
of
this
program”
(Food

 Assistance
Program
Overview,
2011).

 The
state
and
federal
governments
share

 administraGve
costs.
(Food
Assistance

 Program
Overview,
2011).

 DHS
determines
eligibility
for
FAP.

Electronic Benefit
            Transfer
 Electronic
Benefit
Transfer
(EBT)
is
an
electronic
system
that

allows
a
recipient
to
authorize
transfer
of
their
government

benefits
from
a
Federal
account
to
a
retailer
account
to
pay

for
products
received
(
SNAP,
2009).

 “EBT
is
used
in
all
50
States,
the
District
of
Columbia,

Puerto
Rico,
the
Virgin
Islands,
and
Guam”
(
SNAP,
2009).

 
“State
food
stamp
agencies
work
with
contractors
to

procure
their
own
EBT
systems
for
delivery
of
Food
Stamp

and
other
state‐administered
benefit
programs”
(
SNAP,

2009).

EBT continued..
 “Once
eligibility
and
level
of
benefits
have
been

determined,
an
account
is
established
in
the
parGcipant's

name,
and
food
stamp
benefits
are
deposited
electronically

in
the
account
each
month”
(SNAP,2009).

 
“A
plasGc
card,
similar
to
a
bank
card,
is
issued”
(SNAP,
2009).

 “
A
personal
idenGficaGon
number
(PIN)
is
assigned
or

chosen
by
the
recipient
to
give
access
to
the

account”
(SNAP,2009).

Michigan’s Food Assistance
        Program:
   Food
Assistance
Benefits
are
issued
into
a
food
account

  using
electronic
technology
and
a
debit
card
known
as
the

  Michigan
Bridge
Card
oZen
called
the
“Bridge
Card”.

   Assistance
administered
by
Department
of
Human
Services

  in
Michigan.

Eligibility
Low
or
No
Income

Based
on
Household
Income
and
number
of
people

in
FAP
group.

Countable
Income:

   Wages

   Rental
Income

   Child
Support

   Social
Security
and
Veteran
Benefits
Work Requirements
To
Receive
FAP
Benefits:
  Adults
who
are
already
working
may
not:
    Voluntarily
quit
a
job
of
30
hours
or
more
per
week.

    Voluntarily
reduce
hours
of
employment
below
30
hours

    per
week.

    Be
fired
from
a
job
for
misconduct
or
absenteeism.
  Adults
who
are
not
working
or
are
working
less

 than
30
hours
per
week
must:
    Accept
a
bona‐fide
offer
of
employment
.
    ParGcipate
in
employment‐related
acGviGes
that
are

    required
of
an
individual
in
order
to
receive

    unemployment
compensaGon.
(DHS)
Work Requirements
   Continued…
Must
also
work
at
least
80
hours
a
month
(DHS).

 “Unless
deferred,
household
members
age
16

through
59
must
agree
to
parGcipate
in
employment‐
related
acGviGes
if
referred.
InformaGon
regarding

work
requirements
will
be
given
at
applicaGon
and

review”
(Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,

p.2).

Food Assistance
Total
amount
of
Food
Assistance
based
on

deducGons
of
20%
of
total
income
and
other

allowable
expenses.
    Allowable
expenses
include:
        Medical
expenses
over
$35
a
month
not

       covered
by
a
3rd
party
        Some
housing
and
uGlity
costs
        Some
Childcare
costs
        Court‐ordered
Child
support
paid
to
non‐
       household
member.
 
 
 (DHS)
What Can and Cannot Be
Can:      Purchased?
1.)
Any
non‐taxed
food
or
food
product.
2.)
Seeds
and
plants
for
use
in
a
home
garden.



Cannot:               


You
cannot
buy
nonfood
items
such
as:
1.)
soap


































2.)
pet
food
3.)
tobacco





























4.)
paper
products,

5.)
alcoholic
beverages











6.)
HOT
foods
7.)
Ready
to
Eat
foods











8.)
vitamins
or
medicines.

(
Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
p.
2).

Who Can Receive
          Benefits?
 “Any
“household”
that
meets
the
income
and
other

basic
eligibility
rules
shown
below
can
get
Food

Assistance
benefits”
(Food
Assistance
Benefits
in

Michigan,
2011,
p.2).
 
A
household
may
be
one
person
or
a
group
of

people
who
live
together
and
customarily
buy
and

prepare
their
food
together”
(

Food
Assistance

Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
p.2).

 A
person
who
is
a
boarder
or
lives
in
an
insGtuGon

(with
some
excepGons)
cannot
get
Food
Assistance

benefits
(
Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,

2011,
p.2).

How To Apply:

        Anyone
has
the
right
to
apply.

        The
local
Department
of
Human
Services
(DHS)
office
gives
or
mails
applicaGons

        in
the
date
requested.

        Requests
can
be
made:
         
 ‐
in
person
         
 ‐
by
phone
         
 ‐
by
mail
         
 ‐
by
someone
else
who
can
do
this
for
the
household

        The
applicaGon
must
be
turned
into
local
DHS
office
        Applicants
are
given
assistance
upon
request

        The
applicaGon
is
taken
on
the
day
the
day
that
it
is
turned
in,
even
if
the
case

        worker
is
not
present.

        You
can
also
apply
online
at
hkp://www.michigan.gov/mibridges
                  Once
in
the
program
consumers
can
also
uGlize
this
website
to
see
their

                  balance,
their
worker’s
contact
informaGon
and
can
reapply
when

                  necessary.

(
Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
p.2).

How To Apply
             Continued..
     Each applicant must be interviewed
      Interview is often over the phone unless an in-
     person interview is requested or consumer applying
     for cash benefits also.
     Eligible households receive their benefits by the
     30th day after turning in the filing form and/or the
     application.
      Those with little or no money may be able to get
     Food Assistance benefits within seven days.
(Food Assistance Benefits in Michigan, 2011, p.2).
Issue:
  The  State of Michigan is
   changing food assistance
requirements to be in sync with
     the Federal guidelines.

New Policy
“(They)
must
be
caring
for
children,
physically
or
mentally

unfit
for
employment,
parGcipaGng
in
an
on‐the‐job

training
program,
or
working
20
hours
a
week,”
said

ChrisGna
Fecher,
a
spokesperson
for
the
Michigan

Department
of
Human
Services
(DHS).
“Akending
college

by
itself
is
not
an
approved
excepGon,
and
our
department

will
enforce
that
policy
starGng
in
April”
(Witbeck,
2011).
Why Is This An Issue?

Many college students..

     FEEL that they need the assistance to make
   ends meet.

     WORRY that their assistance will be cut.
     DO NOT GET get assistance from
   parents or guardians and rely on public assistance.

     THINK         they deserve the assistance because
   they are working towards being a productive member
   of society.
Positive Perspectives...

  “Such
an
excepGon
is
not
only
unnecessary,
but
it
goes

  against
the
very
fiber
of
why
the
program
was
created
—

  to
help
low‐income
people.
Under
the
new
policy,
if

  students
meet
the
income
and
work
requirements,
they

  are
eligible
just
like
everyone
else”
(Inks,
2011).




  “(The
DHS)
is
ready
to
extend
a
helping
hand
to
any

  ciGzen
who
is
truly
in
need,
including
college
students

  who
…
are
taking
the
right
steps
toward
becoming
self‐
  sufficient,”
(Witbeck,
2011).

Positive Perspectives
“This
is
federal
money
…
and
we’re
blowing
it
on
welfare.
We

need
to
make
sure
that
it
is
going
to
those
who
really
need
it,”
he

said.
“If
we
don’t
get
a
handle
on
these
enGtlements,
the
future

generaGons
will
have
to
foot
a
lot
of
crazy
bills
for
things
we

didn’t
address”‐
Bob
Genetski
(legislator)
(Witbeck,
2011).



“A
lot
of
taxpayers
don’t
mind
helping
people
who
are
truly
in

need
but
they
were
infuriated
to
see
that
their
tax
dollars
were

going
to
a
situaGon
that
wasn’t
needy,”
he
said.
“A
lot
of
people

who
are
really
mad
about
it
are
those
who
worked
part‐Gme
or

full‐Gme
jobs
to
get
through
college.
They
feel
as
if
the
current

generaGon
doesn’t
understand
that
work
ethic”(Witbeck,
2011).

Negative Perspectives..
“No numbers for how much money the
move will save are available” - Christina Fecher;
DHS spokesperson

“I understand some students might abuse
the program, but students by and large
cannot afford food despite many state
officials’ assertions that students should
obtain assistance from family. My parents
help me out with some stuff, but they can’t
afford to help me out with everything...
Money you get from working in the summer
only lasts for so long.” -Josh Broecker Advertising
Senior at MSU
Negative Perspectives:

“The decision should have lashed out more
broadly at abuse by people other than college
students.” -State Rep. Mark Meadows D-East Lansing

“I would use [a food pantry] if it were a last resort,
but I think it’s for people who really really need
it,” said Hildbrandt-Cooper, who said she feels
caught in the middle ground between being “too
poor to afford groceries but not poor enough for
a food pantry.” - Grand Valley Lanthorn
Positive Impacts
   SAVES
money

   
PotenGally
DECREASES
fraud

   ALLOWS
Food
Assistance
Program
to
serve

those
that
are
truly
in
need

   IMPROVES           public perception of food
assistance programs and other welfare spending.
Negative Impacts

Students  SUFFER from starvation and
malnutrition.


Policy   ENCOURAGES Pregnancies.
Students spend less time studying and more time

WORRYING about the next meal.
LOSS of revenues for grocery stores.
Statistics
“The federally funded Food Assistance Program
serves almost 1.9 million Michigan residents,
including 805,000 children” (Peter, 2011)

DHS estimates that up to 20,000 of those users
are students qualified solely for the purpose of
being a college student.

2010 Census showed the Michigan Population at
9,883,640.

20% of all Michigan Residents receive food
assistance of which 1% are students in which this
policy impacts.
Recommendations

Making the state Bridge Card program uniform
with federal Food Assistance guidelines is the

RIGHT DECISION.
  Does
not
mean
students
are
ineligible
for
FAP
benefits.

  There
are
other
forms
of
food
assistance.

  Decreases
fraud
and
makes
the
system
serve
only
those

  who
have
true
need.
References

–   Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan
(2011
).
In
State
of
Michigan
Department
of
Human
Services

Retrieved

    April
19,
2011,
from
hkp://www.michigan.gov/documents/dhs/Pub_0016_206544_7.pdf

–   Food
Assistance
Program
Overview
(2011).
In
Department
of
Human
Services
.
Retrieved
April
19,
2011,
from

    hkp://www.michigan.gov/dhs/0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐21832‐‐,00.htmlhkp://www.michigan.gov/dhs/
    0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐21832‐‐,00.html



–   Inks,
N.
(n.d.).
COLUMN:
Michigan’s
former
Bridge
Card
policy
unnecessary
excepGon.
In
Central
Michigan

    Life
.
Retrieved
February
17,
2011,
from
hkp://www.cm‐life.com/2011/02/17/column‐michigans‐former‐
    bridge‐card‐policy‐unnecessary‐excepGon/hkp://www.cm‐life.com/2011/02/17/column‐michigans‐former‐
    bridge‐card‐policy‐unnecessary‐excepGon/

–   Luke, Peter. " Most Michigan college students will be ineligible for Bridge Card food
    assistance | MLive.com." MichiganLocal News, Breaking News, Sports & Weather -
    MLive.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Apr. 2011. <http://www.mlive.com/politics/index.ssf/
    2011/02/most_michigan_college_students

–   Supplemental
NutriGon
Assistance
Program
(n.d.).
In
United
States
Department
of
Agriculture:
Food
and

    Nutri?on
Service
.
Retrieved
April
30,
2009,
from
hkp://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/rules/LegislaGon/about.htm
References Cont..

State
of
Michigan
Department
of
Human
Services.
(n.d.).
Assistance
Applica?on
Informa?on
Booklet.
Retrieved
(April
19,2011)

         hkp://www.michigan.gov/documents/dhs/DHS_InformaGon_Boo
klet_and_Assistance_ApplicaGon_242170_7.pdf
   State
of
Michigan

Department
of
Human
Services.
(n.d.).
FAP
Eligibility
Requirements.
Retrieved
(April
19,
2011)
hkp://
                               www.michigan.gov/dhs/0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐13176‐‐,00.html


    State
of
Michigan
Department
of
Human
Services.
(n.d.).

FAP
Work
Requirements.

Retrieved
(April
19,
2011)
hkp://
                               www.michigan.gov/dhs/0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐13180‐‐,00.html
     Witbeck,
C.
(2011
,
February
24).
New
Rules
May
Decrease
Number
of
Students
Receiving
Benefits
.
In
The
North
Wind.


                     Retrieved   April
19,
2011,
from
http://www.thenorthwindonline.com/?p=3860275

More Related Content

What's hot

MC 380 Public Policy Paper
MC 380 Public Policy PaperMC 380 Public Policy Paper
MC 380 Public Policy PaperMikaela Haley
 
Interdisciplinary Team Collaboration
Interdisciplinary Team CollaborationInterdisciplinary Team Collaboration
Interdisciplinary Team CollaborationWriters Per Hour
 
Policy Accomplishments 2000-14
Policy Accomplishments 2000-14Policy Accomplishments 2000-14
Policy Accomplishments 2000-14Dennis S Murray Sr
 
MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...
MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...
MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...Steven Banjoff
 
SPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care Act
SPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care ActSPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care Act
SPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care Actmdanielsfirstfocus
 
Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014
Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014
Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014Carrie Spero-Usher
 
Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13
Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13
Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13Mary Beth Levin
 
1US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 2
1US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 21US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 2
1US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 2Jacqueline Slorach
 
Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013
Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013
Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013ClevelandFoodbank
 
Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)
Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)
Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)Kevin Kane
 
Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...
Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...
Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...Mitchell Davis Jr
 
Universal american healthcare
Universal american healthcareUniversal american healthcare
Universal american healthcareGary Sheets
 
Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...
Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...
Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...HFG Project
 

What's hot (20)

MC 380 Public Policy Paper
MC 380 Public Policy PaperMC 380 Public Policy Paper
MC 380 Public Policy Paper
 
Interdisciplinary Team Collaboration
Interdisciplinary Team CollaborationInterdisciplinary Team Collaboration
Interdisciplinary Team Collaboration
 
Policy Accomplishments 2000-14
Policy Accomplishments 2000-14Policy Accomplishments 2000-14
Policy Accomplishments 2000-14
 
MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...
MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...
MPH 608 Health communication and informatics Final Writing Assignment sample ...
 
SPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care Act
SPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care ActSPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care Act
SPARC Webinar: Child Welfare and the Affordable Care Act
 
Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014
Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014
Food-For-Thought---Winter-2014
 
Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13
Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13
Minnesota SEP State Fact Sheet 4.19.13
 
hypocrisy_report
hypocrisy_reporthypocrisy_report
hypocrisy_report
 
1US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 2
1US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 21US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 2
1US Agriculture Dept.- Ba...es - DominicanToday.com copy 2
 
HHS FY 2016 Budget
HHS  FY 2016 BudgetHHS  FY 2016 Budget
HHS FY 2016 Budget
 
Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013
Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013
Informational powerpoint CFB Help Center updated october 2013
 
UHPP 2016 Annual Report
UHPP 2016 Annual ReportUHPP 2016 Annual Report
UHPP 2016 Annual Report
 
211 in Utah
211 in Utah211 in Utah
211 in Utah
 
Nda regulatory breakout
Nda regulatory breakoutNda regulatory breakout
Nda regulatory breakout
 
International food-aid-reform
International food-aid-reformInternational food-aid-reform
International food-aid-reform
 
Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)
Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)
Got Healthcare? Affordable Care Act PP (July 2013)
 
Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...
Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...
Legislativerpt2007_Investing in Minnesota's Populations of Color and American...
 
Health 2.0 – The Next Wave
Health 2.0 – The Next WaveHealth 2.0 – The Next Wave
Health 2.0 – The Next Wave
 
Universal american healthcare
Universal american healthcareUniversal american healthcare
Universal american healthcare
 
Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...
Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...
Linkages Between the Essential Health Services Package and Government-Sponsor...
 

Similar to Michigan Bridge Card Changes Spark Debate

Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...
Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...
Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...BestHomeCare
 
Sir medicaid opportunity presentation
Sir medicaid opportunity presentationSir medicaid opportunity presentation
Sir medicaid opportunity presentationdongrunt
 
After reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docx
After reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docxAfter reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docx
After reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docxADDY50
 
Medicaid's Role for People with Disabilities
Medicaid's Role for People with DisabilitiesMedicaid's Role for People with Disabilities
Medicaid's Role for People with DisabilitiesVikki Wachino
 
Introduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docx
Introduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docxIntroduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docx
Introduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docxnormanibarber20063
 
Running head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docx
Running head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docxRunning head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docx
Running head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docxcowinhelen
 
Case Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docx
Case Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docxCase Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docx
Case Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docxwendolynhalbert
 
State Roles in Health Reform
State Roles in Health ReformState Roles in Health Reform
State Roles in Health Reformsoder145
 
The Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy Changes
The Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy ChangesThe Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy Changes
The Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy ChangesFeliciaF1
 
Tcad - Results Budget Debate Slides
Tcad - Results Budget Debate SlidesTcad - Results Budget Debate Slides
Tcad - Results Budget Debate Slidesoatmealbeach
 
Mental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental Health
Mental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental HealthMental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental Health
Mental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental HealthDr. James Swartz
 

Similar to Michigan Bridge Card Changes Spark Debate (16)

Michigan EBT
Michigan EBTMichigan EBT
Michigan EBT
 
Food stamps
Food stampsFood stamps
Food stamps
 
The farm bill 2013 stl food bank
The farm bill 2013  stl food bankThe farm bill 2013  stl food bank
The farm bill 2013 stl food bank
 
Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...
Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...
Learn Valuable Information for Getting Paid to Take Care of Your Family Membe...
 
Sir medicaid opportunity presentation
Sir medicaid opportunity presentationSir medicaid opportunity presentation
Sir medicaid opportunity presentation
 
After reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docx
After reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docxAfter reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docx
After reading the report on services in Georgia, write a short paper.docx
 
Medicaid's Role for People with Disabilities
Medicaid's Role for People with DisabilitiesMedicaid's Role for People with Disabilities
Medicaid's Role for People with Disabilities
 
Introduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docx
Introduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docxIntroduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docx
Introduction Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) .docx
 
Editorial
EditorialEditorial
Editorial
 
Running head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docx
Running head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docxRunning head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docx
Running head MEDICAID PROGRAM 1MEDICAID PROGRAM 7.docx
 
Case Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docx
Case Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docxCase Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docx
Case Study Global VillageNameMy Global Village question.docx
 
State Roles in Health Reform
State Roles in Health ReformState Roles in Health Reform
State Roles in Health Reform
 
AOF.webinar.09.27.11
AOF.webinar.09.27.11AOF.webinar.09.27.11
AOF.webinar.09.27.11
 
The Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy Changes
The Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy ChangesThe Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy Changes
The Negative Consequences of SNAP Policy Changes
 
Tcad - Results Budget Debate Slides
Tcad - Results Budget Debate SlidesTcad - Results Budget Debate Slides
Tcad - Results Budget Debate Slides
 
Mental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental Health
Mental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental HealthMental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental Health
Mental Health Policy - The Affordablle Care Act and Mental Health
 

Michigan Bridge Card Changes Spark Debate

  • 1. Changes to the Michigan Bridge Card: Is it Worth the Sacrifice? --------------------------------------- Michael Bennett Kaleigh Lawrence Brian Veenstra Prof. Jenn DeHaan PA 307 - 01
  • 2. FOOD ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (FAP) “The
Food
Assistance
Program
(FAP)
 supplements
the
food
purchasing
power
of
 low‐income
individuals
and
families”
(Food
 Assistance
Program
Overview,
2011).
 “The
U.S.
Department
of
Agriculture
funds
 100
percent
of
this
program”
(Food
 Assistance
Program
Overview,
2011).
 The
state
and
federal
governments
share
 administraGve
costs.
(Food
Assistance
 Program
Overview,
2011).
 DHS
determines
eligibility
for
FAP.

  • 3. Electronic Benefit Transfer Electronic
Benefit
Transfer
(EBT)
is
an
electronic
system
that
 allows
a
recipient
to
authorize
transfer
of
their
government
 benefits
from
a
Federal
account
to
a
retailer
account
to
pay
 for
products
received
(
SNAP,
2009).
 “EBT
is
used
in
all
50
States,
the
District
of
Columbia,
 Puerto
Rico,
the
Virgin
Islands,
and
Guam”
(
SNAP,
2009).
 
“State
food
stamp
agencies
work
with
contractors
to
 procure
their
own
EBT
systems
for
delivery
of
Food
Stamp
 and
other
state‐administered
benefit
programs”
(
SNAP,
 2009).

  • 4. EBT continued.. “Once
eligibility
and
level
of
benefits
have
been
 determined,
an
account
is
established
in
the
parGcipant's
 name,
and
food
stamp
benefits
are
deposited
electronically
 in
the
account
each
month”
(SNAP,2009).
 
“A
plasGc
card,
similar
to
a
bank
card,
is
issued”
(SNAP, 2009).
 “
A
personal
idenGficaGon
number
(PIN)
is
assigned
or
 chosen
by
the
recipient
to
give
access
to
the
 account”
(SNAP,2009).

  • 5.
  • 6. Michigan’s Food Assistance Program: Food
Assistance
Benefits
are
issued
into
a
food
account
 using
electronic
technology
and
a
debit
card
known
as
the
 Michigan
Bridge
Card
oZen
called
the
“Bridge
Card”.
 Assistance
administered
by
Department
of
Human
Services
 in
Michigan.

  • 8. Work Requirements To
Receive
FAP
Benefits: Adults
who
are
already
working
may
not: Voluntarily
quit
a
job
of
30
hours
or
more
per
week.
 Voluntarily
reduce
hours
of
employment
below
30
hours
 per
week.
 Be
fired
from
a
job
for
misconduct
or
absenteeism. Adults
who
are
not
working
or
are
working
less
 than
30
hours
per
week
must: Accept
a
bona‐fide
offer
of
employment
. ParGcipate
in
employment‐related
acGviGes
that
are
 required
of
an
individual
in
order
to
receive
 unemployment
compensaGon.
(DHS)
  • 9. Work Requirements Continued… Must
also
work
at
least
80
hours
a
month
(DHS). “Unless
deferred,
household
members
age
16
 through
59
must
agree
to
parGcipate
in
employment‐ related
acGviGes
if
referred.
InformaGon
regarding
 work
requirements
will
be
given
at
applicaGon
and
 review”
(Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
 p.2).

  • 10. Food Assistance Total
amount
of
Food
Assistance
based
on
 deducGons
of
20%
of
total
income
and
other
 allowable
expenses. Allowable
expenses
include: Medical
expenses
over
$35
a
month
not
 covered
by
a
3rd
party Some
housing
and
uGlity
costs Some
Childcare
costs Court‐ordered
Child
support
paid
to
non‐ household
member.
 
 
 (DHS)
  • 11. What Can and Cannot Be Can: Purchased? 1.)
Any
non‐taxed
food
or
food
product. 2.)
Seeds
and
plants
for
use
in
a
home
garden.
 Cannot: 

 You
cannot
buy
nonfood
items
such
as: 1.)
soap


































2.)
pet
food 3.)
tobacco





























4.)
paper
products,
 5.)
alcoholic
beverages











6.)
HOT
foods 7.)
Ready
to
Eat
foods











8.)
vitamins
or
medicines. (
Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
p.
2).

  • 12. Who Can Receive Benefits? “Any
“household”
that
meets
the
income
and
other
 basic
eligibility
rules
shown
below
can
get
Food
 Assistance
benefits”
(Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
 Michigan,
2011,
p.2). 
A
household
may
be
one
person
or
a
group
of
 people
who
live
together
and
customarily
buy
and
 prepare
their
food
together”
(

Food
Assistance
 Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
p.2).
 A
person
who
is
a
boarder
or
lives
in
an
insGtuGon
 (with
some
excepGons)
cannot
get
Food
Assistance
 benefits
(
Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
 2011,
p.2).

  • 13. How To Apply:
 Anyone
has
the
right
to
apply.
 The
local
Department
of
Human
Services
(DHS)
office
gives
or
mails
applicaGons
 in
the
date
requested.
 Requests
can
be
made: 
 ‐
in
person 
 ‐
by
phone 
 ‐
by
mail 
 ‐
by
someone
else
who
can
do
this
for
the
household
 The
applicaGon
must
be
turned
into
local
DHS
office Applicants
are
given
assistance
upon
request
 The
applicaGon
is
taken
on
the
day
the
day
that
it
is
turned
in,
even
if
the
case
 worker
is
not
present.
 You
can
also
apply
online
at
hkp://www.michigan.gov/mibridges Once
in
the
program
consumers
can
also
uGlize
this
website
to
see
their
 balance,
their
worker’s
contact
informaGon
and
can
reapply
when
 necessary.
 (
Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan,
2011,
p.2).

  • 14. How To Apply Continued.. Each applicant must be interviewed Interview is often over the phone unless an in- person interview is requested or consumer applying for cash benefits also. Eligible households receive their benefits by the 30th day after turning in the filing form and/or the application. Those with little or no money may be able to get Food Assistance benefits within seven days. (Food Assistance Benefits in Michigan, 2011, p.2).
  • 15. Issue: The State of Michigan is changing food assistance requirements to be in sync with the Federal guidelines.

  • 17. Why Is This An Issue?
 Many college students.. FEEL that they need the assistance to make ends meet. WORRY that their assistance will be cut. DO NOT GET get assistance from parents or guardians and rely on public assistance. THINK they deserve the assistance because they are working towards being a productive member of society.
  • 18. Positive Perspectives...
 “Such
an
excepGon
is
not
only
unnecessary,
but
it
goes
 against
the
very
fiber
of
why
the
program
was
created
—
 to
help
low‐income
people.
Under
the
new
policy,
if
 students
meet
the
income
and
work
requirements,
they
 are
eligible
just
like
everyone
else”
(Inks,
2011).
 “(The
DHS)
is
ready
to
extend
a
helping
hand
to
any
 ciGzen
who
is
truly
in
need,
including
college
students
 who
…
are
taking
the
right
steps
toward
becoming
self‐ sufficient,”
(Witbeck,
2011).

  • 19. Positive Perspectives “This
is
federal
money
…
and
we’re
blowing
it
on
welfare.
We
 need
to
make
sure
that
it
is
going
to
those
who
really
need
it,”
he
 said.
“If
we
don’t
get
a
handle
on
these
enGtlements,
the
future
 generaGons
will
have
to
foot
a
lot
of
crazy
bills
for
things
we
 didn’t
address”‐
Bob
Genetski
(legislator)
(Witbeck,
2011).
 “A
lot
of
taxpayers
don’t
mind
helping
people
who
are
truly
in
 need
but
they
were
infuriated
to
see
that
their
tax
dollars
were
 going
to
a
situaGon
that
wasn’t
needy,”
he
said.
“A
lot
of
people
 who
are
really
mad
about
it
are
those
who
worked
part‐Gme
or
 full‐Gme
jobs
to
get
through
college.
They
feel
as
if
the
current
 generaGon
doesn’t
understand
that
work
ethic”(Witbeck,
2011).

  • 20. Negative Perspectives.. “No numbers for how much money the move will save are available” - Christina Fecher; DHS spokesperson “I understand some students might abuse the program, but students by and large cannot afford food despite many state officials’ assertions that students should obtain assistance from family. My parents help me out with some stuff, but they can’t afford to help me out with everything... Money you get from working in the summer only lasts for so long.” -Josh Broecker Advertising Senior at MSU
  • 21. Negative Perspectives: “The decision should have lashed out more broadly at abuse by people other than college students.” -State Rep. Mark Meadows D-East Lansing “I would use [a food pantry] if it were a last resort, but I think it’s for people who really really need it,” said Hildbrandt-Cooper, who said she feels caught in the middle ground between being “too poor to afford groceries but not poor enough for a food pantry.” - Grand Valley Lanthorn
  • 22. Positive Impacts SAVES
money
 
PotenGally
DECREASES
fraud
 ALLOWS
Food
Assistance
Program
to
serve
 those
that
are
truly
in
need IMPROVES public perception of food assistance programs and other welfare spending.
  • 23. Negative Impacts Students SUFFER from starvation and malnutrition. Policy ENCOURAGES Pregnancies. Students spend less time studying and more time WORRYING about the next meal. LOSS of revenues for grocery stores.
  • 24. Statistics “The federally funded Food Assistance Program serves almost 1.9 million Michigan residents, including 805,000 children” (Peter, 2011) DHS estimates that up to 20,000 of those users are students qualified solely for the purpose of being a college student. 2010 Census showed the Michigan Population at 9,883,640. 20% of all Michigan Residents receive food assistance of which 1% are students in which this policy impacts.
  • 25. Recommendations Making the state Bridge Card program uniform with federal Food Assistance guidelines is the RIGHT DECISION. Does
not
mean
students
are
ineligible
for
FAP
benefits. There
are
other
forms
of
food
assistance. Decreases
fraud
and
makes
the
system
serve
only
those
 who
have
true
need.
  • 26. References
 – Food
Assistance
Benefits
in
Michigan
(2011
).
In
State
of
Michigan
Department
of
Human
Services

Retrieved
 April
19,
2011,
from
hkp://www.michigan.gov/documents/dhs/Pub_0016_206544_7.pdf – Food
Assistance
Program
Overview
(2011).
In
Department
of
Human
Services
.
Retrieved
April
19,
2011,
from
 hkp://www.michigan.gov/dhs/0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐21832‐‐,00.htmlhkp://www.michigan.gov/dhs/ 0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐21832‐‐,00.html – Inks,
N.
(n.d.).
COLUMN:
Michigan’s
former
Bridge
Card
policy
unnecessary
excepGon.
In
Central
Michigan
 Life
.
Retrieved
February
17,
2011,
from
hkp://www.cm‐life.com/2011/02/17/column‐michigans‐former‐ bridge‐card‐policy‐unnecessary‐excepGon/hkp://www.cm‐life.com/2011/02/17/column‐michigans‐former‐ bridge‐card‐policy‐unnecessary‐excepGon/ – Luke, Peter. " Most Michigan college students will be ineligible for Bridge Card food assistance | MLive.com." MichiganLocal News, Breaking News, Sports & Weather - MLive.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Apr. 2011. <http://www.mlive.com/politics/index.ssf/ 2011/02/most_michigan_college_students – Supplemental
NutriGon
Assistance
Program
(n.d.).
In
United
States
Department
of
Agriculture:
Food
and
 Nutri?on
Service
.
Retrieved
April
30,
2009,
from
hkp://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/rules/LegislaGon/about.htm
  • 27. References Cont.. State
of
Michigan
Department
of
Human
Services.
(n.d.).
Assistance
Applica?on
Informa?on
Booklet.
Retrieved
(April
19,2011)
 hkp://www.michigan.gov/documents/dhs/DHS_InformaGon_Boo
klet_and_Assistance_ApplicaGon_242170_7.pdf State
of
Michigan

Department
of
Human
Services.
(n.d.).
FAP
Eligibility
Requirements.
Retrieved
(April
19,
2011)
hkp:// www.michigan.gov/dhs/0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐13176‐‐,00.html
 State
of
Michigan
Department
of
Human
Services.
(n.d.).

FAP
Work
Requirements.

Retrieved
(April
19,
2011)
hkp:// www.michigan.gov/dhs/0,1607,7‐124‐5453_5527‐13180‐‐,00.html Witbeck,
C.
(2011
,
February
24).
New
Rules
May
Decrease
Number
of
Students
Receiving
Benefits
.
In
The
North
Wind.
 Retrieved April
19,
2011,
from
http://www.thenorthwindonline.com/?p=3860275

Editor's Notes

  1. \n
  2. \n
  3. \n
  4. \n
  5. \n
  6. \n
  7. \n
  8. \n
  9. \n
  10. \n
  11. \n
  12. \n
  13. \n
  14. \n
  15. \n
  16. \n
  17. \n
  18. \n
  19. \n
  20. \n
  21. \n
  22. \n
  23. \n
  24. \n
  25. \n
  26. \n
  27. \n