SlideShare a Scribd company logo
EUCI FIT 2 PROGRAM
             M & A Activities
            How We Got There
  (It seemed like a good idea at the time)
                     &
         Where We Go From Here
     (Look w hat you got us into Ollie!)
                                      Toronto, Ontario
                                          July 20, 2012
Basic Presentation Approach
• D efine M & A – For purposes of this
  presentation, does not mean Mergers and
  Acquisitions but financing and associated
  activities
• In the context of the FIT 1 program means
  financing of a FIT project to satisfy the
  requirements of N TP
• Expanded under FIT 2 because of rule changes
  and changing nature of Ontario pow er market
• Includes debt and equity and focuses on (i)
  requirements for launch FIT 1 projects and (ii)
  financing requirements under FIT 2 environment
Who Is ORTECH
•   Head office in Mississauga w ith satellite offices in Windsor and
    Sarnia
•   Predecessor is Ontario Research Foundation
•   Active in atmospheric sciences since mid 1970’s; privatized in 1999
•   Staff of 40 professionals and technicians in tw o divisions ORTECH
    Environmental & ORTECH Pow er
•   Principals of ORTECH Pow er have backgrounds as renew able
    energy developers w ith experience in small hydro and w ind –
    developed, constructed & operated 3.3 MW small hydro project near
    Englehart & developed Wolfe Island Ecocentre now ow ned and
    operated by TransAlta
•   Focused on consulting in 2005 after acquisition of development
    business by Canadian Hydro D evelopers
Who Is ORTECH
• ORTECH Pow er has tw o classes of clients: (i) Private
  developers w ho use ORTECH to provide technical and
  financial analytical services and (ii) financial institutions and
  infrastructure investors w ho have financial skills but need
  technical advice
• One of few renew able energy consulting firms that take
  technical information and apply it to financial models to
  assess economic viability of renew able projects
• Have evaluated onshore and offshore w ind, hydro and solar
  projects throughout N orth America and Europe
• Practical experience as developers and operators gives
  sensitivity to unknow ns such as O & M Costs and component
  life cycles; special skills at finding plugged numbers
Current Ontario Pow er
               Market
•   Period of falling industrial demand and increasing non -dispatchable
    renew able supply
•   Fixed price contracts for renew ables exceeds hourly spot market price
    (HOEP) by large margin
•   Rapidly increasing Global Adjustment (GA) is a sensitive political
    issue threatening FIT Program
•   GA is difference betw een fixed price FIT program pricing and HOEP;
    for onshore w ind under FIT 1 current price in excess of $140 MWh;
    HOEP averages $30-$40/MWh w hich means GA w ill increase by
    $100/ MWh as FIT 1 projects reach COD
•   Problem w ill intensify as more FIT 1 projects come on line
•   Rising pow er prices w ill determine M & A activity for next few
    years
Ontario Pow er Prices
                $80.00
                              Ontario Market Prices   5000000

                                                      4500000
                $70.00
                                                                                    HOEP
                                                      4000000
                $60.00
                                                      3500000




                                                                Annual MWh Output
                $50.00                                                              GA
Price per MWh




                                                      3000000

                $40.00                                2500000
                                                                                    Op Reserve
                                                      2000000
                $30.00
                                                      1500000
                $20.00
                                                                                    on-peak
                                                      1000000
                                                                                    minus off-
                $10.00                                                              peak
                                                      500000

                   $-                                 0
FIT 1 M & A Activities
• Launch Period Projects approaching N PT
• Facing Liquidated D amages over failure
  to meet Milestone COD
• Tw o principal reasons (i) over-optimistic
  belief in ability to complete projects on
  an accelerated basis and (ii) failure of
  REA process to live up to streamlined
  approval process – see demise of REA co-
  ordinator from expediter to receptionist
FIT 1 M & A Activities
        OPA Potential Responses
• Under FIT 1 rules failure to meet Milestone N TP D ate can
  result in cancellation of contract
• Form of Waiver precludes Supplier claiming force majeure
  for permitting reasons
• Unclear w hether elevation of REA to the Environmental
  Tribunal qualifies as force majeure claim
• Given oversupply of renew able energy capacity, no
  incentive for OPA to be lenient
• But cancellation of FIT contracts w ith D omestic Content
  requirements w ill impact job creation targets under Green
  Energy & Economy Act.
• Classic “rock and hard place” competing policies dilemma
FIT 1 M & A Activities
• One possibility is in Section 2.4 (f) is a
  N TP D eferral N otice
• Second approach is horse trading w ith
  respect to D omestic Content levels
• Conclusion: FIT Launch projects may
  be high risk leading to contingent
  payments and development fees offset
  by liquidated damages.
• Buyer bew are.
FIT 2 M & A Activities
           What’s N ew
• Backlog of microFIT Projects – OPA reports 49,000 microFIT
  applications plus additional 12,000 in draft contract stage
• Priority Point system for FIT 2 Projects: Minimum 1 point
  necessary to qualify for FIT Contract. Highest point level for
  Community, Aboriginal and MUSH sector projects
• microFIT Projects present opportunity to broaden base of
  support for FIT Program w ith minimal increase in Global
  Adjustment
• Community, Aboriginal and MUSH sector projects also
  increase FIT support, serve broader social objectives, but less
  Global Adjustment neutral
FIT 2 M & A Activities
      Opportunities & Fearless Forecasts
• 192 FIT 1 projects had reached COD
  as of D ecember 31, 2011
• As of D ecember 31, 2011 the OPA had aw arded
  1,968 FIT Contracts leaving 1,772 to reach N TP. Of
  the 1,968, 1,792 or 91% w ere solar PV
• Given FIT 2 price reductions and falling module
  prices these contracts are extremely valuable
• Watch for intense competition for these contracts as
  they approach N TP and are required to submit
  financial plans
FIT 2 M & A Activities
           More Fearless Forecasts
• Emphasis on microFIT is an opportunity for
  aggregators and mortgage lenders
• Aggregators w ill require debt funding; due
  diligence activity for banks and other lenders to
  assess economic and technical merits of microFIT
  projects
• Community and Aboriginal projects w ill require
  innovative financial structures to ensure maximum
  adders
FIT 2 M & A Activities
 Land Mines, Booby Traps & Roadside IED ’s
• Given oversupply and falling demand large scale
  projects likely to be deferred – possibly until 2017
  w hen SBG issue is expected to disappear
• Failure to meet Milestone COD cannot be redeemed
  through repurchase of missed days
• For Priority Point projects, drop in Participation
  Level = Event of D efault
• Annual Pricing Review adds further uncertainty
• Long-term project planning and development
  expenditures threatened by inherent political risk
FIT 2 M & A Activities
        Thank you for your attention

Copies of this presentation are available on the ORTECH w ebsite –
w w w .ortech.ca

Or email or telephone    achant@ortech.ca
                         905-822-4120 ext. 463

More Related Content

Similar to EUCI Presentation by Andrew Chant FIT 2.0 Program July 20 2012

Earnings Presentation to Investors and Analysts
Earnings Presentation to Investors and AnalystsEarnings Presentation to Investors and Analysts
Earnings Presentation to Investors and Analysts
flanagin
 
BHP Billiton vs. Rio Tinto
BHP Billiton vs. Rio TintoBHP Billiton vs. Rio Tinto
BHP Billiton vs. Rio Tinto
eholmes80
 
Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...
Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...
Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...
Lu-Alex Lu-Alex
 
Bahia Investment Opportunities
Bahia Investment OpportunitiesBahia Investment Opportunities
Bahia Investment Opportunities
Romeu Temporal
 
Presentación TechBa - Csoftmty
Presentación TechBa - CsoftmtyPresentación TechBa - Csoftmty
Presentación TechBa - Csoftmty
Csoftmty Monterrey
 
D2 challenger point
D2 challenger pointD2 challenger point
D2 challenger pointJon Morgan
 
Infrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High Commissioner
Infrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High CommissionerInfrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High Commissioner
Infrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High CommissionerUK Trade & Investment Australia
 
Solar Energy - China - Sample
Solar Energy - China - SampleSolar Energy - China - Sample
Solar Energy - China - Sample
Netscribes, Inc.
 
2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit
2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit
2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit
Jack Brittain
 
Ship Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentation
Ship Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentationShip Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentation
Ship Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentationTradeWindsnews
 
24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...
24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...
24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...
The Business Council of Mongolia
 
Overview of the 2012 Farm Bill
Overview of the 2012 Farm BillOverview of the 2012 Farm Bill
Overview of the 2012 Farm Bill
nacaa
 
Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...
Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...
Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...
Burton Lee
 
Real Food Happens Here
Real Food Happens HereReal Food Happens Here
Real Food Happens Here
Todd Sweet
 
Infrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economy
Infrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economyInfrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economy
Infrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economy
JohnsonAtCornell
 
Hoffman presentation
Hoffman presentationHoffman presentation
Hoffman presentationLeslie Feeney
 
The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know
The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know
The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know
siq_agile
 
Survey of recent developments
Survey of recent developmentsSurvey of recent developments
Survey of recent developments
rossmcle
 
Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3
Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3
Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3
Leonardo ENERGY
 
State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]
State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]
State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]
Smithers Apex
 

Similar to EUCI Presentation by Andrew Chant FIT 2.0 Program July 20 2012 (20)

Earnings Presentation to Investors and Analysts
Earnings Presentation to Investors and AnalystsEarnings Presentation to Investors and Analysts
Earnings Presentation to Investors and Analysts
 
BHP Billiton vs. Rio Tinto
BHP Billiton vs. Rio TintoBHP Billiton vs. Rio Tinto
BHP Billiton vs. Rio Tinto
 
Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...
Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...
Facile pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass at high loadings in room tempe...
 
Bahia Investment Opportunities
Bahia Investment OpportunitiesBahia Investment Opportunities
Bahia Investment Opportunities
 
Presentación TechBa - Csoftmty
Presentación TechBa - CsoftmtyPresentación TechBa - Csoftmty
Presentación TechBa - Csoftmty
 
D2 challenger point
D2 challenger pointD2 challenger point
D2 challenger point
 
Infrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High Commissioner
Infrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High CommissionerInfrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High Commissioner
Infrastructure: UK Opportunities - H.E. Paul Madden, British High Commissioner
 
Solar Energy - China - Sample
Solar Energy - China - SampleSolar Energy - China - Sample
Solar Energy - China - Sample
 
2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit
2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit
2012 National Governors Association Growing State Economies Summit
 
Ship Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentation
Ship Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentationShip Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentation
Ship Finance Int Q3 2012 results presentation
 
24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...
24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...
24.11.2010 The role of emerging markets in meeting the worlds commodity deman...
 
Overview of the 2012 Farm Bill
Overview of the 2012 Farm BillOverview of the 2012 Farm Bill
Overview of the 2012 Farm Bill
 
Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...
Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...
Burton Lee - University Research Panel - Intl Technology Law Assn 4th Confere...
 
Real Food Happens Here
Real Food Happens HereReal Food Happens Here
Real Food Happens Here
 
Infrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economy
Infrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economyInfrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economy
Infrastructure PPPs as an investment opportunity in Brazil’s economy
 
Hoffman presentation
Hoffman presentationHoffman presentation
Hoffman presentation
 
The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know
The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know
The Business Case for Agile: What Every Executive Needs to Know
 
Survey of recent developments
Survey of recent developmentsSurvey of recent developments
Survey of recent developments
 
Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3
Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3
Course on Regulation and Sustainable Energy in Developing Countries - Session 3
 
State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]
State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]
State RPS targets and the CEC role in achieving success [CSTP 2010]
 

More from mtingle

Managing The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy Projects
Managing The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy ProjectsManaging The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy Projects
Managing The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy Projects
mtingle
 
One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?
One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?
One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?
mtingle
 
A case study in offshore wind farm project management
A case study in offshore wind farm project managementA case study in offshore wind farm project management
A case study in offshore wind farm project management
mtingle
 
Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010
Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010
Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010
mtingle
 
Understanding Challenges Facing Small Wind Projects
Understanding Challenges Facing  Small Wind ProjectsUnderstanding Challenges Facing  Small Wind Projects
Understanding Challenges Facing Small Wind Projects
mtingle
 
Firstly, Why Wind ?
Firstly,  Why Wind ?Firstly,  Why Wind ?
Firstly, Why Wind ?
mtingle
 
Wind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons Learned
Wind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons LearnedWind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons Learned
Wind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons Learned
mtingle
 
O&M Budgeting
O&M BudgetingO&M Budgeting
O&M Budgeting
mtingle
 
Wind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource AssessmentWind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource Assessmentmtingle
 
Wind Industry and Gear Boxes
Wind Industry and Gear BoxesWind Industry and Gear Boxes
Wind Industry and Gear Boxes
mtingle
 
Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)
Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)
Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)
mtingle
 
2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...
2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...
2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...
mtingle
 
Community Wind – Making Them Work
Community Wind – Making Them WorkCommunity Wind – Making Them Work
Community Wind – Making Them Work
mtingle
 
Odour Management 101 Wef2008
Odour Management 101 Wef2008Odour Management 101 Wef2008
Odour Management 101 Wef2008
mtingle
 
Financial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to Know
Financial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to KnowFinancial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to Know
Financial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to Know
mtingle
 
Maximizing Wind Farm Output
Maximizing Wind Farm OutputMaximizing Wind Farm Output
Maximizing Wind Farm Output
mtingle
 
Wind Farms: Underperformance Fears –Avoid Overcompensating
Wind Farms:  Underperformance Fears –Avoid OvercompensatingWind Farms:  Underperformance Fears –Avoid Overcompensating
Wind Farms: Underperformance Fears –Avoid Overcompensatingmtingle
 
Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...
Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...
Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...
mtingle
 

More from mtingle (18)

Managing The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy Projects
Managing The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy ProjectsManaging The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy Projects
Managing The Risk Of Financing Renewable Energy Projects
 
One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?
One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?
One Odour Unit-Precisely how can an Odour Unit be measured?
 
A case study in offshore wind farm project management
A case study in offshore wind farm project managementA case study in offshore wind farm project management
A case study in offshore wind farm project management
 
Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010
Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010
Can Wea Supply Chain Final June 10, 2010
 
Understanding Challenges Facing Small Wind Projects
Understanding Challenges Facing  Small Wind ProjectsUnderstanding Challenges Facing  Small Wind Projects
Understanding Challenges Facing Small Wind Projects
 
Firstly, Why Wind ?
Firstly,  Why Wind ?Firstly,  Why Wind ?
Firstly, Why Wind ?
 
Wind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons Learned
Wind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons LearnedWind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons Learned
Wind Sector Building a Business Strategy Our Lessons Learned
 
O&M Budgeting
O&M BudgetingO&M Budgeting
O&M Budgeting
 
Wind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource AssessmentWind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource Assessment
 
Wind Industry and Gear Boxes
Wind Industry and Gear BoxesWind Industry and Gear Boxes
Wind Industry and Gear Boxes
 
Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)
Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)
Opacity of Visible Emissions Ontario Regulation 419/05 Section 34 (Amended)
 
2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...
2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...
2010 Green Energy Act Finance Forum Presentation on Risk Management for small...
 
Community Wind – Making Them Work
Community Wind – Making Them WorkCommunity Wind – Making Them Work
Community Wind – Making Them Work
 
Odour Management 101 Wef2008
Odour Management 101 Wef2008Odour Management 101 Wef2008
Odour Management 101 Wef2008
 
Financial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to Know
Financial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to KnowFinancial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to Know
Financial Sensitivity in the Wind Industry The Numbers You Really Need to Know
 
Maximizing Wind Farm Output
Maximizing Wind Farm OutputMaximizing Wind Farm Output
Maximizing Wind Farm Output
 
Wind Farms: Underperformance Fears –Avoid Overcompensating
Wind Farms:  Underperformance Fears –Avoid OvercompensatingWind Farms:  Underperformance Fears –Avoid Overcompensating
Wind Farms: Underperformance Fears –Avoid Overcompensating
 
Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...
Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...
Managing Technical & Project Risks on Small Renewable Energy Projects (...
 

EUCI Presentation by Andrew Chant FIT 2.0 Program July 20 2012

  • 1. EUCI FIT 2 PROGRAM M & A Activities How We Got There (It seemed like a good idea at the time) & Where We Go From Here (Look w hat you got us into Ollie!) Toronto, Ontario July 20, 2012
  • 2. Basic Presentation Approach • D efine M & A – For purposes of this presentation, does not mean Mergers and Acquisitions but financing and associated activities • In the context of the FIT 1 program means financing of a FIT project to satisfy the requirements of N TP • Expanded under FIT 2 because of rule changes and changing nature of Ontario pow er market • Includes debt and equity and focuses on (i) requirements for launch FIT 1 projects and (ii) financing requirements under FIT 2 environment
  • 3. Who Is ORTECH • Head office in Mississauga w ith satellite offices in Windsor and Sarnia • Predecessor is Ontario Research Foundation • Active in atmospheric sciences since mid 1970’s; privatized in 1999 • Staff of 40 professionals and technicians in tw o divisions ORTECH Environmental & ORTECH Pow er • Principals of ORTECH Pow er have backgrounds as renew able energy developers w ith experience in small hydro and w ind – developed, constructed & operated 3.3 MW small hydro project near Englehart & developed Wolfe Island Ecocentre now ow ned and operated by TransAlta • Focused on consulting in 2005 after acquisition of development business by Canadian Hydro D evelopers
  • 4. Who Is ORTECH • ORTECH Pow er has tw o classes of clients: (i) Private developers w ho use ORTECH to provide technical and financial analytical services and (ii) financial institutions and infrastructure investors w ho have financial skills but need technical advice • One of few renew able energy consulting firms that take technical information and apply it to financial models to assess economic viability of renew able projects • Have evaluated onshore and offshore w ind, hydro and solar projects throughout N orth America and Europe • Practical experience as developers and operators gives sensitivity to unknow ns such as O & M Costs and component life cycles; special skills at finding plugged numbers
  • 5. Current Ontario Pow er Market • Period of falling industrial demand and increasing non -dispatchable renew able supply • Fixed price contracts for renew ables exceeds hourly spot market price (HOEP) by large margin • Rapidly increasing Global Adjustment (GA) is a sensitive political issue threatening FIT Program • GA is difference betw een fixed price FIT program pricing and HOEP; for onshore w ind under FIT 1 current price in excess of $140 MWh; HOEP averages $30-$40/MWh w hich means GA w ill increase by $100/ MWh as FIT 1 projects reach COD • Problem w ill intensify as more FIT 1 projects come on line • Rising pow er prices w ill determine M & A activity for next few years
  • 6. Ontario Pow er Prices $80.00 Ontario Market Prices 5000000 4500000 $70.00 HOEP 4000000 $60.00 3500000 Annual MWh Output $50.00 GA Price per MWh 3000000 $40.00 2500000 Op Reserve 2000000 $30.00 1500000 $20.00 on-peak 1000000 minus off- $10.00 peak 500000 $- 0
  • 7. FIT 1 M & A Activities • Launch Period Projects approaching N PT • Facing Liquidated D amages over failure to meet Milestone COD • Tw o principal reasons (i) over-optimistic belief in ability to complete projects on an accelerated basis and (ii) failure of REA process to live up to streamlined approval process – see demise of REA co- ordinator from expediter to receptionist
  • 8. FIT 1 M & A Activities OPA Potential Responses • Under FIT 1 rules failure to meet Milestone N TP D ate can result in cancellation of contract • Form of Waiver precludes Supplier claiming force majeure for permitting reasons • Unclear w hether elevation of REA to the Environmental Tribunal qualifies as force majeure claim • Given oversupply of renew able energy capacity, no incentive for OPA to be lenient • But cancellation of FIT contracts w ith D omestic Content requirements w ill impact job creation targets under Green Energy & Economy Act. • Classic “rock and hard place” competing policies dilemma
  • 9. FIT 1 M & A Activities • One possibility is in Section 2.4 (f) is a N TP D eferral N otice • Second approach is horse trading w ith respect to D omestic Content levels • Conclusion: FIT Launch projects may be high risk leading to contingent payments and development fees offset by liquidated damages. • Buyer bew are.
  • 10. FIT 2 M & A Activities What’s N ew • Backlog of microFIT Projects – OPA reports 49,000 microFIT applications plus additional 12,000 in draft contract stage • Priority Point system for FIT 2 Projects: Minimum 1 point necessary to qualify for FIT Contract. Highest point level for Community, Aboriginal and MUSH sector projects • microFIT Projects present opportunity to broaden base of support for FIT Program w ith minimal increase in Global Adjustment • Community, Aboriginal and MUSH sector projects also increase FIT support, serve broader social objectives, but less Global Adjustment neutral
  • 11. FIT 2 M & A Activities Opportunities & Fearless Forecasts • 192 FIT 1 projects had reached COD as of D ecember 31, 2011 • As of D ecember 31, 2011 the OPA had aw arded 1,968 FIT Contracts leaving 1,772 to reach N TP. Of the 1,968, 1,792 or 91% w ere solar PV • Given FIT 2 price reductions and falling module prices these contracts are extremely valuable • Watch for intense competition for these contracts as they approach N TP and are required to submit financial plans
  • 12. FIT 2 M & A Activities More Fearless Forecasts • Emphasis on microFIT is an opportunity for aggregators and mortgage lenders • Aggregators w ill require debt funding; due diligence activity for banks and other lenders to assess economic and technical merits of microFIT projects • Community and Aboriginal projects w ill require innovative financial structures to ensure maximum adders
  • 13. FIT 2 M & A Activities Land Mines, Booby Traps & Roadside IED ’s • Given oversupply and falling demand large scale projects likely to be deferred – possibly until 2017 w hen SBG issue is expected to disappear • Failure to meet Milestone COD cannot be redeemed through repurchase of missed days • For Priority Point projects, drop in Participation Level = Event of D efault • Annual Pricing Review adds further uncertainty • Long-term project planning and development expenditures threatened by inherent political risk
  • 14. FIT 2 M & A Activities Thank you for your attention Copies of this presentation are available on the ORTECH w ebsite – w w w .ortech.ca Or email or telephone achant@ortech.ca 905-822-4120 ext. 463