The Philippine Board of Ophthalmology embarks on a difficult task of mandating teaching of ethics and professionalism for residency Training Programs in Ophthalmology in the country. This is the first lecture in that conference defining both ethics and medical professionalism.
IntroductionThis paper will provide a review of the compliance r.docxnormanibarber20063
Introduction
This paper will provide a review of the compliance report based on the general conducts of the medical staff at USA Community Hospital. The validity of patients’ claims for denial of services will be investigated and a mechanism to address such claims will be also provided. The primary roles that the staff can play in upholding ethics at their work place will be provided and legal consequences for non-compliance will also be stipulated.
A Plan to Investigate the Validity of Patients’ Claims for Denial of Services
1. Identification of Allegations and Issues to be Investigated- The issues to be investigated include the allegation of denial of services to the HIV/AIDS patients. Other issues to be investigated include patient review registries, and standard procedures surrounding the ethical treatment of patients with HIV / AIDS. These follow complaints that were brought forward by the public that the professional staff at USA Community Hospital were denying HIV/AIDS patients proper treatment.
2. Investigative Strategy- The investigation will involve a request to the patients who suffered the discriminative treatment to come forward for individual interviews to help in finding out more about their allegations. The medical files of these patients will be checked to verify their claims and to identify any sign of negligence on the doctors’ part. Finally the mentioned medical personnel will also be individually interviewed and thoroughly investigated. The interview panel will be chaired by the head healthcare administrators and other members will consist of the quality assurance manager, case manager, and file coordinator.
3. Sources of Evidence- The sources of evidence will consist of any violation of applicable laws, procedures, regulations, or ethical guidelines as pertained to the hospital patient treatment regulations. Other sources of evidence will involve documentation such as notes on the patients file, patients’ lab reports, e-mail exchange between the patients and doctors, and the personal files of the involved professional staff. Witnesses and physical evidence such as video records will be used.
4. Special Considerations- This process will involve use of power as provided in the US constitution. It will also involve surprise visits to the alleged doctors’ to find out how they treat their patients. Reluctant witnesses will be identified and interviewed.
5. Required Personnel and Resources- The process will involve a wide range of personnel and resources. Experts and lawyers for the victims and the accused personnel will be required in the process. Medical Psychologist and Psychiatrist will also be invited to help identify the validity of statements from the complainants as well as the accused. Enough time, rooms, and other facilities such as remunerations for the panel members will also be considered and made available.
6. Milestones and Timelines- This whole process goal is to only take two months to get to completion and.
Patient PrivacyWK1 Disc1Explain the importance of patient priv.docxdanhaley45372
Patient Privacy
WK1 Disc1
Explain the importance of patient privacy. How can one protect the privacy of one’s health records? How can one prove that one’s medical privacy was violated? What can be done if one thinks that one’s medical privacy was violated? 300-word discussion post
Wk 1 Disc 2
Analyze why patients are sometimes reluctant to complain about their health care. What could be some reasons for the reluctance to complain? How can medical providers encourage patients to express concerns about their health care? How can confidence to complain be developed among patients? 300-word discussion post
IntroductionContracts flourish in the health care industry. They could either be oral or written. The law of contracts is introduced as it relates to health care organizations and health care professionals. Contracts are important that even big corporations rely on them. Health care organizations have specified duties to care for both their stakeholders and customers. The mandatory Sarbanes-Oxley Act and legal doctrine Respondeat Superior are discussed. Organizations are sometimes held liable for the negligence of their employees. Legal issues surrounding the duties and responsibilities of an organization’s governing body are analyzed. Article
Wood, D. (2011). Michael Jackson trial: Did Conrad Murray act as a doctor or an enabler? The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved from the ProQuest database.
Wk 2 Disc 1
Create an enforceable contract in any department of a health care organization. How can a contract be legally valid? When is a contract voidable? What happens when one of the parties cannot perform the obligations written in the contract?
Wk 2 Disc 2
Develop a plan for compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) in a hospital setting. How can employees become knowledgeable with the major provisions of SOX? How can top executives comply with the major provisions? How can conflicts of interests in the organization be observed? Respond to two of your classmates’ posts.
Introduction
Physicians play a critical role in the American health care system. They are not only leaders, but, they greatly influence the lives of the people that they treat. The responsibility is enormous in meeting the needs of the patients, As such, standards of conduct are provided to guide them in dealing with patients and other health care professionals. They have to work collaboratively with nursing staff members and other allied professionals in caring for their patients. Thus, legal issues concerning the allied professionals are examined and law in nursing is explored.
Articles
Beck, M. (2010). The doctor will never see you again; Physicians can boot patients for unruly behavior, drug abuse and other reasons, but must follow rules. Wall Street Journal (Online). Retrieved from the ABI/INFORM database.
Hanson, M. (2010). RNs and LPNs want to be heard on changing roles: Is the state board changing rules, or just clarifying them.
Navigate 2 Scenario for Health PolicyEpisode 1Policy An.docxmayank272369
Navigate 2 Scenario for Health Policy
Episode 1:
Policy Analysis and Development
Overview
In this episode, you will be in a health care policy internship program in a Senator’s office in Washington, D.C. The Senator wants to develop policy that requires all health care organizations that receive federal funds to implement the recommendations presented in the Institute of Medicine reports on quality care. You will develop a policy, so that it can become proposed legislation. You must collect data, describe the problem, solutions and related ethical issues, examine the cost-benefit analysis, identify stakeholders (such as lobbyists from American Hospital Association, health care providers, health care corporations, pharmaceuticals, insurers, etc.), and impact. Based on this information, you will create a policy description that will be the foundation for a bill. You will describe critical issues that would be in the bill such as requirements of hospitals to:
Monitor and report medical errors to the Department of Health and Human Services
Use root cause analysis on a certain percentage of errors
Track and report patient outcomes focused on the clinical problems identified in the
National Health Care
Quality Report
Integrate the 5 health care profession core competencies into staff education and track outcomes
Establish a no-blame culture
*I suggest for you to do some research on your own, and if you use outside sources to help your compile your policy description, be sure to reference them (following an APA format) at the end of your post.
Assignment
You will post a policy description to this discussion board forum. Make sure to identify a plan that addresses legal and ethical issues in a health care policy. You must also respond to 2 of your peers' posts and make sure to reference any outside sources you may have used in your recommendation.
Below are the characters from this LearnScapes scenario (LearnScapes for
Health Policy
1):
The Student (which is you), Health Care Policy Intern for Congress
The student used to work within the Bright Road Health Care System, and had a special interest in policy. The student is thinking about moving into politics, hoping to make a difference at that level. The student has just been accepted into the internship; this is the student’s first big project.
Peter Shackley, Senior Policy Staff Member
The student’s mentor, Peter, is a young and feisty staff member. In his late 20s, Pete has been interested in politics since he was President of his high school student body. He’s especially passionate about policy-making and how the process works. Pete will help guide the student through the policy-making process.
Gretchen Wilde, Senator Chief of Staff
Gretchen is in her 30s and has been the Senator’s Chief of Staff for about 2 years now. She’s very professional, and holds high expectations for everyone in the Senator’s office, including interns. Gretchen is responsible for reviewing polic.
The Philippine Board of Ophthalmology embarks on a difficult task of mandating teaching of ethics and professionalism for residency Training Programs in Ophthalmology in the country. This is the first lecture in that conference defining both ethics and medical professionalism.
IntroductionThis paper will provide a review of the compliance r.docxnormanibarber20063
Introduction
This paper will provide a review of the compliance report based on the general conducts of the medical staff at USA Community Hospital. The validity of patients’ claims for denial of services will be investigated and a mechanism to address such claims will be also provided. The primary roles that the staff can play in upholding ethics at their work place will be provided and legal consequences for non-compliance will also be stipulated.
A Plan to Investigate the Validity of Patients’ Claims for Denial of Services
1. Identification of Allegations and Issues to be Investigated- The issues to be investigated include the allegation of denial of services to the HIV/AIDS patients. Other issues to be investigated include patient review registries, and standard procedures surrounding the ethical treatment of patients with HIV / AIDS. These follow complaints that were brought forward by the public that the professional staff at USA Community Hospital were denying HIV/AIDS patients proper treatment.
2. Investigative Strategy- The investigation will involve a request to the patients who suffered the discriminative treatment to come forward for individual interviews to help in finding out more about their allegations. The medical files of these patients will be checked to verify their claims and to identify any sign of negligence on the doctors’ part. Finally the mentioned medical personnel will also be individually interviewed and thoroughly investigated. The interview panel will be chaired by the head healthcare administrators and other members will consist of the quality assurance manager, case manager, and file coordinator.
3. Sources of Evidence- The sources of evidence will consist of any violation of applicable laws, procedures, regulations, or ethical guidelines as pertained to the hospital patient treatment regulations. Other sources of evidence will involve documentation such as notes on the patients file, patients’ lab reports, e-mail exchange between the patients and doctors, and the personal files of the involved professional staff. Witnesses and physical evidence such as video records will be used.
4. Special Considerations- This process will involve use of power as provided in the US constitution. It will also involve surprise visits to the alleged doctors’ to find out how they treat their patients. Reluctant witnesses will be identified and interviewed.
5. Required Personnel and Resources- The process will involve a wide range of personnel and resources. Experts and lawyers for the victims and the accused personnel will be required in the process. Medical Psychologist and Psychiatrist will also be invited to help identify the validity of statements from the complainants as well as the accused. Enough time, rooms, and other facilities such as remunerations for the panel members will also be considered and made available.
6. Milestones and Timelines- This whole process goal is to only take two months to get to completion and.
Patient PrivacyWK1 Disc1Explain the importance of patient priv.docxdanhaley45372
Patient Privacy
WK1 Disc1
Explain the importance of patient privacy. How can one protect the privacy of one’s health records? How can one prove that one’s medical privacy was violated? What can be done if one thinks that one’s medical privacy was violated? 300-word discussion post
Wk 1 Disc 2
Analyze why patients are sometimes reluctant to complain about their health care. What could be some reasons for the reluctance to complain? How can medical providers encourage patients to express concerns about their health care? How can confidence to complain be developed among patients? 300-word discussion post
IntroductionContracts flourish in the health care industry. They could either be oral or written. The law of contracts is introduced as it relates to health care organizations and health care professionals. Contracts are important that even big corporations rely on them. Health care organizations have specified duties to care for both their stakeholders and customers. The mandatory Sarbanes-Oxley Act and legal doctrine Respondeat Superior are discussed. Organizations are sometimes held liable for the negligence of their employees. Legal issues surrounding the duties and responsibilities of an organization’s governing body are analyzed. Article
Wood, D. (2011). Michael Jackson trial: Did Conrad Murray act as a doctor or an enabler? The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved from the ProQuest database.
Wk 2 Disc 1
Create an enforceable contract in any department of a health care organization. How can a contract be legally valid? When is a contract voidable? What happens when one of the parties cannot perform the obligations written in the contract?
Wk 2 Disc 2
Develop a plan for compliance with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) in a hospital setting. How can employees become knowledgeable with the major provisions of SOX? How can top executives comply with the major provisions? How can conflicts of interests in the organization be observed? Respond to two of your classmates’ posts.
Introduction
Physicians play a critical role in the American health care system. They are not only leaders, but, they greatly influence the lives of the people that they treat. The responsibility is enormous in meeting the needs of the patients, As such, standards of conduct are provided to guide them in dealing with patients and other health care professionals. They have to work collaboratively with nursing staff members and other allied professionals in caring for their patients. Thus, legal issues concerning the allied professionals are examined and law in nursing is explored.
Articles
Beck, M. (2010). The doctor will never see you again; Physicians can boot patients for unruly behavior, drug abuse and other reasons, but must follow rules. Wall Street Journal (Online). Retrieved from the ABI/INFORM database.
Hanson, M. (2010). RNs and LPNs want to be heard on changing roles: Is the state board changing rules, or just clarifying them.
Navigate 2 Scenario for Health PolicyEpisode 1Policy An.docxmayank272369
Navigate 2 Scenario for Health Policy
Episode 1:
Policy Analysis and Development
Overview
In this episode, you will be in a health care policy internship program in a Senator’s office in Washington, D.C. The Senator wants to develop policy that requires all health care organizations that receive federal funds to implement the recommendations presented in the Institute of Medicine reports on quality care. You will develop a policy, so that it can become proposed legislation. You must collect data, describe the problem, solutions and related ethical issues, examine the cost-benefit analysis, identify stakeholders (such as lobbyists from American Hospital Association, health care providers, health care corporations, pharmaceuticals, insurers, etc.), and impact. Based on this information, you will create a policy description that will be the foundation for a bill. You will describe critical issues that would be in the bill such as requirements of hospitals to:
Monitor and report medical errors to the Department of Health and Human Services
Use root cause analysis on a certain percentage of errors
Track and report patient outcomes focused on the clinical problems identified in the
National Health Care
Quality Report
Integrate the 5 health care profession core competencies into staff education and track outcomes
Establish a no-blame culture
*I suggest for you to do some research on your own, and if you use outside sources to help your compile your policy description, be sure to reference them (following an APA format) at the end of your post.
Assignment
You will post a policy description to this discussion board forum. Make sure to identify a plan that addresses legal and ethical issues in a health care policy. You must also respond to 2 of your peers' posts and make sure to reference any outside sources you may have used in your recommendation.
Below are the characters from this LearnScapes scenario (LearnScapes for
Health Policy
1):
The Student (which is you), Health Care Policy Intern for Congress
The student used to work within the Bright Road Health Care System, and had a special interest in policy. The student is thinking about moving into politics, hoping to make a difference at that level. The student has just been accepted into the internship; this is the student’s first big project.
Peter Shackley, Senior Policy Staff Member
The student’s mentor, Peter, is a young and feisty staff member. In his late 20s, Pete has been interested in politics since he was President of his high school student body. He’s especially passionate about policy-making and how the process works. Pete will help guide the student through the policy-making process.
Gretchen Wilde, Senator Chief of Staff
Gretchen is in her 30s and has been the Senator’s Chief of Staff for about 2 years now. She’s very professional, and holds high expectations for everyone in the Senator’s office, including interns. Gretchen is responsible for reviewing polic.
Similar to Ethics & Professionalism Lecture 2_slides (20)
Empowering ACOs: Leveraging Quality Management Tools for MIPS and BeyondHealth Catalyst
Join us as we delve into the crucial realm of quality reporting for MSSP (Medicare Shared Savings Program) Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).
In this session, we will explore how a robust quality management solution can empower your organization to meet regulatory requirements and improve processes for MIPS reporting and internal quality programs. Learn how our MeasureAble application enables compliance and fosters continuous improvement.
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdfNEHA GUPTA
The "ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance" PDF provides a comprehensive overview of the International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH) guidelines related to pharmacovigilance. These guidelines aim to ensure that drugs are safe and effective for patients by monitoring and assessing adverse effects, ensuring proper reporting systems, and improving risk management practices. The document is essential for professionals in the pharmaceutical industry, regulatory authorities, and healthcare providers, offering detailed procedures and standards for pharmacovigilance activities to enhance drug safety and protect public health.
The dimensions of healthcare quality refer to various attributes or aspects that define the standard of healthcare services. These dimensions are used to evaluate, measure, and improve the quality of care provided to patients. A comprehensive understanding of these dimensions ensures that healthcare systems can address various aspects of patient care effectively and holistically. Dimensions of Healthcare Quality and Performance of care include the following; Appropriateness, Availability, Competence, Continuity, Effectiveness, Efficiency, Efficacy, Prevention, Respect and Care, Safety as well as Timeliness.
This document is designed as an introductory to medical students,nursing students,midwives or other healthcare trainees to improve their understanding about how health system in Sri Lanka cares children health.
For those battling kidney disease and exploring treatment options, understanding when to consider a kidney transplant is crucial. This guide aims to provide valuable insights into the circumstances under which a kidney transplant at the renowned Hiranandani Hospital may be the most appropriate course of action. By addressing the key indicators and factors involved, we hope to empower patients and their families to make informed decisions about their kidney care journey.
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...Guillermo Rivera
This conference will delve into the intricate intersections between mental health, legal frameworks, and the prison system in Bolivia. It aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the current challenges faced by mental health professionals working within the legislative and correctional landscapes. Topics of discussion will include the prevalence and impact of mental health issues among the incarcerated population, the effectiveness of existing mental health policies and legislation, and potential reforms to enhance the mental health support system within prisons.
India Diagnostic Labs Market: Dynamics, Key Players, and Industry Projections...Kumar Satyam
According to the TechSci Research report titled “India Diagnostic Labs Market Industry Size, Share, Trends, Competition, Opportunity, and Forecast, 2019-2029,” the India Diagnostic Labs Market was valued at USD 16,471.21 million in 2023 and is projected to grow at an impressive compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 11.55% through 2029. This significant growth can be attributed to various factors, including collaborations and partnerships among leading companies, the expansion of diagnostic chains, and increasing accessibility to diagnostic services across the country. This comprehensive report delves into the market dynamics, recent trends, drivers, competitive landscape, and benefits of the research report, providing a detailed analysis of the India Diagnostic Labs Market.
Collaborations and Partnerships
Collaborations and partnerships among leading companies play a pivotal role in driving the growth of the India Diagnostic Labs Market. These strategic alliances allow companies to merge their expertise, strengthen their market positions, and offer innovative solutions. By combining resources, companies can enhance their research and development capabilities, expand their product portfolios, and improve their distribution networks. These collaborations also facilitate the sharing of technological advancements and best practices, contributing to the overall growth of the market.
Expansion of Diagnostic Chains
The expansion of diagnostic chains is a driving force behind the growing demand for diagnostic lab services. Diagnostic chains often establish multiple laboratories and diagnostic centers in various cities and regions, including urban and rural areas. This expanded network makes diagnostic services more accessible to a larger portion of the population, addressing healthcare disparities and reaching underserved populations. The presence of diagnostic chain facilities in multiple locations within a city or region provides convenience for patients, reducing travel time and effort. A broader network of labs often leads to reduced waiting times for appointments and sample collection, ensuring that patients receive timely and efficient diagnostic services.
Rising Prevalence of Chronic Diseases
The increasing prevalence of chronic diseases is a significant driver for the demand for diagnostic lab services. Chronic conditions such as diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and cancer require regular monitoring and diagnostic testing for effective management. The rise in chronic diseases necessitates the use of advanced diagnostic tools and technologies, driving the growth of the diagnostic labs market. Additionally, early diagnosis and timely intervention are crucial for managing chronic diseases, further boosting the demand for diagnostic lab services.
Medical Technology Tackles New Health Care Demand - Research Report - March 2...pchutichetpong
M Capital Group (“MCG”) predicts that with, against, despite, and even without the global pandemic, the medical technology (MedTech) industry shows signs of continuous healthy growth, driven by smaller, faster, and cheaper devices, growing demand for home-based applications, technological innovation, strategic acquisitions, investments, and SPAC listings. MCG predicts that this should reflects itself in annual growth of over 6%, well beyond 2028.
According to Chris Mouchabhani, Managing Partner at M Capital Group, “Despite all economic scenarios that one may consider, beyond overall economic shocks, medical technology should remain one of the most promising and robust sectors over the short to medium term and well beyond 2028.”
There is a movement towards home-based care for the elderly, next generation scanning and MRI devices, wearable technology, artificial intelligence incorporation, and online connectivity. Experts also see a focus on predictive, preventive, personalized, participatory, and precision medicine, with rising levels of integration of home care and technological innovation.
The average cost of treatment has been rising across the board, creating additional financial burdens to governments, healthcare providers and insurance companies. According to MCG, cost-per-inpatient-stay in the United States alone rose on average annually by over 13% between 2014 to 2021, leading MedTech to focus research efforts on optimized medical equipment at lower price points, whilst emphasizing portability and ease of use. Namely, 46% of the 1,008 medical technology companies in the 2021 MedTech Innovator (“MTI”) database are focusing on prevention, wellness, detection, or diagnosis, signaling a clear push for preventive care to also tackle costs.
In addition, there has also been a lasting impact on consumer and medical demand for home care, supported by the pandemic. Lockdowns, closure of care facilities, and healthcare systems subjected to capacity pressure, accelerated demand away from traditional inpatient care. Now, outpatient care solutions are driving industry production, with nearly 70% of recent diagnostics start-up companies producing products in areas such as ambulatory clinics, at-home care, and self-administered diagnostics.
LGBTQ+ Adults: Unique Opportunities and Inclusive Approaches to CareVITASAuthor
This webinar helps clinicians understand the unique healthcare needs of the LGBTQ+ community, primarily in relation to end-of-life care. Topics include social and cultural background and challenges, healthcare disparities, advanced care planning, and strategies for reaching the community and improving quality of care.
PET CT beginners Guide covers some of the underrepresented topics in PET CTMiadAlsulami
This lecture briefly covers some of the underrepresented topics in Molecular imaging with cases , such as:
- Primary pleural tumors and pleural metastases.
- Distinguishing between MPM and Talc Pleurodesis.
- Urological tumors.
- The role of FDG PET in NET.
PET CT beginners Guide covers some of the underrepresented topics in PET CT
Ethics & Professionalism Lecture 2_slides
1.
2. The Culture of Health Care
Ethics and Professionalism
Lecture b
This material (Comp 2 Unit 8) was developed by Oregon Health & Science University, funded by the Department
of Health and Human Services, Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology under
Award Number IU24OC000015. This material was updated in 2016 by Bellevue College under Award
Number 90WT0002.
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International
License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/.
3. Ethics and Professionalism
Learning Objectives
• Discuss foundational concepts in medical ethics
and professionalism (Lecture a).
• Examine the relationships among ethical ideals,
professionalism, and legal duties (Lecture a, b).
• Apply the general principles of ethics and
professionalism to specific topics (Lecture c, d).
• Examine ethical issues in health informatics
(Lecture d).
3
4. Ethical Standards and
Legal Standards
• Sometimes they are the same
– Example: Both law and ethics prohibit harmful surgery
on a healthy patient
• Sometimes they overlap or interact
– Example of overlap: State and federal laws set
standards for the practice of medicine
– Example of interaction: Failure to meet professional
standards can create legal liability (malpractice case)
• Sometimes they conflict
– Example: Court orders disclosure of patient
information
4
5. AMA Opinion
• Ethical values and legal principles are closely related
• Ethical obligations typically exceed legal duties
• Sometimes the law mandates unethical conduct
• Generally, physicians should obey current laws and work
to change unjust laws
• In rare cases, ethical responsibilities should take priority
over unjust laws
• Even if a legal proceeding finds a physician to be
innocent, he or she may have acted unethically
5
7. State Medical Practice Law
• Defines the practice of medicine within the
state
• Establishes a state medical board
• Governs testing and licensing of
physicians
• Specifies procedures for investigation,
enforcement, and discipline of physicians
7
8. State Medical Board
• The majority of the members are
physicians, but should also include non-
physicians
• Writes rules and regulations
• Gives examinations and awards medical
licenses
• Investigates complaints, holds hearings
• Administers disciplinary actions
• Evaluates medical education programs 8
9. Unprofessional Conduct
• Investigators gather information
• Board determines whether unprofessional
conduct has occurred
• Board imposes sanctions
– Fines
– Mandatory medical education
– Mandatory medical treatment
– Suspension or revocation of license
9
10. Investigation vs. Malpractice
• State medical board investigation
– Addresses physician’s responsibility to the
medical profession
• Malpractice lawsuit
– Addresses physician’s liability to patient
• The same act or situation may result in
both an investigation and a lawsuit
10
11. Four Basics of Malpractice
• Health care provider had a duty to the
patient
• Minimum standards of care were not met
• The failure to meet standards of care
caused an injury
• The injury resulted in damages (harm)
11
12. Professionalism and
the Culture of Health Care
• Lofty goals can compete with fear of
potential consequences
• Prevailing attitudes in the health care
culture can make it difficult to uncover
ethical lapses
12
13. The Hidden Curriculum
in Medical Education
• The “culture” of a medical school can
contradict formal medical ethics training
• Students learn by:
– “Reading between the lines” of written
institutional policies
– Observing standards used for evaluation of
success
– Following the money
– Noticing the language an institution uses
13
14. How the Hidden Curriculum
Is Taught
• Institutional policies
– Statements about how much federal grant
money the faculty is generating tell students
that attracting money to the institution is an
important value
• Evaluation activities
– The attributes and behaviors of those who are
promoted may be more influential than ethics
statements
14
15. How the Hidden Curriculum
Is Taught Continued
• Resource-allocation decisions
– Office space
– Which programs are funded
• Institutional language about money
15
16. Barriers to Disclosing
Unethical Behavior
• Personal motivations
– Loyalty to the profession
• Institutional motivations
– Fear of negative publicity associated with a
scandal
• Understandings about physician behavior
– Be confident and exercise independent
judgment
– Do not raise concerns with others
16
17. Whistleblowing
and Health Care Ethics
• Generally, about 6 out of 10 people who
observe workplace misconduct will report
it
• The percentage may be even lower in the
health care field
– Fewer than 5% of medical students in their
last weeks of training said they would report
unethical behavior
17
18. Funds Recovered Due to
Whistleblowing in 2015
8.5 Chart: Health care fraud
Of the $3.5 billion recovered, $1.9 billion
was related to health care fraud
Department of Justice, 2015
18
19. Retaliation for Whistleblowing
• About 15% of whistleblowers face
retaliation
• Can range from mild to severe, for
example:
– Snubbed by coworkers
– Verbal abuse by supervisor
– Denied promotion or raises
– Property damage
– Physical assault
19
20. Protection of Whistleblowers
Federal Law Example of When It Applies
False Claims Act A false claim for payment has
been made, such as Medicare
fraud
Occupational Safety and
Health Act
Practices that result in an
unsafe workplace
Clean Air Act Practices that contribute to air
pollution
Solid Waste Disposal Act Improper disposal of solid
waste
8.6 Table: Protection of whistleblowers (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0, 2012).
20
21. Ethics and Professionalism
Summary – Lecture b
• Health care professionals must meet both ethical
and legal standards
– Sometimes these standards are the same, but not
always
• The sources of legal standards for health care
professionals include state medical practices
laws and malpractice law
• The culture of health care includes expectations
that may make it difficult to disclose illegal or
unethical behavior or practices
21
22. Ethics and Professionalism
References – Lecture b
References
Aasland, O.G., & Forde, R. (2005). Impact of feeling responsible for adverse events on doctors’
personal and professional lives: The importance of being open to criticism from colleagues.
Quality and Safety in Health Care, 14(1), 13–17.
American Medical Association. (2012). The AMA Code of Medical Ethics' Opinions on Confidentiality of
Patient Information. Opinion E-5.05—Confidentiality. AMA Journal of Ethics. Retrieved from
http://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/2012/09/coet1-1209.html
American Medical Association. (2016). AMA’s code of medical ethics. Retrieved from http://www.ama-
assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/code-medical-ethics.page
American Medical Association. (2016). Frequently asked questions in ethics. Retrieved from
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/code-medical-
ethics/frequently-asked-questions.page
Benatar, D. (2006). Bioethics and health and human rights: a critical view. Journal of Medical Ethics,
32(1), 17–20. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2563274/
Bolsin, S., Faunce, T., & Oakley, J. (2005). Practical virtue ethics: Healthcare whistleblowing and
portable digital technology. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31(10), 612–618.
Brock, L. V., & Mastroianni, A. (2013). Clinical ethics and law. University of Washington School of
Medicine. Retrieved from https://depts.washington.edu/bioethx/topics/law.html
Center for Practical Bioethics. (n.d.). What is bioethics? Retrieved from
https://www.practicalbioethics.org/what-is-bioethics
22
23. Ethics and Professionalism
References – Lecture b Continued
The Economist. (2014, May 31). The $272 billion swindle. Why thieves love America’s health-care
system. Retrieved from http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21603078-why-thieves-
love-americas-health-care-system-272-billion-swindle
Ethics & Compliance Initiative. (n.d.). Ethics and compliance glossary. Retrieved from
https://www.ethics.org/resources/free-toolkit/toolkit-glossary
Farnan, J. M., Sulmasy, L. S., Worster, B. K., Chaudhry, H. J., Rhyne, J. A., & Arora, V. M. (2013).
Online medical professionalism: Patient and public relationships: Policy statement from the
American College of Physicians and the Federation of State Medical Boards. Annals of Internal
Medicine, 158(8), 620–627.
Federation of State Medical Boards. (2015). Essentials of a state medical and osteopathic practice act.
Retrieved from http://www.fsmb.org/Media/Default/PDF/FSMB/Advocacy/GRPOL_essentials.pdf
Gillon, R., & Higgs, R. (2015). What is it to do good medical ethics? A kaleidoscope of views. Journal
of Medical Ethics, 41(1), 1–4.
Grunwald H. W., Howard D. S., McCabe M. S., Storm C. D., & Rodriguez M. A. (2008) Misdiagnosis:
Disclosing a colleague’s error. Journal of Oncology Practice, 4(3), 158–160.
Hafferty FW. (1998) Beyond curriculum reform: confronting medicine's hidden curriculum. Academy of
Medicine, 73(4): 403–407
23
24. Ethics and Professionalism
References – Lecture b Continued 2
Hannawa, A. F. (2012). Principles of medical ethics: implications for the disclosure of medical
errors. Medicolegal and Bioethics, 2, 1–1. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/profile/
Annegret_Hannawa2/publication/232252062_Principles_of_medical_ethics_Implications_for_the_
disclosure_of_medical_errors
Kesselheim, A. S., Studdert, D. M., & Mello, M. M. (2010). Whistle-blowers’ experiences in fraud
litigation against pharmaceutical companies. New England Journal of Medicine, 362(19), 1832–
1839. Retrieved from http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmsr0912039
Klaas, P. B., Berge, K. H., Klaas, K. M., Klaas, J. P., & Larson, A. N. (2014). When patients are
harmed, but are not wronged: Ethics, law, and history. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 89(9), 1279–
1286.
Krause, J. H. (2013). Kickbacks, self-referrals, and false claims: The hazy boundaries of health-care
fraud. CHEST Journal, 144(3), 1045–1050. Retrieved from http://journal.publications.chestnet.org/
article.aspx?articleid=1732168
Lyons, C. (2012). Medical malpractice apology law: “Don’t tell me what happened, tell me that you’re
sorry.”. Health Law Outlook, 27. Retrieved from http://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent
.cgi?article=1006&context=health_law_outlook#page=27
Macklin, R. (2015). Can one do good medical ethics without principles? Journal of Medical Ethics, 41,
75–78. Retrieved from http://jme.bmj.com/content/41/1/75.full
Mannion, R., & Davies, H. T. (2015). Cultures of silence and cultures of voice: The role of
whistleblowing in healthcare organisations. International Journal of Health Policy and
Management, 4(8), 503. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4529038
24
25. Ethics and Professionalism
References – Lecture b Continued 3
Outterson, K. (2012). Punishing health care fraud—Is the GSK settlement sufficient?. New England
Journal of Medicine, 367(12), 1082–1085.
Pickler N. (2011, December 19). Justice reports record false claims recoveries. Yahoo Finance News.
Retrieved from http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Justice-reports-record-false-apf-
3660225829.html?x=0
Rhodes, R., & Strain, J. J. (2004). Whistleblowing in academic medicine. Journal of Medical Ethics,
30(1), 35–39.
U.S. Department of Justice (2015). Justice Department recovers over $3.5 Billion from False Claims
Act cases in fiscal year 2015. Retrieved from https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-
recovers-over-35-billion-false-claims-act-cases-fiscal-year-2015
Vincler, L. A. (2013). Ethics in medicine: Clinical ethics and law. University of Washington School of
Medicine. Retrieved from http://depts.washington.edu/bioethx/topics/law.html
Wallace, I. M. (2015). Is patient confidentiality compromised with the electronic health record?: A
position paper. Computers Informatics Nursing, 33(2), 58–62
Charts, Tables, Figures
8.4 Figure: Standards of professionalism (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0, 2012).
8.5 Chart: Health care fraud (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0, 2016).
8.6 Table: Protection of whistleblowers (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0, 2012).
25
26. The Culture of Health Care
Ethics and Professionalism
Lecture b
This material was developed by Oregon Health &
Science University, funded by the Department of
Health and Human Services, Office of the National
Coordinator for Health Information Technology
under Award Number IU24OC000015. This
material was updated in 2016 by Bellevue College
under Award Number 90WT0002.
26
Editor's Notes
No audio. Recording preparation.
Welcome to The Culture of Health Care: Ethics and Professionalism. This is Lecture b.
The component, The Culture of Health Care, addresses job expectations in health care settings. It discusses how care is organized within a practice setting, privacy laws, and professional and ethical issues encountered in the workplace.
The objectives for Ethics and Professionalism are to:
Discuss foundational concepts in medical ethics and professionalism
Examine the relationships among ethical ideals, professionalism, and legal duties
Apply the general principles of ethics and professionalism to specific topics
Examine ethical issues in health informatics
This lecture discusses ethical and legal standards and how they interact. People in the medical profession are required to meet both ethical standards and legal standards. Sometimes these standards are one and the same. For example, it would be both an ethical violation and a crime to perform disabling surgery on a healthy person. Sometimes, ethical standards and legal standards overlap or interact, and they are subject to interpretation by both legal authorities and professional oversight committees. In other cases, ethical and legal standards may conflict. For example, even though a physician has an ethical duty to maintain patient confidentiality, a court may order the release of a patient’s medical records for use in a lawsuit.
In recent decades, two new academic fields—bioethics and health and human rights—have begun addressing ethical issues in medicine. Bioethics is the study of the ethical and moral implications of medical advances, research, and practice at the intersection of the law and the human rights of the patient. Examples include genetic engineering and drug research. Health and human rights examines a vast array of ethical concerns around such issues as health care inequities, vulnerable populations, reproductive and sexual health, death and dying, and more.
The American Medical Association has made a very clear statement about the relationship between ethics and law. It says:
[quote] “Ethical values and legal principles are usually closely related, but ethical obligations typically exceed legal duties. In some cases, the law mandates unethical conduct. In general, when physicians believe a law is unjust, they should work to change the law. In exceptional circumstances of unjust laws, ethical responsibilities should supersede legal obligations. The fact that a physician charged with allegedly illegal conduct is acquitted or exonerated in civil or criminal proceedings does not necessarily mean that the physician acted ethically.” [end quote]
The relationship between professionalism and law is a two-way street. The law sets standards for professionalism, and standards set by a profession can provide a basis for legal responsibility. State medical practice laws are a primary source of legal standards of professionalism, but other state and federal laws also apply.
Courts sometimes decide that a health care professional did not meet the bottom-line standard for professionalism. In other words, health care professionals are sometimes found legally liable for actions that are not specifically prohibited by law.
A state medical practice law defines the physician’s practice of medicine and establishes a state medical board. In addition, the law specifies the method for testing medical school graduates who want to be admitted as a physician to the practice of medicine, and it sets requirements for physician licensing. The law also establishes procedures for enforcing professional standards, investigating complaints against physicians, and disciplining doctors where appropriate.
A group called the Federation of State Medical Boards has written a model state medical practice law. However, the states are not required to follow it, so the laws governing medical practice vary from state to state.
Similar laws in each state govern other health care professions, such as nursing, pharmacy, and dentistry. Many states also regulate allied professions such as physical therapy.
The next two slides look at physician medical practice laws; however, it’s important to remember that similar laws apply to dentists, nurses, and many other health care professionals in each state. The point is that in the culture of health care, the law plays a large role in the professional standards that must be met.
Although legislators decide the medical practice law in each state, the state medical board is in charge of the nuts-and-bolts governance of the medical profession for physicians. In some states, the board is an independent entity, whereas in other states it’s part of a larger organization, such as the state department of health.
A state medical board is usually made up of non-physician members of the community as well as physicians. However, the Federation of State Medical Boards recommends that physicians should be the majority and should have primary responsibility for overseeing the board’s licensing and education responsibilities.
The typical powers and responsibilities of a state medical board include the ability to write rules and regulations based on the state medical practice law. For example, the board evaluates medical schools. It gives examinations to graduates who want to enter medical practice, and it investigates complaints against physicians. It’s responsible for disciplining physicians it finds to be in violation of professional standards. In addition, the board deals with any individuals who are practicing medicine without a license.
Other health care professions may also have a state board, such as a state board of nursing or a state board of pharmacy. These operate in a manner similar to the medical board for physicians.
When a state medical board receives information suggesting that a physician has violated professional standards, it initiates an investigation. If sufficient evidence is found in the investigation, the board holds a hearing or some other procedure to determine whether a violation has occurred. This process must be conducted in a way that is fair and that protects the basic rights of the physician.
If a violation is found to have occurred, the board can impose a penalty. In a professional setting, a penalty is usually called a sanction. Although a sanction is a punishment in a practical sense, it’s not intended to punish the individual physician. Rather, the purpose of a sanction is to protect the public from substandard medical practices. The sanction might be a monetary fine. If the physician’s violation involved substandard skills, the board may order him or her to seek additional medical education. If the violation involved a medical condition, such as drug addiction, the board might order the physician to submit to medical treatment. For serious violations, the board might also suspend or revoke the physician’s medical license.
Setting professional standards through medical practice laws is one example of how ethics, professionalism, and law interact. The next two slides discuss another way in which these concepts interact: malpractice liability.
An investigation by a state medical board addresses the responsibility of the physician to the medical profession. A malpractice case is different in that it addresses the liability of a physician regarding the treatment of an individual patient. A physician might face both a board investigation and a malpractice lawsuit for the same act or situation.
There are four parts to proving a claim of medical malpractice. The first is that the health care provider had a duty to the patient who is bringing the case. This is an example of where malpractice law and ethics interact. When does a specific health care professional have a duty to a specific patient?
The second element of malpractice is that the minimum standards of care were not met in some way. Perhaps a surgeon performed an operation for which he or she was not properly trained, or a physician did not fully inform a patient about the risks of a treatment. This second element of malpractice is closely intertwined with standards of professionalism.
The last two elements of a successful malpractice case are that the failure to meet the standard of care caused some kind of injury, and the injury resulted in damages, such as emotional distress or lost time from work. Lack of professionalism is not malpractice if it does not result in some injury and if the injury does not result in harm to the patient.
Malpractice law applies not only to doctors but also to other health care providers. Nurses, pharmacists, physical therapists, who can be sued successfully if the elements of a malpractice case are met.
Another way in which law, ethics, and professionalism intersect is in the self-regulation of the health care profession. On one hand, the health care profession holds itself to lofty ethical goals. On the other hand, the severity of the potential consequences can make it difficult for the profession to police itself.
Most health care professionals behave ethically, but sometimes, unethical acts or practices occur. General attributes of the culture of health care can make it difficult for people to report unethical behavior to their bosses or to outside authorities.
Children are often told, “Do as I say, not as I do.” But the lessons learned by example are very powerful. So far, this unit has outlined a strong set of ethical values that are formally taught in medical schools. However, many experts say that when it comes to prevailing ethical values, medical education contains a “hidden curriculum.” According to the widely discussed ideas of sociology professor Frederic Hafferty [haf-fur-tee], medical students acquire their ethical standards in a variety of ways, some of which make up the hidden curriculum.
The next slides explain how institutional policies, standards for evaluation, resource-allocation decisions, and institutional language can influence what medical students learn about ethics.
Students learn about values from the policies of the institution. For example, if a medical school’s brochures feature statements about how much grant money its faculty members generate, this tells students that attracting money to the institution is an important internal value. How faculty are selected for promotion and what type of student is selected as chief resident also makes a statement about the values the organization embraces. The attributes and behaviors of those who are promoted may be more powerful indicators of institutional values than ethics policies or ethics classes.
When students observe an institution’s environment, they form ideas about what is most valued by the institution and the profession based on things like the size of faculty offices and department facilities. In addition, the language that is used day to day sends a powerful message. Professor Hafferty observed that when the language of investment professionals becomes commonly used by medical professionals, that sends a message about the relative importance of the business aspects of practicing medicine.
Two other experts examined several well-known cases in which institutions refused to acknowledge ethical lapses by doctors or researchers, even after extensive investigations. The problems were exposed only when the facts of these cases were investigated by outside authorities. The conclusion from the study was that learned institutional values in medicine can create a culture in which it’s difficult to report the ethical gaps of others.
The study identified three general types of barriers to disclosing unethical behavior: personal motivations, institutional motivations, and shared understandings of how physicians behave.
All of this leads to another area in which law, ethics, and professionalism intertwine: whistleblowing. The term whistleblower refers to someone who reports illegal or unethical behavior to his or her superiors at work or to outside authorities. A wide range of activities have been described as health care whistleblowing, from telling a patient about an error to disclosing violations of professional conduct that are occurring throughout an entire institution.
Generally, about six out of ten people who observe workplace misconduct report it to their superiors or to outside authorities. The figure may be even lower in the health care professions. In one study, only about five of one hundred medical students who were in the last weeks of their training said they would report unethical behavior.
Under a federal law called the False Claims Act, citizens who have evidence of fraud against federal government contracts and programs can sue, on behalf of the government, in order to recover the stolen funds. In compensation for their risk and effort, the whistleblowers may be rewarded with a portion of the funds recovered, typically between fifteen and twenty-five percent.
In fiscal year 2015, the federal government recovered $3.5 billion dollars from False Claims Act cases. Of the $3.5 billion dollars recovered, $1.9 billion dollars was related to health care fraud. Prominent examples of health care fraud are falsified claims for Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement.
About fifteen percent of employees who report workplace misconduct face negative consequences. According to research conducted by the Ethics Resource Center, sixty percent of whistleblowers who reported retaliation said they were given a cold shoulder by their coworkers. Furthermore, sixty-two percent experienced verbal abuse by a superior. In addition, forty-three percent said that as a consequence of their whistleblowing, they did not receive promotions or raises. At the most extreme end, four percent of whistleblowers reported physical harm to themselves or their property.
Many federal laws protect whistleblowers from retaliation, depending on the circumstances. For example, whistleblowers who disclose information about unsafe workplaces may be protected from job discrimination by the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act.
Unfortunately, it can be difficult to prove that a negative act, such as an employer’s failure to promote a whistleblower, is really retaliation for the whistleblowing.
This concludes Lecture b of Ethics and Professionalism. In summary, health care professionals must meet both ethical standards and legal standards. Sometimes these are the same, but not always. Ethical standards may overlap or intersect with legal standards, and the two types of standards may even conflict. Just because something is legal does not mean it’s necessarily ethical.
One source of legal standards for physicians is each state’s medical practices law. It defines the practice of medicine within the state, establishes a state medical board, administers testing and licensing of physicians, and specifies procedures for investigation, enforcement, and discipline. The state medical board writes rules and regulations to carry out the law. There are similar state boards for other professionals—nursing, pharmacy, and dentistry, to name a few.
A source of legal standards for all health care professionals is each state’s malpractice laws. In order to bring a successful malpractice suit, the patient must prove that the health care provider had a duty to the patient, that minimum standards of care were not met, that the failure to meet the standards caused an injury, and that the injury resulted in damages.
Certain values in the culture of health care, such as the belief in doctors’ independence, make it difficult to disclose illegal or unethical behavior. The hidden curriculum in medical schools may teach students more about ethics than formal ethics training does. In 2011, a large amount of health care fraud was reported under the federal False Claims Act, showing that unethical behavior is more common in the health care professions than people might like to think.