PagesJaunes, a French leader in local advertising and information, launched a project to monitor and analyze its online reputation and influence. It developed a 3-part strategy for reputation (e-Reputation), influence (e-Influence), and learning (e-Learning). It chose Spotter to monitor sources in French for brand, corporate, product, and CSR topics. Spotter provided a customized solution and ongoing support to help PagesJaunes understand online discourse and engage audiences.
[FR] L’innovation pour piloter son eReputation et gérer les leviers d’influen...Akio
Support de présentation du pitch lors des chemins de l’innovation au VillagebyCA avec l’Observatoire COM MEDIA, du 8 avril 2015.
Du temps réel pour anticiper et gérer les risques, à l’analyse de tendances pour obtenir des insights utiles à la prise de décision.
[En] Air France client case: e-reputation projectAkio
Focus on the real-life case study E-reputation for Air France, a company that is innovative in their use of social media, following conversations in order to better understand their clients who express themselves spontaneously on blogs, forums, advice websites, Twitter, Facebook etc.
http://spotter.com/
[En] How State of the Art Media Monitoring and Analysis Work As Part of Commu...Akio
European communication Summit - Spotter Conference - How State of the Art Media Monitoring and Analysis Work As Part of Communications and Reputation Management Strategy? - Brussels, 4 & 5 July 2012.
http://spotter.com/
[FR] Témoignage client La Poste Mobile : Conjuguer volumétrie et excellence d...Akio
Témoignage client La Poste Mobile
2 millions d’appels, 200 000 courriers et mails par an... Comment l'opérateur mobile conjugue volumétrie et excellence d'un service client cross-canal ?
- Miser sur le rebond cross-canal pour offrir une meilleure expérience client.
- Optimiser la qualité de service, la proactivité et l’efficacité des conseillers
- Améliorer le pilotage des 6 sites service client basés en France et à l’étranger
[FR] L’innovation pour piloter son eReputation et gérer les leviers d’influen...Akio
Support de présentation du pitch lors des chemins de l’innovation au VillagebyCA avec l’Observatoire COM MEDIA, du 8 avril 2015.
Du temps réel pour anticiper et gérer les risques, à l’analyse de tendances pour obtenir des insights utiles à la prise de décision.
[En] Air France client case: e-reputation projectAkio
Focus on the real-life case study E-reputation for Air France, a company that is innovative in their use of social media, following conversations in order to better understand their clients who express themselves spontaneously on blogs, forums, advice websites, Twitter, Facebook etc.
http://spotter.com/
[En] How State of the Art Media Monitoring and Analysis Work As Part of Commu...Akio
European communication Summit - Spotter Conference - How State of the Art Media Monitoring and Analysis Work As Part of Communications and Reputation Management Strategy? - Brussels, 4 & 5 July 2012.
http://spotter.com/
[FR] Témoignage client La Poste Mobile : Conjuguer volumétrie et excellence d...Akio
Témoignage client La Poste Mobile
2 millions d’appels, 200 000 courriers et mails par an... Comment l'opérateur mobile conjugue volumétrie et excellence d'un service client cross-canal ?
- Miser sur le rebond cross-canal pour offrir une meilleure expérience client.
- Optimiser la qualité de service, la proactivité et l’efficacité des conseillers
- Améliorer le pilotage des 6 sites service client basés en France et à l’étranger
Comprehensive information on our vision and mission, products and services that we deal with and some of the projects that we have undertaken for our clients.
Romexsoft is a High-load Java Application Development company founded in 2004. During the last 12 years we've developed and successfully delivered more than 100 projects to our clients in Fintech, HealthCare and Broadcast Media industries.
We are obsessed about innovations and their implementation into our processes, so we could provide effective and market competitive solutions to industry leaders and startups with creative ideas.
Xerox Transforms Channel Partners’ Social Presence with socialondemand® from ...rgrogersPCA
These are the slides from the recent purechannelapps webinar with Olivier Choron, CEO and Founder of purechannelapps, Andy Hill, Social Media Manager, Channel Partner Operations, Xerox and Tony Gibiino from Zerographic as they explore social media amplification and syndication technologies, and how purechannelapps revolutionised Xerox's approach to channel partner social media marketing.
#DigitalBosses par Spotter - Etude 1er trimestre 2017Akio
Connaissez-vous #DigitalBosses, le Baromètre des dirigeants français ?
Nous avons mis en place une plateforme Spotter Pulse dédiée au suivi de la visibilité des patrons du SBF120, en partenariat avec Boursorama. L'offre #DigitalBosses permet aux dirigeants et communiquants d'avoir accès à une solution simple et en temps réel pour suivre les prises de paroles, ou les mentions, sur les réseaux sociaux et les médias en ligne.
Découvrez l'infographie du premier trimestre 2017, réalisée avec les données de la plateforme #DigitalBosses !
More Related Content
Similar to [En] PagesJaunes client case: Social and Online Media - What strategy to use for monitoring and analysis?
Comprehensive information on our vision and mission, products and services that we deal with and some of the projects that we have undertaken for our clients.
Romexsoft is a High-load Java Application Development company founded in 2004. During the last 12 years we've developed and successfully delivered more than 100 projects to our clients in Fintech, HealthCare and Broadcast Media industries.
We are obsessed about innovations and their implementation into our processes, so we could provide effective and market competitive solutions to industry leaders and startups with creative ideas.
Xerox Transforms Channel Partners’ Social Presence with socialondemand® from ...rgrogersPCA
These are the slides from the recent purechannelapps webinar with Olivier Choron, CEO and Founder of purechannelapps, Andy Hill, Social Media Manager, Channel Partner Operations, Xerox and Tony Gibiino from Zerographic as they explore social media amplification and syndication technologies, and how purechannelapps revolutionised Xerox's approach to channel partner social media marketing.
#DigitalBosses par Spotter - Etude 1er trimestre 2017Akio
Connaissez-vous #DigitalBosses, le Baromètre des dirigeants français ?
Nous avons mis en place une plateforme Spotter Pulse dédiée au suivi de la visibilité des patrons du SBF120, en partenariat avec Boursorama. L'offre #DigitalBosses permet aux dirigeants et communiquants d'avoir accès à une solution simple et en temps réel pour suivre les prises de paroles, ou les mentions, sur les réseaux sociaux et les médias en ligne.
Découvrez l'infographie du premier trimestre 2017, réalisée avec les données de la plateforme #DigitalBosses !
[FR] Support de conférence "Cross-Canal" - Salon Banque & Innovation - 1er O...Akio
Appels, emails, tchats, réseaux sociaux : Comment assurer une communication cohérente et sans couture quels que soient vos canaux d'interaction client ?
[FR] Support de présentation Social Media Intelligence de la conférence « La ...Akio
Social Media Intelligence : Faites rayonner votre marque !
Transformer le Bigdata en Smartdata : retour d’expérience.
L’utilisation par les marques des outils de veille et d’analyse des réseaux sociaux pour mieux engager avec leurs publics, comprendre leurs besoins, et anticiper les risques.
Baromètre #DigitalBosses novembre 2014, TBWA Corporate – SpotterAkio
Top 5 de novembre en bref :
Laurence Parisot, dont les tweets trouvent écho auprès de plusieurs personnalités politiques, conserve sa 1ème place et améliore sa performance de +0,27M Echo Reach* par rapport à octobre.
Pascal Nègre bénéficie de la réactivité et de la popularité sur Twitter des artistes du label MMC, affilié à Universal Music France
Mathieu Galet progresse de 10 places grâce à ses tweets sur l'inauguration de la Maison de la Radio dont Radio France et ses journalistes se sont fait l'écho.
Dominique Delport, avec une timeline orientée "content curation", s'attire les retweets de nombreux acteurs de la communication et des médias.
Denis Olivennes, en une poignée de tweets bien choisis, rallie plusieurs des comptes media et journalistes du groupe de Lagardère Active.
* Indice de classement #DigitalBosses, conçu par Spotter pour mesurer la portée d’un compte Twitter sur une période donnée (audience gagnée grâce aux RT des tweets publiés par la personnalité). L’indice traduit la réactivité et la notoriété des communautés qui retweetent le dirigeant.
[Fr] Cas client Air France : Projet E-ReputationAkio
Focus sur le projet E-Reputation d’Air France, une société pionnière en matière de gestion des médias sociaux, qui suit les conversations afin de comprendre ses clients qui s’expriment spontanément dans les blogs, les forums, les sites d’avis, sur Twitter, Facebook, etc.
http://spotter.com/
Tata Group Dials Taiwan for Its Chipmaking Ambition in Gujarat’s DholeraAvirahi City Dholera
The Tata Group, a titan of Indian industry, is making waves with its advanced talks with Taiwanese chipmakers Powerchip Semiconductor Manufacturing Corporation (PSMC) and UMC Group. The goal? Establishing a cutting-edge semiconductor fabrication unit (fab) in Dholera, Gujarat. This isn’t just any project; it’s a potential game changer for India’s chipmaking aspirations and a boon for investors seeking promising residential projects in dholera sir.
Visit : https://www.avirahi.com/blog/tata-group-dials-taiwan-for-its-chipmaking-ambition-in-gujarats-dholera/
At Techbox Square, in Singapore, we're not just creative web designers and developers, we're the driving force behind your brand identity. Contact us today.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.Any kyc Account
Learn how to use Binance Savings to expand your bitcoin holdings. Discover how to maximize your earnings on one of the most reliable cryptocurrency exchange platforms, as well as how to earn interest on your cryptocurrency holdings and the various savings choices available.
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media MasterclassLuanWise
In this masterclass, presented at the Global HR Summit on 5th June 2024, Luan Wise explored the essential features of social media platforms that support talent acquisition, including LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, X (formerly Twitter) and TikTok.
Personal Brand Statement:
As an Army veteran dedicated to lifelong learning, I bring a disciplined, strategic mindset to my pursuits. I am constantly expanding my knowledge to innovate and lead effectively. My journey is driven by a commitment to excellence, and to make a meaningful impact in the world.
buy old yahoo accounts buy yahoo accountsSusan Laney
As a business owner, I understand the importance of having a strong online presence and leveraging various digital platforms to reach and engage with your target audience. One often overlooked yet highly valuable asset in this regard is the humble Yahoo account. While many may perceive Yahoo as a relic of the past, the truth is that these accounts still hold immense potential for businesses of all sizes.
B2B payments are rapidly changing. Find out the 5 key questions you need to be asking yourself to be sure you are mastering B2B payments today. Learn more at www.BlueSnap.com.
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024Lital Barkan
Have you ever heard that user-generated content or video testimonials can take your brand to the next level? We will explore how you can effectively use video testimonials to leverage and boost your sales, content strategy, and increase your CRM data.🤯
We will dig deeper into:
1. How to capture video testimonials that convert from your audience 🎥
2. How to leverage your testimonials to boost your sales 💲
3. How you can capture more CRM data to understand your audience better through video testimonials. 📊
Event Report - SAP Sapphire 2024 Orlando - lots of innovation and old challengesHolger Mueller
Holger Mueller of Constellation Research shares his key takeaways from SAP's Sapphire confernece, held in Orlando, June 3rd till 5th 2024, in the Orange Convention Center.
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.AnnySerafinaLove
This letter, written by Kellen Harkins, Course Director at Full Sail University, commends Anny Love's exemplary performance in the Video Sharing Platforms class. It highlights her dedication, willingness to challenge herself, and exceptional skills in production, editing, and marketing across various video platforms like YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram.
Discover the innovative and creative projects that highlight my journey throu...dylandmeas
Discover the innovative and creative projects that highlight my journey through Full Sail University. Below, you’ll find a collection of my work showcasing my skills and expertise in digital marketing, event planning, and media production.
Discover the innovative and creative projects that highlight my journey throu...
[En] PagesJaunes client case: Social and Online Media - What strategy to use for monitoring and analysis?
1. Social and Online Media: What strategy to
use for monitoring and analysis?
Pages Jaunes’ e-Reputation monitoring
platform for the Web & Social Media
GIVING YOU THE POWER TO UNDERSTAND
SPOTTER 2012. Tous droits réservés.
2. PRESENTATION OF PAGESJAUNES
PagesJaunes is the French leader in local advertising and information
on the internet, via mobile and in print.
PagesJaunes is also one of the leaders in France for small online
advertisements (with the sites AnnoncesJaunes and A Vendre A
Louer) and is the biggest website creator for professionals.
PagesJaunes belongs to the group ‘PagesJaunes Groupe’, the
European leader in local advertising and information on the
internet, via mobile and in print, reaching a 1.1bn Euro turnover in
2011. The group is made up of 12 companies with a total of 5,000
employees in France, Spain, Luxembourg and Austria, 2,200 of
whom are local and digital communication advisers who
accompany the group’s 712,000 local and national advertising
clients.
As a creator of useful media, PagesJaunes Groupe is present in
3 complementary activities: content and services editing, local
media, and advertising management and advice.
2
3. PAGESJAUNES IN FIGURES
PagesJaunes means:
• 16 million individual visitors and 85 million visits every month to the website
pagesjaunes.fr
• Over 12 million mobile application downloads and 20 million visits via mobile
phones every month
• Over 660 000 advertisers
• Over 100 000 sites created and managed for professionals in France
• Almost 9 out of 10 people in France who use at least one PagesJaunes support
3
4. CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVES OF THE PROJECT
In order to professionalise its digital communication and develop a relational
and conversational strategy for its different audiences (influencers, opinion
leaders, users and advertisers), PagesJaunes decided to launch a programme to
manage its e-reputation.
To do this, it developed a project split into 3 sections:
• e-Reputation
• e-Influence
• e-Learning
PagesJaunes chose Spotter for the monitoring of its e-reputation. The objective
being to monitor and follow the evolution of how the brand and its services are
perceived, most notably through an analysis of media discourse, opinion leaders
and influencers online, as well as identifying consumers’ and professionals’
conversations concerning 4 major themes:
Brands, Corporate issues, Products and services, CSR
4
5. PagesJaunes’ Project
• Context of the project
• Scope of the monitoring
• Team organisation
6. All-round and Adaptable SOLUTION
PagesJaunes places the ‘cursor’ where it likes and Spotter guarantees training and support
throughout the project.
You manage your project You produce and You benefit from deliverables
from A to Z with our support distribute your deliverables produced by Spotter
SPOTTER guides you during the SPOTTER ensures the fine-tuning of
setup phase of the project, develops the SPOTTER produces the deliverables,
automatic data qualification, the improvement of puts the results into perspective, and presents
source connectors and ensures on-going
queries and treatments, and assigns you a our recommendations to your team and/or
support via its online interface.
dedicated Project Manager. your management.
For the PagesJaunes project, the ‘We work together’
mode is used
6
7. PAGESJAUNES – SET UP
2011 – 2012 – Continuous monitoring for
Pilot 3 months – 12 months 2013
Sept to Dec January to December
Reputation Day – June 2011
Setting up of the monitoring platform for the e-Reputation of PagesJaunes’
brand on online media, social media, blogs and forums with a scope of
France / French Language.
First contact
Training & Transfer of skills for the digital team at
PagesJaunes and its communications agency for the
exploitation of online data and creating deliverables
(summaries & reports)
7
8. PAGESJAUNES - The project’s scope
PagesJaunes’ objectives:
To pick up on and analyse media, opinion leaders and
influencers’ discourse;
To identify consumers and professionals’ conversations on 4
main topics: Brands, Corporate issues, Products & Services,
CSR.
Panel of sources:
A panel of sources in French only and published in France is
monitored:
Online Media + ‘Pure Players’ sites
Social Media (excluding Twitter) + A specific panel for Twitter
Blogs (excluding IT) / Forums
CSR Sites & Blogs: all sources based on the environment, green technology, recycling
etc.
Financial Sites: shares, prices on the stock market,…
IT Sites & Blogs: all sites based on technology, mobile telephones, etc...
Trade Union Sites: trade union blogs and sites e.g. syndicat-fo-pagesjaunes.fr
Alternative Sites: sites dedicated to alternative political parties (alterglobalisation, etc...).
Institutions’ Sites: institutions’ sites, local authorities, CNIL (the board that enforces law on
data protection), etc...
8
9. Organisation of the project’s team
The team and exchanges with the client
The in-house team’s tasks:
Quality control of the
The setting up of a dedicated monitoring team at documents harvested and
their relevance
Spotter.
Validation of the information
2 people (1 analyst + 1 Project Manager) brought up by the system
Quality control of the
Daily validation and quality control of data + qualification of the
automatic qualification of
Tone & Importance that is automatically attributed by the
documents
platform.
Training & a Transfer of skills
to PagesJaunes digital
Technical support, advice and guidance for the PagesJaunes
team and its digital communications agency. communications agency +
the permanent availability of
the platform
Support and training of the
PagesJaunes team +
permanent access to the
platform
11. Software modules used for the PagesJaunes project
The Spotter Platform combines modules and decision making tools that can
be activated according to the needs of each user’s profile.
This module includes tools to This module includes tools to This module includes Back-office
visualise, personalise and explore, organise, qualify and tools for a complete and
manage interactive analyse project data. Also autonomous project
dashboards, which can be allowing the user to generate, management: sourcing,queries,
shared by a group of users or export and publish graphs and users, treatment and
individuals in the case of a newsletters online. qualification of data etc. …
specific user.
Access for Spotter’s
Permanent access for PagesJaunes + its Agency
back-office only
11
12. Spotter’s Analysis Workshop
Main Functions Used
• Immediate visualisation of the number of results for a
certain day and archives in the monitoring plan
• Results structured by theme, sub-theme, type of media,
and/or groups of sources
• Qualification of results by tone, risk level, or any other
qualitative variable defined for the project
• Advanced search engine combining full-text, metadata
and text-mining methods of research
• Monitoring the impact of social media in real time for
all results published on the internet
• Word Clouds of the words most used to speak about
entities, in specific mentions and in the content of relevant
discourse
• Graphs generated with an export function so they can be
published in Newsletters and Reports
• Creation, visualisation and diffusion of Newsletters,
Alerts and Press Reviews
• Adding/Modifying summaries, post-its, translations and
refining the qualification of results
• A dedicated analyst space for each user to manage
their corpus study, queries and graphs.
12
13. SPOTTERANALYTICS – Breakdown of the Monitoring Plan
Database organised by
themes and sub-themes
Organisation of results
by type of source
Search engine
Monitoring of the main
brand PagesJaunes +
a look at 13 other of the
group’s main brands
(Mappy, Urban Dive,
AnnoncesJaunes,
Keltravo, 123People,
Horyzon Média, A
Vendre A Louer,..)
13
14. SPOTTERANALYTICS – Exploring the data
Graphic visualisation of queries and
dynamic modifications of the
presentation
Lists of results from the monitoring plan
and clouds of the tags used
14
15. SPOTTERANALYTICS – Advanced research & access to documents
Direct access to the original
documents and access to the
metadata when in ‘editing’ mode
Advanced research functions with all
metadata
15
16. The Dashboard is accessible on iPad
and all other tablet PCs
Three types of Widgets:
• Graphs: volume, themes, tone, …
• Written content: summaries and/or a selection of results
• Scores: compound indicators that are specific to the
project
This allows:
• An in-depth multi level analysis thanks to interlinking
dashboards
• Specific settings with dashboards that can be
customised according to users’ needs,
• Direct access to articles, posts, comments, tweets etc.
with dynamic, interactive widgets.
Library of Spotter Widgets
Visibility and voice share Global tone Influence score
Type of sources Top sources and tone Satisfaction score
Themes and sub themes Top authors and tone Reputation score
Top entities per theme Top themes and tone Risk score
Entities with Risks Twitter presence …
16
17. SPOTTERDASHBOARD – Visualisation of the main indicators (1/3)
10 key indicators for
a global vision
A curve showing the
volume registered over
15 days – excluding
Twitter as a source
Origin of the documents
over 7 days
‘MustRead’ references
with direct access to the
original documents,
classed by type of
source, tone and
importance
17
18. SPOTTERDASHBOARD – Visualisation of the main indicators (2/3)
10 key indicators for
a global vision
Tone of coverage over a
period of 7 day
(excluding Twitter)
Tone of the main
themes present over a
period of 7 days
(excluding Twitter)
Tone of coverage over a
period of 7 days (Twitter
only)
Tone of the main
themes present over a
period of 7 days
(Twitter only)
18
19. SPOTTERDASHBOARD – Visualisation of the main indicators (3/3)
10 key indicators for
a global vision
Volume curve over a
period of 15 days –
Twitter only
Top Topics over a period
of 7 days, Twitter &
Webnews
The Top actors on social
media only, over a
period of 7 days.
19
20. Main functions
• Managing the sources panel: There is a tool that allows the project’s universe of sources to be identified.
The user accesses SPOTTER’s catalogue of sources and chooses a selection of them for the project.
• Managing the monitoring plan: Another tool allows settings to be made, identifying the themes to follow
for the project. The user describes each theme through Boolean queries that can use key words, ontology
methods, and data from text-mining (lemmatisation, statements, metadata…).
• Adding documents: A workflow is identified for the mass integration of internal documents (in all formats,
text or image). This workflow includes a module of automatic text extraction (OCR: Optical Character
Back-office Recognition).
module for the • Managing the harvest from Web Panel and Open web: There is a tool for configuring research settings
overall according to each type of source and ‘connector’ (Facebook, Twitter, Google News, Google Blog, Linkedin,
YouTube,…).
management of
• Managing potentially interesting documents: A tool that detects documents that could potentially be of
the PagesJaunes interest for the project but that may not have been identified within the universe to be monitored for the
project by Spotter project (discovery module).
analysts • Qualifying documents: A workflow is identified for validating the information harvested.
The user has a professional sector interface that allows them to prioritise the documents that need to be
validated and qualified according to their importance for the project (it is possible to breakdown the volume
of the documents gathered into several corpuses using specific queries)
This stage means the relevance of the documents gathered by the system can be assessed and in certain
cases, it is possible to re-qualify a document if necessary (by importance, tone, themes, pre-qualified
documents etc.).
• Managing the SPOTTERDASHBOARD and SPOTTERANALYTICS modules: modules that allow the management
of the platform for consulting validated documents.
• Supervising the system: A module that presents statistics on the system in real time (The harvesting -
Validation status – Status of the server’s load …)
• Updates of the different client modules: This module allows the different modules of the project to be
updated, and thus, makes the data validated by the analyst visible to all users.
20
22. A few concrete results
“To start with, the project’s aim was to evaluate PagesJaunes’ e-
reputation in order to refine our plans and communication action and to
make them more effective, to create interaction concerning the brand
and to engage in conversation with online communities.
As the year passed, the monitoring we put in place allowed us to obtain
feedback concerning other issues (customer relations, HR, legal
matters, technical matters…). And so, we have enlarged the field of
action for the Spotter tool, making a centre for listening and analysis
for other management sectors in the company.”
Daniel LEMIN
Head of Digital Relations at PagesJaunes
22
23. A few concrete results
For a year now, PagesJaunes’ monitoring platform has allowed the company to find
concrete and efficient solutions based on the following:
Protecting the PagesJaunes brand
In the context of usurpation and parasitism of the brand for example
Help with crisis management
Strengthening customer relations (users and advertisers)
Identifying conversations (comments, questions, criticisms, appreciation…) about the
brand on talk pages (blogs, forums, social networks…) in order to respond where
necessary
Identifying influential actors for the brand
Developping projects that cover several areas
Customer management, business process, HR…
23
24. CONTACT
For more information, E contact@spotter.com
Contact us! T + 33(0)4 67 68 61 70
24
25. APPENDIX: SPOTTER – About us
Through being 100% dedicated to developing
solutions for the monitoring and analysis of
media and social media for some of the largest
companies and organisations, we have created a
benchmark in Europe in this sector. We have:
Over 14 years of expertise in the monitoring and
analysis of media discourse and conversations
on the Internet.
Multilingual & multicultural profiles
Analysts | Engineers | Researchers
Over 30 languages
A production branch in Portugal
50% of our turnover created internationally
30% of revenue invested in R&D every year
A unique positioning on the market for
Technology | Analysis | Content
Strong and controlled organic growth
25
26. SPOTTER – 14 years of evolution in innovative technology
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
26
27. COMBINING Technology and Expertise
SPOTTER offers a qualitative approach at each step of the project to garauntee the best use of its
tools and a continious adaptation of the monitoring plan and/or delivrables.
Precise sourcing Intelligent qualification
Detailed panel of Structured and relevant
sources that can evolve data
COMBINING TECHNOLOGY
AND EXPERTISE
Decision making Advanced analysis
reporting Key figures, specific
Platform, delivrables and indicators and scores
recommendations
27