1. What should we include in A2?
Ask: What do our readers want to know?
What is your proposed idea?
• Introduce problem and purpose (Lesson 8:
Introduction)
What do you hope to achieve?
• State your goal and objectives (Lesson 8: Goal
and Objectives)
Is your proposed idea needed?
• Justify problems, needs and limitations of
existing solutions - with reference to authentic,
relevant and credible sources (Lesson 9:
Justification/Current Situation)
Will your proposed idea make a difference?
• Highlight impact (Lesson 10: Impact)
Is your proposed idea feasible?
• Explain features, functions and feasibility –
materials, resources and technology involved
(Lesson 10: Features, Functions and Technical
Description)
• Highlight credibility and experience of the
project team (Lesson 6: Project Team)
• List schedule and budget (Excel template)
How should we format A2?
The ELC Fund does not require applicants to
follow a fixed structure/format. Teams are
required to decide on the best structure and
approach for your idea.
• Organise everything listed in “What Should
We Include in A1?” clearly and logically
• Include an effective overview and conclusion
(Lesson 12: Overview & Conclusion)
• Include other additional sections as needed
• Select a professional format
ELC Fund
A scheme for funding projects in the computing
field which make people’s daily living more
convenient, comfortable and safer, or address
the needs of specific target groups.
With a maximum seed funding of HK$150,000
over a one-year development plan, ELC Fund
aims to turn ideas with a positive social impact
into reality.
In Assessment 2 (A2), you will collaborate in
groups of 3 or 4 and produce a group project
proposal.
Are there samples?
• GuideBuddy (APA and IEEE)
What is peer review?
The Peer Review Activity is an opportunity for
you to:
• receive feedback on your proposal
• learn through giving constructive and
actionable feedback to your peers
• review and finalise your proposal
During Week 7 class, as individuals, you will
complete the peer review activity according to
your teacher’s instructions. You will
• share draft proposal
• go through a Peer Review Sample activity
• review 1 draft proposal from a peer group
• refer to a checklist and give at least FIVE
action points focusing on how your peers
can improve
By giving 5 action points (constructive and
actionable feedback), you will receive 5%.
What is the word limit of A2?
• Groups of 3: 2100-2300
• Groups of 4: 2600-2800
• Schedule and Budget: Use excel template
How will our proposal be graded?
The ELC Fund Assessment Panel will review:
1. Significance of the project goals and social impact
2. Justification of problems, need and opportunities
3. Uniqueness of project idea in comparison with
existing solutions
4. Feasibility of project idea
5. Authenticity and credibility of project team
6. Effectiveness of overall structure
7. Professionalism of overall presentation
Assessment Rubric (group grade except for Peer Review)
Analysis (30%) Strength of arguments and ideas; analysis
and coverage of current situation; Quality and relevance
of evidence
Clarity (20%) Clarity of purpose; logical structure and
sequencing, integration and connection of ideas
Appropriacy (20%) Appropriateness of content; style and
formality of written language; accuracy and integration
of citations
Persuasiveness (25%) Use of persuasive strategies;
credibility of project team; quality of design and layout
Peer Review (5%)
ELC3524
Assessment 2 (A2)
Overview
from Subject Information Sheet and Assessment
Guide
