SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Do Now Moral Dilemmas<br />Suppose we have to choose between building a new sports stadium and building a new hospital. Should we build the stadium if there are many more sports fans than sick people? What about the sick people? Aren’t we sacrificing their interests?<br />Suppose we have $1 million of government money. We can use it either to build a new school for one thousand children, or to buy one million ice cream cones for one million children. Should we buy the ice cream cones, if that would produce the greatest balance of pleasure? Are all pleasures created equal? <br />Suppose you have to move to Boston or to Las Vegas. If you move to Boston, you’ll fall in love and get married. If you move to Vegas, you’ll get rich but stay single. Should you move to Vegas, if being rich gives you more pleasure? <br />John Stuart Mill, a utilitarian, says that we should protect individual rights because, in the long run, that is the best way to increase the sum of happiness. Is that true? <br />

More Related Content

More from Robin Montgomery

Hinduism ppt 1 for slideshare
Hinduism ppt 1 for slideshareHinduism ppt 1 for slideshare
Hinduism ppt 1 for slideshareRobin Montgomery
 
World religion presentation 2
World religion presentation 2World religion presentation 2
World religion presentation 2Robin Montgomery
 
World view day 1 - semester 2
World view   day 1 - semester 2World view   day 1 - semester 2
World view day 1 - semester 2Robin Montgomery
 
Pechakutcha what is philosophy for unit 1
Pechakutcha   what is philosophy for unit 1Pechakutcha   what is philosophy for unit 1
Pechakutcha what is philosophy for unit 1Robin Montgomery
 
Pechakutcha world religion
Pechakutcha   world religionPechakutcha   world religion
Pechakutcha world religionRobin Montgomery
 
Do now life_is_beautiful(2)
Do now life_is_beautiful(2)Do now life_is_beautiful(2)
Do now life_is_beautiful(2)Robin Montgomery
 
Do now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evilDo now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evilRobin Montgomery
 
Do now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evilDo now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evilRobin Montgomery
 
Do now to prepare for oprah
Do now to prepare for oprahDo now to prepare for oprah
Do now to prepare for oprahRobin Montgomery
 
Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3
Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3
Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3Robin Montgomery
 
The problem of the past and the problem of other minds
The problem of the past and the problem of other mindsThe problem of the past and the problem of other minds
The problem of the past and the problem of other mindsRobin Montgomery
 
Do nows for week of aug 16
Do nows for week of aug 16Do nows for week of aug 16
Do nows for week of aug 16Robin Montgomery
 

More from Robin Montgomery (20)

Branches of judaism
Branches of judaism Branches of judaism
Branches of judaism
 
Judaism review
Judaism reviewJudaism review
Judaism review
 
Judaism
Judaism Judaism
Judaism
 
Hinduism ppt 1 for slideshare
Hinduism ppt 1 for slideshareHinduism ppt 1 for slideshare
Hinduism ppt 1 for slideshare
 
World religion presentation 2
World religion presentation 2World religion presentation 2
World religion presentation 2
 
World view day 1 - semester 2
World view   day 1 - semester 2World view   day 1 - semester 2
World view day 1 - semester 2
 
Day 1 world religion
Day 1 world religionDay 1 world religion
Day 1 world religion
 
Pechakutcha what is philosophy for unit 1
Pechakutcha   what is philosophy for unit 1Pechakutcha   what is philosophy for unit 1
Pechakutcha what is philosophy for unit 1
 
Pechakutcha world religion
Pechakutcha   world religionPechakutcha   world religion
Pechakutcha world religion
 
Do now life_is_beautiful(2)
Do now life_is_beautiful(2)Do now life_is_beautiful(2)
Do now life_is_beautiful(2)
 
Do now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evilDo now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evil
 
Do now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evilDo now 11.29 problem of evil
Do now 11.29 problem of evil
 
Sequence of philosophy
Sequence of philosophySequence of philosophy
Sequence of philosophy
 
Do now to prepare for oprah
Do now to prepare for oprahDo now to prepare for oprah
Do now to prepare for oprah
 
Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3
Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3
Unit 3 ch 7 outline part 3
 
Morris ch 8 reading guide
Morris ch 8 reading guideMorris ch 8 reading guide
Morris ch 8 reading guide
 
Morris ch 7 reading guide
Morris ch 7 reading guideMorris ch 7 reading guide
Morris ch 7 reading guide
 
Unit 3 do nows #1
Unit 3 do nows #1Unit 3 do nows #1
Unit 3 do nows #1
 
The problem of the past and the problem of other minds
The problem of the past and the problem of other mindsThe problem of the past and the problem of other minds
The problem of the past and the problem of other minds
 
Do nows for week of aug 16
Do nows for week of aug 16Do nows for week of aug 16
Do nows for week of aug 16
 

Do now for wednesday 9.15 moral dilemma

  • 1. Do Now Moral Dilemmas<br />Suppose we have to choose between building a new sports stadium and building a new hospital. Should we build the stadium if there are many more sports fans than sick people? What about the sick people? Aren’t we sacrificing their interests?<br />Suppose we have $1 million of government money. We can use it either to build a new school for one thousand children, or to buy one million ice cream cones for one million children. Should we buy the ice cream cones, if that would produce the greatest balance of pleasure? Are all pleasures created equal? <br />Suppose you have to move to Boston or to Las Vegas. If you move to Boston, you’ll fall in love and get married. If you move to Vegas, you’ll get rich but stay single. Should you move to Vegas, if being rich gives you more pleasure? <br />John Stuart Mill, a utilitarian, says that we should protect individual rights because, in the long run, that is the best way to increase the sum of happiness. Is that true? <br />