SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 35
Student:JonathanShelton
Course:BA (Hons) PopularMusicology
Roll Number:@00259206
Document:
Dissertation –‘A Basterdto Analyse:Anexplorationintothe
relationshipbetweenmusicandfilminQuentinTarantino’s
‘IngloriousBasterds’ (12,000words)
SubmissionDate:May8th
, 2013
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford1
A BASTERD TO ANALYSE:
AN EXPLORATION INTO THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN MUSIC AND FILM IN QUENTIN TARANTINO’S
INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
Since the turn of the twentiethcentury,the worldof filmhasbecome one of the mostpopular,accessible and
commerciallyvaluable assetsof the cultural industries.Likepopularmusic,cinemahasdevelopedandtransformed
greatlyintoa vehicle transportedcommoditisedproduce forglobal audience toenjoyandcherish.Aswithanyformof
endeavour,those whopioneertheirspecificfieldbecome celebratedfortheircontributions.Take the audio-visualbody
of workby Americandirector/producer/screenwriter/actorQuentinTarantino.Tarantino’sbackcatalogue hasmet
enthusiasticcritical acclaimsince hisfirstofficial release of ReservoirDogs in1992 – an unconventional,intense
depictionof contemporaryAmericangangsterlife.Subsequentprojectsstabilizedhisreputation,astwoyearson Pulp
Fiction amassedglobal recognitionandanarray of prestigiousawards,andsince thenhistacklingof Blaxploitation
(JackieBrown) andchanbara cinema(Kill Bill Vol.I & II) eclipse one anotherasTarantino’smostprevalentwork.One can
identifyeclecticismwithinTarantino’srepertoire.Whilstexcellingcommercially,Tarantinohasconstructedfilmsthat
challenge the conventional practice of cinema.Hisuse andglorificationof violence hasbecome iconicandisa theme
referencedcontinuallyregardlessof genre.Hisnon-linearapproachtostructure,interweavingof storylinesandthinly-
textureddialogue are consideredasignature uponhisworks.Hiscastingcollaborationsinmostcaseshave beenfruitful
(regularlyworkingwithSamuel L.Jackson,UmaThurman,Tim Rothand Michael Madsenamongstsuccessful others),
and theyhave inno waybecome stockcharacter and prevailedintheirapproachestochallengingroles.
A keyexample of unconventional practice inTarantino’sworksisthe use of musicinhisfilms.Specifically,his use of pre-
existingpopularmusicforhisfilmscores. Aninterview in2003 withthe BBC displaysTarantino’smusical approach:
“I’ve always thought my soundtracks do pretty good, because they’re basically professional equivalents of a mix tape I’d make for you at home. To
me, movies and music go hand in hand. When I’m writing a script, one of the first things I do is find the music I’m going to play for the opening
sequence. I can’t go forward until I figure out how I’m going to start – what the opening mood music is going to be1”.
In ReservoirDogs,our firstmusical encounterisThe George BakerSelection’s“LittleGreenBag”and itsvisual pairingto
the Dogsis constructedastheywalkaway froma dinerintime to the rhythmof the track. In Pulp Fiction, upon
1 http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2003/10/06/quentin_tarantino_kill_bill_volume1_interview.shtml
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford2
revealingthe unlawfulprofessionsof HoneyBunnyandPumpkin(burglars) visually,Tarantinoaidstheircause by
throwingusintothe highoctane surferrockanthem “Misirlou”byDick Dale and his Deltones. InKill Bill Vol.I, the first
track is NancySinatra’s“Bang Bang”, whichassistsin teachingthe audience of the bride (UmaThurman) andshaping
the beginningof hernarrative.It’snotjustan introductorytool forTarantino:lookingthroughhissoundtracks,one will
findT-Rex (Deathproof),BuddyHolly(Pulp Fiction),DavidBowie (InglouriousBasterds),Stealer’sWheel (ReservoirDogs),
BobbyWomack (JackieBrown) anda host of otherexamplesof popularmusic.
There are scholarlywritingsonthe musicof Tarantinofilms,butasWojcikand Knightconveyin“SoundtrackAvailable:
Essayson PopularMusic andFilm”,they’re notinabundance:
“No doubt many readers will be disappointed at not finding specific readings of specific films and soundtracks here: films by Martin Scorsese,
Quentin Tarantino and Spike Lee are only the most obvious examples. Apparently new forms of popular film music … still await analysis2 ”.
ConsiderTarantino’s2009 World War II thrillerInglouriousBasterds.Itisthe tale of an unconventional Jewish-American
secretarmy regiment,whoare droppeddeepbehindenemylinesinNazi-occupiedFrance,withaview toendthe war
and slaughterasmanyNazi’salongthe way as possible.Intandemtothis,the Jewish –FrenchDreyfusfamilyare hiding
beneathFrenchdairyFarmerPerrierLaPadite’sfloorboards;SSColonel HansLandaextractsthisknowledge fromthe
farmeron a routine Nazi visit,beforeinstructinghismentoshootthroughthe floorboardsatthe family.Shoshanna
Dreyfus,the daughterof the family,isthe onlysurvivor,andshe fleesintothe fieldsurroundingthe landandisallowed
to live byLanda.As the narrative progresses,we findherinParis,underanew name (Emmanuelle Mimieux) andthe
proprietorof a modestcinema,whichshe runswithherpartnerMarcel.The climax of the filmisreachedat Shoshanna’s
cinema,asPropagandaMinisterJosef Goebbelsholdsthe premieretohisnew film‘A Nation’sPride’there.The film
stars FrenchNazi-turned-filmstarFrederickZoller,whoduring hisservice killedthree hundredAmericansoldiersfroma
bell towerinItalyanddefeatedthe invasionalmostsingle-handedly.Allthe highestrankingofficersof the Nazisare in
attendance atthe premiere;the Basterdsundertake OperationKino,amilitaryoperationintendedtokill all Nazis
presentandthusendthe war.ParallelingthisisShoshanna’sownplansof vengeance,asshe intendstoburnall of her
nitrate filmatthe premiere,killingall inattendance. AsstandardTarantinopractice,these twostoriesweave intoone
2 Knight & Wojcik. 2001. Soundtrack Available: Essays on Film and Popular Music. DurhamandLondon:Duke UniversityPress.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford3
another,inthe form of five chapters:‘Once Upona Time … InNazi-occupiedFrance’,‘InglouriousBasterds’,‘German
NightinParis’,‘OperationKino’and‘Revengeof the GiantFace’.
Thisdissertationwill studycertainsongsfromthe soundtrackof InglouriousBasterds.There are several reasonsforthis
choice. Initially, whenthisstudybegan,thiswasthe mostrecentTarantinofilmtodate3
. Fromhere,several important
discoverieswere made;primarily,the filmdiffersfrompreviousTarantinofilmsinthe representationof characters’
personal interactionwithmusic.The source of The George BakerSelection’s“Little GreenBag”in ReservoirDogs isthe
fictional radioshow K-Billy’sSuperSoundsof theSeventies whichthe characterslistentoanddiscussinthe opening
scene.Twocharacters in Pulp Fiction visita fictional diner‘JackRabbitSlims’ whichpayshomage tokeyfiguresfrom
popularmusicand culture fromdifferentera,suchasBuddyHolly,ElvisPresley,HankWilliams,toname a few;in Kill Bill
Vol.II we learnthat the bride’shusband-to-beowns recordstore whichthe pairplanto workin together.The listgoes
on; Tarantino’scharactersusuallylike Tarantino’smusic,butthe cultural inclinationsof the charactersof Inglourious
Basterds all directto a love of cinema.Notonlya love of cinema,butbarelyanyevidence of musical taste orintereston
the character’s behalves.The onlyinstancesinwhichwe see musicinthe worldof the film, or diegetic,are inchapter
three (German Nightin Paris):GestapoofficerDieterHellstrom escortsShoshannathroughaNazi restaurantto meet
GoebbelsandZollerandwe hearapplause afterRizOrtolani’s‘The Saloon’plays(althoughwe see nosuchperformer),
and chapterfour(Operation Kino):the same Gestapoofficerliftsthe needle onarecordplayer,inorderto impose on
the dispute betweenthree Basterdswhoare posingasNazisand a Nazi Staff Sargeant.Inchapter three’sreference,
theyare meetingtodiscussthe possibilityof holdingtheirpremiereatShoshanna’scinema;chapterfour’sdiegetic
example,the staff sergeantandhisregimenthave beengiventhe nightoff tocelebrate the birthof hischild.The
Basterdsare there meetingtheirdoubleagent,Germanfilm actressBridgetVonHammersmark;one of the Basterdsis
EnglishmanLt.Archie Hiccox,whoprimarilyisassignedthe role forhisabilitytospeakfluentGerman,butalsoas before
the war, he was a German filmcritic,havinghadwritingspublishedonthe subject.
Anotherkeyreasonforthe choice isthe film’ssettingandera.For once ina Tarantinofilm, we are detailedfromthe
beginninginsubtitlesof the yearandcountry we are in;if thischanges,thenwe are toldinsimilarcircumstances.These
usuallyappearinbetweenchapters,butthe backdropof WorldWar IImeansthe audience foronce don’treallyneedto
know.Thisismost realisticbackdroptoa Tarantinofilminhistory,andthispurelybecause WorldWarII tookplace.We
3 Havingnowbeen succeededby2012 Spaghetti WesternDjango Unchained.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford4
are neverinformedin ReservoirDogs/Pulp Fiction/Jackie Brown etc.of locationortime period.For InglouriousBasterds,
we can safelyassume the audience will know the contextto the film.Whilstthe protagonistsare fictional,Tarantino’s
depictionsof HitlerandGoebbelsare strikinglysimilartothe authenticimagesthe audience will know of them.
Finally,choosingInglouriousBasterds overanyotherTarantinofilmisrational because of the filmssoundtrack.Despite
the overtlyreferencedenthusiasmforcinemaoncharacters’behalves,the filmstill hasnearlythirtymusical
accompanimentsthroughoutthe fivechapters.Study Figure1.1 inthisdissertation’sappendicesfordetailedevidence
of chapterlengthandmusical chapterlengthinthe film.There are several differentsongs,fromseveral different
genres,fromseveral differenterasandcountriesinthe soundtrack.RangingfrompopularGermansongsfromthe war
era to coversof Ray Charlesto DavidBowie,one cannotargue the vast array of music’sincluded. Furthermore,all of
these songsoriginallywere usedinotherfilms –westerns,Germanpropagandafilms,Americanhistorical epicsand
erotichorror films,Blaxploitationfilmsetc.Interestingly,none of the musicappearsinEnzoCastellari’s1978 Italianwar
filmTheIngloriousBastards,whichshareslittle commonalitywithTarantino’sfilmotherthanthe name and WorldWar
II context.
METHODOLOGY
The limitationsof thisstudycompromisehowmanysongsfromthe filmcanbe analysedeffectively.Therefore,
parametersneedtobe installedinordertoexpose the music’sfunctionalityandcapacitytofacilitate thatfunctionali ty.
Thisdissertationwill centre onthe ideologyof dualitiespresentwithinthe film’smusic;thismeanssongsthatappear
twice inthe film,orif an artist’stracksallude toa particularcharacter or chapter/scene,orif the musicitself refers to
anothermusical bodyof work.The decisiontoconstructsuch parametersbecame evidentafterreadingDavidDeacon’s
essay Why Counting Counts inResearch MethodsforCulturalStudies.Itencouragesthe use of quantitativeanalysisin
cultural studiesandsuggests“reluctanceto engagewith systematiccounting createsanalyticalvaguenessand even
internal contradictionsand logicalinconsistencies”.Deaconcontinuestodictate thatcontinuedoppositionagainstthis
notioncan have “restrictive implications4
”.The solidarityofferedinquantitative databalancesthe subsequentmassof
theoretical investigationsandconclusions:itaccountsforthe chosentext’sinclusionsandseversandpre -existingties
4 Pickering, M. 2008. Research Methods for Cultural Studies. Edinburgh:EdinburghUniversityPressLtd.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford5
the conductor mayhave harbouredpre-examination.Inastudythat’snumericallylimitedinitliterarycontent,itseems
viable toapproachthe music’s inquestionwithasimilarmethodology.
Figure 1.2 profilesthe three songsthatappeartwice in InglouriousBasterds;all three will be includedinthe studyas we
progress. Thismakesforsix differentanalyses,aseachsongappearsin differentplacesalongthe narrative structure.
Eventhoughthese choicesare basednumerically,the lengthof theseexertsandtheirlocationsinvarying chapters
provide awiderspectrumthatoriginallyseemedpossiblethroughusingthree songs.
Anotherreasontoinclude TheBig Gundown Rare Earth’s‘What’dI Say’ inparticularisthat Rare Earth aren’tthe original
composers;the track isa RayCharlescover,althoughthe fragmentutilisedin InglouriousBasterds doesn’tconnotethis
as it’sa rhythmicpercussive loopandnothingelse.Whilstthistrackisthe onlycover throughoutthe soundtrack,itis
not the onlyone to sample anotherartist’smaterial;the firsttrackof the film, EnnioMorricone’s‘The Verdict (DopoLa
Condanna)’referstoaninstantlyrecognisable pianophrase fromBeethoven’sclassic‘FurElise’.Furtheringonfromthis,
it originallyappearedinaWesternfilm –SergioSollima’s1966. It isone of eightMorricone songsinthe soundtrack;
providingsolidquantitative groundupontobuildatheoretical study. Consequently,twofurtherMorricone songswillbe
sampled;the choicesof whichare difficulttodefine.However,the three songsthatappeartwice and‘The Verdict’don’t
place enoughfocusonShoshanna,consideringhercentral role tothe film.Uponfurtherinspection,Morricone supports
herentrance and exittothe film,whichoccurin oppositional circumstancesandmusicallyare almostthe antithesisof
one another.The two textsinquestionare ‘L’incontro Con La Figlia’(The Meeting of the Daughter) and‘Un Amico’(A
Friend).The appropriate academicframeworkswhichall these songsare tobe measuredagainstare detailedineach
section.
JAMESON’S POSTMODERNISMS AND TARANTINO’S MUSIC
The aural textsmustbe interrogatedefficiently,inordertofullyexpose theirpurpose andcapacitytofacilitate that
purpose.Onlyappropriate modesof enquirymustbe deployed;akeyone isthe conceptof postmodernism.Tarantino
has beencelebrated asa postmodernpractitionerbeforeinhiscareer;academically,intextssuchas“The Cambridge
CompaniontoPostmodernism5
”and“PostmodernMusic/PostmodernThought6
”,andsocio-culturally,with Pulp Fiction
5 Connor, S. 3004. The Cambridge Companion to Postmodernism. Cambridge: Cambridge UniversityPress.
6
Auner &Lochhead. 2002. Postmodern Music Postmodern Thought. London/New York: Routledge.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford6
beingclassedassuchwebsitessuchas‘Wikipedia7
’.Reliabilityof the lattersource isquestionable,butsuchanotion
doesexist–of hisfilmsandtheirmusic.Thisisbecause Tarantino’snon-linearnarrativesare confusedfurtherby
contrastingmusical accompaniments,suchasthe ‘ear-chopping’sceneinReservoirDogs,whichisaurallysupportedby
‘Stuckin the Middle withYou’byStealer’sWheel,orin Pulp Fiction where Mia overdosesonherointoUrge Overkill’s
‘Girl,You’ll be a WomanSoon’amongstotherexamples.
Postmodernismisachallengingconcepttograspand apply,sointroductorytextssuchasBarry Smart’s“Postmodernity:
KeyIdeas8
”and Bestand Kellner’s“PostmodernTheory:Critical Interrogations9
”are ideal preliminaryreadings.They
presentthe differencesof modernismtopostmodernismandthe periodwherepostmodernismcame tofruition,and
leadonto shape the thoughtsof relevantwritersonthe subject.Take FredricJameson;Jameson’swritingson
postmodernisminline withpopularculture are integral tothe discourse. “Postmodernism:The Cultural Logicof Late
Capitalism10
”and“PostmodernismandConsumerSociety11
”are dialecticworksfrom livingmemoryandare considered
amongstthe most importantwritingssince the publicationsof The FrankfurtSchool. Inthe latter,Jamesondeclares:
“Radical breaks between periods do not generally involve complete changes of content, but rather the restructuration of a certain number of
elements alreadygiven: features that in an earlier period or system were subordinate now become dominant and features that had been dominant
again become secondary”.
Jameson,withregardtofilm,continuestodeclare thatrealistcontentseldomappears.
“If there is any realism left here, it is a "realism" which springs from the shock of grasping that confinement and of realizi ng that, for whatever
peculiar reasons, we seem condemned to seek the historical past through our own pop images and stereotypes about that past, which itself
remains forever out of reach”.
Theoretically,Jamesonargueshispersonallyconceptualised“nostalgiafilm”,whichAnne Friedburgsummarisesinher
text“WindowShopping:Cinemaandthe Postmodern12
”:
7 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postmodernist_film
8
Smart, B. 1993. Postmodernity: Key Ideas. London:Routledge.
9
Best & Kellner. 1991. Postmodern Theory: Critical Interrogations. London:MacmillanEducationLtd.
10 Jameson, F. 1991. Postmodernism:The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism. Durham:Duke UniversityPress.
11 Jameson, F. 1998. The Cultural Turn: Selected Writings on the Postmodern 1983 – 1998. London/NewYork:Verso.
12
Friedburg, A. 1993. Window Shopping: Cinema and the Postmodern. Berkeley/Los Angeles/London:Universityof California Press.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford7
“Although Jameson doesn’t perform an exact taxonomy, his descriptions divide the ‘nostalgia film’ into:
1) Films that are about the past and set in the past (‘Chinatown’, ‘American Graffiti’)
2) Films that ‘reinvent’ the past (‘Star Wars’, ‘Raiders of the Lost Ark’)
3) Films that are set in the present but invoke the past (‘Body Heat’; we could add ‘Miami Vice’, ‘Moonlighting’, ‘Batman’)”
The firstand secondof the three couldbothcategoricallydefine InglouriousBasterds;the secondinparticularmirrors
the film’sremouldingof the endof the warand constructionsof those whoendit.Jameson’spostmodernismsasa
whole have alsobeenclassified - these canbe foundinhiswritingsorinother postmodernisttexts,suchas“Crisis
Cinema:The ApocalypticIdeainPostmodernNarrative Film”:
“(Jameson’s postmodernisms) as the following: [1] Postmodernism is misunderstood. [2] Its tenuous unity is evident only in its opposition to high
modernism. [3] It designates an erosion of distinctions between high and low art. [4] It effaces genre conventions. [5] It is ahistorical. [6] It
models on the multitude of intersections between art and the cultural conditions of late capitalism. [7] In its seeming randomness, it simulates
an undifferentiated (schizophrenic) world vision13”.
It isagainstthese measurementsthatthe textsinquestionwill be analysedinordertodeterminetheirpostmodernist
potency.Reappropriating‘postmodernism’withinthesearticlestostandfor‘aural text’will subsequentlyreveal the
identityof the songsusedinthe film.
THE VERDICT (DOPO LA CONDANNA) – ENNIO MORRICONE
It isplausible topropose thatthere are active mechanismsof postmodernismatthe beginningof the film;Lisa
Coulthardin“QuentinTarantino’s‘InglouriousBasterds’:A Manipulationof Metacinema”qualifies:
“(this) temporal distension and affective intensification are particularly prominent in the opening sequence, which is in many ways the most
‘Western’ chapter in the film … “The Verdict” from ‘The Big Gundown’ slowly rises in the mix to dominate the sequence until the music fades into
the car engine motor as it reaches the farmhouse. Time is expansive; the car seems to approach as slowly as a man on horseback – that iconic
image seen in the distance at the beginning of innumerable Westerns14.”
We are onlya minute intothe filmbeforeCoulthard’sobservationsunfold;apostmodernistlandscapeisshapedforthe
musical’sarrival.‘The Verdict’appearsforsixtysevenseconds,andreferencesthe introductoryphrase of Beethoven’s
‘Fur Elise’.The vignette bookendsthe piece,withtwoidentical examplesinbetween. Unlikethe original,inwhichthe
13Sharrett, Christopher. 1993. Crisis Cinema:The Apocalyptic Idea in Postmodern Narrative Film. WashingtonDC:Maisonneuve Press
14 Dassanowsky, R. V. 2012. Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds:A Manipulation of Metacinema. New York/London:Continuum International
Publishing Group.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford8
melodyparallelsthe metronomicrhythm,Morricone’salterationsdenote slightaccelerationanddecelerationof the
motif whichismarginallyextended.The adjustmentstotempocause momentsof bathosthatresolve calmly, butthisis
mostevidentwhenthe visual backdropisremoved –otherwise the musicagitatesthe alreadyperturbedfamily.The
pianocomponentisrecognisabletoall;BarryCooper’sbiographyof Beethoventellsusthat“the melodyand
accompanimentof ‘FurElise’evoke anappropriate moodforintense longing15
”.Originallythe longingwasfeltby
Beethoventowardsafemale,butthe longingisreshapedbythe filmtoaimforpeace. ThisgravitatesCoulthard’snotion
of time expansionand confirmsthatthe song’ssupportisaimedatthe protagonists,the LaPadite farmers.The family
and the musiccrystallise the globallysharedlongingharbouredbyNazi oppressorsforpeace duringthe war.
Theoreticallywe canchallenge Tarantino’suse of the trackas a postmodernismof Jameson’s,onthe basisof itsprimary
functionasfilmmusic(aWesterntrack).Morricone too can be assessedasa postmodernistcollaboratorbyrealigning
an esteemedmusical landmarkintofilmmusic.
There are otherforms of instrumentation.Three of the fourpianorunsare followedbystylisticallySpanishacoustic
guitarmovements;the guitarthensucceededbymilitary-styledpercussionrollsinterwovenwithanequallysovereign
hornedsection.The immediate guitaralso hasirregularmomentsmelodically –itbeginsandveryquicklypauses,before
flourishingitssolopartfor the remainderof the section. The gapsthisprovidesare filledbyevocative camerashots
fromvaryinganglesof the farmer,hisdaughterand the approachingNazis,whichare tailoredtoheightenourremorse
for the protagonists.We neverapproachthe house withthe Nazis;we onlyobservetheirapproachfromthe farm,
whichlocatesourmusical experience inthe foregroundof the LaPadite’semotions.The majorityof close shotsfocuson
the father,conveyingthathe will be the characterto engage withthe Nazi’sregardlessof the reasonfortheirvisit.
The third fragmentof instrumentationemitscombatantconnotations,andreinforcesthe militaristiccontrol overthe
scene.The percussive elementssitsecondarydynamically tothe melismatichornswhichfinisheachfragmentwitha
sustainedresolvingnote.Theycontrastthe fluidityof the precedingguitarandpianomovementsthroughthe prolonged
trumpets,andare stabilisedbyshortrepeatedrollsonasnare drum.This is the onlysectiontobe bracedwith
percussion,andparamusical referencestothe rhythmof these sectionsare made visually;the fathercementshisaxe
intoa tree stumpone beatafterthe snare roll,embodyingthe pugnaciousovertoneof the scene.During anotherof
these phrases,the fatherdemandshisdaughters goinside,andisseenfromalow angle withthe cameralookingup,
15 Cooper, B. 2000. Beethoven. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford9
alludingtothe nobilitythe sectionemotivelyprovides.The piece endswithanotherpianoexert,where the farmerwalks
towards hishouse calmly,withthe tree stumpandlodgedaxe inthe foreground.Thisvisuallysolidifiesthe harsh
unchangeable eventstocome,andaurallydisplaysthe fatherwhohasnow peacefullysuccumbedtothe likelynegative
outcome of the Nazi’svisit.
Firstly,we canexamine Tarantino’suse of suchmusicandidentifyanyparallelswithJameson’spostmodernisms.We
can alsoindividuallyqueryMorricone’scompositional values.Conclusivelythere are supportiveattributesforboth
enquiries;onTarantino’s part,the stylisticdifferencesof eachsectioninthe musicare mirroredon screenemotionally,
but inbetweenshotsof the Nazi’sapproach(correctlyacclaimedtoalludetoWesternfilmpracticesbyCoulthard).The
typicalityof Westernfilm’sintroductorysequenceshoweverdoesnotmatchthatof the genericworldwartwofilm;the
oppositionalforcesthatwouldmeetinaWesternfilmare dramatizedandsharpfocusisplacedon the forcesrather
than the contact. The accompanyingmusic,however,uniteswiththe visual Westernconnotationsdue toitspre-existing
connectiontothe Westerngenre.
An erosionof distinctionsbetween‘high’and‘low’artcan be foundinthe differentgenre andstylesthatall three
musical segmentscome from,andforsimilarreasoningwe cancollate the trackto achievingahistoricityandeffacing
genre conventions.The lattercanalsobe heldagainstTarantinoandMorricone,the formerforusinga Westerntrack
and the latterfor usingBeethoveninaWesterntrack.We couldsuggestthose differencesentwinedwiththe song’s
original filmicpurpose alsorepresentaschizophrenicvision,andthatTarantinovisuallyconnotesthisbyimitatingthe
stylesof Westernfilms.
SLAUGHTER – BILLY PRESTON
‘Slaughter’assertsitsauthorityimmediatelythroughthe instantthudof the distortedelectricguitarriff and
instantaneouslyshapesourunderstandingof BasterdHugoStiglitz.Whenwe firstmeethim, we receivethe storyof his
joiningthe Basterds.Asitbegins,the cameracatches himsmirkinginthe centre of the shotbefore anunexpectedflash
on the screenof hisname in comical font.It masksthe foregroundandwe are leftwithStiglitz’headabove the
lettering.Inamomentarysilence inbetweenthe riff playingagain,the view changestoa Germannewspaperfrontpage
whichfillsthe screen;alarge picture of Stiglitzsitsonthe leftunderneaththe mastheadandsubhead,andtothe right
tworows of six much smallerheadshots.AsSamuel L.Jacksonnarrates,Stiglitz’infamyamongstNazi’sisbecause asa
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford10
Germanenlistedman,he killedthirteenGestapoofficers.The picture thenfillsoutbyfocussingonthe largerpicture of
Stiglitzbefore we seegoreydetailedaccountsof some of hisvictims(typical of Tarantino’sultra-violenttendency).For
thispart, the track movespastthe electricguitarintroductoryriffingintoitscontrastingfunk-drivenverse andchorus.
Thisdescriptionof Stiglitz’lifepre-Basterdsiswithinascene alreadyactingasa memory – as Nazi Private Butzinforms
Hitlerof the Basterd’sambushon hisregiment.‘Slaughter’playsforthirtysevenseconds,duringwhichwe don’tsee
Stiglitzinthe presenttense of the scene,otherthanhisheadabove the font.
The text’spurpose andsurroundingschange whenwe come acrossitagainin ‘OperationKino’.Itstill profilesStiglitz,
but hisdifferent,negative emotionsare nowendorsedbythe music.Initiallyhisaudacioussmile almostcreatedhumour
inconjunctionwiththe music,buthere,visuallywe receive Stiglitzstaringangrily (OperationKinohasbeendisruptedby
the presence of Gestapooffice DieterHellstrom,whichangersStiglitz).There are nodistractionsbetweenStiglitz’
emotive bodylanguage andthe roughtone of the musicthistime,unlike theirpreviousdivide of the large comical font.
The audioand the visualsshare a strongerbondand theybothdenote angerandensure vengeance isthe catalystfor
howthe scene unfolds.The musicbecomesthe mainaural focusasthe dialogue fromthe Gestapoofficerfadesout,and
we then enteranothermemory.Stiglitz,tiedtoapost,topless,and beingwhippedrepetitivelywithvisible steamrising
fromthe freshwounds,inagony.Underneaththe crackof the whipandthe guitar riff,there’sapoundingdouble hitof
a bass drumwhichcouldrepresenthisheartrate inboth the scenesthe musichasservedinthischapter.The whipping
inthe montage isfairlyregular,andthisrhythmicqualityisextendedwhenwe returntothe tavernandthe Gestapo
officerpatsStiglitzonthe torsoto get his attention.
Primarily,‘Slaughter’profilesStiglitz;inbothinstancesthe visual mirrorthe audio(‘Slaughter’andStiglitzinharmony)
and therefore onthe secondoccasionthe audience associate the songasa motif forthe character.Furthermore,he is
the onlyBasterdwe are givenaninsighttothe historyof,whichmostwouldfindstandarddue tohisconflicting
appearancesinthe Germanand Americanarmy.But Stiglitzisnotthe leaderof the Basterds.He isn’ta founding
member;theywenttohim and enquiredforhisservices.Beforethen,Stiglitzviolentlyopposedthe Nazi regimeof his
ownaccord, whilstcompromisingadifficultmilitaryposition.Notonlywashe initiallyaNazi and thena Basterd,he then
pretendstobe a Nazi in chapterfour (OperationKino).He diesinaNazi uniform, actingasa Nazi,withan Austrianwho
neverwasenlistedbythe Germans,andanEnglishman(the firstwe’veseensofar) masqueradingasa Nazi withan
unconvincingaccent.Stiglitz’lastlineinthe filmis“saygoodbye toyourNazi balls”aftera cue fromHiccox,and thenhe
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford11
deliversthe firstof manyblowsaimedat DieterHellstrom.InStiglitz’firstmusical cue,he wasthe killerwho
‘slaughtered’everyonehe possiblycould.The seconddemonstratedStiglitz startsthe ‘slaughtering’butdoesnot
survive.
WHAT’D I SAY – RARE EARTH
With‘What’dI Say’,we are showncontrastingemotionsagainbutfromthe same momentintime;the contrastsare
embodiedbythe Basterds andShoshannaandMarcel,and theirdifferentapproachestoundertakingtheirplans.The
firsttime we hearthe exert,we’ve justseenDonny(The BearJew) getuptoleave the auditorium;whenthe music
beginsthe cameraisopposite the double doorstothe cinema. He walksright,pastthe camera, andwe thenliftupand
meethimat the top of the rightstaircase.We watch Donnywalkthroughdoor frame,andour nextangle isfromhis
perspective,peeringaroundawall viewingthe guardsoutside Hitler’sprivatebalcony.We swivel one hundredand
eighty degreesandsee Donny’sface forasplitsecond,before spinningbacktosee Hitlercome outfrom hisbalcony.
We returnto Donny’sface,whichpresentsdisbelief andexcitement.He disappears;musicstops.
Secondslater, Donny retrieves Omarfromthe auditorium(whocomicallyfallsoveranddrawsmuch Nazi attention,
whilstfeigninganItalianaccent).The musicstartsagain at the openingof the doors.We are setmuchfurtherback and
followthemfromalowangle as theyquicklyascendthe staircase. Ourassociationsof DonnyandOmarwiththistrack
are thenconfused,asournextshotis of Shoshannafromthe projectionroom, lookingoutintothe cinema.Marcel
arrivesbehindher,tellsherthattime isupon them;she turns,and instantlygetsemotional.Theyembrace,andkiss,for
several secondswhilstShoshanna’snervesincrease.Marcel then leaves,andShoshannais cryingandgasping.Donny
and Shoshanna’sactionscontrast;Donnyiseager forthe actionto beginandhurriestoget Omar; Shoshannalatches
ontoMarcel and theirmomentof passionisextended.Afterthiswe see Marcel comingoutontothe top of the lobby,
comingdownthe opposite staircase thatDonnyandOmar wentup.Holdingtwopoles,we see himopenone of the
doorsto the cinema,where (onscreen)Zolleriscarvinga swastikaintothe floor,whichismetbycheering;the music
stops.
The music inthese twoscenesisidentical.The sectioninquestionisthe song’sending –it couldbe heard underneath
otherinstrumentationatearlierpartsof the track but here itis isolated.The strophicsectionsmirrorthe passagesin
‘Slaughter’;bothtracksappeartwice withthe same andadditional charactersandtime isvisuallydistorted. Further
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford12
contrastscan be foundvisually;The Basterdsmasquerade cinemaindustryworkers,whereasatthe startof chapterfive
we see Shoshannaapplyingmake upwithtribal undertonesthroughout.Atsome points,the combatantbecomethe
hostsand vice versa,all to the same timelessrhythmicloopfroma Rare Earth’scover,not Ray Charles’original.Broadly
speaking,ShoshannaalsohasparallelstoStiglitz –we receive ahistoryof bothand the catalystsfortheirnow
destructive behaviour;theybothattimesappease Nazi superiority,andtheybothdie atthe handsof those they’re up
against.Shoshanna’sdeathoccursinstrangercircumstances,asher final kissiswithMarcel (whomthe narrative deems
as her partner) practicallyonthe same spotas her restingplace,nexttoNazi filmstarFredrikZoller.Shoshannashoots
Zoller, the starof A Nation’sPridedue to hismarksmanship;before Stiglitzkills DieterHellstrom,he saysfromclose
range,he’sthe real ‘FredrikZoller’,eventhoughthe real FredrikZollerisshotinhis deathscene fromclose range.
Furthermore,whenwe follow DonnyandOmaringreatdetail upthe stairs,we must remembertheyare onlythere due
to the deathof Stiglitz,Hiccox and WilhelmWicki;Stiglitzwasmeanttobe there. Thisisimportantbecause sofar we’ve
seentime visuallydistortedbyStiglitz’themesong‘Slaughter’andby‘What’dI Say’,yetif OperationKinohadn’tfailed
inthe tavern,itwouldbe Stiglitzwhopreparedtokill the Nazi’salongto‘What’dI Say’.
Linkingall these unearthedvisual relationshipsisthe style of the musicthatsupportsthem.Bothhave sectionslooped
on bothoccasions,andin all fourinstancesthisalludestothe distortionof time visually.
Consideringthe time lapseof the twosongs,itcouldbe arguedthat the tracks efface genericconventionsof filmmusic
practise:Inan essaystudyingmotificmusicanditsvisual counterpart,ClaudiaGorbmanobservesthe Gyorgi Ligetipiano
musicinStanleyKubrick’s‘EyesWide Shut’:
“ … A suspense cue with its insistence on the semitone and on the spectral creepiness of octaves played deep in the bass … in all five scenes scored
with the Ligeti, Bill’s complacency is strongly shaken, and in one way or another he is unmasked or gripped with shame16.”
There are novariablesinGorbman’sdiscussion,whichtherefore reinforcesBill’sretributionsiseasilydone byusingthe
same musiccontinually.Inourstudieshoweverwe have foundthatdissectingthe song’sstructure encouragesdifferent
musical pointstoreferto differentthings.However, theycan’tactmotificallyif asegmentonlyappearsonce,andif
visual increasesordecreasesintime are presentthenthe musicisn’ttruly representingwhatwe see everytime.Forthe
same reasonwe can qualifyamisunderstandingof the narrative,andahistoricityisachievedbyusingsongsfromafter
the war to supportthe fictional oppressorsof Nazism inawidelyfictionalscenario.A schizophrenicvisionisofferedto
16 Donnelly, K. J. 2001. Film Music:Critical Approaches. New York/London:Continuum International Publishing Group
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford13
us bythe opposite viewpointswe receivefromdifferentcharactersall aimingtokill the ThirdReichthroughthe same
track (‘What’dI Say’).Oppositiontohighmodernismcouldbe demonstratedbythe prolongedpassionShoshannaand
Marcel share,despite the gravityandhuge implicationstheirpreferredoutcomewouldhave (inthe worldof the film).
The longevityof the embrace wouldn’tbe emphasizedwere itnotforthe musicand itscontrastingnotionof time
elsewhere inthe film.
LARSEN’S DICHOTOMY: CHARLES BERNSTEIN’S ‘WHITE LIGHTNING’
‘Slaughter’and‘What’dISay’ accountfor two of three songsthat feature twice inthe film.The thirdisCharles
Bernstein’s‘WhiteLightning’,originallythe openingtheme forJosephSargent’s1973 film White Lightning (also
appearinginTarantino’s Kill Bill Vol.I).In InglouriousBasterds,the trackbookendsaretrospective scene thatstems
fromNazi Private Butz’recallingtoHitlerof the Basterdsambushonhis regiment.The scene isthe thirdof three in
chaptertwo (‘InglouriousBasterds’),having firstmetAldoRaine andhismenthroughtheirunconventional military
briefing,andthenseenHitler’sangeratthe Basterds’growingreputationamongsthissoldiers.ErnoRapée dictatesthat
“as longas you varyyour instrumentationoryourtonalityit will notgettiresome17
”.Rapée’saccountsare hugelydated
(1924) but we can still contesthisnotionsthroughthe musical passagesin‘WhiteLightning’.The trackconstitutes
several differentinstrumentsfromdifferentculturesthatplayinunisonandoccasionallywarrantasolopart, in
conjunctiontothe otherinstruments.The vastarrayof instrumentscontestsRapée’sconceptaswe have awider
selectionof passagestochoose from.Bernsteintestifiesthatforthe compositionof the songhe hiredsome of the best
countrymusiciansinAmericaatthe time (the original film‘White Lightning’issetisArkansas,southernAmerica)18
.The
track’s bookendingof ourfirstinsighttothe Basterd’smethodsplacesitatthe start andbeginningof asmallernarrati ve
structure;the scene’sdepictionof the Basterdsatwork ismemorable foritsultra-violenttone andpassive-aggressive
dialogue.Thisensures the audience will rememberthe scene as itsownentity,aswell aswithin inthe greaternarrative
strand.The interrogativeelementsof the Basterd’smissionsare vital toprofilingtheirstatusandsuperiorityoverNazis
inthe film;the wide arrayof instrumentationsin‘White Lightning’mirrorsthe multiplicityof scenesitservesfor.
17 Rapée, Erno. 1974 (originally1924). Motion Picture Moods for Pianists and Organists. New York:Arno Press.
18 http://www.filmscoremonthly.com/board/posts.cfm?threadID=68442&forumID=1&archive=0
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford14
PeterLarsen’s‘FilmMusic’(2005) isa recenttextthatassessesthe problemsof musicfilmanalysis,beforeproposinga
model andapplyingitamongstotherwritings.Hisdiscursive chapter‘AnalysingFilmMusic’determinesadichotomyof
analysisisrequired:
“It will concentrate on the mutual relations between the individual elements and on the function of the elements in the totality”.
ConceptuallyforLarsen,“actual,thoroughanalysesof the functionsof filmmusicinparticularfilmsisrare”,and“film
musicisfunctional music– musicwhose structure hasbeendeterminedbyfactorsthatlie outside the musicitself19
”.
Larsennominatesthatbasicissuesof musicandcinemacan be tackledsimilarlyastheyfocusonsimilarcomponents –
segmentation,motifictendency,expectationsof the audience,narrativethreadingetc.Larsenequatesthatasmusic
analysisandfilmanalysis,intheirmostprimitive forms,share terminology,methodandlimitations,itisessential to
understandhowa track runsfundamentallywithoutanarrative,visual backdrop,before reinstatingthatbackdropand
measuringthe findingsagainstthe scenery.Forthisensuinganalysis,thismethodwillbe exercised.The musicwill be
interrogatedasmusic,the track’swide soundscape providingthe basisforselectingthisparticulartrack.Subsequentlyit
will be studiedwiththe preliminaryfindingsagainstthe visual backdropitadheresto –the differentmomentsof
sceneryaffordingourchoice forpickingthe musicfromthe scene.
‘White Lightning’issegmented;initiallythe instrumentsbuilduponone another,before all stoppingandallowingsolo
movementsinthe silence fordifferentthreadsof the musical fabric.The firstsoundwe hearisa bass guitarpluckingat
a moderate tempo,fromG (3) downa fifthtoC, thena secondto B♭,before the minorthirddescenttothe lowerG
octave.The latterG note resonatesbefore routinelyperformingthe riff again,andafteronce aroundthe riff the quick
tappingof a hi –hat. The rhythm sectionisthenlayered withirregularlyplacedbongo/tom-likedrums,andthenthe
melodicbassislayeredwithaslide guitar,scalingthe Gminorpentatonicscale.Again,the rhythmrespondswith
additional hi-hathitsthatstandalone alongeachbar,withgrowingemphasisonthe tomsunderneathit –one
resonatingsimilarlytoasnare.Unexpectedlythe followingadditionisanechoedbreathe-likegasp,andthenthe slide
guitarrollsaroundthe pentatonicscale again.Thisisthirtyfive secondsin,andthe echoemittedfromthe vocal and
resoundingtomsemphasisesthe vastspace the songis in.A breakdowntriggeredbyasolitarypianochordrevealsa
sustained,highregisteringwoodwindblowthatisparticularlyintimidatingonce itcollideswithalow minorpianochord.
19 Larsen, P. 2005. Film Music. London:ReaktionBooks Ltd
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford15
Then, a panoramicsnare-like roll,shakingof maracas,and furtherslide guitarall individuallyperform.Subsequentlya
similarbuildupentails,thistime withthe additionfromthe startof the new sectionof the ironicallynamedjewharp,
whichgoeson to configure asolopositioninthe succeedingbreakdown.
The advantage of employingthissonganditsassociatedscenesasobjectsof Larsen’smethodologyisthatthe scope of
instrumentsfullyoptimizesthe individual andcombinedcomponents’relationships; toequallysingularorcollective
aspectsof the scene’sindividual narrative withinthe film’stotality.Forthe firstscene,the musicbeginsvisuallybehind
the lateraffirmedPrivate Butz,whoisbeingescortedupastaircase bytwo Nazi staff.We hear himbefore we see his
face,as the ensuingconversationwithHitlerbeginsbefore we jointhemvisually;the slide guitarisaudible but
underneaththe dominantdialogue.He detailsthe survivorsof the ambushbefore the recollectioncomesalive,ashe
describes‘removingthe hair’;anunknownBasterd’sknife isskimmingthroughadeadNazi’sscalpinunnervingfashion.
As the drumrollsbeginsthe viewgoestothe three survivedNazisare marshalleddownpastthe leftof ourscreen.
The seconddeploymentof ‘White Lightning’alsobeginsinButzandHitler’sdialogue,before again carrying us back into
Butz’s memory. Butz, translator Wicki and Aldo are stood left to right, with a map between Butz and Aldo. Aldo’s
questions,the translationandthe answers are followedbythe camera. The jovial questioning of what Butz plans to do
when he gets home, and what he intends to do with his uniform, profile the fear Butz has and the Basterd’s darkly
humorous tone as its antithesis. The slide guitar plays when Aldo asks his questions, linking the two regionally and
authoritatively,due tothe guitar’sprominence inthe song and Aldo’s Basterd rank. Bathos is created by filling the gap
betweenWicki’stranslationsandAldo’ssarcasticcommentswiththe panoramicsnare roll onboth occasions. However,
the conversation intensifies and Aldo stands up as the bass re-joins (solidifying his balance on the scene) and steps
toward Butz, which pushes him out of shot. The aural response is to introduce the jew harp into proceedings, which
fundamentallycontradictsthe growingtensioninitsplayfullylax stretches.However,the unconventional sound stands
out, as it balances on a typically rockabilly/rock ‘n’ roll rhythmic foundation. The sound mirrors the pacey and broad
accent of Aldo,whose intentionsandauthorityare transpiringnow he’sstoodup.ItalsoparallelsAldo’sunconventional
military approach, particularly his request for “one hundred Nazi scalps” and the scarring of any survivors. Claudia
Gorbman, in ‘Unheard Melodies’, highlights that film music “bonds spectator to spectacle, it envelops spectator and
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford16
spectacle ina harmonious place20
”; ‘White Lightning’ begins to aid the divide between Nazi and Basterd, and enables
the audience toallude toBasterd ideology, despite seeing this through the eyes of a Nazi. Aldo informs us he doesn’t
like Naziswhotake off their uniform, as their Nazi identity is concealed. Wicki begins to relay to Butz, and flute eerily
glides above the dialogue, representing Butz’s growing fears. The solution is to give him something he can’t remove,
indicatedasscarringthroughAldo’sviciousraisingof hisknife.Asthisisstated, the guitar plays, and its genre and style
cementsRaine’spowerinthe scene.ThisisachievedthroughreferencinghisrootsinsouthernAmerica, and paralleling
the Lieutenant’s dominance byappearingcentral tothe totalityof itsownbackdrop.The track’sindividual soloing parts
have thus far served for different emotions of oppositional characters but predominantly outlined the Basterd’s
supremacy in the Nazi memory. We return to view Hitler, whose shock is evident, before we then turn to Butz’
forehead, where a swastika scar sits. Our return to the memory is set through Butz’ view, which has Donny and Aldo
above him, with Aldo’s knife with a minute drop of blood on the blade. Donny compliments the scarring, and Aldo
responds: “You know how to get to Carnegie Hall, don’t ya? … Practice.”
The jewharp thenresoundsinthe visual successionintodarkness,beginning ata higherregisteranddroppingtoa
lowerone swiftly;itembodieslaughterorchortlingatRaine’sthrowawayresponse,before the scene andchaptercome
to a close.The musicbarelychangesforthe transition,asthe jew harpringsaroundthe emptyvisual space withthe
guitarand bass underneathit.Afterwe’reinformedof the nextchapterandthe year,the instrumentationstopsasthe
flute returns;thisplaysasa camera pansverticallydownacinema,pasta circular window whichagirl walkspast,and
eventuallyshe meetsusatthe bottomentrance of the cinema.She comesoutside,andthe bassand guitarhave just
come back intothe mix.She beginschangingthe lettersaroundthe bannerfrontingabove the cinemadoors,beforethe
musicends,and“ShoshannaDreyfus:FourYearsAfterthe Massacre of herFamily”flashesuponthe screen.
The ambiguityof thischaracter’sidentityiscodedatthroughthe visual andaudiopatternsonce again;we see herfora
splitsecond,walkingahead,pastthe circularwindow.Fromthe topon the cinemaview andpastthiswindow,the
constantwoodwindnote resonates,onlytobe replacedwiththe less tense guitarlineswhenshe comesoutside.
Althoughwe don’tknowatthispointwhoshe is,we can predict heridentityandnarrative through the music;the
similarityinscore betweenAldoandthe Basterdsinstilsasubconscioustrustwiththe female character.Furthermore,in
20
Gorbman, C. 1987. Unheard Melodies:Narrative Film Music. Bloomington:Universityof Indiana Press.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford17
betweenthe twoplaying’sof ‘White Lightning’,Raine commentstothe soon-to-be-deadNazi SergeantRachtmannthat
watchingDonny(The BearJew) clubbingGermanstodeathis“the closestanyof (them) gettogoin’to the movies”;the
scene endswithDonnyandAldocentral to the shotfrom Butz,before we arrive ata cinema.
Isolationof the musical textandsubsequentexaminationdictatesthatthe track ismade up of both contrastingand
similarinstruments,withsimilardiscontinuityfoundwithinthe timbreof those instruments –phrasing,length,tone,
and presence withinthe totalityof the track.These individualelementsandtheirrole inthe track’stotalitycompliment
the singularityof the Basterds inthisscene.Asa whole,‘White Lightning’isaBasterdstrack, but the separate musical
featuresequate tothe Basterd’sseparate charactersandtheirNazi counterpartsinthe scene.Aldoinparticularis
activelybeingprofiledbysingle instrumentativeexamples,whereasotherkeymemberssuchasDonnyeithertie into
that ideologyorhave theirown(whenhe emergesfromthe cave to‘The Surrender’byEnnioMorricone,andBilly
Preston’s‘Slaughter’actingtorepresentHugoStiglitzmusically).If we heardthese instrumentsontheirown,they
wouldconnote paramusical ideasandemotions.Forexample, fear,throughthe highestregistering,highlysustained
flute;regionally,the slide guitaranditsmovementscrystalliseAldo’sownrootsandideologies;bathosfromthe jew
harp thencommendsbothAldo’sunconventional militaryapproachandhissarcastic,anticlimactictone andsense of
humour.
ENNIO MORRICONE AND SHOSHANNA DREYFUS
The majorityof textsconsideredthusfarsurroundthose whooppose Nazismin‘InglouriousBasterds’;onlyonce,in
Morricone’s‘DopoLa Condanna’have we dissectedmusicthatprofiledthe threatandauthorityharbouredbythe Nazis.
Otherwise thisstudyhasfocusedelsewhere,mostlyonthe Basterdsthemselves.Cinematically,anglingthe study
towards the film’sJewishheroine ShoshannaDreyfushasn’toccurred abundantly.She epitomisesthe face of Jewish
vengeance inthe final chapter‘Revenge of the GiantFace’,aftera lengthyprocessof editingthe reel to A Nation’sPride
so that she answersZoller’squestion“Whowantstosenda message toGermany?”with“I want to senda message to
Germany… thatyou are all goingto die.”Subsequentlythe cinemaburnsdownandthe Basterdsattendingthe
premiere shooteveryonefromHitler’sbalcony(aftershootinghim, Goebbelsandthe translatorFrancesca).Thisdisplay
of determinationisthe antithesisof howwe initiallyperceiveShoshanna –weak,coveredinherfamily’sblood,
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford18
aimlesslyrunningawayfromthe LaPadite farm.Herdevelopmentthroughoutthe film more thanjustifiesstudyingher
musical underpinnings.
The final proposal of enquirywill seektounderstandMorricone’srole inshapingthe audience’sreadingof Shoshanna;
withparticularemphasisuponherarrival intothe filmandherdeparture,both underscoredbyMorricone.
L’INCONTRO CON LA FIGLIA (THE MEETING OF THE DAUGHTER)
Jeff Smith,in‘The Soundsof Commerce:MarketingPopularFilmMusic’locatesthat‘Morricone’spragmatismand
eclecticism allowed him to function within a numberof commercialmusic contexts21
’;hisabilitytocreate polysemicfilm
music’sonmany occasionsunderlinesthisclaim.The twotextstobe analysedfurtherthis astheyare the antithesisof
one another.Ourfirst,‘L’incontroConLa Figlia’(‘The Meetingof the Daughter’)’sascensionindynamicsalludestothe
creationof fearand terror; the scramblingviolinsthatbeginnearthe startof the track are reminiscentof ‘Flightof the
Bumblebee’,withoutanyobviousmotifsoperating.Sustainingoverthe topof the stringsectionisa Frenchhorn,
internallypedallingthe note.Itdoesn’tsoundsolo;aviolasoundstobe playinginunisonandaddinggravitastothe
sound.The tensionisdirectlyincreasedbythe faintcrashesof cymbalsheardinthe backgroundfromfortysix seconds
in– theydon’tforefrontthe mix oract rhythmicallytoatiming.Fromhere,the sustainedroll onasnare (withall its
militaryconnotations) canbe heardunderneaththe stringsandhorns,before we getto01:05 where the hornsand
snare stop,before re-joiningthreesecondslatertoperformthe track’scrashingmovement.The hornbeginsatone
lower,andissupportedbythe higherE octave note inlowerregisteredstringsandhorns.Itsplayingresonatesaround
the track and contradictsthe shimmeringandstill scramblingviolinsunderneathit,thatare settledata higherregister
withrepeatedtonal dropsata fasttempo.We are now intothe secondhalf of the track, whichisledbythe stomping
riffsof lowerbrassinstrumentssuchasthe bass tuba.The forefrontof the track issharedbetweentheselowbrass
instrumentsandafalsettochoirthat act out a descenteachtime they’re heard.The lowerbrassisreplacedbytrumpets
that alsorecur arounda riff before (like the lowerbrassbefore it) pedallingthe finalnote.
This track not onlyintroducesShoshanna,butalsothe twistedinterrogative methodsof Landaandthe obedience
inflictedthroughoutNazi ranks.Italsoprofilesthe angstandpainof LaPadite,whose Englishconversation withLanda
21
Smith, J. 1998. The Sounds of Commerce:Marketing Popular Film Music. New York/Chichester, West Sussex:Columbia UniversityPress.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford19
meansthe deceasedhadnoideaof theirimpendingdeath.RobertCumbow,inhistext“Once Upona Time:The Filmsof
SergioLeone”talksof Morricone’sdominationoverthe visual scape:“Nevermerelyaccompanyingorcommentingon
the shotsor on the action,the musicassumesequal proportiontowhatistakingplace onthe screen22
”.The only
dialogue duringthe musicisthe theatricsonLanda,and a few nervousshakesof LaPadite’shead.Thesetwofactors
workperfectlyinconjunctiontoone another:Sparingthe scene of dialogueotherthanonLanda’spart highlightsthe
powerof the music, the sensual emotive connotationsitmakes,andLanda’sdisturbingattitudetohiswork.He instructs
LaPadite toswitchback to Frenchonce he has coaxedthe informationof the hiddenJewsfromthe farmer.Eventhough
the Dreyfus’scan’tsee Landa,he openshisarms and animates athank youfor the farmer’shospitality.The imagerythis
createswiththisaural backdrop locatesLandaperfectly,asthe out-of-the-ordinarySSColonelTarantinowrote himto
be23
.
Shoshannaiscapturedrunningawayfromthe house both frombehindandinfrontof her; the house loominginthe
distantbackgroundcrystallisingherdeparture,andthe rural surroundingshighlightingherlackof directionorplan.All
the while,close upsonherface and of her overtemotional placementappearwhilstthe trackconflictsemotionally
betweenscramblingstringsandsustained,boomingbrass.The varietyof timbre inthe track’sinstrumentationclearly
demonstratesbothLanda’scapability athisjoband Shoshanna’sshockandangst, consequently alsoalludingtoNazi
power.The visualsdepictLandaallowinghertolive however,whichinsinuatesherrole inthe filmisnotyetover.
Shoshannawill be back,we justdon’tknowhow,when,where,orwhoshe maybe with.Undeniably,retribution
becomesaninstanttheme underpinningherasshe’ssurvived.
UN AMICO (A FRIEND)
In chapterfive (‘The Revengeof the GiantFace’),Nazi Nightisinfull swingand the filmpremiere of Goebbel’s A
Nation’sPrideappearsto be goingwell fromboth a Nazi perspective andfromaBasterds/Shoshannaperspective.
However,the untimelydescent‘Nation’sPride’takesintoultra-violentactsonZoller’spartmake the Nazi feel
uncomfortable;he stridestowardsShoshanna’sprojectionroom, accompaniedbythe fearful colourof “TigerTank”by
Lalo Schifrin.AfterignoringShoshanna’sclaimsthathe can’tbe inthat room and that he shouldbe watchingthe
22
Cumbow, R. C. Once Upon a Time:The Films of Sergio Leone. Metuchen, N.J./London:The Scarecrow Press, Inc.
23 In an interview with Ella Taylor,Tarantino claims thatLanda comes from “a longlineof suave, charmingNazis that have appeared
in Postwar cinema”. http://www.villagevoice.com/2009-08-18/news/quentin-tarantino-the-inglourious-basterds-interview/ Date
accessed – April 2013.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford20
premiere,she theninsultshimbyaskinghimif hisnewly foundNazi statushasleadhimtoforgetwhat‘no’means.He
burststhroughthe doorand confrontsher,as she takesthe opportunity.She tellshimtoclose the dooras they‘don’t
have much time’,before shootinghimthree timesinthe backashe locksthe door.‘Un Amico’(‘A Friend’)beginstoplay
as she turns fromherviewintothe cinematowardshisbodyon the floor.
Beginningwiththe slow,floatingacousticguitarpicking, aroundthe Cmajorchord for three bars at the start of the
fourthbar, violinsbegintoplaya melodysimilartothe guitarsbut witha muchfullersound,anda more lyrical flow
withinitsmelody.The twoplayinconjunctionforthe nextelevenbars,the guitar’smotificrepetition complimenting
the stringsdevelopingmelody.The endof the eleventhbarismetwitha subtle drumfill aroundthe snare and toms
before advancingtoa 4/4 rhythm.Thisisalsowhere the bassguitar joins,whichfollowsthe rootnotesof the chords
and itspluckingrecallsDu-Wopconventionality,asthe firstnote ringsoutbefore the nexttwoare playedquicklyone
afteranother.The tranquillityof the stringsandguitarhasbeendistractedbutonlybythe euphoricevolutionthe
stringshave undertaken:Theynowcanbe foundrepeatingasimilarmotif tobefore butanoctave higherandwithan
eventhickersound(multiplicityinthe violinsseemstobe the cause,alongwithemphasisonsome of the phrasesfrom
flutes).The lyrical styleof the violinsstillremains,asitisstill the focal pointof the track. The nextsectionbridge sto
anotheridentical sectionbutgoesthroughthe chordsina stabbingwaltzmotiononthe midregisterof the violinsfor
three bars independently.These are metbya similarlysteadydrumfill before the violin’smelodyisplayedbya
keyboard/synthesizer.Despite followingthe melody,thissectionisn’tasecstaticasbefore asit’sof a softertone and
registeredlower,inthe midrange.The track doescontinue andfollowsthese sectionsthroughout,butourfilm
experience of itendshere abruptly.
By killingZollerbefore the musicstarts,the musicdisorientatesourscope of Shoshanna’semotionsasmuchas she
does;she triesto lookawayfromZoller,butTarantinosurroundsher.The scene in‘Nation’sPride’we are catching
snippetsof displaysZollerstrugglingtofightof the enemyandlookingdefeated,hisface central tothe camera.
Shoshannaflicksbetweenbothhisbodyandhispresence inthe film,until Zollergroansandshe cannot helpherself but
assisthim.Here,Shoshanna’scompassionkillsEmannuelle Mimieux.She walksovertohim(whichwe see froma
Birdseye view,whichlocatesthe twoontheirownina small room),andshe turnshim over;as she doesso,the first
drum fill playsandZollerstretcheshisarmoutand shootsherin the torso.Perfectlytimed,Shoshannafallsbackinslow
motionsurroundedbyanexplosionof small redparticles, justasthe violinsrepeattheirmelodybutatthe higher
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford21
registerandwiththe rhythmicstabilisingof the drumsandthe bass.We see herscreechin slow motion,andbounce off
the wall (where throughthe glasswe see Zolleronscreen,behindher,cockinghisrifle).The camerathenlandsdirectly
infront of her face,portrayingher pain.However,tothismusicandwithoutdialogue,Shoshannalooksorgasmic,which
underpinsthe romantictonalityof the piece.Shoshannafallstothe floor;she islyingvertically,atthe bottomof Zoller’s
feet,whoislyinghorizontally.The cameraswitchestoZoller,andprimarilyfocusesonhimbefore hispistol;whenhe
firesthe pistol,we returntonormal speedandhere Shoshannascreamashe’sjustpulledthe trigge r.Bloodissplattered
everywhere,andthe twoare viewedagainfromthe Birdseye view.The constantreferral tothe small space theyare
bothin and the fact that there are onlytwocharacters presentplacestheirweddednarrative furtherthanplatonic
realms.DuringShoshanna’sritualisticpreparationsforthe night the deepredof hercostume codesenticedthe anger
and vengeance evidentonscreen;now,paralleltoZoller’sovertlywhite militaryjacketembeddedwithbadges,the red
and the white complimentthe romanticovertonesthat‘UnAmico’implies.WhilstShoshannakilledFrederick,onecould
argue Emmanuelle fell inlove withhim.The factthat the twofindthemselvessidebyside inthe filmreelsShoshanna
has editedmeansZoller’scharacterisimmortalisedwithShoshanna,whereasShoshanna’scharacterdieswithZoller.
The visual effectof slowmotiontoa relativelyslow tempotrackaddsto thisidea – theirduality,whetherromantic,
platonicor contrasting,ismade timeless,bothonthe screen of ‘Nation’sPride’and‘InglouriousBasterds’bytheirvery
owndualitieswiththemselves.
CONCLUSION AND EVALUATION
The analytical modelscementedtothisdissertationencourage the writingtowrite descriptivelyforcertainaspectson
investigations.Jameson’spostmodernismsare culturallyinclined,consequentlyanymeasurementmade againstthem
will require adetailed explanationof the filmmusic’srole inthe greaternarrative.Larsen’sdichotomydictatesthatas
there are some similaritiesinvernacularbetweenprimitive musicandfilmanalysis,insinuatingtwoformsof analyses
needtobe undertaken.The thirdsegment,concerningMorricone andShoshanna,basesonnoparticularacademic
frameworkbutthe Larsen’swritingshave taughtusthroughouta steadymethodof analyseswhichcoincidentallysuits
the two antithetical Morricone tracksusedtoscore Shoshanna’sentrance anddeparture.
ConsiderPhilipTagg’s‘Functionsof FilmMusic24
’:Tagg’staxonomyreappropriates PolishmusicologistZofiaLissa’s1959
24 http://www.tagg.org/udem/musimgmot/filmfunx.html Date accessed:October 2012.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford22
study Ästhetikder Filmmusik for contemporaryuse.Inconjunctionwiththisscript,‘The Verdict(DopoLaCondanna)’
equatesto‘Expressionsof Actor’sEmotions’(6) withconstantclose visual surveillance of LaPadite workingintandem
withBarry Cooper’sdiscussionof the emotional longingtransposedfrom‘FurElise’.Technicallyitalsomatcheswiththe
‘Opening’ssubheadingfrom‘EnhancementandDemarcationof the Film’sFormal Structure’(10),asit’sthe firsttrackin
the film.BillyPreston’s‘Slaughter’alsomirrorsasubheadingfrom(10),thatof ‘Leitmotif’asitservesto‘re-identifywith
characters’amongstother filmicelements.Thisalsoleadsusbackto(6) whenwe regardthe differingemotive
connotationsStiglitzemitsonbothoccasions.‘What’dISay’meetsthe descriptionof ‘Symbol’(8),aswe learnof the
Nazi oppressor’scommencingtoendthe nightprematurelybefore the Nazisdo.Italso,againequatesto(6) withfurther
examplesof contrastingemotions,fromthe excitedBasterdsanddistressedShoshanna.‘White Lightning’parallelsthe
thirdsubheadingfrom(10),‘LinksandBridges’asit ‘bridges’the gapbetweenchapterstwoandthree andsecuresour
trust withthe unidentifiedfemale(Shoshanna).Bernstein’strackrelays‘Emphasisof Movement’(1) asAldo’sl iteral
stance is concretedwithtimelyadditionsof dampbassguitar.At thispointthe dialogue andmusicintensifiesgreatly
but the visualsdonotsuggestthisas prominentlyasthe musicdoes,ensuringwe canmirror‘White Lightning’to
‘Anticipationof SubsequentAction’(9).The varyinginstrumentationsalsoleadusbackto‘Expressionsof Actor’s
Emotions’(6).‘L’IncontroConLa Figlia’endorses(9) completely,asthe raise indynamicsunveilsthe scramblingand
sustainingminortonesof the track’s instruments;the visualsare nearenoughidentical tohow they’ve beenforthe
majorityof chapterone.Certainly(6) againforLaPadite andsubsequentlyafleeingShoshanna,butalsothe track suits
the twistedmethodsof Landa,whoisthe scene’svictor (providingthe earlierWesterncontextsetby‘The Verdict(Dopo
La Condanna)’).‘UnAmico’leadsustostudy‘Comment’(5),asitdictatesa typical case of such is through“contradicting
the connotative sphere of the visual action”.ShoshannaandFredrick’skillingof one anotherrepresentsthe untimely
endfor twointegral charactersinthe film:Accompaniedby‘UnAmico’recontextualisesourinterpretationhoweverand
crystallisesthe tworomantically.Italsomirrors‘ExpressionsforAudience’sEmotions’(7) henceforth.
Mostly,the dissertationismotivatedbythe necessityof scrutinisingthe musicandassociatedscenery.Detailed
descriptive language allowsforconcise findingsanalytically,butonlyif the analytical structure inplacesallowsforsuch.
The disadvantage of buildingonquantifiedsongchoiceswitharegimentedtaxonomysuchasTagg’sis that there could
arguablybe little roomtoidentifythe music’spolysemictendency;if anyat all.Employingaview of postmodern
discourse uponthe topicdemonstratesaside tothe songsthat isunobtainable withoutaconcise knowledge of the area
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford23
and itssurroundings;the footnotesaccompanyingthe dissertationthroughoutdon’tequate tothe amountof
preliminaryreadingundertooktolearnof the discourse.Jameson’spostmodernismscouldbe appliedtofilmanalysisor
musicanalysisindependently;infact,to almostanyartefactsof popularculture.Applyingthemtofilmmusicpermits
the conductor to deconstructthe audio-visual bondandtoexamine the strandsbetweenthemwithacultural eye,a
widerscope.Were itnotfor the tightconstraintsof the essay,one couldemploythe parametersof Baudrillardor
Lyotard forexample,andwould locate differentfindings.Usingamodel suchasTagg’s infinitelyinalargersectionof the
dissertationcompressesthe findingstobe purelymusical andcinematic,withnoneedforwiderscope.Alongside the
more narrow scope of Larsen maytherefore seemcontradictory,butonlyif thispaperhasa view toinvestigate
InglouriousBasterds music’sasacultural artefactthroughout;butit doesn’t,andone mustn’tforgetthis.If we are to
fullyutilise the limitationsof the study,it’svital torememberthatprimarily,we are investigatingmusicandits
relationship tothe film.These elementsmustbe tackledappropriately –Larsen’sdichotomyprovingasuccessful model.
WhereasJameson’sworkcouldbe subjective forsome academics,Larsenappreciatesthe needtounderstandmusic
and filmseparatelybeforeconsequentlycollaboratingthe twospheres.Larsen’smethod,if successful,will ensure the
conductorhas a sophisticatedyetconcise approachtothe twobasic entitiesunderobservation;determiningthese
faculties certifiesforthe inclusionof amuchmore analytical,culturallymindedapproachsuchasJameson’s
postmodernisms.
The concept of dualitiesisexploredthroughdifferentexamplesthroughoutthe dissertation.The basisforchoosing
these textsstemsfromDeacon’searliersuggestionsof regardingquantitative researchasa cultural researchmethod.
Underpinningthe twoframesof academiawithnumericallybasedsongchoicesensuresnopersonal affiliationswithany
of the soundtrackare made on the conductor’sbehalf;the catalystforthe selectionsmustbe balanced,forthe ensuing
analysesmaybe subjective todifferentsubscribersof analytical frameworks.Instantlythroughthesedualismsdenote
motificactivity,justthroughthe word’smeaning,asArnold Whittall dictates:
“…to represent or symbolize a person, object, place, idea, state of mind, supernatural force or any other ingredient25”.
25 Grove, George, Sir, 1820-1900; Sadie, Stanley, 1930-;Tyrrell, John. 2001. The NewGrove Dictionaryof Music and Musicians. London: Macmillan
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford24
Each of the songsthat appeartwice all meetWhittall’sdefinitions;measuringthemagainstadiscursive facultysuchas
postmodernismdetailsfindingsinaccessible throughpure musical orfilmanalysis.Butinordertoreceive these findings,
one mustclearlyunderstandthe fundamentalsof musicinrelationtothe filmandinitsisolation.
There are othersongsthat wouldhave providedinterestingresults –DavidBowie’s‘CatPeople’isarguablythe most
‘popular’trackon the soundtrack,and isthe longestmusical textfoundinthe foregroundof itsappropriate scene.It’s
depictionof Shoshanna’sritualisticroutineof preparingforNazi Nightisfragmentedbyadetailedaccountof herand
Marcel’sstrive forsuccess,regardlessof the cost.The track alsoisthe mostobviouswithlyrical connectionstothe
characters,withthe repeatedphrasingof ‘beensolong’crystallisingShoshannaunderNazi rule andherlengthy plansof
vengeance.One couldsuggestdualitiesthroughthe constantlyrical repetition‘beensolong’directlylinkedto
Shoshanna,however forthe idiomsaffixedtothe studythere waslittle roomforacademicconsiderationof the text.A
keydualitynotaccreditedtoisthe openingcreditstothe closingcredits,butina tightlyconfinedstudy,the music’s
dominantpurpose istorelaymessagesof the visualsonscreen –withthe choicesinthistextprovingmore fruitful
purelybecause theyhave ascene tounderscore.However,forthe size andconstraintsof the study,itis feasibleto
suggestthe evidence portrayedthroughoutthe studyclearlydemonstratesanexplorationintothe musicof the film,its
purpose,anditscapacity tofacilitate the purpose inquestion.Thisconclusionwouldn’thave beenmetwithoutthe
theoretical andacademicframeworkstomeasure the musicagainst;whilstnosuchcase can be foundinthe thirdmode
of analysisinthe dissertation,the twobeforeiteducatedusintohow tofindwhatwe are lookingfor,culminatinginthe
musicof Morricone comparedto Shoshanna;tworelicsof the filmthatcouldnotbe ignored.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford25
Appendices
Figure 1.1
13%
11%
17%
29%
30%
Chapter Length (M/S)
One: 'Once Upon a Time… in
Nazi-occupied France' 18:26
Two: 'Inglourious Basterds'
15:52
Three: 'German Night in
Paris' 24:11
Four: Operation Kino' 40:36
Five: 'The Revenge of the
Giant Face' 41:31
8%
20%
20%
22%
30%
Musical Chapter Length (M/S)
One: 'Once Upon a Time… in Nazi-
occupied France' 02:47
Two: 'Inglourious Basterds' 06:36
Three: 'German Night in Paris'
06:26
Four: Operation Kino' 07:14
Five: 'The Revenge of the Giant
Face' 10:02
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford26
Figure 1.2
8%
20%
12%
4%
10%
46%
RepeatedTexts(inLengthOrder)
"What'd I Say" Rare Earth (Chapter Five; first
appearance) 00:25
What'd I Say Rare Earth (Chapter Five; second
appearance) 00:58
"Slaughter" Billy Preston (Chapter Two; first
appearace) 00:37
"Slaughter" Billy Preston (Chapter Four; second
appearance) 00:11
"White Lightning" Charles Bernstein (Chapter
Two; first appearance) 00:30
"White Lightning" Charles Bernstein (Chapter
Two/Three; second appearance 02:17
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford27
KEY SHOTS FROM INGLORIOUS BASTERDS
ChapterOne (Once Upon a Time …
In Nazi-occupiedFrance):The Nazis
arrive at the LaPadite farm.
ChapterOne (Once Upon a Time …
In Nazi-occupiedFrance):Perrier
LaPadite’sprofilingasNazisarrive.
ChapterOne (Once Upon a Time …
In Nazi-occupiedFrance):Shoshanna
fleesasLanda lookson.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford28
ChapterTwo (InglouriousBasterds):
We meetHugoStiglitz.
ChapterTwo (InglouriousBasterds):
View fromButz’s foreheadatthe
endof the chapter.
ChapterFour (OperationKino):
Stiglitzbeingwhipped.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford29
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):Donnyleavesthe
cinema.
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):DonnyandOmar leave
the cinema.
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):ShoshannaandMarcel
embrace forthe lasttime.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford30
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):Frederickshoots
Shoshanna.
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):Shoshannaand
Frederick’srestingplaces.
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):“Who wantsto senda
message toGermany?”
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford31
ChapterFive (The Revenge of the
Giant Face):“I have a message for
Germany…That you are all goingto
die."
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford32
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Literature:
Auner&Lochhead.2002. Postmodern MusicPostmodern Thought.London/New York:Routledge.
Best& Kellner.1991. Postmodern Theory:CriticalInterrogations.London:MacmillanEducationLtd.
Boswell,M.2012. HolocaustImpietyin Literature, PopularMusicand Film. Basingstoke:PalgraveMacmillan.
Brown,Royal S. 1994. Overtonesand Undertones:Reading FilmMusic.Berkeley/LosAngeles/London:Universityof
CaliforniaPress.
Chandler,D.2002. The Basics:Semiotics. Abingdon,Oxon:Routledge.
Connor,S. 3004. The CambridgeCompanion to Postmodernism.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress.
Connor,S. 1989. PostmodernistCulture:An Introduction to Theoriesof theContemporary.Oxford:BlackwellPublishers.
Cooper,B.2000. Beethoven. Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress.
Cumbow,R.C. Once Upon a Time: The Films of Sergio Leone.Metuchen,N.J./London:The Scarecrow Press,Inc.
Dassanowsky,R.V.2012. Quentin Tarantino’sInglouriousBasterds:A Manipulationof Metacinema.New York/London:
ContinuumInternational PublishingGroup.
Dawson,J.1995. Quentin Tarantino:The Cinema of Cool.New York: Applause Books.
Donnelly,K.J.2001. Film Music: Critical Approaches. New York/London:ContinuumInternationalPublishingGroup.
Friedburg,A.1993. WindowShopping:Cinema and thePostmodern.Berkeley/LosAngeles/London:Universityof
CaliforniaPress.
Gorbman,C. 1987. Unheard Melodies:NarrativeFilmMusic. Bloomington:Universityof IndianaPress.
Grove, George, Sir, 1820-1900; Sadie, Stanley, 1930-;Tyrrell, John. 2001. The New Grove Dictionary of Musicand
Musicians. London:Macmillan.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford33
Holm,D. K. 2004. The Pocket Essentials:Quentin Tarantino.Harpenden:PocketEssentials.
Knight& Wojcik.2001. SoundtrackAvailable:Essayson Filmand PopularMusic. Durhamand London:Duke University
Press.
Larsen, P. 2005. Film Music. London: Reaktion Books Ltd.
Mundy,J. 1999. PopularMusicon Screen: FromHollywood Musicalto MusicVideo.Manchester:Universityof
ManchesterPress.
Pickering,M.2008. Research MethodsforCulturalStudies.Edinburgh:EdinburghUniversityPressLtd.
Powrie &Stilwell.2006. Changing Tunes:TheUseof Pre-existing Musicin Film. Aldershot:AshgatePublishingLtd.
Rapée,Erno.1974 (originally1924). Motion PictureMoodsforPianistsand Organists.New York:ArnoPress.
Sharrett,Christopher.1993. Crisis Cinema:The ApocalypticIdea in Postmodern NarrativeFilm.WashingtonDC:
Maisonneuve Press.
Smart, B. 1993. Postmodernity:Key Ideas.London:Routledge.
Smith,J.1998. The Soundsof Commerce:Marketing PopularFilmMusic. New York/Chichester,WestSussex:Columbia
UniversityPress.
Storey,J.1993. An Introductory Guideto Cultural Theory and PopularCulture.Hemel Hempstead,Hertfordshire:
HarvesterWheatsheaf.
Strinati,D.1995. An Introduction to Theoriesof PopularCulture. London/New York:Routledge.
Tasker,Y. 2002.Fifty Contemporary Filmmakers.London:Routledge.
Zelizer,B.2001. VisualCultureand the Holocaust.London:The Athlone Press.
JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation
Universityof Salford34
Films:
Sollima,S(Director) (1966).The BigGundown.VHS:Unknown.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (2007). Deathproof. DVD.A BandApart Productions.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (1997). JackieBrown.DVD.A Band ApartProductions.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (2003). Kill Bill Vol.1. DVD.A Band ApartProductions.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (2004). Kill Bill Vol.2. DVD.A Band ApartProductions.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (2009). InglouriousBasterds.DVD.A BandApartProductions.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (1994). Pulp Fiction. DVD.A Band ApartProductions.
Tarantino,Q (Director) (1992). ReservoirDogs.DVD.A Band ApartProductions.
Websites:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2003/10/06/quentin_tarantino_kill_bill_volume1_interview.shtml
http://www.filmscoremonthly.com/board/posts.cfm?threadID=68442&forumID=1&archive=0
http://www.tagg.org/udem/musimgmot/filmfunx.html
http://www.villagevoice.com/2009-08-18/news/quentin-tarantino-the-inglourious-basterds-interview/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postmodernist_film

More Related Content

What's hot

Music powerpoint
Music powerpointMusic powerpoint
Music powerpoint
liancymunoz
 
1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre
1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre
1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre
Parnyan
 
The Beatles
The BeatlesThe Beatles
The Beatles
Dendodge
 
The dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rock
The dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rockThe dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rock
The dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rock
heatherseelbach
 

What's hot (19)

Documentary pitch
Documentary pitchDocumentary pitch
Documentary pitch
 
1970's
1970's1970's
1970's
 
Music
MusicMusic
Music
 
70's presentation
70's presentation70's presentation
70's presentation
 
Med332 women and pop
Med332 women and popMed332 women and pop
Med332 women and pop
 
The Beatles (by Montse)
The Beatles (by Montse)The Beatles (by Montse)
The Beatles (by Montse)
 
Street fashion and subculture: past present and future
Street fashion and subculture:  past present and futureStreet fashion and subculture:  past present and future
Street fashion and subculture: past present and future
 
Music powerpoint
Music powerpointMusic powerpoint
Music powerpoint
 
American Musical Theatre
American Musical TheatreAmerican Musical Theatre
American Musical Theatre
 
Dada Futurism Expressionism
Dada Futurism ExpressionismDada Futurism Expressionism
Dada Futurism Expressionism
 
Other(ed) Voices
Other(ed) VoicesOther(ed) Voices
Other(ed) Voices
 
G:\Power Punks
G:\Power PunksG:\Power Punks
G:\Power Punks
 
1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre
1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre
1920’s – 1930’s of Musical Theatre
 
Hippies
HippiesHippies
Hippies
 
The Beatles
The BeatlesThe Beatles
The Beatles
 
The Goth life
The Goth life The Goth life
The Goth life
 
The dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rock
The dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rockThe dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rock
The dark side 2014 – late 60s progressive rock
 
Weekend round up newsletter - may 17 - 19, 2019
Weekend round up newsletter - may 17 - 19, 2019Weekend round up newsletter - may 17 - 19, 2019
Weekend round up newsletter - may 17 - 19, 2019
 
Genre theory in The Pogues & Kirsty MacColl - The fairytale of New York
Genre theory in The Pogues & Kirsty MacColl - The fairytale of New YorkGenre theory in The Pogues & Kirsty MacColl - The fairytale of New York
Genre theory in The Pogues & Kirsty MacColl - The fairytale of New York
 

Similar to Dissertation Final Edit (8)

NITTFest '17 MELAS Quiz
NITTFest '17 MELAS QuizNITTFest '17 MELAS Quiz
NITTFest '17 MELAS Quiz
 
Metalocalypse Paper
Metalocalypse PaperMetalocalypse Paper
Metalocalypse Paper
 
Med332 punk and art rock lecture
Med332 punk and art rock lectureMed332 punk and art rock lecture
Med332 punk and art rock lecture
 
Europavox Festival 2015 review
Europavox Festival 2015 reviewEuropavox Festival 2015 review
Europavox Festival 2015 review
 
Livro
LivroLivro
Livro
 
Newsletter
NewsletterNewsletter
Newsletter
 
Media Sociology M U S I C
Media Sociology  M U S I CMedia Sociology  M U S I C
Media Sociology M U S I C
 
The Beatles Documentary
The Beatles Documentary The Beatles Documentary
The Beatles Documentary
 

Dissertation Final Edit

  • 1. Student:JonathanShelton Course:BA (Hons) PopularMusicology Roll Number:@00259206 Document: Dissertation –‘A Basterdto Analyse:Anexplorationintothe relationshipbetweenmusicandfilminQuentinTarantino’s ‘IngloriousBasterds’ (12,000words) SubmissionDate:May8th , 2013
  • 2. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford1 A BASTERD TO ANALYSE: AN EXPLORATION INTO THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN MUSIC AND FILM IN QUENTIN TARANTINO’S INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS Since the turn of the twentiethcentury,the worldof filmhasbecome one of the mostpopular,accessible and commerciallyvaluable assetsof the cultural industries.Likepopularmusic,cinemahasdevelopedandtransformed greatlyintoa vehicle transportedcommoditisedproduce forglobal audience toenjoyandcherish.Aswithanyformof endeavour,those whopioneertheirspecificfieldbecome celebratedfortheircontributions.Take the audio-visualbody of workby Americandirector/producer/screenwriter/actorQuentinTarantino.Tarantino’sbackcatalogue hasmet enthusiasticcritical acclaimsince hisfirstofficial release of ReservoirDogs in1992 – an unconventional,intense depictionof contemporaryAmericangangsterlife.Subsequentprojectsstabilizedhisreputation,astwoyearson Pulp Fiction amassedglobal recognitionandanarray of prestigiousawards,andsince thenhistacklingof Blaxploitation (JackieBrown) andchanbara cinema(Kill Bill Vol.I & II) eclipse one anotherasTarantino’smostprevalentwork.One can identifyeclecticismwithinTarantino’srepertoire.Whilstexcellingcommercially,Tarantinohasconstructedfilmsthat challenge the conventional practice of cinema.Hisuse andglorificationof violence hasbecome iconicandisa theme referencedcontinuallyregardlessof genre.Hisnon-linearapproachtostructure,interweavingof storylinesandthinly- textureddialogue are consideredasignature uponhisworks.Hiscastingcollaborationsinmostcaseshave beenfruitful (regularlyworkingwithSamuel L.Jackson,UmaThurman,Tim Rothand Michael Madsenamongstsuccessful others), and theyhave inno waybecome stockcharacter and prevailedintheirapproachestochallengingroles. A keyexample of unconventional practice inTarantino’sworksisthe use of musicinhisfilms.Specifically,his use of pre- existingpopularmusicforhisfilmscores. Aninterview in2003 withthe BBC displaysTarantino’smusical approach: “I’ve always thought my soundtracks do pretty good, because they’re basically professional equivalents of a mix tape I’d make for you at home. To me, movies and music go hand in hand. When I’m writing a script, one of the first things I do is find the music I’m going to play for the opening sequence. I can’t go forward until I figure out how I’m going to start – what the opening mood music is going to be1”. In ReservoirDogs,our firstmusical encounterisThe George BakerSelection’s“LittleGreenBag”and itsvisual pairingto the Dogsis constructedastheywalkaway froma dinerintime to the rhythmof the track. In Pulp Fiction, upon 1 http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2003/10/06/quentin_tarantino_kill_bill_volume1_interview.shtml
  • 3. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford2 revealingthe unlawfulprofessionsof HoneyBunnyandPumpkin(burglars) visually,Tarantinoaidstheircause by throwingusintothe highoctane surferrockanthem “Misirlou”byDick Dale and his Deltones. InKill Bill Vol.I, the first track is NancySinatra’s“Bang Bang”, whichassistsin teachingthe audience of the bride (UmaThurman) andshaping the beginningof hernarrative.It’snotjustan introductorytool forTarantino:lookingthroughhissoundtracks,one will findT-Rex (Deathproof),BuddyHolly(Pulp Fiction),DavidBowie (InglouriousBasterds),Stealer’sWheel (ReservoirDogs), BobbyWomack (JackieBrown) anda host of otherexamplesof popularmusic. There are scholarlywritingsonthe musicof Tarantinofilms,butasWojcikand Knightconveyin“SoundtrackAvailable: Essayson PopularMusic andFilm”,they’re notinabundance: “No doubt many readers will be disappointed at not finding specific readings of specific films and soundtracks here: films by Martin Scorsese, Quentin Tarantino and Spike Lee are only the most obvious examples. Apparently new forms of popular film music … still await analysis2 ”. ConsiderTarantino’s2009 World War II thrillerInglouriousBasterds.Itisthe tale of an unconventional Jewish-American secretarmy regiment,whoare droppeddeepbehindenemylinesinNazi-occupiedFrance,withaview toendthe war and slaughterasmanyNazi’salongthe way as possible.Intandemtothis,the Jewish –FrenchDreyfusfamilyare hiding beneathFrenchdairyFarmerPerrierLaPadite’sfloorboards;SSColonel HansLandaextractsthisknowledge fromthe farmeron a routine Nazi visit,beforeinstructinghismentoshootthroughthe floorboardsatthe family.Shoshanna Dreyfus,the daughterof the family,isthe onlysurvivor,andshe fleesintothe fieldsurroundingthe landandisallowed to live byLanda.As the narrative progresses,we findherinParis,underanew name (Emmanuelle Mimieux) andthe proprietorof a modestcinema,whichshe runswithherpartnerMarcel.The climax of the filmisreachedat Shoshanna’s cinema,asPropagandaMinisterJosef Goebbelsholdsthe premieretohisnew film‘A Nation’sPride’there.The film stars FrenchNazi-turned-filmstarFrederickZoller,whoduring hisservice killedthree hundredAmericansoldiersfroma bell towerinItalyanddefeatedthe invasionalmostsingle-handedly.Allthe highestrankingofficersof the Nazisare in attendance atthe premiere;the Basterdsundertake OperationKino,amilitaryoperationintendedtokill all Nazis presentandthusendthe war.ParallelingthisisShoshanna’sownplansof vengeance,asshe intendstoburnall of her nitrate filmatthe premiere,killingall inattendance. AsstandardTarantinopractice,these twostoriesweave intoone 2 Knight & Wojcik. 2001. Soundtrack Available: Essays on Film and Popular Music. DurhamandLondon:Duke UniversityPress.
  • 4. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford3 another,inthe form of five chapters:‘Once Upona Time … InNazi-occupiedFrance’,‘InglouriousBasterds’,‘German NightinParis’,‘OperationKino’and‘Revengeof the GiantFace’. Thisdissertationwill studycertainsongsfromthe soundtrackof InglouriousBasterds.There are several reasonsforthis choice. Initially, whenthisstudybegan,thiswasthe mostrecentTarantinofilmtodate3 . Fromhere,several important discoverieswere made;primarily,the filmdiffersfrompreviousTarantinofilmsinthe representationof characters’ personal interactionwithmusic.The source of The George BakerSelection’s“Little GreenBag”in ReservoirDogs isthe fictional radioshow K-Billy’sSuperSoundsof theSeventies whichthe characterslistentoanddiscussinthe opening scene.Twocharacters in Pulp Fiction visita fictional diner‘JackRabbitSlims’ whichpayshomage tokeyfiguresfrom popularmusicand culture fromdifferentera,suchasBuddyHolly,ElvisPresley,HankWilliams,toname a few;in Kill Bill Vol.II we learnthat the bride’shusband-to-beowns recordstore whichthe pairplanto workin together.The listgoes on; Tarantino’scharactersusuallylike Tarantino’smusic,butthe cultural inclinationsof the charactersof Inglourious Basterds all directto a love of cinema.Notonlya love of cinema,butbarelyanyevidence of musical taste orintereston the character’s behalves.The onlyinstancesinwhichwe see musicinthe worldof the film, or diegetic,are inchapter three (German Nightin Paris):GestapoofficerDieterHellstrom escortsShoshannathroughaNazi restaurantto meet GoebbelsandZollerandwe hearapplause afterRizOrtolani’s‘The Saloon’plays(althoughwe see nosuchperformer), and chapterfour(Operation Kino):the same Gestapoofficerliftsthe needle onarecordplayer,inorderto impose on the dispute betweenthree Basterdswhoare posingasNazisand a Nazi Staff Sargeant.Inchapter three’sreference, theyare meetingtodiscussthe possibilityof holdingtheirpremiereatShoshanna’scinema;chapterfour’sdiegetic example,the staff sergeantandhisregimenthave beengiventhe nightoff tocelebrate the birthof hischild.The Basterdsare there meetingtheirdoubleagent,Germanfilm actressBridgetVonHammersmark;one of the Basterdsis EnglishmanLt.Archie Hiccox,whoprimarilyisassignedthe role forhisabilitytospeakfluentGerman,butalsoas before the war, he was a German filmcritic,havinghadwritingspublishedonthe subject. Anotherkeyreasonforthe choice isthe film’ssettingandera.For once ina Tarantinofilm, we are detailedfromthe beginninginsubtitlesof the yearandcountry we are in;if thischanges,thenwe are toldinsimilarcircumstances.These usuallyappearinbetweenchapters,butthe backdropof WorldWar IImeansthe audience foronce don’treallyneedto know.Thisismost realisticbackdroptoa Tarantinofilminhistory,andthispurelybecause WorldWarII tookplace.We 3 Havingnowbeen succeededby2012 Spaghetti WesternDjango Unchained.
  • 5. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford4 are neverinformedin ReservoirDogs/Pulp Fiction/Jackie Brown etc.of locationortime period.For InglouriousBasterds, we can safelyassume the audience will know the contextto the film.Whilstthe protagonistsare fictional,Tarantino’s depictionsof HitlerandGoebbelsare strikinglysimilartothe authenticimagesthe audience will know of them. Finally,choosingInglouriousBasterds overanyotherTarantinofilmisrational because of the filmssoundtrack.Despite the overtlyreferencedenthusiasmforcinemaoncharacters’behalves,the filmstill hasnearlythirtymusical accompanimentsthroughoutthe fivechapters.Study Figure1.1 inthisdissertation’sappendicesfordetailedevidence of chapterlengthandmusical chapterlengthinthe film.There are several differentsongs,fromseveral different genres,fromseveral differenterasandcountriesinthe soundtrack.RangingfrompopularGermansongsfromthe war era to coversof Ray Charlesto DavidBowie,one cannotargue the vast array of music’sincluded. Furthermore,all of these songsoriginallywere usedinotherfilms –westerns,Germanpropagandafilms,Americanhistorical epicsand erotichorror films,Blaxploitationfilmsetc.Interestingly,none of the musicappearsinEnzoCastellari’s1978 Italianwar filmTheIngloriousBastards,whichshareslittle commonalitywithTarantino’sfilmotherthanthe name and WorldWar II context. METHODOLOGY The limitationsof thisstudycompromisehowmanysongsfromthe filmcanbe analysedeffectively.Therefore, parametersneedtobe installedinordertoexpose the music’sfunctionalityandcapacitytofacilitate thatfunctionali ty. Thisdissertationwill centre onthe ideologyof dualitiespresentwithinthe film’smusic;thismeanssongsthatappear twice inthe film,orif an artist’stracksallude toa particularcharacter or chapter/scene,orif the musicitself refers to anothermusical bodyof work.The decisiontoconstructsuch parametersbecame evidentafterreadingDavidDeacon’s essay Why Counting Counts inResearch MethodsforCulturalStudies.Itencouragesthe use of quantitativeanalysisin cultural studiesandsuggests“reluctanceto engagewith systematiccounting createsanalyticalvaguenessand even internal contradictionsand logicalinconsistencies”.Deaconcontinuestodictate thatcontinuedoppositionagainstthis notioncan have “restrictive implications4 ”.The solidarityofferedinquantitative databalancesthe subsequentmassof theoretical investigationsandconclusions:itaccountsforthe chosentext’sinclusionsandseversandpre -existingties 4 Pickering, M. 2008. Research Methods for Cultural Studies. Edinburgh:EdinburghUniversityPressLtd.
  • 6. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford5 the conductor mayhave harbouredpre-examination.Inastudythat’snumericallylimitedinitliterarycontent,itseems viable toapproachthe music’s inquestionwithasimilarmethodology. Figure 1.2 profilesthe three songsthatappeartwice in InglouriousBasterds;all three will be includedinthe studyas we progress. Thismakesforsix differentanalyses,aseachsongappearsin differentplacesalongthe narrative structure. Eventhoughthese choicesare basednumerically,the lengthof theseexertsandtheirlocationsinvarying chapters provide awiderspectrumthatoriginallyseemedpossiblethroughusingthree songs. Anotherreasontoinclude TheBig Gundown Rare Earth’s‘What’dI Say’ inparticularisthat Rare Earth aren’tthe original composers;the track isa RayCharlescover,althoughthe fragmentutilisedin InglouriousBasterds doesn’tconnotethis as it’sa rhythmicpercussive loopandnothingelse.Whilstthistrackisthe onlycover throughoutthe soundtrack,itis not the onlyone to sample anotherartist’smaterial;the firsttrackof the film, EnnioMorricone’s‘The Verdict (DopoLa Condanna)’referstoaninstantlyrecognisable pianophrase fromBeethoven’sclassic‘FurElise’.Furtheringonfromthis, it originallyappearedinaWesternfilm –SergioSollima’s1966. It isone of eightMorricone songsinthe soundtrack; providingsolidquantitative groundupontobuildatheoretical study. Consequently,twofurtherMorricone songswillbe sampled;the choicesof whichare difficulttodefine.However,the three songsthatappeartwice and‘The Verdict’don’t place enoughfocusonShoshanna,consideringhercentral role tothe film.Uponfurtherinspection,Morricone supports herentrance and exittothe film,whichoccurin oppositional circumstancesandmusicallyare almostthe antithesisof one another.The two textsinquestionare ‘L’incontro Con La Figlia’(The Meeting of the Daughter) and‘Un Amico’(A Friend).The appropriate academicframeworkswhichall these songsare tobe measuredagainstare detailedineach section. JAMESON’S POSTMODERNISMS AND TARANTINO’S MUSIC The aural textsmustbe interrogatedefficiently,inordertofullyexpose theirpurpose andcapacitytofacilitate that purpose.Onlyappropriate modesof enquirymustbe deployed;akeyone isthe conceptof postmodernism.Tarantino has beencelebrated asa postmodernpractitionerbeforeinhiscareer;academically,intextssuchas“The Cambridge CompaniontoPostmodernism5 ”and“PostmodernMusic/PostmodernThought6 ”,andsocio-culturally,with Pulp Fiction 5 Connor, S. 3004. The Cambridge Companion to Postmodernism. Cambridge: Cambridge UniversityPress. 6 Auner &Lochhead. 2002. Postmodern Music Postmodern Thought. London/New York: Routledge.
  • 7. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford6 beingclassedassuchwebsitessuchas‘Wikipedia7 ’.Reliabilityof the lattersource isquestionable,butsuchanotion doesexist–of hisfilmsandtheirmusic.Thisisbecause Tarantino’snon-linearnarrativesare confusedfurtherby contrastingmusical accompaniments,suchasthe ‘ear-chopping’sceneinReservoirDogs,whichisaurallysupportedby ‘Stuckin the Middle withYou’byStealer’sWheel,orin Pulp Fiction where Mia overdosesonherointoUrge Overkill’s ‘Girl,You’ll be a WomanSoon’amongstotherexamples. Postmodernismisachallengingconcepttograspand apply,sointroductorytextssuchasBarry Smart’s“Postmodernity: KeyIdeas8 ”and Bestand Kellner’s“PostmodernTheory:Critical Interrogations9 ”are ideal preliminaryreadings.They presentthe differencesof modernismtopostmodernismandthe periodwherepostmodernismcame tofruition,and leadonto shape the thoughtsof relevantwritersonthe subject.Take FredricJameson;Jameson’swritingson postmodernisminline withpopularculture are integral tothe discourse. “Postmodernism:The Cultural Logicof Late Capitalism10 ”and“PostmodernismandConsumerSociety11 ”are dialecticworksfrom livingmemoryandare considered amongstthe most importantwritingssince the publicationsof The FrankfurtSchool. Inthe latter,Jamesondeclares: “Radical breaks between periods do not generally involve complete changes of content, but rather the restructuration of a certain number of elements alreadygiven: features that in an earlier period or system were subordinate now become dominant and features that had been dominant again become secondary”. Jameson,withregardtofilm,continuestodeclare thatrealistcontentseldomappears. “If there is any realism left here, it is a "realism" which springs from the shock of grasping that confinement and of realizi ng that, for whatever peculiar reasons, we seem condemned to seek the historical past through our own pop images and stereotypes about that past, which itself remains forever out of reach”. Theoretically,Jamesonargueshispersonallyconceptualised“nostalgiafilm”,whichAnne Friedburgsummarisesinher text“WindowShopping:Cinemaandthe Postmodern12 ”: 7 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postmodernist_film 8 Smart, B. 1993. Postmodernity: Key Ideas. London:Routledge. 9 Best & Kellner. 1991. Postmodern Theory: Critical Interrogations. London:MacmillanEducationLtd. 10 Jameson, F. 1991. Postmodernism:The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism. Durham:Duke UniversityPress. 11 Jameson, F. 1998. The Cultural Turn: Selected Writings on the Postmodern 1983 – 1998. London/NewYork:Verso. 12 Friedburg, A. 1993. Window Shopping: Cinema and the Postmodern. Berkeley/Los Angeles/London:Universityof California Press.
  • 8. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford7 “Although Jameson doesn’t perform an exact taxonomy, his descriptions divide the ‘nostalgia film’ into: 1) Films that are about the past and set in the past (‘Chinatown’, ‘American Graffiti’) 2) Films that ‘reinvent’ the past (‘Star Wars’, ‘Raiders of the Lost Ark’) 3) Films that are set in the present but invoke the past (‘Body Heat’; we could add ‘Miami Vice’, ‘Moonlighting’, ‘Batman’)” The firstand secondof the three couldbothcategoricallydefine InglouriousBasterds;the secondinparticularmirrors the film’sremouldingof the endof the warand constructionsof those whoendit.Jameson’spostmodernismsasa whole have alsobeenclassified - these canbe foundinhiswritingsorinother postmodernisttexts,suchas“Crisis Cinema:The ApocalypticIdeainPostmodernNarrative Film”: “(Jameson’s postmodernisms) as the following: [1] Postmodernism is misunderstood. [2] Its tenuous unity is evident only in its opposition to high modernism. [3] It designates an erosion of distinctions between high and low art. [4] It effaces genre conventions. [5] It is ahistorical. [6] It models on the multitude of intersections between art and the cultural conditions of late capitalism. [7] In its seeming randomness, it simulates an undifferentiated (schizophrenic) world vision13”. It isagainstthese measurementsthatthe textsinquestionwill be analysedinordertodeterminetheirpostmodernist potency.Reappropriating‘postmodernism’withinthesearticlestostandfor‘aural text’will subsequentlyreveal the identityof the songsusedinthe film. THE VERDICT (DOPO LA CONDANNA) – ENNIO MORRICONE It isplausible topropose thatthere are active mechanismsof postmodernismatthe beginningof the film;Lisa Coulthardin“QuentinTarantino’s‘InglouriousBasterds’:A Manipulationof Metacinema”qualifies: “(this) temporal distension and affective intensification are particularly prominent in the opening sequence, which is in many ways the most ‘Western’ chapter in the film … “The Verdict” from ‘The Big Gundown’ slowly rises in the mix to dominate the sequence until the music fades into the car engine motor as it reaches the farmhouse. Time is expansive; the car seems to approach as slowly as a man on horseback – that iconic image seen in the distance at the beginning of innumerable Westerns14.” We are onlya minute intothe filmbeforeCoulthard’sobservationsunfold;apostmodernistlandscapeisshapedforthe musical’sarrival.‘The Verdict’appearsforsixtysevenseconds,andreferencesthe introductoryphrase of Beethoven’s ‘Fur Elise’.The vignette bookendsthe piece,withtwoidentical examplesinbetween. Unlikethe original,inwhichthe 13Sharrett, Christopher. 1993. Crisis Cinema:The Apocalyptic Idea in Postmodern Narrative Film. WashingtonDC:Maisonneuve Press 14 Dassanowsky, R. V. 2012. Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds:A Manipulation of Metacinema. New York/London:Continuum International Publishing Group.
  • 9. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford8 melodyparallelsthe metronomicrhythm,Morricone’salterationsdenote slightaccelerationanddecelerationof the motif whichismarginallyextended.The adjustmentstotempocause momentsof bathosthatresolve calmly, butthisis mostevidentwhenthe visual backdropisremoved –otherwise the musicagitatesthe alreadyperturbedfamily.The pianocomponentisrecognisabletoall;BarryCooper’sbiographyof Beethoventellsusthat“the melodyand accompanimentof ‘FurElise’evoke anappropriate moodforintense longing15 ”.Originallythe longingwasfeltby Beethoventowardsafemale,butthe longingisreshapedbythe filmtoaimforpeace. ThisgravitatesCoulthard’snotion of time expansionand confirmsthatthe song’ssupportisaimedatthe protagonists,the LaPadite farmers.The family and the musiccrystallise the globallysharedlongingharbouredbyNazi oppressorsforpeace duringthe war. Theoreticallywe canchallenge Tarantino’suse of the trackas a postmodernismof Jameson’s,onthe basisof itsprimary functionasfilmmusic(aWesterntrack).Morricone too can be assessedasa postmodernistcollaboratorbyrealigning an esteemedmusical landmarkintofilmmusic. There are otherforms of instrumentation.Three of the fourpianorunsare followedbystylisticallySpanishacoustic guitarmovements;the guitarthensucceededbymilitary-styledpercussionrollsinterwovenwithanequallysovereign hornedsection.The immediate guitaralso hasirregularmomentsmelodically –itbeginsandveryquicklypauses,before flourishingitssolopartfor the remainderof the section. The gapsthisprovidesare filledbyevocative camerashots fromvaryinganglesof the farmer,hisdaughterand the approachingNazis,whichare tailoredtoheightenourremorse for the protagonists.We neverapproachthe house withthe Nazis;we onlyobservetheirapproachfromthe farm, whichlocatesourmusical experience inthe foregroundof the LaPadite’semotions.The majorityof close shotsfocuson the father,conveyingthathe will be the characterto engage withthe Nazi’sregardlessof the reasonfortheirvisit. The third fragmentof instrumentationemitscombatantconnotations,andreinforcesthe militaristiccontrol overthe scene.The percussive elementssitsecondarydynamically tothe melismatichornswhichfinisheachfragmentwitha sustainedresolvingnote.Theycontrastthe fluidityof the precedingguitarandpianomovementsthroughthe prolonged trumpets,andare stabilisedbyshortrepeatedrollsonasnare drum.This is the onlysectiontobe bracedwith percussion,andparamusical referencestothe rhythmof these sectionsare made visually;the fathercementshisaxe intoa tree stumpone beatafterthe snare roll,embodyingthe pugnaciousovertoneof the scene.During anotherof these phrases,the fatherdemandshisdaughters goinside,andisseenfromalow angle withthe cameralookingup, 15 Cooper, B. 2000. Beethoven. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • 10. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford9 alludingtothe nobilitythe sectionemotivelyprovides.The piece endswithanotherpianoexert,where the farmerwalks towards hishouse calmly,withthe tree stumpandlodgedaxe inthe foreground.Thisvisuallysolidifiesthe harsh unchangeable eventstocome,andaurallydisplaysthe fatherwhohasnow peacefullysuccumbedtothe likelynegative outcome of the Nazi’svisit. Firstly,we canexamine Tarantino’suse of suchmusicandidentifyanyparallelswithJameson’spostmodernisms.We can alsoindividuallyqueryMorricone’scompositional values.Conclusivelythere are supportiveattributesforboth enquiries;onTarantino’s part,the stylisticdifferencesof eachsectioninthe musicare mirroredon screenemotionally, but inbetweenshotsof the Nazi’sapproach(correctlyacclaimedtoalludetoWesternfilmpracticesbyCoulthard).The typicalityof Westernfilm’sintroductorysequenceshoweverdoesnotmatchthatof the genericworldwartwofilm;the oppositionalforcesthatwouldmeetinaWesternfilmare dramatizedandsharpfocusisplacedon the forcesrather than the contact. The accompanyingmusic,however,uniteswiththe visual Westernconnotationsdue toitspre-existing connectiontothe Westerngenre. An erosionof distinctionsbetween‘high’and‘low’artcan be foundinthe differentgenre andstylesthatall three musical segmentscome from,andforsimilarreasoningwe cancollate the trackto achievingahistoricityandeffacing genre conventions.The lattercanalsobe heldagainstTarantinoandMorricone,the formerforusinga Westerntrack and the latterfor usingBeethoveninaWesterntrack.We couldsuggestthose differencesentwinedwiththe song’s original filmicpurpose alsorepresentaschizophrenicvision,andthatTarantinovisuallyconnotesthisbyimitatingthe stylesof Westernfilms. SLAUGHTER – BILLY PRESTON ‘Slaughter’assertsitsauthorityimmediatelythroughthe instantthudof the distortedelectricguitarriff and instantaneouslyshapesourunderstandingof BasterdHugoStiglitz.Whenwe firstmeethim, we receivethe storyof his joiningthe Basterds.Asitbegins,the cameracatches himsmirkinginthe centre of the shotbefore anunexpectedflash on the screenof hisname in comical font.It masksthe foregroundandwe are leftwithStiglitz’headabove the lettering.Inamomentarysilence inbetweenthe riff playingagain,the view changestoa Germannewspaperfrontpage whichfillsthe screen;alarge picture of Stiglitzsitsonthe leftunderneaththe mastheadandsubhead,andtothe right tworows of six much smallerheadshots.AsSamuel L.Jacksonnarrates,Stiglitz’infamyamongstNazi’sisbecause asa
  • 11. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford10 Germanenlistedman,he killedthirteenGestapoofficers.The picture thenfillsoutbyfocussingonthe largerpicture of Stiglitzbefore we seegoreydetailedaccountsof some of hisvictims(typical of Tarantino’sultra-violenttendency).For thispart, the track movespastthe electricguitarintroductoryriffingintoitscontrastingfunk-drivenverse andchorus. Thisdescriptionof Stiglitz’lifepre-Basterdsiswithinascene alreadyactingasa memory – as Nazi Private Butzinforms Hitlerof the Basterd’sambushon hisregiment.‘Slaughter’playsforthirtysevenseconds,duringwhichwe don’tsee Stiglitzinthe presenttense of the scene,otherthanhisheadabove the font. The text’spurpose andsurroundingschange whenwe come acrossitagainin ‘OperationKino’.Itstill profilesStiglitz, but hisdifferent,negative emotionsare nowendorsedbythe music.Initiallyhisaudacioussmile almostcreatedhumour inconjunctionwiththe music,buthere,visuallywe receive Stiglitzstaringangrily (OperationKinohasbeendisruptedby the presence of Gestapooffice DieterHellstrom,whichangersStiglitz).There are nodistractionsbetweenStiglitz’ emotive bodylanguage andthe roughtone of the musicthistime,unlike theirpreviousdivide of the large comical font. The audioand the visualsshare a strongerbondand theybothdenote angerandensure vengeance isthe catalystfor howthe scene unfolds.The musicbecomesthe mainaural focusasthe dialogue fromthe Gestapoofficerfadesout,and we then enteranothermemory.Stiglitz,tiedtoapost,topless,and beingwhippedrepetitivelywithvisible steamrising fromthe freshwounds,inagony.Underneaththe crackof the whipandthe guitar riff,there’sapoundingdouble hitof a bass drumwhichcouldrepresenthisheartrate inboth the scenesthe musichasservedinthischapter.The whipping inthe montage isfairlyregular,andthisrhythmicqualityisextendedwhenwe returntothe tavernandthe Gestapo officerpatsStiglitzonthe torsoto get his attention. Primarily,‘Slaughter’profilesStiglitz;inbothinstancesthe visual mirrorthe audio(‘Slaughter’andStiglitzinharmony) and therefore onthe secondoccasionthe audience associate the songasa motif forthe character.Furthermore,he is the onlyBasterdwe are givenaninsighttothe historyof,whichmostwouldfindstandarddue tohisconflicting appearancesinthe Germanand Americanarmy.But Stiglitzisnotthe leaderof the Basterds.He isn’ta founding member;theywenttohim and enquiredforhisservices.Beforethen,Stiglitzviolentlyopposedthe Nazi regimeof his ownaccord, whilstcompromisingadifficultmilitaryposition.Notonlywashe initiallyaNazi and thena Basterd,he then pretendstobe a Nazi in chapterfour (OperationKino).He diesinaNazi uniform, actingasa Nazi,withan Austrianwho neverwasenlistedbythe Germans,andanEnglishman(the firstwe’veseensofar) masqueradingasa Nazi withan unconvincingaccent.Stiglitz’lastlineinthe filmis“saygoodbye toyourNazi balls”aftera cue fromHiccox,and thenhe
  • 12. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford11 deliversthe firstof manyblowsaimedat DieterHellstrom.InStiglitz’firstmusical cue,he wasthe killerwho ‘slaughtered’everyonehe possiblycould.The seconddemonstratedStiglitz startsthe ‘slaughtering’butdoesnot survive. WHAT’D I SAY – RARE EARTH With‘What’dI Say’,we are showncontrastingemotionsagainbutfromthe same momentintime;the contrastsare embodiedbythe Basterds andShoshannaandMarcel,and theirdifferentapproachestoundertakingtheirplans.The firsttime we hearthe exert,we’ve justseenDonny(The BearJew) getuptoleave the auditorium;whenthe music beginsthe cameraisopposite the double doorstothe cinema. He walksright,pastthe camera, andwe thenliftupand meethimat the top of the rightstaircase.We watch Donnywalkthroughdoor frame,andour nextangle isfromhis perspective,peeringaroundawall viewingthe guardsoutside Hitler’sprivatebalcony.We swivel one hundredand eighty degreesandsee Donny’sface forasplitsecond,before spinningbacktosee Hitlercome outfrom hisbalcony. We returnto Donny’sface,whichpresentsdisbelief andexcitement.He disappears;musicstops. Secondslater, Donny retrieves Omarfromthe auditorium(whocomicallyfallsoveranddrawsmuch Nazi attention, whilstfeigninganItalianaccent).The musicstartsagain at the openingof the doors.We are setmuchfurtherback and followthemfromalowangle as theyquicklyascendthe staircase. Ourassociationsof DonnyandOmarwiththistrack are thenconfused,asournextshotis of Shoshannafromthe projectionroom, lookingoutintothe cinema.Marcel arrivesbehindher,tellsherthattime isupon them;she turns,and instantlygetsemotional.Theyembrace,andkiss,for several secondswhilstShoshanna’snervesincrease.Marcel then leaves,andShoshannais cryingandgasping.Donny and Shoshanna’sactionscontrast;Donnyiseager forthe actionto beginandhurriestoget Omar; Shoshannalatches ontoMarcel and theirmomentof passionisextended.Afterthiswe see Marcel comingoutontothe top of the lobby, comingdownthe opposite staircase thatDonnyandOmar wentup.Holdingtwopoles,we see himopenone of the doorsto the cinema,where (onscreen)Zolleriscarvinga swastikaintothe floor,whichismetbycheering;the music stops. The music inthese twoscenesisidentical.The sectioninquestionisthe song’sending –it couldbe heard underneath otherinstrumentationatearlierpartsof the track but here itis isolated.The strophicsectionsmirrorthe passagesin ‘Slaughter’;bothtracksappeartwice withthe same andadditional charactersandtime isvisuallydistorted. Further
  • 13. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford12 contrastscan be foundvisually;The Basterdsmasquerade cinemaindustryworkers,whereasatthe startof chapterfive we see Shoshannaapplyingmake upwithtribal undertonesthroughout.Atsome points,the combatantbecomethe hostsand vice versa,all to the same timelessrhythmicloopfroma Rare Earth’scover,not Ray Charles’original.Broadly speaking,ShoshannaalsohasparallelstoStiglitz –we receive ahistoryof bothand the catalystsfortheirnow destructive behaviour;theybothattimesappease Nazi superiority,andtheybothdie atthe handsof those they’re up against.Shoshanna’sdeathoccursinstrangercircumstances,asher final kissiswithMarcel (whomthe narrative deems as her partner) practicallyonthe same spotas her restingplace,nexttoNazi filmstarFredrikZoller.Shoshannashoots Zoller, the starof A Nation’sPridedue to hismarksmanship;before Stiglitzkills DieterHellstrom,he saysfromclose range,he’sthe real ‘FredrikZoller’,eventhoughthe real FredrikZollerisshotinhis deathscene fromclose range. Furthermore,whenwe follow DonnyandOmaringreatdetail upthe stairs,we must remembertheyare onlythere due to the deathof Stiglitz,Hiccox and WilhelmWicki;Stiglitzwasmeanttobe there. Thisisimportantbecause sofar we’ve seentime visuallydistortedbyStiglitz’themesong‘Slaughter’andby‘What’dI Say’,yetif OperationKinohadn’tfailed inthe tavern,itwouldbe Stiglitzwhopreparedtokill the Nazi’salongto‘What’dI Say’. Linkingall these unearthedvisual relationshipsisthe style of the musicthatsupportsthem.Bothhave sectionslooped on bothoccasions,andin all fourinstancesthisalludestothe distortionof time visually. Consideringthe time lapseof the twosongs,itcouldbe arguedthat the tracks efface genericconventionsof filmmusic practise:Inan essaystudyingmotificmusicanditsvisual counterpart,ClaudiaGorbmanobservesthe Gyorgi Ligetipiano musicinStanleyKubrick’s‘EyesWide Shut’: “ … A suspense cue with its insistence on the semitone and on the spectral creepiness of octaves played deep in the bass … in all five scenes scored with the Ligeti, Bill’s complacency is strongly shaken, and in one way or another he is unmasked or gripped with shame16.” There are novariablesinGorbman’sdiscussion,whichtherefore reinforcesBill’sretributionsiseasilydone byusingthe same musiccontinually.Inourstudieshoweverwe have foundthatdissectingthe song’sstructure encouragesdifferent musical pointstoreferto differentthings.However, theycan’tactmotificallyif asegmentonlyappearsonce,andif visual increasesordecreasesintime are presentthenthe musicisn’ttruly representingwhatwe see everytime.Forthe same reasonwe can qualifyamisunderstandingof the narrative,andahistoricityisachievedbyusingsongsfromafter the war to supportthe fictional oppressorsof Nazism inawidelyfictionalscenario.A schizophrenicvisionisofferedto 16 Donnelly, K. J. 2001. Film Music:Critical Approaches. New York/London:Continuum International Publishing Group
  • 14. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford13 us bythe opposite viewpointswe receivefromdifferentcharactersall aimingtokill the ThirdReichthroughthe same track (‘What’dI Say’).Oppositiontohighmodernismcouldbe demonstratedbythe prolongedpassionShoshannaand Marcel share,despite the gravityandhuge implicationstheirpreferredoutcomewouldhave (inthe worldof the film). The longevityof the embrace wouldn’tbe emphasizedwere itnotforthe musicand itscontrastingnotionof time elsewhere inthe film. LARSEN’S DICHOTOMY: CHARLES BERNSTEIN’S ‘WHITE LIGHTNING’ ‘Slaughter’and‘What’dISay’ accountfor two of three songsthat feature twice inthe film.The thirdisCharles Bernstein’s‘WhiteLightning’,originallythe openingtheme forJosephSargent’s1973 film White Lightning (also appearinginTarantino’s Kill Bill Vol.I).In InglouriousBasterds,the trackbookendsaretrospective scene thatstems fromNazi Private Butz’recallingtoHitlerof the Basterdsambushonhis regiment.The scene isthe thirdof three in chaptertwo (‘InglouriousBasterds’),having firstmetAldoRaine andhismenthroughtheirunconventional military briefing,andthenseenHitler’sangeratthe Basterds’growingreputationamongsthissoldiers.ErnoRapée dictatesthat “as longas you varyyour instrumentationoryourtonalityit will notgettiresome17 ”.Rapée’saccountsare hugelydated (1924) but we can still contesthisnotionsthroughthe musical passagesin‘WhiteLightning’.The trackconstitutes several differentinstrumentsfromdifferentculturesthatplayinunisonandoccasionallywarrantasolopart, in conjunctiontothe otherinstruments.The vastarrayof instrumentscontestsRapée’sconceptaswe have awider selectionof passagestochoose from.Bernsteintestifiesthatforthe compositionof the songhe hiredsome of the best countrymusiciansinAmericaatthe time (the original film‘White Lightning’issetisArkansas,southernAmerica)18 .The track’s bookendingof ourfirstinsighttothe Basterd’smethodsplacesitatthe start andbeginningof asmallernarrati ve structure;the scene’sdepictionof the Basterdsatwork ismemorable foritsultra-violenttone andpassive-aggressive dialogue.Thisensures the audience will rememberthe scene as itsownentity,aswell aswithin inthe greaternarrative strand.The interrogativeelementsof the Basterd’smissionsare vital toprofilingtheirstatusandsuperiorityoverNazis inthe film;the wide arrayof instrumentationsin‘White Lightning’mirrorsthe multiplicityof scenesitservesfor. 17 Rapée, Erno. 1974 (originally1924). Motion Picture Moods for Pianists and Organists. New York:Arno Press. 18 http://www.filmscoremonthly.com/board/posts.cfm?threadID=68442&forumID=1&archive=0
  • 15. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford14 PeterLarsen’s‘FilmMusic’(2005) isa recenttextthatassessesthe problemsof musicfilmanalysis,beforeproposinga model andapplyingitamongstotherwritings.Hisdiscursive chapter‘AnalysingFilmMusic’determinesadichotomyof analysisisrequired: “It will concentrate on the mutual relations between the individual elements and on the function of the elements in the totality”. ConceptuallyforLarsen,“actual,thoroughanalysesof the functionsof filmmusicinparticularfilmsisrare”,and“film musicisfunctional music– musicwhose structure hasbeendeterminedbyfactorsthatlie outside the musicitself19 ”. Larsennominatesthatbasicissuesof musicandcinemacan be tackledsimilarlyastheyfocusonsimilarcomponents – segmentation,motifictendency,expectationsof the audience,narrativethreadingetc.Larsenequatesthatasmusic analysisandfilmanalysis,intheirmostprimitive forms,share terminology,methodandlimitations,itisessential to understandhowa track runsfundamentallywithoutanarrative,visual backdrop,before reinstatingthatbackdropand measuringthe findingsagainstthe scenery.Forthisensuinganalysis,thismethodwillbe exercised.The musicwill be interrogatedasmusic,the track’swide soundscape providingthe basisforselectingthisparticulartrack.Subsequentlyit will be studiedwiththe preliminaryfindingsagainstthe visual backdropitadheresto –the differentmomentsof sceneryaffordingourchoice forpickingthe musicfromthe scene. ‘White Lightning’issegmented;initiallythe instrumentsbuilduponone another,before all stoppingandallowingsolo movementsinthe silence fordifferentthreadsof the musical fabric.The firstsoundwe hearisa bass guitarpluckingat a moderate tempo,fromG (3) downa fifthtoC, thena secondto B♭,before the minorthirddescenttothe lowerG octave.The latterG note resonatesbefore routinelyperformingthe riff again,andafteronce aroundthe riff the quick tappingof a hi –hat. The rhythm sectionisthenlayered withirregularlyplacedbongo/tom-likedrums,andthenthe melodicbassislayeredwithaslide guitar,scalingthe Gminorpentatonicscale.Again,the rhythmrespondswith additional hi-hathitsthatstandalone alongeachbar,withgrowingemphasisonthe tomsunderneathit –one resonatingsimilarlytoasnare.Unexpectedlythe followingadditionisanechoedbreathe-likegasp,andthenthe slide guitarrollsaroundthe pentatonicscale again.Thisisthirtyfive secondsin,andthe echoemittedfromthe vocal and resoundingtomsemphasisesthe vastspace the songis in.A breakdowntriggeredbyasolitarypianochordrevealsa sustained,highregisteringwoodwindblowthatisparticularlyintimidatingonce itcollideswithalow minorpianochord. 19 Larsen, P. 2005. Film Music. London:ReaktionBooks Ltd
  • 16. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford15 Then, a panoramicsnare-like roll,shakingof maracas,and furtherslide guitarall individuallyperform.Subsequentlya similarbuildupentails,thistime withthe additionfromthe startof the new sectionof the ironicallynamedjewharp, whichgoeson to configure asolopositioninthe succeedingbreakdown. The advantage of employingthissonganditsassociatedscenesasobjectsof Larsen’smethodologyisthatthe scope of instrumentsfullyoptimizesthe individual andcombinedcomponents’relationships; toequallysingularorcollective aspectsof the scene’sindividual narrative withinthe film’stotality.Forthe firstscene,the musicbeginsvisuallybehind the lateraffirmedPrivate Butz,whoisbeingescortedupastaircase bytwo Nazi staff.We hear himbefore we see his face,as the ensuingconversationwithHitlerbeginsbefore we jointhemvisually;the slide guitarisaudible but underneaththe dominantdialogue.He detailsthe survivorsof the ambushbefore the recollectioncomesalive,ashe describes‘removingthe hair’;anunknownBasterd’sknife isskimmingthroughadeadNazi’sscalpinunnervingfashion. As the drumrollsbeginsthe viewgoestothe three survivedNazisare marshalleddownpastthe leftof ourscreen. The seconddeploymentof ‘White Lightning’alsobeginsinButzandHitler’sdialogue,before again carrying us back into Butz’s memory. Butz, translator Wicki and Aldo are stood left to right, with a map between Butz and Aldo. Aldo’s questions,the translationandthe answers are followedbythe camera. The jovial questioning of what Butz plans to do when he gets home, and what he intends to do with his uniform, profile the fear Butz has and the Basterd’s darkly humorous tone as its antithesis. The slide guitar plays when Aldo asks his questions, linking the two regionally and authoritatively,due tothe guitar’sprominence inthe song and Aldo’s Basterd rank. Bathos is created by filling the gap betweenWicki’stranslationsandAldo’ssarcasticcommentswiththe panoramicsnare roll onboth occasions. However, the conversation intensifies and Aldo stands up as the bass re-joins (solidifying his balance on the scene) and steps toward Butz, which pushes him out of shot. The aural response is to introduce the jew harp into proceedings, which fundamentallycontradictsthe growingtensioninitsplayfullylax stretches.However,the unconventional sound stands out, as it balances on a typically rockabilly/rock ‘n’ roll rhythmic foundation. The sound mirrors the pacey and broad accent of Aldo,whose intentionsandauthorityare transpiringnow he’sstoodup.ItalsoparallelsAldo’sunconventional military approach, particularly his request for “one hundred Nazi scalps” and the scarring of any survivors. Claudia Gorbman, in ‘Unheard Melodies’, highlights that film music “bonds spectator to spectacle, it envelops spectator and
  • 17. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford16 spectacle ina harmonious place20 ”; ‘White Lightning’ begins to aid the divide between Nazi and Basterd, and enables the audience toallude toBasterd ideology, despite seeing this through the eyes of a Nazi. Aldo informs us he doesn’t like Naziswhotake off their uniform, as their Nazi identity is concealed. Wicki begins to relay to Butz, and flute eerily glides above the dialogue, representing Butz’s growing fears. The solution is to give him something he can’t remove, indicatedasscarringthroughAldo’sviciousraisingof hisknife.Asthisisstated, the guitar plays, and its genre and style cementsRaine’spowerinthe scene.ThisisachievedthroughreferencinghisrootsinsouthernAmerica, and paralleling the Lieutenant’s dominance byappearingcentral tothe totalityof itsownbackdrop.The track’sindividual soloing parts have thus far served for different emotions of oppositional characters but predominantly outlined the Basterd’s supremacy in the Nazi memory. We return to view Hitler, whose shock is evident, before we then turn to Butz’ forehead, where a swastika scar sits. Our return to the memory is set through Butz’ view, which has Donny and Aldo above him, with Aldo’s knife with a minute drop of blood on the blade. Donny compliments the scarring, and Aldo responds: “You know how to get to Carnegie Hall, don’t ya? … Practice.” The jewharp thenresoundsinthe visual successionintodarkness,beginning ata higherregisteranddroppingtoa lowerone swiftly;itembodieslaughterorchortlingatRaine’sthrowawayresponse,before the scene andchaptercome to a close.The musicbarelychangesforthe transition,asthe jew harpringsaroundthe emptyvisual space withthe guitarand bass underneathit.Afterwe’reinformedof the nextchapterandthe year,the instrumentationstopsasthe flute returns;thisplaysasa camera pansverticallydownacinema,pasta circular window whichagirl walkspast,and eventuallyshe meetsusatthe bottomentrance of the cinema.She comesoutside,andthe bassand guitarhave just come back intothe mix.She beginschangingthe lettersaroundthe bannerfrontingabove the cinemadoors,beforethe musicends,and“ShoshannaDreyfus:FourYearsAfterthe Massacre of herFamily”flashesuponthe screen. The ambiguityof thischaracter’sidentityiscodedatthroughthe visual andaudiopatternsonce again;we see herfora splitsecond,walkingahead,pastthe circularwindow.Fromthe topon the cinemaview andpastthiswindow,the constantwoodwindnote resonates,onlytobe replacedwiththe less tense guitarlineswhenshe comesoutside. Althoughwe don’tknowatthispointwhoshe is,we can predict heridentityandnarrative through the music;the similarityinscore betweenAldoandthe Basterdsinstilsasubconscioustrustwiththe female character.Furthermore,in 20 Gorbman, C. 1987. Unheard Melodies:Narrative Film Music. Bloomington:Universityof Indiana Press.
  • 18. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford17 betweenthe twoplaying’sof ‘White Lightning’,Raine commentstothe soon-to-be-deadNazi SergeantRachtmannthat watchingDonny(The BearJew) clubbingGermanstodeathis“the closestanyof (them) gettogoin’to the movies”;the scene endswithDonnyandAldocentral to the shotfrom Butz,before we arrive ata cinema. Isolationof the musical textandsubsequentexaminationdictatesthatthe track ismade up of both contrastingand similarinstruments,withsimilardiscontinuityfoundwithinthe timbreof those instruments –phrasing,length,tone, and presence withinthe totalityof the track.These individualelementsandtheirrole inthe track’stotalitycompliment the singularityof the Basterds inthisscene.Asa whole,‘White Lightning’isaBasterdstrack, but the separate musical featuresequate tothe Basterd’sseparate charactersandtheirNazi counterpartsinthe scene.Aldoinparticularis activelybeingprofiledbysingle instrumentativeexamples,whereasotherkeymemberssuchasDonnyeithertie into that ideologyorhave theirown(whenhe emergesfromthe cave to‘The Surrender’byEnnioMorricone,andBilly Preston’s‘Slaughter’actingtorepresentHugoStiglitzmusically).If we heardthese instrumentsontheirown,they wouldconnote paramusical ideasandemotions.Forexample, fear,throughthe highestregistering,highlysustained flute;regionally,the slide guitaranditsmovementscrystalliseAldo’sownrootsandideologies;bathosfromthe jew harp thencommendsbothAldo’sunconventional militaryapproachandhissarcastic,anticlimactictone andsense of humour. ENNIO MORRICONE AND SHOSHANNA DREYFUS The majorityof textsconsideredthusfarsurroundthose whooppose Nazismin‘InglouriousBasterds’;onlyonce,in Morricone’s‘DopoLa Condanna’have we dissectedmusicthatprofiledthe threatandauthorityharbouredbythe Nazis. Otherwise thisstudyhasfocusedelsewhere,mostlyonthe Basterdsthemselves.Cinematically,anglingthe study towards the film’sJewishheroine ShoshannaDreyfushasn’toccurred abundantly.She epitomisesthe face of Jewish vengeance inthe final chapter‘Revenge of the GiantFace’,aftera lengthyprocessof editingthe reel to A Nation’sPride so that she answersZoller’squestion“Whowantstosenda message toGermany?”with“I want to senda message to Germany… thatyou are all goingto die.”Subsequentlythe cinemaburnsdownandthe Basterdsattendingthe premiere shooteveryonefromHitler’sbalcony(aftershootinghim, Goebbelsandthe translatorFrancesca).Thisdisplay of determinationisthe antithesisof howwe initiallyperceiveShoshanna –weak,coveredinherfamily’sblood,
  • 19. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford18 aimlesslyrunningawayfromthe LaPadite farm.Herdevelopmentthroughoutthe film more thanjustifiesstudyingher musical underpinnings. The final proposal of enquirywill seektounderstandMorricone’srole inshapingthe audience’sreadingof Shoshanna; withparticularemphasisuponherarrival intothe filmandherdeparture,both underscoredbyMorricone. L’INCONTRO CON LA FIGLIA (THE MEETING OF THE DAUGHTER) Jeff Smith,in‘The Soundsof Commerce:MarketingPopularFilmMusic’locatesthat‘Morricone’spragmatismand eclecticism allowed him to function within a numberof commercialmusic contexts21 ’;hisabilitytocreate polysemicfilm music’sonmany occasionsunderlinesthisclaim.The twotextstobe analysedfurtherthis astheyare the antithesisof one another.Ourfirst,‘L’incontroConLa Figlia’(‘The Meetingof the Daughter’)’sascensionindynamicsalludestothe creationof fearand terror; the scramblingviolinsthatbeginnearthe startof the track are reminiscentof ‘Flightof the Bumblebee’,withoutanyobviousmotifsoperating.Sustainingoverthe topof the stringsectionisa Frenchhorn, internallypedallingthe note.Itdoesn’tsoundsolo;aviolasoundstobe playinginunisonandaddinggravitastothe sound.The tensionisdirectlyincreasedbythe faintcrashesof cymbalsheardinthe backgroundfromfortysix seconds in– theydon’tforefrontthe mix oract rhythmicallytoatiming.Fromhere,the sustainedroll onasnare (withall its militaryconnotations) canbe heardunderneaththe stringsandhorns,before we getto01:05 where the hornsand snare stop,before re-joiningthreesecondslatertoperformthe track’scrashingmovement.The hornbeginsatone lower,andissupportedbythe higherE octave note inlowerregisteredstringsandhorns.Itsplayingresonatesaround the track and contradictsthe shimmeringandstill scramblingviolinsunderneathit,thatare settledata higherregister withrepeatedtonal dropsata fasttempo.We are now intothe secondhalf of the track, whichisledbythe stomping riffsof lowerbrassinstrumentssuchasthe bass tuba.The forefrontof the track issharedbetweentheselowbrass instrumentsandafalsettochoirthat act out a descenteachtime they’re heard.The lowerbrassisreplacedbytrumpets that alsorecur arounda riff before (like the lowerbrassbefore it) pedallingthe finalnote. This track not onlyintroducesShoshanna,butalsothe twistedinterrogative methodsof Landaandthe obedience inflictedthroughoutNazi ranks.Italsoprofilesthe angstandpainof LaPadite,whose Englishconversation withLanda 21 Smith, J. 1998. The Sounds of Commerce:Marketing Popular Film Music. New York/Chichester, West Sussex:Columbia UniversityPress.
  • 20. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford19 meansthe deceasedhadnoideaof theirimpendingdeath.RobertCumbow,inhistext“Once Upona Time:The Filmsof SergioLeone”talksof Morricone’sdominationoverthe visual scape:“Nevermerelyaccompanyingorcommentingon the shotsor on the action,the musicassumesequal proportiontowhatistakingplace onthe screen22 ”.The only dialogue duringthe musicisthe theatricsonLanda,and a few nervousshakesof LaPadite’shead.Thesetwofactors workperfectlyinconjunctiontoone another:Sparingthe scene of dialogueotherthanonLanda’spart highlightsthe powerof the music, the sensual emotive connotationsitmakes,andLanda’sdisturbingattitudetohiswork.He instructs LaPadite toswitchback to Frenchonce he has coaxedthe informationof the hiddenJewsfromthe farmer.Eventhough the Dreyfus’scan’tsee Landa,he openshisarms and animates athank youfor the farmer’shospitality.The imagerythis createswiththisaural backdrop locatesLandaperfectly,asthe out-of-the-ordinarySSColonelTarantinowrote himto be23 . Shoshannaiscapturedrunningawayfromthe house both frombehindandinfrontof her; the house loominginthe distantbackgroundcrystallisingherdeparture,andthe rural surroundingshighlightingherlackof directionorplan.All the while,close upsonherface and of her overtemotional placementappearwhilstthe trackconflictsemotionally betweenscramblingstringsandsustained,boomingbrass.The varietyof timbre inthe track’sinstrumentationclearly demonstratesbothLanda’scapability athisjoband Shoshanna’sshockandangst, consequently alsoalludingtoNazi power.The visualsdepictLandaallowinghertolive however,whichinsinuatesherrole inthe filmisnotyetover. Shoshannawill be back,we justdon’tknowhow,when,where,orwhoshe maybe with.Undeniably,retribution becomesaninstanttheme underpinningherasshe’ssurvived. UN AMICO (A FRIEND) In chapterfive (‘The Revengeof the GiantFace’),Nazi Nightisinfull swingand the filmpremiere of Goebbel’s A Nation’sPrideappearsto be goingwell fromboth a Nazi perspective andfromaBasterds/Shoshannaperspective. However,the untimelydescent‘Nation’sPride’takesintoultra-violentactsonZoller’spartmake the Nazi feel uncomfortable;he stridestowardsShoshanna’sprojectionroom, accompaniedbythe fearful colourof “TigerTank”by Lalo Schifrin.AfterignoringShoshanna’sclaimsthathe can’tbe inthat room and that he shouldbe watchingthe 22 Cumbow, R. C. Once Upon a Time:The Films of Sergio Leone. Metuchen, N.J./London:The Scarecrow Press, Inc. 23 In an interview with Ella Taylor,Tarantino claims thatLanda comes from “a longlineof suave, charmingNazis that have appeared in Postwar cinema”. http://www.villagevoice.com/2009-08-18/news/quentin-tarantino-the-inglourious-basterds-interview/ Date accessed – April 2013.
  • 21. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford20 premiere,she theninsultshimbyaskinghimif hisnewly foundNazi statushasleadhimtoforgetwhat‘no’means.He burststhroughthe doorand confrontsher,as she takesthe opportunity.She tellshimtoclose the dooras they‘don’t have much time’,before shootinghimthree timesinthe backashe locksthe door.‘Un Amico’(‘A Friend’)beginstoplay as she turns fromherviewintothe cinematowardshisbodyon the floor. Beginningwiththe slow,floatingacousticguitarpicking, aroundthe Cmajorchord for three bars at the start of the fourthbar, violinsbegintoplaya melodysimilartothe guitarsbut witha muchfullersound,anda more lyrical flow withinitsmelody.The twoplayinconjunctionforthe nextelevenbars,the guitar’smotificrepetition complimenting the stringsdevelopingmelody.The endof the eleventhbarismetwitha subtle drumfill aroundthe snare and toms before advancingtoa 4/4 rhythm.Thisisalsowhere the bassguitar joins,whichfollowsthe rootnotesof the chords and itspluckingrecallsDu-Wopconventionality,asthe firstnote ringsoutbefore the nexttwoare playedquicklyone afteranother.The tranquillityof the stringsandguitarhasbeendistractedbutonlybythe euphoricevolutionthe stringshave undertaken:Theynowcanbe foundrepeatingasimilarmotif tobefore butanoctave higherandwithan eventhickersound(multiplicityinthe violinsseemstobe the cause,alongwithemphasisonsome of the phrasesfrom flutes).The lyrical styleof the violinsstillremains,asitisstill the focal pointof the track. The nextsectionbridge sto anotheridentical sectionbutgoesthroughthe chordsina stabbingwaltzmotiononthe midregisterof the violinsfor three bars independently.These are metbya similarlysteadydrumfill before the violin’smelodyisplayedbya keyboard/synthesizer.Despite followingthe melody,thissectionisn’tasecstaticasbefore asit’sof a softertone and registeredlower,inthe midrange.The track doescontinue andfollowsthese sectionsthroughout,butourfilm experience of itendshere abruptly. By killingZollerbefore the musicstarts,the musicdisorientatesourscope of Shoshanna’semotionsasmuchas she does;she triesto lookawayfromZoller,butTarantinosurroundsher.The scene in‘Nation’sPride’we are catching snippetsof displaysZollerstrugglingtofightof the enemyandlookingdefeated,hisface central tothe camera. Shoshannaflicksbetweenbothhisbodyandhispresence inthe film,until Zollergroansandshe cannot helpherself but assisthim.Here,Shoshanna’scompassionkillsEmannuelle Mimieux.She walksovertohim(whichwe see froma Birdseye view,whichlocatesthe twoontheirownina small room),andshe turnshim over;as she doesso,the first drum fill playsandZollerstretcheshisarmoutand shootsherin the torso.Perfectlytimed,Shoshannafallsbackinslow motionsurroundedbyanexplosionof small redparticles, justasthe violinsrepeattheirmelodybutatthe higher
  • 22. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford21 registerandwiththe rhythmicstabilisingof the drumsandthe bass.We see herscreechin slow motion,andbounce off the wall (where throughthe glasswe see Zolleronscreen,behindher,cockinghisrifle).The camerathenlandsdirectly infront of her face,portrayingher pain.However,tothismusicandwithoutdialogue,Shoshannalooksorgasmic,which underpinsthe romantictonalityof the piece.Shoshannafallstothe floor;she islyingvertically,atthe bottomof Zoller’s feet,whoislyinghorizontally.The cameraswitchestoZoller,andprimarilyfocusesonhimbefore hispistol;whenhe firesthe pistol,we returntonormal speedandhere Shoshannascreamashe’sjustpulledthe trigge r.Bloodissplattered everywhere,andthe twoare viewedagainfromthe Birdseye view.The constantreferral tothe small space theyare bothin and the fact that there are onlytwocharacters presentplacestheirweddednarrative furtherthanplatonic realms.DuringShoshanna’sritualisticpreparationsforthe night the deepredof hercostume codesenticedthe anger and vengeance evidentonscreen;now,paralleltoZoller’sovertlywhite militaryjacketembeddedwithbadges,the red and the white complimentthe romanticovertonesthat‘UnAmico’implies.WhilstShoshannakilledFrederick,onecould argue Emmanuelle fell inlove withhim.The factthat the twofindthemselvessidebyside inthe filmreelsShoshanna has editedmeansZoller’scharacterisimmortalisedwithShoshanna,whereasShoshanna’scharacterdieswithZoller. The visual effectof slowmotiontoa relativelyslow tempotrackaddsto thisidea – theirduality,whetherromantic, platonicor contrasting,ismade timeless,bothonthe screen of ‘Nation’sPride’and‘InglouriousBasterds’bytheirvery owndualitieswiththemselves. CONCLUSION AND EVALUATION The analytical modelscementedtothisdissertationencourage the writingtowrite descriptivelyforcertainaspectson investigations.Jameson’spostmodernismsare culturallyinclined,consequentlyanymeasurementmade againstthem will require adetailed explanationof the filmmusic’srole inthe greaternarrative.Larsen’sdichotomydictatesthatas there are some similaritiesinvernacularbetweenprimitive musicandfilmanalysis,insinuatingtwoformsof analyses needtobe undertaken.The thirdsegment,concerningMorricone andShoshanna,basesonnoparticularacademic frameworkbutthe Larsen’swritingshave taughtusthroughouta steadymethodof analyseswhichcoincidentallysuits the two antithetical Morricone tracksusedtoscore Shoshanna’sentrance anddeparture. ConsiderPhilipTagg’s‘Functionsof FilmMusic24 ’:Tagg’staxonomyreappropriates PolishmusicologistZofiaLissa’s1959 24 http://www.tagg.org/udem/musimgmot/filmfunx.html Date accessed:October 2012.
  • 23. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford22 study Ästhetikder Filmmusik for contemporaryuse.Inconjunctionwiththisscript,‘The Verdict(DopoLaCondanna)’ equatesto‘Expressionsof Actor’sEmotions’(6) withconstantclose visual surveillance of LaPadite workingintandem withBarry Cooper’sdiscussionof the emotional longingtransposedfrom‘FurElise’.Technicallyitalsomatcheswiththe ‘Opening’ssubheadingfrom‘EnhancementandDemarcationof the Film’sFormal Structure’(10),asit’sthe firsttrackin the film.BillyPreston’s‘Slaughter’alsomirrorsasubheadingfrom(10),thatof ‘Leitmotif’asitservesto‘re-identifywith characters’amongstother filmicelements.Thisalsoleadsusbackto(6) whenwe regardthe differingemotive connotationsStiglitzemitsonbothoccasions.‘What’dISay’meetsthe descriptionof ‘Symbol’(8),aswe learnof the Nazi oppressor’scommencingtoendthe nightprematurelybefore the Nazisdo.Italso,againequatesto(6) withfurther examplesof contrastingemotions,fromthe excitedBasterdsanddistressedShoshanna.‘White Lightning’parallelsthe thirdsubheadingfrom(10),‘LinksandBridges’asit ‘bridges’the gapbetweenchapterstwoandthree andsecuresour trust withthe unidentifiedfemale(Shoshanna).Bernstein’strackrelays‘Emphasisof Movement’(1) asAldo’sl iteral stance is concretedwithtimelyadditionsof dampbassguitar.At thispointthe dialogue andmusicintensifiesgreatly but the visualsdonotsuggestthisas prominentlyasthe musicdoes,ensuringwe canmirror‘White Lightning’to ‘Anticipationof SubsequentAction’(9).The varyinginstrumentationsalsoleadusbackto‘Expressionsof Actor’s Emotions’(6).‘L’IncontroConLa Figlia’endorses(9) completely,asthe raise indynamicsunveilsthe scramblingand sustainingminortonesof the track’s instruments;the visualsare nearenoughidentical tohow they’ve beenforthe majorityof chapterone.Certainly(6) againforLaPadite andsubsequentlyafleeingShoshanna,butalsothe track suits the twistedmethodsof Landa,whoisthe scene’svictor (providingthe earlierWesterncontextsetby‘The Verdict(Dopo La Condanna)’).‘UnAmico’leadsustostudy‘Comment’(5),asitdictatesa typical case of such is through“contradicting the connotative sphere of the visual action”.ShoshannaandFredrick’skillingof one anotherrepresentsthe untimely endfor twointegral charactersinthe film:Accompaniedby‘UnAmico’recontextualisesourinterpretationhoweverand crystallisesthe tworomantically.Italsomirrors‘ExpressionsforAudience’sEmotions’(7) henceforth. Mostly,the dissertationismotivatedbythe necessityof scrutinisingthe musicandassociatedscenery.Detailed descriptive language allowsforconcise findingsanalytically,butonlyif the analytical structure inplacesallowsforsuch. The disadvantage of buildingonquantifiedsongchoiceswitharegimentedtaxonomysuchasTagg’sis that there could arguablybe little roomtoidentifythe music’spolysemictendency;if anyat all.Employingaview of postmodern discourse uponthe topicdemonstratesaside tothe songsthat isunobtainable withoutaconcise knowledge of the area
  • 24. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford23 and itssurroundings;the footnotesaccompanyingthe dissertationthroughoutdon’tequate tothe amountof preliminaryreadingundertooktolearnof the discourse.Jameson’spostmodernismscouldbe appliedtofilmanalysisor musicanalysisindependently;infact,to almostanyartefactsof popularculture.Applyingthemtofilmmusicpermits the conductor to deconstructthe audio-visual bondandtoexamine the strandsbetweenthemwithacultural eye,a widerscope.Were itnotfor the tightconstraintsof the essay,one couldemploythe parametersof Baudrillardor Lyotard forexample,andwould locate differentfindings.Usingamodel suchasTagg’s infinitelyinalargersectionof the dissertationcompressesthe findingstobe purelymusical andcinematic,withnoneedforwiderscope.Alongside the more narrow scope of Larsen maytherefore seemcontradictory,butonlyif thispaperhasa view toinvestigate InglouriousBasterds music’sasacultural artefactthroughout;butit doesn’t,andone mustn’tforgetthis.If we are to fullyutilise the limitationsof the study,it’svital torememberthatprimarily,we are investigatingmusicandits relationship tothe film.These elementsmustbe tackledappropriately –Larsen’sdichotomyprovingasuccessful model. WhereasJameson’sworkcouldbe subjective forsome academics,Larsenappreciatesthe needtounderstandmusic and filmseparatelybeforeconsequentlycollaboratingthe twospheres.Larsen’smethod,if successful,will ensure the conductorhas a sophisticatedyetconcise approachtothe twobasic entitiesunderobservation;determiningthese faculties certifiesforthe inclusionof amuchmore analytical,culturallymindedapproachsuchasJameson’s postmodernisms. The concept of dualitiesisexploredthroughdifferentexamplesthroughoutthe dissertation.The basisforchoosing these textsstemsfromDeacon’searliersuggestionsof regardingquantitative researchasa cultural researchmethod. Underpinningthe twoframesof academiawithnumericallybasedsongchoicesensuresnopersonal affiliationswithany of the soundtrackare made on the conductor’sbehalf;the catalystforthe selectionsmustbe balanced,forthe ensuing analysesmaybe subjective todifferentsubscribersof analytical frameworks.Instantlythroughthesedualismsdenote motificactivity,justthroughthe word’smeaning,asArnold Whittall dictates: “…to represent or symbolize a person, object, place, idea, state of mind, supernatural force or any other ingredient25”. 25 Grove, George, Sir, 1820-1900; Sadie, Stanley, 1930-;Tyrrell, John. 2001. The NewGrove Dictionaryof Music and Musicians. London: Macmillan
  • 25. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford24 Each of the songsthat appeartwice all meetWhittall’sdefinitions;measuringthemagainstadiscursive facultysuchas postmodernismdetailsfindingsinaccessible throughpure musical orfilmanalysis.Butinordertoreceive these findings, one mustclearlyunderstandthe fundamentalsof musicinrelationtothe filmandinitsisolation. There are othersongsthat wouldhave providedinterestingresults –DavidBowie’s‘CatPeople’isarguablythe most ‘popular’trackon the soundtrack,and isthe longestmusical textfoundinthe foregroundof itsappropriate scene.It’s depictionof Shoshanna’sritualisticroutineof preparingforNazi Nightisfragmentedbyadetailedaccountof herand Marcel’sstrive forsuccess,regardlessof the cost.The track alsoisthe mostobviouswithlyrical connectionstothe characters,withthe repeatedphrasingof ‘beensolong’crystallisingShoshannaunderNazi rule andherlengthy plansof vengeance.One couldsuggestdualitiesthroughthe constantlyrical repetition‘beensolong’directlylinkedto Shoshanna,however forthe idiomsaffixedtothe studythere waslittle roomforacademicconsiderationof the text.A keydualitynotaccreditedtoisthe openingcreditstothe closingcredits,butina tightlyconfinedstudy,the music’s dominantpurpose istorelaymessagesof the visualsonscreen –withthe choicesinthistextprovingmore fruitful purelybecause theyhave ascene tounderscore.However,forthe size andconstraintsof the study,itis feasibleto suggestthe evidence portrayedthroughoutthe studyclearlydemonstratesanexplorationintothe musicof the film,its purpose,anditscapacity tofacilitate the purpose inquestion.Thisconclusionwouldn’thave beenmetwithoutthe theoretical andacademicframeworkstomeasure the musicagainst;whilstnosuchcase can be foundinthe thirdmode of analysisinthe dissertation,the twobeforeiteducatedusintohow tofindwhatwe are lookingfor,culminatinginthe musicof Morricone comparedto Shoshanna;tworelicsof the filmthatcouldnotbe ignored.
  • 26. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford25 Appendices Figure 1.1 13% 11% 17% 29% 30% Chapter Length (M/S) One: 'Once Upon a Time… in Nazi-occupied France' 18:26 Two: 'Inglourious Basterds' 15:52 Three: 'German Night in Paris' 24:11 Four: Operation Kino' 40:36 Five: 'The Revenge of the Giant Face' 41:31 8% 20% 20% 22% 30% Musical Chapter Length (M/S) One: 'Once Upon a Time… in Nazi- occupied France' 02:47 Two: 'Inglourious Basterds' 06:36 Three: 'German Night in Paris' 06:26 Four: Operation Kino' 07:14 Five: 'The Revenge of the Giant Face' 10:02
  • 27. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford26 Figure 1.2 8% 20% 12% 4% 10% 46% RepeatedTexts(inLengthOrder) "What'd I Say" Rare Earth (Chapter Five; first appearance) 00:25 What'd I Say Rare Earth (Chapter Five; second appearance) 00:58 "Slaughter" Billy Preston (Chapter Two; first appearace) 00:37 "Slaughter" Billy Preston (Chapter Four; second appearance) 00:11 "White Lightning" Charles Bernstein (Chapter Two; first appearance) 00:30 "White Lightning" Charles Bernstein (Chapter Two/Three; second appearance 02:17
  • 28. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford27 KEY SHOTS FROM INGLORIOUS BASTERDS ChapterOne (Once Upon a Time … In Nazi-occupiedFrance):The Nazis arrive at the LaPadite farm. ChapterOne (Once Upon a Time … In Nazi-occupiedFrance):Perrier LaPadite’sprofilingasNazisarrive. ChapterOne (Once Upon a Time … In Nazi-occupiedFrance):Shoshanna fleesasLanda lookson.
  • 29. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford28 ChapterTwo (InglouriousBasterds): We meetHugoStiglitz. ChapterTwo (InglouriousBasterds): View fromButz’s foreheadatthe endof the chapter. ChapterFour (OperationKino): Stiglitzbeingwhipped.
  • 30. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford29 ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):Donnyleavesthe cinema. ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):DonnyandOmar leave the cinema. ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):ShoshannaandMarcel embrace forthe lasttime.
  • 31. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford30 ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):Frederickshoots Shoshanna. ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):Shoshannaand Frederick’srestingplaces. ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):“Who wantsto senda message toGermany?”
  • 32. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford31 ChapterFive (The Revenge of the Giant Face):“I have a message for Germany…That you are all goingto die."
  • 33. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford32 BIBLIOGRAPHY Literature: Auner&Lochhead.2002. Postmodern MusicPostmodern Thought.London/New York:Routledge. Best& Kellner.1991. Postmodern Theory:CriticalInterrogations.London:MacmillanEducationLtd. Boswell,M.2012. HolocaustImpietyin Literature, PopularMusicand Film. Basingstoke:PalgraveMacmillan. Brown,Royal S. 1994. Overtonesand Undertones:Reading FilmMusic.Berkeley/LosAngeles/London:Universityof CaliforniaPress. Chandler,D.2002. The Basics:Semiotics. Abingdon,Oxon:Routledge. Connor,S. 3004. The CambridgeCompanion to Postmodernism.Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress. Connor,S. 1989. PostmodernistCulture:An Introduction to Theoriesof theContemporary.Oxford:BlackwellPublishers. Cooper,B.2000. Beethoven. Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress. Cumbow,R.C. Once Upon a Time: The Films of Sergio Leone.Metuchen,N.J./London:The Scarecrow Press,Inc. Dassanowsky,R.V.2012. Quentin Tarantino’sInglouriousBasterds:A Manipulationof Metacinema.New York/London: ContinuumInternational PublishingGroup. Dawson,J.1995. Quentin Tarantino:The Cinema of Cool.New York: Applause Books. Donnelly,K.J.2001. Film Music: Critical Approaches. New York/London:ContinuumInternationalPublishingGroup. Friedburg,A.1993. WindowShopping:Cinema and thePostmodern.Berkeley/LosAngeles/London:Universityof CaliforniaPress. Gorbman,C. 1987. Unheard Melodies:NarrativeFilmMusic. Bloomington:Universityof IndianaPress. Grove, George, Sir, 1820-1900; Sadie, Stanley, 1930-;Tyrrell, John. 2001. The New Grove Dictionary of Musicand Musicians. London:Macmillan.
  • 34. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford33 Holm,D. K. 2004. The Pocket Essentials:Quentin Tarantino.Harpenden:PocketEssentials. Knight& Wojcik.2001. SoundtrackAvailable:Essayson Filmand PopularMusic. Durhamand London:Duke University Press. Larsen, P. 2005. Film Music. London: Reaktion Books Ltd. Mundy,J. 1999. PopularMusicon Screen: FromHollywood Musicalto MusicVideo.Manchester:Universityof ManchesterPress. Pickering,M.2008. Research MethodsforCulturalStudies.Edinburgh:EdinburghUniversityPressLtd. Powrie &Stilwell.2006. Changing Tunes:TheUseof Pre-existing Musicin Film. Aldershot:AshgatePublishingLtd. Rapée,Erno.1974 (originally1924). Motion PictureMoodsforPianistsand Organists.New York:ArnoPress. Sharrett,Christopher.1993. Crisis Cinema:The ApocalypticIdea in Postmodern NarrativeFilm.WashingtonDC: Maisonneuve Press. Smart, B. 1993. Postmodernity:Key Ideas.London:Routledge. Smith,J.1998. The Soundsof Commerce:Marketing PopularFilmMusic. New York/Chichester,WestSussex:Columbia UniversityPress. Storey,J.1993. An Introductory Guideto Cultural Theory and PopularCulture.Hemel Hempstead,Hertfordshire: HarvesterWheatsheaf. Strinati,D.1995. An Introduction to Theoriesof PopularCulture. London/New York:Routledge. Tasker,Y. 2002.Fifty Contemporary Filmmakers.London:Routledge. Zelizer,B.2001. VisualCultureand the Holocaust.London:The Athlone Press.
  • 35. JonathanShelton BA (Hons) PopularMusicologyLevel Six Dissertation Universityof Salford34 Films: Sollima,S(Director) (1966).The BigGundown.VHS:Unknown. Tarantino,Q (Director) (2007). Deathproof. DVD.A BandApart Productions. Tarantino,Q (Director) (1997). JackieBrown.DVD.A Band ApartProductions. Tarantino,Q (Director) (2003). Kill Bill Vol.1. DVD.A Band ApartProductions. Tarantino,Q (Director) (2004). Kill Bill Vol.2. DVD.A Band ApartProductions. Tarantino,Q (Director) (2009). InglouriousBasterds.DVD.A BandApartProductions. Tarantino,Q (Director) (1994). Pulp Fiction. DVD.A Band ApartProductions. Tarantino,Q (Director) (1992). ReservoirDogs.DVD.A Band ApartProductions. Websites: http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2003/10/06/quentin_tarantino_kill_bill_volume1_interview.shtml http://www.filmscoremonthly.com/board/posts.cfm?threadID=68442&forumID=1&archive=0 http://www.tagg.org/udem/musimgmot/filmfunx.html http://www.villagevoice.com/2009-08-18/news/quentin-tarantino-the-inglourious-basterds-interview/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postmodernist_film