SlideShare a Scribd company logo
History Dissertation
MHV322094-14-AB
Whilst examining women’s experiences in
concentration and sub camps, determine
whether or not gender-related
characteristics helped them survive.
Leigh-Ann Todd
S1109398
Dr. Ben Shepherd
2014/ 2015
This Dissertation is submitted in partial fulfilment of the BA (Hons) Degree in Social
Sciences, Glasgow School for Business and Society, Glasgow Caledonian University.
Contents
Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................... 3
Abstract.......................................................................................................................................4
Introduction.................................................................................................................................5
Domestic chapter............................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
Physical Chapter............................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Social Chapter.................................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
Conclusion ....................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Bibliography..................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Acknowledgements
Firstly, I would like to give a great deal of thanks to my supervisor Dr. Ben Shepherd who
helped me throughout my entire dissertation process. Without his guidance and support I
would not have been able to complete this dissertation, therefore I am extremely grateful.
Also I would like to extend my thanks to the facilities which allowed me to consult
testimonies and literature necessary for my research – the Scottish Jewish Archive Centre,
the Imperial War Museum and the Weiner Library.
Finally, thank you to my family and friends for their support and assistance during this
stressful time.
Abstract
The intention of this dissertation was to determine whether or not gender-related
characteristics helped women survive concentration or sub camps. The leading motivation
for conducting a study surrounding this subject area was because the majority of research
discussing the Holocaust is one sided – typically highlighting men’s perspectives – and
disregards gender as a factor. Therefore, this study aimed to discuss the Holocaust from a
gender-oriented view, with particular emphasis on characteristics women had which may or
may not have helped them survive. In order to approach this area of study, secondary and
primary sources were consulted. Several secondary sources were examined, in the form of
books and journals articles, to grasp a greater understanding of the subject as a whole.
Primary sources were accessed in the Scottish Jewish Archive Centre and the Imperial War
Museum. Testimonies examined within these archives offered further insight into women’s
experiences in concentration and sub camps. By examining first hand experiences and
consulting the literature, my findings highlighted that domestic, physical and social gender-
related characteristics affected women’s survival. Within each of these three chapters,
certain aspects were identified which contributed more to women’s survival than others.
Introduction
“Gender affected women’s ability to struggle against the subhuman conditions of
degradation, deprivation, terror, and even death, and being female offered benefits
yet also produced liabilities”.1
David Engel explains quite effectively the difference between concentration, extermination
and sub camps in his book ‘The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews’. Engel notes that
concentration camps were built to detain groups of people, who opposed the political,
ideological or behavioural ideals of the Third Reich – such as Communists, Socialists,
Jehovah’s witnesses and homosexuals.2 Additionally, those deemed racially inferior were
also incarcerated, such as the Jews, the Roma and Sinti (‘Gypsies’), Slavic people (i.e.
Russians, Poles and others), and the mentally and physically disabled.3 Engel argues that
occasionally the extermination camps are referred to as ‘concentration camps’, however
this is “a misnomer”.4 There were a total of six extermination camps, or ‘killing centres’5,
located across Europe with a sole purpose – to implement the mass murder of the Jewish
people by asphyxiation. Due to economic needs attributable to World War II being
prolonged, the Germans exploited prisoners as a labour force within ‘sub camps’6
(Aussenlager), at “existing or new production facilities”.7 Nevertheless, the Nazis’ plan to
murder the Jews was still in place, by a process of “extermination through labour” – this...
1 Yad Vashem Studies, Vol. XXVIII,Jerusalem 2000,pp. 363-378.Accessed 4 Mar. 2014,from
http://www.yadvashem.org/odot_pdf/Microsoft%20Word%20-%203228.pdf
2 Engel, D. (2013) The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews (Seminar Studies), 2nd edition,Cambridge:
Pearson Education Limited, p.5
3 Ibid.
4 Ibid.,p.67
5 Ibid.,Glossary xxii
6 Also known as ‘labour camps’,as David Engel defines in The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews.
However, there were ‘labour camps’situated across Europewhich were not connected to the Final Solution;
instead they were used as ‘correction centres’ for potentially disruptiveelements in countries likeFrance and
Belgium
7 Yad Vashem (n.d.) The Holocaust Resource Centre – Labour and Forced Labour Camps. Accessed 4 March
2015,from http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/holocaust/resource_center/item.asp?gate=2-26; Gregor, N.
(ed.) (2005) Nazism, War and Genocide: New perspectives on the history of the Third Reich, Exeter: University
of Exeter Press.,p.2

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Escaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressed
Escaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressedEscaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressed
Escaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressed
Javier Albuja
 
Yehia Helmy - CV
Yehia Helmy - CVYehia Helmy - CV
Yehia Helmy - CV
yehia helmy
 
Employment Solutions
Employment SolutionsEmployment Solutions
Employment Solutions
Employment Solutions
 
res
resres
Tristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAIL
Tristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAILTristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAIL
Tristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAIL
Tristan Griffiths
 
Fibonaccin lukujono
Fibonaccin lukujonoFibonaccin lukujono
Fibonaccin lukujono
ryhta
 
Demographics of Substance Abuse
Demographics of Substance AbuseDemographics of Substance Abuse
Demographics of Substance Abuse
Get Real Recovery
 
DCBADD2015 our req are good
DCBADD2015 our req are goodDCBADD2015 our req are good
DCBADD2015 our req are good
IIBADCBADD
 
Top 4 Resort For Vacations
Top 4 Resort For VacationsTop 4 Resort For Vacations
Top 4 Resort For Vacations
Business world Travel
 
Kalilinux
KalilinuxKalilinux
Kalilinux
haha loser
 
5 клас урок 14
5 клас урок 145 клас урок 14
5 клас урок 14
Iren50
 
A new look for the mind
A new look for the mindA new look for the mind
A new look for the mind
Doha Momeanah
 
Searching with Wikipedia
Searching with WikipediaSearching with Wikipedia
Searching with Wikipedia
MSVUlibrary
 
07.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 2014
07.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 201407.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 2014
07.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 2014Jill Novotny
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Escaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressed
Escaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressedEscaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressed
Escaneo deontologia ilovepdf-compressed
 
Yehia Helmy - CV
Yehia Helmy - CVYehia Helmy - CV
Yehia Helmy - CV
 
Employment Solutions
Employment SolutionsEmployment Solutions
Employment Solutions
 
res
resres
res
 
Tristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAIL
Tristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAILTristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAIL
Tristan Griffiths Resume 2015 EMAIL
 
Fibonaccin lukujono
Fibonaccin lukujonoFibonaccin lukujono
Fibonaccin lukujono
 
Demographics of Substance Abuse
Demographics of Substance AbuseDemographics of Substance Abuse
Demographics of Substance Abuse
 
DCBADD2015 our req are good
DCBADD2015 our req are goodDCBADD2015 our req are good
DCBADD2015 our req are good
 
Top 4 Resort For Vacations
Top 4 Resort For VacationsTop 4 Resort For Vacations
Top 4 Resort For Vacations
 
Kalilinux
KalilinuxKalilinux
Kalilinux
 
5 клас урок 14
5 клас урок 145 клас урок 14
5 клас урок 14
 
A new look for the mind
A new look for the mindA new look for the mind
A new look for the mind
 
Searching with Wikipedia
Searching with WikipediaSearching with Wikipedia
Searching with Wikipedia
 
07.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 2014
07.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 201407.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 2014
07.03_7.3 Få mere ud af dine powerpiont KOMP 2. opd April 2014
 

Similar to Dissertation

A history of the case study.pdf
A history of the case study.pdfA history of the case study.pdf
A history of the case study.pdf
Sarah Pollard
 
Narrative research
Narrative researchNarrative research
Narrative research
Eko_Mulyono
 
Historian Task Essay
Historian Task EssayHistorian Task Essay
Historian Task Essay
Raghad Swalem
 
Strassler Center YER 2015
Strassler Center YER 2015Strassler Center YER 2015
Strassler Center YER 2015
Mary Jane Rein
 
Description Of An Essay
Description Of An EssayDescription Of An Essay
Description Of An Essay
Brenda Howard
 
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing ArgumentsArts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
UWAStudySmarter
 
Warburton.Dissertation
Warburton.DissertationWarburton.Dissertation
Warburton.Dissertation
Tim Warburton
 
Special treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattogno
Special treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattognoSpecial treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattogno
Special treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattogno
RareBooksnRecords
 
Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...
Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...
Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...
RareBooksnRecords
 
Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)
Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)
Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)
Stephen Cheng
 
Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...
Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...
Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...
Carolyn Wagner
 
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdfMarkakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Abraham Lebeza
 
603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web
603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web
603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web
Mary Jane Rein
 
Comprehension Essay.pdf
Comprehension Essay.pdfComprehension Essay.pdf
Comprehension Essay.pdf
Laura Cappabianca
 
  1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx
   1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx   1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx
  1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx
MARRY7
 

Similar to Dissertation (15)

A history of the case study.pdf
A history of the case study.pdfA history of the case study.pdf
A history of the case study.pdf
 
Narrative research
Narrative researchNarrative research
Narrative research
 
Historian Task Essay
Historian Task EssayHistorian Task Essay
Historian Task Essay
 
Strassler Center YER 2015
Strassler Center YER 2015Strassler Center YER 2015
Strassler Center YER 2015
 
Description Of An Essay
Description Of An EssayDescription Of An Essay
Description Of An Essay
 
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing ArgumentsArts Voices: Constructing Arguments
Arts Voices: Constructing Arguments
 
Warburton.Dissertation
Warburton.DissertationWarburton.Dissertation
Warburton.Dissertation
 
Special treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattogno
Special treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattognoSpecial treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattogno
Special treatment-in-auschwitz-origin-and-meaning-of-a-term-carlo-mattogno
 
Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...
Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...
Concentration camp-stutthof-and-its-function-in-national-socialist-jewish-pol...
 
Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)
Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)
Jewish Resistance to Nazi Germany (a Coursera essay)
 
Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...
Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...
Motivation Theories Essays. ️ Essay about motivation for college. Free Motiva...
 
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdfMarkakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
Markakis-Schlee-Young-2021-The-nation-state.pdf
 
603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web
603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web
603064Strassler2015-16YearEndReport_web
 
Comprehension Essay.pdf
Comprehension Essay.pdfComprehension Essay.pdf
Comprehension Essay.pdf
 
  1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx
   1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx   1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx
  1  Holocaust Survivor Groups and Memory Work in Ari.docx
 

Dissertation

  • 1. History Dissertation MHV322094-14-AB Whilst examining women’s experiences in concentration and sub camps, determine whether or not gender-related characteristics helped them survive. Leigh-Ann Todd S1109398 Dr. Ben Shepherd 2014/ 2015 This Dissertation is submitted in partial fulfilment of the BA (Hons) Degree in Social Sciences, Glasgow School for Business and Society, Glasgow Caledonian University.
  • 2. Contents Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................... 3 Abstract.......................................................................................................................................4 Introduction.................................................................................................................................5 Domestic chapter............................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined. Physical Chapter............................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined. Social Chapter.................................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined. Conclusion ....................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined. Bibliography..................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
  • 3. Acknowledgements Firstly, I would like to give a great deal of thanks to my supervisor Dr. Ben Shepherd who helped me throughout my entire dissertation process. Without his guidance and support I would not have been able to complete this dissertation, therefore I am extremely grateful. Also I would like to extend my thanks to the facilities which allowed me to consult testimonies and literature necessary for my research – the Scottish Jewish Archive Centre, the Imperial War Museum and the Weiner Library. Finally, thank you to my family and friends for their support and assistance during this stressful time.
  • 4. Abstract The intention of this dissertation was to determine whether or not gender-related characteristics helped women survive concentration or sub camps. The leading motivation for conducting a study surrounding this subject area was because the majority of research discussing the Holocaust is one sided – typically highlighting men’s perspectives – and disregards gender as a factor. Therefore, this study aimed to discuss the Holocaust from a gender-oriented view, with particular emphasis on characteristics women had which may or may not have helped them survive. In order to approach this area of study, secondary and primary sources were consulted. Several secondary sources were examined, in the form of books and journals articles, to grasp a greater understanding of the subject as a whole. Primary sources were accessed in the Scottish Jewish Archive Centre and the Imperial War Museum. Testimonies examined within these archives offered further insight into women’s experiences in concentration and sub camps. By examining first hand experiences and consulting the literature, my findings highlighted that domestic, physical and social gender- related characteristics affected women’s survival. Within each of these three chapters, certain aspects were identified which contributed more to women’s survival than others.
  • 5. Introduction “Gender affected women’s ability to struggle against the subhuman conditions of degradation, deprivation, terror, and even death, and being female offered benefits yet also produced liabilities”.1 David Engel explains quite effectively the difference between concentration, extermination and sub camps in his book ‘The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews’. Engel notes that concentration camps were built to detain groups of people, who opposed the political, ideological or behavioural ideals of the Third Reich – such as Communists, Socialists, Jehovah’s witnesses and homosexuals.2 Additionally, those deemed racially inferior were also incarcerated, such as the Jews, the Roma and Sinti (‘Gypsies’), Slavic people (i.e. Russians, Poles and others), and the mentally and physically disabled.3 Engel argues that occasionally the extermination camps are referred to as ‘concentration camps’, however this is “a misnomer”.4 There were a total of six extermination camps, or ‘killing centres’5, located across Europe with a sole purpose – to implement the mass murder of the Jewish people by asphyxiation. Due to economic needs attributable to World War II being prolonged, the Germans exploited prisoners as a labour force within ‘sub camps’6 (Aussenlager), at “existing or new production facilities”.7 Nevertheless, the Nazis’ plan to murder the Jews was still in place, by a process of “extermination through labour” – this... 1 Yad Vashem Studies, Vol. XXVIII,Jerusalem 2000,pp. 363-378.Accessed 4 Mar. 2014,from http://www.yadvashem.org/odot_pdf/Microsoft%20Word%20-%203228.pdf 2 Engel, D. (2013) The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews (Seminar Studies), 2nd edition,Cambridge: Pearson Education Limited, p.5 3 Ibid. 4 Ibid.,p.67 5 Ibid.,Glossary xxii 6 Also known as ‘labour camps’,as David Engel defines in The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews. However, there were ‘labour camps’situated across Europewhich were not connected to the Final Solution; instead they were used as ‘correction centres’ for potentially disruptiveelements in countries likeFrance and Belgium 7 Yad Vashem (n.d.) The Holocaust Resource Centre – Labour and Forced Labour Camps. Accessed 4 March 2015,from http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/holocaust/resource_center/item.asp?gate=2-26; Gregor, N. (ed.) (2005) Nazism, War and Genocide: New perspectives on the history of the Third Reich, Exeter: University of Exeter Press.,p.2