SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
1
To: David Oskandy
From: Max Drickey
cc: Laurent Masson
Date: April 15, 2015
Re: Envisioning a Corporate Citizenship Program for Avanade
While corporate social responsibility programs (CSRs) have existed for many years, an increasing
number of companies have implemented these programs in the last decade. These organizations
recognize that CSR programs improve their: (i) reputation, (ii) competitive advantage, (iii) ability to retain
and attract current and prospective employees, clients, customers or users, and (iv) relationships with
suppliers, governments, and communities. Importantly, CSR programs foster cooperation and team spirit
within an organization’s workforce, reinforce the messaging behind an organization’s code of conduct,
and empower a company’s employees to take an ownership stake in the wellbeing of their community
and their company.
To date, industry leaders, including technology giants like Intel and Microsoft, have established some of
the world’s most recognizable CSR programs. But companies in all industries and of all sizes have
created successful and impactful CSR programs. Accordingly, smaller professional service providers like
Avanade can make substantive contributions to their communities through targeted initiatives that
leverage core strengths and values of the organization. By evaluating the CSR programs of some of
Avanade’s competitors as well as the programs of other organizations that are similar in size and
earnings to Avanade, Avanade can “cherry pick” from these CSR programs to construct its own
customized CSR program that reflects its culture and values.
This memo should be reviewed in tandem with the Corporate Citizenship Comparison excel spreadsheet
previously provided.
Page 2
Methodology
Creating a Matrix of Characteristics for Sample CSR Programs
To gain an understanding of how Avanade might construct its own CSR program, I researched
comparable programs of other organizations to learn about the various types of arrangements that a CSR
program could take. Given the enormous variety of CSR initiatives seen in the marketplace, I employed
the following criteria to refine my research efforts, and to compare them against Avanade’s resources,
strengths and priorities:
 Size – The number of employees and net revenue of organizations were considered. Although
company size does not necessarily dictate the scope or size of an organization’s CSR program,
an organization’s revenue and workforce serves as a useful standard by which to assess the
applicability of particular types of CSR initiatives to Avanade’s unique conditions and corporate
environment.
 Industry – Only organizations that focused on the creation of information technology products or
services or the creation or management of information assets were considered. These
companies typically share a pool of marketable skills.
 Eminence – Only CSR programs that have been recognized by the Ethisphere Institute, a non-
profit organization that annually identifies the world’s most ethical companies, or by CSR program
subject matter experts1,2 as being impressive were considered.
 Maturity – Only programs that have been operated successfully for more than 10 years with the
support and sponsorship of the parent organizations were considered.
Source Material
To learn more about CSR programs, I examined the content and materials provided by the sources
described below:
 The Conference Board – An organization that provides reports and surveys detailing the types
of CSR programs available to companies at various sizes and capacities, and outlines the
preliminary steps necessary to start those programs.
 The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development – An organization that
provides reports that identify more unconventional ways of expanding a company’s CSR
initiatives at an international level.
1
Benjamin Weinberg is theprobonopartnerat Dentons, managing thelaw firm’s substantialpro bonoprogram.
Prior to his employmentat Dentons, he servedas thechief of the Illinois AttorneyGeneral’sPublicInterest Division,
overseeing major litigation in the publicintereston such issuesascivilrights, disabilityrights, and publicutilities.
2
Deb Krause servesastheSteeringCommittee Chair of Mercer’sGlobalCommunity Caresfoundation. She was
previouslyemployed at UnitedHealthGroup astheDirectorof theOffice of SocialResponsibility.
Page 3
 Boston College Center for Corporate Citizenship – An organization that provides data on the
benefits of CSR programs to businesses and provides information about the current state of CSR
initiatives.
 Points of Light – An organization that provides information on economy-wide challenges to
improve CSR initiatives, and supplies basic resources useful to establishing a CSR program
within an organization.
 Subject matter experts – Experienced individuals who have created or managed several CSR
programs within multiple organizations and industries shared experience and know-how. These
SMEs identified “best in class” CSR programs and other information and resources for research
and comparative purposes.
 Websites of existing CSR programs – Websites of the established CSR initiatives of
companies that describe these programs enabled me to understand the various CSR
programmatic approaches. Some website provide knowledge-sharing content to assist
organizations create new CSR programs (e.g., Salesforce Foundation).
Types of CSR Programs:
At the most basic level, CSR programs differ from company to company in the way that they support and
interface with non-profit organizations:
 Financial contributions – The CSR program facilitates the donation of financial resources to
non-profit organizations directly or promotes employee donations via a matched contribution
program.
 Volunteering – The CSR program coordinates with non-profit or needy organizations to establish
days of service (e.g., P.A.D.S. Lunch Program, cleaning parks or public spaces). Simple
volunteerism is rewarding, team-building, and reflects favorably on the company in many cultures,
positing a down-to-earth “just folks” public image of the company without a huge commitment of
company resources beyond manpower.
 Skills-based volunteering – The CSR program coordinates with non-profit or needy
organizations to provide pro bono services (e.g., managed services to public schools, the
development of software to help women’s shelters). Skills-based volunteerism suggests a
company with a deep commitment to the community and can provide more value to the recipient
party than simple volunteerism since a more complex set of services can be donated.
 Partnered programs – The CSR program coordinates with existing business partners to provide
joint donations or skills-based volunteering to non-profit and needy organizations through jointly
sponsored social responsibility initiatives (e.g., provision of Microsoft software and technology
implementations to non-profits). When both organizations share similar corporate cultures and
goals, partnered social responsibility initiatives can produce positive and far-reaching results
through shared efforts.
Page 4
Structure and Operation of CSR Programs:
CSR programs vary structurally, both in how they align to the business strategy of the company, and in
how they are managed. An organization may find that a CSR program that reflects its corporate
structure, operation, and culture will be easiest to develop and deploy.
There is no “one size fits all” approach to creating a successful CSR program -- successful programs are
tailored to the organization and strengths of the company. While some programs are structurally or
operationally better suited for larger or smaller companies, and some programs are best aligned with
particular industries, the form of an organization’s CSR program ultimately depends on an organization’s
corporate culture and structure. Listed below are alternative structural and operational models for CSR
programs:
 Structural Models:
a) Corporate giving – Financial donations or in-kind goods and services are planned as an
expense during the company’s annual budgeting process and funded with pre-tax income.
Because money flows directly from the company to third party organizations, corporate giving
can resemble normal business transactions that serve the company’s business interest.
Thus, while corporate giving proves the easiest, most direct way to serve communities, some
cultures may interpret the practice as disingenuous.
b) Global corporate foundation – Social investments are channeled through a private charity
foundation, established by the company and managed as an autonomous organization.
Because the company does not receive any direct business benefit from the foundation’s
activities, company-specific foundations are often viewed as more authentic signs of
corporate social responsibility.
c) In-country corporate foundation – Domestic foundations serve ostensibly the same function
as an international foundation, but convey a strong sense of corporate responsibility at the
domestic level. Establishing separate foundations in multiple regions can prove time
intensive, however.
d) Some combination of the above
 Operational Models:
a) Centralized – The CSR program strategy and budget are decided and managed at company
headquarters. Centralization predicates operational simplicity, but runs the risk of
disempowering employees from getting involved in the program in a meaningful way.
b) Decentralized – Each company location is responsible for defining its own strategy and
managing its own budget. Empowering offices to control scaled CSR initiatives yields more
Page 5
efficient programs that address the interests of employees and their community. However,
the decentralized approach can be difficult to standardize across the company.
c) Strong regional management – Each region is allocated a budget and expected to pursue
initiatives defined by management at the local level. This “middle-ground” between
centralized and decentralized approaches allows for a unified direction for social
responsibility initiatives while providing reasonable autonomy for individual offices in their
approach to CSR.
Supplementary CSR Initiatives:
Organizations can demonstrate their commitment to corporate social responsibility in ways that do not require a
formal CSR program. These CSR “best practices” are not intended to replace comprehensive CSR programs,
but rather, can be used to augment established CSR programs.
 Ethics Policy – Updating a company’s ethics policy to ensure that it reflects an express commitment to
community service as an integral part of its ethical foundation.
 Multi-stakeholder initiatives – Collaborating with social partners (e.g., worker and employer
organizations, NGOs, other companies) to address specific CSR issues like good business practices
(e.g., anti-bribery) or sustainability practices (e.g., waste reduction).
 Certification and labeling – Submitting to auditing by accredited third parties and remediating areas of
noncompliance in exchange for positive and marketable certifications.
 Sectorial initiatives– Supporting sector or industry-wide initiatives that seek business solutions to
socioeconomic challenges (e.g., retail stores creating infrastructure to support and assist manufacturers
in Asia to upgrade facilitates to comply with better building codes). These may involve management of
the company’s supply chain and cooperation with its downstream suppliers.
 International Framework Agreements– Negotiating with national trade unions and global union
federations to create agreements that pledge that company standards are applied consistently on the
global scale within the company and within the company’s partners.
Initial Stepsto CSR Program Development
In reviewing written resources and conferring with subject matter experts, I learned that a successful CSR
program requires the support of the program at the highest level. Without executive backing and involvement,
good corporate CSR intentions can wither on the vine. Subject matter experts advocate identifying and building
upon the personal philanthropic interests of Board members and company executives as an effective strategy to
commence a CSR program build. By starting with a small and targeted CSR initiative that has executive
support, a company can use the success of this initial effort to evolve and grow into a larger CSR program.
Page 6
Perhaps the biggest danger for any small company, including Avanade, is the well-intentioned desire to meet
overambitious goals in unrealistic timeframes. Once a company has outlined a proposed business plan that
addresses the desired structure, operation and goals of its CSR program, the company should pilot the program
in a single office to understand strengths and weaknesses of the program and to make any necessary fixes
before the program is deployed on a larger scale. The SMEs with whom I spoke suggested that, to assist in
assuring the best-case outcome of the initial phases of a company-wide CSR program, the best performing,
best managed office should be the site of the trial program.
After successful deployment of the initial phases of a company-wide CSR program, a company can establish
goals and objectives for its CSR program growth. One such goal is the “1/1/1 Model.” Established by
Salesforce.com founder Marc Benioff and adopted by numerous technology companies, including Google, the
1/1/1 Model calls for the annual donation of 1% of company equity, 1% of company profit and 1% of employee
hours to charitable causes.
Ultimately, there is no single approach to creating a successful CSR program – CSR programs take all forms
and sizes depending on the industry, size, goals, and resources of the organization. My research suggests that
Avanade should identify a limited number of goals that enjoys executive sponsorship and has synergies with its
corporate culture, start small, and pilot a program in one or two of its offices. Replicating the successful parts
and remediating the gaps in the pilot program, Avanade can continue to build and grow a sustainable CSR
program. Avanade’s brand, its workforce, and the community all stand to benefit greatly from the successful
creation and deployment of a CSR program.

More Related Content

What's hot

Overview Of Fundrasing Methods
Overview Of Fundrasing MethodsOverview Of Fundrasing Methods
Overview Of Fundrasing Methodsvkmlaw
 
GAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docx
GAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docxGAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docx
GAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docxJaveGeneDeAquino1
 
AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua)
AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua) AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua)
AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua) Carla
 
Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...
Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...
Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...حمد بوجرادة
 
Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee
Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee
Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee jo bitonio
 
100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc
100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc
100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cchomeworkping7
 
Sample of a Community Development project proposal writing
Sample of a Community Development project proposal writingSample of a Community Development project proposal writing
Sample of a Community Development project proposal writingMariki Belingtone
 
ACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docx
ACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docxACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docx
ACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docxGlotelynSoriano1
 
Strategic Management Lecture 2
Strategic Management Lecture 2Strategic Management Lecture 2
Strategic Management Lecture 2jillmitchell8778
 
Lions Region Chairpersons
Lions Region ChairpersonsLions Region Chairpersons
Lions Region Chairpersonsm nagaRAJU
 
The Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil Service
The Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil ServiceThe Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil Service
The Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil ServiceDaisy Punzalan Bragais
 
minutes of meeting sample
minutes of meeting sampleminutes of meeting sample
minutes of meeting sampleEstrella Piccio
 
Strategic Restructuring Presentation
Strategic Restructuring PresentationStrategic Restructuring Presentation
Strategic Restructuring PresentationDaniel Schott
 
03 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 02
03 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 0203 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 02
03 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 02Flab Villasencio
 
DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)
DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)
DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)Lym Relampagos Ongoy
 
Diamond Chemicals
Diamond ChemicalsDiamond Chemicals
Diamond Chemicalsjsilmon
 
First day of service (substitute teacher)
First day of service (substitute teacher)First day of service (substitute teacher)
First day of service (substitute teacher)89o
 

What's hot (20)

Overview Of Fundrasing Methods
Overview Of Fundrasing MethodsOverview Of Fundrasing Methods
Overview Of Fundrasing Methods
 
GAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docx
GAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docxGAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docx
GAD-Plan-and-Budget-2023.docx
 
AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua)
AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua) AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua)
AC102 PPT8 - Partnership Liquidation Lump Sum (PPT from Sir Leandro Fua)
 
Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...
Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...
Quiz 5QUIZ strategic management concepts &cases 11th edition by Fred R. David...
 
Larong Pinoy Company Sports Fest
Larong Pinoy Company Sports FestLarong Pinoy Company Sports Fest
Larong Pinoy Company Sports Fest
 
Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee
Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee
Orientation for Cooperative in Education and Training Committee
 
100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc
100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc
100127520 partnership-midterm-reviewer-cc
 
The case analysis
The case analysisThe case analysis
The case analysis
 
Sample of a Community Development project proposal writing
Sample of a Community Development project proposal writingSample of a Community Development project proposal writing
Sample of a Community Development project proposal writing
 
ACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docx
ACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docxACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docx
ACTIVITY-COMPLETION-REPORT-TEMPLATE (1).docx
 
Strategic Management Lecture 2
Strategic Management Lecture 2Strategic Management Lecture 2
Strategic Management Lecture 2
 
Lions Region Chairpersons
Lions Region ChairpersonsLions Region Chairpersons
Lions Region Chairpersons
 
The Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil Service
The Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil ServiceThe Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil Service
The Administrative Disciplinary Process in the Philippine Civil Service
 
minutes of meeting sample
minutes of meeting sampleminutes of meeting sample
minutes of meeting sample
 
Strategy of the NGO
Strategy of the NGOStrategy of the NGO
Strategy of the NGO
 
Strategic Restructuring Presentation
Strategic Restructuring PresentationStrategic Restructuring Presentation
Strategic Restructuring Presentation
 
03 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 02
03 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 0203 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 02
03 chapter 4 deductions from gross estate part 02
 
DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)
DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)
DOLE Government Internship Program (GIP)
 
Diamond Chemicals
Diamond ChemicalsDiamond Chemicals
Diamond Chemicals
 
First day of service (substitute teacher)
First day of service (substitute teacher)First day of service (substitute teacher)
First day of service (substitute teacher)
 

Similar to CSR Memo (final1)

Corporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibilityCorporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibilityAayush Agarwal
 
State of community management 2014
State of community management 2014State of community management 2014
State of community management 2014Michelle Friesen
 
The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...
The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...
The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...iosrjce
 
Brochure_CSR Solutions
Brochure_CSR Solutions Brochure_CSR Solutions
Brochure_CSR Solutions FSPL
 
Project on Corporate social responsibility
Project on Corporate social responsibilityProject on Corporate social responsibility
Project on Corporate social responsibilitykabul university
 
Shipping and Sustainability Approach.docx
Shipping and Sustainability Approach.docxShipping and Sustainability Approach.docx
Shipping and Sustainability Approach.docxwrite12
 
CSR Value Continuum: Value Distribution to Value Creation
CSR Value Continuum:  Value Distribution to Value CreationCSR Value Continuum:  Value Distribution to Value Creation
CSR Value Continuum: Value Distribution to Value CreationWayne Dunn
 
PR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilities
PR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilitiesPR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilities
PR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilitiesRaja Sarkar
 
Corporate social responsibility infosys
Corporate social responsibility infosysCorporate social responsibility infosys
Corporate social responsibility infosysVrajBhavsar6
 
From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR
From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR
From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR greenkettleconsulting
 
Corporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibilityCorporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibilityJanStephanieRamos
 
The 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-Vacations
The 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-VacationsThe 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-Vacations
The 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-VacationsTseli Mohammed
 
What is social enterprise nccu cedi presentation
What is social enterprise nccu cedi presentationWhat is social enterprise nccu cedi presentation
What is social enterprise nccu cedi presentationJeff Stern
 
EVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPRO
EVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPROEVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPRO
EVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPROSudharshanE1
 
Opportunity analysis project
Opportunity analysis projectOpportunity analysis project
Opportunity analysis projectMaitri Sisodia
 
Corporate Social Responsibility
Corporate Social ResponsibilityCorporate Social Responsibility
Corporate Social ResponsibilityLarissa Long
 
The 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR Program
The 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR ProgramThe 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR Program
The 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR ProgramVardaan
 

Similar to CSR Memo (final1) (20)

Csr Essay
Csr EssayCsr Essay
Csr Essay
 
Corporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibilityCorporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibility
 
State of community management 2014
State of community management 2014State of community management 2014
State of community management 2014
 
Csr ebook
Csr ebookCsr ebook
Csr ebook
 
Csr chap 1 2
Csr chap 1 2Csr chap 1 2
Csr chap 1 2
 
The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...
The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...
The Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies and Activities Employed By the...
 
Brochure_CSR Solutions
Brochure_CSR Solutions Brochure_CSR Solutions
Brochure_CSR Solutions
 
Project on Corporate social responsibility
Project on Corporate social responsibilityProject on Corporate social responsibility
Project on Corporate social responsibility
 
Shipping and Sustainability Approach.docx
Shipping and Sustainability Approach.docxShipping and Sustainability Approach.docx
Shipping and Sustainability Approach.docx
 
CSR Value Continuum: Value Distribution to Value Creation
CSR Value Continuum:  Value Distribution to Value CreationCSR Value Continuum:  Value Distribution to Value Creation
CSR Value Continuum: Value Distribution to Value Creation
 
PR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilities
PR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilitiesPR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilities
PR and its role in communicating corporate social responsibilities
 
Corporate social responsibility infosys
Corporate social responsibility infosysCorporate social responsibility infosys
Corporate social responsibility infosys
 
From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR
From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR
From Ideas to Action - Planning for sustainable CSR
 
Corporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibilityCorporate social responsibility
Corporate social responsibility
 
The 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-Vacations
The 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-VacationsThe 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-Vacations
The 3V Initiative: Volunteer-Value-Vacations
 
What is social enterprise nccu cedi presentation
What is social enterprise nccu cedi presentationWhat is social enterprise nccu cedi presentation
What is social enterprise nccu cedi presentation
 
EVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPRO
EVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPROEVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPRO
EVALUATION OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ETHICS OF WIPRO
 
Opportunity analysis project
Opportunity analysis projectOpportunity analysis project
Opportunity analysis project
 
Corporate Social Responsibility
Corporate Social ResponsibilityCorporate Social Responsibility
Corporate Social Responsibility
 
The 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR Program
The 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR ProgramThe 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR Program
The 5 Elements of a Top-Notch CSR Program
 

CSR Memo (final1)

  • 1. 1 To: David Oskandy From: Max Drickey cc: Laurent Masson Date: April 15, 2015 Re: Envisioning a Corporate Citizenship Program for Avanade While corporate social responsibility programs (CSRs) have existed for many years, an increasing number of companies have implemented these programs in the last decade. These organizations recognize that CSR programs improve their: (i) reputation, (ii) competitive advantage, (iii) ability to retain and attract current and prospective employees, clients, customers or users, and (iv) relationships with suppliers, governments, and communities. Importantly, CSR programs foster cooperation and team spirit within an organization’s workforce, reinforce the messaging behind an organization’s code of conduct, and empower a company’s employees to take an ownership stake in the wellbeing of their community and their company. To date, industry leaders, including technology giants like Intel and Microsoft, have established some of the world’s most recognizable CSR programs. But companies in all industries and of all sizes have created successful and impactful CSR programs. Accordingly, smaller professional service providers like Avanade can make substantive contributions to their communities through targeted initiatives that leverage core strengths and values of the organization. By evaluating the CSR programs of some of Avanade’s competitors as well as the programs of other organizations that are similar in size and earnings to Avanade, Avanade can “cherry pick” from these CSR programs to construct its own customized CSR program that reflects its culture and values. This memo should be reviewed in tandem with the Corporate Citizenship Comparison excel spreadsheet previously provided.
  • 2. Page 2 Methodology Creating a Matrix of Characteristics for Sample CSR Programs To gain an understanding of how Avanade might construct its own CSR program, I researched comparable programs of other organizations to learn about the various types of arrangements that a CSR program could take. Given the enormous variety of CSR initiatives seen in the marketplace, I employed the following criteria to refine my research efforts, and to compare them against Avanade’s resources, strengths and priorities:  Size – The number of employees and net revenue of organizations were considered. Although company size does not necessarily dictate the scope or size of an organization’s CSR program, an organization’s revenue and workforce serves as a useful standard by which to assess the applicability of particular types of CSR initiatives to Avanade’s unique conditions and corporate environment.  Industry – Only organizations that focused on the creation of information technology products or services or the creation or management of information assets were considered. These companies typically share a pool of marketable skills.  Eminence – Only CSR programs that have been recognized by the Ethisphere Institute, a non- profit organization that annually identifies the world’s most ethical companies, or by CSR program subject matter experts1,2 as being impressive were considered.  Maturity – Only programs that have been operated successfully for more than 10 years with the support and sponsorship of the parent organizations were considered. Source Material To learn more about CSR programs, I examined the content and materials provided by the sources described below:  The Conference Board – An organization that provides reports and surveys detailing the types of CSR programs available to companies at various sizes and capacities, and outlines the preliminary steps necessary to start those programs.  The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development – An organization that provides reports that identify more unconventional ways of expanding a company’s CSR initiatives at an international level. 1 Benjamin Weinberg is theprobonopartnerat Dentons, managing thelaw firm’s substantialpro bonoprogram. Prior to his employmentat Dentons, he servedas thechief of the Illinois AttorneyGeneral’sPublicInterest Division, overseeing major litigation in the publicintereston such issuesascivilrights, disabilityrights, and publicutilities. 2 Deb Krause servesastheSteeringCommittee Chair of Mercer’sGlobalCommunity Caresfoundation. She was previouslyemployed at UnitedHealthGroup astheDirectorof theOffice of SocialResponsibility.
  • 3. Page 3  Boston College Center for Corporate Citizenship – An organization that provides data on the benefits of CSR programs to businesses and provides information about the current state of CSR initiatives.  Points of Light – An organization that provides information on economy-wide challenges to improve CSR initiatives, and supplies basic resources useful to establishing a CSR program within an organization.  Subject matter experts – Experienced individuals who have created or managed several CSR programs within multiple organizations and industries shared experience and know-how. These SMEs identified “best in class” CSR programs and other information and resources for research and comparative purposes.  Websites of existing CSR programs – Websites of the established CSR initiatives of companies that describe these programs enabled me to understand the various CSR programmatic approaches. Some website provide knowledge-sharing content to assist organizations create new CSR programs (e.g., Salesforce Foundation). Types of CSR Programs: At the most basic level, CSR programs differ from company to company in the way that they support and interface with non-profit organizations:  Financial contributions – The CSR program facilitates the donation of financial resources to non-profit organizations directly or promotes employee donations via a matched contribution program.  Volunteering – The CSR program coordinates with non-profit or needy organizations to establish days of service (e.g., P.A.D.S. Lunch Program, cleaning parks or public spaces). Simple volunteerism is rewarding, team-building, and reflects favorably on the company in many cultures, positing a down-to-earth “just folks” public image of the company without a huge commitment of company resources beyond manpower.  Skills-based volunteering – The CSR program coordinates with non-profit or needy organizations to provide pro bono services (e.g., managed services to public schools, the development of software to help women’s shelters). Skills-based volunteerism suggests a company with a deep commitment to the community and can provide more value to the recipient party than simple volunteerism since a more complex set of services can be donated.  Partnered programs – The CSR program coordinates with existing business partners to provide joint donations or skills-based volunteering to non-profit and needy organizations through jointly sponsored social responsibility initiatives (e.g., provision of Microsoft software and technology implementations to non-profits). When both organizations share similar corporate cultures and goals, partnered social responsibility initiatives can produce positive and far-reaching results through shared efforts.
  • 4. Page 4 Structure and Operation of CSR Programs: CSR programs vary structurally, both in how they align to the business strategy of the company, and in how they are managed. An organization may find that a CSR program that reflects its corporate structure, operation, and culture will be easiest to develop and deploy. There is no “one size fits all” approach to creating a successful CSR program -- successful programs are tailored to the organization and strengths of the company. While some programs are structurally or operationally better suited for larger or smaller companies, and some programs are best aligned with particular industries, the form of an organization’s CSR program ultimately depends on an organization’s corporate culture and structure. Listed below are alternative structural and operational models for CSR programs:  Structural Models: a) Corporate giving – Financial donations or in-kind goods and services are planned as an expense during the company’s annual budgeting process and funded with pre-tax income. Because money flows directly from the company to third party organizations, corporate giving can resemble normal business transactions that serve the company’s business interest. Thus, while corporate giving proves the easiest, most direct way to serve communities, some cultures may interpret the practice as disingenuous. b) Global corporate foundation – Social investments are channeled through a private charity foundation, established by the company and managed as an autonomous organization. Because the company does not receive any direct business benefit from the foundation’s activities, company-specific foundations are often viewed as more authentic signs of corporate social responsibility. c) In-country corporate foundation – Domestic foundations serve ostensibly the same function as an international foundation, but convey a strong sense of corporate responsibility at the domestic level. Establishing separate foundations in multiple regions can prove time intensive, however. d) Some combination of the above  Operational Models: a) Centralized – The CSR program strategy and budget are decided and managed at company headquarters. Centralization predicates operational simplicity, but runs the risk of disempowering employees from getting involved in the program in a meaningful way. b) Decentralized – Each company location is responsible for defining its own strategy and managing its own budget. Empowering offices to control scaled CSR initiatives yields more
  • 5. Page 5 efficient programs that address the interests of employees and their community. However, the decentralized approach can be difficult to standardize across the company. c) Strong regional management – Each region is allocated a budget and expected to pursue initiatives defined by management at the local level. This “middle-ground” between centralized and decentralized approaches allows for a unified direction for social responsibility initiatives while providing reasonable autonomy for individual offices in their approach to CSR. Supplementary CSR Initiatives: Organizations can demonstrate their commitment to corporate social responsibility in ways that do not require a formal CSR program. These CSR “best practices” are not intended to replace comprehensive CSR programs, but rather, can be used to augment established CSR programs.  Ethics Policy – Updating a company’s ethics policy to ensure that it reflects an express commitment to community service as an integral part of its ethical foundation.  Multi-stakeholder initiatives – Collaborating with social partners (e.g., worker and employer organizations, NGOs, other companies) to address specific CSR issues like good business practices (e.g., anti-bribery) or sustainability practices (e.g., waste reduction).  Certification and labeling – Submitting to auditing by accredited third parties and remediating areas of noncompliance in exchange for positive and marketable certifications.  Sectorial initiatives– Supporting sector or industry-wide initiatives that seek business solutions to socioeconomic challenges (e.g., retail stores creating infrastructure to support and assist manufacturers in Asia to upgrade facilitates to comply with better building codes). These may involve management of the company’s supply chain and cooperation with its downstream suppliers.  International Framework Agreements– Negotiating with national trade unions and global union federations to create agreements that pledge that company standards are applied consistently on the global scale within the company and within the company’s partners. Initial Stepsto CSR Program Development In reviewing written resources and conferring with subject matter experts, I learned that a successful CSR program requires the support of the program at the highest level. Without executive backing and involvement, good corporate CSR intentions can wither on the vine. Subject matter experts advocate identifying and building upon the personal philanthropic interests of Board members and company executives as an effective strategy to commence a CSR program build. By starting with a small and targeted CSR initiative that has executive support, a company can use the success of this initial effort to evolve and grow into a larger CSR program.
  • 6. Page 6 Perhaps the biggest danger for any small company, including Avanade, is the well-intentioned desire to meet overambitious goals in unrealistic timeframes. Once a company has outlined a proposed business plan that addresses the desired structure, operation and goals of its CSR program, the company should pilot the program in a single office to understand strengths and weaknesses of the program and to make any necessary fixes before the program is deployed on a larger scale. The SMEs with whom I spoke suggested that, to assist in assuring the best-case outcome of the initial phases of a company-wide CSR program, the best performing, best managed office should be the site of the trial program. After successful deployment of the initial phases of a company-wide CSR program, a company can establish goals and objectives for its CSR program growth. One such goal is the “1/1/1 Model.” Established by Salesforce.com founder Marc Benioff and adopted by numerous technology companies, including Google, the 1/1/1 Model calls for the annual donation of 1% of company equity, 1% of company profit and 1% of employee hours to charitable causes. Ultimately, there is no single approach to creating a successful CSR program – CSR programs take all forms and sizes depending on the industry, size, goals, and resources of the organization. My research suggests that Avanade should identify a limited number of goals that enjoys executive sponsorship and has synergies with its corporate culture, start small, and pilot a program in one or two of its offices. Replicating the successful parts and remediating the gaps in the pilot program, Avanade can continue to build and grow a sustainable CSR program. Avanade’s brand, its workforce, and the community all stand to benefit greatly from the successful creation and deployment of a CSR program.