Page 1                                                                                   December 2010




From The President


T
          he U.S. has just come through another             • Notes From Pakistan.................. 2
         spirited election cycle and another                • On a Mission to Fund a Vision... 2
         demonstration of the vitality of our
democracy. Yet for many of us, the divisive tone            • Testimonials from Richard Land,
and tenor of the election was dispiriting. And                Anita Dunn, Senator Harris
just as importantly, this election seems unlikely             Wofford, and Kelly Johnston..... 3
to inspire a capacity for cooperative problem               • Convergence Briefs: Movements
solving that is equal to the economic, social, and            on Wellness Project; USMEI
security challenges the nation now faces.                     Receives Mellon Grant............... 4
In his book To Heal A Fractured World,                      • Expanding Horizons.................... 4
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks writes:
   “At the heart of divisiveness and polarization is a terrible fear,
   a sense of abandonment, and a failure of optimism and
   courage… too much anger and vituperation; too much speaking
   and too little listening; too much condemnation and too little
   understanding; too much self-righteousness and too little
   humility; and too much preoccupation with our fears and
                                                                              Convergence
   pains, too little attention to others' fears and pains.”                   Community
Working with many of you, Convergence seeks to be in the                      Expands
vanguard of addressing the conditions Rabbi Sacks so eloquently
identifies as causing unnecessary and costly division and                     ...And We Thank
polarization. As a nation, we are yet to institutionalize capacity to
resolve problems in a manner that maximizes listening, empathy,               You
and understanding. We have not learned to hear one another so
that our real, and not imagined, differences can be used to generate          You are an essential
better ideas and solutions than those held by advocates of any one            part of the
perspective.                                                                  Convergence
There are no simple or comprehensive solutions for how to engage              Community,
our collective intelligence to work for the common good.                      supporting us
Convergence has no illusions about its ability alone to reverse a             financially, making
troubling loss of civility and mutual respect in our political system.        valuable connections
Yet, with a strong leadership group and talented partners,                    on our behalf, sharing
including many of you, we are working to take our vision to scale to
address major issues of the day. This newsletter provides a glimpse
                                                                              your ideas and
of what we are undertaking and how we are doing so. We welcome                inspirations—without
your input and involvement.                                                   you we would not be
                                                                              here!
We wish all of you a prosperous and peaceful holiday season.
                               ~Robert Fersh, Founder and President

      Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org
Page 2                                                                                                            December 2010

Notes From Pakistan
Convergence is partnering with three other non-profit organizations to conduct the U.S.- Pakistan
Leaders Forum, a three-year initiative of dialogue among civil society leaders to create
understanding, partnerships and cooperative projects to the benefit of both countries. The Forum is
a part of the larger U.S.- Muslim Engagement Initiative. To help organize the first Forum meeting in
Lahore in February 2011, David Fairman of the Consensus Building Institute (and Convergence
Leadership Council) and Aakif Ahmad of Convergence arrived in Islamabad, Pakistan on September
26 for a weeklong series of interviews with civil society leaders across the country. The goal was to
understand the primary concerns and perceptions of Pakistani leaders about their own society and
their relationship with the U.S., and assess the level of Pakistani leadership interest in and support
for the Forum. This is Aakif’s first-hand report.
We traveled to three cities in six days and met with over fifty Nearly all of the Pakistani leaders expressed strong
                                 influential Pakistanis in media,        interest in the idea of a U.S.-Pakistan Leaders Forum
                                 education, energy, agriculture,         to bring civil society leaders together for dialogue and
                                 business, finance, health and social    partnership building. Many commented that such an
                                 services, conflict resolution, national initiative is “long overdue” and “urgently needed” as a
                                 security, law, local and provincial     way for Pakistanis and Americans outside of
                                 governance, and key officials at the    government to address negative perceptions, identify
                                 U.S. Embassy. Fortunately, the roads areas of common interest, and build new partnerships.
                                 are much improved in Pakistan these Many told us: “We wish you had come ten years ago.”
                                 days, yet we appreciated our two able
                                                                         David and I considered this a very productive trip. We
                                 consultants, one who doubled as an
                                                                         were very encouraged by the enthusiastic response we
                                 expert driver, as we rushed from one
                                                                         received, including among the more conservative
                                 meeting to the next in bustling city
                                                                         elements of the country; and we were impressed by the
    Aakif Ahmad and David         and suburban environments flanked
  Fairman in Karachi visiting                                            vibrant entrepreneurship and problem-solving
 the Minister for Youth Affairs, by SUV’s, motorbikes, rickshaws         orientation of many we met. “Our system is tough to
      Mr. Faisal Sabswari         and cyclists.
                                                                         work in, but we can do the work,” one leader said. “But
Many Pakistani leaders we met with expressed strong                      you have the
concern on three issues: national and local governance; flood best practices,
recovery and underlying economic and social challenges;                  the skills, and
and national security issues. They also reflected a range of             the training
views and concerns on Pakistan’s relationship with the U.S.              that we can
                                                                         learn from
Most leaders said the relationship between the Pakistani and and…we also
the U.S. government was seriously flawed. At the same time, have a thing
they stressed that many Pakistanis have positive views of the or two to
U.S. for its economic opportunities, educational system,
                                                                         teach,” he said,       Aakif Ahmad and David Fairman in Lahore
culture of hard work and individual responsibility, and                                          visiting six former Mayors in the State of
                                                                         smiling.               Punjab, including former Mayor of Lahore,
personal freedoms—values that many Pakistanis believe the                                                Mr. Mian Amer Mehmood
two societies share and can form the basis for greater
cooperation for mutual interest and benefit.                             David and I believe this can be the basis for positive
                                                                                                    cooperation, improved
On A Mission to Fund A Vision                                                                          understanding, and more
                                                                                                        positive relations over time.
You are invited to make a year-end contribution and play a part in our                                  The next step is to return to
Campaign for Convergence. Our goal is to raise $2.5M in gifts and multi-year                            Pakistan (February 2011)
pledges by July 1, 2011, to develop at least three breakthrough solutions over                          with twenty or so American
the next three years. This process will exemplify a better way to reach                                 leaders to meet with twenty
intelligent solutions that most Americans will support.                                                 Pakistani counterparts. The
                                                                                                        concentration will be in the
Join our community by becoming a:
                                                                                                        areas of education (including
Champion ($5,000 and up)                            Patron ($2,500-$4,999)
                                                                                                        job training and youth
Benefactor ($1,000-$2,499)                          Supporter ($500-$999)
                                                                                                        leadership) and agriculture,
Friend (up to $499)                                 Sustaining Member (monthly donation)
                                                                                                        with crosscutting discussion
Your gift provides essential and timely seed funding for                                                of governance, media, and
Convergence—funding we can leverage to attract additional                                               overall perception issues.
funding. Please give as generously as you can. Convergence is a                                         We look forward to updating
501(c) 3 charitable organization. All donations are deductible to the you with the results of the
                                                                                                        Forum’s first meeting in the
full extent of the law.
                                                                                                        next newsletter. We welcome
http://cnvg.org/Donate.html or mail a check to Convergence                                              your thoughts and feedback.

        Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org
Page 3                                                                                  December 2010

Presenters at Recent Convergence
Leadership Council Meeting
                     Rev. Richard Land                                         Anita Dunn
                     President, Ethics &                                       Senior Partner,
                     Religious Liberty                                         Squier Knapp Dunn
                     Commission, Southern                                      Communications
                     Baptist Convention                                       “Convergence is a good
                     "I was pleased to be part of the                         idea at the right time.
                     US-Muslim Engagement                                     With policy debates so
                     Project, which demonstrated                              charged and politicized
                     the ability of people of very                            today, the country needs
differing backgrounds and perspectives to find          places where people with differing and
important common ground on a crucial national           conflicting views can actually talk with, not
issue. Now, I wholeheartedly support the                past, each other to solve problems. I wish
approach of Convergence and am pleased to be            Convergence success in its efforts to fill this
part of it. When people ask me how to build             important need.”
bridges to the Southern Baptist Convention, my
answer is always simple—just talk with us.
Whether it is international issues involving
violence, or domestic issues where tempers run
high, I am partial to the Winston Churchill quote,
‘to jaw-jaw is always better than to war-war.'"

In Their Own Words: From Our LC Members
                    The Honorable                                             Kelly Johnston
                    Harris Wofford,                                           Vice President,
                    Former U.S. Senator,                                      Government Affairs,
                    Pennsylvania                                              Campbell Soup
                     “Although I have witnessed                               Company
                     many instances of strange                                "In a sense, Convergence
                     bedfellows working together                              to me is like an alcoholic
                     over the years, my specific                              recovery organization.
                     introduction to policy                                   That’s because prior to
consensus-building came from working with my            my joining the private sector, I spent a good
former political adversary Rick Santorum on             part of my career being part of the problem in
community and faith-based approaches to poverty         Washington–advancing partisan solutions
alleviation. That process, in the 2001-2 period,        for political gain. Moving to the private sector
demonstrated to me that even groups with                and in search of bipartisan solutions, I
contentious differences could find ways to work         realized the gridlock and distrust I had
together. This is one reason why I am so                helped foment. Convergence is the answer.
supportive of and involved with Convergence.            Convergence is for serious, public-spirited
Given the challenges we face and the frustrations       people to openly dialogue respectfully and
with the current state of politics, Convergence         inspire trust without surrendering one’s
may be coming along at just the right juncture          passions and beliefs. Convergence is about
where history and opportunity merge for a new           inspiring and generating new directions and
level of national problem solving.”                     aligning with creative new approaches to
                                                        some of our most intractable issues. It is a
                                                        breath of fresh air in the public arena, and its
                                                        time is now."
      Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org
Page 4                                                                                           December 2010

                       Convergence Takes on Wellness
• CONVERGENCE BRIEFS   Convergence seeks to convene an unprecedented dialogue-
                       leading-to-action among the leading voices and concerned parties
                       on food, nutrition and health, especially including those with
                       divergent views and incentives. The project had an outstanding
                       kick-off planning meeting November 15. Participating were
                       former Governors Tommy Thompson and Mike Dukakis and
                       representatives of a wide range of stakeholders including the food
                       industry, consumer and community leaders, health care groups,
                       pharmaceutical companies and others.

                       USMEI Receives Mellon Grant
                       Convergence is proud to announce an $85,000 grant from the
                       Andrew W. Mellon Foundation to support the U.S.-Muslim
                       Engagement Initiative. The grant will be dedicated to support a
                       full-time post-doctoral fellow in the humanities for a year to work
                       on the U.S.-Muslim Engagement Initiative’s research and
                       programmatic activities.
                                                             It Takes a Visionary to Back a Big Idea
                          You are invited to join the Convergence Founders Circle—a group of generous
                          people who believe that diverse perspectives, knowledge and experience generate the
                          creative tensions necessary for groundbreaking solutions that inspire broad support.
                          Founders Circle members contribute a minimum of $10,000 a year for 3 years for a total of
                          $30,000. Founders Circle members receive invitations to issue-based Briefings and the
                          Annual Founders’ Circle Event, print and online recognition, including a list on a
                          permanent plaque at Convergence headquarters.
                          For more information, contact Lyn Bazzell at lynbazzell@cnvg.org.




Expanding Horizons
Convergence Captures Hearts and Minds
We represented our vision at the following venues this year:
     •     Association for Conflict Resolution, Chicago, September 2010
     •     US Summit for Citizen Diplomacy, Washington, DC, November 2010
     •     Organization of Pakistani Entrepreneurs of North America (OPEN), Houston, December 2010
     •     No Labels Founder's Meeting, New York, December 2010
     •     Greater Baltimore Committee, Baltimore, December 2010



               Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org

Convergence News-December 2010

  • 1.
    Page 1 December 2010 From The President T he U.S. has just come through another • Notes From Pakistan.................. 2 spirited election cycle and another • On a Mission to Fund a Vision... 2 demonstration of the vitality of our democracy. Yet for many of us, the divisive tone • Testimonials from Richard Land, and tenor of the election was dispiriting. And Anita Dunn, Senator Harris just as importantly, this election seems unlikely Wofford, and Kelly Johnston..... 3 to inspire a capacity for cooperative problem • Convergence Briefs: Movements solving that is equal to the economic, social, and on Wellness Project; USMEI security challenges the nation now faces. Receives Mellon Grant............... 4 In his book To Heal A Fractured World, • Expanding Horizons.................... 4 Rabbi Jonathan Sacks writes: “At the heart of divisiveness and polarization is a terrible fear, a sense of abandonment, and a failure of optimism and courage… too much anger and vituperation; too much speaking and too little listening; too much condemnation and too little understanding; too much self-righteousness and too little humility; and too much preoccupation with our fears and Convergence pains, too little attention to others' fears and pains.” Community Working with many of you, Convergence seeks to be in the Expands vanguard of addressing the conditions Rabbi Sacks so eloquently identifies as causing unnecessary and costly division and ...And We Thank polarization. As a nation, we are yet to institutionalize capacity to resolve problems in a manner that maximizes listening, empathy, You and understanding. We have not learned to hear one another so that our real, and not imagined, differences can be used to generate You are an essential better ideas and solutions than those held by advocates of any one part of the perspective. Convergence There are no simple or comprehensive solutions for how to engage Community, our collective intelligence to work for the common good. supporting us Convergence has no illusions about its ability alone to reverse a financially, making troubling loss of civility and mutual respect in our political system. valuable connections Yet, with a strong leadership group and talented partners, on our behalf, sharing including many of you, we are working to take our vision to scale to address major issues of the day. This newsletter provides a glimpse your ideas and of what we are undertaking and how we are doing so. We welcome inspirations—without your input and involvement. you we would not be here! We wish all of you a prosperous and peaceful holiday season. ~Robert Fersh, Founder and President Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org
  • 2.
    Page 2 December 2010 Notes From Pakistan Convergence is partnering with three other non-profit organizations to conduct the U.S.- Pakistan Leaders Forum, a three-year initiative of dialogue among civil society leaders to create understanding, partnerships and cooperative projects to the benefit of both countries. The Forum is a part of the larger U.S.- Muslim Engagement Initiative. To help organize the first Forum meeting in Lahore in February 2011, David Fairman of the Consensus Building Institute (and Convergence Leadership Council) and Aakif Ahmad of Convergence arrived in Islamabad, Pakistan on September 26 for a weeklong series of interviews with civil society leaders across the country. The goal was to understand the primary concerns and perceptions of Pakistani leaders about their own society and their relationship with the U.S., and assess the level of Pakistani leadership interest in and support for the Forum. This is Aakif’s first-hand report. We traveled to three cities in six days and met with over fifty Nearly all of the Pakistani leaders expressed strong influential Pakistanis in media, interest in the idea of a U.S.-Pakistan Leaders Forum education, energy, agriculture, to bring civil society leaders together for dialogue and business, finance, health and social partnership building. Many commented that such an services, conflict resolution, national initiative is “long overdue” and “urgently needed” as a security, law, local and provincial way for Pakistanis and Americans outside of governance, and key officials at the government to address negative perceptions, identify U.S. Embassy. Fortunately, the roads areas of common interest, and build new partnerships. are much improved in Pakistan these Many told us: “We wish you had come ten years ago.” days, yet we appreciated our two able David and I considered this a very productive trip. We consultants, one who doubled as an were very encouraged by the enthusiastic response we expert driver, as we rushed from one received, including among the more conservative meeting to the next in bustling city elements of the country; and we were impressed by the Aakif Ahmad and David and suburban environments flanked Fairman in Karachi visiting vibrant entrepreneurship and problem-solving the Minister for Youth Affairs, by SUV’s, motorbikes, rickshaws orientation of many we met. “Our system is tough to Mr. Faisal Sabswari and cyclists. work in, but we can do the work,” one leader said. “But Many Pakistani leaders we met with expressed strong you have the concern on three issues: national and local governance; flood best practices, recovery and underlying economic and social challenges; the skills, and and national security issues. They also reflected a range of the training views and concerns on Pakistan’s relationship with the U.S. that we can learn from Most leaders said the relationship between the Pakistani and and…we also the U.S. government was seriously flawed. At the same time, have a thing they stressed that many Pakistanis have positive views of the or two to U.S. for its economic opportunities, educational system, teach,” he said, Aakif Ahmad and David Fairman in Lahore culture of hard work and individual responsibility, and visiting six former Mayors in the State of smiling. Punjab, including former Mayor of Lahore, personal freedoms—values that many Pakistanis believe the Mr. Mian Amer Mehmood two societies share and can form the basis for greater cooperation for mutual interest and benefit. David and I believe this can be the basis for positive cooperation, improved On A Mission to Fund A Vision understanding, and more positive relations over time. You are invited to make a year-end contribution and play a part in our The next step is to return to Campaign for Convergence. Our goal is to raise $2.5M in gifts and multi-year Pakistan (February 2011) pledges by July 1, 2011, to develop at least three breakthrough solutions over with twenty or so American the next three years. This process will exemplify a better way to reach leaders to meet with twenty intelligent solutions that most Americans will support. Pakistani counterparts. The concentration will be in the Join our community by becoming a: areas of education (including Champion ($5,000 and up) Patron ($2,500-$4,999) job training and youth Benefactor ($1,000-$2,499) Supporter ($500-$999) leadership) and agriculture, Friend (up to $499) Sustaining Member (monthly donation) with crosscutting discussion Your gift provides essential and timely seed funding for of governance, media, and Convergence—funding we can leverage to attract additional overall perception issues. funding. Please give as generously as you can. Convergence is a We look forward to updating 501(c) 3 charitable organization. All donations are deductible to the you with the results of the Forum’s first meeting in the full extent of the law. next newsletter. We welcome http://cnvg.org/Donate.html or mail a check to Convergence your thoughts and feedback. Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org
  • 3.
    Page 3 December 2010 Presenters at Recent Convergence Leadership Council Meeting Rev. Richard Land Anita Dunn President, Ethics & Senior Partner, Religious Liberty Squier Knapp Dunn Commission, Southern Communications Baptist Convention “Convergence is a good "I was pleased to be part of the idea at the right time. US-Muslim Engagement With policy debates so Project, which demonstrated charged and politicized the ability of people of very today, the country needs differing backgrounds and perspectives to find places where people with differing and important common ground on a crucial national conflicting views can actually talk with, not issue. Now, I wholeheartedly support the past, each other to solve problems. I wish approach of Convergence and am pleased to be Convergence success in its efforts to fill this part of it. When people ask me how to build important need.” bridges to the Southern Baptist Convention, my answer is always simple—just talk with us. Whether it is international issues involving violence, or domestic issues where tempers run high, I am partial to the Winston Churchill quote, ‘to jaw-jaw is always better than to war-war.'" In Their Own Words: From Our LC Members The Honorable Kelly Johnston Harris Wofford, Vice President, Former U.S. Senator, Government Affairs, Pennsylvania Campbell Soup “Although I have witnessed Company many instances of strange "In a sense, Convergence bedfellows working together to me is like an alcoholic over the years, my specific recovery organization. introduction to policy That’s because prior to consensus-building came from working with my my joining the private sector, I spent a good former political adversary Rick Santorum on part of my career being part of the problem in community and faith-based approaches to poverty Washington–advancing partisan solutions alleviation. That process, in the 2001-2 period, for political gain. Moving to the private sector demonstrated to me that even groups with and in search of bipartisan solutions, I contentious differences could find ways to work realized the gridlock and distrust I had together. This is one reason why I am so helped foment. Convergence is the answer. supportive of and involved with Convergence. Convergence is for serious, public-spirited Given the challenges we face and the frustrations people to openly dialogue respectfully and with the current state of politics, Convergence inspire trust without surrendering one’s may be coming along at just the right juncture passions and beliefs. Convergence is about where history and opportunity merge for a new inspiring and generating new directions and level of national problem solving.” aligning with creative new approaches to some of our most intractable issues. It is a breath of fresh air in the public arena, and its time is now." Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org
  • 4.
    Page 4 December 2010 Convergence Takes on Wellness • CONVERGENCE BRIEFS Convergence seeks to convene an unprecedented dialogue- leading-to-action among the leading voices and concerned parties on food, nutrition and health, especially including those with divergent views and incentives. The project had an outstanding kick-off planning meeting November 15. Participating were former Governors Tommy Thompson and Mike Dukakis and representatives of a wide range of stakeholders including the food industry, consumer and community leaders, health care groups, pharmaceutical companies and others. USMEI Receives Mellon Grant Convergence is proud to announce an $85,000 grant from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation to support the U.S.-Muslim Engagement Initiative. The grant will be dedicated to support a full-time post-doctoral fellow in the humanities for a year to work on the U.S.-Muslim Engagement Initiative’s research and programmatic activities. It Takes a Visionary to Back a Big Idea You are invited to join the Convergence Founders Circle—a group of generous people who believe that diverse perspectives, knowledge and experience generate the creative tensions necessary for groundbreaking solutions that inspire broad support. Founders Circle members contribute a minimum of $10,000 a year for 3 years for a total of $30,000. Founders Circle members receive invitations to issue-based Briefings and the Annual Founders’ Circle Event, print and online recognition, including a list on a permanent plaque at Convergence headquarters. For more information, contact Lyn Bazzell at lynbazzell@cnvg.org. Expanding Horizons Convergence Captures Hearts and Minds We represented our vision at the following venues this year: • Association for Conflict Resolution, Chicago, September 2010 • US Summit for Citizen Diplomacy, Washington, DC, November 2010 • Organization of Pakistani Entrepreneurs of North America (OPEN), Houston, December 2010 • No Labels Founder's Meeting, New York, December 2010 • Greater Baltimore Committee, Baltimore, December 2010 Convergence | 1333 New Hampshire Ave, NW | Washington, DC 20036 | 202.419.3951 | www.cnvg.org