SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Bill Maher has about as good a grasp in his interpretation of authentic religion as Charles
Manson had on his interpretation of the Beatles' Helter Skelter.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtbiIzK7AXI
Bill, Christianity has its own critique of jingoistic, militaristic, homophobes and doesn't need
assistance from you, who, like Dennett, Dawkins, Harris and Hitchens, have never been
philosophically rigorous or theologically interesting. You are all superficial atheists who
engage superficial theists, ironically, on their own fundamentalistic terms. You are in no
position, therefore, to determine who is ignoring rather than interpreting Scripture and
Tradition.
No, a Christian does not rejoice in war and does not take revenge. Yes, a Christian may use
coercive force to defend innocents, including self. It is much too facile and way too cynical
to cursorily dismiss 2,000 years of Christian ethical reflection on nonviolence as a simple
squaring of a circle or a mere lawyering of the Bible.
Regarding who may be Christ followers versus "just fans," well Bill, charitably, we've always
left that distinction to Someone Else. Finally, you might want to stick with social and political
comedy and stay away from the topic of religion, where you are being far too, in a word,
religulous. You are embarassing - not just yourself, but - Camus, Feuerbach, Hobbes, Hume,
Nietzsche, Russell, Sartre and Voltaire.
+++
John N Veronica
The distinction between a Christ-follower and a Christ-fan, in my view, speaks directly to
one's relationship with God vis a vis sin, hence my reluctance to frame the issue in that way.
This does not mean that we cannot discern and proclaim another's behavior as a failure to
cooperate with grace, only that we cannot ever know whether that failure results from
ignorance, poor formation or even de-formative influences, or from an outright refusal (sin).
Neither does it mean that such a failure should not be confronted and perhaps interdicted.
Because human morality is transparent to human reason without the benefit of any special
revelation, it is sufficient to draw distinctions between immoral and moral, ethical and
unethical, useful and unhelpful, behaviors without couching them (naively & facilely) in
explicitly theological categories.

The Christian unitive norms of love are well suited to moral and practical ends but their aims
otherwise transcend merely moral concerns and thus exemplify extraordinary virtue, thus
going beyond the universal norms of justice and ordinary virtue. The martyrs are therefore
extolled as widely recognized saints, but that doesn't mean that us run-of-the-mill anawim
are necessarily "just fans" because we choose to defend innocents or maybe even
ourselves.
1
More people DO need to speak out and challenge immoral and unethical, unhelpful and
ignorant, messages and behaviors but the pejorative use of fraught labels, especially where
we enjoy so little consensus regarding their meaning, should be avoided. A great deal of the
confusion, as I see it, results from poor critical thinking and philosophical category errors
(confusion between the methods of science, philosophy, culture and religion), so I tend to
address those, presuming ignorance but not malice.

It is not sufficient that Bill Maher be right in THAT religious fundamentalism is incorrect and
a problem, even a real danger. It is also necessary that he gets right exactly WHY it is
incorrect (and it is not because the religious fundamentalists' literal readings of Scripture are
not logically consistent with the Enlightenment fundamentalists' literal readings of
Scripture, for example). Rather than subvert religious fundamentalism, Maher dignifies it on
its own terms because he fails to understand why it is in error. Both religious and
Enlightenment fundamentalists need to accomplish the same paradigm shift, which draws
methodological distinctions between descriptive sciences, normative philosophies and
interpretive religions. (One has to feel sorry for some of the NALT atheists, too. Maybe they,
too, need to beef up their challenge of their own petty, narrow-minded and militant
cohort.)

Finally, even when one so happens to be right, and of course Maher is right regarding some
immoral behaviors, there is a RIGHT way to be right. People may not be able to strictly
define it but they know meanness when they hear and/or see it.
19 minutes ago · Like
John N Veronica I understand and appreciate complaints aimed at extremists on both Left
and Right but resist any broad generalizations re: secular vs religious, liberal vs conservative,
left vs right, and so on. I prefer to engage the best a tradition has to offer and not its worst
elements, authentic representatives and not caricatures.
2 seconds ago · Like
I am curious: How can you be a follower of Christ's teachings and at the same time justify
violence (even for self-defense)? You might be a follower of the church which would allow
certain exceptions but how is it possible to ignore "turn the other cheek" and "love your
enemies"?

Doesn't be a follower of someone mean to follow THEIR words and not the reflec ons
by other people in the following years?
2
Please don't consider my remarks as insults. I am really looking for an answer.
compassionatevegan 55 minutes ago

@compassionatevegan Some say His words apply more so to some eschatological
(future) realization of Kingdom values & not immediately. Others say His imperatives &
injunctives apply more so to a personal vocation & not political statecraft. That DOES sound
like lawyering! Jesus' words were not ambiguous. Pacifism, martyrdom and nonviolence
conform to the pattern of His Life and Teachings and are esteemed vocations. But following
isn't a simple either-or reality; rather, it is realized in degrees.
wfb2008rip 23 minutes ago

@compassionatevegan Continuing - So, in my view, there can be no theoretical
theological capitulation. What is encouraged sometimes, though, is a practical, pastoral
accommodation to human weakness. At the same time, Jesus is inviting us to extraordinary
virtue, to the unitive norms of love, which exceed the demands of justice. These go beyond
our universal moral norms, where self-defense is s ll ethical & part of ordinary virtue. One
does the best one can. Perfection isn't required.
wfb2008rip 14 minutes ago

@compassionatevegan We do not need special religious revelations to live a good &
ethical life because morality is transparent to all human reasoning. What differentiates the
Gospel in the marketplace, then, is not its moral teachings but, rather, the Good News that
the universe was both created & is far friendlier than one could ever imagine (b/c reality is
far too ambiguous for us & ambivalent toward us for us to otherwise draw such a
conclusion). God is Abba, Daddy, is the primary take-away!
wfb2008rip 6 minutes ago

@compassionatevegan Finally, rather than answering What can I know? (describing
reality) or What must I do? (norming reality), religion addresses What might I hope for?
Descriptive science answers: What's that? Evaluative cultures: What's that to us? Normative
philosophy: How might we best acquire/avoid that? Interpretive religion: How do we tie (religate) this all together? And it doesn't get to make up the answers to the 1st 3 ques ons.
It goes beyond but not without them. Hope this helps.

3
wfb2008rip 3 seconds ago

There are ~38,000 Chris an denomina ons. Who in their right mind imagines that
anyone speaks for us all? or that there is a consensus definition, even, of Christ-follower or
Christ-like?

wfb2008rip 1 hour ago

4

More Related Content

What's hot

I hate
I hateI hate
I hate
weareoneorg
 
Romans 14 commentary
Romans 14 commentaryRomans 14 commentary
Romans 14 commentary
GLENN PEASE
 
CRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUD
CRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUDCRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUD
CRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUD
Mia Joyce Martin
 
Dialogue, Other Religions and Evangelism
Dialogue, Other Religions and EvangelismDialogue, Other Religions and Evangelism
Dialogue, Other Religions and Evangelism
Robert Munson
 
Atheist
AtheistAtheist
Atheism and Spirituality
Atheism and SpiritualityAtheism and Spirituality
Atheism and Spirituality
Osopher
 
Psychology of Religion
Psychology of ReligionPsychology of Religion
Psychology of Religion
schellhammereducation
 
Cross-cultural Pastoral Counseling
Cross-cultural Pastoral CounselingCross-cultural Pastoral Counseling
Cross-cultural Pastoral Counseling
Robert Munson
 
Peace in a world of conflicts
Peace in a world of conflictsPeace in a world of conflicts
Peace in a world of conflicts
renaud fabbri
 
Thed4
Thed4Thed4
Atheists are evolved souls
Atheists are evolved soulsAtheists are evolved souls
Atheists are evolved souls
Arhata Osho
 
1.4 situation ethics
1.4 situation ethics1.4 situation ethics
1.4 situation ethics
jadewellington
 
Religion and spirituality
Religion and spiritualityReligion and spirituality
Religion and spirituality
Mycz Doña
 
What is heathenism
What is heathenismWhat is heathenism
What is heathenism
Sanjib Addy
 
Psychology of Religion
Psychology of ReligionPsychology of Religion
Psychology of Religion
Domenic Marbaniang
 
Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.
Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.
Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.
AshenafiBordea
 
Morality Chapter 2
Morality Chapter 2Morality Chapter 2
Morality Chapter 2
kepurple
 
Bourgeault
BourgeaultBourgeault
Either Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for Rationality
Either Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for RationalityEither Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for Rationality
Either Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for Rationality
Dale Hull
 

What's hot (19)

I hate
I hateI hate
I hate
 
Romans 14 commentary
Romans 14 commentaryRomans 14 commentary
Romans 14 commentary
 
CRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUD
CRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUDCRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUD
CRITICS ON RELIGION: FREUD
 
Dialogue, Other Religions and Evangelism
Dialogue, Other Religions and EvangelismDialogue, Other Religions and Evangelism
Dialogue, Other Religions and Evangelism
 
Atheist
AtheistAtheist
Atheist
 
Atheism and Spirituality
Atheism and SpiritualityAtheism and Spirituality
Atheism and Spirituality
 
Psychology of Religion
Psychology of ReligionPsychology of Religion
Psychology of Religion
 
Cross-cultural Pastoral Counseling
Cross-cultural Pastoral CounselingCross-cultural Pastoral Counseling
Cross-cultural Pastoral Counseling
 
Peace in a world of conflicts
Peace in a world of conflictsPeace in a world of conflicts
Peace in a world of conflicts
 
Thed4
Thed4Thed4
Thed4
 
Atheists are evolved souls
Atheists are evolved soulsAtheists are evolved souls
Atheists are evolved souls
 
1.4 situation ethics
1.4 situation ethics1.4 situation ethics
1.4 situation ethics
 
Religion and spirituality
Religion and spiritualityReligion and spirituality
Religion and spirituality
 
What is heathenism
What is heathenismWhat is heathenism
What is heathenism
 
Psychology of Religion
Psychology of ReligionPsychology of Religion
Psychology of Religion
 
Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.
Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.
Religion is Dead. Spirituality Science is Bron.
 
Morality Chapter 2
Morality Chapter 2Morality Chapter 2
Morality Chapter 2
 
Bourgeault
BourgeaultBourgeault
Bourgeault
 
Either Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for Rationality
Either Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for RationalityEither Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for Rationality
Either Rationality or Nothing Sam Harris and the Quest for Rationality
 

Viewers also liked

Lespedagogiques
LespedagogiquesLespedagogiques
Lespedagogiquesmiro64
 
Official Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and Sport
Official Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and SportOfficial Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and Sport
Official Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and Sport
Miss. Antónia FICOVÁ, Engineer. (Not yet Dr.)
 
Ateliers sur la Google Adresse
Ateliers sur la Google Adresse  Ateliers sur la Google Adresse
Ateliers sur la Google Adresse
brunoant
 
Lista de atitudes para vendas
Lista de atitudes para vendasLista de atitudes para vendas
Lista de atitudes para vendas
Gráfica 9 - Consultoria
 
Scale drawing table
Scale drawing tableScale drawing table
Scale drawing table
Cinnaminson Public Schools
 
CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?
CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?
CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?
Anna Vetter
 
A cruz sinal de vitoria
A cruz sinal de vitoriaA cruz sinal de vitoria
A cruz sinal de vitoria
Marlos Matos
 
Planeación de una empresa
Planeación de una empresaPlaneación de una empresa
Planeación de una empresa
frequesita7
 
Tema1 nuevo 2014
Tema1 nuevo 2014Tema1 nuevo 2014
Tema1 nuevo 2014
Roxana Burgos
 
Stip scenario's 19 november 2013
Stip scenario's 19 november 2013Stip scenario's 19 november 2013
Stip scenario's 19 november 2013
Michiel Otto
 
La canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coral
La canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coralLa canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coral
La canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coral
camiloroblesc
 
The Girl From The Forest
The Girl From The ForestThe Girl From The Forest
The Girl From The Forest
Edward Eric Thinh
 
applications of planar transmission lines
applications of planar transmission linesapplications of planar transmission lines
applications of planar transmission lines
PARNIKA GUPTA
 
Who has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidence
Who has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidenceWho has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidence
Who has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidence
Emil Lupu
 
L'Oranie Vue Du Ciel
L'Oranie Vue Du CielL'Oranie Vue Du Ciel
L'Oranie Vue Du Ciel
Mimi_T
 
CV-Zakir
CV-ZakirCV-Zakir
Breakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing Analysis
Breakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing AnalysisBreakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing Analysis
Breakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing Analysis
Alessandro Masi
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Lespedagogiques
LespedagogiquesLespedagogiques
Lespedagogiques
 
Official Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and Sport
Official Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and SportOfficial Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and Sport
Official Documents of Ministry of Education, Research and Sport
 
Student´s Mobility
Student´s MobilityStudent´s Mobility
Student´s Mobility
 
Ateliers sur la Google Adresse
Ateliers sur la Google Adresse  Ateliers sur la Google Adresse
Ateliers sur la Google Adresse
 
Lista de atitudes para vendas
Lista de atitudes para vendasLista de atitudes para vendas
Lista de atitudes para vendas
 
Gioia-Lavinia-Pisani
Gioia-Lavinia-PisaniGioia-Lavinia-Pisani
Gioia-Lavinia-Pisani
 
Scale drawing table
Scale drawing tableScale drawing table
Scale drawing table
 
CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?
CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?
CLOM et apprentissage des langues : où en est-on ?
 
Whatever or let it be2
Whatever or let it be2Whatever or let it be2
Whatever or let it be2
 
A cruz sinal de vitoria
A cruz sinal de vitoriaA cruz sinal de vitoria
A cruz sinal de vitoria
 
Planeación de una empresa
Planeación de una empresaPlaneación de una empresa
Planeación de una empresa
 
Tema1 nuevo 2014
Tema1 nuevo 2014Tema1 nuevo 2014
Tema1 nuevo 2014
 
Stip scenario's 19 november 2013
Stip scenario's 19 november 2013Stip scenario's 19 november 2013
Stip scenario's 19 november 2013
 
La canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coral
La canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coralLa canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coral
La canica ingravida (recuperacion) camilo coral
 
The Girl From The Forest
The Girl From The ForestThe Girl From The Forest
The Girl From The Forest
 
applications of planar transmission lines
applications of planar transmission linesapplications of planar transmission lines
applications of planar transmission lines
 
Who has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidence
Who has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidenceWho has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidence
Who has the data ... and will breach the duty of confidence
 
L'Oranie Vue Du Ciel
L'Oranie Vue Du CielL'Oranie Vue Du Ciel
L'Oranie Vue Du Ciel
 
CV-Zakir
CV-ZakirCV-Zakir
CV-Zakir
 
Breakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing Analysis
Breakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing AnalysisBreakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing Analysis
Breakout TV Series 2015 - Marketing Analysis
 

Similar to Contra billmaher

Dear johndear
Dear johndearDear johndear
Dear johndear
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Coercion freedom
Coercion freedomCoercion freedom
Coercion freedom
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Gospel nonviolence
Gospel nonviolenceGospel nonviolence
Gospel nonviolence
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Christian government, nyet
Christian government, nyetChristian government, nyet
Christian government, nyet
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 septPolitical philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 septPolitical philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Political philosophy jss
Political philosophy jssPolitical philosophy jss
Political philosophy jss
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Political philosophy jss
Political philosophy jssPolitical philosophy jss
Political philosophy jss
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Does Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docx
Does Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docxDoes Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docx
Does Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docx
elinoraudley582231
 
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obamaDear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Sorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categoriesSorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categories
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Christian government, nyet
Christian government, nyetChristian government, nyet
Christian government, nyet
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Johnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1bJohnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1b
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obamaDear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
johnboy_philothea_net
 
SPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGION
SPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGIONSPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGION
SPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGION
AJHSSR Journal
 
Capitalism as class warfare
Capitalism as class warfareCapitalism as class warfare
Capitalism as class warfare
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Pneumatology explained
Pneumatology explainedPneumatology explained
Pneumatology explained
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Ethical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a h
Ethical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a hEthical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a h
Ethical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a h
BetseyCalderon89
 
Religion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docx
Religion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docxReligion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docx
Religion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docx
debishakespeare
 
Sbnr
SbnrSbnr

Similar to Contra billmaher (20)

Dear johndear
Dear johndearDear johndear
Dear johndear
 
Coercion freedom
Coercion freedomCoercion freedom
Coercion freedom
 
Gospel nonviolence
Gospel nonviolenceGospel nonviolence
Gospel nonviolence
 
Christian government, nyet
Christian government, nyetChristian government, nyet
Christian government, nyet
 
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 septPolitical philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
 
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 septPolitical philosophy jss 2011 sept
Political philosophy jss 2011 sept
 
Political philosophy jss
Political philosophy jssPolitical philosophy jss
Political philosophy jss
 
Political philosophy jss
Political philosophy jssPolitical philosophy jss
Political philosophy jss
 
Does Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docx
Does Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docxDoes Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docx
Does Morality Need Religion – Yes!Professor Derrick Willis.docx
 
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obamaDear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
 
Sorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categoriesSorting truth claims and categories
Sorting truth claims and categories
 
Christian government, nyet
Christian government, nyetChristian government, nyet
Christian government, nyet
 
Johnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1bJohnboy musings part1b
Johnboy musings part1b
 
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obamaDear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
Dear dr krauthammer re gospel of obama
 
SPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGION
SPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGIONSPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGION
SPIRITUALITY WITH NO AFFILIATION TO RELIGION
 
Capitalism as class warfare
Capitalism as class warfareCapitalism as class warfare
Capitalism as class warfare
 
Pneumatology explained
Pneumatology explainedPneumatology explained
Pneumatology explained
 
Ethical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a h
Ethical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a hEthical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a h
Ethical Theory PaperElijah KimWhat is the meaning of being a h
 
Religion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docx
Religion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docxReligion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docx
Religion & Ethics A very short introduction Dr. Bruce.docx
 
Sbnr
SbnrSbnr
Sbnr
 

More from johnboy_philothea_net

Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathyMoral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spiEmerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Eucharistic model
Eucharistic modelEucharistic model
Eucharistic model
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
The missing divine attribute   omnipathyThe missing divine attribute   omnipathy
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
johnboy_philothea_net
 
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeperIn all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
johnboy_philothea_net
 
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxyA soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Deconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionismDeconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionismFaith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulnessIn defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fastjohnboy_philothea_net
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as loverjohnboy_philothea_net
 
To john caputo yes, but
To john caputo   yes, butTo john caputo   yes, but
To john caputo yes, but
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theologicalOntologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!
johnboy_philothea_net
 
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrismThe (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
johnboy_philothea_net
 
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage pointA look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Dorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel normsDorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel norms
johnboy_philothea_net
 
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchangeInterfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
johnboy_philothea_net
 

More from johnboy_philothea_net (20)

Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathyMoral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
 
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spiEmerging christianity   interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
 
Eucharistic model
Eucharistic modelEucharistic model
Eucharistic model
 
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
The missing divine attribute   omnipathyThe missing divine attribute   omnipathy
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
 
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeperIn all religions we are invited to dig deeper
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
 
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxyA soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
 
Deconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionismDeconstructing deconstructionism
Deconstructing deconstructionism
 
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionismFaith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
 
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulnessIn defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
 
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics   not so fastThe role of change in metaphysics   not so fast
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
 
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as loverOrthodoxy weds polydoxy   god as lover
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
 
To john caputo yes, but
To john caputo   yes, butTo john caputo   yes, but
To john caputo yes, but
 
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theologicalOntologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
 
Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!Deconstruct this!
Deconstruct this!
 
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrismThe (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
 
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage pointA look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
 
Dorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel normsDorothy day and gospel norms
Dorothy day and gospel norms
 
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchangeInterfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
 

Recently uploaded

English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdfEnglish - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
Filipino Tracts and Literature Society Inc.
 
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu ExpertSanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu
 
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
Rick Peterson
 
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
cfk7atz3
 
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - MessageThe Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
Cole Hartman
 
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
makhmalhalaaay
 
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
Traditional Healer, Love Spells Caster and Money Spells That Work Fast
 
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
OH TEIK BIN
 
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
Phoenix O
 
Important places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptx
Important places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptxImportant places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptx
Important places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptx
ShyamSundar991228
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
deerfootcoc
 
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
franktsao4
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_RestorationThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
Network Bible Fellowship
 

Recently uploaded (13)

English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdfEnglish - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
English - The Book of Ruth - King James Bible.pdf
 
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu ExpertSanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
Sanatan Vastu | Experience Great Living | Vastu Expert
 
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
312 A Wise Woman of Abel Beth Maakah Saves The Town
 
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
快速办理(PU毕业证书)普渡大学毕业证文凭证书一模一样
 
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - MessageThe Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
The Hope of Salvation - Jude 1:24-25 - Message
 
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
Kala jadu (black magic) expert,Black magic specialist in Dubai vashikaran spe...
 
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
How to Stop a Divorce and Save Your Marriage: Divorce Spells That Really Work...
 
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons    to Learn   ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
A Free eBook ~ Valuable LIFE Lessons to Learn ( 5 Sets of Presentations)...
 
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
The Enchantment and Shadows_ Unveiling the Mysteries of Magic and Black Magic...
 
Important places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptx
Important places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptxImportant places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptx
Important places of Vrindavan-Braj Mandal Parikrama .pptx
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 6 16 24
 
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord,  the taste of the Lord The taste of...
A375 Example Taste the taste of the Lord, the taste of the Lord The taste of...
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_RestorationThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_104_Repentance_and_Restoration
 

Contra billmaher

  • 1. Bill Maher has about as good a grasp in his interpretation of authentic religion as Charles Manson had on his interpretation of the Beatles' Helter Skelter. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtbiIzK7AXI Bill, Christianity has its own critique of jingoistic, militaristic, homophobes and doesn't need assistance from you, who, like Dennett, Dawkins, Harris and Hitchens, have never been philosophically rigorous or theologically interesting. You are all superficial atheists who engage superficial theists, ironically, on their own fundamentalistic terms. You are in no position, therefore, to determine who is ignoring rather than interpreting Scripture and Tradition. No, a Christian does not rejoice in war and does not take revenge. Yes, a Christian may use coercive force to defend innocents, including self. It is much too facile and way too cynical to cursorily dismiss 2,000 years of Christian ethical reflection on nonviolence as a simple squaring of a circle or a mere lawyering of the Bible. Regarding who may be Christ followers versus "just fans," well Bill, charitably, we've always left that distinction to Someone Else. Finally, you might want to stick with social and political comedy and stay away from the topic of religion, where you are being far too, in a word, religulous. You are embarassing - not just yourself, but - Camus, Feuerbach, Hobbes, Hume, Nietzsche, Russell, Sartre and Voltaire. +++ John N Veronica The distinction between a Christ-follower and a Christ-fan, in my view, speaks directly to one's relationship with God vis a vis sin, hence my reluctance to frame the issue in that way. This does not mean that we cannot discern and proclaim another's behavior as a failure to cooperate with grace, only that we cannot ever know whether that failure results from ignorance, poor formation or even de-formative influences, or from an outright refusal (sin). Neither does it mean that such a failure should not be confronted and perhaps interdicted. Because human morality is transparent to human reason without the benefit of any special revelation, it is sufficient to draw distinctions between immoral and moral, ethical and unethical, useful and unhelpful, behaviors without couching them (naively & facilely) in explicitly theological categories. The Christian unitive norms of love are well suited to moral and practical ends but their aims otherwise transcend merely moral concerns and thus exemplify extraordinary virtue, thus going beyond the universal norms of justice and ordinary virtue. The martyrs are therefore extolled as widely recognized saints, but that doesn't mean that us run-of-the-mill anawim are necessarily "just fans" because we choose to defend innocents or maybe even ourselves. 1
  • 2. More people DO need to speak out and challenge immoral and unethical, unhelpful and ignorant, messages and behaviors but the pejorative use of fraught labels, especially where we enjoy so little consensus regarding their meaning, should be avoided. A great deal of the confusion, as I see it, results from poor critical thinking and philosophical category errors (confusion between the methods of science, philosophy, culture and religion), so I tend to address those, presuming ignorance but not malice. It is not sufficient that Bill Maher be right in THAT religious fundamentalism is incorrect and a problem, even a real danger. It is also necessary that he gets right exactly WHY it is incorrect (and it is not because the religious fundamentalists' literal readings of Scripture are not logically consistent with the Enlightenment fundamentalists' literal readings of Scripture, for example). Rather than subvert religious fundamentalism, Maher dignifies it on its own terms because he fails to understand why it is in error. Both religious and Enlightenment fundamentalists need to accomplish the same paradigm shift, which draws methodological distinctions between descriptive sciences, normative philosophies and interpretive religions. (One has to feel sorry for some of the NALT atheists, too. Maybe they, too, need to beef up their challenge of their own petty, narrow-minded and militant cohort.) Finally, even when one so happens to be right, and of course Maher is right regarding some immoral behaviors, there is a RIGHT way to be right. People may not be able to strictly define it but they know meanness when they hear and/or see it. 19 minutes ago · Like John N Veronica I understand and appreciate complaints aimed at extremists on both Left and Right but resist any broad generalizations re: secular vs religious, liberal vs conservative, left vs right, and so on. I prefer to engage the best a tradition has to offer and not its worst elements, authentic representatives and not caricatures. 2 seconds ago · Like I am curious: How can you be a follower of Christ's teachings and at the same time justify violence (even for self-defense)? You might be a follower of the church which would allow certain exceptions but how is it possible to ignore "turn the other cheek" and "love your enemies"? Doesn't be a follower of someone mean to follow THEIR words and not the reflec ons by other people in the following years? 2
  • 3. Please don't consider my remarks as insults. I am really looking for an answer. compassionatevegan 55 minutes ago @compassionatevegan Some say His words apply more so to some eschatological (future) realization of Kingdom values & not immediately. Others say His imperatives & injunctives apply more so to a personal vocation & not political statecraft. That DOES sound like lawyering! Jesus' words were not ambiguous. Pacifism, martyrdom and nonviolence conform to the pattern of His Life and Teachings and are esteemed vocations. But following isn't a simple either-or reality; rather, it is realized in degrees. wfb2008rip 23 minutes ago @compassionatevegan Continuing - So, in my view, there can be no theoretical theological capitulation. What is encouraged sometimes, though, is a practical, pastoral accommodation to human weakness. At the same time, Jesus is inviting us to extraordinary virtue, to the unitive norms of love, which exceed the demands of justice. These go beyond our universal moral norms, where self-defense is s ll ethical & part of ordinary virtue. One does the best one can. Perfection isn't required. wfb2008rip 14 minutes ago @compassionatevegan We do not need special religious revelations to live a good & ethical life because morality is transparent to all human reasoning. What differentiates the Gospel in the marketplace, then, is not its moral teachings but, rather, the Good News that the universe was both created & is far friendlier than one could ever imagine (b/c reality is far too ambiguous for us & ambivalent toward us for us to otherwise draw such a conclusion). God is Abba, Daddy, is the primary take-away! wfb2008rip 6 minutes ago @compassionatevegan Finally, rather than answering What can I know? (describing reality) or What must I do? (norming reality), religion addresses What might I hope for? Descriptive science answers: What's that? Evaluative cultures: What's that to us? Normative philosophy: How might we best acquire/avoid that? Interpretive religion: How do we tie (religate) this all together? And it doesn't get to make up the answers to the 1st 3 ques ons. It goes beyond but not without them. Hope this helps. 3
  • 4. wfb2008rip 3 seconds ago There are ~38,000 Chris an denomina ons. Who in their right mind imagines that anyone speaks for us all? or that there is a consensus definition, even, of Christ-follower or Christ-like? wfb2008rip 1 hour ago 4