1) The author argues that the climate movement has had limited success because it has failed to learn from past successes in influencing social change, such as family planning programs in East Asia in the 1960s.
2) These programs in South Korea and Taiwan were highly successful by first targeting "innovators" and "early adopters" to build acceptance, rather than confronting opponents head-on. In contrast, the Philippines program argued with opponents and saw much less success.
3) The author believes the climate movement made a similar mistake by confronting "deniers" instead of first educating those who are open but not yet convinced of the issue. To succeed, the focus should be on moving the "disengaged
The following pages document my
responses to the online discussion questions in the Spring 2017 version of ARC 211
American Diversity and Design at the University at Buffalo – State University of New
York.
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job betterDigitasLBi Paris
From forms to porn banners, how behavioral economics can optimize user experience?
by DigitasLBi strategic planning
Des formulaires aux bannières porno: comment l'économie comportementale peut optimiser l'exp. utilisateur - par les planneurs de DigitasLBi
Holons, Holarchies and Holonic Networks : The Ghost in the Production Machine, by Piero Mella, P a v i a U n i v e r s i t y P r e s s, 2009 . Official Link: http://www.paviauniversitypress.it/scientifica/download/Mella-sito_2010-01-23.pdf
The following pages document my
responses to the online discussion questions in the Spring 2017 version of ARC 211
American Diversity and Design at the University at Buffalo – State University of New
York.
Behavioral economics : what it is and how it could help us do our job betterDigitasLBi Paris
From forms to porn banners, how behavioral economics can optimize user experience?
by DigitasLBi strategic planning
Des formulaires aux bannières porno: comment l'économie comportementale peut optimiser l'exp. utilisateur - par les planneurs de DigitasLBi
Holons, Holarchies and Holonic Networks : The Ghost in the Production Machine, by Piero Mella, P a v i a U n i v e r s i t y P r e s s, 2009 . Official Link: http://www.paviauniversitypress.it/scientifica/download/Mella-sito_2010-01-23.pdf
Michael Arth for governor of Florida/NO PARTYjenkan04
Michael Arth ion the issues for Governor of Florida
Candidates personal history
Presented by The Highlands Tea Party http://thehighlandsteaparty.com /
Prepared by John Nelson
The Educational Reforms Policy Education Essay - PHDessay.com. Essay On Education Reform : A Research Into The Reform Of Education. Ghana and The Education Reform Essay Example | Topics and Well Written .... Essay On Education Reform : Education in america essay. (PDF) ON THE MANY EDUCATIONAL REFORMS IN THE PHILIPPINES. The perfect school :: education reform essays discount. 1988 education reform act essay scoring. US Education Reform Essay. Expository essay: Essay about education reform. Education Reform Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written .... Essays for IBPS PO VII in 250 Words : Need of Educational Reforms in .... Three Critical Components for Successful Education Reform, By Adetola .... Education-a fundamental right: Essay Should Education Be Nationalised. Transforming Schools Alternative Perspectives on School Reform - 3232 .... Education reform essay sample – WriteMyEssay. Education Reform Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays .... Persuasive Essay 1-Government Paying for Education | Test (Assessment .... Thought From the Educational Reform Movement: A Collection of Essays .... Education Reforms In Pakistan | Complete Essay With Outline - Tech Urdu. Educational reform (1790 - 1860). Educational Reform Essay - From the following list, select two .... Three Essays on Education Reform in the United States | RAND. (PDF) Putting Students at the Centre of Educational Reform.
Students selected topics from the book "What Matters: The World's Preeminent Photojournalists and Thinkers Depict Essential Issues of Our Time" by David Elliot Cohen who maintains that "a single image still has the power to change the world." They reserached their topic, composed an interest statement about whay it mattered to them (and should matter to everyone), compiled images and URLs about the topic to post to a blog and facebook group page.
The Sustainable(ish) Living Guide: Everything you Need to Know to Make Small ...Lucky Gods
Planet in peril? You're not powerless!
Feeling overwhelmed by climate change and eco-anxiety? Don't worry, you're not alone! But instead of sinking into despair, grab this book and let's ditch the doomscrolling and embrace the "Do-something!" revolution! ✊
Imagine:
Swapping plastic for reusable magic: single-use, hello sustainable swag! ✨
Transforming your home into an eco-haven: Solar panels, compost bins, and green cleaning – let's get groovy!
Eating like a planet-loving foodie: Ditch the factory farms, embrace local, seasonal goodness!
Being the change you wanna see in the world: Inspire others, spark conversations, and make a real difference!
This book is your sustainable superpower manual:
Unravel the eco-lingo: ♻️ Compost, carbon footprint, upcycling – we'll make it all crystal clear!
Discover bite-sized actions: Easy, practical tips for every aspect of your life, from travel to fashion! ✈️
Debunk eco-myths: ♀️ Say goodbye to greenwashing and embrace fact-based, actionable advice!
Fuel your eco-fire with inspiration: Meet real people making a difference, and find your own sustainable groove!
So, toss that "too-little-too-late" mindset and grab this book! ️ It's time to embrace the power of small changes, make a big impact, and show the planet you care!
Current Essay Topics. 006 Essay Example Writing Topics With ThatsnotusTina Johnson
50 Compelling Argumentative Essay Topics. Argumentative Essay Topics for Middle School | Middle school writing .... Essay Topics. Exceptional Easy Argumentative Essay Topics College Students ~ Thatsnotus. 017 Argumentative Essay Topics College Level Coursework Help Easy .... 005 Diagnostic Essay Example Topics Commentary Examples In Essays .... 10 Daring Persuasive Argumentative Essay Topics - Academic Writing Success. Imposing Easy Essay Topics ~ Thatsnotus. 025 Essay Example Current Event Events Standard Paragraph Outline .... Current Event Essay: A Guide, Tips, Examples, and Topic Ideas. 011 Best College Essay Topics Student Sample ~ Thatsnotus. Current Topics For Essay Writing For Competitive Exams | PDF. Important current affairs essay topics 2014 / dissertation writing help. 013 Good Persuasive Essay Topics Example ~ Thatsnotus. Top 100 Extended Essay Topics. 020 Interesting Essay Topics Argumentative Persuasive L ~ Thatsnotus. 003 Current Event Essay Example Essays College Format Sample Free .... 003 Essay Love Sample Descriptive Topics Definition Essays 936x1332 .... ️ Best essay topics for class 10. 200 Best Argumentative Essay Topics .... 012 Essay Writing Topics Example ~ Thatsnotus. Free Online Essays On Current Topics. Important Essay Based on Current Topics in Hindi - Examtrix.com. Current affairs essay topics 2012 - technicalcollege.web.fc2.com. 018 Illustration Essay Topic Ideas List Illustrative Photo Awesome .... College Essay Topics | Custom Essays & Term Papers Lab. Unique Persuasive Essay Topics Middle School ~ Thatsnotus. Current topics in india for essay writing. Awesome Argumentative Essay Topics For High School ~ Thatsnotus. 006 Essay Example Writing Topics With ~ Thatsnotus. 012 Informative Essay Examples For High School Example Narrative Goal ... Current Essay Topics
Make sustainability sustainable (preview)Fan Foundry
Marketing "green" products often backfires because, much as we'd like all buyers to follow the altruistic "because green is better" thinking, other unaddressed factors intervene to short circuit that thinking, with the result that sustainable solutions fail to gain traction in the hearts and minds of buyers. But it doesn't have to be that way.
Excellent paper presented at the Proceedings IGLC-21, July 2013, Fortaleza, Brazil by Dan Fauchier and Thaís da C. L. Alves .Observation of fifteen teams on nine projects utilizing Last Planner® System. Demonstrate how participation in LPS teaches-by-doing foundational lean behaviors. Three main sets of behaviors related to or promoted by the LPS that were identified: Building social networks, Addressing multiple needs in a dynamic environment, and Treating projects as production systems.
SUR LA VOIE RAPIDE - Guide de l’innovation à l'intention des petites et moyen...CollectiveKnowledge
Excellent guide développé et diffusé par l'Agence de promotion économique du Canada atlantique. Une bonne introduction à l'innovation et au développement de produits. Complet et bien structuré. Comprend une section sur les brevets canadiens.
Materialism has become synonymous with consumerism – wasteful, debt-fuelled and ultimately unsatisfying. Yet, inescapably, we are part of the material world. How, then, can we develop a healthy connection to it? This pamphlet argues for a ‘New Materialism,’ in which we grow a more deeply pleasurable, and also respectful relationship with the world of ‘things’.
More Related Content
Similar to Climate change: Learning from past experience
Michael Arth for governor of Florida/NO PARTYjenkan04
Michael Arth ion the issues for Governor of Florida
Candidates personal history
Presented by The Highlands Tea Party http://thehighlandsteaparty.com /
Prepared by John Nelson
The Educational Reforms Policy Education Essay - PHDessay.com. Essay On Education Reform : A Research Into The Reform Of Education. Ghana and The Education Reform Essay Example | Topics and Well Written .... Essay On Education Reform : Education in america essay. (PDF) ON THE MANY EDUCATIONAL REFORMS IN THE PHILIPPINES. The perfect school :: education reform essays discount. 1988 education reform act essay scoring. US Education Reform Essay. Expository essay: Essay about education reform. Education Reform Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written .... Essays for IBPS PO VII in 250 Words : Need of Educational Reforms in .... Three Critical Components for Successful Education Reform, By Adetola .... Education-a fundamental right: Essay Should Education Be Nationalised. Transforming Schools Alternative Perspectives on School Reform - 3232 .... Education reform essay sample – WriteMyEssay. Education Reform Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays .... Persuasive Essay 1-Government Paying for Education | Test (Assessment .... Thought From the Educational Reform Movement: A Collection of Essays .... Education Reforms In Pakistan | Complete Essay With Outline - Tech Urdu. Educational reform (1790 - 1860). Educational Reform Essay - From the following list, select two .... Three Essays on Education Reform in the United States | RAND. (PDF) Putting Students at the Centre of Educational Reform.
Students selected topics from the book "What Matters: The World's Preeminent Photojournalists and Thinkers Depict Essential Issues of Our Time" by David Elliot Cohen who maintains that "a single image still has the power to change the world." They reserached their topic, composed an interest statement about whay it mattered to them (and should matter to everyone), compiled images and URLs about the topic to post to a blog and facebook group page.
The Sustainable(ish) Living Guide: Everything you Need to Know to Make Small ...Lucky Gods
Planet in peril? You're not powerless!
Feeling overwhelmed by climate change and eco-anxiety? Don't worry, you're not alone! But instead of sinking into despair, grab this book and let's ditch the doomscrolling and embrace the "Do-something!" revolution! ✊
Imagine:
Swapping plastic for reusable magic: single-use, hello sustainable swag! ✨
Transforming your home into an eco-haven: Solar panels, compost bins, and green cleaning – let's get groovy!
Eating like a planet-loving foodie: Ditch the factory farms, embrace local, seasonal goodness!
Being the change you wanna see in the world: Inspire others, spark conversations, and make a real difference!
This book is your sustainable superpower manual:
Unravel the eco-lingo: ♻️ Compost, carbon footprint, upcycling – we'll make it all crystal clear!
Discover bite-sized actions: Easy, practical tips for every aspect of your life, from travel to fashion! ✈️
Debunk eco-myths: ♀️ Say goodbye to greenwashing and embrace fact-based, actionable advice!
Fuel your eco-fire with inspiration: Meet real people making a difference, and find your own sustainable groove!
So, toss that "too-little-too-late" mindset and grab this book! ️ It's time to embrace the power of small changes, make a big impact, and show the planet you care!
Current Essay Topics. 006 Essay Example Writing Topics With ThatsnotusTina Johnson
50 Compelling Argumentative Essay Topics. Argumentative Essay Topics for Middle School | Middle school writing .... Essay Topics. Exceptional Easy Argumentative Essay Topics College Students ~ Thatsnotus. 017 Argumentative Essay Topics College Level Coursework Help Easy .... 005 Diagnostic Essay Example Topics Commentary Examples In Essays .... 10 Daring Persuasive Argumentative Essay Topics - Academic Writing Success. Imposing Easy Essay Topics ~ Thatsnotus. 025 Essay Example Current Event Events Standard Paragraph Outline .... Current Event Essay: A Guide, Tips, Examples, and Topic Ideas. 011 Best College Essay Topics Student Sample ~ Thatsnotus. Current Topics For Essay Writing For Competitive Exams | PDF. Important current affairs essay topics 2014 / dissertation writing help. 013 Good Persuasive Essay Topics Example ~ Thatsnotus. Top 100 Extended Essay Topics. 020 Interesting Essay Topics Argumentative Persuasive L ~ Thatsnotus. 003 Current Event Essay Example Essays College Format Sample Free .... 003 Essay Love Sample Descriptive Topics Definition Essays 936x1332 .... ️ Best essay topics for class 10. 200 Best Argumentative Essay Topics .... 012 Essay Writing Topics Example ~ Thatsnotus. Free Online Essays On Current Topics. Important Essay Based on Current Topics in Hindi - Examtrix.com. Current affairs essay topics 2012 - technicalcollege.web.fc2.com. 018 Illustration Essay Topic Ideas List Illustrative Photo Awesome .... College Essay Topics | Custom Essays & Term Papers Lab. Unique Persuasive Essay Topics Middle School ~ Thatsnotus. Current topics in india for essay writing. Awesome Argumentative Essay Topics For High School ~ Thatsnotus. 006 Essay Example Writing Topics With ~ Thatsnotus. 012 Informative Essay Examples For High School Example Narrative Goal ... Current Essay Topics
Make sustainability sustainable (preview)Fan Foundry
Marketing "green" products often backfires because, much as we'd like all buyers to follow the altruistic "because green is better" thinking, other unaddressed factors intervene to short circuit that thinking, with the result that sustainable solutions fail to gain traction in the hearts and minds of buyers. But it doesn't have to be that way.
Excellent paper presented at the Proceedings IGLC-21, July 2013, Fortaleza, Brazil by Dan Fauchier and Thaís da C. L. Alves .Observation of fifteen teams on nine projects utilizing Last Planner® System. Demonstrate how participation in LPS teaches-by-doing foundational lean behaviors. Three main sets of behaviors related to or promoted by the LPS that were identified: Building social networks, Addressing multiple needs in a dynamic environment, and Treating projects as production systems.
SUR LA VOIE RAPIDE - Guide de l’innovation à l'intention des petites et moyen...CollectiveKnowledge
Excellent guide développé et diffusé par l'Agence de promotion économique du Canada atlantique. Une bonne introduction à l'innovation et au développement de produits. Complet et bien structuré. Comprend une section sur les brevets canadiens.
Materialism has become synonymous with consumerism – wasteful, debt-fuelled and ultimately unsatisfying. Yet, inescapably, we are part of the material world. How, then, can we develop a healthy connection to it? This pamphlet argues for a ‘New Materialism,’ in which we grow a more deeply pleasurable, and also respectful relationship with the world of ‘things’.
GUIDE D’ÉVALUATION DE PROJET À L’INTENTION DES ORGANISMES SANS BUT LUCRATIFCollectiveKnowledge
GUIDE D’ÉVALUATION DE PROJET À L’INTENTION DES ORGANISMES SANS BUT LUCRATIF - Méthodes et étapes fondamentales pour procéder à l’évaluation de projets - Publication d'Imagine Canada
Chemical information transfer between plants: back to the futureCollectiveKnowledge
by Marcel Dicke and Jan Bruin, Laboratory of Entomology, Department of Plant Sciences, Wageningen University, in Biochemical Systematics and Ecology 29 (2001) 981–994
Insights and Trends: Current Portfolio, Programme, and Project Management ...CollectiveKnowledge
2012 PWC's third global survey on the current state of project management. New study is starting now and will be release somewhere this year (2014). Meanwhile, this is only 2 years old, so quite relevant. A total of 1,524 respondents from 38 countries and within 34 industries shared their insights
A selection of verses from the book 'The Experience of Insight' by Joseph Goldstein. This is a marvelous introduction to insight meditation with plenty of beautiful and very inspiring drawings
Digital Sustainability Conversations How Local Governments can Engage Resid...CollectiveKnowledge
This guidebook provides case studies and a step-by-step guide to support local government digital engagement efforts.
Funding for the guidebook was provided by the Urban Sustainability Directors Network (USDN) Urban Sustainability Innovation (USI) Fund with funds provided by the Summit Foundation, the Surdna Foundation, and The Home Depot Foundation.
Texte de Guy Théraulaz, Directeur de recherches au CNRS, Centre de Recherches sur la Cognition Animale, CNRS UMR 5169, Université Paul Sabatier, Toulouse. Paru dans Le Courrier de la Nature n° 250 - Spécial Fourmis 2009
Unlock TikTok Success with Sociocosmos..SocioCosmos
Discover how Sociocosmos can boost your TikTok presence with real followers and engagement. Achieve your social media goals today!
https://www.sociocosmos.com/product-category/tiktok/
Exploring The Dimensions and Dynamics of Felt Obligation: A Bibliometric Anal...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTARCT: This study presents, to our knowledge, the first bibliometric analysis focusing on the concept of
"felt obligation," examining 120 articles published between 1986 and 2024. The aim of the study is to deepen our
understanding of the existing knowledge in the field of "felt obligation" and to provide guidance for further
research. The analysis is centered around the authors, countries, institutions, and keywords of the articles. The
findings highlight prominent researchers in this field, leading universities, and influential journals. Particularly,
it is identified that China plays a leading role in "felt obligation" research. The analysis of keywords emphasizes
the thematic focuses of these studies and provides a roadmap for future research. Finally, various
recommendations are presented to deepen the knowledge in this area and promote applied research. This study
serves as a foundation to expand and advance the understanding of "felt obligation" in the field.
KEYWORDS: Felt Obligation, Bibliometric Analysis, Research Trends
Telegram is a messaging platform that ushers in a new era of communication. Available for Android, Windows, Mac, and Linux, Telegram offers simplicity, privacy, synchronization across devices, speed, and powerful features. It allows users to create their own stickers with a user-friendly editor. With robust encryption, Telegram ensures message security and even offers self-destructing messages. The platform is open, with an API and source code accessible to everyone, making it a secure and social environment where groups can accommodate up to 200,000 members. Customize your messenger experience with Telegram's expressive features.
Buy Pinterest Followers, Reactions & Repins Go Viral on Pinterest with Socio...SocioCosmos
Get more Pinterest followers, reactions, and repins with Sociocosmos, the leading platform to buy all kinds of Pinterest presence. Boost your profile and reach a wider audience.
https://www.sociocosmos.com/product-category/pinterest/
The Evolution of SEO: Insights from a Leading Digital Marketing AgencyDigital Marketing Lab
Explore the latest trends in Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and discover how modern practices are transforming business visibility. This document delves into the shift from keyword optimization to user intent, highlighting key trends such as voice search optimization, artificial intelligence, mobile-first indexing, and the importance of E-A-T principles. Enhance your online presence with expert insights from Digital Marketing Lab, your partner in maximizing SEO performance.
Improving Workplace Safety Performance in Malaysian SMEs: The Role of Safety ...AJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: In the Malaysian context, small and medium enterprises (SMEs) experience a significant
burden of workplace accidents. A consensus among scholars attributes a substantial portion of these incidents to
human factors, particularly unsafe behaviors. This study, conducted in Malaysia's northern region, specifically
targeted Safety and Health/Human Resource professionals within the manufacturing sector of SMEs. We
gathered a robust dataset comprising 107 responses through a meticulously designed self-administered
questionnaire. Employing advanced partial least squares-structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM) techniques
with SmartPLS 3.2.9, we rigorously analyzed the data to scrutinize the intricate relationship between safety
behavior and safety performance. The research findings unequivocally underscore the palpable and
consequential impact of safety behavior variables, namely safety compliance and safety participation, on
improving safety performance indicators such as accidents, injuries, and property damages. These results
strongly validate research hypotheses. Consequently, this study highlights the pivotal significance of cultivating
safety behavior among employees, particularly in resource-constrained SME settings, as an essential step toward
enhancing workplace safety performance.
KEYWORDS :Safety compliance, safety participation, safety performance, SME
Enhance your social media strategy with the best digital marketing agency in Kolkata. This PPT covers 7 essential tips for effective social media marketing, offering practical advice and actionable insights to help you boost engagement, reach your target audience, and grow your online presence.
Your Path to YouTube Stardom Starts HereSocioCosmos
Skyrocket your YouTube presence with Sociocosmos' proven methods. Gain real engagement and build a loyal audience. Join us now.
https://www.sociocosmos.com/product-category/youtube/
Surat Digital Marketing School is created to offer a complete course that is specifically designed as per the current industry trends. Years of experience has helped us identify and understand the graduate-employee skills gap in the industry. At our school, we keep up with the pace of the industry and impart a holistic education that encompasses all the latest concepts of the Digital world so that our graduates can effortlessly integrate into the assigned roles.
This is the place where you become a Digital Marketing Expert.
Multilingual SEO Services | Multilingual Keyword Research | Filosemadisonsmith478075
Multilingual SEO services are essential for businesses aiming to expand their global presence. They involve optimizing a website for search engines in multiple languages, enhancing visibility, and reaching diverse audiences. Filose offers comprehensive multilingual SEO services designed to help businesses optimize their websites for search engines in various languages, enhancing their global reach and market presence. These services ensure that your content is not only translated but also culturally and contextually adapted to resonate with local audiences.
Visit us at -https://www.filose.com/
Project Serenity is an innovative initiative aimed at transforming urban environments into sustainable, self-sufficient communities. By integrating green architecture, renewable energy, smart technology, sustainable transportation, and urban farming, Project Serenity seeks to minimize the ecological footprint of cities while enhancing residents' quality of life. Key components include energy-efficient buildings, IoT-enabled resource management, electric and autonomous transportation options, green spaces, and robust waste management systems. Emphasizing community engagement and social equity, Project Serenity aspires to serve as a global model for creating eco-friendly, livable urban spaces that harmonize modern conveniences with environmental stewardship.
EASY TUTORIAL OF HOW TO USE G-TEAMS BY: FEBLESS HERNANEFebless Hernane
Using Google Teams (G-Teams) is simple. Start by opening the Google Teams app on your phone or visiting the G-Teams website on your computer. Sign in with your Google account. To join a meeting, click on the link shared by the organizer or enter the meeting code in the "Join a Meeting" section. To start a meeting, click on "New Meeting" and share the link with others. You can use the chat feature to send messages and the video button to turn your camera on or off. G-Teams makes it easy to connect and collaborate with others!
This tutorial presentation provides a step-by-step guide on how to use Facebook, the popular social media platform. In simple and easy-to-understand language, this presentation explains how to create a Facebook account, connect with friends and family, post updates, share photos and videos, join groups, and manage privacy settings. Whether you're new to Facebook or just need a refresher, this presentation will help you navigate the features and make the most of your Facebook experience.
Grow Your Reddit Community Fast.........SocioCosmos
Sociocosmos helps you gain Reddit followers quickly and easily. Build your community and expand your influence.
https://www.sociocosmos.com/product-category/reddit/
Your LinkedIn Success Starts Here.......SocioCosmos
In order to make a lasting impression on your sector, SocioCosmos provides customized solutions to improve your LinkedIn profile.
https://www.sociocosmos.com/product-category/linkedin/
1. Climate Change:
Lets learn from past successes (and failures)
By Dave Finnigan, Director
Climate Change is Elementary
www.climatechangeiselementary.org
dave@climatechangeiselementary.org
One of the reasons that the Climate Movement has had such
opposition and only limited success is that we have failed to learn
from successes and failures in the past. In the 1960s I was privileged
to be the Information, Education and Communication consultant to
the National Family Planning Programs of South Korea, Taiwan and
the Philippines. We used, as one of our guidelines, the work of Prof.
Everett Rogers on Diffusion of Innovations, how a new idea spreads
and is adopted in a culture.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations.
Rogers used a normal curve to show the five different groups of
consumers and how they came aboard in the adoption of a new
technology. You do best if you start with the Innovators on the left
hand side of the chart, and work your way to the right.
An analogy is that first you get the choir singing, then you teach the
congregation, and then you go to nearby neighbors before you go out
to the people far from the church or those who are opposed to your
song or to singing in general.
2. In Korea and Taiwan we followed Roger's advice and we assembled
our forces from among the Innovators, Early Adopters and the Early
Majority. As a consequence people flocked to the new program under
the theme "Girls and Boys are equal, two is enough" We used no
coercion, but we gave lots of positive reinforcement to adopters.
In the Philippines on the other hand the program did not focus on the
Early Adopters, but instead took the bait of the Catholic Church and
got into an argument from the start trying to defeat the Laggards, who
were like our climate change deniers today.
The end result is that in Korea the average family size went from 6
kids to 1.2 over the last 45 years and average per capita income went
from under $1,000 per year to over $38,000. But in the Philippines
average family size went from 6 kids to 3.2 and the per capita income
is just now about to hit $2,000. Korea’s population went from about
30,000,000 in 1966 to 48,000,000 today and will fall to around
40,000,000 by 2040. The Philippines population went from
30,000,000 to an unsustainable 94,000,000 today and, barring
cataclysm, will be 188,000,000 by 2040 because the parents of the
additional 94,000,000 children are already born and many are
entering their reproductive years.
3. This proves once again that "demography is destiny.
The reason this is relevant to my own work today is that I ignore
deniers. They are best presented today by the Yale Study on Six
Americas which updated Rogers' work and added another category.
http://environment.yale.edu/climate-communication/files/SixAmericas-March-2012.pdf
My own interpretation of the original Rogers Curve, using the Yale
study categories is as shown very roughly in this illustration. I hope it
is clear that this is a bimodal curve and that in the larger and left hand
hump are ourselves and our colleagues and in the right hand side of
the curve are the two groups who I ignore and who we would do well
to not confront, the Dismissive and the Doubtful.
In our work with elementary school families and teachers we feel we
are working to bring the one group that transcends both humps, the
Disengaged on board.
Since this is a bimodal curve there is no chance of converting the
Dismissive and Doubtful over to our mode. We are battling for the
hearts and minds of the Disengaged. It is rare that anyone jumps
from one hump to another although there are some notable
exceptions, including occasional climate scientists who see the light
4. and change modes (make a "hump jump"). Richard Muller was one
such exception, but it was not through argument or confrontation that
he changed, but through his own research.
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/jul/29/climate-changesceptics-change-mind
Part of Everett Rogers' work was a "stairway" from Awareness to
Adoption which I have modified here to show how I see this problem
and our movement toward successful conclusions.
I have taken the liberty of adding a few steps based on my own
experience. What we found in the Family Planning programs of East
Asia was that after a person or a couple became adopters, with the
right reinforcements we could help them to choose to become
advocates as well.
So as we help people who are Disengaged or are already Cautious,
Concerned, or Alarmed to move up the stairway toward advocacy we
have so many small steps that we can help them take in the trial and
evaluation phase. They can change light bulbs and see the result, get
an energy audit and see the result, buy an efficient vehicle and see
the result, instal solar hot water and see the result, put solar panels
on their roof and see the result, convert to wind energy and see the
5. result. Once they have taken these many intermediate steps they
become adopters and get confirmation from friends and neighbors
who applaud their work. Finally they become advocates.
As a result of this personal experience with culture change, I am
loathe to confront anyone on their strongly held beliefs and in my
opinion that is where the climate conversation has gone awry. This
project got politicized. Politics is much more confrontational than is
social science. Many of us got wound up by Al Gore, who pointed us
at the deniers who were identified as "the enemy" when we perhaps
should have first gone out and worked with our friends. They would
have come on board by the millions if they were simply shown the full
story in an educational and non-confrontational manner and they
would have become part of the Concerned crowd, maybe even
joining the Alarmed.
But we took the bait and in doing so we fell into traps that have been
laid by the media and the Deniers, accepting their frames and
repeating their pet phrases, like "Clean Coal" over and over in
arguing against them, thereby strengthening their hands. For an
explanation of the idea of framing please read anything by George
Lakoff, such as
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/feb/01/george-lakoffinterview
Lakoff says "Framing is not primarily about politics or political
messaging or communication. It is far more fundamental than that:
frames are the mental structures that allow human beings to
understand reality – and sometimes to create what we take to be
reality. But frames do have an enormous bearing on politics … they
structure our ideas and concepts, they shape the way we reason …
For the most part, our use of frames is unconscious and automatic."
So you can understand why I am such an optimist for our work. I do
not, will not, and cannot, harbor negative thoughts about our
outcomes because in my framing we are headed toward a clean and
green future and the children of the World will lead the way. If we do
confront a skeptic or two in our evening program that is held every
night with www.climatechangeiselementary.org we have a big banner
on the wall that sets them straight. It says "Whether the climate is
changing or not, and whether people are the cause or not, these
children deserve a clean and green future."
When the denier rears his head, we read this in chorus and they
usually sit back down and stay quiet.
6. Petroleum is a legal drug to which we are all addicted. We cannot
effectively interdict the flow of illegal drugs, so how can we stop the
flow of a drug you and I use every day? Although I've been arrested
at the White House for standing up against Keystone XL Pipeline, I
think some of us need to look at the issue in a non-confrontational
manner, by reducing the demand for this drug we will make the
construction of all pipelines moot, and we will stop the oil trains as a
bonus. That is why I want to spend my energy helping people get
onto solar and wind energy, to reduce our dependence on the fossil
fuel drug. Although I'll still go to rallies, I'll let others fight against
fracking, pipelines, investments, mountain top removal, and other
fossil fuel related battles.
My latest two slides are a very quick and concise look at where I think
we are today in the moment in history when everything is about to
change.
And a projection of the cost of gasoline, probably very much
underestimated.
7. So my conclusion, written from the point of view of a 72 year old
eternal optimist is that we will lick this problem, but to do so we need
to get the huge group of disengaged elementary school and middle
school kids and their parents and teachers (most of whom are
actually cautious supporters) to make the sort of changes that those
of us who are concerned and alarmed know everyone needs to take.
Conclusions – Although I understand the natural human instinct to
join causes against perceived evils or impending crises, and have
many scars from such skirmishes myself, I see that there is another
way to solve any problem, and that is through the use of “honey
rather than vinegar.” Many people do not react well to images of
doom and gloom, but will react positively to stories about hope and
change. Dispirited people do not take action, but people who see a
glimmer of hope will act positively.
If we really want to solve this problem it is my contention that many of
us need to get on the positive side here and reframe the issue as one
we can solve with the appropriate application of grit and muscle. I
applaud the work of the groups that head bravely into battle, but I
prefer to work on changing the environment in which the war is taking
place to make the battle unnecessary.
Written in Celebration, FL - 7 February 2014