SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
Kendallville Bank
Case Study
Anastasiia Shevyreva
Ali Alizada
California State University Los Angeles
Outline
• What happened at Kendallville Bank
• The Fraud Triangle
• Organizational Chart
• CEO’S Course of Actions
CLO proposed changes to
ALLL calculation
Increase look-back period Combine CRE1 and CRE2
Effects on Net Income
1 Year Ago Current Year
Q2 Q3 Q2 Q3
Net Income $2.09 $2.01 $2.12 $2.04
1 Year Ago Current Year
Q2 Q3 Q2 Q3
PLLL $1.02 $0.98 $0.79 $0.76
The Fraud Triangle
Pressure
Incentives to
commit fraud:
1) Maintain
Reputation
2) Upcoming
Acquisition
Ability to commit
fraud:
1) Unquestioning
Trust of Upper
Management
2) Weak Internal
Controls
Justification of
Actions:
1) Just Combining
Categories
2) Help in
Acquisition
Organizational Chart
Board of
Directors
Audit
Committee
CEO
Head of
Internal
Audit
CFO
Consumer
Business
Head
CLO
Commercial
Business
Head
Chief
Operating
Officer
Senior VP
External
Reporting
Head of
Internal
Audit
Senior VP
External
Reporting
Renwood’s Course of Action
• Amendment of filed financial statements
• Investigate CLO Davis
• CFO Kmetko
• Internal control changes:
o System of checks & balances
o Audit Committee
Renwood’s Course of Action
• External audit
• Evaluate employee’s qualifications
• Train the Head of Internal Audit in ALLL
• Improve overall communication
Any Questions?

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Nidhi thigale portfolio
Nidhi thigale portfolioNidhi thigale portfolio
Nidhi thigale portfolioNidhi Thigale
 
Bonesz andrew arch_portfolio
Bonesz andrew arch_portfolioBonesz andrew arch_portfolio
Bonesz andrew arch_portfolioBonesaw
 
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-138299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1Nantha Kumaran
 
Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case StudyBusiness Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case StudyMizah Khalidi
 
Architectural competitions
Architectural  competitionsArchitectural  competitions
Architectural competitionszehbamp
 
architectural design
architectural design architectural design
architectural design ganesh keskar
 
Fraud in the Banking Sector
Fraud in the Banking Sector Fraud in the Banking Sector
Fraud in the Banking Sector Venktesh Venke
 
Architectural Portfolio
Architectural PortfolioArchitectural Portfolio
Architectural Portfoliotb55
 
Agency theory
Agency theoryAgency theory
Agency theorysagarphul
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Nidhi thigale portfolio
Nidhi thigale portfolioNidhi thigale portfolio
Nidhi thigale portfolio
 
Bonesz andrew arch_portfolio
Bonesz andrew arch_portfolioBonesz andrew arch_portfolio
Bonesz andrew arch_portfolio
 
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-138299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
38299644 tyco-fraud-case-study-1
 
Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case StudyBusiness Ethics TYCO Case Study
Business Ethics TYCO Case Study
 
Architectural competitions
Architectural  competitionsArchitectural  competitions
Architectural competitions
 
architectural design
architectural design architectural design
architectural design
 
Fraud in the Banking Sector
Fraud in the Banking Sector Fraud in the Banking Sector
Fraud in the Banking Sector
 
Architectural Portfolio
Architectural PortfolioArchitectural Portfolio
Architectural Portfolio
 
Agency theory
Agency theoryAgency theory
Agency theory
 

Similar to How Kendallville Bank Overcame Fraud and Strengthened Controls

04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf
04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf
04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdfWikudhara
 
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)Bladex
 
Bladex's 1 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 1 q15 conference call presentationBladex's 1 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 1 q15 conference call presentationBladex
 
Bladex's 3 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 3 q15 conference call presentationBladex's 3 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 3 q15 conference call presentationBladex
 
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)Bladex
 
The CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage Analysis
The CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage AnalysisThe CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage Analysis
The CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage AnalysisLibby Bierman
 
Progressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial ResultsProgressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial ResultsProgressiveWaste
 
Progressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings Release
Progressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings ReleaseProgressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings Release
Progressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings ReleaseProgressiveWaste
 
Progressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial ResultsProgressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial ResultsProgressiveWaste
 
1Q2016 earnings presentation
1Q2016 earnings presentation1Q2016 earnings presentation
1Q2016 earnings presentationBladex
 
Sustainablity Health Check for Tech Startups
Sustainablity Health Check for Tech StartupsSustainablity Health Check for Tech Startups
Sustainablity Health Check for Tech StartupsEkoInnovationCentre
 
Níall fitzgerald - CARB Reviews
Níall fitzgerald - CARB ReviewsNíall fitzgerald - CARB Reviews
Níall fitzgerald - CARB ReviewsDavinMcCormick
 
Peeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh Tucker
Peeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh TuckerPeeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh Tucker
Peeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh TuckerAMSolutions
 
North Kingstown 2008
North Kingstown 2008North Kingstown 2008
North Kingstown 2008jdwcpa
 
Why Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your Institution
Why Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your InstitutionWhy Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your Institution
Why Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your InstitutionBaker Hill
 
Financial Sustainability at UC Davis
Financial Sustainability at UC DavisFinancial Sustainability at UC Davis
Financial Sustainability at UC Davisucdavisarm
 

Similar to How Kendallville Bank Overcame Fraud and Strengthened Controls (20)

Campbells cagny 2014
Campbells cagny 2014Campbells cagny 2014
Campbells cagny 2014
 
ppt01.pptx
ppt01.pptxppt01.pptx
ppt01.pptx
 
04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf
04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf
04-01 - Financial Analysis.pdf
 
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 1 trim15 (inglés)
 
Bladex's 1 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 1 q15 conference call presentationBladex's 1 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 1 q15 conference call presentation
 
Bladex's 3 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 3 q15 conference call presentationBladex's 3 q15 conference call presentation
Bladex's 3 q15 conference call presentation
 
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)
Bladex presentación de llamada en conferencia 3 trim15 (inglés)
 
The CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage Analysis
The CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage AnalysisThe CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage Analysis
The CECL Workshop Series Part II: Vintage Analysis
 
Viva Presentation winc
Viva Presentation wincViva Presentation winc
Viva Presentation winc
 
Progressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial ResultsProgressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions First Quarter 2015 Financial Results
 
Progressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings Release
Progressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings ReleaseProgressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings Release
Progressive Waste Solutions Q2 2015 Earnings Release
 
Progressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial ResultsProgressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results
Progressive Waste Solutions Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results
 
1Q2016 earnings presentation
1Q2016 earnings presentation1Q2016 earnings presentation
1Q2016 earnings presentation
 
Sustainablity Health Check for Tech Startups
Sustainablity Health Check for Tech StartupsSustainablity Health Check for Tech Startups
Sustainablity Health Check for Tech Startups
 
Níall fitzgerald - CARB Reviews
Níall fitzgerald - CARB ReviewsNíall fitzgerald - CARB Reviews
Níall fitzgerald - CARB Reviews
 
Peeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh Tucker
Peeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh TuckerPeeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh Tucker
Peeling Back the Covers on Nonprofit Financials - Leigh Tucker
 
North Kingstown 2008
North Kingstown 2008North Kingstown 2008
North Kingstown 2008
 
Why Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your Institution
Why Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your InstitutionWhy Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your Institution
Why Knowing Profitability Is the Key to Success at Your Institution
 
Water Management - EPA Guidelines_Project
Water Management - EPA Guidelines_ProjectWater Management - EPA Guidelines_Project
Water Management - EPA Guidelines_Project
 
Financial Sustainability at UC Davis
Financial Sustainability at UC DavisFinancial Sustainability at UC Davis
Financial Sustainability at UC Davis
 

How Kendallville Bank Overcame Fraud and Strengthened Controls

  • 1. Kendallville Bank Case Study Anastasiia Shevyreva Ali Alizada California State University Los Angeles
  • 2. Outline • What happened at Kendallville Bank • The Fraud Triangle • Organizational Chart • CEO’S Course of Actions
  • 3. CLO proposed changes to ALLL calculation Increase look-back period Combine CRE1 and CRE2
  • 4. Effects on Net Income 1 Year Ago Current Year Q2 Q3 Q2 Q3 Net Income $2.09 $2.01 $2.12 $2.04 1 Year Ago Current Year Q2 Q3 Q2 Q3 PLLL $1.02 $0.98 $0.79 $0.76
  • 5. The Fraud Triangle Pressure Incentives to commit fraud: 1) Maintain Reputation 2) Upcoming Acquisition Ability to commit fraud: 1) Unquestioning Trust of Upper Management 2) Weak Internal Controls Justification of Actions: 1) Just Combining Categories 2) Help in Acquisition
  • 6. Organizational Chart Board of Directors Audit Committee CEO Head of Internal Audit CFO Consumer Business Head CLO Commercial Business Head Chief Operating Officer Senior VP External Reporting Head of Internal Audit Senior VP External Reporting
  • 7. Renwood’s Course of Action • Amendment of filed financial statements • Investigate CLO Davis • CFO Kmetko • Internal control changes: o System of checks & balances o Audit Committee
  • 8. Renwood’s Course of Action • External audit • Evaluate employee’s qualifications • Train the Head of Internal Audit in ALLL • Improve overall communication