SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Those of us fortunate enough to live in
Northern Wisconsin walk out each day
and marvel at the pristine beauty of the
place we call home.
People travel from hundreds of miles away to spend time here—to fish
and swim and sail in our waters. They see the value of our precious
natural resources.
Those who live near
Lake Superior must
remain keenly
aware of their role
as stewards of the
lake and the
streams that supply
water to it.
And right now, there are looming threats to the
health of the lake and the health of those of us
who choose to live here.
Local farmers have found this area to be an excellent place to
raise animals to support their families and supply the region,
and elsewhere, with quality meats and dairy products.
They have also
worked to manage
the size of their
herds and the
waste the animals
produce.
Even so, many times
each year, local
beaches in
Chequamegon Bay
are under advisory
or closed due to high
levels of E. coli
bacteria.
When high levels of E. coli are detected, it is likely
due to fecal matter from mammals.
E. coli is an indicator species that often means other
more harmful bacteria, viruses, and protozoans are
most likely present.
Giardia
Salmonella
E.Coli
Rotavirus CampylobacterTetnus
Fecal matter can makes its way to the lake via
runoff from the many streams, creeks, and rivers
in the Lake Superior watershed.
Heavy rains cause the ground to become saturated
and there is a higher chance of agricultural runoff
draining into Chequamegon Bay.
Photo by NOAA
We see evidence of this each spring and summer
when the bay runs red with clay deposits at the
mouth of Fish Creek.
What ends up in the Bay will travel to other parts of
the lake due to existing current patterns
From Dr. Randy Lehr, Co-director Center of Freshwater Innovation, Northland College
These diagrams demonstrate how far floating
objects can travel
From Dr. Randy Lehr, Co-director Center of Freshwater Innovation, Northland College
This region has many small
farmers, some of whom have up
to 500 animals on their farms.
This size is manageable and they
have been committed to
balancing manure storage and
spreading practices to keep
their waste out of the local
water sources.
Up until now family farms in this region
have managed the waste from their
farm animals with little scrutiny.
Reicks View Family Farms, LLC is
disrupting this historic balance by
proposing to build a CAFO eight miles
from Lake Superior on the Fish Creek
Watershed. Their CAFO will be called
Badgerwood LLC.
10% OF THE WORLDS
FRESH WATER
Photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
This facility will house approximately 26,000 animals
(or 6,162.5 animal units).
This is an unprecedented number of animals in the
region.
Photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
This CAFO will be the biggest pig factory in
Wisconsin.
Photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
Reicks View Family Farms is registered at 1020 Pembroke
Ave. in Lawler, Iowa and 666 Grand Ave. Suite 200 Des
Moines, Iowa. They also operate under the following 34
names:
Cottonwood Ridge LLC
Yellowwood Farms LLC
Birchwood Lane LLC
Jerico Construction LLC
Jerico Equipment Inc
Cherry Ridge LLC
Northwood Creek LLC
Miller Creek LLC
Cy Creek LLC
Reicks View Family Farms LLC
Reicks View Farms Quality
Meats LLC
Reicks View Mill LLC
Iowa Pantry LLC
Pinewood Ridge LLC
Willow Creek LLC
Cardinal Creek LLC
Ashwood Creek LLC
Dogwood Ridge LLC
Reicksview Farms LLC
Alde Controls Inc
Lake View Family Farms LLC
Rosewood Creek LLC
Maple Creek LLC
Linden Creek LLC
Oak View Farms LLC
The Pub At The Pinicon LLC
Melwood LLC
Northeast Iowa Artificial Insemination Inc
Gopherwood LLC
Peachwood Creek LLC
Pearwood Creek LLC
Badgerwood LLC
Goldbrook, LLC
When Pigs Fly LLC
Reicks View Family Farms calls itself
a “family farm”.
This HUGE CORPORATION is not a
family farm.
Recent purchases by the “Family Farm”
$634,900
c
c
Recent purchases by the “Family Farm”
$1,225,000
c
None of the family farmers we
know are able to make these
kind of purchases.
REICK$VILLE:
• They will NOT be supplying local meat.
• They will NOT be selling to local businesses.
Here are some of the places where this
meat may end up.
Economic Benefits?
• Reicks has their own mill, construction and
equipment companies
• They have their own experts for managing the
operation
• Most often, CAFO employees are transients
who will do the work no one else wants to do
• There may be tax revenue, but at what cost?
Potential Costs
• How will this effect local land and real estate
prices?
• What will this do to Highway 63 and other
local roads?
• How will it effect tourism?
• What about community-wide healthcare costs
related to this operation?
• Who is going to test the wells and aquifers
near this CAFO?
• How much would a potential clean up cost?
• And who would pay?
Badgerwood CAFO will produce 8.7 million
gallons of liquid manure per year.
This is roughly as much excrement as a city
of 50,000 people – equivalent to a city the
size of La Crosse.
Local farmers generally dispose of their
composted manure by spreading it over
fields for fertilizer.
This is a common and longstanding practice
that is dependent on the characteristics of
local soil and climate. The soil on the
proposed Town of Eileen site is significantly
clay-based which does not absorb liquid very
well.
Reicks has proposed
disposing of their 8.7
million gallons of liquid
raw manure by injecting it
directly into the soil at a
depth of 6” to 9”.
This is of great concern
because the land where this
8.7 million gallons of raw
liquid manure will be spread is
located near the headwaters
of Fish Creek which feeds into
Lake Superior's Chequamegon
Bay.
Chequamegon Bay is the source of drinking
water for the City of Ashland, a city of over
8,000 people.
There is also no way to predict what will happen to
the aquifers and wells in this area when this waste is
injected into the ground. If the clay and soil
temperatures inhibit the absorption of the waste
into the ground, it could find its way into the Fish
Creek Watershed.
The section of their nutrient management plan
dealing with manure storage only includes waste
production calculations for 180 days.
Reicks reported to the Bayfield County Board that
they will have the capacity to store manure for
12-14 months to allow for fluctuations in weather
and will work with the community to find “optimal
spreading times”.
The proposed Badgerwood CAFO will self-
report and self-regulate all activities relating
to water usage, nutrient levels in the manure,
and manure storage and spreading.
In addition to dangerous bacteria, the runoff will add high levels of
phosphorous and nitrogen to the lake that may cause algae blooms
which will suck the oxygen out of the water, killing plants and fish----
potentially creating a Dead Zone such as the ones in Green Bay and
Lake Erie.
Chequamegon Bay is
currently considered to
be one of the prime fish
biodiversity sites in the
country. The runoff of
such large amounts of
phosphorous and
nitrogen has the
potential to decimate
life in the Bay.
This would come at a heavy cost to commercial and
sports fishing on Chequamegon Bay.
Heard enough yet?
Heard enough yet?
According to the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration, nearly 80 percent of
antibiotics in the United States are sold for
use in livestock.
Antibiotic use by agriculture is not regulated
and does not need to be reported.
It has been proven that the excessive use of
antibiotics has created super bugs and
antibiotic-resistant strains of bacteria such as
MRSA (Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus
aureus), which can be life threatening.
Drug resistant bacteria can be spread through
food products, manure, air, wildlife, insects,
transport trucks, and crops.
[Silbergeld et al, Medical Clinics of North America, 2008]
Reicks wants to move
into our area to
increase their ‘bio-
security’ and avoid
diseases such as PEDv
that have a nearly 100
percent mortality rate
in suckling piglets.
e McArthur / We Animals
In addition to disease prevention,
there may be other motivating
factors to move to WI including
dispersed production, adequate
supply of corn, “rational”
regulations, positive tax climate,
land availability for manure
spreading, and more.
Their aim is to breed
sows in Bayfield County
and ship the young
piglets back to Iowa
along Highway 63.
The Badgerwood pig factory would also use vast
amounts of water. In their permit application, they
estimate that they will be using approximately
24,367,508 gallons of water per year.
This corporation
has moved into
our community,
dividing us—
pitting citizens
against one
another—all in the
name of their
profit.
Farmers and others have existed in this region in
cooperation for hundreds of years.
The owners of the Badgerwood CAFO are not
concerned with our community, our health, or our
water.
THEY ARE IN IT FOR PROFIT AND PROFIT ONLY.
It should not be done at our expense. It is up to
each of us to act as stewards of Lake Superior and
the health of those of us who call this place home.
If you’d like more info go to:
farmsnotfactories.com
Photos by
Eric Iversen
Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
Mary Dougherty
Julie Buckles
Jeremy Oswald
Joe Van Der Puy
NOAA
CDC
Created by
Gina Kirsten
Jeremy Oswald
Amber Vadnais

More Related Content

What's hot

Nov 2007 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2007 Santa Barbara AudubonNov 2007 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2007 Santa Barbara Audubon
xx5v4
 
Nov 2006 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2006 Santa Barbara AudubonNov 2006 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2006 Santa Barbara Audubon
xx5v4
 
Freshwater Matters from the FBA
Freshwater Matters from the FBAFreshwater Matters from the FBA
Freshwater Matters from the FBA
Lancaster University
 
Water first nations ws8.3
Water   first nations ws8.3Water   first nations ws8.3
Water first nations ws8.3
chauber
 
Okehampton April 2018: Community Information Session
Okehampton April 2018: Community Information SessionOkehampton April 2018: Community Information Session
Okehampton April 2018: Community Information Session
Tassal_Community
 
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013
Long Beach Grows
 
Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...
Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...
Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...
Innspub Net
 
AES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINT
AES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINTAES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINT
AES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINTBenjamin Reynard
 
Little plover river presentation revised v2 2013
Little plover river presentation  revised  v2 2013Little plover river presentation  revised  v2 2013
Little plover river presentation revised v2 2013BarbGifford
 
Tribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual Report
Tribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual ReportTribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual Report
Tribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual Report
Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission
 
Water first nations ws8.1
Water   first nations ws8.1Water   first nations ws8.1
Water first nations ws8.1
chauber
 
Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark
Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark
Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark IIAD
 
Performance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp Feeds
Performance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp FeedsPerformance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp Feeds
Performance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp FeedsAlberto Nunes
 
Biosecurity
BiosecurityBiosecurity
Biosecurity
iswadi37
 
1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer
1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer
1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer
Brad Attig
 
MooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposter
MooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposterMooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposter
MooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposterCallie B. Moore
 
Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022
Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022
Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022
Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission
 
Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...
Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...
Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...
riseagrant
 
Optimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat Snook
Optimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat SnookOptimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat Snook
Optimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat Snook
Alberto Nunes
 

What's hot (20)

Nov 2007 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2007 Santa Barbara AudubonNov 2007 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2007 Santa Barbara Audubon
 
Nov 2006 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2006 Santa Barbara AudubonNov 2006 Santa Barbara Audubon
Nov 2006 Santa Barbara Audubon
 
Freshwater Matters from the FBA
Freshwater Matters from the FBAFreshwater Matters from the FBA
Freshwater Matters from the FBA
 
Water first nations ws8.3
Water   first nations ws8.3Water   first nations ws8.3
Water first nations ws8.3
 
Okehampton April 2018: Community Information Session
Okehampton April 2018: Community Information SessionOkehampton April 2018: Community Information Session
Okehampton April 2018: Community Information Session
 
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013
Sustainable Agriculture & Food Security lecture to CSULB 4-26-2013
 
Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...
Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...
Ratio « number of males on number of females » for the mass production of Sar...
 
AES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINT
AES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINTAES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINT
AES MeadowMixBroch 2014 PRINT
 
Little plover river presentation revised v2 2013
Little plover river presentation  revised  v2 2013Little plover river presentation  revised  v2 2013
Little plover river presentation revised v2 2013
 
Tribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual Report
Tribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual ReportTribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual Report
Tribal Natural Resources Management 2021 Annual Report
 
Water first nations ws8.1
Water   first nations ws8.1Water   first nations ws8.1
Water first nations ws8.1
 
May2013
May2013May2013
May2013
 
Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark
Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark
Disposal option-in-shenandoah-cty-va-r.clark
 
Performance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp Feeds
Performance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp FeedsPerformance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp Feeds
Performance of Animal Protein Sources in Shrimp Feeds
 
Biosecurity
BiosecurityBiosecurity
Biosecurity
 
1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer
1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer
1st Alternative Co-op Jan 13 Ad Flyer
 
MooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposter
MooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposterMooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposter
MooreandSpragens_YKDCacklersBerries_13NAAGposter
 
Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022
Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022
Tribal Natural Resources Management Annual Report for 2022
 
Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...
Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...
Carl LoBue, "TNC’s shellfish restoration efforts on Long Island NY: Achieveme...
 
Optimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat Snook
Optimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat SnookOptimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat Snook
Optimal Dietary Lipid, Energy Content For Fat Snook
 

Similar to Cafo presentation 6.3.2015 standard

Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011
Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011
Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011Shahla Werner
 
Data Reports New Orleans 0909 Lemmon
Data Reports New Orleans 0909 LemmonData Reports New Orleans 0909 Lemmon
Data Reports New Orleans 0909 Lemmon
Blue Thumb
 
Wisconsin Water Issues
Wisconsin Water IssuesWisconsin Water Issues
Wisconsin Water Issues
Shahla Werner
 
Maui - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and Today
Maui  - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and TodayMaui  - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and Today
Maui - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and Today
Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Fox Valley Water Resources
Fox Valley Water ResourcesFox Valley Water Resources
Fox Valley Water Resources
kakelly2
 
Fox valley water resources
Fox valley water resourcesFox valley water resources
Fox valley water resources
kakelly2
 
Ethics show and tell 1
Ethics show and tell 1Ethics show and tell 1
Ethics show and tell 1
Zach Hanson
 
Diet for a changing climate
Diet for a changing climateDiet for a changing climate
Diet for a changing climate
Coacharya
 
Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014
Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014
Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014Shahla Werner
 
Heal the Susquehanna
Heal the SusquehannaHeal the Susquehanna
Heal the Susquehanna
Stewards of the Lower Susquehanna
 
Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...
Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...
Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...
Clifton M. Hasegawa & Associates, LLC
 
Matt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498C
Matt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498CMatt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498C
Matt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498CMatthew Villalobos
 
Toward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshop
Toward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshopToward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshop
Toward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshop
ILRI
 
Stateof issues water_2013
Stateof issues water_2013Stateof issues water_2013
Stateof issues water_2013Shahla Werner
 
Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...
Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...
Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...
John Blue
 
Sustainable? agriculture and water in California
Sustainable? agriculture and water in California Sustainable? agriculture and water in California
Sustainable? agriculture and water in California
DavidBainbridge5
 
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston MassachusettsOyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Mass Oyster Project
 
How to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docx
How to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docxHow to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docx
How to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...
Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...
Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...
John Blue
 

Similar to Cafo presentation 6.3.2015 standard (20)

Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011
Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011
Foxvalleywaterresources 09082011
 
Data Reports New Orleans 0909 Lemmon
Data Reports New Orleans 0909 LemmonData Reports New Orleans 0909 Lemmon
Data Reports New Orleans 0909 Lemmon
 
Wisconsin Water Issues
Wisconsin Water IssuesWisconsin Water Issues
Wisconsin Water Issues
 
Maui - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and Today
Maui  - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and TodayMaui  - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and Today
Maui - Agriculture and Water -- Yesterday and Today
 
Fox Valley Water Resources
Fox Valley Water ResourcesFox Valley Water Resources
Fox Valley Water Resources
 
Fox valley water resources
Fox valley water resourcesFox valley water resources
Fox valley water resources
 
Ethics show and tell 1
Ethics show and tell 1Ethics show and tell 1
Ethics show and tell 1
 
Diet for a changing climate
Diet for a changing climateDiet for a changing climate
Diet for a changing climate
 
Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014
Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014
Protecting Wisconsin's Water - 2014
 
Heal the Susquehanna
Heal the SusquehannaHeal the Susquehanna
Heal the Susquehanna
 
Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...
Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...
Hawaii - Natural Environment - Environmental Stewardship - A Sense of Place -...
 
Matt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498C
Matt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498CMatt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498C
Matt Villalobos POSTER ECO 498C
 
Toward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshop
Toward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshopToward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshop
Toward a LWP assessment methodology: a contribution to the Karkheh CPWF workshop
 
Stateof issues water_2013
Stateof issues water_2013Stateof issues water_2013
Stateof issues water_2013
 
Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...
Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...
Dr. John Hawke - Exploring Lessons from Disease Management in Commercial Aqua...
 
Sustainable? agriculture and water in California
Sustainable? agriculture and water in California Sustainable? agriculture and water in California
Sustainable? agriculture and water in California
 
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston MassachusettsOyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
 
How to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docx
How to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docxHow to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docx
How to Farm a Better Fish By Joel K. Bourne, Jr. Photographs.docx
 
Stewardship Station
Stewardship StationStewardship Station
Stewardship Station
 
Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...
Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...
Mr. Sebastian Belle - Problems, Stumbling Blocks and Solutions for U.S. Aquac...
 

Cafo presentation 6.3.2015 standard

  • 1. Those of us fortunate enough to live in Northern Wisconsin walk out each day and marvel at the pristine beauty of the place we call home.
  • 2. People travel from hundreds of miles away to spend time here—to fish and swim and sail in our waters. They see the value of our precious natural resources.
  • 3. Those who live near Lake Superior must remain keenly aware of their role as stewards of the lake and the streams that supply water to it.
  • 4. And right now, there are looming threats to the health of the lake and the health of those of us who choose to live here.
  • 5. Local farmers have found this area to be an excellent place to raise animals to support their families and supply the region, and elsewhere, with quality meats and dairy products.
  • 6. They have also worked to manage the size of their herds and the waste the animals produce.
  • 7. Even so, many times each year, local beaches in Chequamegon Bay are under advisory or closed due to high levels of E. coli bacteria.
  • 8. When high levels of E. coli are detected, it is likely due to fecal matter from mammals. E. coli is an indicator species that often means other more harmful bacteria, viruses, and protozoans are most likely present. Giardia Salmonella E.Coli Rotavirus CampylobacterTetnus
  • 9. Fecal matter can makes its way to the lake via runoff from the many streams, creeks, and rivers in the Lake Superior watershed.
  • 10. Heavy rains cause the ground to become saturated and there is a higher chance of agricultural runoff draining into Chequamegon Bay. Photo by NOAA
  • 11. We see evidence of this each spring and summer when the bay runs red with clay deposits at the mouth of Fish Creek.
  • 12. What ends up in the Bay will travel to other parts of the lake due to existing current patterns From Dr. Randy Lehr, Co-director Center of Freshwater Innovation, Northland College
  • 13. These diagrams demonstrate how far floating objects can travel From Dr. Randy Lehr, Co-director Center of Freshwater Innovation, Northland College
  • 14. This region has many small farmers, some of whom have up to 500 animals on their farms. This size is manageable and they have been committed to balancing manure storage and spreading practices to keep their waste out of the local water sources.
  • 15. Up until now family farms in this region have managed the waste from their farm animals with little scrutiny.
  • 16. Reicks View Family Farms, LLC is disrupting this historic balance by proposing to build a CAFO eight miles from Lake Superior on the Fish Creek Watershed. Their CAFO will be called Badgerwood LLC. 10% OF THE WORLDS FRESH WATER
  • 17. Photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
  • 18. This facility will house approximately 26,000 animals (or 6,162.5 animal units). This is an unprecedented number of animals in the region. Photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
  • 19. This CAFO will be the biggest pig factory in Wisconsin. Photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals
  • 20. Reicks View Family Farms is registered at 1020 Pembroke Ave. in Lawler, Iowa and 666 Grand Ave. Suite 200 Des Moines, Iowa. They also operate under the following 34 names: Cottonwood Ridge LLC Yellowwood Farms LLC Birchwood Lane LLC Jerico Construction LLC Jerico Equipment Inc Cherry Ridge LLC Northwood Creek LLC Miller Creek LLC Cy Creek LLC Reicks View Family Farms LLC Reicks View Farms Quality Meats LLC Reicks View Mill LLC Iowa Pantry LLC Pinewood Ridge LLC Willow Creek LLC Cardinal Creek LLC Ashwood Creek LLC Dogwood Ridge LLC Reicksview Farms LLC Alde Controls Inc Lake View Family Farms LLC Rosewood Creek LLC Maple Creek LLC Linden Creek LLC Oak View Farms LLC The Pub At The Pinicon LLC Melwood LLC Northeast Iowa Artificial Insemination Inc Gopherwood LLC Peachwood Creek LLC Pearwood Creek LLC Badgerwood LLC Goldbrook, LLC When Pigs Fly LLC
  • 21. Reicks View Family Farms calls itself a “family farm”. This HUGE CORPORATION is not a family farm.
  • 22. Recent purchases by the “Family Farm” $634,900 c c
  • 23. Recent purchases by the “Family Farm” $1,225,000 c
  • 24. None of the family farmers we know are able to make these kind of purchases.
  • 25. REICK$VILLE: • They will NOT be supplying local meat. • They will NOT be selling to local businesses.
  • 26. Here are some of the places where this meat may end up.
  • 27. Economic Benefits? • Reicks has their own mill, construction and equipment companies • They have their own experts for managing the operation • Most often, CAFO employees are transients who will do the work no one else wants to do • There may be tax revenue, but at what cost?
  • 28. Potential Costs • How will this effect local land and real estate prices? • What will this do to Highway 63 and other local roads? • How will it effect tourism? • What about community-wide healthcare costs related to this operation? • Who is going to test the wells and aquifers near this CAFO? • How much would a potential clean up cost? • And who would pay?
  • 29. Badgerwood CAFO will produce 8.7 million gallons of liquid manure per year. This is roughly as much excrement as a city of 50,000 people – equivalent to a city the size of La Crosse.
  • 30. Local farmers generally dispose of their composted manure by spreading it over fields for fertilizer.
  • 31. This is a common and longstanding practice that is dependent on the characteristics of local soil and climate. The soil on the proposed Town of Eileen site is significantly clay-based which does not absorb liquid very well.
  • 32. Reicks has proposed disposing of their 8.7 million gallons of liquid raw manure by injecting it directly into the soil at a depth of 6” to 9”.
  • 33. This is of great concern because the land where this 8.7 million gallons of raw liquid manure will be spread is located near the headwaters of Fish Creek which feeds into Lake Superior's Chequamegon Bay.
  • 34. Chequamegon Bay is the source of drinking water for the City of Ashland, a city of over 8,000 people.
  • 35. There is also no way to predict what will happen to the aquifers and wells in this area when this waste is injected into the ground. If the clay and soil temperatures inhibit the absorption of the waste into the ground, it could find its way into the Fish Creek Watershed.
  • 36. The section of their nutrient management plan dealing with manure storage only includes waste production calculations for 180 days. Reicks reported to the Bayfield County Board that they will have the capacity to store manure for 12-14 months to allow for fluctuations in weather and will work with the community to find “optimal spreading times”.
  • 37. The proposed Badgerwood CAFO will self- report and self-regulate all activities relating to water usage, nutrient levels in the manure, and manure storage and spreading.
  • 38. In addition to dangerous bacteria, the runoff will add high levels of phosphorous and nitrogen to the lake that may cause algae blooms which will suck the oxygen out of the water, killing plants and fish---- potentially creating a Dead Zone such as the ones in Green Bay and Lake Erie.
  • 39. Chequamegon Bay is currently considered to be one of the prime fish biodiversity sites in the country. The runoff of such large amounts of phosphorous and nitrogen has the potential to decimate life in the Bay.
  • 40. This would come at a heavy cost to commercial and sports fishing on Chequamegon Bay.
  • 41. Heard enough yet? Heard enough yet?
  • 42. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, nearly 80 percent of antibiotics in the United States are sold for use in livestock. Antibiotic use by agriculture is not regulated and does not need to be reported.
  • 43. It has been proven that the excessive use of antibiotics has created super bugs and antibiotic-resistant strains of bacteria such as MRSA (Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus), which can be life threatening.
  • 44. Drug resistant bacteria can be spread through food products, manure, air, wildlife, insects, transport trucks, and crops. [Silbergeld et al, Medical Clinics of North America, 2008]
  • 45. Reicks wants to move into our area to increase their ‘bio- security’ and avoid diseases such as PEDv that have a nearly 100 percent mortality rate in suckling piglets. e McArthur / We Animals
  • 46. In addition to disease prevention, there may be other motivating factors to move to WI including dispersed production, adequate supply of corn, “rational” regulations, positive tax climate, land availability for manure spreading, and more.
  • 47. Their aim is to breed sows in Bayfield County and ship the young piglets back to Iowa along Highway 63.
  • 48. The Badgerwood pig factory would also use vast amounts of water. In their permit application, they estimate that they will be using approximately 24,367,508 gallons of water per year.
  • 49. This corporation has moved into our community, dividing us— pitting citizens against one another—all in the name of their profit.
  • 50. Farmers and others have existed in this region in cooperation for hundreds of years.
  • 51. The owners of the Badgerwood CAFO are not concerned with our community, our health, or our water. THEY ARE IN IT FOR PROFIT AND PROFIT ONLY. It should not be done at our expense. It is up to each of us to act as stewards of Lake Superior and the health of those of us who call this place home.
  • 52. If you’d like more info go to: farmsnotfactories.com
  • 53. Photos by Eric Iversen Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals Mary Dougherty Julie Buckles Jeremy Oswald Joe Van Der Puy NOAA CDC
  • 54. Created by Gina Kirsten Jeremy Oswald Amber Vadnais