SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Building effective analogies
          Ajay Ganapathy
Analogies

• According to Schema Theory, people
  understand new, unfamiliar things in terms of
  old, familiar things,

• They do this by constructing analogies that
  bridge the gap between the unfamiliar and
  familiar.
The limits of analogies

• Analogies are a lot like bridges. There are
  limits to how far they can stretch, and they will
  collapse under excessive tension.

• The more tenuous an analogy, the less weight
  a learner can place on it before it falls
  through.
Native understanding
• Bridges are only a pathway to a destination.
  Similarly, analogies are only a means to an
  end. In this case, that end is a comprehensive
  mental model that gives learners a sense of
  familiarity to the concepts they are learning.

• We can refer to this end as a "native
  understanding"
Building effective
          analogies

• A bridge is only useful if it can be crossed.

• Every analogy has to be custom-built to the
  user's schema.
Teachers and
             designers
• Teachers build a separate bridge for each user.
  Each bridge is built to reach out to the exact
  schema of the user. Teachers then lead each user
  across the bridge.

• Designers build a single bridge that is accessible
  to most users. They leave the job of reaching out
  to each individual user to the teacher.

• Designers make the job of the teacher easier.
Making one analogy for
      everyone.
• Who is the lowest common denominator in
  your target audience?

• What does this person know?

• What does this person not know?

• What does this person think they know?

More Related Content

Similar to Building good analogies

Remedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large Classes
Remedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large ClassesRemedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large Classes
Remedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large ClassesDilip Barad
 
Tamu copyright accessibility
Tamu copyright accessibilityTamu copyright accessibility
Tamu copyright accessibilityljmcneill33
 
How to Teach Transitions in The Classroom
How to Teach Transitions in The ClassroomHow to Teach Transitions in The Classroom
How to Teach Transitions in The ClassroomC B
 
illumnus LMS for School - Open Deck
illumnus LMS for School - Open Deckillumnus LMS for School - Open Deck
illumnus LMS for School - Open DeckAkash Deep Singhal
 
Free the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern Community
Free the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern CommunityFree the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern Community
Free the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern CommunityDouglas Schuler
 
Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010
Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010
Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010Stephen Best
 
253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx
253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx
253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptxSaiGuyo
 
10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change
10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change
10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of ChangeJoyce Seitzinger
 
Evaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessme
Evaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessmeEvaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessme
Evaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessmeIFLA
 
Sharefest val garton
Sharefest   val gartonSharefest   val garton
Sharefest val gartonvgarton
 
Design Strategy for UCForward
Design Strategy for UCForwardDesign Strategy for UCForward
Design Strategy for UCForwardmagrislm04
 
Saltspring.personalized learning
Saltspring.personalized learningSaltspring.personalized learning
Saltspring.personalized learningFaye Brownlie
 
Paul Willett - theory
Paul Willett - theoryPaul Willett - theory
Paul Willett - theoryPaul Willett
 
Brooke before and after comp presentor notes
Brooke before and after comp presentor notesBrooke before and after comp presentor notes
Brooke before and after comp presentor notescpudawg2k9
 
Teaching Text Structure
Teaching Text StructureTeaching Text Structure
Teaching Text StructureEmily Kissner
 
Rupert.nov.6 12session
Rupert.nov.6 12sessionRupert.nov.6 12session
Rupert.nov.6 12sessionFaye Brownlie
 

Similar to Building good analogies (20)

Mooc presentation 1
Mooc presentation 1Mooc presentation 1
Mooc presentation 1
 
Remedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large Classes
Remedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large ClassesRemedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large Classes
Remedy for the Challenge of Continuous Assessment in Large Classes
 
Tamu copyright accessibility
Tamu copyright accessibilityTamu copyright accessibility
Tamu copyright accessibility
 
ASH2023 aug 23 Malina .pptx
ASH2023 aug 23  Malina .pptxASH2023 aug 23  Malina .pptx
ASH2023 aug 23 Malina .pptx
 
ELPS Strategies
ELPS StrategiesELPS Strategies
ELPS Strategies
 
How to Teach Transitions in The Classroom
How to Teach Transitions in The ClassroomHow to Teach Transitions in The Classroom
How to Teach Transitions in The Classroom
 
illumnus LMS for School - Open Deck
illumnus LMS for School - Open Deckillumnus LMS for School - Open Deck
illumnus LMS for School - Open Deck
 
Free the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern Community
Free the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern CommunityFree the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern Community
Free the Patterns! The Vital Challenge to the Pattern Community
 
Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010
Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010
Science Book Studies as PLCs - MSTA 2010
 
UDL Assignment
UDL AssignmentUDL Assignment
UDL Assignment
 
253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx
253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx
253155929-Interactive-Reading-Model.pptx
 
10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change
10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change
10 Learner Experience Powers from Experience Girl - #imoot16 Agents of Change
 
Evaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessme
Evaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessmeEvaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessme
Evaluating library spaces while developing a ?culture of assessme
 
Sharefest val garton
Sharefest   val gartonSharefest   val garton
Sharefest val garton
 
Design Strategy for UCForward
Design Strategy for UCForwardDesign Strategy for UCForward
Design Strategy for UCForward
 
Saltspring.personalized learning
Saltspring.personalized learningSaltspring.personalized learning
Saltspring.personalized learning
 
Paul Willett - theory
Paul Willett - theoryPaul Willett - theory
Paul Willett - theory
 
Brooke before and after comp presentor notes
Brooke before and after comp presentor notesBrooke before and after comp presentor notes
Brooke before and after comp presentor notes
 
Teaching Text Structure
Teaching Text StructureTeaching Text Structure
Teaching Text Structure
 
Rupert.nov.6 12session
Rupert.nov.6 12sessionRupert.nov.6 12session
Rupert.nov.6 12session
 

More from Ajay Ganapathy

Critique of infinity blade
Critique of infinity bladeCritique of infinity blade
Critique of infinity bladeAjay Ganapathy
 
The zen of hidden functionality
The zen of hidden functionalityThe zen of hidden functionality
The zen of hidden functionalityAjay Ganapathy
 
The three state model for input
The three state model for inputThe three state model for input
The three state model for inputAjay Ganapathy
 
The language of the user interface
The language of the user interfaceThe language of the user interface
The language of the user interfaceAjay Ganapathy
 
Mental models and intuition
Mental models and intuitionMental models and intuition
Mental models and intuitionAjay Ganapathy
 
Final presentation for ITGM 120
Final presentation for ITGM 120Final presentation for ITGM 120
Final presentation for ITGM 120Ajay Ganapathy
 

More from Ajay Ganapathy (6)

Critique of infinity blade
Critique of infinity bladeCritique of infinity blade
Critique of infinity blade
 
The zen of hidden functionality
The zen of hidden functionalityThe zen of hidden functionality
The zen of hidden functionality
 
The three state model for input
The three state model for inputThe three state model for input
The three state model for input
 
The language of the user interface
The language of the user interfaceThe language of the user interface
The language of the user interface
 
Mental models and intuition
Mental models and intuitionMental models and intuition
Mental models and intuition
 
Final presentation for ITGM 120
Final presentation for ITGM 120Final presentation for ITGM 120
Final presentation for ITGM 120
 

Building good analogies

  • 2. Analogies • According to Schema Theory, people understand new, unfamiliar things in terms of old, familiar things, • They do this by constructing analogies that bridge the gap between the unfamiliar and familiar.
  • 3. The limits of analogies • Analogies are a lot like bridges. There are limits to how far they can stretch, and they will collapse under excessive tension. • The more tenuous an analogy, the less weight a learner can place on it before it falls through.
  • 4. Native understanding • Bridges are only a pathway to a destination. Similarly, analogies are only a means to an end. In this case, that end is a comprehensive mental model that gives learners a sense of familiarity to the concepts they are learning. • We can refer to this end as a "native understanding"
  • 5. Building effective analogies • A bridge is only useful if it can be crossed. • Every analogy has to be custom-built to the user's schema.
  • 6. Teachers and designers • Teachers build a separate bridge for each user. Each bridge is built to reach out to the exact schema of the user. Teachers then lead each user across the bridge. • Designers build a single bridge that is accessible to most users. They leave the job of reaching out to each individual user to the teacher. • Designers make the job of the teacher easier.
  • 7. Making one analogy for everyone. • Who is the lowest common denominator in your target audience? • What does this person know? • What does this person not know? • What does this person think they know?