This document summarizes a literature review on the ethical implications of native advertising. It defines native advertising as paid content that matches the style and format of independent editorial content. While native ads can be effective, they are often accused of being deceptive by disguising advertising as real content. The document examines definitions of deceptive advertising and reviews studies on factors that influence the credibility of native ads. It concludes by proposing five guidelines for creating native ads in an ethical manner that avoids misleading consumers about the sponsored nature of the content.
This document summarizes a research article that critiques the dominant "information processing model" of advertising. Some key points:
- The information processing model views advertising as a one-way communication to convey a clear message about product benefits in order to increase knowledge, change attitudes, and ultimately drive purchases.
- However, the article argues this model is inadequate and not reflective of how most successful advertising actually works. It cites an example where highly creative advertising that contained no explicit product information performed exceptionally well in the real world, contradicting research predictions.
- The information processing model is deeply embedded in advertising practices through research methodologies, agency/client processes, and marketing textbooks, despite limited empirical support. The article calls
The Elongating Tail of Brand Communication: An approach to brand-building inc...Iqbal Mohammed
This document discusses an approach to brand building that incorporates long tail economics. It argues that traditional brand positioning, which focuses on communicating a single clear message, is outdated in today's fragmented media landscape. Instead, it proposes that brands should communicate multiple credible brand propositions to different consumer segments using the long tail approach. This allows brands to build layered, nuanced identities without sacrificing simplicity. The document outlines how marketers can harness the power of the long tail in brand communication to create engaging brands.
Predictive Pre-Testing: A New Model for Ad Pre-Testing Based on Prediction Ma...Iqbal Mohammed
The document proposes a new model for advertising pre-testing based on prediction markets. It argues that current pre-testing methods using focus groups are unreliable and fail to capture diverse, independent opinions. The proposed model would use a prediction market approach to aggregate responses from a decentralized group. This would better align with the "wisdom of crowds" principle of tapping into collective intelligence. However, several challenges must be addressed such as how to provide real-world outcomes to judge predictions and how to motivate diverse strategies among participants in a single pre-testing session. The document also discusses moving from introspective individual responses to having participants predict how others would respond to ads.
Is native advertising something new, or just a new name? Is it the same as content marketing? How does it relate to social media marketing? Does native advertising work? Does it have negative consequences for society?Should native advertisement be deregulated, or should it be more seriously regulated?
This document discusses future trends in advertising. It predicts that in 10 years, advertisements will need to be more attention-getting, interactive, and brief due to consumers having less time and shorter attention spans. Small businesses will be able to market themselves globally through online tools. However, some consumers may want fewer product ads, so personalized advertising based on personal data and interests may become more common, though this raises privacy concerns. Celebrity endorsements and visually appealing images in ads will also remain effective strategies.
Advertising exists to gain our attention in public spaces and persuade us to buy products. It works through various media platforms and appeals to emotions, nostalgia, and aspirations. Advertising suggests life will be better if we consume certain products and makes viewers feel anxiety that can only be relieved by purchasing. While advertising claims to support consumer choice, it also uses stereotypes and sells audiences to other companies. There is debate around how to reasonably limit advertising and whether it imposes values within a free market society.
1. Stall Talk provides creative marketing solutions through adhesive vinyl wraps installed on portable restrooms at large outdoor events. This allows brands to advertise to captive audiences.
2. Stall Talk collects demographic and social media data from people who respond to offers using mobile technology. This allows advertisers to analyze campaign effectiveness and target follow up.
3. Advertisers can choose from hundreds of events across the US catering to millions of attendees to install their wraps. Stall Talk measures engagement and ROI for marketing campaigns.
This document summarizes a research article that critiques the dominant "information processing model" of advertising. Some key points:
- The information processing model views advertising as a one-way communication to convey a clear message about product benefits in order to increase knowledge, change attitudes, and ultimately drive purchases.
- However, the article argues this model is inadequate and not reflective of how most successful advertising actually works. It cites an example where highly creative advertising that contained no explicit product information performed exceptionally well in the real world, contradicting research predictions.
- The information processing model is deeply embedded in advertising practices through research methodologies, agency/client processes, and marketing textbooks, despite limited empirical support. The article calls
The Elongating Tail of Brand Communication: An approach to brand-building inc...Iqbal Mohammed
This document discusses an approach to brand building that incorporates long tail economics. It argues that traditional brand positioning, which focuses on communicating a single clear message, is outdated in today's fragmented media landscape. Instead, it proposes that brands should communicate multiple credible brand propositions to different consumer segments using the long tail approach. This allows brands to build layered, nuanced identities without sacrificing simplicity. The document outlines how marketers can harness the power of the long tail in brand communication to create engaging brands.
Predictive Pre-Testing: A New Model for Ad Pre-Testing Based on Prediction Ma...Iqbal Mohammed
The document proposes a new model for advertising pre-testing based on prediction markets. It argues that current pre-testing methods using focus groups are unreliable and fail to capture diverse, independent opinions. The proposed model would use a prediction market approach to aggregate responses from a decentralized group. This would better align with the "wisdom of crowds" principle of tapping into collective intelligence. However, several challenges must be addressed such as how to provide real-world outcomes to judge predictions and how to motivate diverse strategies among participants in a single pre-testing session. The document also discusses moving from introspective individual responses to having participants predict how others would respond to ads.
Is native advertising something new, or just a new name? Is it the same as content marketing? How does it relate to social media marketing? Does native advertising work? Does it have negative consequences for society?Should native advertisement be deregulated, or should it be more seriously regulated?
This document discusses future trends in advertising. It predicts that in 10 years, advertisements will need to be more attention-getting, interactive, and brief due to consumers having less time and shorter attention spans. Small businesses will be able to market themselves globally through online tools. However, some consumers may want fewer product ads, so personalized advertising based on personal data and interests may become more common, though this raises privacy concerns. Celebrity endorsements and visually appealing images in ads will also remain effective strategies.
Advertising exists to gain our attention in public spaces and persuade us to buy products. It works through various media platforms and appeals to emotions, nostalgia, and aspirations. Advertising suggests life will be better if we consume certain products and makes viewers feel anxiety that can only be relieved by purchasing. While advertising claims to support consumer choice, it also uses stereotypes and sells audiences to other companies. There is debate around how to reasonably limit advertising and whether it imposes values within a free market society.
1. Stall Talk provides creative marketing solutions through adhesive vinyl wraps installed on portable restrooms at large outdoor events. This allows brands to advertise to captive audiences.
2. Stall Talk collects demographic and social media data from people who respond to offers using mobile technology. This allows advertisers to analyze campaign effectiveness and target follow up.
3. Advertisers can choose from hundreds of events across the US catering to millions of attendees to install their wraps. Stall Talk measures engagement and ROI for marketing campaigns.
This document summarizes a study on the post-purchase behavior of customers who purchased the Hyundai i10 car in Chennai, India. The study aimed to identify customers' post-purchase behavior, satisfaction levels, and perceptions of after-sales service. A survey was conducted of 150 Hyundai i10 owners. The findings suggested that customers' income, age, and perceptions of value and delivery time influenced their satisfaction levels and expectations of after-sales service. The study provided recommendations to improve customer satisfaction and service.
Regulators took enforcement actions against over 25 companies in 2015 for deceptive advertising of consumer financial products. The top lessons from these actions were: 1) advertisements must accurately explain the nature of the product; 2) all terms and conditions must be clearly disclosed; 3) advertisements must represent offers that are actually available; 4) companies are responsible for oversight of vendors' advertising; and 5) advertisements cannot obscure their true source.
"Marketers be aware" of deceptive advertising, trade practices and consumer r...Maxwell Ranasinghe
This document discusses issues with deceptive advertising practices in Sri Lanka and calls for marketers to be aware of consumer protections and the Consumer Affairs Authority (CAA). It highlights several common deceptive practices like false claims in infomercials, misleading offers in telemarketing, and exaggerated health/safety claims. The CAA has strong legal powers to investigate misleading advertising under the Consumer Affairs Authority Act. As consumers become more educated and assertive of their rights, there is potential for many future cases against deceptive marketers. The document advises marketers to reduce deception in advertising and be aware of consumers' negative perceptions of ads, as well as the CAA's ability to crack down on violations.
Andrew Miller Natural Advertising LawsuitsAndrew Miller
The document discusses the increasing number of lawsuits against food manufacturers for making deceptive "natural" claims without a clear industry or regulatory definition of the term. With no standard definition, consumer expectations of "natural" foods are often misleadingly different than the actual ingredients in the products. This confusion has led to lawsuits against companies like Quaker Oats, Kashi, and General Mills for labeling foods containing synthetic ingredients or pesticide residues as "100% natural". The FDA is seeking public input on defining "natural" but has not yet acted, while the FTC has recently taken action against companies for falsely advertising "all natural" personal care products. Food marketers are warned to carefully consider "natural" claims given the rising litigation and
Illinois Complaint Against Financial Advisor Charged With Falsely Advertising...Advisors4Advisors
The complaint alleges that Defendants Dick Van Dyke Financial, Ltd. and Richard Lee Van Dyke, Jr. engaged in unfair and deceptive business practices related to the marketing and sale of insurance products, particularly deferred annuities, to senior citizens. Specifically, the complaint alleges that the Defendants misrepresented Dick Van Dyke's qualifications and credentials to portray him as an objective financial expert, when in fact his primary business was selling annuities on commission. The complaint further alleges that the Defendants used misleading and deceptive marketing strategies, including false claims about Dick Van Dyke's credentials and certifications, as well as misrepresentations about the nature of "educational seminars" to target senior citizens for the sale of annuities
This document summarizes a student paper on false advertising. The paper examines what constitutes false advertising, tactics used like bait-and-switch and artificially inflated prices. It discusses regulators like the FTC and FCC that police false ads. As an example, it outlines a case where Lord & Taylor paid Instagram influencers without disclosing it was an ad. The conclusion is that as advertising becomes more competitive, it's important for consumers and regulators to be aware of deceptive practices.
Idp presentation on Consumer Behavior towards online shopping in Jamnagar cityDarshana Chauhan
This document summarizes a research report on consumer behavior towards online shopping in Jamnagar City, India. The report was prepared by two students under the guidance of a professor. It includes an introduction to online shopping, literature review on the topic, research objectives and design, data collection methods, findings, suggestions and conclusions. The key findings are that Amazon is the most preferred website, discounts strongly influence purchases, and faster delivery is important to consumers. Suggestions include developing mobile apps and improving website design and delivery speed.
Post purchase behavior of consumers towards hyundai productsDr. Raghavendra GS
This document provides an overview of the Indian automobile industry from its beginnings in the late 19th century through modern times. It discusses key events and policies that shaped the industry, including the establishment of early assembly plants in the 1920s-1940s, government restrictions post-independence that stalled growth, the introduction of Maruti Suzuki in the 1980s that kickstarted mass production, and liberalization in the 1990s that opened the market to foreign manufacturers. The document also profiles major players in the industry like Hyundai, Tata, and Mahindra and analyzes factors influencing consumer purchasing behavior.
ERP is a type of business management software that allows organizations to collect, store, manage and interpret data across business functions like procurement, manufacturing, sales, inventory and shipping in real-time from a common database. ERP provides an integrated view of core business processes and tracks resources and commitments throughout the organization. While originally designed for large enterprises, smaller businesses also increasingly adopt ERP systems.
The document discusses the benefits of exercise for mental health. Regular physical activity can help reduce anxiety and depression and improve mood and cognitive function. Exercise causes chemical changes in the brain that may help protect against mental illness and improve symptoms for those who already suffer from conditions like anxiety and depression.
Este documento presenta varios ejemplos de maltrato animal, incluyendo un perro que recibió una paliza brutal por parte de sus dueños, una leona maltratada y desnutrida en un circo, un oso que le falta la parte inferior de la mandíbula, un caballo desnutrido, y una imagen de un dueño pisando la cabeza de su mascota. El documento también menciona que el abandono constituye maltrato animal y expresa horror por el maltrato de los animales.
El documento describe el origen e historia de Internet, sus principales usos como la comunicación, el comercio, los estudios y el entretenimiento. También explica los fraudes de correo electrónico más comunes, donde las víctimas son contactadas por supuestos herederos ricos que ofrecen una parte de una herencia a cambio de ayuda para transferir fondos. Finalmente, presenta una serie de comportamientos digitales responsables para proteger la privacidad e integridad personal y de los demás en Internet.
This document describes a convolutional neural network model for classifying images of distracted drivers into 10 categories. The authors used transfer learning with pre-trained AlexNet and Inception v3 models, replacing the final layers and retraining on the distracted driver image dataset. They applied techniques like dropout and data augmentation to prevent overfitting given the small dataset size. The model achieved good results, demonstrating that transfer learning from models trained on large datasets can be effective for smaller specialized classification tasks.
Native Advertising and Content Marketing - White Paper - IAB Europe - Decembr...Romain Fonnier
Dans un livre blanc sur le native advertising et le content marketing, l’IAB Europe livre un aperçu de la manière dont ce type de contenus contribue à fournir de meilleures expériences publicitaires. La publication revient également sur les nouveaux types de formats et fournit des conseils sur la création et la distribution de ces publicités.
Ont notamment contribué à ce livre blanc, Stéphane Hauser (IAB France), Charlotte Diemer (Teads), Mick Loizou Michail (Yahoo), Jean-Paul Edwards (OMD), Libby Wright (MediaCom)…
This document provides an overview of native advertising and content marketing. It discusses how native advertising can enable meaningful relationships between consumers and brands by providing high-quality content that fits with the style and format of surrounding editorial content. The document also outlines key considerations for creating and distributing native advertising, including ensuring transparency and distinguishing advertising from editorial content. Publisher and advertiser perspectives on native advertising are presented.
IAB Europe White Paper : Native Advertising and Content Marketing - December ...SCREENVIEW
This document provides an overview and guidance on native advertising and content marketing. It defines key terms and discusses various native advertising formats including in-feed units, recommendation widgets, social media units, and out-stream video ads. It also covers business models for native advertising, including how content is monetized through production and distribution fees. The document aims to help advertisers, publishers and marketers better understand native advertising and its opportunities to build meaningful consumer relationships.
study: readers' evaluations of native advertising in a mobile news appSimone Krouwer
Qualitative study on readers' perceptions of native ads in a mobile news app. Presented at the Annual conference of the American Advertising Academy in New York (2018)
A qualitative study on readers' evaluations of native advertisements in a mob...Simone Krouwer
Usability testing and interviews
4 key factors that are important:
- Recognizability
- Credibility of the advertiser
- Perceived control
- Information utility
Readers prefer native advertisements over paying for online news. Most readers also prefer native ads over banner ads and pre-roll video ads, due to perceived control (banner ads and video ads are more intrustive).
A presentation discussing the increasingly popular trend of Native advertising. Written as though we're presenting on a panel for an agency. Done for Advanced Media Strategies in the TexasMedia Sequence at the University of Texas at Austin.
This document provides an overview of native advertising. It begins with a definition and history of native advertising, explaining how it is integrated advertising content designed to look like normal site content. It then discusses the types of native advertising units and provides examples. The document notes that native advertising is growing as consumers prefer valuable content over interruptive ads. It concludes by outlining the benefits of native advertising for advertisers, such as higher brand engagement and intent to purchase.
This document summarizes a study on the post-purchase behavior of customers who purchased the Hyundai i10 car in Chennai, India. The study aimed to identify customers' post-purchase behavior, satisfaction levels, and perceptions of after-sales service. A survey was conducted of 150 Hyundai i10 owners. The findings suggested that customers' income, age, and perceptions of value and delivery time influenced their satisfaction levels and expectations of after-sales service. The study provided recommendations to improve customer satisfaction and service.
Regulators took enforcement actions against over 25 companies in 2015 for deceptive advertising of consumer financial products. The top lessons from these actions were: 1) advertisements must accurately explain the nature of the product; 2) all terms and conditions must be clearly disclosed; 3) advertisements must represent offers that are actually available; 4) companies are responsible for oversight of vendors' advertising; and 5) advertisements cannot obscure their true source.
"Marketers be aware" of deceptive advertising, trade practices and consumer r...Maxwell Ranasinghe
This document discusses issues with deceptive advertising practices in Sri Lanka and calls for marketers to be aware of consumer protections and the Consumer Affairs Authority (CAA). It highlights several common deceptive practices like false claims in infomercials, misleading offers in telemarketing, and exaggerated health/safety claims. The CAA has strong legal powers to investigate misleading advertising under the Consumer Affairs Authority Act. As consumers become more educated and assertive of their rights, there is potential for many future cases against deceptive marketers. The document advises marketers to reduce deception in advertising and be aware of consumers' negative perceptions of ads, as well as the CAA's ability to crack down on violations.
Andrew Miller Natural Advertising LawsuitsAndrew Miller
The document discusses the increasing number of lawsuits against food manufacturers for making deceptive "natural" claims without a clear industry or regulatory definition of the term. With no standard definition, consumer expectations of "natural" foods are often misleadingly different than the actual ingredients in the products. This confusion has led to lawsuits against companies like Quaker Oats, Kashi, and General Mills for labeling foods containing synthetic ingredients or pesticide residues as "100% natural". The FDA is seeking public input on defining "natural" but has not yet acted, while the FTC has recently taken action against companies for falsely advertising "all natural" personal care products. Food marketers are warned to carefully consider "natural" claims given the rising litigation and
Illinois Complaint Against Financial Advisor Charged With Falsely Advertising...Advisors4Advisors
The complaint alleges that Defendants Dick Van Dyke Financial, Ltd. and Richard Lee Van Dyke, Jr. engaged in unfair and deceptive business practices related to the marketing and sale of insurance products, particularly deferred annuities, to senior citizens. Specifically, the complaint alleges that the Defendants misrepresented Dick Van Dyke's qualifications and credentials to portray him as an objective financial expert, when in fact his primary business was selling annuities on commission. The complaint further alleges that the Defendants used misleading and deceptive marketing strategies, including false claims about Dick Van Dyke's credentials and certifications, as well as misrepresentations about the nature of "educational seminars" to target senior citizens for the sale of annuities
This document summarizes a student paper on false advertising. The paper examines what constitutes false advertising, tactics used like bait-and-switch and artificially inflated prices. It discusses regulators like the FTC and FCC that police false ads. As an example, it outlines a case where Lord & Taylor paid Instagram influencers without disclosing it was an ad. The conclusion is that as advertising becomes more competitive, it's important for consumers and regulators to be aware of deceptive practices.
Idp presentation on Consumer Behavior towards online shopping in Jamnagar cityDarshana Chauhan
This document summarizes a research report on consumer behavior towards online shopping in Jamnagar City, India. The report was prepared by two students under the guidance of a professor. It includes an introduction to online shopping, literature review on the topic, research objectives and design, data collection methods, findings, suggestions and conclusions. The key findings are that Amazon is the most preferred website, discounts strongly influence purchases, and faster delivery is important to consumers. Suggestions include developing mobile apps and improving website design and delivery speed.
Post purchase behavior of consumers towards hyundai productsDr. Raghavendra GS
This document provides an overview of the Indian automobile industry from its beginnings in the late 19th century through modern times. It discusses key events and policies that shaped the industry, including the establishment of early assembly plants in the 1920s-1940s, government restrictions post-independence that stalled growth, the introduction of Maruti Suzuki in the 1980s that kickstarted mass production, and liberalization in the 1990s that opened the market to foreign manufacturers. The document also profiles major players in the industry like Hyundai, Tata, and Mahindra and analyzes factors influencing consumer purchasing behavior.
ERP is a type of business management software that allows organizations to collect, store, manage and interpret data across business functions like procurement, manufacturing, sales, inventory and shipping in real-time from a common database. ERP provides an integrated view of core business processes and tracks resources and commitments throughout the organization. While originally designed for large enterprises, smaller businesses also increasingly adopt ERP systems.
The document discusses the benefits of exercise for mental health. Regular physical activity can help reduce anxiety and depression and improve mood and cognitive function. Exercise causes chemical changes in the brain that may help protect against mental illness and improve symptoms for those who already suffer from conditions like anxiety and depression.
Este documento presenta varios ejemplos de maltrato animal, incluyendo un perro que recibió una paliza brutal por parte de sus dueños, una leona maltratada y desnutrida en un circo, un oso que le falta la parte inferior de la mandíbula, un caballo desnutrido, y una imagen de un dueño pisando la cabeza de su mascota. El documento también menciona que el abandono constituye maltrato animal y expresa horror por el maltrato de los animales.
El documento describe el origen e historia de Internet, sus principales usos como la comunicación, el comercio, los estudios y el entretenimiento. También explica los fraudes de correo electrónico más comunes, donde las víctimas son contactadas por supuestos herederos ricos que ofrecen una parte de una herencia a cambio de ayuda para transferir fondos. Finalmente, presenta una serie de comportamientos digitales responsables para proteger la privacidad e integridad personal y de los demás en Internet.
This document describes a convolutional neural network model for classifying images of distracted drivers into 10 categories. The authors used transfer learning with pre-trained AlexNet and Inception v3 models, replacing the final layers and retraining on the distracted driver image dataset. They applied techniques like dropout and data augmentation to prevent overfitting given the small dataset size. The model achieved good results, demonstrating that transfer learning from models trained on large datasets can be effective for smaller specialized classification tasks.
Native Advertising and Content Marketing - White Paper - IAB Europe - Decembr...Romain Fonnier
Dans un livre blanc sur le native advertising et le content marketing, l’IAB Europe livre un aperçu de la manière dont ce type de contenus contribue à fournir de meilleures expériences publicitaires. La publication revient également sur les nouveaux types de formats et fournit des conseils sur la création et la distribution de ces publicités.
Ont notamment contribué à ce livre blanc, Stéphane Hauser (IAB France), Charlotte Diemer (Teads), Mick Loizou Michail (Yahoo), Jean-Paul Edwards (OMD), Libby Wright (MediaCom)…
This document provides an overview of native advertising and content marketing. It discusses how native advertising can enable meaningful relationships between consumers and brands by providing high-quality content that fits with the style and format of surrounding editorial content. The document also outlines key considerations for creating and distributing native advertising, including ensuring transparency and distinguishing advertising from editorial content. Publisher and advertiser perspectives on native advertising are presented.
IAB Europe White Paper : Native Advertising and Content Marketing - December ...SCREENVIEW
This document provides an overview and guidance on native advertising and content marketing. It defines key terms and discusses various native advertising formats including in-feed units, recommendation widgets, social media units, and out-stream video ads. It also covers business models for native advertising, including how content is monetized through production and distribution fees. The document aims to help advertisers, publishers and marketers better understand native advertising and its opportunities to build meaningful consumer relationships.
study: readers' evaluations of native advertising in a mobile news appSimone Krouwer
Qualitative study on readers' perceptions of native ads in a mobile news app. Presented at the Annual conference of the American Advertising Academy in New York (2018)
A qualitative study on readers' evaluations of native advertisements in a mob...Simone Krouwer
Usability testing and interviews
4 key factors that are important:
- Recognizability
- Credibility of the advertiser
- Perceived control
- Information utility
Readers prefer native advertisements over paying for online news. Most readers also prefer native ads over banner ads and pre-roll video ads, due to perceived control (banner ads and video ads are more intrustive).
A presentation discussing the increasingly popular trend of Native advertising. Written as though we're presenting on a panel for an agency. Done for Advanced Media Strategies in the TexasMedia Sequence at the University of Texas at Austin.
This document provides an overview of native advertising. It begins with a definition and history of native advertising, explaining how it is integrated advertising content designed to look like normal site content. It then discusses the types of native advertising units and provides examples. The document notes that native advertising is growing as consumers prefer valuable content over interruptive ads. It concludes by outlining the benefits of native advertising for advertisers, such as higher brand engagement and intent to purchase.
Antecedents and consequences of web advertising credibility冠儒 黃
This study examines how source credibility, including website credibility and advertiser credibility, impact consumer responses to banner ads. It explores these relationships through a literature review and research model testing the effects of credibility on ad credibility, brand attitudes, and purchase intentions. An experiment was conducted developing websites and banner ads to test the hypotheses. Results found that both website and advertiser credibility positively influence ad credibility and consumer responses. Advertiser credibility was also found to directly impact brand attitudes and purchase intent. Product relevance between the website content and ad was also found to influence responses. The study expands understanding of how source credibility impacts online advertising effectiveness.
guest lecture university of amsterdam native advertising Simone Krouwer
This document discusses native advertising on online news platforms. It begins by defining native advertising as paid advertisements that mimic the form and function of the editorial content they appear alongside. It then notes that spending on native advertising formats in Europe is expected to reach €13.2 billion by 2020. The document goes on to discuss several studies that have examined factors like advertisement labeling, brand prominence, message sidedness, and advertiser credibility that influence readers' responses to native ads. The overall conclusion is that native ads are most effective when they are clearly labeled, limit brand prominence, provide two-sided messages like a journalist would, and come from a credible source.
Select three advertisements from three different countries using tra.docxzenobiakeeney
Select three advertisements from three different countries using traditional advertising venues and Internet advertising venues. Assess how culture and ethics influence understanding the ad from each country.Incorporate concepts and examples from this week’s lecture in your post.
Week Three Lecture
Advertising Message
Welcome to the world of advertising! How many of you think advertisers unfairly influence us and “make” us buy items we do not need, cannot afford, and will not use? If you raised your hand or silently said “I do,” then you are among a majority of people who think advertisers will lie to encourage sales and believe consumers are helpless pawns in the corporate game of profitability.
Nothing could be further from the truth! Advertisers design catchy slogans, phrases, and songs to help us remember the points about a particular item the organization thinks will appeal to us. Did advertisers create the need? No! Did advertisers determine whether or not we wanted an item? Again, no! Although the psychology behind buyer motivation is the focus for another course, advertisers only use what is known to appeal to a specific group of buyers in hopes of affecting sales.
We are entering a world of bright lights, vivid colors, and every sensory perception will become aware when a commercial is on that appeals to something we have decided we need. Why do we want a Mercedes? Good quality? No, superior quality! But does it really cost $30,000 more to manufacturer a Mercedes than, say, a Ford? Most likely not. Then why do we have a mental image of a Mercedes as a premium product? Why, advertisers, of course! Keep in mind as we move throughout our course . . . advertisers work very hard to write messages and music that will appeal to us and motivate us into action.
The objective of advertising is to “inform, persuade, and reminder consumers about business and organizational products and other offerings” (Ogden & Ogden, 2014, section 4.1). There are three message executional frameworks: cognitive; affective; and conative, and how marketers determine which strategy has the highest probability of producing the desired effect on consumer behavior (Clow & Baack, 2012). Parker (2013) stated national universities tend to use more emotional, ego-based ads whereas regional universities tend to use more informational and rational ads. National universities use the affective message strategy, whereas regional universities use the cognitive message strategy. The key is to determine what type of message has the greatest chance of impacting consumer behavior.
Writing an advertising plan requires tedious and detailed concentration on many items. Figure 4.1 (Ogden & Ogden, 2014) in our text lists the ten steps in writing an advertising plan. As you can see from the figure, there is a tremendous amount of work involved in the planning. Today’s marketing managers are being held responsible for ROI within their allocated budget, so time must be taken to get th.
Advertisements are of great importance for any business activity as it attracts people to use the particular service. Most of the businessmen are using various different means of communication to reach people around the world and turn them into leads that can be further turned into potent customers. There are various ways of putting up an advertisement as per the audience to be addressed. Most people use to look for these advertisements very carefully observing carefully the specifications and efficiency of the featured product. However, it’s impossible for someone to get the reality check through these advertisements, so in order to get clearer idea about a particular service one must go for people’s feedback about a particular product or service and these feedbacks must also be genuine as some of them maybe done for fake publicity.
The document discusses best practices for building an effective brand newsroom. It recommends clearly defining the target audience and establishing an editorial proposition that provides "news you can use" rather than just promoting the brand. It also advises finding an authentic tone of voice and focusing on quality over going viral. The key is producing useful content that addresses issues the audience cares about rather than just talking about the brand.
Native advertising on online news platforms was discussed. Key points included:
- Native advertising mimics the look and feel of editorial content to promote brands.
- European spending on native advertising is expected to reach €13.2 billion by 2020.
- Disclosure labels and brand prominence influence how readers perceive native ads. More prominent brands and less clear labels lead to more negative evaluations.
- More detailed disclosure labels about ad authorship and the business model increase transparency and understanding without harming perceptions.
- Two-sided native ads that discuss both benefits and limitations are perceived as more credible than one-sided ads and are processed less critically by readers.
- Source credibility also influences perceptions, with high-credibility sources
The document is a major project essay that analyzes whether the decline of mass media will lead to a shift from brand building through advertising to public relations based on conversation and relationships. It first evaluates evidence around the decline of mass media and advertising, finding that while mass media is changing with new online formats, there is no clear evidence it is declining. It then examines how advertising has adapted to the online environment through targeted and social ads. While advertising has grown online, consumers now have more control over ads and word-of-mouth is important for brands. The essay concludes that brands are focusing on engaging consumers through social media to develop relationships and conversations in order to build their brands.
The Impact of Creativity and Wow Factor in AdvertisingProjects Kart
The approach used in this report is a case study approach. It essentially deals with two aspects; creativity and WOW factor. These two terms have been defined and the impact they have in advertising has been studied. The objectives of doing such a study were to understand creativity, to define it and to find factors that elicit a WOW response from viewers.
The document provides a framework for discussing native advertising options with the goal of reducing marketplace confusion. It identifies six main types of native ad units and provides guidelines for how advertisers should evaluate these units. Specifically, it recommends advertisers consider how the ad fits with the page design, its function, integration, buying/targeting options, measurement metrics, and disclosure. The framework is intended to establish a common language for discussing native ads and focus the industry on effectiveness rather than debates over ad unit definitions.
The document discusses the rise of native advertising and defines it as sponsored content that is relevant to consumers, not interruptive, and looks similar to the surrounding editorial content. It summarizes research conducted on consumer behaviors and attitudes toward native advertising versus traditional ads. The research found that younger generations have a strong preference for native advertising and are more likely to interact with brands online. It concludes that native advertising is effective for reaching younger audiences and is likely to continue growing as these generations age.
Look at the different types of advertising shown in Table 4.2 of the.docxeubanksnefen
Look at the different types of advertising shown in Table 4.2 of the text. Select one product and determine how each type of advertising strategy would be used. Incorporate concepts and examples from this week’s lecture in your post.
Week Three Lecture
Advertising Message
Welcome to the world of advertising! How many of you think advertisers unfairly influence us and “make” us buy items we do not need, cannot afford, and will not use? If you raised your hand or silently said “I do,” then you are among a majority of people who think advertisers will lie to encourage sales and believe consumers are helpless pawns in the corporate game of profitability.
Nothing could be further from the truth! Advertisers design catchy slogans, phrases, and songs to help us remember the points about a particular item the organization thinks will appeal to us. Did advertisers create the need? No! Did advertisers determine whether or not we wanted an item? Again, no! Although the psychology behind buyer motivation is the focus for another course, advertisers only use what is known to appeal to a specific group of buyers in hopes of affecting sales.
We are entering a world of bright lights, vivid colors, and every sensory perception will become aware when a commercial is on that appeals to something we have decided we need. Why do we want a Mercedes? Good quality? No, superior quality! But does it really cost $30,000 more to manufacturer a Mercedes than, say, a Ford? Most likely not. Then why do we have a mental image of a Mercedes as a premium product? Why, advertisers, of course! Keep in mind as we move throughout our course . . . advertisers work very hard to write messages and music that will appeal to us and motivate us into action.
The objective of advertising is to “inform, persuade, and reminder consumers about business and organizational products and other offerings” (Ogden & Ogden, 2014, section 4.1). There are three message executional frameworks: cognitive; affective; and conative, and how marketers determine which strategy has the highest probability of producing the desired effect on consumer behavior (Clow & Baack, 2012). Parker (2013) stated national universities tend to use more emotional, ego-based ads whereas regional universities tend to use more informational and rational ads. National universities use the affective message strategy, whereas regional universities use the cognitive message strategy. The key is to determine what type of message has the greatest chance of impacting consumer behavior.
Writing an advertising plan requires tedious and detailed concentration on many items. Figure 4.1 (Ogden & Ogden, 2014) in our text lists the ten steps in writing an advertising plan. As you can see from the figure, there is a tremendous amount of work involved in the planning. Today’s marketing managers are being held responsible for ROI within their allocated budget, so time must be taken to get the advertising plan written in a manner for the .
1. Running head: NATIVE ADVERTISING 1
Native Advertising:
Ethical Implications and Guidelines for Effective Utilization
Madeline J. Buchel
DePaul University
2. NATIVE ADVERTISING
2
Abstract
Native advertising is a technique that has grown in popularity in recent years; as digital
journalism continues to be on the rise, native advertising has become a “hot topic” in the
advertising world. As the format of native advertisements is constantly changing, particularly in
regards to in-feed ads, new ethical quandaries have arisen not just in the field of advertisement,
but in journalism as well. The purpose of this literature review is to examine what makes a native
advertisement ethical by defining deception in advertising while simultaneously investigating
how source credibility affects the effectiveness of native advertisements. This paper also
analyzes visual and rhetorical studies in its quest to provide five guidelines for both advertisers
and publishers on how to best maximize the effectiveness and the ethical soundness of native
advertisements.
3. NATIVE ADVERTISING
3
Native Advertising’s Place in the Current Digital Landscape
In June of 2014, The New York Times ran an article by Melanie Deziel entitled “Women
Inmates: Why the Male Model Doesn’t Work.” It discussed the specific plight of women
prisoners, complete with statistics and interviews with psychologists, leaders of advocacy
groups, and past inmates. At the top of the page, two small logos denoted that this real piece of
reporting was, in fact, a “paid post,” or advertisement—for Netflix and their original program,
Orange Is the New Black. This work by T Brand Studio, the branded content studio in The New
York Times advertising department, was highlighted by a variety of advertising publications (e.g.,
Moses, 2014; Sebastian, 2014). In particular, Moses (2014) quoted the tweets of a number of
journalists praising the narrative quality of this sponsored content. When considering the
“separation of church and state” language that is usually used to discuss the divide between
journalism and advertising, these reporters’ praise seems especially remarkable.
At the same time, there have been outspoken critics of this advertising approach, most notably
John Oliver, host of the popular HBO satirical news show Last Week Tonight, and blogger
Andrew Sullivan, creator of news site The Dish. According to a summary by Lichterman (2014),
Oliver argued on his show that native advertising acts “simply to trick readers since they won’t
click on traditional banner ads.” In a Digiday interview, Sullivan went one step further, saying,
“If [sites like The New York Times] wanted not to deceive, they would have these as ads, not as
paid posts” (Braiker, 2014). Sullivan also questioned the many terms that are used to refer to the
concept of native advertising, such as “sponsored content” and “branded content” adding, “as
soon as they start giving you gibberish, you realize they’re doing something naughty.”
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has defined native advertising as “the blending of
advertisements with news, entertainment, and other editorial content in digital media” noting that
4. NATIVE ADVERTISING
4
this phenomenon can also be described by the terms “custom content,” “brand journalism,” and
“advertorials” (Kurnit, 2014). In 2013, the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) released a
playbook outlining the burgeoning field of native advertising with the goal of providing a
universal framework with which to discuss it. IAB admits there is “no universally agreed-upon”
definition of native advertising; however, the clear goal of the technique is “to deliver paid ads
that are so cohesive with the page content, assimilated into the design, and consistent with the
platform behavior that the viewer simply feels that they belong” (IAB, 2013). Six categories
were suggested to differentiate the various kinds of native advertising: in-feed ads, search ads,
recommendation widgets, promoted listings, in-ad (IAB standard), and custom/can’t be
contained. This is far from an exhaustive list of labels that the industry uses; however, for the
purposes of this paper, the focus will be on “native advertising” defined as IAB’s “in-feed ad.”
These two starkly different perspectives about native advertising from tad consumers present
an ethical dilemma for the advertisers as well as the publishers. Those who reproach native
advertising often use the word “deception” to criticize the practice (Wasserman, 2013).
However, in a similar way to how the advertising industry has found it difficult to agree upon a
definition of “native advertising,” what it means for an ad to be deceptive is up for debate among
academics, professionals, and various regulatory agencies. Therefore, this paper asks, “What
does it mean for an ad to be deceptive, and how can this be avoided while also creating ethical
native advertisements?” To answer the question, this paper examines the definition of deceptive
advertising, provides a review of what makes native advertising more or less credible, and
examines studies of visual rhetoric to propose how to create effective in-feed native
advertisements in an ethical manner.
5. NATIVE ADVERTISING
5
What is Native Advertising?
The 2014 Times “paid post” article on women inmates falls under the category of an in-feed
ad—“an endemic in-feed ad that is in a publisher’s normal content well, is in story form where
the content has been written by or in partnership with the publisher’s team to match the
surrounding stories, links to a page within the site like any editorial story, has been sold with a
guaranteed placement so the buyer knows exactly what context will surround it, and is measured
on brand metrics such as interaction and brand lift” (IAB, 2013, p. 8). According to the IAB
playbook, commonly used disclosure language associated with in-feed ads include
“advertisement,” “promoted,” “sponsored,” “presented by,” and/or “suggested.” Journalist Amar
Bakshi contextualizes the definition of native advertisement for online advertising—“it refers to
the practice of online publishers accepting payment from particular advertisers to publish
customized content that looks very similar—in terms of tone, presentation, and functionality—to
the independently produced news, editorial, and entertainment content on the site” (2015, p. 6).
Deception in Advertising
Since native advertising is frequently accused of being deceptive in nature, it is important
to understand what this truly means. In his 1975 conceptualization of deception in advertising,
Gardner acquiesces it is difficult to define. He proposes a definition that is prescriptive, not
proscriptive, suggesting that if an advertisement “leaves the consumer with an impression(s)
and/or belief(s) different from what would normally be expected if the consumer had reasonable
knowledge, and that impression(s) and/or belief(s) is factually untrue or potentially misleading
(p. 42),” then one can conclude that it is deception. However, as it is reasonable to assume there
will always be people who claim to not have knowledge of a certain brand or project and,
6. NATIVE ADVERTISING
6
therefore, feel misled, Carson, Wokutch, and Cox (1985) make the important distinction between
“consumers” and “intelligent and knowledgeable adults” and provide a revised definition
replacing “consumers” with “intelligent and knowledgeable adults (or a significant percentage of
intelligent and knowledgeable adults)” (p. 95). Thus, if someone who is educated on the content
of an advertisement is confused as to its true meaning, then it can be deemed deceptive and
problematic.
The Federal Trade Commission has long defined deceptive advertisements as those which
“mislead consumers into believing they are independent, impartial, or not from the sponsoring
advertiser itself” (2015, p. 1). Most recently, the FTC has extended this definition to specifically
address native advertisements; it maintains that regardless of medium, deception occurs when
consumers are misled about a source in a way that has the potential to affect their decision-
making process. In most of the anecdotes included in the FTC enforcement policy statement,
advertisers were instructed to clearly denote an advertorial or in-feed native ad as a “Paid
Advertisement” in order to ensure it is not deceptive to viewers (p. 4). The major difference
between academic definitions of deceptive advertising and the FTC’s wording is the FTC
stresses advertisement can only be deceptive if it is likely to affect the behavior of the viewer of
the ad. While certain findings suggest viewers are most likely to recognize an advertisement if
disclosures are positioned in the middle or bottom of an article, it is important to note
experimental studies would have to occur with virtually every native ad to accurately determine
if a “Paid Advertisement” label changes how the viewer chooses to interact with the product or
brand after seeing it (Wojdynski & Evans, 2015).
When it comes to native advertising, it is essential to keep in mind that if every ad was a
native ad, they would cease to be effective because consumers would adapt their approach to
7. NATIVE ADVERTISING
7
media in light of that fact. This is one of the arguments against both deceptive advertising and
native advertising—a Kantian approach to the ethics of native advertising would claim that, for it
to be an ethically sound practice, every advertisement should be able to be a native advertisement
(Carson et al., 1985). However, while native advertisements would cease to be effective should
that be the case, it is important to address the healthy skepticism that all intelligent and
knowledgeable adults should exhibit when approaching any kind of media, whether it be a news
article or an in-feed advertisement (Carson et al., 1985).
The trouble with native advertisement comes when even if a skeptical approach is employed,
the reader of the in-feed ad is not aware of the agenda at hand. Amar Bakshi, a former journalist,
addresses this by pointing to a Scientology in-feed ad in The Atlantic as an example. Not only
was an in-feed ad used for a controversial topic, such as religion, the article was written in a tone
not in keeping with the publication’s other articles. While it is possible to argue that writing a
native advertisement in a different style from the parent publication has the potential to make it
easier for readers to identify the article as an advertisement, it is jarring to the reader and, by
most definitions of deceptive advertising, is not enough to constitute an acknowledgment of the
sponsored nature of the article. Most egregiously, in the case of The Atlantic’s Scientology
advertisement, the comments section was painstakingly monitored and all negative comments
were removed (Bakshi, 2015).
Advertising is strategic action, not strictly communicative action, and this should be
considered before accusing any native advertising of being deceptive. However, it is essential
that the consumer, the intelligent and knowledgeable adult, is able to consciously acknowledge
the strategic action at play. When comments sections are censored, or controversial opinions are
8. NATIVE ADVERTISING
8
presented in the form of an ostensibly unbiased news article, native advertising does have the
potential to become problematic and should be avoided at all costs.
Michael Sebastian writes in his 2014 AdAge article, “Confusing the consumer about the
source of the ad is simply an unintended consequence of creating more engaging ads.” Native
advertising is designed to entertain and appeal to the reader—if ads that look like trailers or
television shows don’t offend anyone’s ethical sensibilities, if consumers are fine with
discovering new music by hearing it in a commercial, then why do ads that match the tone of a
publication face backlash? Perhaps, the backlash is only deserved when the in-feed ad is jarring
to the reader, when there has been no effort put in for it to seamlessly match the agenda of the
article. As Worzel puts it, “The greatest sin of The Atlantic…may be licensing bizarre and
uninteresting content that falls well outside the walls of the magazine’s brand” (2013).
Source Credibility in Advertising and Journalism
Source credibility is a major tenant of effective and ethical journalism and advertising, and
this is no less true when applied to the practice of native advertising. Source credibility is defined
as “a message source’s ability or motivation to provide accurate or truthful information”
(Kelman and Hovland, 1953). Source credibility is equated with the trustworthiness of the ad,
and so it is essential that an in-feed ad is both placed within a publication that is trusted by its
target audience while simultaneously not threatening the credibility of that publication by its
content. For both publisher and advertiser, it is important to keep in mind that if a controversial
or opinion-based product or brand is natively advertised it can imply endorsement by the
publication. This can upset the consumer’s view of both the advertiser and the publication as a
credible and trustworthy source, leading to an ineffective ad with potentially negative
9. NATIVE ADVERTISING
9
associations and consequences, such as a perceived lack of authenticity of the product, brand, or
publication.
A study found that a source’s impact on the persuasiveness of an ad is strongest when the
source is revealed before the user receives the message (Nan 2013). When applied to native
advertising, this suggests it is best to prominently feature the publication’s name and its
association with the article, since the publication is its source. Since this is the case with almost
all in-feed ads, which must use disclosure statements according to the FTC, this can perhaps
account for the continued success of these kinds of articles and native advertising as a practice.
This can additionally enhance the effectiveness of in-feed ads since the reader will almost always
be aware of the publication since they have chosen to either physically open it or access it
electronically. For example, if an online reader was to click on a Buzzfeed in-feed ad,
“Buzzfeed” is the first thing the reader sees digitally, providing immediate endorsement and
validation of the advertisement’s credibility.
The same idea can be extrapolated to the logos these publications and brands utilize.
According to multiple studies, the trustworthiness of a source is most influential for consumers
in determining its credibility (Berlo et al., 1969; Whitehead, 1968). When the source credibility
of brand logos was analyzed, it strongly influenced trusting and distrusting beliefs and attitudes
toward the brand; logos were one of the first visual elements looked to when interacting with a
website (Lowry et al., 2014). Not only does this signify that viewers pay attention to the brand
that is advertising, and so it is important to make that clear in a native ad, but it also can imply
that consumers are aware of “sponsored content” and similar tags on in-feed advertisements. In
order to ensure the most ethically sound advertisement is created, this research could suggest
advertisers should consider incorporating the “sponsored content” or “paid advertisement” label
10. NATIVE ADVERTISING
10
into their brand name or logo to confirm the average reader will see it. The ability to be aware of
brand logos and labels can potentially negate the common ethical criticism of native advertising
that it is deceptive to the consumer.
Some scholars acknowledge a difference between visceral and discretional judgment when it
comes to source credibility in the field of journalism (e.g., Reich, 2011). Visceral judgment is
highly subjective and intuitive, whereas discretional judgment is based on legitimate reasoning
about the credibility of a source (Reich, 2011). Most journalists employ discretional judgment
when it comes to their sources but every so often, utilize visceral judgment (Reich, 2011). For
example, discretional judgment takes into account a source’s credentials, their past work, their
awards, and any other tangible proof they are a credible source. A reader would utilize
discretional judgment when evaluating an article in a journal and making sure it is peer-
reviewed. However, a reader might employ visceral judgment when reading something that
agrees with his or her previously established schemas; despite the fact a blog post may not be a
credible source by discretional standards, if the reader agrees with its sentiment, he or she may
be more likely to take a more intuitive approach to its credibility. When a reader is evaluating the
credibility of a publication when engaging with an in-feed ad, it is likely they are also utilizing a
combination of the two methods; this suggests that advertisers should match their native
advertisements with publications that are relevant, logical fits to the brand in order to be more
naturally accepted by the consumer.
Finally, native advertising at its best has the opportunity to appeal to the aspects of
consumers that respond to “slice-of-life” advertisements as opposed to fantastical or emotional
visuals. In a study where the same model was presented in a “slice-of-life” visual, a “fantasy”
visual, and an “emotional” visual, the model in the slice-of-life approach was viewed by
11. NATIVE ADVERTISING
11
respondents as being more experienced, more trustworthy, and more liked, regardless of
ethnicity or gender (Clow et. al, 2011). Due to the visual nature of in-feed native advertisements,
where they are meant to resemble the style of the publication’s articles, they are likely to appeal
to the reader as more realistic and relatable. Applied hypothetically, this could mean that an in-
feed advertisement in Vogue magazine discussing how a modern businesswoman styles a
particular outfit from Marc Jacobs could be viewed as more credible or trustworthy by readers
than a Marc Jacobs campaign overflowing with celebrities and opulent luxury.
Visual Rhetoric and Elements in Native Advertising
As previously shown, some argue that native advertising can be deceiving because of the very
nature of its format, but visual studies have shown consumers still process the copy of an
advertisement, regardless of how distracted they are by its visuals.
Research suggests the usage of pictures in print advertisements can be a distraction to
consumers, leading them to peripherally process copy and have more positive associations with
the brand or product since they are not evaluating the claims of the ad as closely as they might
without the pictures; a study suggested that an individual’s attitude toward a brand was
significantly more positive when the picture was large and the text small, as opposed to an ad
with a small picture and large text (Rossiter & Percy, 1978).
However, a study found that even when presented with ads which contained photographs that
had “virtually no information about the product,” people could recall a large number of product
attributes (Mitchell, 1986). Furthermore, when subjects were asked to complete a questionnaire
critically evaluating an ad, their attitudes toward the brand became more negative, possibly
12. NATIVE ADVERTISING
12
because they were cognitively processing a response that was initially more emotionally
influenced.
If applied to in-feed native advertisements, both of the aforementioned studies imply it is
most effective to generate an emotional response through copy and visual elements. Perhaps
brand logos should not be minimized as much as possible, but instead written in a font that
matches the article, so as not to interfere with the desired effect of the advertisement. Mitchell’s
findings serve to negate any ethical qualms this might inspire, since it appears individuals will
still process the copy, and most importantly in this regard, the disclosure statements, regardless
of how distracting or uninformative visual elements of the advertisements are.
When considering where to place the all-important disclosure statement, or sponsored content
disclaimer, in native advertising, analysis of visual studies offers specific and clear suggestions
for the most ethically appealing design. Recent studies show viewers are most likely to recognize
an advertisement when disclosure statements are placed in the middle or bottom of the content;
however, this increased recognition leads to an increase in negative responses to the
advertisement (Wojdynski & Evans, 2015). Nonetheless, studies of online reading behavior have
shown information near the top left corner of the page is most likely to be seen by viewers
(Nielsen, 2006). Furthermore, additional research suggests consumers are better able to
acknowledge advertising when disclosures are placed before or above the content (Boerman et.
al, 2014). When taking the results of these studies into account, it is important to remember the
purpose of native advertisement is to engage consumers in an entertaining and seamless
fashion—it is no wonder, then, that subjects responded negatively to the placement of disclosure
statements in the middle of an in-feed ad, or at the end, since these jarring statements could be
irritating to a reader. Additionally, it would seem that placing a disclosure statement in the
13. NATIVE ADVERTISING
13
middle or at the bottom of sponsored content, when the reader has already agreed to engage with
the ad, would be less transparent and ethically murkier than simply being straightforward with
the consumer and placing a disclosure statement at the top left corner of the page.
Suggested Guidelines for Effective and Ethical Utilization of Native Advertising
The following guidelines draw on the above analysis of experimental and meta-analytical
studies and the reaction of the popular press in an attempt to clarify what makes a native
advertisement both ethical and effective at this point in time.
1. Include A Disclosure Statement
From an ethical perspective, it can be argued the responsibility of the advertiser for the
implications of a native advertisement leaves his or her hands as long as the viewer possesses the
capability to be aware he or she is looking at an advertisement. The various examined definitions
of deception in advertising share in this underlying idea: if the viewer can consent to the ad
through the utilization of a disclosure statement, preferably to the top left of the page, then any
other rhetorical or visual strategies used to imitate the tone or design of the publication it is
contained within fall soundly on the side of ethical. While it appears the FTC believes it is also
acceptable by ethical standards for a viewer to not know he or she is viewing an ad as long as
that lack of knowledge does not affect their subsequent behavior, the work of scholars on the
topic would suggest this is an opportunity for further experimental research to determine if
whether the consumer is aware he is viewing an ad or not has any tangible effect on behavior.
2. Utilize Native Advertising for Hedonic & Relevant Products
Simply because a native advertisement is ethical, however, does not necessarily imply it will
be effective. The analysis of research and the climate in the popular press surrounding native
14. NATIVE ADVERTISING
14
advertising suggests it is most effective to utilize in-feed advertisements for two major kinds of
products and brands: those which are hedonic, and those which are relevant to the publication.
The Orange Is the New Black in-feed article in The New York Times was, for the most part,
positively accepted for three reasons: the advertisement was for a television show, which is a
product used for pleasure; female incarceration is a topic Times readers would be interested in;
and the writing style used by the author was consistent with that of the publication.
3. Do Not Utilize Native Advertising for Controversial or Polarizing Brand/Product
The Atlantic’s Scientology article, on the other hand, broke the cardinal rule of effective
native advertising, according to Bakshi—do not use native advertising for a controversial topic
or a topic where the public may have differing opinions. Scientology is a religion, a serious
topic, that was written about in The Atlantic in a way that did not match the style or flow of the
publication. Since native advertising is a relatively novel and somewhat ethically ambiguous
technique in the eyes of the general public, it is best not to compound any of that discomfort with
a product, brand, or kind of faith that could also inspire feelings of doubt or dissonance within
the reader.
4. Place Disclosure Statement at Top Left Corner of Page
Visually, the only crucial element is the disclosure statement that the in-feed advertisement is,
indeed, a native ad. The IAB suggests a variety of terminology that can be used to achieve this;
an opportunity for further research would be to explore which phrasing of the disclosure
statement receives the most positive response from subjects. Studies suggest placing this
disclosure at the top left corner of the page, so it is before the content (Nielsen, 2006; Boerman
et. al, 2014). Research implies it may make for a more successful advertisement to feature the
disclosure statement close to the logo, while simultaneously maximizing the emotional impact of
15. NATIVE ADVERTISING
15
the visual elements of the ad; however, more explicit research should be conducted on this matter
to determine to what extent this is the case when it specifically comes to native advertising
(Rossiter & Percy, 1978; Mitchell, 1986; Lowry et. al, 2014; Wojdynski & Evans, 2015).
5. Feature Publication Logos Prominently in In-Feed Ads
Source credibility studies support the claim that logos are one of the primary visual elements
looked to when clicking on a website; additionally, they can be highly influential in determining
how a consumer perceives the trustworthiness of an advertisement, an article, or an in-feed ad
(Lowry et al., 2014). In The New York Times’ well-received in-feed ad regarding Orange Is the
New Black, the Times’ logo appears at the top of the page, followed by the logo of the “T Brand
Studio,” the native advertisement studio that created the ad at the top left of the page, with the
words “Paid Post” and the Netflix and Orange Is the New Black logos appearing in the center
beneath the Times’ logo (Deziel, 2014). Additionally, as one scrolls through the article, all of
these logos at the top continue to follow the reader while taking up only about one-eighth of the
screen space. This is a prime example of how to most ethically and effectively incorporate brand
and publication logos into an in-feed native advertisement.
Conclusion
It is not to say that it is impossible for a native advertisement to be ethically ambiguous
or offensive, or that every in-feed ad achieves its strategic objectives. One must only look at the
failed case of The Atlantic’s in-feed ad about Scientology to understand the concerns some
advertisers and journalists harbor toward the practice. However, what should be taken away is
that ethical dilemmas and ineffective creative are problems which arise in all kinds of
advertisements, from out-of-home to Super Bowl commercials. As long as there are official
guidelines and definitions that can be agreed upon by the advertising and journalism
16. NATIVE ADVERTISING
16
communities, there is no reason that native advertising, which can be inspiring, informational,
and innovative at its best, should be reprimanded for being a deceptive or inefficient technique.
17. NATIVE ADVERTISING
17
References
Bakshi, A. (2015). Why and how to regulate native advertising in online news publications.
Journal of Media Law and Ethics, 4, 4-47.
Boerman, S., E. Van Reijmersdal, & P. Neijens (2014). Effects of sponsorship disclosure tim-
ing on the processing of sponsored content: A study on the effectiveness of European
disclosure regulations. Psychology and Marketing, 31, 3, 214-24.
Braiker, B. (2014). Andrew Sullivan on native ads: Journalism has surrendered. Digiday.
Retrieved from http://digiday.com/publishers/andrew-sullivan-native-ads/
Braun, P. (January 01, 1988). Deception in journalism. Journal of Mass Media Ethics, 3, 1, 77-
83.
Carlson, M. (November 02, 2015). When news sites go native: Redefining the advertising-
editorial divide in response to native advertising. Journalism, 16, 7, 849-865.
Carson, T. L., Wokutch, R. E., & Cox, J. E. (April 01, 1985). An ethical analysis of deception in
advertising. Journal of Business Ethics, 4, 2, 93.
Clow, K. E., James, K. E., Sisk, S. E., & Cole, H. S. (April 01, 2011). Source credibility, visual
strategy and the model in print advertisements. Journal of Marketing Development &
Competitiveness, 5, 3.
Deziel, M. (2014, June 13). Women inmates: why the male model doesn’t work. The New York
Times. Retrieved from http://paidpost.nytimes.com/netflix/women-inmates-separate-but-
not-equal.html
18. NATIVE ADVERTISING
18
Edell, J. A., & Staelin, R. (1983). The information processing of pictures in print
advertisements. Journal of Consumer Research, 10(1), 45–61. Retrieved from
http://www.jstor.org/stable/2488855
Gardner, D. M. (January 01, 1975). Deception in advertising-a conceptual approach. Journal of
Marketing, 39, 1, 40.
Federal Trade Commission. (2015). Commission Enforcement Policy Statement on Deceptively
Formatted Advertisements. Retrieved from
https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/896923/151222deceptivee
nforcement.pdf
Interactive Advertising Bureau (2013, December 4). The Native Advertising Playbook. Retrieved
from http://www.iab.net/media/file/IAB-Native-Advertising-Playbook2.pdf
Kurnit, R. (December 07, 2014). Defining native advertising. Communications Lawyer:
Publication of the Forum Committee on Communications Law, American Bar
Association, 30, 4.
Lichterman, J. (2014, August 4). John Oliver goes off on native advertising. NiemanLab.
Retrieved from http://www.niemanlab.org/2014/08/john-oliver-goes-off-on-native-
advertising/
Lowry, P. B., Wilson, D. W., & Haig, W. L. (January 01, 2014). A picture is worth a thousand
words: source credibility theory applied to logo and website design for heightened
credibility and consumer trust. International Journal of Human - Computer
Interaction, 30, 1, 63.
19. NATIVE ADVERTISING
19
Mitchell, A. A. (1986). The effect of verbal and visual components of advertisements on brand
attitudes and attitude toward the advertisement. Journal of Consumer Research, 13(1),
12–24. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/2489283
Moses, L. (2014). New York Times debuts the ‘snowfall’ of native ads. Digiday. Retrieved from
http://digiday.com/publishers/new-york-times-native-ad-thats-winning-skeptics/
Nan, X. (January 01, 2013). Perceived source credibility and advertising persuasiveness: An
investigation of moderators and psychological processes. Journal of Current Issues and
Research in Advertising, 34, 2, 195.
Nielsen, J. (2006). F-Shaped Pattern for Reading Web Content. Retrieved from
http://www.nngroup.com/articles/f-shaped-pattern-reading-web-content/
Reich, Z. (February 01, 2011). Source credibility and journalism. Journalism Practice, 5, 1, 51-
67.
Sebastian, M. (2014). Native ad production values keep growing with “Orange Is the New
Black” promo. Advertising Age. Retrieved from http://adage.com/article/media/york-
times-runs-native-ad-orange-black/293713/
Wasserman, E. (2013). Advertising goes native, and deception runs free. Huffington Post.
Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/edward-wasserman/native-advertising-
atlantic-scientology_b_2575945.html
Wojdynski, B. W., & Evans, N. J. (2015). Going Native: Effects of Disclosure Position and
Language on the Recognition and Evaluation of Online Native Advertising. Journal of
Advertising, 1-12.