Benchmarking
Explore Unique Ways to
Reflect, Learn & Improve
Desired
Current
A. Introduction & overview
B. What is benchmarking?
C. Why benchmarking?
D. How to benchmark?
E. Effective KPI’s?
F. Next Steps
2
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Does your organisation report on Health and Safety
external benchmarks to the Board/Senior Management?
(Yes/No)
3
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Poll #1
Who?
Benchmarking
4
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Internal
Competitive
Industry
Partner is not a direct competitor, but does
share the same industry as one's organisation
Comparisons are made against another
department/area within one's organisation
Comparisons are made with direct
competitors
Comparisons of processes/practices regardless
of the industry or field of the partner.
Generic
Based on Organisational Type
What?
Benchmarking
5
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
xx
Examines how companies compete
(Bogan & English, 1994).
Strategic
Based on Organisational Practices
4P Performance
Compares product or service performance
Focuses on discrete processes, places, plant
or people
4P
Benchmarking
Why?
“Benchmarking helps create the learning organisation: a group of dedicated individuals who actively
pursue excellence, growth and knowledge. If the experts are right..., only those organisations that can
quickly learn from and master their environments will survive into the twenty-first century.
Objective information can help trigger the transformation to the continuous improvement
philosophy, but it can only do so if it is continually reapplied and reinforced. Benchmarking sets the
framework for excellence, attaining it depends on the actions that are taken once the results are in. “
(Leibfried & McNair, 1992: 320-321)
6
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Engage & Enable
Why?
Often benchmarking is used
as a catalyst for change.
Important for ‘framing’ the
need for benchmarking.
* Kotter’s 8 steps change model
7
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
8. Embed Change
7. Build on change
6. Create quick wins
5. Empower others
4. Communicate the vision
3. Create a Vision
2. Build a Coalition
1. Create Urgency
Create a Climate
for Change
Implement & Sustain
Benchmarking
How?
- How to access reliable data?
- How to access partners?
- Collect Data: Evidence or
opinion-based data
- Analysis: Compare data,
establish goals, develop actions
- Action: Assign ownership and
implement actions
- Learn: Share, reflect and
learn with benchmark
Partners or Focus Groups
- Review: Have objectives
been achieved?
- Improve: Have we enabled
improvement?
- Objectives: Have we achieved
our benchmarking objectives?
1Approach Deployment 1Review Improvement
(Bogan & English, 1994)
8
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
1FEFO Consulting facilitated Focus Groups
Opinion-based
Evidence-based
Balanced
KPI’s
01
Predictive
02
Valid
03
Reliable
04
Important
05
Functional
06
Clear
01 Predictive Accurately forecasts the future.
02 Valid
Measures what you intended, statistically
meaningful.
03 Reliable
Repeatable providing statistically consistent
results., e.g., Health and Safety Index
04 Important Directly reflects an outcome that matters.
05 Functional
Used to inform operational and strategic risk.
Balances compliance vs performance.
06 Clear Understood and easily communicated.
9
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Benchmarking – What makes a good KPI?
Benchmarking
How?
10
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Statistically Reliable Benchmarks
Poll #2
Would you be interested to participate in facilitated
benchmarking focus group calls with likeminded organisations?
(Yes/No)
11
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
Benchmarking: Next Steps
Catalyst: Do you have a need for
change?
What: Do you have the most relevant
benchmarking?
Partner: Do you have a reliable benchmarking
partner and reliable data?
How: Is your approach, deployment, and
review effective to enable improvements?
1
2
3
4
12
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
OUR PEOPLE OUR CLIENTS OUR RECOGNITION
Follow Us
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au 13
SAFETY & ENVIRONMENT
STRATEGY
HEALTH & SAFETY SURVEYS
TRAINING & LEADERSHIP
DEVELOPMENT
MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
SAFETY IN DESIGN
FEDERAL SAFETY COMMISSIONER
CHAIN OF RESPONSIBILITY
EVENT SAFETY
HEALTH & WELLBEING
P S Y C H O S O C I A L R I S K
A S S E S S M E N T S
S T R AT E G Y
T E A M / J O B D E S I G N
S Y S T E M S A N D P R O C E S S E S
T R A I N I N G
P S Y C H O L O G I C A L I L L N E S S
I N V E S T I G AT I O N S
RISK & ASSURANCE
BUSINESS RISK
DUE DILIGENCE
CRITICAL RISK MANAGEMENT
CONTRACTOR MANAGEMENT
INVESTIGATIONS
AUDIT & ASSURANCE
Subscribe
Email
Phone
Website
FEFO Consulting
T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au 14

Benchmarking: Explore Unique Ways to Reflect, Learn and Improve

  • 1.
    Benchmarking Explore Unique Waysto Reflect, Learn & Improve
  • 2.
    Desired Current A. Introduction &overview B. What is benchmarking? C. Why benchmarking? D. How to benchmark? E. Effective KPI’s? F. Next Steps 2 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
  • 3.
    Does your organisationreport on Health and Safety external benchmarks to the Board/Senior Management? (Yes/No) 3 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au Poll #1
  • 4.
    Who? Benchmarking 4 FEFO Consulting T: +611300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au Internal Competitive Industry Partner is not a direct competitor, but does share the same industry as one's organisation Comparisons are made against another department/area within one's organisation Comparisons are made with direct competitors Comparisons of processes/practices regardless of the industry or field of the partner. Generic Based on Organisational Type
  • 5.
    What? Benchmarking 5 FEFO Consulting T: +611300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au xx Examines how companies compete (Bogan & English, 1994). Strategic Based on Organisational Practices 4P Performance Compares product or service performance Focuses on discrete processes, places, plant or people 4P
  • 6.
    Benchmarking Why? “Benchmarking helps createthe learning organisation: a group of dedicated individuals who actively pursue excellence, growth and knowledge. If the experts are right..., only those organisations that can quickly learn from and master their environments will survive into the twenty-first century. Objective information can help trigger the transformation to the continuous improvement philosophy, but it can only do so if it is continually reapplied and reinforced. Benchmarking sets the framework for excellence, attaining it depends on the actions that are taken once the results are in. “ (Leibfried & McNair, 1992: 320-321) 6 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
  • 7.
    Engage & Enable Why? Oftenbenchmarking is used as a catalyst for change. Important for ‘framing’ the need for benchmarking. * Kotter’s 8 steps change model 7 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au 8. Embed Change 7. Build on change 6. Create quick wins 5. Empower others 4. Communicate the vision 3. Create a Vision 2. Build a Coalition 1. Create Urgency Create a Climate for Change Implement & Sustain
  • 8.
    Benchmarking How? - How toaccess reliable data? - How to access partners? - Collect Data: Evidence or opinion-based data - Analysis: Compare data, establish goals, develop actions - Action: Assign ownership and implement actions - Learn: Share, reflect and learn with benchmark Partners or Focus Groups - Review: Have objectives been achieved? - Improve: Have we enabled improvement? - Objectives: Have we achieved our benchmarking objectives? 1Approach Deployment 1Review Improvement (Bogan & English, 1994) 8 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au 1FEFO Consulting facilitated Focus Groups
  • 9.
    Opinion-based Evidence-based Balanced KPI’s 01 Predictive 02 Valid 03 Reliable 04 Important 05 Functional 06 Clear 01 Predictive Accuratelyforecasts the future. 02 Valid Measures what you intended, statistically meaningful. 03 Reliable Repeatable providing statistically consistent results., e.g., Health and Safety Index 04 Important Directly reflects an outcome that matters. 05 Functional Used to inform operational and strategic risk. Balances compliance vs performance. 06 Clear Understood and easily communicated. 9 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au Benchmarking – What makes a good KPI?
  • 10.
    Benchmarking How? 10 FEFO Consulting T: +611300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au Statistically Reliable Benchmarks
  • 11.
    Poll #2 Would yoube interested to participate in facilitated benchmarking focus group calls with likeminded organisations? (Yes/No) 11 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
  • 12.
    Benchmarking: Next Steps Catalyst:Do you have a need for change? What: Do you have the most relevant benchmarking? Partner: Do you have a reliable benchmarking partner and reliable data? How: Is your approach, deployment, and review effective to enable improvements? 1 2 3 4 12 FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au
  • 13.
    OUR PEOPLE OURCLIENTS OUR RECOGNITION Follow Us FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au 13
  • 14.
    SAFETY & ENVIRONMENT STRATEGY HEALTH& SAFETY SURVEYS TRAINING & LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS SAFETY IN DESIGN FEDERAL SAFETY COMMISSIONER CHAIN OF RESPONSIBILITY EVENT SAFETY HEALTH & WELLBEING P S Y C H O S O C I A L R I S K A S S E S S M E N T S S T R AT E G Y T E A M / J O B D E S I G N S Y S T E M S A N D P R O C E S S E S T R A I N I N G P S Y C H O L O G I C A L I L L N E S S I N V E S T I G AT I O N S RISK & ASSURANCE BUSINESS RISK DUE DILIGENCE CRITICAL RISK MANAGEMENT CONTRACTOR MANAGEMENT INVESTIGATIONS AUDIT & ASSURANCE Subscribe Email Phone Website FEFO Consulting T: +61 1300 909 649 E: info@fefo.com.au W: fefo.com.au 14