Benchmark	
  |	
  World	
  Tour	
  2015	
  
	
  
Niche	
  Minerals	
  vs.	
  
Commodi;es:	
  
Opportuni;es	
  &	
  risks	
  in	
  baCery	
  
raw	
  material	
  markets	
  
	
  
Andrew	
  Miller,	
  Benchmark	
  Mineral	
  Intelligence,	
  UK	
  
amiller@benchmarkminerals.com	
  |	
  www.benchmarkminerals.com	
  	
  
A	
  new	
  genera;on	
  of	
  growth	
  markets	
  
Source:	
  Penflip,	
  Benchmark	
  Mineral	
  Intelligence	
  
1800s	
  
1st	
  Industrial	
  Revolu;on	
  
	
  
•  Metallurgy	
  
•  Steam	
  power	
  
•  Cement	
  
	
  
Raw	
  materials:	
  
Coal,	
  clay,	
  limestone	
  
1900s	
  
2nd	
  Industrial	
  Revolu;on	
  
	
  
•  Electrifica;on	
  
•  Transporta;on	
  
•  Chemicals	
  
Raw	
  materials:	
  
Iron	
  ore,	
  petroleum	
  
2000s	
  
3rd	
  	
  Industrial	
  Revolu;on	
  
	
  
•  3D	
  prin;ng	
  
•  Aerospace	
  
•  Advanced	
  materials	
  
•  BaCeries	
  
	
  
Global	
  economic	
  slowdown	
  
	
  
•  Slowing	
  growth	
  in	
  emerging	
  
economies	
  
	
  
•  Slowing	
  economic	
  development	
  
limi;ng	
  sales	
  into	
  tradi;onal	
  
end-­‐markets	
  
•  Industrial	
  markets	
  slowing	
  –	
  new	
  
lower	
  equilibrium?	
  	
  
	
  
	
  
A	
  new	
  genera9on	
  of	
  growth	
  markets	
  
Source:	
  The	
  Wall	
  Street	
  Journal	
  
•  China’s	
  economy	
  underperforming	
  
for	
  first	
  ;me	
  in	
  a	
  	
  genera;on	
  
•  2015	
  GDP	
  growth	
  target	
  lowered	
  to	
  
7.3%	
  
	
  
Long-­‐term	
  objec;ves	
  remain:	
  	
  
•  Develop	
  downstream	
  markets	
  
•  Protect	
  domes;c	
  resources	
  
•  Secure	
  low-­‐cost	
  resources	
  abroad	
  
•  Value-­‐added	
  economy	
  
	
  
•  The	
  materials	
  China	
  has	
  needed	
  over	
  
the	
  past	
  20	
  years	
  will	
  change	
  on	
  the	
  
next	
  20	
  years	
  
China’s	
  evolu9on	
  
Rising	
  cri9cality	
  
Explora;on	
   Mining	
   Processing	
   Trading	
   End-­‐markets	
  
Supply	
  chain	
  dis9nc9ons	
  
•  Explora;on	
  commonplace	
  in	
  commodi;es	
  
	
  
•  New	
  for	
  niche	
  minerals	
  /	
  specialist	
  
products	
  –	
  since	
  2009	
  
	
  
•  Explora;on	
  widening	
  
•  Lithium:	
  Argen;na,	
  Chile,	
  Bolivia,	
  
USA,	
  Canada,	
  Ireland,	
  Mongolia,	
  
Australia	
  +	
  
•  Graphite:	
  Canada,	
  Australia,	
  
Mozambique,	
  Madagascar,	
  Sweden	
  +	
  
•  Rare	
  earths:	
  USA,	
  Canada,	
  Australia,	
  
Greenland,	
  Mongolia	
  +	
  	
  
•  Cobalt:	
  USA,	
  Canada,	
  Russia	
  +	
  
Explora9on	
  
Commodi9es	
  
•  Extrac;ng	
  material	
  in	
  bulk	
  
•  Distribu;on	
  and	
  logis;cs	
  key	
  
•  Large-­‐scale	
  opera;ons	
  
•  Resource	
  loca;on	
  diverse	
  
Niche	
  Minerals	
  
•  Small	
  opera;ons	
  
•  Focus	
  on	
  processing	
  	
  
•  High	
  produc;on	
  costs	
  	
  
•  Specialist	
  products	
  
	
  
Mining	
  
Extrac;on	
   Processing	
   Separa;on	
  &	
  
refining	
  
Distribu;on	
   Logis;cs	
  
Source:	
  Gapso	
  Analy;cs,	
  Benchmark	
  Mineral	
  Intelligence	
  
$ $ $ $ $
$ = Niche Minerals $ = Commodities
Processing	
  
Trading	
  
•  Exchange	
  traded	
  
•  Subject	
  to	
  financial	
  
instruments	
  
•  Markets	
  more	
  fluid	
  
•  Short-­‐term	
  fluctua;ons	
  
•  Non-­‐exchange	
  traded	
  
•  Tradi;onally	
  annual/	
  bi-­‐
annual	
  contrac;ng	
  
•  Rigid	
  markets	
  
•  Supply-­‐chain	
  security	
  to	
  
force	
  moderniza;on	
  
Commodi9es	
   Niche	
  Minerals	
  
Trading	
  
Price	
  divergence	
  
	
  
•  Commodi;es	
  ;ed	
  closely	
  to	
  
industrial	
  markets	
  
•  Slowing	
  growth	
  in	
  emerging	
  
economies	
  paint	
  bleak	
  
picture	
  
•  China’s	
  currency	
  devalua;on	
  
to	
  limit	
  any	
  short-­‐term	
  
recovery	
  
•  Several	
  micro	
  and	
  macro	
  
impediments	
  to	
  recovery	
  
-­‐40%	
   -­‐30%	
   -­‐20%	
   -­‐10%	
   0%	
   10%	
   20%	
   30%	
  
Nickel
Tin
Copper
Aluminium
Cobalt
Graphite
Lithium
Prices:	
  Commodi9es	
  vs.	
  Niche	
  Minerals	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  
(Jan	
  ‘15	
  –	
  Sept	
  ’15)	
  
Source:	
  London	
  Metal	
  Exchange,	
  Benchmark	
  Mineral	
  Intelligence	
  
Trading	
  
•  Niche	
  minerals	
  proving	
  more	
  
resolute	
  
•  Fortunes	
  have	
  become	
  removed	
  
from	
  tradi;onal	
  markets	
  
•  Slow	
  turning	
  circles,	
  but	
  greater	
  
upward	
  pressure	
  
•  Diverging	
  trends	
  already	
  
emerging	
  
Commodi9es:	
  	
  
	
  
•  Homogenous	
  requirements	
  
	
  
•  Focus	
  on	
  volumes	
  and	
  reliable	
  supply	
  
	
  
•  Industry	
  specs	
  established	
  
	
  
Niche	
  Minerals:	
  
	
  
•  Several	
  grades	
  –	
  differing	
  specs	
  
	
  
•  Refining	
  process	
  key	
  
	
  
•  Specs	
  s;ll	
  in	
  development	
  
	
  
End-­‐markets	
  
•  Industrial	
  markets	
  to	
  seCle	
  at	
  
new	
  lower	
  equilibrium	
  
•  Technology	
  markets	
  the	
  new	
  
areas	
  of	
  notable	
  growth	
  
•  Evolu;on	
  in	
  the	
  way	
  we	
  create,	
  
store,	
  distribute	
  and	
  consume	
  
power	
  
•  Forecasts	
  predic;ng	
  growth	
  in	
  
orders	
  of	
  magnitude	
  
•  Raw	
  material	
  markets	
  under	
  
prepared	
  for	
  surge	
  in	
  demand	
  
	
  
	
  
The	
  technology	
  economy	
  
Evolving	
  industry	
  dynamics	
  
Supply-­‐chain	
  visibility	
  	
  
	
  
•  Fear	
  of	
  supply	
  disrup;on	
  –	
  e.g.	
  
China	
  rare	
  earths	
  
•  The	
  need	
  to	
  secure	
  raw	
  material	
  
supply	
  chains	
  reaching	
  cri;cal	
  level	
  
•  Tradi;onal	
  vs	
  emerging	
  markets	
  
•  Supply	
  chain	
  visibility	
  impera;ve	
  
	
  
•  Pressures	
  for	
  sustainable	
  sourcing	
  
The	
  Karooshy	
  Price	
  Vola;lity	
  Curve	
  
Evolving	
  industry	
  dynamics	
  
Microeconomic	
  developments	
  accelera9ng	
  
Microeconomic	
  developments	
  accelera9ng	
  
Differen9a9ng	
  between	
  the	
  disruptors	
  
Project	
  variables:	
  
1.  Grade	
  
2.  Loca;on	
  
3.  Infrastructure	
  
4.  Management	
  team	
  
5.  Industry	
  experience	
  
6.  Customer	
  base	
  
Differen9a9ng	
  between	
  the	
  disruptors	
  
Conclusions	
  
1.  Niche	
  minerals	
  differ	
  from	
  tradi;onal	
  
commodi;es	
  on	
  several	
  levels	
  
2.  The	
  emergence	
  of	
  new	
  hi-­‐tech	
  markets	
  
will	
  require	
  larger	
  volumes	
  of	
  refined	
  
material	
  
3.  This	
  new	
  supply	
  is	
  becoming	
  a	
  cri;cal	
  
issue	
  
4.  To	
  maximise	
  these	
  opportuni;es,	
  a	
  full	
  
understanding	
  of	
  niche	
  mineral	
  
complexi;es	
  is	
  required	
  
5.  New	
  investment	
  models	
  will	
  be	
  
needed	
  to	
  benefit	
  from	
  new	
  growth	
  
sectors	
  

Benchmark Lithium Supply Presentation 2015 By Andrew Miller

  • 1.
    Benchmark  |  World  Tour  2015     Niche  Minerals  vs.   Commodi;es:   Opportuni;es  &  risks  in  baCery   raw  material  markets     Andrew  Miller,  Benchmark  Mineral  Intelligence,  UK   amiller@benchmarkminerals.com  |  www.benchmarkminerals.com    
  • 2.
    A  new  genera;on  of  growth  markets   Source:  Penflip,  Benchmark  Mineral  Intelligence   1800s   1st  Industrial  Revolu;on     •  Metallurgy   •  Steam  power   •  Cement     Raw  materials:   Coal,  clay,  limestone   1900s   2nd  Industrial  Revolu;on     •  Electrifica;on   •  Transporta;on   •  Chemicals   Raw  materials:   Iron  ore,  petroleum   2000s   3rd    Industrial  Revolu;on     •  3D  prin;ng   •  Aerospace   •  Advanced  materials   •  BaCeries    
  • 3.
    Global  economic  slowdown     •  Slowing  growth  in  emerging   economies     •  Slowing  economic  development   limi;ng  sales  into  tradi;onal   end-­‐markets   •  Industrial  markets  slowing  –  new   lower  equilibrium?         A  new  genera9on  of  growth  markets  
  • 4.
    Source:  The  Wall  Street  Journal   •  China’s  economy  underperforming   for  first  ;me  in  a    genera;on   •  2015  GDP  growth  target  lowered  to   7.3%     Long-­‐term  objec;ves  remain:     •  Develop  downstream  markets   •  Protect  domes;c  resources   •  Secure  low-­‐cost  resources  abroad   •  Value-­‐added  economy     •  The  materials  China  has  needed  over   the  past  20  years  will  change  on  the   next  20  years   China’s  evolu9on  
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Explora;on   Mining   Processing   Trading   End-­‐markets   Supply  chain  dis9nc9ons  
  • 7.
    •  Explora;on  commonplace  in  commodi;es     •  New  for  niche  minerals  /  specialist   products  –  since  2009     •  Explora;on  widening   •  Lithium:  Argen;na,  Chile,  Bolivia,   USA,  Canada,  Ireland,  Mongolia,   Australia  +   •  Graphite:  Canada,  Australia,   Mozambique,  Madagascar,  Sweden  +   •  Rare  earths:  USA,  Canada,  Australia,   Greenland,  Mongolia  +     •  Cobalt:  USA,  Canada,  Russia  +   Explora9on  
  • 8.
    Commodi9es   •  Extrac;ng  material  in  bulk   •  Distribu;on  and  logis;cs  key   •  Large-­‐scale  opera;ons   •  Resource  loca;on  diverse   Niche  Minerals   •  Small  opera;ons   •  Focus  on  processing     •  High  produc;on  costs     •  Specialist  products     Mining  
  • 9.
    Extrac;on   Processing   Separa;on  &   refining   Distribu;on   Logis;cs   Source:  Gapso  Analy;cs,  Benchmark  Mineral  Intelligence   $ $ $ $ $ $ = Niche Minerals $ = Commodities Processing  
  • 10.
    Trading   •  Exchange  traded   •  Subject  to  financial   instruments   •  Markets  more  fluid   •  Short-­‐term  fluctua;ons   •  Non-­‐exchange  traded   •  Tradi;onally  annual/  bi-­‐ annual  contrac;ng   •  Rigid  markets   •  Supply-­‐chain  security  to   force  moderniza;on   Commodi9es   Niche  Minerals  
  • 11.
    Trading   Price  divergence     •  Commodi;es  ;ed  closely  to   industrial  markets   •  Slowing  growth  in  emerging   economies  paint  bleak   picture   •  China’s  currency  devalua;on   to  limit  any  short-­‐term   recovery   •  Several  micro  and  macro   impediments  to  recovery  
  • 12.
    -­‐40%   -­‐30%   -­‐20%   -­‐10%   0%   10%   20%   30%   Nickel Tin Copper Aluminium Cobalt Graphite Lithium Prices:  Commodi9es  vs.  Niche  Minerals                   (Jan  ‘15  –  Sept  ’15)   Source:  London  Metal  Exchange,  Benchmark  Mineral  Intelligence   Trading   •  Niche  minerals  proving  more   resolute   •  Fortunes  have  become  removed   from  tradi;onal  markets   •  Slow  turning  circles,  but  greater   upward  pressure   •  Diverging  trends  already   emerging  
  • 13.
    Commodi9es:       •  Homogenous  requirements     •  Focus  on  volumes  and  reliable  supply     •  Industry  specs  established     Niche  Minerals:     •  Several  grades  –  differing  specs     •  Refining  process  key     •  Specs  s;ll  in  development     End-­‐markets  
  • 14.
    •  Industrial  markets  to  seCle  at   new  lower  equilibrium   •  Technology  markets  the  new   areas  of  notable  growth   •  Evolu;on  in  the  way  we  create,   store,  distribute  and  consume   power   •  Forecasts  predic;ng  growth  in   orders  of  magnitude   •  Raw  material  markets  under   prepared  for  surge  in  demand       The  technology  economy  
  • 15.
    Evolving  industry  dynamics   Supply-­‐chain  visibility       •  Fear  of  supply  disrup;on  –  e.g.   China  rare  earths   •  The  need  to  secure  raw  material   supply  chains  reaching  cri;cal  level   •  Tradi;onal  vs  emerging  markets   •  Supply  chain  visibility  impera;ve     •  Pressures  for  sustainable  sourcing  
  • 16.
    The  Karooshy  Price  Vola;lity  Curve   Evolving  industry  dynamics  
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Differen9a9ng  between  the  disruptors   Project  variables:   1.  Grade   2.  Loca;on   3.  Infrastructure   4.  Management  team   5.  Industry  experience   6.  Customer  base  
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Conclusions   1.  Niche  minerals  differ  from  tradi;onal   commodi;es  on  several  levels   2.  The  emergence  of  new  hi-­‐tech  markets   will  require  larger  volumes  of  refined   material   3.  This  new  supply  is  becoming  a  cri;cal   issue   4.  To  maximise  these  opportuni;es,  a  full   understanding  of  niche  mineral   complexi;es  is  required   5.  New  investment  models  will  be   needed  to  benefit  from  new  growth   sectors